Players who played for Cincinnati Reds and Cleveland Guardians

Return to the form to edit this search or create a new search.

Are you hooked on Immaculate Grid, the daily trivia game from Baseball Reference? Whether you're looking for a little help on your grid or you already filled it out and want to know who else qualified, we have you covered. There were 220 players who played for both the Cincinnati Reds and Cleveland Guardians.

Top Players who Played for the Cincinnati Reds and Cleveland Guardians.

(Ranked by WAR)

Frank Robinson

Hall of Famer Frank Robinson played 10 seasons for the Cincinnati Reds (63.7 WAR) and 3 seasons for the Cleveland Guardians (0.9 WAR).

Vada Pinson

Vada Pinson played 11 seasons for the Cincinnati Reds (47.7 WAR) and 2 seasons for the Cleveland Guardians (2.9 WAR).

Buddy Bell

Buddy Bell played 4 seasons for the Cincinnati Reds (5.2 WAR) and 7 seasons for the Cleveland Guardians (24.5 WAR).

Jim Bagby

Jim Bagby played 1 season for the Cincinnati Reds (0.2 WAR) and 7 seasons for the Cleveland Guardians (31.7 WAR).

Shin-Soo Choo

Shin-Soo Choo played 1 season for the Cincinnati Reds (4.6 WAR) and 7 seasons for the Cleveland Guardians (21.8 WAR).

Batting

  • 189 players batted for each of these franchises.
Batting Table
Cincinnati Reds Cleveland Guardians
Name Yrs G AB BA HR SB WAR Yrs G AB BA HR SB WAR
Ted Abernathy1967-196814834.02900-0.31963-19649611.182000.1
Joe Adcock1950-19523321145.2713142.4196397283.2511310.0
Yonder Alonso2010-201169117.299500.22018145516.2502301.5
Dave Altizer1910-19114085.271020.519082989.213070.5
Nate Andrews1946714.07100-0.11940-194181.000000.0
Pete Appleton1927-19283842.381000.61930-19327364.20300-0.1
Joe Azcue19601431.09700-0.41963-19695941904.26645410.6
Jim Bagby191255.00000-0.11916-1922299635.225231.5
Trevor Bauer2019-2020914.143000.12013-20191325.08000-0.2
Harry Bay1901-190247173.22514-0.31902-19086282467.277416511.0
Johnny Beall1915-19161655.273110.3191366.16700
Erve Beck190248187.305121.11901135539.289671.6
Fred Beebe19103573.16400-0.319162028.214000.1
Buddy Bell1985-19883861391.2664365.21972-19789873712.274642424.5
Ray Benge193893.333000.01925-1926108.375000.1
Will Benson2023-2024140400.25315251.520222855.18200-0.3
Gerónimo Berroa19921315.267000.019982065.20001-0.3
Bob Bescher1908-19137452807.2621132014.919182560.333030.8
Jim Bolger1950-195494.25001-0.1195987.00000
Aaron Boone1997-20036682383.271868311.72005-2006247865.24623140.8
Buddy Bradford197179100.20024-0.11970-197195201.189700.0
Jeff Branson1992-19975711345.2483190.71997-199892172.22730-0.7
Russell Branyan2002-2003158393.2322531.91998-2010294882.2325521.6
Lynn Brenton1920-19212223.174000.01913-19151217.11800-0.2
Charlie Brewster194378.12500-0.1194632.000000.0
Rocky Bridges1953-1957346672.241280.519601027.333000.1
Jim Brower2001-20026630.267000.31999-200023.00000-0.1
Jumbo Brown193742.000000.01927-1928136.667000.3
Jay Bruce2008-201612204481.2492336117.3201743149.248710.3
Dave Burba1995-199779128.13320-0.11998-2002812.167100.2
Marlon Byrd201596359.2371920.8201634115.270500.2
Asdrúbal Cabrera20212026.07700-0.52007-20149143460.270826920.7
Jolbert Cabrera200848115.252320.31998-2002310573.234320-1.2
Orlando Cabrera2010123494.2634110.7201191324.24446-0.9
Bernie Carbo1969-1972254699.26326125.7197860174.287410.3
Charlie Carr19062294.19100-0.31904-1905121426.2321120.6
Sean Casey1998-200510754007.3051181516.71997610.200000.0
Charlie Chech1905-190650114.193000.219082748.104000.0
Shin-Soo Choo2013154569.28521204.62006-20126852524.292838521.8
Ty Cline1970-1971117160.225030.81960-1962137444.24826-0.1
Billy Clingman1890727.259000.119032164.281020.6
Gordy Coleman1960-19677672369.2719897.21959615.533000.2
Jackie Collum1953-19559889.258100.7196210000.0
Fritz Coumbe1920-19213638.289110.31914-1919155196.19901-0.5
Kyle Crockett2018130000.02014-2017110000.0
Ed Crosby19733651.216000.21974-1976100216.227000.0
Jacob Cruz2004-2005206274.230700.11998-200172186.274610.7
Nick Cullop1930-1931111356.258910.319273268.23510-0.1
George Culver1968-19698197.11300-0.41966-1967586.167000.0
Leo Cárdenas1960-196811574047.261722614.8197372195.21501-1.2
Delino DeShields20212547.255120.2202037107.252030.0
Chris Dickerson2008-2010148401.2748192.920144198.224230.0
Pete Donohue1921-1930318692.247512.4193122.000000.0
Gus Dorner190625.00000-0.11902-19031638.184000.0
Brian Dorsett1993-1994101279.247700.21987511.273100.0
Frank Duffy1970-19711927.185010.21972-19778052503.233264711.3
Jim Dyck19561811.09100-0.21954211.00000
Bo Díaz1985-19894601578.2543924.91978-1981198548.2541230.7
Hank Edwards1951-1952115311.296901.81941-19494131439.2753397.7
James Edwards19281810.300000.11922-192586111.11700-1.1
Edwin Encarnación2005-20095141764.26271193.22017-20182941054.2527054.7
Joe Engel191713.00000-0.1191910000.0
Tony Fernández1994104366.2798121.61997120409.2861162.2
Hank Foiles1953-196349147.259710.01953-196094186.263200.6
Lew Fonseca1921-1924248882.3028143.71927-19314011494.33712399.0
Terry Francona1987102207.22732-0.9198862212.311100.2
Joe Frazier19561017.23510-0.21947914.07100-0.2
Mike Freeman20213759.18601-0.42019-202099215.270411.1
Jim Fridley195859.22200-0.1195262175.25143-0.2
Milt Galatzer193935.00000-0.11933-1936248712.270110-0.6
Frank Genins189235110.18207-0.1190126101.22803-0.2
Lefty George1915712.333000.219121114.214000.1
Gus Getz1917714.286000.01918615.133000.1
Jim Gleeson1941-1942111321.231370.4193641139.259420.2
Martin Glendon190211.000000.0190338.00000-0.1
Raúl González2001-20022137.24302-0.12004711.09100-0.2
Mike Gosling2006-2007235.00000-0.1200910000.0
Eddie Grant1911-1913259807.227346-0.4190528.375000.0
Gene Green19631531.22610-0.31962-1963109221.253130-0.1
Bob Grim1960261.000000.0196030000.0
Jack Hannahan2013-2014109187.20910-1.02011-2012215607.2471223.1
Tommy Harper1962-19676482312.255441249.31968130235.2176111.0
Fred Hatfield195831.000000.0195838.12500-0.3
Rollie Hemsley1933-194285231.15200-2.11938-19413901302.2641061.9
Harvey Hendrick1931-1932231928.309564.019252528.286000.1
Bill Hinchman1905-190635105.229060.11907-19094281435.2389465.7
Kenny Hogan192112.00000-0.11923-192431.00000
Todd Hollandsworth20063468.26510-0.2200656156.237600.1
Tyler Holt2015-2016111190.22605-0.92014-20154591.23102-0.3
Bob Hooper195581.000000.01953-19546017.05900-0.2
Thomas Howard1993-1996355960.28018320.41992-1993191536.2635200.9
Dixie Howell194999.111000.0194030000.0
Damian Jackson1997-19982565.277130.51996-19971319.211010.1
Michael Jackson1995404.250000.01997-1999130000.0
Reggie Jefferson199157.143100.21991-1993163556.254131-0.6
Stan Jefferson19911319.05302-0.219904998.276280.3
Alex Johnson1968-19692881126.31319276.51972108356.23986-0.9
Doc Johnston1909310.00000-0.31912-19217212557.2738892.8
Willie Jones1959-1961160389.2521010.619591118.222000.3
Austin Kearns2002-20064521593.26771209.82010-2011141451.2481040.4
Bob Kelly1953-19583017.11800-0.21958134.250000.0
Bill Kennedy1956-195792.000000.0194863.667000.1
Vern Kennedy19452453.226000.01942-194486105.19001-0.1
Marty Keough1962-1965377721.2482251.6196065149.24832-0.3
Jim Kern1982507.00000-0.11974-198631.000000.0
Johnny Klippstein1955-1962174175.09110-1.519604914.143000.0
Elmer Koestner191455.400000.119102748.313020.4
Larry Kopf1916-19215271941.2503535.31913610.300000.1
Rick Krivda1998154.00000-0.1199810000.0
Ernie Krueger19253788.307110.0191356.00000-0.1
Art Kruger1907100317.2330100.0191062223.170012-0.6
Ryan Lavarnway2019518.278200.22021928.250000.0
Cliff Lee192466.333000.01925-192698270.300520.8
Mark Lewis1995-2000180363.287900.21991-2001246865.255710-0.7
Jim Lindsey193440000.01922-19243227.14800-0.2
Paddy Livingston190650139.158000.01901-19122149.22400-0.4
Bobby Locke1965111.000000.01959-19619681.259100.8
Howard Lohr19141847.21302-0.5191637.14301-0.1
Ryan Ludwick2012-2014275908.2583700.82003-200573227.2471321.1
Luke Maile2023-202492227.216720.7202276181.221300.7
Billy Martin1960103317.24630-1.4195973242.260900.8
Jack McCarthy1893-189489362.276090.01901-19032891117.2880363.8
Barney McCosky19512550.320100.31951-1953107162.21012-0.6
Cal McLish19603741.04900-0.51956-1959157190.153211.0
George McQuillan19111922.09100-0.2191854.00000-0.1
Sam Mele19553562.21020-0.3195657114.254400.0
Randy Milligan199383234.274601.119931947.426001.1
Kevin Mitchell1993-1996225747.3325537.719972059.15341-0.5
Howie Moss1946726.19200-0.21946832.06300-0.7
Tyler Naquin2021-2022183598.2632681.12016-2020325939.27431112.8
Don Newcombe1958-1960124201.289402.719602420.300000.2
Pete O'Brien19011654.20410-0.3190743145.228010.5
Ivy Olson191563207.2320100.11911-19144581692.2522581.1
Bob Owchinko19844912.167000.1198010000.0
Camilo Pascual196950000.0197195.600000.2
Monte Pearson194185.00000-0.11932-193596204.240110.8
Orlando Peña1958-19605935.08600-0.11967488.00000-0.2
Brandon Phillips2006-201616146351.27919119428.12002-2005135432.20664-0.4
Vada Pinson1958-196815656335.29718622147.71970-19712941140.27535322.9
Bud Podbielan1952-1957109133.14300-0.2195961.000000.0
Wally Post1949-19639023021.2661721915.6196458.00000-0.1
John Powers19594343.256200.21960812.167000.1
Yasiel Puig2019100373.25222140.4201949182.297250.5
Eduardo Pérez1996-1998208505.2462350.620063799.303800.6
Pedro Ramos1969388.00000-0.11962-1964137162.142800.5
Morrie Rath1919-19202671043.2663275.819102467.194020.2
Arthur Rhodes2009-20101291.000000.0200520000.0
Steve Ridzik1955136.167000.0195861.000000.0
Bip Roberts1992-1993230824.2945704.819972385.271330.2
Frank Robinson1956-196515025527.30332416163.71974-1976100235.2261400.9
Bill Rodgers1915-191675217.235081.219151645.311030.4
Adam Rosales2008-2009105259.21242-0.620181319.21110-0.1
Don Rudolph195951.000000.0196210000.0
Richie Scheinblum19732954.222100.11965-1969143321.21810-1.6
Ed Scott190042123.15410-0.619011748.208100.1
Bill Selby20013692.22820-0.52000-2003122244.20160-0.6
Wally Shaner19291328.321110.1192334.250000.0
Joe Shaute193484.250000.01922-1930258539.271133.1
Milt Shoffner1939-19403027.11100-0.21929-19314761.13110-0.3
Elmer Smith192596284.271860.71914-19216722185.281464010.6
Willie Smith19713155.16410-0.31967-19685474.17600-1.1
Drew Stubbs2009-20124861791.241591106.12013146430.23310170.9
Billy Sullivan193585241.266240.61936-1937165487.329562.4
Drew Sutton2009-20104469.232200.020101136.222100.2
Ed Taubensee1994-20006942097.2867785.01991-200178182.24730-0.8
Sammy Taylor196336.00000-0.11963410.300000.1
Johnny Temple1952-19649843632.2911510515.11960-1961227899.2735200.1
Jeff Treadway1987-1988126385.270432.2199397221.303210.6
Manny Trillo19891739.20500-0.4198388320.272110.5
Ted Uhlaender197273113.15900-0.81970-1971282973.2791360.4
Bob Usher1946-1951321798.227139-3.61957108.12500-0.1
Mike Vail1981-1982109220.24140-0.419781434.23501-0.1
Johnny Vander Meer1937-1949346668.15311-1.0195111.000000.0
Gee Walker1942-19454601645.25215320.91941121445.2836121.3
Mark Watson200320000.0200020000.0
Wally Westlake195259183.20230-0.31952-1955212547.2852133.3
Gus Weyhing190113.00000-0.1190125.00000-0.1
Pete Whisenant1957-1961215380.2292141.9196076.16700-0.1
Rick White2006250000.0200460000.0
Fred Whitfield1968-1969161245.224700.41963-19675791866.2579362.8
Bill Wight195870000.01953-1955375.00000-0.1
Milt Wilcox1970-19712314.07100-0.11972-19743345.200000.3
Nigel Wilson199557.00000-0.119961012.250200.1
Mark Wohlers2000-2001490000.0200230000.0
Bob Wood1898-1900147443.289072.61901-1902179604.293173.4
Craig Worthington19951018.278100.21992924.16700-0.4
Earl Yingling191461120.192130.11911611.273000.1
George Zuverink195422.500000.01951-1952180000.0
Miguel de la Hoz196911.000001960-1963189495.2571400.6

Pitching

  • 92 players pitched for each of these franchises.
Pitching Table
Cincinnati Reds Cleveland Guardians
Name Yrs G IP W L SV ERA WAR Yrs G IP W L SV ERA WAR
Ted Abernathy1967-1968148241.21610411.949.01963-196496132.098233.680.4
Nate Andrews1946743.12403.95-0.71940-1941814.10106.91-0.4
Pete Appleton1927-192837112.15503.930.81930-193272203.1121134.561.4
Jack Armstrong1988-199179413.2253204.610.5199235166.261504.64-0.4
Jim Bagby1912517.12103.120.31916-19222901735.212286263.0330.1
Trevor Bauer2019-202021129.17903.762.62013-20191801044.1675313.8916.2
Fred Beebe191035214.1121403.071.2191620100.25322.410.7
Matt Belisle2003-2008132341.2162215.061.12018810.20005.060.0
Ray Benge1938915.11124.110.01925-19261023.12002.700.2
Jason Bere1998-19992187.06205.48-0.32000-20031361.06306.34-0.2
Lynn Brenton1920-19212278.13924.25-0.81913-19151253.02303.57-0.4
Jim Brower2001-200268168.291013.952.21999-20002687.25405.750.5
Jumbo Brown193749.21008.38-0.41927-19281333.10306.48-0.7
Dave Burba1995-199779418.1282504.095.91998-2002142799.2573504.6510.4
Charlie Chech1905-190650333.2151832.782.0190827165.211701.742.5
Bruce Chen20023939.20204.31-0.1201526.101012.79-0.4
Jackie Collum1953-195598337.2232243.703.7196211.100013.50-0.1
Fritz Coumbe1920-192131101.13513.460.51914-1919145597.23431112.836.2
Kyle Crockett2018159.11005.79-0.32014-201710765.14103.441.3
George Culver1968-196974327.1162363.551.41966-19675884.27534.46-0.9
Rich DeLucia1994810.20004.220.0199969.10106.750.0
John Denny198627171.1111004.201.21980-198256392.2242304.155.7
Ross Detwiler20223026.10214.440.4201674.20005.790.0
Pete Donohue1921-19303161996.1127110133.7317.6193125.10008.44-0.2
Gus Dorner1906215.00101.200.51902-190316109.26603.45-0.4
James Edwards19281832.02227.59-0.91922-192586365.0172414.221.2
Joe Engel191718.00105.63-0.3191910.00000.0
Mike Freeman202110.10000.000.02019-202012.00009.000.0
Lefty George1915528.02203.860.219121144.10504.87-0.7
Justin Germano200626.20105.400.02010-20113248.00403.940.3
Ian Gibaut2022-2023107110.19643.752.0202211.10000.000.0
Martin Glendon190213.001012.00-0.31903327.21200.980.5
Mike Gosling2006-20072434.12005.24-0.220091525.00005.040.0
Danny Graves1997-2005465733.039431823.946.61996-20063355.04104.91-0.4
Bob Grim19602630.12224.45-0.2196032.101011.57-0.4
Ross Grimsley1971-197394601.1372523.264.019801474.24506.75-1.4
Bob Hooper1955813.00207.62-0.31953-195460104.05494.33-0.5
Dixie Howell1949513.10108.10-0.2194035.00001.800.2
Michael Jackson19954049.06122.391.51997-1999212207.2610942.996.1
Jason Johnson200648.20003.120.020061477.03805.96-0.3
Jeff Kaiser199333.10002.700.11987-19901622.10105.64-0.3
Bob Kelly1953-19583068.11224.350.719581327.20205.20-0.2
Bill Kennedy1956-1957914.20237.98-0.31948611.110011.12-0.8
Vern Kennedy194524157.251214.001.81942-194468313.2162013.501.1
Jim Kern19825076.03522.841.81974-1986201423.13031463.447.0
Johnny Klippstein1955-1962174636.2394094.274.919604974.155142.911.1
Elmer Koestner1914518.10004.42-0.4191027145.051023.04-0.5
Rick Krivda19981626.102011.28-1.619981125.02003.240.5
Derek Lilliquist199653.20007.360.01992-1994163155.01010172.555.0
Jim Lindsey193444.00004.500.01922-19243286.24516.54-0.6
Ben Lively20231988.24705.380.32024421.21102.080.7
Bobby Locke19651117.10105.71-0.51959-196193296.0101163.682.6
Cal McLish196037151.141414.160.21956-1959153667.0462743.356.8
George McQuillan19111977.02604.68-1.51918523.00112.350.2
Kent Mercker1997-2008207286.2131553.644.919961011.21003.090.3
Aaron Myette200454.10008.31-0.1200322.200023.63-0.2
Don Newcombe1958-196066438.0242123.647.019602054.02314.33-0.2
Chris Nichting20013636.10314.46-0.1200079.00007.00-0.1
Bob Owchinko19844994.03524.120.8198029114.12905.270.4
Camilo Pascual196957.10008.59-0.21971923.12203.090.6
Monte Pearson1941724.11305.18-0.21932-193596579.2363124.217.4
Orlando Peña1958-196059160.161084.271.119674888.10383.361.3
Bud Podbielan1952-1957109462.0183424.462.61959612.10105.84-0.2
Ted Power1983-1991349719.24741443.807.31992-199384119.13563.321.7
Pedro Ramos19693866.14325.16-1.01962-1964109519.0263013.873.2
Arthur Rhodes2009-2010135108.15502.413.020054743.13102.081.0
Steve Ridzik19551330.00304.500.3195868.20202.08-0.5
Don Rudolph195957.10004.910.0196210.10000.000.0
Jeff Russell1983-198443250.0102303.922.119941312.21154.970.0
Ed Scott190042315.0172013.862.1190117124.26614.400.5
Scott Scudder1989-199171273.1152314.540.61992-199325113.061105.42-1.8
Joe Shaute1934817.10214.150.21922-19302521447.07888114.1115.5
Jeff Shaw1996-1998195249.01412692.319.31990-199243128.231014.90-0.1
Milt Shoffner1939-19403092.03204.70-0.71929-193147170.171007.03-1.0
John Smiley1993-1997125775.1484804.168.11997637.12405.540.2
Jerry Spradlin1993-19964457.12124.400.4199943.000018.00-0.2
Greg Swindell199231213.212802.705.41986-19961661071.2615603.8616.5
Johnny Vander Meer1937-19493132028.011611613.4126.8195113.001018.00-0.3
Ron Villone1999-200064283.2191724.821.119982527.00006.00-0.1
Mysterious Walker191013.00003.000.0191211.00000.000.1
Mark Watson200322.00004.500.0200066.10108.53-0.2
David Weathers1998-2009341398.22227613.975.91997916.21207.56-0.3
Gus Weyhing190119.00103.00-0.21901211.10007.94-0.2
Rick White20062627.11016.26-0.520045978.15515.29-0.6
Kevin Wickander19933325.11006.75-0.51989-19936764.22113.341.0
Bill Wight195876.20104.050.01953-19553750.22123.200.8
Milt Wilcox1970-19712365.25323.020.41972-197499361.2172644.55-1.1
Mark Wohlers2000-20015060.04304.200.220026471.13474.790.2
Blake Wood2016-2017125134.07914.70-0.22013-201497.20105.87-0.1
Earl Yingling191434198.091303.450.21911422.11004.43-0.3
Alex Young20236353.24213.860.82021-20221110.20007.59-0.3
George Zuverink195426.00009.00-0.21951-19521726.20005.06-0.1

What is Immaculate Grid?

Immaculate Grid is a daily trivia game powered by Sports Reference.

Is there an Immaculate Grid game for basketball, football, hockey and soccer?

Yes, Sports Reference has Immaculate Grid games for Men's Basketball, Women's Basketball, Football, Hockey and Soccer as well as Baseball.

How do you play Immaculate Grid?

To play Immaculate Grid, you choose nine players to fill a grid. The grid is laid out as three rows and three columns. You select a player for each cell that matches the criteria for that cell's row and column. You have nine guesses to fill out the grid. Each guess, whether correct or incorrect, counts as a guess.

There is a new grid every day at 6:00 am ET.

See the full rules for more.