+ - Indicates Hall of Famer. Bold indicates active player.
This statistic is computed from play-by-play data which is only complete from 1974 to the present. From 1950-1973, the data is incomplete, though for most seasons only less than 20 games per season total are missing. Please see our page on data coverage for a full view of the data used to create these lists.
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Babe Ruth+ (22) | 190.0 | L |
| 2. | Barry Bonds (22) | 171.8 | L |
| 3. | Ty Cobb+ (24) | 159.5 | L |
| 4. | Willie Mays+ (22) | 154.7 | R |
| 5. | Cy Young+ (22) | 143.2 | R |
| 6. | Hank Aaron+ (23) | 141.6 | R |
| 7. | Walter Johnson+ (21) | 139.8 | R |
| 8. | Honus Wagner+ (21) | 134.5 | R |
| 9. | Tris Speaker+ (22) | 132.9 | L |
| 10. | Roger Clemens (24) | 128.8 | R |
| 11. | Rogers Hornsby+ (23) | 127.8 | R |
| Stan Musial+ (22) | 127.8 | L | |
| 13. | Eddie Collins+ (25) | 126.7 | L |
| 14. | Ted Williams+ (19) | 125.3 | L |
| 15. | Mickey Mantle+ (18) | 120.2 | B |
| 16. | Lou Gehrig+ (17) | 118.4 | L |
| 17. | Rickey Henderson+ (25) | 113.1 | R |
| 18. | Mel Ott+ (22) | 109.3 | L |
| 19. | Mike Schmidt+ (18) | 108.3 | R |
| 20. | Frank Robinson+ (21) | 107.4 | R |
| 21. | Pete Alexander+ (20) | 106.8 | R |
| 22. | Tom Seaver+ (20) | 106.1 | R |
| 23. | Alex Rodriguez (18, 35) | 104.6 | R |
| 24. | Nap Lajoie+ (21) | 104.2 | R |
| 25. | Joe Morgan+ (22) | 103.5 | L |
| 26. | Kid Nichols+ (15) | 103.2 | B |
| 27. | Cap Anson+ (27) | 99.3 | R |
| 28. | Eddie Mathews+ (17) | 98.3 | L |
| 29. | Greg Maddux (23) | 96.9 | R |
| 30. | Jimmie Foxx+ (20) | 95.2 | R |
| 31. | Lefty Grove+ (17) | 93.3 | L |
| 32. | Phil Niekro+ (24) | 93.0 | R |
| 33. | Bob Gibson+ (17) | 91.8 | R |
| 34. | Al Kaline+ (22) | 91.0 | R |
| 35. | Christy Mathewson+ (17) | 90.7 | R |
| 36. | Gaylord Perry+ (22) | 90.5 | R |
| 37. | George Davis+ (20) | 90.3 | B |
| 38. | Cal Ripken+ (21) | 89.9 | R |
| 39. | Warren Spahn+ (21) | 89.7 | L |
| 40. | Randy Johnson (22) | 89.6 | R |
| 41. | Wade Boggs+ (18) | 89.0 | L |
| 42. | Albert Pujols (11, 31) | 88.7 | R |
| Carl Yastrzemski+ (23) | 88.7 | L | |
| 44. | Bert Blyleven+ (22) | 87.6 | R |
| 45. | Roger Connor+ (18) | 87.2 | L |
| 46. | Steve Carlton+ (24) | 86.9 | L |
| 47. | George Brett+ (21) | 85.0 | L |
| 48. | Roberto Clemente+ (18) | 83.8 | R |
| 49. | Joe DiMaggio+ (13) | 83.6 | R |
| 50. | Chipper Jones (18, 39) | 82.7 | B |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Robin Roberts+ (19) | 82.7 | B | |
| 52. | Dan Brouthers+ (19) | 81.7 | L |
| 53. | Fergie Jenkins+ (19) | 81.5 | R |
| 54. | John Clarkson+ (12) | 81.3 | R |
| 55. | Charlie Gehringer+ (19) | 80.9 | L |
| 56. | Nolan Ryan+ (27) | 80.5 | R |
| 57. | Jeff Bagwell (15) | 79.9 | R |
| 58. | Rod Carew+ (19) | 79.1 | L |
| 59. | Tim Keefe+ (14) | 79.0 | R |
| 60. | Ken Griffey (22) | 78.6 | L |
| 61. | Robin Yount+ (20) | 76.9 | R |
| 62. | Eddie Plank+ (17) | 76.8 | L |
| 63. | Sam Crawford+ (19) | 76.6 | L |
| 64. | Bill Dahlen (21) | 75.9 | R |
| Frank Thomas (19) | 75.9 | R | |
| 66. | Arky Vaughan+ (14) | 75.6 | L |
| 67. | Pete Rose (24) | 75.3 | B |
| 68. | Frankie Frisch+ (19) | 74.8 | B |
| Paul Molitor+ (21) | 74.8 | R | |
| 70. | Ed Delahanty+ (16) | 74.7 | R |
| 71. | Reggie Jackson+ (21) | 74.6 | L |
| Mike Mussina (18) | 74.6 | L | |
| 73. | Paul Waner+ (20) | 73.8 | L |
| 74. | Old Hoss Radbourn+ (12) | 73.6 | R |
| 75. | Pedro Martinez (18) | 73.5 | R |
| 76. | Fred Clarke+ (21) | 73.4 | L |
| 77. | Tom Glavine (22) | 71.6 | L |
| 78. | Bob Caruthers (10) | 71.4 | L |
| Jim Thome (21, 40) | 71.4 | L | |
| 80. | Johnny Bench+ (17) | 71.3 | R |
| 81. | Derek Jeter (17, 37) | 70.4 | R |
| 82. | Johnny Mize+ (15) | 70.2 | L |
| 83. | Don Drysdale+ (14) | 69.8 | R |
| 84. | Lou Whitaker (19) | 69.7 | L |
| 85. | Billy Hamilton+ (14) | 69.6 | L |
| Tony Mullane (13) | 69.6 | B | |
| 87. | Harry Heilmann+ (17) | 69.4 | R |
| 88. | Luke Appling+ (20) | 69.3 | R |
| 89. | Brooks Robinson+ (23) | 69.1 | R |
| 90. | Barry Larkin+ (19) | 68.9 | R |
| 91. | Tony Gwynn+ (20) | 68.4 | L |
| 92. | Jim Edmonds (17) | 67.9 | L |
| 93. | Curt Schilling (20) | 67.7 | R |
| 94. | Bobby Grich (17) | 67.6 | R |
| 95. | Duke Snider+ (18) | 67.5 | L |
| 96. | Carlton Fisk+ (24) | 67.3 | R |
| Ivan Rodriguez (21, 39) | 67.3 | R | |
| Red Ruffing+ (22) | 67.3 | R | |
| Larry Walker (17) | 67.3 | L | |
| 100. | Edgar Martinez (18) | 67.2 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 101. | Alan Trammell (20) | 66.9 | R |
| 102. | Eddie Murray+ (21) | 66.7 | B |
| Pee Wee Reese+ (16) | 66.7 | R | |
| 104. | Manny Ramirez (19, 39) | 66.6 | R |
| 105. | Ron Santo+ (15) | 66.4 | R |
| 106. | Gary Carter+ (19) | 66.3 | R |
| 107. | Craig Biggio (20) | 66.2 | R |
| Scott Rolen (16, 36) | 66.2 | R | |
| 109. | Rafael Palmeiro (20) | 66.0 | L |
| 110. | Bobby Wallace+ (25) | 65.9 | R |
| 111. | Don Sutton+ (23) | 65.6 | R |
| 112. | Kenny Lofton (17) | 65.3 | L |
| Rick Reuschel (19) | 65.3 | R | |
| John Smoltz (21) | 65.3 | R | |
| 115. | Willie McCovey+ (22) | 65.1 | L |
| 116. | Monte Ward+ (17) | 64.9 | L |
| 117. | Tim Raines (23) | 64.6 | B |
| Ozzie Smith+ (19) | 64.6 | B | |
| 119. | Ernie Banks+ (19) | 64.4 | R |
| 120. | Jesse Burkett+ (16) | 64.1 | L |
| 121. | Kevin Brown (19) | 64.0 | R |
| 122. | Home Run Baker+ (13) | 63.7 | L |
| Jim McCormick (10) | 63.7 | R | |
| 124. | Carl Hubbell+ (16) | 63.6 | R |
| Al Simmons+ (20) | 63.6 | R | |
| 126. | Roberto Alomar+ (17) | 63.5 | B |
| 127. | Reggie Smith (17) | 63.4 | B |
| 128. | Bob Feller+ (18) | 63.3 | R |
| Gary Sheffield (22) | 63.3 | R | |
| 130. | Jackie Robinson+ (10) | 63.2 | R |
| 131. | Mark McGwire (16) | 63.1 | R |
| Jim Palmer+ (19) | 63.1 | R | |
| 133. | Goose Goslin+ (18) | 63.0 | L |
| 134. | Shoeless Joe Jackson (13) | 62.9 | L |
| Ted Lyons+ (21) | 62.9 | B | |
| 136. | Juan Marichal+ (16) | 62.7 | R |
| 137. | Joe Cronin+ (20) | 62.5 | R |
| 138. | Amos Rusie+ (10) | 62.1 | R |
| 139. | Ryne Sandberg+ (16) | 62.0 | R |
| 140. | Yogi Berra+ (19) | 61.9 | L |
| 141. | Dwight Evans (20) | 61.8 | R |
| 142. | Graig Nettles (22) | 61.6 | L |
| 143. | Dick Allen (15) | 61.2 | R |
| 144. | Harmon Killebrew+ (22) | 61.1 | R |
| 145. | Keith Hernandez (17) | 61.0 | L |
| 146. | Jake Beckley+ (20) | 60.9 | L |
| 147. | Buddy Bell (18) | 60.8 | R |
| Carlos Beltran (14, 34) | 60.8 | B | |
| Willie Keeler+ (19) | 60.8 | L | |
| 150. | Sal Bando (16) | 60.6 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Roy Halladay (14, 34) | 60.6 | R | |
| 152. | Willie Randolph (18) | 60.5 | R |
| 153. | Andruw Jones (16, 34) | 60.4 | R |
| 154. | Todd Helton (15, 37) | 59.9 | L |
| 155. | Jim Wynn (15) | 59.8 | R |
| 156. | Sammy Sosa (18) | 59.7 | R |
| Dave Winfield+ (22) | 59.7 | R | |
| 158. | Jeff Kent (17) | 59.4 | R |
| Luis Tiant (19) | 59.4 | R | |
| 160. | Vladimir Guerrero (16, 36) | 59.2 | R |
| 161. | Sherry Magee (16) | 59.1 | R |
| Mike Piazza (16) | 59.1 | R | |
| 163. | Bobby Abreu (16, 37) | 58.7 | L |
| Pud Galvin+ (15) | 58.7 | R | |
| 165. | Ken Boyer (15) | 58.4 | R |
| 166. | Dennis Eckersley+ (24) | 58.3 | R |
| Early Wynn+ (23) | 58.3 | B | |
| 168. | Jack Glasscock (17) | 58.2 | R |
| 169. | Richie Ashburn+ (15) | 58.0 | L |
| 170. | Bid McPhee+ (18) | 57.9 | R |
| 171. | Zack Wheat+ (19) | 57.8 | L |
| 172. | Will Clark (15) | 57.6 | L |
| 173. | Hal Newhouser+ (17) | 57.5 | L |
| Willie Stargell+ (21) | 57.5 | L | |
| 175. | Charlie Buffinton (11) | 57.4 | R |
| 176. | Darrell Evans (21) | 57.3 | L |
| 177. | Willie Davis (18) | 57.2 | L |
| Billy Williams+ (18) | 57.2 | L | |
| 179. | Jim Bunning+ (17) | 57.1 | R |
| 180. | Bobby Bonds (14) | 57.0 | R |
| Andre Dawson+ (21) | 57.0 | R | |
| Tommy John (26) | 57.0 | R | |
| 183. | David Cone (17) | 56.9 | L |
| 184. | Whitey Ford+ (16) | 56.8 | L |
| Hank Greenberg+ (13) | 56.8 | R | |
| John Olerud (17) | 56.8 | L | |
| Ed Walsh+ (14) | 56.8 | R | |
| 188. | Elmer Flick+ (13) | 56.7 | L |
| 189. | Mariano Rivera (17, 41) | 56.3 | R |
| 190. | Lou Boudreau+ (15) | 56.0 | R |
| 191. | Joe Medwick+ (17) | 55.8 | R |
| 192. | Mordecai Brown+ (14) | 55.6 | B |
| Billy Herman+ (15) | 55.6 | R | |
| Joe Torre (18) | 55.6 | R | |
| 195. | Joe Kelley+ (17) | 55.5 | R |
| Robin Ventura (16) | 55.5 | L | |
| 197. | Bill Terry+ (14) | 55.4 | L |
| Mickey Welch+ (13) | 55.4 | R | |
| 199. | Jack Clark (18) | 55.0 | R |
| Frank Tanana (21) | 55.0 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 201. | Joe Gordon+ (11) | 54.9 | R |
| 202. | Stan Hack (16) | 54.8 | L |
| 203. | Ichiro Suzuki (11, 37) | 54.5 | L |
| 204. | Bill Dickey+ (17) | 54.4 | L |
| Bret Saberhagen (16) | 54.4 | R | |
| 206. | Chuck Finley (17) | 54.3 | L |
| 207. | Enos Slaughter+ (19) | 54.1 | L |
| 208. | Jim O'Rourke+ (23) | 54.0 | R |
| 209. | Dazzy Vance+ (16) | 53.8 | R |
| 210. | Jason Giambi (17, 40) | 53.7 | L |
| 211. | Orel Hershiser (18) | 53.5 | R |
| Larry Jackson (14) | 53.5 | R | |
| 213. | Wes Ferrell (15) | 53.3 | R |
| Jerry Koosman (19) | 53.3 | R | |
| 215. | Bob Johnson (13) | 53.2 | R |
| 216. | Silver King (10) | 53.1 | R |
| 217. | Jimmy Collins+ (14) | 53.0 | R |
| Dave Stieb (16) | 53.0 | R | |
| Jack Stivetts (11) | 53.0 | R | |
| 220. | Norm Cash (17) | 52.9 | L |
| 221. | Clark Griffith+ (21) | 52.8 | R |
| Minnie Minoso (17) | 52.8 | R | |
| 223. | Harry Hooper+ (17) | 52.6 | L |
| 224. | George Sisler+ (15) | 52.5 | L |
| 225. | Bob Elliott (15) | 52.3 | R |
| 226. | Cesar Cedeno (17) | 52.2 | R |
| Jose Cruz (19) | 52.2 | L | |
| 228. | Ron Cey (17) | 52.0 | R |
| 229. | Billy Pierce (18) | 51.8 | L |
| Jimmy Sheckard (17) | 51.8 | L | |
| 231. | Johnny Damon (17, 37) | 51.6 | L |
| 232. | Buck Ewing+ (18) | 51.4 | R |
| 233. | Red Faber+ (20) | 51.3 | B |
| 234. | Lance Berkman (13, 35) | 51.2 | B |
| Mickey Cochrane+ (13) | 51.2 | L | |
| Sam Rice+ (20) | 51.2 | L | |
| 237. | Bob Lemon+ (15) | 51.0 | L |
| 238. | Tommy Leach (19) | 50.9 | R |
| 239. | Max Carey+ (20) | 50.6 | B |
| 240. | Fred McGriff (19) | 50.5 | L |
| Tony Perez+ (23) | 50.5 | R | |
| 242. | Ted Simmons (21) | 50.4 | B |
| Vic Willis+ (13) | 50.4 | R | |
| 244. | Gabby Hartnett+ (20) | 50.3 | R |
| 245. | Urban Shocker (13) | 50.2 | R |
| 246. | David Wells (21) | 50.1 | L |
| 247. | Tim Hudson (13, 35) | 50.0 | R |
| 248. | Luis Aparicio+ (18) | 49.9 | R |
| Kevin Appier (16) | 49.9 | R | |
| Dwight Gooden (16) | 49.9 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Chet Lemon (16) | 49.9 | R | |
| 252. | CC Sabathia (11, 30) | 49.8 | L |
| 253. | Tommy Bridges (16) | 49.6 | R |
| Eddie Cicotte (14) | 49.6 | B | |
| Kiki Cuyler+ (18) | 49.6 | R | |
| Hugh Duffy+ (17) | 49.6 | R | |
| 257. | Frank Chance+ (17) | 49.5 | R |
| Joe McGinnity+ (10) | 49.5 | R | |
| 259. | Brian Downing (20) | 49.4 | R |
| Andy Pettitte (16) | 49.4 | L | |
| 261. | John McGraw+ (16) | 49.3 | L |
| Vada Pinson (18) | 49.3 | L | |
| 263. | Joe Tinker+ (15) | 49.2 | R |
| 264. | Sandy Koufax+ (12) | 48.7 | R |
| Gene Tenace (15) | 48.7 | R | |
| 266. | Stan Coveleski+ (14) | 48.5 | R |
| 267. | Johnny Evers+ (18) | 48.4 | L |
| Eppa Rixey+ (21) | 48.4 | R | |
| Joe Sewell+ (14) | 48.4 | L | |
| 270. | Tony Lazzeri+ (14) | 48.3 | R |
| 271. | Tony Phillips (18) | 48.2 | B |
| Jack Quinn (23) | 48.2 | R | |
| 273. | Dave Foutz (13) | 48.1 | R |
| 274. | Ellis Burks (18) | 47.9 | R |
| 275. | Fielder Jones (15) | 47.8 | L |
| 276. | Bobby Doerr+ (14) | 47.7 | R |
| 277. | Adrian Beltre (14, 32) | 47.6 | R |
| Carl Mays (15) | 47.6 | L | |
| 279. | Wilbur Cooper (15) | 47.5 | R |
| King Kelly+ (16) | 47.5 | R | |
| 281. | Larry Doby+ (13) | 47.4 | L |
| 282. | Fred Lynn (17) | 47.3 | L |
| Bernie Williams (16) | 47.3 | B | |
| 284. | Cupid Childs (13) | 47.2 | L |
| Larry Doyle (14) | 47.2 | L | |
| 286. | Mark Grace (16) | 47.1 | L |
| Toby Harrah (17) | 47.1 | R | |
| Johan Santana (11, 32) | 47.1 | L | |
| Dizzy Trout (15) | 47.1 | R | |
| 290. | Mark Langston (16) | 47.0 | R |
| Mike Smith (14) | 47.0 | L | |
| 292. | Orlando Cepeda+ (17) | 46.8 | R |
| 293. | Mike Cameron (17, 38) | 46.7 | R |
| Rocky Colavito (14) | 46.7 | R | |
| Sam Thompson+ (15) | 46.7 | L | |
| 296. | Jamie Moyer (24) | 46.6 | L |
| Harry Stovey (14) | 46.6 | R | |
| 298. | Brett Butler (17) | 46.5 | L |
| Edd Roush+ (18) | 46.5 | L | |
| 300. | Dave Bancroft+ (16) | 46.4 | B |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Heinie Groh (16) | 46.4 | R | |
| Hughie Jennings+ (18) | 46.4 | R | |
| Rube Waddell+ (13) | 46.4 | R | |
| 304. | Babe Adams (19) | 46.3 | L |
| Mark Buehrle (12, 32) | 46.3 | L | |
| Luis Gonzalez (19) | 46.3 | L | |
| Kenny Rogers (20) | 46.3 | L | |
| 308. | Jim Fregosi (18) | 46.1 | R |
| Roy Oswalt (11, 33) | 46.1 | R | |
| George Van Haltren (17) | 46.1 | L | |
| 311. | J.D. Drew (14, 35) | 45.9 | L |
| George Gore (14) | 45.9 | L | |
| Ralph Kiner+ (10) | 45.9 | R | |
| 314. | George Uhle (17) | 45.8 | R |
| 315. | Jimmy Key (15) | 45.6 | R |
| 316. | Bert Campaneris (19) | 45.2 | R |
| Mike Griffin (12) | 45.2 | L | |
| Rusty Staub (23) | 45.2 | L | |
| 319. | George Burns (15) | 45.1 | R |
| Waite Hoyt+ (21) | 45.1 | R | |
| Dixie Walker (18) | 45.1 | L | |
| 322. | Earl Averill+ (13) | 45.0 | L |
| Dennis Martinez (23) | 45.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Ryan (18) | 45.0 | R | |
| Jim Whitney (10) | 45.0 | L | |
| 326. | Jim Kaat (25) | 44.9 | L |
| Mike Tiernan (13) | 44.9 | L | |
| 328. | Lave Cross (21) | 44.8 | R |
| Kirby Puckett+ (12) | 44.8 | R | |
| 330. | Earle Combs+ (12) | 44.7 | L |
| Jorge Posada (17, 39) | 44.7 | B | |
| 332. | Gil Hodges (18) | 44.6 | R |
| Ed Konetchy (15) | 44.6 | R | |
| Herman Long (16) | 44.6 | L | |
| 335. | Bucky Walters (19) | 44.5 | R |
| Roy White (15) | 44.5 | B | |
| 337. | Nellie Fox+ (19) | 44.4 | L |
| Ron Guidry (14) | 44.4 | L | |
| Buddy Myer (17) | 44.4 | L | |
| 340. | Carlos Delgado (17) | 44.2 | L |
| Dale Murphy (18) | 44.2 | R | |
| 342. | Dolf Luque (20) | 44.1 | R |
| Heinie Manush+ (17) | 44.1 | L | |
| 344. | Augie Galan (16) | 44.0 | B |
| Lon Warneke (15) | 44.0 | R | |
| 346. | Mickey Lolich (16) | 43.9 | B |
| Matt Williams (17) | 43.9 | R | |
| 348. | Wally Schang (19) | 43.8 | B |
| 349. | Joe Judge (20) | 43.7 | L |
| Steve Rogers (13) | 43.7 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 351. | Bobby Veach (14) | 43.6 | L |
| 352. | Vern Stephens (15) | 43.5 | R |
| 353. | Charlie Keller (13) | 43.4 | L |
| Thurman Munson (11) | 43.4 | R | |
| 355. | Bill Freehan (15) | 43.3 | R |
| Travis Jackson+ (15) | 43.3 | R | |
| 357. | Jack Powell (16) | 43.1 | R |
| Frank Viola (15) | 43.1 | L | |
| 359. | Dolph Camilli (12) | 43.0 | L |
| Larry Gardner (17) | 43.0 | L | |
| 361. | Vida Blue (17) | 42.9 | B |
| Darryl Strawberry (17) | 42.9 | L | |
| Roy Thomas (13) | 42.9 | L | |
| 364. | Art Fletcher (13) | 42.8 | R |
| Burleigh Grimes+ (19) | 42.8 | R | |
| 366. | Bob Friend (16) | 42.7 | R |
| 367. | Deacon White (20) | 42.6 | L |
| 368. | George Foster (18) | 42.5 | R |
| Nomar Garciaparra (14) | 42.5 | R | |
| Brian Giles (15) | 42.5 | L | |
| Curt Simmons (20) | 42.5 | L | |
| Miguel Tejada (15, 37) | 42.5 | R | |
| Fred Tenney (17) | 42.5 | L | |
| Wilbur Wood (17) | 42.5 | R | |
| 375. | Tony Oliva (15) | 42.4 | L |
| 376. | Roger Bresnahan+ (17) | 42.3 | R |
| Eddie Rommel (13) | 42.3 | R | |
| Chase Utley (9, 32) | 42.3 | L | |
| Omar Vizquel (23, 44) | 42.3 | B | |
| 380. | Claude Osteen (18) | 42.1 | L |
| 381. | Murry Dickson (18) | 42.0 | R |
| 382. | Chief Bender+ (16) | 41.9 | R |
| Milt Pappas (17) | 41.9 | R | |
| 384. | Dizzy Dean+ (12) | 41.8 | R |
| Paul Hines (20) | 41.8 | R | |
| Phil Rizzuto+ (13) | 41.8 | R | |
| 387. | Jose Canseco (17) | 41.7 | R |
| 388. | Andy Van Slyke (13) | 41.6 | L |
| 389. | Lenny Dykstra (12) | 41.5 | L |
| Dutch Leonard (20) | 41.5 | R | |
| Bobo Newsom (20) | 41.5 | R | |
| Jim Rice+ (16) | 41.5 | R | |
| 393. | Ben Chapman (15) | 41.4 | R |
| 394. | Devon White (17) | 41.3 | B |
| 395. | Chuck Knoblauch (12) | 41.2 | R |
| 396. | Tommy Bond (10) | 41.1 | R |
| Bob Welch (17) | 41.1 | R | |
| 398. | Brad Radke (12) | 40.9 | R |
| Doc White (13) | 40.9 | L | |
| 400. | Del Pratt (13) | 40.8 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 401. | Hardy Richardson (14) | 40.7 | R |
| Fernando Valenzuela (17) | 40.7 | L | |
| 403. | Jack Fournier (15) | 40.6 | L |
| Julio Franco (23) | 40.6 | R | |
| Darrell Porter (17) | 40.6 | L | |
| Bob Shawkey (15) | 40.6 | R | |
| Ken Singleton (15) | 40.6 | B | |
| Javier Vazquez (14, 34) | 40.6 | R | |
| 409. | Steve Finley (19) | 40.5 | L |
| 410. | Amos Otis (17) | 40.4 | R |
| Roger Peckinpaugh (17) | 40.4 | R | |
| Red Schoendienst+ (19) | 40.4 | B | |
| 413. | Joe Mauer (8, 28) | 40.3 | L |
| 414. | Miguel Cabrera (9, 28) | 40.2 | R |
| 415. | Schoolboy Rowe (15) | 40.1 | R |
| 416. | Wally Berger (11) | 40.0 | R |
| Larry French (14) | 40.0 | R | |
| Gil McDougald (10) | 40.0 | R | |
| Ed McKean (13) | 40.0 | R | |
| Al Orth (15) | 40.0 | L | |
| Jesse Tannehill (15) | 40.0 | B | |
| 422. | Nap Rucker (10) | 39.9 | R |
| 423. | Roger Maris (12) | 39.8 | L |
| Don Mattingly (14) | 39.8 | L | |
| 425. | David Justice (14) | 39.7 | L |
| Boog Powell (17) | 39.7 | L | |
| 427. | Tony Fernandez (17) | 39.6 | B |
| Ned Garver (14) | 39.6 | R | |
| 429. | Harry Brecheen (12) | 39.5 | L |
| Rich Gossage+ (22) | 39.5 | R | |
| 431. | Felipe Alou (17) | 39.4 | R |
| Sid Gordon (13) | 39.4 | R | |
| Frank Howard (16) | 39.4 | R | |
| 434. | Guy Hecker (9) | 39.3 | R |
| Carney Lansford (15) | 39.3 | R | |
| Davey Lopes (16) | 39.3 | R | |
| Jack Morris (18) | 39.3 | R | |
| 438. | Doug DeCinces (15) | 39.2 | R |
| Chuck Klein+ (17) | 39.2 | L | |
| 440. | Lou Brock+ (19) | 39.1 | L |
| Jim Gilliam (14) | 39.1 | B | |
| Hack Wilson+ (12) | 39.1 | R | |
| 443. | Tom Candiotti (16) | 39.0 | R |
| Ernie Lombardi+ (17) | 39.0 | R | |
| Bill Nicholson (16) | 39.0 | L | |
| Willie Wilson (19) | 39.0 | B | |
| 447. | John Candelaria (19) | 38.8 | L |
| Al Oliver (18) | 38.8 | L | |
| 449. | Lonny Frey (14) | 38.7 | L |
| Red Lucas (16) | 38.7 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Don Newcombe (10) | 38.7 | L | |
| 452. | Sam McDowell (15) | 38.6 | L |
| Mark Teixeira (9, 31) | 38.6 | B | |
| Virgil Trucks (17) | 38.6 | R | |
| 455. | Al Dark (14) | 38.5 | R |
| Harry Davis (22) | 38.5 | R | |
| Mel Stottlemyre (11) | 38.5 | R | |
| 458. | Ray Lankford (14) | 38.4 | L |
| Reggie Sanders (17) | 38.4 | R | |
| 460. | Noodles Hahn (8) | 38.3 | L |
| Mel Harder (20) | 38.3 | R | |
| 462. | Moises Alou (17) | 38.2 | R |
| Jake Daubert (15) | 38.2 | L | |
| Lefty Gomez+ (14) | 38.2 | L | |
| Rabbit Maranville+ (23) | 38.2 | R | |
| 466. | Sam Leever (13) | 38.1 | R |
| Jon Matlack (13) | 38.1 | L | |
| Eddie Stanky (11) | 38.1 | R | |
| 469. | Charlie Bennett (15) | 38.0 | R |
| George Mullin (14) | 38.0 | R | |
| Herb Pennock+ (22) | 38.0 | B | |
| Rick Wise (18) | 38.0 | R | |
| 473. | Ted Breitenstein (11) | 37.9 | L |
| Addie Joss+ (9) | 37.9 | R | |
| Hoyt Wilhelm+ (21) | 37.9 | R | |
| 476. | Gary Gaetti (20) | 37.8 | R |
| Dave Parker (19) | 37.8 | L | |
| 478. | Dick Bartell (18) | 37.7 | R |
| Jason Kendall (15) | 37.7 | R | |
| 480. | Tommy Henrich (11) | 37.6 | L |
| Ed Morris (7) | 37.6 | B | |
| Tim Salmon (14) | 37.6 | R | |
| Ezra Sutton (18) | 37.6 | R | |
| 484. | Albert Belle (12) | 37.4 | R |
| Charlie Root (17) | 37.4 | R | |
| 486. | Chili Davis (19) | 37.3 | B |
| Andy Messersmith (12) | 37.3 | R | |
| Ken Williams (14) | 37.3 | L | |
| 489. | Donie Bush (16) | 37.2 | B |
| Lonnie Smith (17) | 37.2 | R | |
| 491. | Frank Dwyer (12) | 37.1 | R |
| Kirk Gibson (17) | 37.1 | L | |
| Pie Traynor+ (17) | 37.1 | R | |
| Carlos Zambrano (11, 30) | 37.1 | B | |
| 495. | Harold Baines (22) | 37.0 | L |
| Jim Maloney (12) | 37.0 | L | |
| 497. | Sadie McMahon (9) | 36.8 | R |
| Hippo Vaughn (13) | 36.8 | B | |
| 499. | Ned Williamson (13) | 36.7 | R |
| 500. | Cy Seymour (16) | 36.6 | L |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 501. | Billy Nash (15) | 36.5 | R |
| 502. | Max Bishop (12) | 36.4 | L |
| Charlie Hough (25) | 36.4 | R | |
| 504. | Nig Cuppy (10) | 36.3 | R |
| Adonis Terry (14) | 36.3 | R | |
| 506. | Roy Campanella+ (10) | 36.2 | R |
| Babe Herman (13) | 36.2 | L | |
| Dan McGann (12) | 36.2 | B | |
| Ross Youngs+ (10) | 36.2 | L | |
| 510. | Pete Browning (13) | 36.1 | R |
| Danny Darwin (21) | 36.1 | R | |
| Al Leiter (19) | 36.1 | L | |
| Claude Passeau (13) | 36.1 | R | |
| 514. | Eric Chavez (14, 33) | 36.0 | L |
| 515. | Curt Flood (15) | 35.9 | R |
| Steve Garvey (19) | 35.9 | R | |
| Denny Lyons (13) | 35.9 | R | |
| 518. | Ed Reulbach (13) | 35.8 | R |
| 519. | Jesse Barfield (12) | 35.7 | R |
| Miller Huggins+ (13) | 35.7 | B | |
| Bill Hutchinson (9) | 35.7 | R | |
| Lance Parrish (19) | 35.7 | R | |
| 523. | Harvey Haddix (14) | 35.6 | L |
| Rico Petrocelli (13) | 35.6 | R | |
| 525. | Don Buford (10) | 35.5 | B |
| Bill Donovan (18) | 35.5 | B | |
| Paul O'Neill (17) | 35.5 | L | |
| Placido Polanco (14, 35) | 35.5 | R | |
| Smoky Joe Wood (14) | 35.5 | R | |
| 530. | Catfish Hunter+ (15) | 35.4 | R |
| Bill Madlock (15) | 35.4 | R | |
| Andy Pafko (17) | 35.4 | R | |
| 533. | Kent Hrbek (14) | 35.3 | L |
| 534. | Richie Hebner (18) | 35.2 | L |
| 535. | Pedro Guerrero (15) | 35.1 | R |
| Arlie Latham (17) | 35.1 | R | |
| Dick McAuliffe (16) | 35.1 | L | |
| Bob Rush (13) | 35.1 | R | |
| Kip Selbach (13) | 35.1 | R | |
| Jim Sundberg (16) | 35.1 | R | |
| 541. | Carl Furillo (15) | 35.0 | R |
| 542. | Dusty Baker (19) | 34.8 | R |
| Jay Bell (18) | 34.8 | R | |
| Bill Bradley (14) | 34.8 | R | |
| Mark Gubicza (14) | 34.8 | R | |
| Eddie Lopat (12) | 34.8 | L | |
| Camilo Pascual (18) | 34.8 | R | |
| Jim Perry (17) | 34.8 | B | |
| 549. | Harlond Clift (12) | 34.7 | R |
| Fred Dunlap (12) | 34.7 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 551. | Ron Fairly (21) | 34.6 | L |
| Burt Hooton (15) | 34.6 | R | |
| Magglio Ordonez (15, 37) | 34.6 | R | |
| 554. | Cecil Cooper (17) | 34.5 | L |
| Troy Glaus (13) | 34.5 | R | |
| Topsy Hartsel (14) | 34.5 | L | |
| Jeff Heath (14) | 34.5 | L | |
| Gus Weyhing (14) | 34.5 | R | |
| 559. | Bob Allison (13) | 34.4 | R |
| Freddie Fitzsimmons (19) | 34.4 | R | |
| Tom Gordon (21) | 34.4 | R | |
| Jimmy Rollins (12, 32) | 34.4 | B | |
| B.J. Surhoff (19) | 34.4 | L | |
| 564. | Lu Blue (13) | 34.3 | B |
| Clyde Milan (16) | 34.3 | L | |
| 566. | Joe Adcock (17) | 34.2 | R |
| Wally Joyner (16) | 34.2 | L | |
| David Ortiz (15, 35) | 34.2 | L | |
| Gene Woodling (17) | 34.2 | L | |
| 570. | Bartolo Colon (14, 38) | 34.0 | R |
| Eric Davis (17) | 34.0 | R | |
| Larry Dierker (14) | 34.0 | R | |
| 573. | Phil Cavarretta (22) | 33.9 | L |
| 574. | Ginger Beaumont (12) | 33.8 | L |
| Art Devlin (10) | 33.8 | R | |
| Bill Joyce (8) | 33.8 | L | |
| Garry Maddox (15) | 33.8 | R | |
| Heinie Zimmerman (13) | 33.8 | R | |
| 579. | Curt Davis (13) | 33.7 | R |
| Jeff Pfeffer (13) | 33.7 | R | |
| Jose Valentin (16) | 33.7 | B | |
| 582. | Dave Concepcion (19) | 33.6 | R |
| Ron Gant (16) | 33.6 | R | |
| George Kell+ (15) | 33.6 | R | |
| Chick Stahl (10) | 33.6 | L | |
| 586. | Kid Gleason (22) | 33.5 | B |
| Juan Gonzalez (17) | 33.5 | R | |
| Sad Sam Jones (22) | 33.5 | R | |
| Brian Jordan (15) | 33.5 | R | |
| Rick Rhoden (16) | 33.5 | R | |
| 591. | Danny Murphy (16) | 33.4 | R |
| Maury Wills (14) | 33.4 | B | |
| 593. | George Grantham (13) | 33.3 | L |
| 594. | Johnny Callison (16) | 33.2 | L |
| Jeff Cirillo (14) | 33.2 | R | |
| Freddy Garcia (13, 34) | 33.2 | R | |
| Mickey Vernon (20) | 33.2 | L | |
| 598. | Rafael Furcal (12, 33) | 33.1 | B |
| Bill White (13) | 33.1 | L | |
| 600. | Ken Caminiti (15) | 33.0 | B |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Jerry Reuss (22) | 33.0 | L | |
| Al Rosen (10) | 33.0 | R | |
| 603. | Gavvy Cravath (11) | 32.9 | R |
| Paul Derringer (15) | 32.9 | R | |
| Dwayne Murphy (12) | 32.9 | L | |
| Bobby Thomson (15) | 32.9 | R | |
| 607. | Tom Zachary (19) | 32.8 | L |
| 608. | Ray Durham (14) | 32.7 | B |
| Mike Garcia (14) | 32.7 | R | |
| Rick Monday (19) | 32.7 | L | |
| Bobby Murcer (17) | 32.7 | L | |
| 612. | Tommy Holmes (11) | 32.6 | L |
| David Wright (8, 28) | 32.6 | R | |
| 614. | Ross Barnes (9) | 32.5 | R |
| Mark Belanger (18) | 32.5 | R | |
| Jack Chesbro+ (11) | 32.5 | R | |
| Travis Fryman (13) | 32.5 | R | |
| Will White (10) | 32.5 | B | |
| 619. | Jim Bottomley+ (16) | 32.4 | L |
| Jimmy Williams (11) | 32.4 | R | |
| 621. | Claude Hendrix (10) | 32.3 | R |
| Frank McCormick (13) | 32.3 | R | |
| 623. | Freddy Parent (12) | 32.2 | R |
| 624. | Bobby Bonilla (16) | 32.1 | B |
| Bobby Shantz (16) | 32.1 | R | |
| Riggs Stephenson (14) | 32.1 | R | |
| 627. | Ice Box Chamberlain (10) | 32.0 | R |
| Don Money (16) | 32.0 | R | |
| 629. | Jack Clements (17) | 31.9 | L |
| Dom DiMaggio (11) | 31.9 | R | |
| Mike Donlin (12) | 31.9 | L | |
| Ken Griffey (19) | 31.9 | L | |
| Vern Law (16) | 31.9 | R | |
| 634. | Smoky Burgess (18) | 31.8 | L |
| John Tudor (12) | 31.8 | L | |
| 636. | Johnny Antonelli (12) | 31.7 | L |
| Bruce Hurst (15) | 31.7 | L | |
| Derek Lowe (15, 38) | 31.7 | R | |
| Ken McMullen (16) | 31.7 | R | |
| Edgar Renteria (16, 34) | 31.7 | R | |
| Jose Rijo (14) | 31.7 | R | |
| 642. | Tom Daly (17) | 31.6 | B |
| 643. | Doyle Alexander (19) | 31.5 | R |
| Earl Torgeson (15) | 31.5 | L | |
| Greg Vaughn (15) | 31.5 | R | |
| Earl Whitehill (17) | 31.5 | L | |
| 647. | Rico Carty (15) | 31.4 | R |
| Deacon Phillippe (13) | 31.4 | R | |
| Rick Sutcliffe (18) | 31.4 | L | |
| Tim Wallach (17) | 31.4 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 651. | Dick Groat (14) | 31.3 | R |
| Benny Kauff (8) | 31.3 | L | |
| Thornton Lee (16) | 31.3 | L | |
| 654. | Pat Hentgen (14) | 31.2 | R |
| Barry Zito (12, 33) | 31.2 | L | |
| 656. | Derrek Lee (15, 35) | 31.1 | R |
| Johnny Pesky (10) | 31.1 | L | |
| 658. | Chris Carpenter (14, 36) | 31.0 | R |
| Kevin McReynolds (12) | 31.0 | R | |
| Robby Thompson (11) | 31.0 | R | |
| 661. | Elbie Fletcher (12) | 30.9 | L |
| Dan Haren (9, 30) | 30.9 | R | |
| Matt Holliday (8, 31) | 30.9 | R | |
| Claude Ritchey (13) | 30.9 | B | |
| George Scott (14) | 30.9 | R | |
| Chris Short (15) | 30.9 | R | |
| John Valentin (11) | 30.9 | R | |
| Tim Wakefield (19, 44) | 30.9 | R | |
| 669. | Bill Dinneen (12) | 30.8 | R |
| Charlie Ferguson (4) | 30.8 | B | |
| Ted Kluszewski (15) | 30.8 | L | |
| Joe Start (16) | 30.8 | L | |
| 673. | Brady Anderson (15) | 30.7 | L |
| Matt Kilroy (10) | 30.7 | L | |
| 675. | Kid Elberfeld (14) | 30.6 | R |
| Sid Fernandez (15) | 30.6 | L | |
| Willie Kamm (13) | 30.6 | R | |
| Frank Lary (12) | 30.6 | R | |
| Cy Williams (19) | 30.6 | L | |
| 680. | Bill Doran (12) | 30.5 | B |
| Jesse Haines+ (19) | 30.5 | R | |
| Gary Matthews (16) | 30.5 | R | |
| Bob Watson (19) | 30.5 | R | |
| 684. | Paul Blair (17) | 30.4 | R |
| Bump Hadley (16) | 30.4 | R | |
| Trevor Hoffman (18) | 30.4 | R | |
| 687. | Howie Pollet (14) | 30.3 | L |
| Eddie Yost (18) | 30.3 | R | |
| 689. | Charlie Leibrandt (14) | 30.2 | R |
| Terry Turner (17) | 30.2 | R | |
| 691. | Dummy Hoy (14) | 30.1 | L |
| Wally Pipp (15) | 30.1 | L | |
| 693. | Mike Hargrove (12) | 30.0 | L |
| Ron Hunt (12) | 30.0 | R | |
| Harry Steinfeldt (14) | 30.0 | R | |
| 696. | Pink Hawley (10) | 29.9 | L |
| Sherm Lollar (18) | 29.9 | R | |
| 698. | Jim Barr (12) | 29.8 | R |
| Stuffy McInnis (19) | 29.8 | R | |
| Mickey Rivers (15) | 29.8 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 701. | Torii Hunter (15, 35) | 29.7 | R |
| Kevin Mitchell (13) | 29.7 | R | |
| Fritz Ostermueller (15) | 29.7 | L | |
| Hal Schumacher (13) | 29.7 | R | |
| Lee Smith (18) | 29.7 | R | |
| 706. | Andy Benes (14) | 29.6 | R |
| Cliff Lee (10, 32) | 29.6 | L | |
| Johnny Logan (13) | 29.6 | R | |
| Denis Menke (13) | 29.6 | R | |
| 710. | Chick Hafey+ (13) | 29.5 | R |
| Brickyard Kennedy (12) | 29.5 | R | |
| Rube Walberg (15) | 29.5 | L | |
| Kevin Youkilis (8, 32) | 29.5 | R | |
| 714. | Tony Cuccinello (15) | 29.4 | R |
| John Denny (13) | 29.4 | R | |
| Shawn Green (15) | 29.4 | L | |
| Willie McGee (18) | 29.4 | B | |
| 718. | Don Baylor (19) | 29.3 | R |
| Tom Haller (12) | 29.3 | L | |
| Hanley Ramirez (7, 27) | 29.3 | R | |
| Jose Reyes (9, 28) | 29.3 | B | |
| Billy Wagner (16) | 29.3 | L | |
| 723. | Hooks Dauss (15) | 29.2 | R |
| Del Ennis (14) | 29.2 | R | |
| Felix Hernandez (7, 25) | 29.2 | R | |
| Dutch Leonard (11) | 29.2 | L | |
| Freddie Lindstrom+ (13) | 29.2 | R | |
| 728. | Sal Maglie (10) | 29.1 | R |
| John Titus (11) | 29.1 | L | |
| 730. | Mike Boddicker (14) | 29.0 | R |
| Roy Cullenbine (10) | 29.0 | B | |
| Marty Marion (13) | 29.0 | R | |
| Don Wilson (9) | 29.0 | R | |
| 734. | Firpo Marberry (14) | 28.9 | R |
| 735. | George Burns (16) | 28.8 | R |
| Mort Cooper (11) | 28.8 | R | |
| Mike Lowell (13) | 28.8 | R | |
| Wally Moses (17) | 28.8 | L | |
| Rudy York (13) | 28.8 | R | |
| 740. | Ed Bailey (14) | 28.7 | L |
| Oyster Burns (11) | 28.7 | R | |
| Bill Hands (11) | 28.7 | R | |
| Ken Keltner (13) | 28.7 | R | |
| 744. | Josh Beckett (11, 31) | 28.6 | R |
| Bullet Joe Bush (17) | 28.6 | R | |
| Jake Peavy (10, 30) | 28.6 | R | |
| George Wright+ (12) | 28.6 | R | |
| 748. | Robinson Cano (7, 28) | 28.5 | L |
| Lance Johnson (14) | 28.5 | L | |
| Grady Sizemore (8, 28) | 28.5 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Vic Wertz (17) | 28.5 | L | |
| 752. | Edgardo Alfonzo (12) | 28.4 | R |
| Ed Brandt (11) | 28.4 | L | |
| Walker Cooper (18) | 28.4 | R | |
| Van Mungo (14) | 28.4 | R | |
| Mel Parnell (10) | 28.4 | L | |
| Johnny Podres (15) | 28.4 | L | |
| 758. | Teddy Higuera (9) | 28.3 | B |
| Eddie Joost (17) | 28.3 | R | |
| 760. | Adrian Gonzalez (8, 29) | 28.2 | L |
| Elston Howard (14) | 28.2 | R | |
| Greg Luzinski (15) | 28.2 | R | |
| Joe Niekro (22) | 28.2 | R | |
| Tip O'Neill (10) | 28.2 | R | |
| Pete Runnels (14) | 28.2 | L | |
| Sonny Siebert (12) | 28.2 | R | |
| 767. | Jimmy Dykes (22) | 28.1 | R |
| Mike Hampton (16) | 28.1 | R | |
| Marty McManus (15) | 28.1 | R | |
| 770. | Javy Lopez (15) | 27.9 | R |
| Terry Steinbach (14) | 27.9 | R | |
| 772. | Darin Erstad (14) | 27.8 | L |
| Frank Killen (10) | 27.8 | L | |
| Mickey Tettleton (14) | 27.8 | B | |
| 775. | Larry Corcoran (8) | 27.7 | B |
| Victor Martinez (10, 32) | 27.7 | B | |
| 777. | Howard Ehmke (15) | 27.6 | R |
| Livan Hernandez (16, 36) | 27.6 | R | |
| Billy Jurges (17) | 27.6 | R | |
| Joe Nuxhall (16) | 27.6 | L | |
| Brandon Webb (7, 32) | 27.6 | R | |
| 782. | John Hiller (15) | 27.5 | R |
| Bill Lee (14) | 27.5 | R | |
| Roy Sievers (17) | 27.5 | R | |
| Greg Swindell (17) | 27.5 | R | |
| 786. | John Anderson (14) | 27.4 | B |
| Bobby Avila (11) | 27.4 | R | |
| Ray Chapman (9) | 27.4 | R | |
| Joe Dobson (14) | 27.4 | R | |
| Cesar Tovar (12) | 27.4 | R | |
| Elmer Valo (20) | 27.4 | L | |
| 792. | Garret Anderson (17) | 27.3 | L |
| Alex Fernandez (10) | 27.3 | R | |
| Cliff Floyd (17) | 27.3 | L | |
| Dave Henderson (14) | 27.3 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (16) | 27.3 | R | |
| Slim Sallee (14) | 27.3 | R | |
| 798. | Ray Caldwell (12) | 27.2 | L |
| Carl Crawford (10, 29) | 27.2 | L | |
| Doug Drabek (13) | 27.2 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Scott Fletcher (15) | 27.2 | R | |
| Raul Mondesi (13) | 27.2 | R | |
| Preacher Roe (12) | 27.2 | R | |
| Hooks Wiltse (12) | 27.2 | R | |
| 805. | Curtis Granderson (8, 30) | 27.1 | L |
| Von Hayes (12) | 27.1 | L | |
| Willis Hudlin (16) | 27.1 | R | |
| Fred Hutchinson (11) | 27.1 | L | |
| Johnny Sain (11) | 27.1 | R | |
| 810. | Johnny Allen (13) | 27.0 | R |
| Allie Reynolds (13) | 27.0 | R | |
| Frank Schulte (15) | 27.0 | L | |
| 813. | Phil Garner (16) | 26.9 | R |
| Kevin Gross (15) | 26.9 | R | |
| George Hendrick (18) | 26.9 | R | |
| Sixto Lezcano (12) | 26.9 | R | |
| Bill Mazeroski+ (17) | 26.9 | R | |
| George Stone (7) | 26.9 | L | |
| Frank White (18) | 26.9 | R | |
| Michael Young (12, 34) | 26.9 | R | |
| 821. | Spud Chandler (11) | 26.8 | R |
| Tim McCarver (21) | 26.8 | L | |
| Jack McDowell (12) | 26.8 | R | |
| Dave Orr (8) | 26.8 | R | |
| Bill Skowron (14) | 26.8 | R | |
| Justin Verlander (7, 28) | 26.8 | R | |
| 827. | Del Crandall (16) | 26.7 | R |
| Andres Galarraga (19) | 26.7 | R | |
| Ryan Klesko (16) | 26.7 | L | |
| Jack Taylor (10) | 26.7 | R | |
| Jered Weaver (6, 28) | 26.7 | R | |
| 832. | Kevin Tapani (13) | 26.6 | R |
| Cecil Travis (12) | 26.6 | L | |
| 834. | Clete Boyer (16) | 26.5 | R |
| Russ Ford (7) | 26.5 | R | |
| Jackie Jensen (11) | 26.5 | R | |
| Melvin Mora (13, 39) | 26.5 | R | |
| Bill Sherdel (15) | 26.5 | L | |
| 839. | Ron Reed (19) | 26.4 | R |
| 840. | Carlos Guillen (14, 35) | 26.3 | B |
| 841. | Tony Gonzalez (12) | 26.2 | L |
| Ken Holtzman (15) | 26.2 | R | |
| Deacon McGuire (26) | 26.2 | R | |
| Hal McRae (19) | 26.2 | R | |
| Jack Rowe (12) | 26.2 | L | |
| Hal Trosky (11) | 26.2 | L | |
| 847. | Bob Boone (19) | 26.1 | R |
| John Kruk (10) | 26.1 | L | |
| Terry Puhl (15) | 26.1 | L | |
| Tommy Tucker (13) | 26.1 | B | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Jarrod Washburn (12) | 26.1 | L | |
| 852. | Gary Nolan (10) | 26.0 | R |
| Kevin Seitzer (12) | 26.0 | R | |
| Woody Williams (15) | 26.0 | R | |
| 855. | Paul Konerko (15, 35) | 25.9 | R |
| Vernon Wells (13, 32) | 25.9 | R | |
| 857. | Dean Chance (11) | 25.8 | R |
| General Crowder (11) | 25.8 | L | |
| Red Rolfe (10) | 25.8 | L | |
| Scott Sanderson (19) | 25.8 | R | |
| Mo Vaughn (12) | 25.8 | L | |
| Rondell White (15) | 25.8 | R | |
| Randy Winn (13) | 25.8 | B | |
| 864. | John Briggs (12) | 25.7 | L |
| Mike Cuellar (15) | 25.7 | L | |
| Harry Howell (13) | 25.7 | R | |
| Tino Martinez (16) | 25.7 | L | |
| Sam Mertes (10) | 25.7 | R | |
| Art Nehf (15) | 25.7 | L | |
| Ben Oglivie (16) | 25.7 | L | |
| 871. | Ken Forsch (16) | 25.6 | R |
| Marquis Grissom (17) | 25.6 | R | |
| Charley Jones (12) | 25.6 | R | |
| Terry Pendleton (15) | 25.6 | B | |
| Doug Rader (11) | 25.6 | R | |
| Billy Werber (11) | 25.6 | R | |
| 877. | Hank Bauer (14) | 25.5 | R |
| Woody English (12) | 25.5 | R | |
| Bob Ewing (11) | 25.5 | R | |
| John Franco (21) | 25.5 | L | |
| Kevin Millwood (15, 36) | 25.5 | R | |
| Amos Strunk (17) | 25.5 | L | |
| 883. | Ferris Fain (9) | 25.4 | L |
| Gary Peters (14) | 25.4 | L | |
| 885. | Solly Hemus (11) | 25.3 | L |
| Dutch Ruether (11) | 25.3 | L | |
| 887. | John Lackey (10, 32) | 25.2 | R |
| Ben Sanders (5) | 25.2 | R | |
| Garry Templeton (16) | 25.2 | B | |
| Kerry Wood (13, 34) | 25.2 | R | |
| 891. | Larry Hisle (14) | 25.1 | R |
| Bill Lange (7) | 25.1 | R | |
| Bobby Lowe (18) | 25.1 | R | |
| Ken Raffensberger (15) | 25.1 | R | |
| Joe Rudi (16) | 25.1 | R | |
| Roy Smalley (13) | 25.1 | B | |
| 897. | Turk Farrell (14) | 25.0 | R |
| Tommy Harper (15) | 25.0 | R | |
| Howard Johnson (14) | 25.0 | B | |
| Ted Lilly (13, 35) | 25.0 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Glenn Wright (11) | 25.0 | R | |
| 902. | Bob Bailey (17) | 24.9 | R |
| Bill Bruton (12) | 24.9 | L | |
| Danny Green (8) | 24.9 | L | |
| Syl Johnson (19) | 24.9 | R | |
| Ian Kinsler (6, 29) | 24.9 | R | |
| Bing Miller (16) | 24.9 | R | |
| Mike Moore (14) | 24.9 | R | |
| Bill Russell (18) | 24.9 | R | |
| Jason Schmidt (14) | 24.9 | R | |
| Chief Zimmer (19) | 24.9 | R | |
| 912. | Stan Javier (17) | 24.8 | B |
| Ellis Kinder (12) | 24.8 | R | |
| Max Lanier (14) | 24.8 | R | |
| 915. | Ossie Bluege (18) | 24.7 | R |
| Matt Cain (7, 26) | 24.7 | R | |
| Joe Harris (10) | 24.7 | R | |
| Johnny Hopp (14) | 24.7 | L | |
| Ramon Martinez (14) | 24.7 | R | |
| Aramis Ramirez (14, 33) | 24.7 | R | |
| Mario Soto (12) | 24.7 | R | |
| Chris Speier (19) | 24.7 | R | |
| Butch Wynegar (13) | 24.7 | B | |
| 924. | Tim Belcher (14) | 24.6 | R |
| High Pockets Kelly+ (16) | 24.6 | R | |
| Dode Paskert (15) | 24.6 | R | |
| Manny Sanguillen (13) | 24.6 | R | |
| Red Smith (9) | 24.6 | R | |
| 929. | Luis Castillo (15) | 24.5 | B |
| Jack Doyle (17) | 24.5 | R | |
| Davey Johnson (13) | 24.5 | R | |
| John Morrill (15) | 24.5 | R | |
| Hank Sauer (15) | 24.5 | R | |
| Snuffy Stirnweiss (10) | 24.5 | R | |
| Sam West (16) | 24.5 | L | |
| 936. | Mike Bordick (14) | 24.4 | R |
| Chris Chambliss (17) | 24.4 | L | |
| Zack Greinke (8, 27) | 24.4 | R | |
| John Reilly (10) | 24.4 | R | |
| Dave Roberts (13) | 24.4 | L | |
| Germany Smith (15) | 24.4 | R | |
| 942. | Rollie Fingers+ (17) | 24.3 | R |
| Mark Grudzielanek (15) | 24.3 | R | |
| Charlie Hickman (12) | 24.3 | R | |
| Willie Horton (18) | 24.3 | R | |
| Harvey Kuenn (15) | 24.3 | R | |
| Dustin Pedroia (6, 27) | 24.3 | R | |
| Dan Quisenberry (12) | 24.3 | R | |
| Bruce Sutter+ (12) | 24.3 | R | |
| Lloyd Waner+ (18) | 24.3 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| 951. | Kelvim Escobar (12) | 24.2 | R |
| Carlos Lee (13, 35) | 24.2 | R | |
| Rube Marquard+ (18) | 24.2 | B | |
| Wally Moon (12) | 24.2 | L | |
| Jim Piersall (17) | 24.2 | R | |
| Bob Purkey (13) | 24.2 | R | |
| 957. | Floyd Bannister (15) | 24.1 | L |
| Tom Burns (13) | 24.1 | R | |
| Whitey Kurowski (9) | 24.1 | R | |
| Evan Longoria (4, 25) | 24.1 | R | |
| Lloyd Moseby (12) | 24.1 | L | |
| Bill North (11) | 24.1 | B | |
| Pete Reiser (10) | 24.1 | L | |
| Dave Stewart (16) | 24.1 | R | |
| 965. | Ray Boone (13) | 24.0 | R |
| Adam Dunn (11, 31) | 24.0 | L | |
| Dennis Leonard (12) | 24.0 | R | |
| Kent Tekulve (16) | 24.0 | R | |
| 969. | Wilson Alvarez (14) | 23.9 | L |
| Jim Bagby (9) | 23.9 | B | |
| Leo Cardenas (16) | 23.9 | R | |
| Mike Flanagan (18) | 23.9 | L | |
| Greg Gagne (15) | 23.9 | R | |
| Buddy Lewis (11) | 23.9 | L | |
| Bob Meusel (11) | 23.9 | R | |
| Andre Thornton (14) | 23.9 | R | |
| 977. | Rick Dempsey (24) | 23.8 | R |
| Jim Devlin (5) | 23.8 | R | |
| Jim Ray Hart (12) | 23.8 | R | |
| Joe Kuhel (18) | 23.8 | L | |
| Henry Larkin (10) | 23.8 | R | |
| Steve Renko (15) | 23.8 | R | |
| Benito Santiago (20) | 23.8 | R | |
| Jake Weimer (7) | 23.8 | R | |
| Randy Wolf (13, 34) | 23.8 | L | |
| 986. | Corey Koskie (9) | 23.7 | L |
| Lefty O'Doul (11) | 23.7 | L | |
| Mike Scioscia (13) | 23.7 | L | |
| Ed Seward (6) | 23.7 | ||
| Troy Tulowitzki (6, 26) | 23.7 | R | |
| Richie Zisk (13) | 23.7 | R | |
| 992. | Casey Blake (13, 37) | 23.6 | R |
| Don Mincher (13) | 23.6 | L | |
| 994. | Ripper Collins (9) | 23.5 | B |
| Ival Goodman (10) | 23.5 | L | |
| Mike Greenwell (12) | 23.5 | L | |
| Steve Gromek (17) | 23.5 | B | |
| Bob Veale (13) | 23.5 | B | |
| 999. | Chris Bosio (11) | 23.4 | R |
| Chris Hoiles (10) | 23.4 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Wins Above Replacement | Bats/Throws |
| Johnny Mostil (10) | 23.4 | R | |
| Alfonso Soriano (13, 35) | 23.4 | R | |
| Earl Wilson (11) | 23.4 | R |
Note that seasons prior to 1876 are not included in single-season marks, but are included in career marks.