Play Index Relaunched / 2010 HOF Ballot
B-R on Twitter / Facebook
S-R.com: Baseball | Basketball | Football | Hockey | Olympics

You Are Here > Baseball-Reference.com > Teams > Franchise Encyclopedia > Batting Leaders

New York Mutuals Top 50 Batting Leaders

Team Encyclopedia
  Starters: Positional / Pitching - Players: Batting / Pitching - Teams: Batting / Pitching
  Leaders: Batting / Pitching - Managers - Attendance/Parks
  Hall of Fame Register - Opening Day Starters
  Logos from SportsLogos.net. Page: none available.

Sponsor this page for $10 and help Baseball-Reference.com provide this service. Your message will replace this ad.

Create Custom Leaderboards

The Baseball-Reference.com Play Index's Batting Season Finder lets you create your own custom leaderboards by team, age, position, years, or any other common criteria. View Sample Leaderboards created with the batting season finder.

New York Mutuals Top 50 Batting Leaders

See Also: Top 10 / Top 50
Click on the Player for player statistics, biography, and information.
Click on the Year for team roster, statistics, and leaders.
1500 PA required for career rate statistics.

Single-Season Leaders

Career Leaders

Batting Average
Rank Player BA Year

1. Joe Start .314 1874

2. Joe Start .287 1875

3. Jim Holdsworth .284 1875

4. Doug Allison .283 1874

5. Dick Higham .261 1874

Batting Average
Rank Player BA PA

On-Base%
Rank Player OBP Year

1. Joe Start .323 1874

2. Doug Allison .296 1874

3. Joe Start .293 1875

4. Jim Holdsworth .286 1875

5. Dick Higham .270 1874

On-Base%
Rank Player OBP PA

Slugging %
Rank Player SLG Year

1. Joe Start .395 1874

2. Joe Start .389 1875

3. Doug Allison .336 1874

4. Dick Higham .330 1874

5. Jim Holdsworth .327 1875

Slugging %
Rank Player SLG PA

On-Base Plus Slugging
Rank Player OPS Year

1. Joe Start .718 1874

2. Joe Start .682 1875

3. Doug Allison .633 1874

4. Jim Holdsworth .613 1875

5. Dick Higham .600 1874

On-Base Plus Slugging
Rank Player OPS PA

Games Played
Rank Player Games Year

1. Jim Holdsworth 71 1875

2. Bobby Mathews 70 1875

Candy Nelson 70 1875

4. Joe Start 69 1875

5. Eddie Booth 68 1875

Count Gedney 68 1875

7. Doug Allison 65 1874

Dick Higham 65 1874

Bobby Mathews 65 1874

Candy Nelson 65 1874

11. Tom Carey 64 1874

Jack Remsen 64 1874

13. John Hatfield 63 1874

Joe Start 63 1874

15. Nat Hicks 62 1875

16. Jack Burdock 61 1874

17. Joe Gerhardt 58 1875

18. Dave Eggler 56 1872

John Hatfield 56 1872

Nat Hicks 56 1872

21. Candy Cummings 55 1872

Joe Start 55 1872

23. John McMullin 54 1872

24. Dave Eggler 53 1873

Count Gedney 53 1873

Jim Holdsworth 53 1873

Joe Start 53 1873

28. John Hatfield 52 1873

Bobby Mathews 52 1873

30. George Bechtel 51 1872

31. Dick Higham 49 1873

32. Jimmy Hallinan 44 1875

Dickey Pearce 44 1872

34. Chick Fulmer 36 1872

Candy Nelson 36 1873

36. Bill Boyd 35 1872

37. Dave Eggler 33 1871

Bob Ferguson 33 1871

John Hatfield 33 1871

Dickey Pearce 33 1871

Joe Start 33 1871

42. Charlie Mills 32 1871

Tom Patterson 32 1871

Rynie Wolters 32 1871

45. Phonney Martin 31 1873

46. Nat Hicks 28 1873

47. Pat McGee 25 1875

48. Dick Higham 21 1871

49. Dick Higham 15 1875

50. Charlie Smith 14 1871

Games Played
Rank Player Games PA

1. Joe Start 273 1328

2. John Hatfield 205 1030

3. Bobby Mathews 187 800

4. Candy Nelson 171 760

5. Dick Higham 150 744

6. Nat Hicks 146 672

7. Dave Eggler 142 722

8. Jim Holdsworth 124 558

9. Count Gedney 121 498

10. Dickey Pearce 77 377

11. Doug Allison 76 373

12. Eddie Booth 68 281

13. Tom Carey 64 288

Jack Remsen 64 284

15. Jack Burdock 61 274

16. Joe Gerhardt 58 252

17. Candy Cummings 55 254

18. John McMullin 54 248

19. George Bechtel 51 254

20. Jimmy Hallinan 44 204

21. Charlie Mills 38 178

22. Chick Fulmer 36 168

23. Bill Boyd 35 171

24. Bob Ferguson 33 161

Tom Patterson 33 157

26. Rynie Wolters 32 148

27. Phonney Martin 31 140

28. Pat McGee 25 95

29. Charlie Smith 14 73

30. Billy Barnie 9 35

Nealy Phelps 9 36

32. Steve Bellan 8 34

Al Metcalf 8 32

34. Billy Geer 2 8

35. Frank Fleet 1 6

Orator Shaffer 1 5

At Bats
Rank Player AB Year

1. Dick Higham 333 1874

2. Jim Holdsworth 324 1875

3. Doug Allison 318 1874

4. Joe Start 314 1875

5. Joe Start 306 1874

6. Bobby Mathews 298 1874

7. Candy Nelson 297 1874

8. John Hatfield 292 1874

9. Dave Eggler 290 1872

10. John Hatfield 288 1872

11. Tom Carey 286 1874

12. Jack Remsen 284 1874

13. Joe Start 282 1872

14. Eddie Booth 281 1875

15. Candy Nelson 276 1875

16. Jack Burdock 273 1874

17. Nat Hicks 269 1875

18. Dave Eggler 268 1873

Nat Hicks 268 1872

20. Count Gedney 267 1875

21. Bobby Mathews 264 1875

22. John Hatfield 255 1873

23. Joe Gerhardt 252 1875

24. Joe Start 251 1873

25. Candy Cummings 250 1872

26. George Bechtel 248 1872

27. Dick Higham 245 1873

28. John McMullin 237 1872

29. Jim Holdsworth 233 1873

30. Count Gedney 224 1873

31. Bobby Mathews 223 1873

32. Dickey Pearce 206 1872

33. Jimmy Hallinan 203 1875

34. John Hatfield 168 1871

Candy Nelson 168 1873

36. Chick Fulmer 166 1872

37. Bill Boyd 165 1872

38. Dickey Pearce 163 1871

39. Joe Start 161 1871

40. Bob Ferguson 158 1871

41. Tom Patterson 151 1871

42. Dave Eggler 147 1871

43. Charlie Mills 146 1871

44. Phonney Martin 140 1873

45. Rynie Wolters 138 1871

46. Nat Hicks 121 1873

47. Pat McGee 95 1875

48. Dick Higham 94 1871

49. Charlie Smith 72 1871

50. Dick Higham 64 1875

At Bats
Rank Player AB PA

1. Joe Start 1314 1328

2. John Hatfield 1007 1030

3. Bobby Mathews 785 800

4. Candy Nelson 741 760

5. Dick Higham 736 744

6. Dave Eggler 705 722

7. Nat Hicks 658 672

8. Jim Holdsworth 557 558

9. Count Gedney 491 498

10. Dickey Pearce 369 377

11. Doug Allison 366 373

12. Tom Carey 286 288

13. Jack Remsen 284 284

14. Eddie Booth 281 281

15. Jack Burdock 273 274

16. Joe Gerhardt 252 252

17. Candy Cummings 250 254

18. George Bechtel 248 254

19. John McMullin 237 248

20. Jimmy Hallinan 203 204

21. Charlie Mills 177 178

22. Chick Fulmer 166 168

23. Bill Boyd 165 171

24. Bob Ferguson 158 161

25. Tom Patterson 156 157

26. Phonney Martin 140 140

27. Rynie Wolters 138 148

28. Pat McGee 95 95

29. Charlie Smith 72 73

30. Nealy Phelps 36 36

31. Billy Barnie 34 35

32. Steve Bellan 32 34

Al Metcalf 32 32

34. Billy Geer 8 8

35. Frank Fleet 6 6

36. Orator Shaffer 5 5

Plate Appearances
Rank Player PA Year

1. Dick Higham 337 1874

2. Jim Holdsworth 325 1875

3. Doug Allison 324 1874

4. Joe Start 317 1875

5. Joe Start 310 1874

6. Candy Nelson 306 1874

7. Bobby Mathews 301 1874

8. John Hatfield 299 1874

9. Dave Eggler 298 1872

10. John Hatfield 297 1872

11. Tom Carey 288 1874

12. Candy Nelson 285 1875

13. Jack Remsen 284 1874

14. Joe Start 282 1872

15. Eddie Booth 281 1875

16. Jack Burdock 274 1874

17. Dave Eggler 273 1873

Nat Hicks 273 1872

19. Nat Hicks 271 1875

20. Count Gedney 267 1875

21. Bobby Mathews 266 1875

22. John Hatfield 258 1873

23. Joe Start 255 1873

24. George Bechtel 254 1872

Candy Cummings 254 1872

26. Joe Gerhardt 252 1875

27. John McMullin 248 1872

28. Dick Higham 247 1873

29. Jim Holdsworth 233 1873

Bobby Mathews 233 1873

31. Count Gedney 231 1873

32. Dickey Pearce 210 1872

33. Jimmy Hallinan 204 1875

34. John Hatfield 172 1871

35. Bill Boyd 171 1872

36. Candy Nelson 169 1873

37. Chick Fulmer 168 1872

38. Dickey Pearce 167 1871

39. Joe Start 164 1871

40. Bob Ferguson 161 1871

41. Tom Patterson 152 1871

42. Dave Eggler 151 1871

43. Rynie Wolters 148 1871

44. Charlie Mills 147 1871

45. Phonney Martin 140 1873

46. Nat Hicks 128 1873

47. Dick Higham 96 1871

48. Pat McGee 95 1875

49. Charlie Smith 73 1871

50. Dick Higham 64 1875

Plate Appearances
Rank Player PA PA

1. Joe Start 1328 1328

2. John Hatfield 1030 1030

3. Bobby Mathews 800 800

4. Candy Nelson 760 760

5. Dick Higham 744 744

6. Dave Eggler 722 722

7. Nat Hicks 672 672

8. Jim Holdsworth 558 558

9. Count Gedney 498 498

10. Dickey Pearce 377 377

11. Doug Allison 373 373

12. Tom Carey 288 288

13. Jack Remsen 284 284

14. Eddie Booth 281 281

15. Jack Burdock 274 274

16. George Bechtel 254 254

Candy Cummings 254 254

18. Joe Gerhardt 252 252

19. John McMullin 248 248

20. Jimmy Hallinan 204 204

21. Charlie Mills 178 178

22. Bill Boyd 171 171

23. Chick Fulmer 168 168

24. Bob Ferguson 161 161

25. Tom Patterson 157 157

26. Rynie Wolters 148 148

27. Phonney Martin 140 140

28. Pat McGee 95 95

29. Charlie Smith 73 73

30. Nealy Phelps 36 36

31. Billy Barnie 35 35

32. Steve Bellan 34 34

33. Al Metcalf 32 32

34. Billy Geer 8 8

35. Frank Fleet 6 6

36. Orator Shaffer 5 5

Runs Scored
Rank Player Runs Year

1. Dave Eggler 94 1872

2. Dave Eggler 82 1873

3. John Hatfield 76 1872

4. Doug Allison 68 1874

5. Joe Start 67 1874

6. Joe Start 62 1872

7. George Bechtel 60 1872

8. Dick Higham 58 1874

Joe Start 58 1875

10. Dick Higham 57 1873

11. Tom Carey 56 1874

12. Nat Hicks 55 1872

Candy Nelson 55 1874

14. John Hatfield 54 1873

15. Jack Remsen 52 1874

16. John McMullin 48 1872

17. John Hatfield 47 1874

18. Jim Holdsworth 46 1873

Bobby Mathews 46 1874

20. Jack Burdock 45 1874

Jim Holdsworth 45 1875

22. Joe Start 42 1873

23. Count Gedney 41 1873

John Hatfield 41 1871

25. Bobby Mathews 40 1873

26. Dave Eggler 37 1871

27. Candy Cummings 36 1872

28. Joe Start 35 1871

29. Eddie Booth 33 1875

Rynie Wolters 33 1871

31. Nat Hicks 32 1875

Dickey Pearce 32 1872

33. Tom Patterson 31 1871

Dickey Pearce 31 1871

35. Bob Ferguson 30 1871

Count Gedney 30 1875

37. Joe Gerhardt 29 1875

Jimmy Hallinan 29 1875

39. Chick Fulmer 28 1872

Candy Nelson 28 1873

Candy Nelson 28 1875

42. Charlie Mills 27 1871

43. Bill Boyd 26 1872

44. Bobby Mathews 23 1875

45. Dick Higham 21 1871

46. Charlie Smith 15 1871

47. Nat Hicks 12 1873

Dick Higham 12 1875

Phonney Martin 12 1873

50. Doug Allison 6 1873

Charlie Mills 6 1872

Runs Scored
Rank Player Runs PA

1. Joe Start 264 1328

2. John Hatfield 219 1030

3. Dave Eggler 213 722

4. Dick Higham 148 744

5. Candy Nelson 111 760

6. Bobby Mathews 109 800

7. Nat Hicks 99 672

8. Jim Holdsworth 91 558

9. Doug Allison 74 373

10. Count Gedney 71 498

11. Dickey Pearce 63 377

12. George Bechtel 60 254

13. Tom Carey 56 288

14. Jack Remsen 52 284

15. John McMullin 48 248

16. Jack Burdock 45 274

17. Candy Cummings 36 254

18. Eddie Booth 33 281

Charlie Mills 33 178

Rynie Wolters 33 148

21. Tom Patterson 32 157

22. Bob Ferguson 30 161

23. Joe Gerhardt 29 252

Jimmy Hallinan 29 204

25. Chick Fulmer 28 168

26. Bill Boyd 26 171

27. Charlie Smith 15 73

28. Phonney Martin 12 140

29. Nealy Phelps 6 36

30. Steve Bellan 4 34

Pat McGee 4 95

32. Al Metcalf 2 32

33. Billy Barnie 1 35

Frank Fleet 1 6

Orator Shaffer 1 5

Hits
Rank Player Hits Year

1. Dave Eggler 98 1872

2. Joe Start 96 1874

3. John Hatfield 92 1872

Jim Holdsworth 92 1875

5. Doug Allison 90 1874

Dave Eggler 90 1873

Joe Start 90 1875

8. Dick Higham 87 1874

9. Tom Carey 82 1874

Nat Hicks 82 1872

11. John Hatfield 78 1873

12. Dick Higham 77 1873

13. Joe Start 76 1872

14. Jack Burdock 75 1874

Jim Holdsworth 75 1873

16. George Bechtel 74 1872

17. Candy Nelson 73 1874

18. Bobby Mathews 72 1874

19. Nat Hicks 67 1875

Joe Start 67 1873

21. John Hatfield 66 1874

22. Jack Remsen 65 1874

23. John McMullin 61 1872

24. Count Gedney 60 1873

25. Jimmy Hallinan 58 1875

Joe Start 58 1871

27. Eddie Booth 56 1875

28. Count Gedney 55 1875

Candy Nelson 55 1873

Candy Nelson 55 1875

31. Joe Gerhardt 54 1875

32. Candy Cummings 52 1872

33. Chick Fulmer 51 1872

Rynie Wolters 51 1871

35. Bobby Mathews 48 1875

36. Dave Eggler 47 1871

37. Bill Boyd 44 1872

Dickey Pearce 44 1871

39. John Hatfield 43 1871

Bobby Mathews 43 1873

41. Dickey Pearce 40 1872

42. Bob Ferguson 38 1871

43. Charlie Mills 36 1871

44. Dick Higham 34 1871

45. Phonney Martin 31 1873

Tom Patterson 31 1871

47. Nat Hicks 29 1873

48. Dick Higham 25 1875

49. Charlie Smith 19 1871

50. Pat McGee 17 1875

Hits
Rank Player Hits PA

1. Joe Start 387 1328

2. John Hatfield 281 1030

3. Dave Eggler 235 722

4. Dick Higham 223 744

5. Candy Nelson 183 760

6. Nat Hicks 178 672

7. Jim Holdsworth 167 558

8. Bobby Mathews 163 800

9. Count Gedney 115 498

10. Doug Allison 100 373

11. Dickey Pearce 84 377

12. Tom Carey 82 288

13. Jack Burdock 75 274

14. George Bechtel 74 254

15. Jack Remsen 65 284

16. John McMullin 61 248

17. Jimmy Hallinan 58 204

18. Eddie Booth 56 281

19. Joe Gerhardt 54 252

20. Candy Cummings 52 254

21. Chick Fulmer 51 168

Rynie Wolters 51 148

23. Bill Boyd 44 171

24. Charlie Mills 40 178

25. Bob Ferguson 38 161

26. Tom Patterson 33 157

27. Phonney Martin 31 140

28. Charlie Smith 19 73

29. Pat McGee 17 95

30. Steve Bellan 7 34

Al Metcalf 7 32

32. Billy Barnie 5 35

Nealy Phelps 5 36

34. Frank Fleet 2 6

Billy Geer 2 8

36. Orator Shaffer 1 5

Total Bases
Rank Player TB Year

1. Joe Start 122 1875

2. Joe Start 121 1874

3. Dave Eggler 118 1872

4. John Hatfield 112 1872

5. Dave Eggler 111 1873

6. Dick Higham 110 1874

7. Doug Allison 107 1874

8. Jim Holdsworth 106 1875

9. Tom Carey 101 1874

John Hatfield 101 1873

11. Nat Hicks 98 1872

12. Jack Burdock 97 1874

13. Jim Holdsworth 95 1873

14. Dick Higham 90 1873

Candy Nelson 90 1874

16. George Bechtel 89 1872

17. Jack Remsen 86 1874

18. Joe Start 84 1873

19. John Hatfield 80 1874

Bobby Mathews 80 1874

Joe Start 80 1872

22. Jimmy Hallinan 79 1875

23. Count Gedney 78 1873

24. Nat Hicks 77 1875

25. Rynie Wolters 75 1871

26. Count Gedney 71 1875

27. John McMullin 69 1872

28. Joe Start 68 1871

29. Eddie Booth 67 1875

Candy Cummings 67 1872

Joe Gerhardt 67 1875

32. Candy Nelson 64 1875

33. Candy Nelson 61 1873

34. Dave Eggler 60 1871

35. Bobby Mathews 58 1875

36. Chick Fulmer 57 1872

37. Bill Boyd 55 1872

38. Bobby Mathews 52 1873

39. John Hatfield 50 1871

40. Dickey Pearce 49 1871

41. Bob Ferguson 46 1871

Charlie Mills 46 1871

Dickey Pearce 46 1872

44. Dick Higham 39 1871

45. Nat Hicks 37 1873

46. Tom Patterson 33 1871

47. Phonney Martin 32 1873

48. Dick Higham 30 1875

49. Charlie Smith 23 1871

50. Pat McGee 19 1875

Total Bases
Rank Player TB PA

1. Joe Start 475 1328

2. John Hatfield 346 1030

3. Dave Eggler 289 722

4. Dick Higham 269 744

5. Candy Nelson 215 760

6. Nat Hicks 212 672

7. Jim Holdsworth 201 558

8. Bobby Mathews 190 800

9. Count Gedney 149 498

10. Doug Allison 117 373

11. Tom Carey 101 288

12. Jack Burdock 97 274

13. Dickey Pearce 95 377

14. George Bechtel 89 254

15. Jack Remsen 86 284

16. Jimmy Hallinan 79 204

17. Rynie Wolters 75 148

18. John McMullin 69 248

19. Eddie Booth 67 281

Candy Cummings 67 254

Joe Gerhardt 67 252

22. Chick Fulmer 57 168

23. Bill Boyd 55 171

24. Charlie Mills 50 178

25. Bob Ferguson 46 161

26. Tom Patterson 35 157

27. Phonney Martin 32 140

28. Charlie Smith 23 73

29. Pat McGee 19 95

30. Steve Bellan 9 34

31. Al Metcalf 7 32

32. Nealy Phelps 6 36

33. Billy Barnie 5 35

34. Frank Fleet 2 6

Billy Geer 2 8

36. Orator Shaffer 1 5

Doubles
Rank Player Doubles Year

1. Dave Eggler 20 1872

2. John Hatfield 15 1872

3. Dick Higham 14 1874

4. Dave Eggler 13 1873

Joe Start 13 1874

6. Count Gedney 12 1875

John Hatfield 12 1874

Nat Hicks 12 1872

Jim Holdsworth 12 1875

10. George Bechtel 11 1872

Jack Burdock 11 1874

12. Tom Carey 10 1874

Nat Hicks 10 1875

Joe Start 10 1875

15. Candy Cummings 9 1872

Jack Remsen 9 1874

17. Joe Start 8 1873

18. Doug Allison 7 1874

Dave Eggler 7 1871

Joe Gerhardt 7 1875

Candy Nelson 7 1874

Candy Nelson 7 1875

23. Bill Boyd 6 1872

Bob Ferguson 6 1871

Jimmy Hallinan 6 1875

Bobby Mathews 6 1874

Bobby Mathews 6 1875

John McMullin 6 1872

Rynie Wolters 6 1871

30. Count Gedney 5 1873

John Hatfield 5 1873

Dick Higham 5 1873

Dick Higham 5 1875

Dickey Pearce 5 1871

Joe Start 5 1871

36. Jim Holdsworth 4 1873

Charlie Mills 4 1871

Candy Nelson 4 1873

Joe Start 4 1872

40. Eddie Booth 3 1875

John Hatfield 3 1871

Dick Higham 3 1871

Bobby Mathews 3 1873

44. Steve Bellan 2 1873

Pat McGee 2 1875

Tom Patterson 2 1871

Charlie Smith 2 1871

48. Chick Fulmer 1 1872

John Hatfield 1 1875

Nat Hicks 1 1873

Phonney Martin 1 1873

Dickey Pearce 1 1872

Nealy Phelps 1 1875

Doubles
Rank Player Doubles PA

1. Dave Eggler 40 722

Joe Start 40 1328

3. John Hatfield 36 1030

4. Dick Higham 27 744

5. Nat Hicks 23 672

6. Candy Nelson 18 760

7. Count Gedney 17 498

8. Jim Holdsworth 16 558

9. Bobby Mathews 15 800

10. George Bechtel 11 254

Jack Burdock 11 274

12. Tom Carey 10 288

13. Candy Cummings 9 254

Jack Remsen 9 284

15. Doug Allison 7 373

Joe Gerhardt 7 252

17. Bill Boyd 6 171

Bob Ferguson 6 161

Jimmy Hallinan 6 204

John McMullin 6 248

Dickey Pearce 6 377

Rynie Wolters 6 148

23. Charlie Mills 4 178

24. Eddie Booth 3 281

25. Steve Bellan 2 34

Pat McGee 2 95

Tom Patterson 2 157

Charlie Smith 2 73

29. Chick Fulmer 1 168

Phonney Martin 1 140

Nealy Phelps 1 36

Triples
Rank Player Triples Year

1. Rynie Wolters 9 1871

2. Jim Holdsworth 8 1873

3. John Hatfield 6 1873

4. Doug Allison 5 1874

Count Gedney 5 1873

Candy Nelson 5 1874

Joe Start 5 1875

8. Eddie Booth 4 1875

Jack Burdock 4 1874

Dave Eggler 4 1873

Dick Higham 4 1873

12. Tom Carey 3 1874

Candy Cummings 3 1872

Dave Eggler 3 1871

Joe Gerhardt 3 1875

Jimmy Hallinan 3 1875

Dick Higham 3 1874

Bobby Mathews 3 1873

Charlie Mills 3 1871

Jack Remsen 3 1874

Joe Start 3 1873

Joe Start 3 1874

23. George Bechtel 2 1872

Count Gedney 2 1875

John Hatfield 2 1871

Nat Hicks 2 1872

Nat Hicks 2 1873

Bobby Mathews 2 1875

29. Bill Boyd 1 1872

Bob Ferguson 1 1871

Chick Fulmer 1 1872

John Hatfield 1 1872

John Hatfield 1 1874

Dick Higham 1 1871

Jim Holdsworth 1 1875

Bobby Mathews 1 1874

John McMullin 1 1872

Candy Nelson 1 1873

Candy Nelson 1 1875

Dickey Pearce 1 1872

Charlie Smith 1 1871

Joe Start 1 1871

Triples
Rank Player Triples PA

1. Joe Start 12 1328

2. John Hatfield 10 1030

3. Jim Holdsworth 9 558

Rynie Wolters 9 148

5. Dick Higham 8 744

6. Dave Eggler 7 722

Count Gedney 7 498

Candy Nelson 7 760

9. Bobby Mathews 6 800

10. Doug Allison 5 373

11. Eddie Booth 4 281

Jack Burdock 4 274

Nat Hicks 4 672

14. Tom Carey 3 288

Candy Cummings 3 254

Joe Gerhardt 3 252

Jimmy Hallinan 3 204

Charlie Mills 3 178

Jack Remsen 3 284

20. George Bechtel 2 254

21. Bill Boyd 1 171

Bob Ferguson 1 161

Chick Fulmer 1 168

John McMullin 1 248

Dickey Pearce 1 377

Charlie Smith 1 73

Home Runs
Rank Player HR Year

1. Joe Start 4 1875

2. Jimmy Hallinan 3 1875

3. John Hatfield 2 1873

Jack Remsen 2 1874

Joe Start 2 1874

6. Bill Boyd 1 1872

Jack Burdock 1 1874

Tom Carey 1 1874

Chick Fulmer 1 1872

Count Gedney 1 1873

John Hatfield 1 1872

Nat Hicks 1 1873

Dick Higham 1 1874

Dickey Pearce 1 1872

Joe Start 1 1871

Joe Start 1 1873

Home Runs
Rank Player HR PA

1. Joe Start 8 1328

2. Jimmy Hallinan 3 204

John Hatfield 3 1030

4. Jack Remsen 2 284

5. Bill Boyd 1 171

Jack Burdock 1 274

Tom Carey 1 288

Chick Fulmer 1 168

Count Gedney 1 498

Nat Hicks 1 672

Dick Higham 1 744

Dickey Pearce 1 377

Runs Batted In
Rank Player RBI Year

1. Joe Start 50 1872

2. John Hatfield 45 1872

John Hatfield 45 1873

Joe Start 45 1874

5. Rynie Wolters 44 1871

6. George Bechtel 41 1872

7. Tom Carey 39 1874

8. Dick Higham 37 1874

Jack Remsen 37 1874

10. Dave Eggler 34 1873

Dick Higham 34 1873

Joe Start 34 1871

13. Nat Hicks 33 1872

14. Bill Boyd 32 1872

Candy Nelson 32 1874

16. John Hatfield 30 1874

Bobby Mathews 30 1874

Joe Start 30 1875

19. Doug Allison 28 1874

Jim Holdsworth 28 1873

Joe Start 28 1873

22. Jack Burdock 27 1874

Candy Cummings 27 1872

24. Bob Ferguson 25 1871

Count Gedney 25 1873

John McMullin 25 1872

27. Jim Holdsworth 23 1875

Candy Nelson 23 1875

Dickey Pearce 23 1872

30. John Hatfield 22 1871

Nat Hicks 22 1875

Charlie Mills 22 1871

Candy Nelson 22 1873

34. Jimmy Hallinan 21 1875

35. Dave Eggler 20 1872

Joe Gerhardt 20 1875

Dickey Pearce 20 1871

38. Eddie Booth 18 1875

Dave Eggler 18 1871

40. Count Gedney 17 1875

41. Bobby Mathews 15 1875

42. Chick Fulmer 14 1872

Nat Hicks 14 1873

Phonney Martin 14 1873

45. Bobby Mathews 13 1873

Tom Patterson 13 1871

47. Dick Higham 10 1875

48. Dick Higham 9 1871

Pat McGee 9 1875

50. Charlie Smith 5 1871

Runs Batted In
Rank Player RBI PA

1. Joe Start 187 1328

2. John Hatfield 143 1030

3. Dick Higham 90 744

4. Candy Nelson 77 760

5. Dave Eggler 72 722

6. Nat Hicks 69 672

7. Bobby Mathews 58 800

8. Jim Holdsworth 51 558

9. Rynie Wolters 44 148

10. Dickey Pearce 43 377

11. Count Gedney 42 498

12. George Bechtel 41 254

13. Tom Carey 39 288

14. Jack Remsen 37 284

15. Bill Boyd 32 171

16. Doug Allison 31 373

17. Jack Burdock 27 274

Candy Cummings 27 254

19. Bob Ferguson 25 161

John McMullin 25 248

21. Charlie Mills 24 178

22. Jimmy Hallinan 21 204

23. Joe Gerhardt 20 252

24. Eddie Booth 18 281

25. Tom Patterson 15 157

26. Chick Fulmer 14 168

Phonney Martin 14 140

28. Pat McGee 9 95

29. Charlie Smith 5 73

30. Steve Bellan 3 34

31. Nealy Phelps 2 36

32. Billy Barnie 1 35

Frank Fleet 1 6

Billy Geer 1 8

Al Metcalf 1 32

Bases on Balls
Rank Player BB Year

1. John McMullin 11 1872

2. Bobby Mathews 10 1873

Rynie Wolters 10 1871

4. John Hatfield 9 1872

Candy Nelson 9 1874

Candy Nelson 9 1875

7. Dave Eggler 8 1872

8. Count Gedney 7 1873

John Hatfield 7 1874

Nat Hicks 7 1873

11. Doug Allison 6 1874

George Bechtel 6 1872

Bill Boyd 6 1872

14. Dave Eggler 5 1873

Nat Hicks 5 1872

16. Candy Cummings 4 1872

Dave Eggler 4 1871

John Hatfield 4 1871

Dick Higham 4 1874

Dickey Pearce 4 1871

Dickey Pearce 4 1872

Joe Start 4 1873

Joe Start 4 1874

24. Bob Ferguson 3 1871

John Hatfield 3 1873

Bobby Mathews 3 1874

Joe Start 3 1871

Joe Start 3 1875

29. Steve Bellan 2 1873

Tom Carey 2 1874

Chick Fulmer 2 1872

Nat Hicks 2 1875

Dick Higham 2 1871

Dick Higham 2 1873

Bobby Mathews 2 1875

36. Doug Allison 1 1873

Billy Barnie 1 1875

Jack Burdock 1 1874

Jimmy Hallinan 1 1875

Jim Holdsworth 1 1875

Charlie Mills 1 1871

Candy Nelson 1 1873

Tom Patterson 1 1871

Charlie Smith 1 1871

Bases on Balls
Rank Player BB PA

1. John Hatfield 23 1030

2. Candy Nelson 19 760

3. Dave Eggler 17 722

4. Bobby Mathews 15 800

5. Nat Hicks 14 672

Joe Start 14 1328

7. John McMullin 11 248

8. Rynie Wolters 10 148

9. Dick Higham 8 744

Dickey Pearce 8 377

11. Doug Allison 7 373

Count Gedney 7 498

13. George Bechtel 6 254

Bill Boyd 6 171

15. Candy Cummings 4 254

16. Bob Ferguson 3 161

17. Steve Bellan 2 34

Tom Carey 2 288

Chick Fulmer 2 168

20. Billy Barnie 1 35

Jack Burdock 1 274

Jimmy Hallinan 1 204

Jim Holdsworth 1 558

Charlie Mills 1 178

Tom Patterson 1 157

Charlie Smith 1 73

Strikeouts
Rank Player SO Year

1. Candy Cummings 14 1872

2. John Hatfield 12 1874

3. Nat Hicks 10 1875

Pat McGee 10 1875

5. Dave Eggler 9 1872

6. Count Gedney 8 1875

Rynie Wolters 8 1871

8. Bill Boyd 7 1872

9. John Hatfield 6 1872

John McMullin 6 1872

11. Doug Allison 5 1874

Jack Burdock 5 1874

Count Gedney 5 1873

Bobby Mathews 5 1875

Candy Nelson 5 1874

Jack Remsen 5 1874

17. Tom Carey 4 1874

Phonney Martin 4 1873

19. George Bechtel 3 1872

Dave Eggler 3 1871

Chick Fulmer 3 1872

Nat Hicks 3 1872

Jim Holdsworth 3 1873

Jim Holdsworth 3 1875

Bobby Mathews 3 1873

Bobby Mathews 3 1874

Al Metcalf 3 1875

28. Eddie Booth 2 1875

Dave Eggler 2 1873

Bob Ferguson 2 1871

Joe Gerhardt 2 1875

Jimmy Hallinan 2 1875

John Hatfield 2 1873

Candy Nelson 2 1873

35. Dick Higham 1 1873

Dick Higham 1 1875

Dickey Pearce 1 1871

Dickey Pearce 1 1872

Nealy Phelps 1 1875

Charlie Smith 1 1871

Strikeouts
Rank Player SO PA

1. John Hatfield 20 1030

2. Candy Cummings 14 254

Dave Eggler 14 722

4. Count Gedney 13 498

Nat Hicks 13 672

6. Bobby Mathews 11 800

7. Pat McGee 10 95

8. Rynie Wolters 8 148

9. Bill Boyd 7 171

Candy Nelson 7 760

11. Jim Holdsworth 6 558

John McMullin 6 248

13. Doug Allison 5 373

Jack Burdock 5 274

Jack Remsen 5 284

16. Tom Carey 4 288

Phonney Martin 4 140

18. George Bechtel 3 254

Chick Fulmer 3 168

Al Metcalf 3 32

21. Eddie Booth 2 281

Bob Ferguson 2 161

Joe Gerhardt 2 252

Jimmy Hallinan 2 204

Dick Higham 2 744

Dickey Pearce 2 377

27. Nealy Phelps 1 36

Charlie Smith 1 73

Stolen Bases
Rank Player SB Year

1. Dave Eggler 18 1872

2. Dave Eggler 14 1871

3. John Hatfield 12 1872

4. John Hatfield 10 1871

5. George Bechtel 9 1872

6. John McMullin 8 1872

7. Candy Nelson 6 1874

Jack Remsen 6 1874

Charlie Smith 6 1871

10. Dick Higham 5 1874

Joe Start 5 1874

12. Eddie Booth 4 1875

Bill Boyd 4 1872

Jack Burdock 4 1874

Dave Eggler 4 1873

Bob Ferguson 4 1871

John Hatfield 4 1874

Candy Nelson 4 1875

Joe Start 4 1871

20. Tom Carey 3 1874

Nat Hicks 3 1872

Dick Higham 3 1871

Jim Holdsworth 3 1875

Joe Start 3 1872

25. Count Gedney 2 1875

Jimmy Hallinan 2 1875

John Hatfield 2 1873

Nat Hicks 2 1873

Bobby Mathews 2 1874

Al Metcalf 2 1875

Charlie Mills 2 1871

Candy Nelson 2 1873

Tom Patterson 2 1871

34. Doug Allison 1 1874

Chick Fulmer 1 1872

Count Gedney 1 1873

Nat Hicks 1 1875

Dick Higham 1 1873

Jim Holdsworth 1 1873

Bobby Mathews 1 1873

Bobby Mathews 1 1875

Dickey Pearce 1 1872

Joe Start 1 1873

Joe Start 1 1875

Rynie Wolters 1 1871

Stolen Bases
Rank Player SB PA

1. Dave Eggler 36 722

2. John Hatfield 28 1030

3. Joe Start 14 1328

4. Candy Nelson 12 760

5. George Bechtel 9 254

Dick Higham 9 744

7. John McMullin 8 248

8. Nat Hicks 6 672

Jack Remsen 6 284

Charlie Smith 6 73

11. Eddie Booth 4 281

Bill Boyd 4 171

Jack Burdock 4 274

Bob Ferguson 4 161

Jim Holdsworth 4 558

Bobby Mathews 4 800

17. Tom Carey 3 288

Count Gedney 3 498

19. Jimmy Hallinan 2 204

Al Metcalf 2 32

Charlie Mills 2 178

Tom Patterson 2 157

23. Doug Allison 1 373

Chick Fulmer 1 168

Dickey Pearce 1 377

Rynie Wolters 1 148

Singles
Rank Player Singles Year

1. Jim Holdsworth 79 1875

2. Doug Allison 78 1874

Dave Eggler 78 1872

Joe Start 78 1874

5. John Hatfield 75 1872

6. Dave Eggler 73 1873

7. Joe Start 72 1872

8. Joe Start 71 1875

9. Dick Higham 69 1874

10. Tom Carey 68 1874

Nat Hicks 68 1872

Dick Higham 68 1873

13. John Hatfield 65 1873

Bobby Mathews 65 1874

15. Jim Holdsworth 63 1873

16. George Bechtel 61 1872

Candy Nelson 61 1874

18. Jack Burdock 59 1874

19. Nat Hicks 57 1875

20. Joe Start 55 1873

21. John McMullin 54 1872

22. John Hatfield 53 1874

23. Jack Remsen 51 1874

Joe Start 51 1871

25. Candy Nelson 50 1873

26. Eddie Booth 49 1875

Count Gedney 49 1873

28. Chick Fulmer 48 1872

29. Candy Nelson 47 1875

30. Jimmy Hallinan 46 1875

31. Joe Gerhardt 44 1875

32. Count Gedney 41 1875

33. Candy Cummings 40 1872

Bobby Mathews 40 1875

35. Dickey Pearce 39 1871

36. John Hatfield 38 1871

37. Dave Eggler 37 1871

Bobby Mathews 37 1873

Dickey Pearce 37 1872

40. Bill Boyd 36 1872

Rynie Wolters 36 1871

42. Bob Ferguson 31 1871

43. Dick Higham 30 1871

Phonney Martin 30 1873

45. Charlie Mills 29 1871

Tom Patterson 29 1871

47. Nat Hicks 25 1873

48. Dick Higham 20 1875

49. Charlie Smith 16 1871

50. Pat McGee 15 1875

Singles
Rank Player Singles PA

1. Joe Start 327 1328

2. John Hatfield 232 1030

3. Dave Eggler 188 722

4. Dick Higham 187 744

5. Candy Nelson 158 760

6. Nat Hicks 150 672

7. Jim Holdsworth 142 558

Bobby Mathews 142 800

9. Count Gedney 90 498

10. Doug Allison 88 373

11. Dickey Pearce 76 377

12. Tom Carey 68 288

13. George Bechtel 61 254

14. Jack Burdock 59 274

15. John McMullin 54 248

16. Jack Remsen 51 284

17. Eddie Booth 49 281

18. Chick Fulmer 48 168

19. Jimmy Hallinan 46 204

20. Joe Gerhardt 44 252

21. Candy Cummings 40 254

22. Bill Boyd 36 171

Rynie Wolters 36 148

24. Charlie Mills 33 178

25. Bob Ferguson 31 161

Tom Patterson 31 157

27. Phonney Martin 30 140

28. Charlie Smith 16 73

29. Pat McGee 15 95

30. Al Metcalf 7 32

31. Billy Barnie 5 35

Steve Bellan 5 34

33. Nealy Phelps 4 36

34. Frank Fleet 2 6

Billy Geer 2 8

36. Orator Shaffer 1 5

Adjusted OPS+
Rank Player OPS+ Year

1. Joe Start 135 1875

2. Joe Start 125 1874

3. Jim Holdsworth 113 1875

4. Doug Allison 99 1874

5. Dick Higham 88 1874

Adjusted OPS+
Rank Player OPS+ PA

Runs Created
Rank Player RC Year

1. Dave Eggler 43 1872

2. Joe Start 40 1874

3. Dave Eggler 39 1873

4. John Hatfield 38 1872

5. Joe Start 34 1875

6. Doug Allison 32 1874

John Hatfield 32 1873

Nat Hicks 32 1872

9. Jim Holdsworth 31 1873

Rynie Wolters 31 1871

11. Tom Carey 30 1874

Jim Holdsworth 30 1875

13. George Bechtel 29 1872

Dick Higham 29 1874

15. Jack Burdock 28 1874

Dick Higham 28 1873

17. Candy Nelson 25 1874

Joe Start 25 1871

19. Joe Start 24 1873

20. Count Gedney 23 1873

21. Dave Eggler 22 1871

Jimmy Hallinan 22 1875

23. John McMullin 21 1872

Candy Nelson 21 1873

Joe Start 21 1872

26. John Hatfield 20 1874

Nat Hicks 20 1875

Bobby Mathews 20 1874

Jack Remsen 20 1874

30. Chick Fulmer 18 1872

31. Bill Boyd 16 1872

32. Candy Cummings 15 1872

33. Count Gedney 14 1875

John Hatfield 14 1871

Dick Higham 14 1871

Candy Nelson 14 1875

Dickey Pearce 14 1871

38. Eddie Booth 13 1875

Joe Gerhardt 13 1875

40. Dick Higham 12 1875

Bobby Mathews 12 1873

Charlie Mills 12 1871

43. Bob Ferguson 11 1871

Nat Hicks 11 1873

Bobby Mathews 11 1875

46. Dickey Pearce 10 1872

47. Phonney Martin 7 1873

Tom Patterson 7 1871

Charlie Smith 7 1871

50. Pat McGee 3 1875

Runs Created
Rank Player RC PA

1. Joe Start 144 1328

2. John Hatfield 106 1030

3. Dave Eggler 104 722

4. Dick Higham 83 744

5. Nat Hicks 63 672

6. Jim Holdsworth 61 558

7. Candy Nelson 60 760

8. Bobby Mathews 43 800

9. Count Gedney 37 498

10. Doug Allison 34 373

11. Rynie Wolters 31 148

12. Tom Carey 30 288

13. George Bechtel 29 254

14. Jack Burdock 28 274

15. Dickey Pearce 24 377

16. Jimmy Hallinan 22 204

17. John McMullin 21 248

18. Jack Remsen 20 284

19. Chick Fulmer 18 168

20. Bill Boyd 16 171

21. Candy Cummings 15 254

22. Eddie Booth 13 281

Joe Gerhardt 13 252

Charlie Mills 13 178

25. Bob Ferguson 11 161

26. Tom Patterson 8 157

27. Phonney Martin 7 140

Charlie Smith 7 73

29. Pat McGee 3 95

30. Steve Bellan 2 34

Al Metcalf 2 32

32. Billy Barnie 1 35

Frank Fleet 1 6

Billy Geer 1 8

Nealy Phelps 1 36

Adj. Batting Runs
Rank Player BtRuns Year

1. Dave Eggler 15 1872

2. Rynie Wolters 15 1871

3. John Hatfield 11 1872

4. Joe Start 10 1875

5. Dave Eggler 9 1873

6. Joe Start 8 1874

7. Joe Start 8 1871

8. Jimmy Hallinan 6 1875

9. Dick Higham 6 1875

10. Nat Hicks 5 1872

11. Dave Eggler 4 1871

12. Dick Higham 4 1871

13. George Bechtel 4 1872

14. Jim Holdsworth 4 1875

15. Jim Holdsworth 4 1873

16. John Hatfield 3 1873

17. Candy Nelson 2 1873

18. Chick Fulmer 1 1872

19. Dick Higham 1 1873

20. John Hatfield 1 1875

21. Nealy Phelps 1 1875

22. Tom Carey 1 1874

23. Tom Patterson 0 1874

24. Bill Boyd 0 1872

25. Frank Fleet 0 1871

Adj. Batting Runs
Rank Player BtRuns PA

1. Dave Eggler 28 722

2. Rynie Wolters 15 148

3. Joe Start 14 1328

4. Jim Holdsworth 8 558

5. Dick Higham 8 744

6. Jimmy Hallinan 6 204

7. George Bechtel 4 254

8. Chick Fulmer 1 168

9. Tom Carey 1 288

10. Bill Boyd 0 171

11. Frank Fleet 0 6

Adj. Batting Wins
Rank Player BtWins Year

1. Dave Eggler 1.4 1872

2. Rynie Wolters 1.3 1871

3. Joe Start 1.2 1875

4. John Hatfield 1.1 1872

5. Joe Start 0.9 1874

6. Dave Eggler 0.9 1873

7. Jimmy Hallinan 0.7 1875

8. Joe Start 0.7 1871

9. Dick Higham 0.7 1875

10. Nat Hicks 0.5 1872

11. Jim Holdsworth 0.5 1875

12. George Bechtel 0.4 1872

13. Dave Eggler 0.4 1871

Dick Higham 0.4 1871

15. Jim Holdsworth 0.4 1873

16. John Hatfield 0.3 1873

17. Candy Nelson 0.1 1873

18. Chick Fulmer 0.1 1872

19. Dick Higham 0.1 1873

20. John Hatfield 0.1 1875

21. Tom Carey 0.1 1874

Nealy Phelps 0.1 1875

23. Tom Patterson 0.0 1874

Adj. Batting Wins
Rank Player BtWins PA

1. Dave Eggler 2.7 722

2. Joe Start 1.5 1328

3. Rynie Wolters 1.3 148

4. Jim Holdsworth 0.8 558

5. Dick Higham 0.8 744

6. Jimmy Hallinan 0.7 204

7. George Bechtel 0.4 254

8. Chick Fulmer 0.1 168

9. Tom Carey 0.1 288

Extra Base Hits
Rank Player XBH Year

1. Dave Eggler 20 1872

2. Joe Start 19 1875

3. Dick Higham 18 1874

Joe Start 18 1874

5. Dave Eggler 17 1873

John Hatfield 17 1872

7. Jack Burdock 16 1874

8. Rynie Wolters 15 1871

9. Tom Carey 14 1874

Count Gedney 14 1875

Nat Hicks 14 1872

Jack Remsen 14 1874

13. George Bechtel 13 1872

John Hatfield 13 1873

John Hatfield 13 1874

Jim Holdsworth 13 1875

17. Doug Allison 12 1874

Candy Cummings 12 1872

Jimmy Hallinan 12 1875

Jim Holdsworth 12 1873

Candy Nelson 12 1874

Joe Start 12 1873

23. Count Gedney 11 1873

24. Dave Eggler 10 1871

Joe Gerhardt 10 1875

Nat Hicks 10 1875

27. Dick Higham 9 1873

28. Bill Boyd 8 1872

Bobby Mathews 8 1875

Candy Nelson 8 1875

31. Eddie Booth 7 1875

Bob Ferguson 7 1871

Bobby Mathews 7 1874

John McMullin 7 1872

Charlie Mills 7 1871

Joe Start 7 1871

37. Bobby Mathews 6 1873

38. John Hatfield 5 1871

Dick Higham 5 1875

Candy Nelson 5 1873

Dickey Pearce 5 1871

42. Nat Hicks 4 1873

Dick Higham 4 1871

Joe Start 4 1872

45. Chick Fulmer 3 1872

Dickey Pearce 3 1872

Charlie Smith 3 1871

48. Steve Bellan 2 1873

Pat McGee 2 1875

Tom Patterson 2 1871

Extra Base Hits
Rank Player XBH PA

1. Joe Start 60 1328

2. John Hatfield 49 1030

3. Dave Eggler 47 722

4. Dick Higham 36 744

5. Nat Hicks 28 672

6. Count Gedney 25 498

Jim Holdsworth 25 558

Candy Nelson 25 760

9. Bobby Mathews 21 800

10. Jack Burdock 16 274

11. Rynie Wolters 15 148

12. Tom Carey 14 288

Jack Remsen 14 284

14. George Bechtel 13 254

15. Doug Allison 12 373

Candy Cummings 12 254

Jimmy Hallinan 12 204

18. Joe Gerhardt 10 252

19. Bill Boyd 8 171

Dickey Pearce 8 377

21. Eddie Booth 7 281

Bob Ferguson 7 161

John McMullin 7 248

Charlie Mills 7 178

25. Chick Fulmer 3 168

Charlie Smith 3 73

27. Steve Bellan 2 34

Pat McGee 2 95

Tom Patterson 2 157

30. Phonney Martin 1 140

Nealy Phelps 1 36

Times On Base
Rank Player TOB Year

1. Dave Eggler 106 1872

2. John Hatfield 101 1872

3. Joe Start 100 1874

4. Doug Allison 96 1874

5. Dave Eggler 95 1873

6. Jim Holdsworth 93 1875

Joe Start 93 1875

8. Dick Higham 91 1874

9. Nat Hicks 87 1872

10. Tom Carey 84 1874

11. Candy Nelson 82 1874

12. John Hatfield 81 1873

13. George Bechtel 80 1872

14. Dick Higham 79 1873

15. Jack Burdock 76 1874

Joe Start 76 1872

17. Jim Holdsworth 75 1873

Bobby Mathews 75 1874

19. John Hatfield 73 1874

20. John McMullin 72 1872

21. Joe Start 71 1873

22. Nat Hicks 69 1875

23. Count Gedney 67 1873

24. Jack Remsen 65 1874

25. Candy Nelson 64 1875

26. Joe Start 61 1871

Rynie Wolters 61 1871

28. Jimmy Hallinan 59 1875

29. Eddie Booth 56 1875

Candy Cummings 56 1872

Candy Nelson 56 1873

32. Count Gedney 55 1875

33. Joe Gerhardt 54 1875

34. Chick Fulmer 53 1872

Bobby Mathews 53 1873

36. Dave Eggler 51 1871

37. Bill Boyd 50 1872

Bobby Mathews 50 1875

39. Dickey Pearce 48 1871

40. John Hatfield 47 1871

41. Dickey Pearce 44 1872

42. Bob Ferguson 41 1871

43. Charlie Mills 37 1871

44. Nat Hicks 36 1873

Dick Higham 36 1871

46. Tom Patterson 32 1871

47. Phonney Martin 31 1873

48. Dick Higham 25 1875

49. Charlie Smith 20 1871

50. Pat McGee 17 1875

Times On Base
Rank Player TOB PA

1. Joe Start 401 1328

2. John Hatfield 304 1030

3. Dave Eggler 252 722

4. Dick Higham 231 744

5. Candy Nelson 202 760

6. Nat Hicks 192 672

7. Bobby Mathews 178 800

8. Jim Holdsworth 168 558

9. Count Gedney 122 498

10. Doug Allison 107 373

11. Dickey Pearce 92 377

12. Tom Carey 84 288

13. George Bechtel 80 254

14. Jack Burdock 76 274

15. John McMullin 72 248

16. Jack Remsen 65 284

17. Rynie Wolters 61 148

18. Jimmy Hallinan 59 204

19. Eddie Booth 56 281

Candy Cummings 56 254

21. Joe Gerhardt 54 252

22. Chick Fulmer 53 168

23. Bill Boyd 50 171

24. Bob Ferguson 41 161

Charlie Mills 41 178

26. Tom Patterson 34 157

27. Phonney Martin 31 140

28. Charlie Smith 20 73

29. Pat McGee 17 95

30. Steve Bellan 9 34

31. Al Metcalf 7 32

32. Billy Barnie 6 35

33. Nealy Phelps 5 36

34. Frank Fleet 2 6

Billy Geer 2 8

36. Orator Shaffer 1 5

Offensive Win %
Rank Player OWn% Year

1. Joe Start .607 1874

2. Joe Start .587 1875

3. Jim Holdsworth .518 1875

4. Doug Allison .469 1874

5. Dick Higham .386 1874

Offensive Win %
Rank Player OWn% PA

Hit By Pitch
Rank Player Hit By Pitch Year

Hit By Pitch
Rank Player Hit By Pitch PA

Sacrifice Hits
Rank Player Sacrifice Hits Year

Sacrifice Hits
Rank Player Sacrifice Hits PA

Sacrifice Flies
Rank Player Sacrifice Flies Year

Sacrifice Flies
Rank Player Sacrifice Flies PA

Intentional Bases on Balls
Rank Player Int. Bases on Balls Year

Intentional Bases on Balls
Rank Player Int. Bases on Balls PA

Double Plays Grounded Into
Rank Player GDP Year

Double Plays Grounded Into
Rank Player GDP PA

Caught Stealing
Rank Player CS Year

1. Dave Eggler 5 1872

Joe Gerhardt 5 1875

John Hatfield 5 1872

4. Bob Ferguson 4 1871

Joe Start 4 1875

6. Eddie Booth 3 1875

Dave Eggler 3 1871

Count Gedney 3 1875

John Hatfield 3 1871

Dick Higham 3 1873

Dick Higham 3 1874

Jim Holdsworth 3 1875

Joe Start 3 1872

14. Bill Boyd 2 1872

Jimmy Hallinan 2 1875

Dick Higham 2 1871

Bobby Mathews 2 1875

John McMullin 2 1872

Candy Nelson 2 1875

Joe Start 2 1871

21. George Bechtel 1 1872

Candy Cummings 1 1872

Dave Eggler 1 1873

Chick Fulmer 1 1872

Phonney Martin 1 1873

Bobby Mathews 1 1873

Tom Patterson 1 1871

Dickey Pearce 1 1872

Caught Stealing
Rank Player CS PA

1. Dave Eggler 9 722

Joe Start 9 1328

3. John Hatfield 8 1030

Dick Higham 8 744

5. Joe Gerhardt 5 252

6. Bob Ferguson 4 161

7. Eddie Booth 3 281

Count Gedney 3 498

Jim Holdsworth 3 558

Bobby Mathews 3 800

11. Bill Boyd 2 171

Jimmy Hallinan 2 204

John McMullin 2 248

Candy Nelson 2 760

15. George Bechtel 1 254

Candy Cummings 1 254

Chick Fulmer 1 168

Phonney Martin 1 140

Tom Patterson 1 157

Dickey Pearce 1 377

Power-Speed #
Rank Player PwrSpd Year

1. Jack Remsen 3.0 1874

2. Joe Start 2.9 1874

3. Jimmy Hallinan 2.4 1875

4. John Hatfield 2.0 1873

5. John Hatfield 1.8 1872

6. Dick Higham 1.7 1874

7. Bill Boyd 1.6 1872

Jack Burdock 1.6 1874

Joe Start 1.6 1871

Joe Start 1.6 1875

11. Tom Carey 1.5 1874

12. Nat Hicks 1.3 1873

13. Chick Fulmer 1.0 1872

Count Gedney 1.0 1873

Dickey Pearce 1.0 1872

Joe Start 1.0 1873

Power-Speed #
Rank Player PwrSpd PA

1. Joe Start 10.2 1328

2. John Hatfield 5.4 1030

3. Jack Remsen 3.0 284

4. Jimmy Hallinan 2.4 204

5. Dick Higham 1.8 744

6. Nat Hicks 1.7 672

7. Bill Boyd 1.6 171

Jack Burdock 1.6 274

9. Tom Carey 1.5 288

Count Gedney 1.5 498

11. Chick Fulmer 1.0 168

Dickey Pearce 1.0 377

AB per SO
Rank Player AB/SO Year

1. Jim Holdsworth 108.0 1875

2. Doug Allison 63.6 1874

AB per SO
Rank Player AB/SO PA

AB per HR
Rank Player AB/HR Year

1. Joe Start 78.5 1875

2. Joe Start 153.0 1874

3. Dick Higham 333.0 1874

AB per HR
Rank Player AB/HR PA

Outs Made
Rank Player Outs Year

1. Dick Higham 249 1874

2. Jim Holdsworth 235 1875

3. Doug Allison 228 1874

Eddie Booth 228 1875

Joe Start 228 1875

6. John Hatfield 226 1874

Bobby Mathews 226 1874

8. Candy Nelson 224 1874

9. Candy Nelson 223 1875

10. Jack Remsen 219 1874

11. Bobby Mathews 218 1875

12. Count Gedney 215 1875

13. Joe Start 210 1874

14. Joe Start 209 1872

15. Tom Carey 204 1874

16. Joe Gerhardt 203 1875

17. Nat Hicks 202 1875

18. John Hatfield 201 1872

19. Candy Cummings 199 1872

20. Jack Burdock 198 1874

21. Dave Eggler 197 1872

22. Nat Hicks 186 1872

23. Joe Start 184 1873

24. Bobby Mathews 181 1873

25. Dave Eggler 179 1873

26. John McMullin 178 1872

27. John Hatfield 177 1873

28. George Bechtel 175 1872

29. Dick Higham 171 1873

30. Dickey Pearce 167 1872

31. Count Gedney 164 1873

32. Jim Holdsworth 158 1873

33. Jimmy Hallinan 147 1875

34. John Hatfield 128 1871

35. Bob Ferguson 124 1871

36. Bill Boyd 123 1872

37. Tom Patterson 121 1871

38. Dickey Pearce 119 1871

39. Chick Fulmer 116 1872

40. Candy Nelson 113 1873

41. Phonney Martin 110 1873

Charlie Mills 110 1871

43. Joe Start 105 1871

44. Dave Eggler 103 1871

45. Nat Hicks 92 1873

46. Rynie Wolters 87 1871

47. Pat McGee 78 1875

48. Dick Higham 62 1871

49. Charlie Smith 53 1871

50. Dick Higham 39 1875

Outs Made
Rank Player Outs PA

1. Joe Start 936 1328

2. John Hatfield 734 1030

3. Bobby Mathews 625 800

4. Candy Nelson 560 760

5. Dick Higham 521 744

6. Nat Hicks 480 672

7. Dave Eggler 479 722

8. Jim Holdsworth 393 558

9. Count Gedney 379 498

10. Dickey Pearce 286 377

11. Doug Allison 266 373

12. Eddie Booth 228 281

13. Jack Remsen 219 284

14. Tom Carey 204 288

15. Joe Gerhardt 203 252

16. Candy Cummings 199 254

17. Jack Burdock 198 274

18. John McMullin 178 248

19. George Bechtel 175 254

20. Jimmy Hallinan 147 204

21. Charlie Mills 137 178

22. Bob Ferguson 124 161

Tom Patterson 124 157

24. Bill Boyd 123 171

25. Chick Fulmer 116 168

26. Phonney Martin 110 140

27. Rynie Wolters 87 148

28. Pat McGee 78 95

29. Charlie Smith 53 73

30. Nealy Phelps 31 36

31. Billy Barnie 29 35

32. Steve Bellan 25 34

Al Metcalf 25 32

34. Billy Geer 6 8

35. Frank Fleet 4 6

Orator Shaffer 4 5

Site last updated Thursday, November 5, 2009 at 07:09:43 AM

Much of the play-by-play, game results, and transaction information both shown and used to create certain data sets was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by RetroSheet.

Win Probability and Leverage Index calculations provided by Tom Tango of InsideTheBook.com, and co-author of The Book: Playing the Percentages in Baseball.

Total Zone Rating calculations provided by Sean Smith of BaseballProjection.com.

A Sports Reference Site: About Baseball Reference | Found a bug or have a suggestion?
Privacy Statement | Conditions & Terms of Service | Use of Data

Partner With: FantasyPlayers.com. Contact Fantasy Sports Ventures for advertising information.