Baseball may be over, but check out our Football, Basketball, and Hockey Sites.
Return to the Baseball-Reference.com Home Page
Quick Index: Play Index | Players | Teams | Leagues | Managers | Leaders | Awards | Postseason | Box Scores | Minors | Draft
  SportingNews.com | Stat of the Day | SR Blog | Tutorial Videos | All-Star | Travel | Bullpen Wiki | Random
You Are Here > Baseball-Reference.com > Teams > New York Mutuals > Batting Leaders

New York Mutuals Batting Leaders

Team Encyclopedia
  Starters: Positional / Pitching - Players: Batting / Pitching
  Leaders: Batting / Pitching - Managers - Attendance/Age/Parks
  Hall of Fame Register - Opening Day Starters
  Logos from SportsLogos.net. Page: none available.

NYC Walkabout - New York City Guide sponsor(s) this page.

You can sponsor a page.
Page Expires: 2008-12-19 Alert Me!
        Great for locals for visitors, locate a NYC Parking Garage, a NYC Art Gallery, and much much more!

Create Custom Leaderboards

The Baseball-Reference.com Play Index's Batting Season Finder lets you create your own custom leaderboards by team, age, position, years, or any other common criteria. View Sample Leaderboards created with the batting season finder.

See Also: Top Ten / Top 50

Batting Leaders

Click on the Player for career stats and accomplishments.
Click on the Year for the team's season summary.
2000 PA required for career rate statistics.
Single-Season LeadersCareer Leaders

Batting Average
RankPlayer  BA  Year

Batting Average
RankPlayer  BA  PA

On-base %
RankPlayer  OBP  Year

On-base %
RankPlayer  OBP  PA

Slugging %
RankPlayer  SLG  Year

Slugging %
RankPlayer  SLG  PA

OPS
RankPlayer  OPS  Year

OPS
RankPlayer  OPS  PA

Games
RankPlayer  G  Year
1.Jim Holdsworth711875
2.Bobby Mathews701875
 Candy Nelson701875
4.Joe Start691875
5.Eddie Booth681875
 Count Gedney681875
7.Doug Allison651874
 Dick Higham651874
 Bobby Mathews651874
 Candy Nelson651874
11.Tom Carey641874
 Jack Remsen641874
13.John Hatfield631874
 Joe Start631874
15.Nat Hicks621875
16.Jack Burdock611874
17.Joe Gerhardt581875
18.Dave Eggler561872
 John Hatfield561872
 Nat Hicks561872
21.Candy Cummings551872
 Joe Start551872
23.John McMullin541872
24.Dave Eggler531873
 Count Gedney531873
 Jim Holdsworth531873
 Joe Start531873
28.John Hatfield521873
 Bobby Mathews521873
30.George Bechtel511872
31.Dick Higham491873
32.Jimmy Hallinan441875
 Dickey Pearce441872
34.Chick Fulmer361872
 Candy Nelson361873
36.Bill Boyd351872
37.Dave Eggler331871
 Bob Ferguson331871
 John Hatfield331871
 Dickey Pearce331871
 Joe Start331871
42.Charlie Mills321871
 Tom Patterson321871
 Rynie Wolters321871
45.Phonney Martin311873
46.Nat Hicks281873
47.Pat McGee251875
48.Dick Higham211871
49.Dick Higham151875
50.Charlie Smith141871

Games
RankPlayer  G  PA
1.Joe Start2731328
2.John Hatfield2051030
3.Bobby Mathews187800
4.Candy Nelson171760
5.Dick Higham150744
6.Nat Hicks146672
7.Dave Eggler142722
8.Jim Holdsworth124558
9.Count Gedney121498
10.Dickey Pearce77377
11.Doug Allison76373
12.Eddie Booth68281
13.Tom Carey64288
 Jack Remsen64284
15.Jack Burdock61274
16.Joe Gerhardt58252
17.Candy Cummings55254
18.John McMullin54248
19.George Bechtel51254
20.Jimmy Hallinan44204
21.Charlie Mills38178
22.Chick Fulmer36168
23.Bill Boyd35171
24.Bob Ferguson33161
 Tom Patterson33157
26.Rynie Wolters32148
27.Phonney Martin31140
28.Pat McGee2595
29.Charlie Smith1473
30.Billy Barnie935
 Nealy Phelps936
32.Steve Bellan834
 Al Metcalf832
34.Billy Geer28
35.Frank Fleet16
 Orator Shaffer15

At Bats
RankPlayer  AB  Year
1.Dick Higham3331874
2.Jim Holdsworth3241875
3.Doug Allison3181874
4.Joe Start3141875
5.Joe Start3061874
6.Bobby Mathews2981874
7.Candy Nelson2971874
8.John Hatfield2921874
9.Dave Eggler2901872
10.John Hatfield2881872
11.Tom Carey2861874
12.Jack Remsen2841874
13.Joe Start2821872
14.Eddie Booth2811875
15.Candy Nelson2761875
16.Jack Burdock2731874
17.Nat Hicks2691875
18.Dave Eggler2681873
 Nat Hicks2681872
20.Count Gedney2671875
21.Bobby Mathews2641875
22.John Hatfield2551873
23.Joe Gerhardt2521875
24.Joe Start2511873
25.Candy Cummings2501872
26.George Bechtel2481872
27.Dick Higham2451873
28.John McMullin2371872
29.Jim Holdsworth2331873
30.Count Gedney2241873
31.Bobby Mathews2231873
32.Dickey Pearce2061872
33.Jimmy Hallinan2031875
34.John Hatfield1681871
 Candy Nelson1681873
36.Chick Fulmer1661872
37.Bill Boyd1651872
38.Dickey Pearce1631871
39.Joe Start1611871
40.Bob Ferguson1581871
41.Tom Patterson1511871
42.Dave Eggler1471871
43.Charlie Mills1461871
44.Phonney Martin1401873
45.Rynie Wolters1381871
46.Nat Hicks1211873
47.Pat McGee951875
48.Dick Higham941871
49.Charlie Smith721871
50.Dick Higham641875

At Bats
RankPlayer  AB  PA
1.Joe Start13141328
2.John Hatfield10071030
3.Bobby Mathews785800
4.Candy Nelson741760
5.Dick Higham736744
6.Dave Eggler705722
7.Nat Hicks658672
8.Jim Holdsworth557558
9.Count Gedney491498
10.Dickey Pearce369377
11.Doug Allison366373
12.Tom Carey286288
13.Jack Remsen284284
14.Eddie Booth281281
15.Jack Burdock273274
16.Joe Gerhardt252252
17.Candy Cummings250254
18.George Bechtel248254
19.John McMullin237248
20.Jimmy Hallinan203204
21.Charlie Mills177178
22.Chick Fulmer166168
23.Bill Boyd165171
24.Bob Ferguson158161
25.Tom Patterson156157
26.Phonney Martin140140
27.Rynie Wolters138148
28.Pat McGee9595
29.Charlie Smith7273
30.Nealy Phelps3636
31.Billy Barnie3435
32.Steve Bellan3234
 Al Metcalf3232
34.Billy Geer88
35.Frank Fleet66
36.Orator Shaffer55

Plate Appearances (approx.)
RankPlayer  PA  Year
1.Dick Higham3371874
2.Jim Holdsworth3251875
3.Doug Allison3241874
4.Joe Start3171875
5.Joe Start3101874
6.Candy Nelson3061874
7.Bobby Mathews3011874
8.John Hatfield2991874
9.Dave Eggler2981872
10.John Hatfield2971872
11.Tom Carey2881874
12.Candy Nelson2851875
13.Jack Remsen2841874
14.Joe Start2821872
15.Eddie Booth2811875
16.Jack Burdock2741874
17.Dave Eggler2731873
 Nat Hicks2731872
19.Nat Hicks2711875
20.Count Gedney2671875
21.Bobby Mathews2661875
22.John Hatfield2581873
23.Joe Start2551873
24.George Bechtel2541872
 Candy Cummings2541872
26.Joe Gerhardt2521875
27.John McMullin2481872
28.Dick Higham2471873
29.Jim Holdsworth2331873
 Bobby Mathews2331873
31.Count Gedney2311873
32.Dickey Pearce2101872
33.Jimmy Hallinan2041875
34.John Hatfield1721871
35.Bill Boyd1711872
36.Candy Nelson1691873
37.Chick Fulmer1681872
38.Dickey Pearce1671871
39.Joe Start1641871
40.Bob Ferguson1611871
41.Tom Patterson1521871
42.Dave Eggler1511871
43.Rynie Wolters1481871
44.Charlie Mills1471871
45.Phonney Martin1401873
46.Nat Hicks1281873
47.Dick Higham961871
48.Pat McGee951875
49.Charlie Smith731871
50.Dick Higham641875

Plate Appearances (approx.)
RankPlayer  PA  PA
1.Joe Start13281328
2.John Hatfield10301030
3.Bobby Mathews800800
4.Candy Nelson760760
5.Dick Higham744744
6.Dave Eggler722722
7.Nat Hicks672672
8.Jim Holdsworth558558
9.Count Gedney498498
10.Dickey Pearce377377
11.Doug Allison373373
12.Tom Carey288288
13.Jack Remsen284284
14.Eddie Booth281281
15.Jack Burdock274274
16.George Bechtel254254
 Candy Cummings254254
18.Joe Gerhardt252252
19.John McMullin248248
20.Jimmy Hallinan204204
21.Charlie Mills178178
22.Bill Boyd171171
23.Chick Fulmer168168
24.Bob Ferguson161161
25.Tom Patterson157157
26.Rynie Wolters148148
27.Phonney Martin140140
28.Pat McGee9595
29.Charlie Smith7373
30.Nealy Phelps3636
31.Billy Barnie3535
32.Steve Bellan3434
33.Al Metcalf3232
34.Billy Geer88
35.Frank Fleet66
36.Orator Shaffer55

Runs
RankPlayer  R  Year
1.Dave Eggler941872
2.Dave Eggler821873
3.John Hatfield761872
4.Doug Allison681874
5.Joe Start671874
6.Joe Start621872
7.George Bechtel601872
8.Dick Higham581874
 Joe Start581875
10.Dick Higham571873
11.Tom Carey561874
12.Nat Hicks551872
 Candy Nelson551874
14.John Hatfield541873
15.Jack Remsen521874
16.John McMullin481872
17.John Hatfield471874
18.Jim Holdsworth461873
 Bobby Mathews461874
20.Jack Burdock451874
 Jim Holdsworth451875
22.Joe Start421873
23.Count Gedney411873
 John Hatfield411871
25.Bobby Mathews401873
26.Dave Eggler371871
27.Candy Cummings361872
28.Joe Start351871
29.Eddie Booth331875
 Rynie Wolters331871
31.Nat Hicks321875
 Dickey Pearce321872
33.Tom Patterson311871
 Dickey Pearce311871
35.Bob Ferguson301871
 Count Gedney301875
37.Joe Gerhardt291875
 Jimmy Hallinan291875
39.Chick Fulmer281872
 Candy Nelson281873
 Candy Nelson281875
42.Charlie Mills271871
43.Bill Boyd261872
44.Bobby Mathews231875
45.Dick Higham211871
46.Charlie Smith151871
47.Nat Hicks121873
 Dick Higham121875
 Phonney Martin121873
50.Doug Allison61873
 Charlie Mills61872

Runs
RankPlayer  R  PA
1.Joe Start2641328
2.John Hatfield2191030
3.Dave Eggler213722
4.Dick Higham148744
5.Candy Nelson111760
6.Bobby Mathews109800
7.Nat Hicks99672
8.Jim Holdsworth91558
9.Doug Allison74373
10.Count Gedney71498
11.Dickey Pearce63377
12.George Bechtel60254
13.Tom Carey56288
14.Jack Remsen52284
15.John McMullin48248
16.Jack Burdock45274
17.Candy Cummings36254
18.Eddie Booth33281
 Charlie Mills33178
 Rynie Wolters33148
21.Tom Patterson32157
22.Bob Ferguson30161
23.Joe Gerhardt29252
 Jimmy Hallinan29204
25.Chick Fulmer28168
26.Bill Boyd26171
27.Charlie Smith1573
28.Phonney Martin12140
29.Nealy Phelps636
30.Steve Bellan434
 Pat McGee495
32.Al Metcalf232
33.Billy Barnie135
 Frank Fleet16
 Orator Shaffer15

Hits
RankPlayer  H  Year
1.Dave Eggler981872
2.Joe Start961874
3.John Hatfield921872
 Jim Holdsworth921875
5.Doug Allison901874
 Dave Eggler901873
 Joe Start901875
8.Dick Higham871874
9.Tom Carey821874
 Nat Hicks821872
11.John Hatfield781873
12.Dick Higham771873
13.Joe Start761872
14.Jack Burdock751874
 Jim Holdsworth751873
16.George Bechtel741872
17.Candy Nelson731874
18.Bobby Mathews721874
19.Nat Hicks671875
 Joe Start671873
21.John Hatfield661874
22.Jack Remsen651874
23.John McMullin611872
24.Count Gedney601873
25.Jimmy Hallinan581875
 Joe Start581871
27.Eddie Booth561875
28.Count Gedney551875
 Candy Nelson551873
 Candy Nelson551875
31.Joe Gerhardt541875
32.Candy Cummings521872
33.Chick Fulmer511872
 Rynie Wolters511871
35.Bobby Mathews481875
36.Dave Eggler471871
37.Bill Boyd441872
 Dickey Pearce441871
39.John Hatfield431871
 Bobby Mathews431873
41.Dickey Pearce401872
42.Bob Ferguson381871
43.Charlie Mills361871
44.Dick Higham341871
45.Phonney Martin311873
 Tom Patterson311871
47.Nat Hicks291873
48.Dick Higham251875
49.Charlie Smith191871
50.Pat McGee171875

Hits
RankPlayer  H  PA
1.Joe Start3871328
2.John Hatfield2811030
3.Dave Eggler235722
4.Dick Higham223744
5.Candy Nelson183760
6.Nat Hicks178672
7.Jim Holdsworth167558
8.Bobby Mathews163800
9.Count Gedney115498
10.Doug Allison100373
11.Dickey Pearce84377
12.Tom Carey82288
13.Jack Burdock75274
14.George Bechtel74254
15.Jack Remsen65284
16.John McMullin61248
17.Jimmy Hallinan58204
18.Eddie Booth56281
19.Joe Gerhardt54252
20.Candy Cummings52254
21.Chick Fulmer51168
 Rynie Wolters51148
23.Bill Boyd44171
24.Charlie Mills40178
25.Bob Ferguson38161
26.Tom Patterson33157
27.Phonney Martin31140
28.Charlie Smith1973
29.Pat McGee1795
30.Steve Bellan734
 Al Metcalf732
32.Billy Barnie535
 Nealy Phelps536
34.Frank Fleet26
 Billy Geer28
36.Orator Shaffer15

Total Bases
RankPlayer  TB  Year
1.Joe Start1221875
2.Joe Start1211874
3.Dave Eggler1181872
4.John Hatfield1121872
5.Dave Eggler1111873
6.Dick Higham1101874
7.Doug Allison1071874
8.Jim Holdsworth1061875
9.Tom Carey1011874
 John Hatfield1011873
11.Nat Hicks981872
12.Jack Burdock971874
13.Jim Holdsworth951873
14.Dick Higham901873
 Candy Nelson901874
16.George Bechtel891872
17.Jack Remsen861874
18.Joe Start841873
19.John Hatfield801874
 Bobby Mathews801874
 Joe Start801872
22.Jimmy Hallinan791875
23.Count Gedney781873
24.Nat Hicks771875
25.Rynie Wolters751871
26.Count Gedney711875
27.John McMullin691872
28.Joe Start681871
29.Eddie Booth671875
 Candy Cummings671872
 Joe Gerhardt671875
32.Candy Nelson641875
33.Candy Nelson611873
34.Dave Eggler601871
35.Bobby Mathews581875
36.Chick Fulmer571872
37.Bill Boyd551872
38.Bobby Mathews521873
39.John Hatfield501871
40.Dickey Pearce491871
41.Bob Ferguson461871
 Charlie Mills461871
 Dickey Pearce461872
44.Dick Higham391871
45.Nat Hicks371873
46.Tom Patterson331871
47.Phonney Martin321873
48.Dick Higham301875
49.Charlie Smith231871
50.Pat McGee191875

Total Bases
RankPlayer  TB  PA
1.Joe Start4751328
2.John Hatfield3461030
3.Dave Eggler289722
4.Dick Higham269744
5.Candy Nelson215760
6.Nat Hicks212672
7.Jim Holdsworth201558
8.Bobby Mathews190800
9.Count Gedney149498
10.Doug Allison117373
11.Tom Carey101288
12.Jack Burdock97274
13.Dickey Pearce95377
14.George Bechtel89254
15.Jack Remsen86284
16.Jimmy Hallinan79204
17.Rynie Wolters75148
18.John McMullin69248
19.Eddie Booth67281
 Candy Cummings67254
 Joe Gerhardt67252
22.Chick Fulmer57168
23.Bill Boyd55171
24.Charlie Mills50178
25.Bob Ferguson46161
26.Tom Patterson35157
27.Phonney Martin32140
28.Charlie Smith2373
29.Pat McGee1995
30.Steve Bellan934
31.Al Metcalf732
32.Nealy Phelps636
33.Billy Barnie535
34.Frank Fleet26
 Billy Geer28
36.Orator Shaffer15

Doubles
RankPlayer  2B  Year
1.Dave Eggler201872
2.John Hatfield151872
3.Dick Higham141874
4.Dave Eggler131873
 Joe Start131874
6.Count Gedney121875
 John Hatfield121874
 Nat Hicks121872
 Jim Holdsworth121875
10.George Bechtel111872
 Jack Burdock111874
12.Tom Carey101874
 Nat Hicks101875
 Joe Start101875
15.Candy Cummings91872
 Jack Remsen91874
17.Joe Start81873
18.Doug Allison71874
 Dave Eggler71871
 Joe Gerhardt71875
 Candy Nelson71874
 Candy Nelson71875
23.Bill Boyd61872
 Bob Ferguson61871
 Jimmy Hallinan61875
 Bobby Mathews61874
 Bobby Mathews61875
 John McMullin61872
 Rynie Wolters61871
30.Count Gedney51873
 John Hatfield51873
 Dick Higham51873
 Dick Higham51875
 Dickey Pearce51871
 Joe Start51871
36.Jim Holdsworth41873
 Charlie Mills41871
 Candy Nelson41873
 Joe Start41872
40.Eddie Booth31875
 John Hatfield31871
 Dick Higham31871
 Bobby Mathews31873
44.Steve Bellan21873
 Pat McGee21875
 Tom Patterson21871
 Charlie Smith21871
48.Chick Fulmer11872
 John Hatfield11875
 Nat Hicks11873
 Phonney Martin11873
 Dickey Pearce11872
 Nealy Phelps11875

Doubles
RankPlayer  2B  PA
1.Dave Eggler40722
 Joe Start401328
3.John Hatfield361030
4.Dick Higham27744
5.Nat Hicks23672
6.Candy Nelson18760
7.Count Gedney17498
8.Jim Holdsworth16558
9.Bobby Mathews15800
10.George Bechtel11254
 Jack Burdock11274
12.Tom Carey10288
13.Candy Cummings9254
 Jack Remsen9284
15.Doug Allison7373
 Joe Gerhardt7252
17.Bill Boyd6171
 Bob Ferguson6161
 Jimmy Hallinan6204
 John McMullin6248
 Dickey Pearce6377
 Rynie Wolters6148
23.Charlie Mills4178
24.Eddie Booth3281
25.Steve Bellan234
 Pat McGee295
 Tom Patterson2157
 Charlie Smith273
29.Chick Fulmer1168
 Phonney Martin1140
 Nealy Phelps136

Triples
RankPlayer  3B  Year
1.Rynie Wolters91871
2.Jim Holdsworth81873
3.John Hatfield61873
4.Doug Allison51874
 Count Gedney51873
 Candy Nelson51874
 Joe Start51875
8.Eddie Booth41875
 Jack Burdock41874
 Dave Eggler41873
 Dick Higham41873
12.Tom Carey31874
 Candy Cummings31872
 Dave Eggler31871
 Joe Gerhardt31875
 Jimmy Hallinan31875
 Dick Higham31874
 Bobby Mathews31873
 Charlie Mills31871
 Jack Remsen31874
 Joe Start31873
 Joe Start31874
23.George Bechtel21872
 Count Gedney21875
 John Hatfield21871
 Nat Hicks21872
 Nat Hicks21873
 Bobby Mathews21875
29.Bill Boyd11872
 Bob Ferguson11871
 Chick Fulmer11872
 John Hatfield11872
 John Hatfield11874
 Dick Higham11871
 Jim Holdsworth11875
 Bobby Mathews11874
 John McMullin11872
 Candy Nelson11873
 Candy Nelson11875
 Dickey Pearce11872
 Charlie Smith11871
 Joe Start11871

Triples
RankPlayer  3B  PA
1.Joe Start121328
2.John Hatfield101030
3.Jim Holdsworth9558
 Rynie Wolters9148
5.Dick Higham8744
6.Dave Eggler7722
 Count Gedney7498
 Candy Nelson7760
9.Bobby Mathews6800
10.Doug Allison5373
11.Eddie Booth4281
 Jack Burdock4274
 Nat Hicks4672
14.Tom Carey3288
 Candy Cummings3254
 Joe Gerhardt3252
 Jimmy Hallinan3204
 Charlie Mills3178
 Jack Remsen3284
20.George Bechtel2254
21.Bill Boyd1171
 Bob Ferguson1161
 Chick Fulmer1168
 John McMullin1248
 Dickey Pearce1377
 Charlie Smith173

Home Runs
RankPlayer  HR  Year
1.Joe Start41875
2.