Mobile Site You Are Here > Home > Teams > Franchise Encyclopedia > Batting Leaders

New York Mutuals Top 50 Batting Leaders

Team Encyclopedia
  Starters: Positional / Pitching - Players: Batting / Pitching - Teams: Batting / Pitching
  Leaders: Batting / Pitching - All-Stars: Batting / Pitching - Managers - Attendance/Parks
  Hall of Fame Register - Opening Day Starters - Team Trade Histories
  Logos from SportsLogos.net. Page: none available.

New York Mutuals Top 50 Batting Leaders

See Also: Top 10 / Top 50
Click on the Player for player statistics, biography, and information.
Click on the Year for team roster, statistics, and leaders.
1500 plate appearances required for career rate statistics.

Single-Season Leaders

Career Leaders

WAR Position Players†

Rank	Player	WAR Position Players	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	3.2	1872
2.	John Hatfield	2.9	1872
3.	Joe Start	2.4	1875
4.	Joe Start	2.3	1874
5.	Nat Hicks	2.2	1872
6.	Dave Eggler	2.0	1873
7.	George Bechtel	1.7	1872
8.	John McMullin	1.5	1872
9.	Jack Burdock	1.3	1874
	Count Gedney	1.3	1873
	Rynie Wolters	1.3	1871
12.	Nat Hicks	1.2	1875
	Jim Holdsworth	1.2	1873
	Jim Holdsworth	1.2	1875
15.	Tom Carey	1.1	1874
	Dave Eggler	1.1	1871
	Chick Fulmer	1.1	1872
	Jimmy Hallinan	1.1	1875
	Joe Start	1.1	1871
20.	John Hatfield	1.0	1873
21.	Candy Nelson	0.9	1875
	Joe Start	0.9	1872
	Joe Start	0.9	1873
24.	Candy Nelson	0.8	1873
25.	Doug Allison	0.7	1874
	Dickey Pearce	0.7	1872
27.	Bill Boyd	0.6	1872
	Count Gedney	0.6	1875
	Dick Higham	0.6	1871
	Dick Higham	0.6	1873
	Dickey Pearce	0.6	1871
32.	John Hatfield	0.5	1874
	Dick Higham	0.5	1875
	Candy Nelson	0.5	1874
35.	John Hatfield	0.4	1871
	Dick Higham	0.4	1874
37.	Bob Ferguson	0.3	1871
	Joe Gerhardt	0.3	1875
	Charlie Mills	0.3	1871
40.	Charlie Smith	0.2	1871
41.	John Hatfield	0.1	1875
	Nat Hicks	0.1	1873
	Bobby Mathews	0.1	1874
	Nealy Phelps	0.1	1875
	Jack Remsen	0.1	1874

WAR Position Players

Rank	Player	WAR Position Players	PA
1.	Joe Start	7.6	1324
2.	Dave Eggler	6.3	721
3.	John Hatfield	4.9	1030
4.	Nat Hicks	3.5	672
5.	Jim Holdsworth	2.4	557
6.	Candy Nelson	2.2	760
7.	Dick Higham	2.1	743
8.	Count Gedney	1.9	498
9.	George Bechtel	1.7	254
10.	John McMullin	1.5	247
11.	Jack Burdock	1.3	274
	Dickey Pearce	1.3	377
	Rynie Wolters	1.3	148
14.	Tom Carey	1.1	289
	Chick Fulmer	1.1	168
	Jimmy Hallinan	1.1	204
17.	Doug Allison	0.7	373
18.	Bill Boyd	0.6	176
19.	Bob Ferguson	0.3	161
	Joe Gerhardt	0.3	252
21.	Charlie Smith	0.2	73
22.	Charlie Mills	0.1	178
	Jack Remsen	0.1	284

Offensive WAR†

Rank	Player	Offensive WAR	Year
1.	John Hatfield	2.5	1872
2.	Dave Eggler	2.4	1872
	Joe Start	2.4	1875
4.	Nat Hicks	2.2	1872
5.	Joe Start	2.0	1874
6.	Jim Holdsworth	1.9	1875
7.	Jimmy Hallinan	1.8	1875
8.	George Bechtel	1.7	1872
	Dave Eggler	1.7	1873
10.	Jim Holdsworth	1.5	1873
11.	Tom Carey	1.4	1874
	John Hatfield	1.4	1873
13.	Nat Hicks	1.3	1875
	Rynie Wolters	1.3	1871
15.	Doug Allison	1.2	1874
	Joe Start	1.2	1871
17.	Chick Fulmer	1.1	1872
	Dick Higham	1.1	1873
19.	Jack Burdock	1.0	1874
	Joe Start	1.0	1872
21.	Dick Higham	0.9	1874
	Dick Higham	0.9	1875
	John McMullin	0.9	1872
	Candy Nelson	0.9	1873
25.	Bill Boyd	0.8	1872
	Dave Eggler	0.8	1871
	Candy Nelson	0.8	1874
28.	Dick Higham	0.7	1871
	Candy Nelson	0.7	1875
	Joe Start	0.7	1873
31.	Joe Gerhardt	0.5	1875
	Dickey Pearce	0.5	1871
33.	Count Gedney	0.4	1873
	Nat Hicks	0.4	1873
35.	Charlie Mills	0.3	1871
36.	John Hatfield	0.2	1871
	Dickey Pearce	0.2	1872
	Charlie Smith	0.2	1871
39.	Steve Bellan	0.1	1873
	John Hatfield	0.1	1875
	Bobby Mathews	0.1	1874
	Nealy Phelps	0.1	1875

Offensive WAR

Rank	Player	Offensive WAR	PA
1.	Joe Start	7.3	1324
2.	Dave Eggler	4.9	721
3.	John Hatfield	4.1	1030
4.	Nat Hicks	3.9	672
5.	Dick Higham	3.6	743
6.	Jim Holdsworth	3.4	557
7.	Candy Nelson	2.4	760
8.	Jimmy Hallinan	1.8	204
9.	George Bechtel	1.7	254
10.	Tom Carey	1.4	289
11.	Rynie Wolters	1.3	148
12.	Doug Allison	1.2	373
13.	Chick Fulmer	1.1	168
14.	Jack Burdock	1.0	274
15.	John McMullin	0.9	247
16.	Bill Boyd	0.8	176
17.	Dickey Pearce	0.7	377
18.	Joe Gerhardt	0.5	252
19.	Count Gedney	0.3	498
20.	Charlie Mills	0.2	178
	Charlie Smith	0.2	73
22.	Steve Bellan	0.1	34

Defensive WAR†

Rank	Player	Defensive WAR	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	0.7	1872
	Count Gedney	0.7	1873
	Dickey Pearce	0.7	1872
4.	John Hatfield	0.5	1872
5.	Jack Burdock	0.4	1874
	Bob Ferguson	0.4	1871
	John Hatfield	0.4	1874
	John McMullin	0.4	1872
	Candy Nelson	0.4	1875
10.	Count Gedney	0.3	1875
	Joe Start	0.3	1874
12.	Dave Eggler	0.2	1871
	Dave Eggler	0.2	1873
	John Hatfield	0.2	1871
	Nat Hicks	0.2	1872
	Nat Hicks	0.2	1875
	Dickey Pearce	0.2	1871
	Joe Start	0.2	1873
19.	Doug Allison	0.1	1873
	Joe Gerhardt	0.1	1875
	Charlie Mills	0.1	1871
	Joe Start	0.1	1875

Defensive WAR

Rank	Player	Defensive WAR	PA
1.	Dave Eggler	1.1	721
2.	Count Gedney	1.0	498
	Dickey Pearce	1.0	377
4.	John Hatfield	0.8	1030
5.	Joe Start	0.5	1324
6.	Jack Burdock	0.4	274
	Bob Ferguson	0.4	161
	John McMullin	0.4	247
9.	Joe Gerhardt	0.1	252
	Nat Hicks	0.1	672
	Charlie Mills	0.1	178
	Candy Nelson	0.1	760

Batting Average

Rank	Player	Batting Average	Year
1.	Joe Start	.314	1874
2.	Joe Start	.287	1875
3.	Jim Holdsworth	.284	1875
4.	Doug Allison	.283	1874
5.	Dick Higham	.261	1874

Batting Average

Rank	Player	Batting Average	PA

On-Base%

Rank	Player	On-Base%	Year
1.	Joe Start	.323	1874
2.	Doug Allison	.296	1874
3.	Joe Start	.293	1875
4.	Jim Holdsworth	.286	1875
5.	Dick Higham	.270	1874

On-Base%

Rank	Player	On-Base%	PA

Slugging %

Rank	Player	Slugging %	Year
1.	Joe Start	.395	1874
2.	Joe Start	.389	1875
3.	Doug Allison	.336	1874
4.	Dick Higham	.330	1874
5.	Jim Holdsworth	.327	1875

Slugging %

Rank	Player	Slugging %	PA

On-Base Plus Slugging

Rank	Player	On-Base Plus Slugging	Year
1.	Joe Start	.718	1874
2.	Joe Start	.682	1875
3.	Doug Allison	.633	1874
4.	Jim Holdsworth	.613	1875
5.	Dick Higham	.600	1874

On-Base Plus Slugging

Rank	Player	On-Base Plus Slugging	PA

Games Played

Rank	Player	Games Played	Year
1.	Jim Holdsworth	71	1875
2.	Bobby Mathews	70	1875
	Candy Nelson	70	1875
4.	Joe Start	69	1875
5.	Eddie Booth	68	1875
	Count Gedney	68	1875
7.	Doug Allison	65	1874
	Dick Higham	65	1874
	Bobby Mathews	65	1874
	Candy Nelson	65	1874
11.	Tom Carey	64	1874
	Jack Remsen	64	1874
13.	John Hatfield	63	1874
	Joe Start	63	1874
15.	Nat Hicks	62	1875
16.	Jack Burdock	61	1874
17.	Joe Gerhardt	58	1875
18.	Dave Eggler	56	1872
	John Hatfield	56	1872
	Nat Hicks	56	1872
21.	Candy Cummings	55	1872
22.	John McMullin	54	1872
	Joe Start	54	1872
24.	Dave Eggler	53	1873
	Count Gedney	53	1873
	Jim Holdsworth	53	1873
	Joe Start	53	1873
28.	John Hatfield	52	1873
	Bobby Mathews	52	1873
30.	George Bechtel	51	1872
31.	Dick Higham	49	1873
32.	Jimmy Hallinan	44	1875
	Dickey Pearce	44	1872
34.	Bill Boyd	36	1872
	Chick Fulmer	36	1872
	Candy Nelson	36	1873
37.	Dave Eggler	33	1871
	Bob Ferguson	33	1871
	John Hatfield	33	1871
	Dickey Pearce	33	1871
	Joe Start	33	1871
42.	Charlie Mills	32	1871
	Tom Patterson	32	1871
	Rynie Wolters	32	1871
45.	Phonney Martin	31	1873
46.	Nat Hicks	28	1873
47.	Pat McGee	25	1875
48.	Dick Higham	21	1871
49.	Dick Higham	15	1875
50.	Charlie Smith	14	1871

Games Played

Rank	Player	Games Played	PA
1.	Joe Start	272	1324
2.	John Hatfield	205	1030
3.	Bobby Mathews	187	800
4.	Candy Nelson	171	760
5.	Dick Higham	150	743
6.	Nat Hicks	146	672
7.	Dave Eggler	142	721
8.	Jim Holdsworth	124	557
9.	Count Gedney	121	498
10.	Dickey Pearce	77	377
11.	Doug Allison	76	373
12.	Eddie Booth	68	281
13.	Tom Carey	64	289
	Jack Remsen	64	284
15.	Jack Burdock	61	274
16.	Joe Gerhardt	58	252
17.	Candy Cummings	55	253
18.	John McMullin	54	247
19.	George Bechtel	51	254
20.	Jimmy Hallinan	44	204
21.	Charlie Mills	38	178
22.	Bill Boyd	36	176
	Chick Fulmer	36	168
24.	Bob Ferguson	33	161
	Tom Patterson	33	157
26.	Rynie Wolters	32	148
27.	Phonney Martin	31	140
28.	Pat McGee	25	95
29.	Charlie Smith	14	73
30.	Billy Barnie	9	35
	Nealy Phelps	9	36
32.	Steve Bellan	8	34
	Alfred Metcalfe	8	32
34.	Billy Geer	2	8
35.	Frank Fleet	1	6
	Orator Shafer	1	5

At Bats

Rank	Player	At Bats	Year
1.	Dick Higham	333	1874
2.	Jim Holdsworth	324	1875
3.	Doug Allison	318	1874
4.	Joe Start	314	1875
5.	Joe Start	306	1874
6.	Bobby Mathews	298	1874
7.	Candy Nelson	297	1874
8.	John Hatfield	292	1874
9.	Dave Eggler	290	1872
10.	John Hatfield	288	1872
11.	Tom Carey	287	1874
12.	Jack Remsen	284	1874
13.	Eddie Booth	281	1875
14.	Joe Start	277	1872
15.	Candy Nelson	276	1875
16.	Jack Burdock	273	1874
17.	Nat Hicks	269	1875
18.	Count Gedney	267	1875
	Nat Hicks	267	1872
20.	Dave Eggler	266	1873
21.	Bobby Mathews	264	1875
22.	John Hatfield	255	1873
23.	Joe Gerhardt	252	1875
	Joe Start	252	1873
25.	Candy Cummings	249	1872
26.	George Bechtel	247	1872
27.	Dick Higham	244	1873
28.	John McMullin	236	1872
29.	Jim Holdsworth	232	1873
30.	Count Gedney	225	1873
31.	Bobby Mathews	223	1873
32.	Dickey Pearce	206	1872
33.	Jimmy Hallinan	203	1875
34.	Bill Boyd	170	1872
35.	John Hatfield	168	1871
	Candy Nelson	168	1873
37.	Chick Fulmer	165	1872
38.	Dickey Pearce	163	1871
39.	Joe Start	161	1871
40.	Bob Ferguson	158	1871
41.	Tom Patterson	151	1871
42.	Dave Eggler	147	1871
43.	Charlie Mills	146	1871
44.	Phonney Martin	140	1873
45.	Rynie Wolters	138	1871
46.	Nat Hicks	120	1873
47.	Pat McGee	95	1875
48.	Dick Higham	94	1871
49.	Charlie Smith	72	1871
50.	Dick Higham	64	1875

At Bats

Rank	Player	At Bats	PA
1.	Joe Start	1310	1324
2.	John Hatfield	1007	1030
3.	Bobby Mathews	785	800
4.	Candy Nelson	741	760
5.	Dick Higham	735	743
6.	Dave Eggler	703	721
7.	Nat Hicks	656	672
8.	Jim Holdsworth	556	557
9.	Count Gedney	492	498
10.	Dickey Pearce	369	377
11.	Doug Allison	366	373
12.	Tom Carey	287	289
13.	Jack Remsen	284	284
14.	Eddie Booth	281	281
15.	Jack Burdock	273	274
16.	Joe Gerhardt	252	252
17.	Candy Cummings	249	253
18.	George Bechtel	247	254
19.	John McMullin	236	247
20.	Jimmy Hallinan	203	204
21.	Charlie Mills	177	178
22.	Bill Boyd	170	176
23.	Chick Fulmer	165	168
24.	Bob Ferguson	158	161
25.	Tom Patterson	156	157
26.	Phonney Martin	140	140
27.	Rynie Wolters	138	148
28.	Pat McGee	95	95
29.	Charlie Smith	72	73
30.	Nealy Phelps	36	36
31.	Billy Barnie	34	35
32.	Steve Bellan	32	34
	Alfred Metcalfe	32	32
34.	Billy Geer	8	8
35.	Frank Fleet	6	6
36.	Orator Shafer	5	5

Plate Appearances

Rank	Player	Plate Appearances	Year
1.	Dick Higham	337	1874
2.	Jim Holdsworth	325	1875
3.	Doug Allison	324	1874
4.	Joe Start	317	1875
5.	Joe Start	310	1874
6.	Candy Nelson	306	1874
7.	Bobby Mathews	301	1874
8.	John Hatfield	299	1874
9.	Dave Eggler	298	1872
10.	John Hatfield	297	1872
11.	Tom Carey	289	1874
12.	Candy Nelson	285	1875
13.	Jack Remsen	284	1874
14.	Eddie Booth	281	1875
15.	Joe Start	277	1872
16.	Jack Burdock	274	1874
17.	Nat Hicks	273	1872
18.	Dave Eggler	272	1873
19.	Nat Hicks	271	1875
20.	Count Gedney	267	1875
21.	Bobby Mathews	266	1875
22.	John Hatfield	258	1873
23.	Joe Start	256	1873
24.	George Bechtel	254	1872
25.	Candy Cummings	253	1872
26.	Joe Gerhardt	252	1875
27.	John McMullin	247	1872
28.	Dick Higham	246	1873
29.	Bobby Mathews	233	1873
30.	Jim Holdsworth	232	1873
31.	Count Gedney	231	1873
32.	Dickey Pearce	210	1872
33.	Jimmy Hallinan	204	1875
34.	Bill Boyd	176	1872
35.	John Hatfield	172	1871
36.	Candy Nelson	169	1873
37.	Chick Fulmer	168	1872
38.	Dickey Pearce	167	1871
39.	Joe Start	164	1871
40.	Bob Ferguson	161	1871
41.	Tom Patterson	152	1871
42.	Dave Eggler	151	1871
43.	Rynie Wolters	148	1871
44.	Charlie Mills	147	1871
45.	Phonney Martin	140	1873
46.	Nat Hicks	128	1873
47.	Dick Higham	96	1871
48.	Pat McGee	95	1875
49.	Charlie Smith	73	1871
50.	Dick Higham	64	1875

Plate Appearances

Rank	Player	Plate Appearances	PA
1.	Joe Start	1324	1324
2.	John Hatfield	1030	1030
3.	Bobby Mathews	800	800
4.	Candy Nelson	760	760
5.	Dick Higham	743	743
6.	Dave Eggler	721	721
7.	Nat Hicks	672	672
8.	Jim Holdsworth	557	557
9.	Count Gedney	498	498
10.	Dickey Pearce	377	377
11.	Doug Allison	373	373
12.	Tom Carey	289	289
13.	Jack Remsen	284	284
14.	Eddie Booth	281	281
15.	Jack Burdock	274	274
16.	George Bechtel	254	254
17.	Candy Cummings	253	253
18.	Joe Gerhardt	252	252
19.	John McMullin	247	247
20.	Jimmy Hallinan	204	204
21.	Charlie Mills	178	178
22.	Bill Boyd	176	176
23.	Chick Fulmer	168	168
24.	Bob Ferguson	161	161
25.	Tom Patterson	157	157
26.	Rynie Wolters	148	148
27.	Phonney Martin	140	140
28.	Pat McGee	95	95
29.	Charlie Smith	73	73
30.	Nealy Phelps	36	36
31.	Billy Barnie	35	35
32.	Steve Bellan	34	34
33.	Alfred Metcalfe	32	32
34.	Billy Geer	8	8
35.	Frank Fleet	6	6
36.	Orator Shafer	5	5

Runs Scored

Rank	Player	Runs Scored	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	94	1872
2.	Dave Eggler	82	1873
3.	John Hatfield	76	1872
4.	Doug Allison	68	1874
5.	Joe Start	67	1874
6.	George Bechtel	61	1872
7.	Joe Start	60	1872
8.	Dick Higham	58	1874
	Joe Start	58	1875
10.	Dick Higham	57	1873
11.	Tom Carey	56	1874
12.	Candy Nelson	55	1874
13.	John Hatfield	54	1873
	Nat Hicks	54	1872
15.	Jack Remsen	52	1874
16.	John Hatfield	47	1874
	John McMullin	47	1872
18.	Jim Holdsworth	46	1873
	Bobby Mathews	46	1874
20.	Jack Burdock	45	1874
	Jim Holdsworth	45	1875
22.	Joe Start	42	1873
23.	Count Gedney	41	1873
	John Hatfield	41	1871
25.	Bobby Mathews	40	1873
26.	Candy Cummings	37	1872
	Dave Eggler	37	1871
28.	Joe Start	35	1871
29.	Eddie Booth	33	1875
	Rynie Wolters	33	1871
31.	Nat Hicks	32	1875
	Dickey Pearce	32	1872
33.	Tom Patterson	31	1871
	Dickey Pearce	31	1871
35.	Bob Ferguson	30	1871
	Count Gedney	30	1875
37.	Chick Fulmer	29	1872
	Joe Gerhardt	29	1875
	Jimmy Hallinan	29	1875
40.	Candy Nelson	28	1873
	Candy Nelson	28	1875
42.	Bill Boyd	27	1872
	Charlie Mills	27	1871
44.	Bobby Mathews	23	1875
45.	Dick Higham	21	1871
46.	Charlie Smith	15	1871
47.	Nat Hicks	12	1873
	Dick Higham	12	1875
	Phonney Martin	12	1873
50.	Doug Allison	6	1873
	Charlie Mills	6	1872

Runs Scored

Rank	Player	Runs Scored	PA
1.	Joe Start	262	1324
2.	John Hatfield	219	1030
3.	Dave Eggler	213	721
4.	Dick Higham	148	743
5.	Candy Nelson	111	760
6.	Bobby Mathews	109	800
7.	Nat Hicks	98	672
8.	Jim Holdsworth	91	557
9.	Doug Allison	74	373
10.	Count Gedney	71	498
11.	Dickey Pearce	63	377
12.	George Bechtel	61	254
13.	Tom Carey	56	289
14.	Jack Remsen	52	284
15.	John McMullin	47	247
16.	Jack Burdock	45	274
17.	Candy Cummings	37	253
18.	Eddie Booth	33	281
	Charlie Mills	33	178
	Rynie Wolters	33	148
21.	Tom Patterson	32	157
22.	Bob Ferguson	30	161
23.	Chick Fulmer	29	168
	Joe Gerhardt	29	252
	Jimmy Hallinan	29	204
26.	Bill Boyd	27	176
27.	Charlie Smith	15	73
28.	Phonney Martin	12	140
29.	Nealy Phelps	6	36
30.	Steve Bellan	4	34
	Pat McGee	4	95
32.	Alfred Metcalfe	2	32
33.	Billy Barnie	1	35
	Frank Fleet	1	6
	Orator Shafer	1	5

Hits

Rank	Player	Hits	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	97	1872
2.	Joe Start	96	1874
3.	John Hatfield	93	1872
4.	Jim Holdsworth	92	1875
5.	Doug Allison	90	1874
	Dave Eggler	90	1873
	Joe Start	90	1875
8.	Dick Higham	87	1874
9.	Tom Carey	82	1874
	Nat Hicks	82	1872
11.	John Hatfield	78	1873
12.	Dick Higham	77	1873
13.	Jack Burdock	75	1874
	Jim Holdsworth	75	1873
	Joe Start	75	1872
16.	George Bechtel	74	1872
17.	Candy Nelson	73	1874
18.	Bobby Mathews	72	1874
19.	Nat Hicks	67	1875
	Joe Start	67	1873
21.	John Hatfield	66	1874
22.	Jack Remsen	65	1874
23.	Count Gedney	60	1873
	John McMullin	60	1872
25.	Jimmy Hallinan	58	1875
	Joe Start	58	1871
27.	Eddie Booth	56	1875
28.	Count Gedney	55	1875
	Candy Nelson	55	1873
	Candy Nelson	55	1875
31.	Joe Gerhardt	54	1875
32.	Candy Cummings	52	1872
33.	Rynie Wolters	51	1871
34.	Chick Fulmer	50	1872
35.	Bobby Mathews	48	1875
36.	Dave Eggler	47	1871
37.	Bill Boyd	44	1872
	Dickey Pearce	44	1871
39.	John Hatfield	43	1871
	Bobby Mathews	43	1873
41.	Dickey Pearce	39	1872
42.	Bob Ferguson	38	1871
43.	Charlie Mills	36	1871
44.	Dick Higham	34	1871
45.	Phonney Martin	31	1873
	Tom Patterson	31	1871
47.	Nat Hicks	29	1873
48.	Dick Higham	25	1875
49.	Charlie Smith	19	1871
50.	Pat McGee	17	1875

Hits

Rank	Player	Hits	PA
1.	Joe Start	386	1324
2.	John Hatfield	282	1030
3.	Dave Eggler	234	721
4.	Dick Higham	223	743
5.	Candy Nelson	183	760
6.	Nat Hicks	178	672
7.	Jim Holdsworth	167	557
8.	Bobby Mathews	163	800
9.	Count Gedney	115	498
10.	Doug Allison	100	373
11.	Dickey Pearce	83	377
12.	Tom Carey	82	289
13.	Jack Burdock	75	274
14.	George Bechtel	74	254
15.	Jack Remsen	65	284
16.	John McMullin	60	247
17.	Jimmy Hallinan	58	204
18.	Eddie Booth	56	281
19.	Joe Gerhardt	54	252
20.	Candy Cummings	52	253
21.	Rynie Wolters	51	148
22.	Chick Fulmer	50	168
23.	Bill Boyd	44	176
24.	Charlie Mills	40	178
25.	Bob Ferguson	38	161
26.	Tom Patterson	33	157
27.	Phonney Martin	31	140
28.	Charlie Smith	19	73
29.	Pat McGee	17	95
30.	Steve Bellan	7	34
	Alfred Metcalfe	7	32
32.	Billy Barnie	5	35
	Nealy Phelps	5	36
34.	Frank Fleet	2	6
	Billy Geer	2	8
36.	Orator Shafer	1	5

Total Bases

Rank	Player	Total Bases	Year
1.	Joe Start	122	1875
2.	Joe Start	121	1874
3.	Dave Eggler	117	1872
4.	John Hatfield	115	1872
5.	Dave Eggler	111	1873
6.	Dick Higham	110	1874
7.	Doug Allison	107	1874
8.	Jim Holdsworth	106	1875
9.	Tom Carey	101	1874
	John Hatfield	101	1873
11.	Nat Hicks	98	1872
12.	Jack Burdock	97	1874
13.	Jim Holdsworth	95	1873
14.	George Bechtel	91	1872
15.	Dick Higham	90	1873
	Candy Nelson	90	1874
17.	Jack Remsen	86	1874
18.	Joe Start	84	1873
19.	John Hatfield	80	1874
	Bobby Mathews	80	1874
	Joe Start	80	1872
22.	Jimmy Hallinan	79	1875
23.	Count Gedney	78	1873
24.	Nat Hicks	77	1875
25.	Rynie Wolters	75	1871
26.	Count Gedney	71	1875
27.	John McMullin	68	1872
	Joe Start	68	1871
29.	Eddie Booth	67	1875
	Candy Cummings	67	1872
	Joe Gerhardt	67	1875
32.	Candy Nelson	64	1875
33.	Candy Nelson	61	1873
34.	Dave Eggler	60	1871
35.	Bobby Mathews	58	1875
36.	Chick Fulmer	56	1872
37.	Bill Boyd	55	1872
38.	Bobby Mathews	52	1873
39.	John Hatfield	50	1871
40.	Dickey Pearce	49	1871
41.	Bob Ferguson	46	1871
	Charlie Mills	46	1871
	Dickey Pearce	46	1872
44.	Dick Higham	39	1871
45.	Nat Hicks	37	1873
46.	Tom Patterson	33	1871
47.	Phonney Martin	32	1873
48.	Dick Higham	30	1875
49.	Charlie Smith	23	1871
50.	Pat McGee	19	1875

Total Bases

Rank	Player	Total Bases	PA
1.	Joe Start	475	1324
2.	John Hatfield	349	1030
3.	Dave Eggler	288	721
4.	Dick Higham	269	743
5.	Candy Nelson	215	760
6.	Nat Hicks	212	672
7.	Jim Holdsworth	201	557
8.	Bobby Mathews	190	800
9.	Count Gedney	149	498
10.	Doug Allison	117	373
11.	Tom Carey	101	289
12.	Jack Burdock	97	274
13.	Dickey Pearce	95	377
14.	George Bechtel	91	254
15.	Jack Remsen	86	284
16.	Jimmy Hallinan	79	204
17.	Rynie Wolters	75	148
18.	John McMullin	68	247
19.	Eddie Booth	67	281
	Candy Cummings	67	253
	Joe Gerhardt	67	252
22.	Chick Fulmer	56	168
23.	Bill Boyd	55	176
24.	Charlie Mills	50	178
25.	Bob Ferguson	46	161
26.	Tom Patterson	35	157
27.	Phonney Martin	32	140
28.	Charlie Smith	23	73
29.	Pat McGee	19	95
30.	Steve Bellan	9	34
31.	Alfred Metcalfe	7	32
32.	Nealy Phelps	6	36
33.	Billy Barnie	5	35
34.	Frank Fleet	2	6
	Billy Geer	2	8
36.	Orator Shafer	1	5

Doubles

Rank	Player	Doubles	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	20	1872
2.	John Hatfield	15	1872
3.	Dick Higham	14	1874
4.	Dave Eggler	13	1873
	Joe Start	13	1874
6.	Count Gedney	12	1875
	John Hatfield	12	1874
	Nat Hicks	12	1872
	Jim Holdsworth	12	1875
10.	George Bechtel	11	1872
	Jack Burdock	11	1874
12.	Tom Carey	10	1874
	Nat Hicks	10	1875
	Joe Start	10	1875
15.	Candy Cummings	9	1872
	Jack Remsen	9	1874
17.	Joe Start	8	1873
18.	Doug Allison	7	1874
	Dave Eggler	7	1871
	Joe Gerhardt	7	1875
	Candy Nelson	7	1874
	Candy Nelson	7	1875
23.	Bill Boyd	6	1872
	Bob Ferguson	6	1871
	Jimmy Hallinan	6	1875
	Bobby Mathews	6	1874
	Bobby Mathews	6	1875
	John McMullin	6	1872
	Rynie Wolters	6	1871
30.	Count Gedney	5	1873
	John Hatfield	5	1873
	Dick Higham	5	1873
	Dick Higham	5	1875
	Dickey Pearce	5	1871
	Joe Start	5	1871
	Joe Start	5	1872
37.	Jim Holdsworth	4	1873
	Charlie Mills	4	1871
	Candy Nelson	4	1873
40.	Eddie Booth	3	1875
	John Hatfield	3	1871
	Dick Higham	3	1871
	Bobby Mathews	3	1873
44.	Steve Bellan	2	1873
	Pat McGee	2	1875
	Tom Patterson	2	1871
	Dickey Pearce	2	1872
	Charlie Smith	2	1871
49.	Chick Fulmer	1	1872
	John Hatfield	1	1875
	Nat Hicks	1	1873
	Phonney Martin	1	1873
	Nealy Phelps	1	1875

Doubles

Rank	Player	Doubles	PA
1.	Joe Start	41	1324
2.	Dave Eggler	40	721
3.	John Hatfield	36	1030
4.	Dick Higham	27	743
5.	Nat Hicks	23	672
6.	Candy Nelson	18	760
7.	Count Gedney	17	498
8.	Jim Holdsworth	16	557
9.	Bobby Mathews	15	800
10.	George Bechtel	11	254
	Jack Burdock	11	274
12.	Tom Carey	10	289
13.	Candy Cummings	9	253
	Jack Remsen	9	284
15.	Doug Allison	7	373
	Joe Gerhardt	7	252
	Dickey Pearce	7	377
18.	Bill Boyd	6	176
	Bob Ferguson	6	161
	Jimmy Hallinan	6	204
	John McMullin	6	247
	Rynie Wolters	6	148
23.	Charlie Mills	4	178
24.	Eddie Booth	3	281
25.	Steve Bellan	2	34
	Pat McGee	2	95
	Tom Patterson	2	157
	Charlie Smith	2	73
29.	Chick Fulmer	1	168
	Phonney Martin	1	140
	Nealy Phelps	1	36

Triples

Rank	Player	Triples	Year
1.	Rynie Wolters	9	1871
2.	Jim Holdsworth	8	1873
3.	John Hatfield	6	1873
4.	Doug Allison	5	1874
	Count Gedney	5	1873
	Candy Nelson	5	1874
	Joe Start	5	1875
8.	Eddie Booth	4	1875
	Jack Burdock	4	1874
	Dave Eggler	4	1873
	Dick Higham	4	1873
12.	George Bechtel	3	1872
	Tom Carey	3	1874
	Candy Cummings	3	1872
	Dave Eggler	3	1871
	Joe Gerhardt	3	1875
	Jimmy Hallinan	3	1875
	Dick Higham	3	1874
	Bobby Mathews	3	1873
	Charlie Mills	3	1871
	Jack Remsen	3	1874
	Joe Start	3	1873
	Joe Start	3	1874
24.	Count Gedney	2	1875
	John Hatfield	2	1871
	John Hatfield	2	1872
	Nat Hicks	2	1872
	Nat Hicks	2	1873
	Bobby Mathews	2	1875
30.	Bill Boyd	1	1872
	Bob Ferguson	1	1871
	Chick Fulmer	1	1872
	John Hatfield	1	1874
	Dick Higham	1	1871
	Jim Holdsworth	1	1875
	Bobby Mathews	1	1874
	John McMullin	1	1872
	Candy Nelson	1	1873
	Candy Nelson	1	1875
	Dickey Pearce	1	1872
	Charlie Smith	1	1871
	Joe Start	1	1871

Triples

Rank	Player	Triples	PA
1.	Joe Start	12	1324
2.	John Hatfield	11	1030
3.	Jim Holdsworth	9	557
	Rynie Wolters	9	148
5.	Dick Higham	8	743
6.	Dave Eggler	7	721
	Count Gedney	7	498
	Candy Nelson	7	760
9.	Bobby Mathews	6	800
10.	Doug Allison	5	373
11.	Eddie Booth	4	281
	Jack Burdock	4	274
	Nat Hicks	4	672
14.	George Bechtel	3	254
	Tom Carey	3	289
	Candy Cummings	3	253
	Joe Gerhardt	3	252
	Jimmy Hallinan	3	204
	Charlie Mills	3	178
	Jack Remsen	3	284
21.	Bill Boyd	1	176
	Bob Ferguson	1	161
	Chick Fulmer	1	168
	John McMullin	1	247
	Dickey Pearce	1	377
	Charlie Smith	1	73

Home Runs

Rank	Player	Home Runs	Year
1.	Joe Start	4	1875
2.	Jimmy Hallinan	3	1875
3.	John Hatfield	2	1873
	Jack Remsen	2	1874
	Joe Start	2	1874
6.	Bill Boyd	1	1872
	Jack Burdock	1	1874
	Tom Carey	1	1874
	Chick Fulmer	1	1872
	Count Gedney	1	1873
	John Hatfield	1	1872
	Nat Hicks	1	1873
	Dick Higham	1	1874
	Dickey Pearce	1	1872
	Joe Start	1	1871
	Joe Start	1	1873

Home Runs

Rank	Player	Home Runs	PA
1.	Joe Start	8	1324
2.	Jimmy Hallinan	3	204
	John Hatfield	3	1030
4.	Jack Remsen	2	284
5.	Bill Boyd	1	176
	Jack Burdock	1	274
	Tom Carey	1	289
	Chick Fulmer	1	168
	Count Gedney	1	498
	Nat Hicks	1	672
	Dick Higham	1	743
	Dickey Pearce	1	377

Runs Batted In

Rank	Player	Runs Batted In	Year
1.	Joe Start	48	1872
2.	John Hatfield	47	1872
3.	John Hatfield	46	1873
	Joe Start	46	1874
5.	Rynie Wolters	44	1871
6.	George Bechtel	42	1872
7.	Tom Carey	38	1874
	Dick Higham	38	1874
	Jack Remsen	38	1874
10.	Dave Eggler	35	1873
11.	Dick Higham	34	1873
	Joe Start	34	1871
13.	Bill Boyd	32	1872
	Nat Hicks	32	1872
15.	Candy Nelson	31	1874
16.	Bobby Mathews	30	1874
	Joe Start	30	1875
18.	John Hatfield	29	1874
	Joe Start	29	1873
20.	Doug Allison	28	1874
	Jim Holdsworth	28	1873
22.	Jack Burdock	26	1874
	Candy Cummings	26	1872
24.	Bob Ferguson	25	1871
25.	Count Gedney	24	1873
	John McMullin	24	1872
27.	Jim Holdsworth	23	1875
	Candy Nelson	23	1875
29.	John Hatfield	22	1871
	Nat Hicks	22	1875
	Charlie Mills	22	1871
	Candy Nelson	22	1873
	Dickey Pearce	22	1872
34.	Jimmy Hallinan	21	1875
35.	Joe Gerhardt	20	1875
	Dickey Pearce	20	1871
37.	Dave Eggler	19	1872
38.	Eddie Booth	18	1875
	Dave Eggler	18	1871
40.	Count Gedney	17	1875
41.	Chick Fulmer	15	1872
	Bobby Mathews	15	1875
43.	Nat Hicks	14	1873
	Phonney Martin	14	1873
	Bobby Mathews	14	1873
46.	Tom Patterson	13	1871
47.	Dick Higham	10	1875
48.	Dick Higham	9	1871
	Pat McGee	9	1875
50.	Charlie Smith	5	1871

Runs Batted In

Rank	Player	Runs Batted In	PA
1.	Joe Start	187	1324
2.	John Hatfield	145	1030
3.	Dick Higham	91	743
4.	Candy Nelson	76	760
5.	Dave Eggler	72	721
6.	Nat Hicks	68	672
7.	Bobby Mathews	59	800
8.	Jim Holdsworth	51	557
9.	Rynie Wolters	44	148
10.	George Bechtel	42	254
	Dickey Pearce	42	377
12.	Count Gedney	41	498
13.	Tom Carey	38	289
	Jack Remsen	38	284
15.	Bill Boyd	32	176
16.	Doug Allison	31	373
17.	Jack Burdock	26	274
	Candy Cummings	26	253
19.	Bob Ferguson	25	161
20.	John McMullin	24	247
	Charlie Mills	24	178
22.	Jimmy Hallinan	21	204
23.	Joe Gerhardt	20	252
24.	Eddie Booth	18	281
25.	Chick Fulmer	15	168
	Tom Patterson	15	157
27.	Phonney Martin	14	140
28.	Pat McGee	9	95
29.	Charlie Smith	5	73
30.	Steve Bellan	3	34
31.	Nealy Phelps	2	36
32.	Billy Barnie	1	35
	Frank Fleet	1	6
	Billy Geer	1	8
	Alfred Metcalfe	1	32

Bases on Balls

Rank	Player	Bases on Balls	Year
1.	John McMullin	11	1872
2.	Bobby Mathews	10	1873
	Rynie Wolters	10	1871
4.	John Hatfield	9	1872
	Candy Nelson	9	1874
	Candy Nelson	9	1875
7.	Dave Eggler	8	1872
	Nat Hicks	8	1873
9.	George Bechtel	7	1872
	John Hatfield	7	1874
11.	Doug Allison	6	1874
	Bill Boyd	6	1872
	Dave Eggler	6	1873
	Count Gedney	6	1873
	Nat Hicks	6	1872
16.	Candy Cummings	4	1872
	Dave Eggler	4	1871
	John Hatfield	4	1871
	Dick Higham	4	1874
	Dickey Pearce	4	1871
	Dickey Pearce	4	1872
	Joe Start	4	1873
	Joe Start	4	1874
24.	Bob Ferguson	3	1871
	Chick Fulmer	3	1872
	John Hatfield	3	1873
	Bobby Mathews	3	1874
	Joe Start	3	1871
	Joe Start	3	1875
30.	Steve Bellan	2	1873
	Tom Carey	2	1874
	Nat Hicks	2	1875
	Dick Higham	2	1871
	Dick Higham	2	1873
	Bobby Mathews	2	1875
36.	Doug Allison	1	1873
	Billy Barnie	1	1875
	Jack Burdock	1	1874
	Jimmy Hallinan	1	1875
	Jim Holdsworth	1	1875
	Charlie Mills	1	1871
	Candy Nelson	1	1873
	Tom Patterson	1	1871
	Charlie Smith	1	1871

Bases on Balls

Rank	Player	Bases on Balls	PA
1.	John Hatfield	23	1030
2.	Candy Nelson	19	760
3.	Dave Eggler	18	721
4.	Nat Hicks	16	672
5.	Bobby Mathews	15	800
6.	Joe Start	14	1324
7.	John McMullin	11	247
8.	Rynie Wolters	10	148
9.	Dick Higham	8	743
	Dickey Pearce	8	377
11.	Doug Allison	7	373
	George Bechtel	7	254
13.	Bill Boyd	6	176
	Count Gedney	6	498
15.	Candy Cummings	4	253
16.	Bob Ferguson	3	161
	Chick Fulmer	3	168
18.	Steve Bellan	2	34
	Tom Carey	2	289
20.	Billy Barnie	1	35
	Jack Burdock	1	274
	Jimmy Hallinan	1	204
	Jim Holdsworth	1	557
	Charlie Mills	1	178
	Tom Patterson	1	157
	Charlie Smith	1	73

Strikeouts

Rank	Player	Strikeouts	Year
1.	Candy Cummings	14	1872
2.	John Hatfield	12	1874
3.	Nat Hicks	10	1875
	Pat McGee	10	1875
5.	Dave Eggler	9	1872
6.	Count Gedney	8	1875
	Rynie Wolters	8	1871
8.	Bill Boyd	7	1872
9.	John Hatfield	6	1872
	John McMullin	6	1872
11.	Doug Allison	5	1874
	Jack Burdock	5	1874
	Bobby Mathews	5	1875
	Candy Nelson	5	1874
	Jack Remsen	5	1874
16.	Tom Carey	4	1874
	Count Gedney	4	1873
	Jim Holdsworth	4	1873
	Phonney Martin	4	1873
	Bobby Mathews	4	1874
21.	George Bechtel	3	1872
	Dave Eggler	3	1871
	Chick Fulmer	3	1872
	Nat Hicks	3	1872
	Jim Holdsworth	3	1875
	Bobby Mathews	3	1873
	Alfred Metcalfe	3	1875
28.	Eddie Booth	2	1875
	Dave Eggler	2	1873
	Bob Ferguson	2	1871
	Joe Gerhardt	2	1875
	Jimmy Hallinan	2	1875
	John Hatfield	2	1873
	Candy Nelson	2	1873
35.	Dick Higham	1	1873
	Dick Higham	1	1875
	Dickey Pearce	1	1871
	Dickey Pearce	1	1872
	Nealy Phelps	1	1875
	Charlie Smith	1	1871

Strikeouts

Rank	Player	Strikeouts	PA
1.	John Hatfield	20	1030
2.	Candy Cummings	14	253
	Dave Eggler	14	721
4.	Nat Hicks	13	672
5.	Count Gedney	12	498
	Bobby Mathews	12	800
7.	Pat McGee	10	95
8.	Rynie Wolters	8	148
9.	Bill Boyd	7	176
	Jim Holdsworth	7	557
	Candy Nelson	7	760
12.	John McMullin	6	247
13.	Doug Allison	5	373
	Jack Burdock	5	274
	Jack Remsen	5	284
16.	Tom Carey	4	289
	Phonney Martin	4	140
18.	George Bechtel	3	254
	Chick Fulmer	3	168
	Alfred Metcalfe	3	32
21.	Eddie Booth	2	281
	Bob Ferguson	2	161
	Joe Gerhardt	2	252
	Jimmy Hallinan	2	204
	Dick Higham	2	743
	Dickey Pearce	2	377
27.	Nealy Phelps	1	36
	Charlie Smith	1	73

Stolen Bases

Rank	Player	Stolen Bases	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	18	1872
2.	Dave Eggler	14	1871
3.	John Hatfield	12	1872
4.	John Hatfield	10	1871
5.	George Bechtel	9	1872
6.	John McMullin	8	1872
7.	Candy Nelson	6	1874
	Jack Remsen	6	1874
	Charlie Smith	6	1871
10.	Dick Higham	5	1874
	Joe Start	5	1874
12.	Eddie Booth	4	1875
	Bill Boyd	4	1872
	Jack Burdock	4	1874
	Bob Ferguson	4	1871
	John Hatfield	4	1874
	Candy Nelson	4	1875
	Joe Start	4	1871
19.	Tom Carey	3	1874
	Dave Eggler	3	1873
	Nat Hicks	3	1872
	Dick Higham	3	1871
	Jim Holdsworth	3	1875
	Joe Start	3	1872
25.	Count Gedney	2	1875
	Jimmy Hallinan	2	1875
	John Hatfield	2	1873
	Nat Hicks	2	1873
	Dick Higham	2	1873
	Bobby Mathews	2	1874
	Alfred Metcalfe	2	1875
	Charlie Mills	2	1871
	Candy Nelson	2	1873
	Tom Patterson	2	1871
35.	Doug Allison	1	1874
	Chick Fulmer	1	1872
	Count Gedney	1	1873
	Nat Hicks	1	1875
	Jim Holdsworth	1	1873
	Phonney Martin	1	1873
	Bobby Mathews	1	1873
	Bobby Mathews	1	1875
	Dickey Pearce	1	1872
	Joe Start	1	1873
	Joe Start	1	1875
	Rynie Wolters	1	1871

Stolen Bases

Rank	Player	Stolen Bases	PA
1.	Dave Eggler	35	721
2.	John Hatfield	28	1030
3.	Joe Start	14	1324
4.	Candy Nelson	12	760
5.	Dick Higham	10	743
6.	George Bechtel	9	254
7.	John McMullin	8	247
8.	Nat Hicks	6	672
	Jack Remsen	6	284
	Charlie Smith	6	73
11.	Eddie Booth	4	281
	Bill Boyd	4	176
	Jack Burdock	4	274
	Bob Ferguson	4	161
	Jim Holdsworth	4	557
	Bobby Mathews	4	800
17.	Tom Carey	3	289
	Count Gedney	3	498
19.	Jimmy Hallinan	2	204
	Alfred Metcalfe	2	32
	Charlie Mills	2	178
	Tom Patterson	2	157
23.	Doug Allison	1	373
	Chick Fulmer	1	168
	Phonney Martin	1	140
	Dickey Pearce	1	377
	Rynie Wolters	1	148

Singles

Rank	Player	Singles	Year
1.	Jim Holdsworth	79	1875
2.	Doug Allison	78	1874
	Joe Start	78	1874
4.	Dave Eggler	77	1872
5.	John Hatfield	75	1872
6.	Dave Eggler	73	1873
7.	Joe Start	71	1875
8.	Joe Start	70	1872
9.	Dick Higham	69	1874
10.	Tom Carey	68	1874
	Nat Hicks	68	1872
	Dick Higham	68	1873
13.	John Hatfield	65	1873
	Bobby Mathews	65	1874
15.	Jim Holdsworth	63	1873
16.	Candy Nelson	61	1874
17.	George Bechtel	60	1872
18.	Jack Burdock	59	1874
19.	Nat Hicks	57	1875
20.	Joe Start	55	1873
21.	John Hatfield	53	1874
	John McMullin	53	1872
23.	Jack Remsen	51	1874
	Joe Start	51	1871
25.	Candy Nelson	50	1873
26.	Eddie Booth	49	1875
	Count Gedney	49	1873
28.	Chick Fulmer	47	1872
	Candy Nelson	47	1875
30.	Jimmy Hallinan	46	1875
31.	Joe Gerhardt	44	1875
32.	Count Gedney	41	1875
33.	Candy Cummings	40	1872
	Bobby Mathews	40	1875
35.	Dickey Pearce	39	1871
36.	John Hatfield	38	1871
37.	Dave Eggler	37	1871
	Bobby Mathews	37	1873
39.	Bill Boyd	36	1872
	Rynie Wolters	36	1871
41.	Dickey Pearce	35	1872
42.	Bob Ferguson	31	1871
43.	Dick Higham	30	1871
	Phonney Martin	30	1873
45.	Charlie Mills	29	1871
	Tom Patterson	29	1871
47.	Nat Hicks	25	1873
48.	Dick Higham	20	1875
49.	Charlie Smith	16	1871
50.	Pat McGee	15	1875

Singles

Rank	Player	Singles	PA
1.	Joe Start	325	1324
2.	John Hatfield	232	1030
3.	Dave Eggler	187	721
	Dick Higham	187	743
5.	Candy Nelson	158	760
6.	Nat Hicks	150	672
7.	Jim Holdsworth	142	557
	Bobby Mathews	142	800
9.	Count Gedney	90	498
10.	Doug Allison	88	373
11.	Dickey Pearce	74	377
12.	Tom Carey	68	289
13.	George Bechtel	60	254
14.	Jack Burdock	59	274
15.	John McMullin	53	247
16.	Jack Remsen	51	284
17.	Eddie Booth	49	281
18.	Chick Fulmer	47	168
19.	Jimmy Hallinan	46	204
20.	Joe Gerhardt	44	252
21.	Candy Cummings	40	253
22.	Bill Boyd	36	176
	Rynie Wolters	36	148
24.	Charlie Mills	33	178
25.	Bob Ferguson	31	161
	Tom Patterson	31	157
27.	Phonney Martin	30	140
28.	Charlie Smith	16	73
29.	Pat McGee	15	95
30.	Alfred Metcalfe	7	32
31.	Billy Barnie	5	35
	Steve Bellan	5	34
33.	Nealy Phelps	4	36
34.	Frank Fleet	2	6
	Billy Geer	2	8
36.	Orator Shafer	1	5

Adjusted OPS+

Rank	Player	Adjusted OPS+	Year
1.	Joe Start	134	1875
2.	Joe Start	127	1874
3.	Jim Holdsworth	112	1875
4.	Doug Allison	101	1874
5.	Dick Higham	90	1874

Adjusted OPS+

Rank	Player	Adjusted OPS+	PA

Runs Created

Rank	Player	Runs Created	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	42	1872
2.	John Hatfield	40	1872
	Joe Start	40	1874
4.	Dave Eggler	39	1873
5.	Joe Start	34	1875
6.	Doug Allison	32	1874
	John Hatfield	32	1873
	Nat Hicks	32	1872
9.	Jim Holdsworth	31	1873
	Rynie Wolters	31	1871
11.	George Bechtel	30	1872
	Tom Carey	30	1874
	Jim Holdsworth	30	1875
14.	Dick Higham	29	1873
	Dick Higham	29	1874
16.	Jack Burdock	27	1874
17.	Candy Nelson	25	1874
	Joe Start	25	1871
19.	Joe Start	23	1873
20.	Dave Eggler	22	1871
	Count Gedney	22	1873
	Jimmy Hallinan	22	1875
23.	Candy Nelson	21	1873
	Joe Start	21	1872
25.	John Hatfield	20	1874
	Nat Hicks	20	1875
	Bobby Mathews	20	1874
	John McMullin	20	1872
	Jack Remsen	20	1874
30.	Chick Fulmer	18	1872
31.	Bill Boyd	16	1872
32.	Candy Cummings	15	1872
33.	Count Gedney	14	1875
	John Hatfield	14	1871
	Dick Higham	14	1871
	Candy Nelson	14	1875
	Dickey Pearce	14	1871
38.	Eddie Booth	13	1875
	Joe Gerhardt	13	1875
40.	Dick Higham	12	1875
	Bobby Mathews	12	1873
	Charlie Mills	12	1871
43.	Bob Ferguson	11	1871
	Nat Hicks	11	1873
	Bobby Mathews	11	1875
46.	Dickey Pearce	9	1872
47.	Phonney Martin	7	1873
	Tom Patterson	7	1871
	Charlie Smith	7	1871
50.	Pat McGee	3	1875

Runs Created

Rank	Player	Runs Created	PA
1.	Joe Start	143	1324
2.	John Hatfield	108	1030
3.	Dave Eggler	103	721
4.	Dick Higham	84	743
5.	Nat Hicks	63	672
6.	Jim Holdsworth	61	557
7.	Candy Nelson	60	760
8.	Bobby Mathews	43	800
9.	Count Gedney	36	498
10.	Doug Allison	34	373
11.	Rynie Wolters	31	148
12.	George Bechtel	30	254
	Tom Carey	30	289
14.	Jack Burdock	27	274
15.	Dickey Pearce	23	377
16.	Jimmy Hallinan	22	204
17.	John McMullin	20	247
	Jack Remsen	20	284
19.	Chick Fulmer	18	168
20.	Bill Boyd	16	176
21.	Candy Cummings	15	253
22.	Eddie Booth	13	281
	Joe Gerhardt	13	252
	Charlie Mills	13	178
25.	Bob Ferguson	11	161
26.	Tom Patterson	8	157
27.	Phonney Martin	7	140
	Charlie Smith	7	73
29.	Pat McGee	3	95
30.	Steve Bellan	2	34
	Alfred Metcalfe	2	32
32.	Billy Barnie	1	35
	Frank Fleet	1	6
	Billy Geer	1	8
	Nealy Phelps	1	36

Adj. Batting Runs

Rank	Player	Adj. Batting Runs	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	15	1872
2.	Rynie Wolters	14	1871
3.	John Hatfield	13	1872
4.	Dave Eggler	10	1873
	Joe Start	10	1875
6.	Joe Start	9	1874
7.	Joe Start	8	1871
8.	Nat Hicks	7	1872
9.	George Bechtel	6	1872
	Jimmy Hallinan	6	1875
	Dick Higham	6	1875
12.	Dave Eggler	4	1871
	Dick Higham	4	1871
	Jim Holdsworth	4	1873
	Jim Holdsworth	4	1875
16.	John Hatfield	3	1873
17.	Chick Fulmer	2	1872
18.	Tom Carey	1	1874
	John Hatfield	1	1875
	Dick Higham	1	1873
	Candy Nelson	1	1873
	Nealy Phelps	1	1875

Adj. Batting Runs

Rank	Player	Adj. Batting Runs	PA
1.	Dave Eggler	29	721
2.	Joe Start	15	1324
3.	Rynie Wolters	14	148
4.	Dick Higham	8	743
	Jim Holdsworth	8	557
6.	George Bechtel	6	254
	Jimmy Hallinan	6	204
8.	Chick Fulmer	2	168
9.	Tom Carey	1	289

Adj. Batting Wins

Rank	Player	Adj. Batting Wins	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	1.4	1872
2.	Rynie Wolters	1.3	1871
3.	John Hatfield	1.2	1872
	Joe Start	1.2	1875
5.	Joe Start	1.0	1874
6.	Dave Eggler	0.9	1873
7.	Jimmy Hallinan	0.7	1875
	Dick Higham	0.7	1875
	Joe Start	0.7	1871
10.	George Bechtel	0.6	1872
	Nat Hicks	0.6	1872
12.	Dave Eggler	0.4	1871
	Dick Higham	0.4	1871
	Jim Holdsworth	0.4	1873
	Jim Holdsworth	0.4	1875
16.	Chick Fulmer	0.2	1872
	John Hatfield	0.2	1873
18.	Tom Carey	0.1	1874
	John Hatfield	0.1	1875
	Dick Higham	0.1	1873
	Candy Nelson	0.1	1873
	Nealy Phelps	0.1	1875

Adj. Batting Wins

Rank	Player	Adj. Batting Wins	PA
1.	Dave Eggler	2.7	721
2.	Joe Start	1.6	1324
3.	Rynie Wolters	1.3	148
4.	Dick Higham	0.8	743
	Jim Holdsworth	0.8	557
6.	Jimmy Hallinan	0.7	204
7.	George Bechtel	0.6	254
8.	Chick Fulmer	0.2	168
9.	Tom Carey	0.1	289

Extra Base Hits

Rank	Player	Extra Base Hits	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	20	1872
2.	Joe Start	19	1875
3.	John Hatfield	18	1872
	Dick Higham	18	1874
	Joe Start	18	1874
6.	Dave Eggler	17	1873
7.	Jack Burdock	16	1874
8.	Rynie Wolters	15	1871
9.	George Bechtel	14	1872
	Tom Carey	14	1874
	Count Gedney	14	1875
	Nat Hicks	14	1872
	Jack Remsen	14	1874
14.	John Hatfield	13	1873
	John Hatfield	13	1874
	Jim Holdsworth	13	1875
17.	Doug Allison	12	1874
	Candy Cummings	12	1872
	Jimmy Hallinan	12	1875
	Jim Holdsworth	12	1873
	Candy Nelson	12	1874
	Joe Start	12	1873
23.	Count Gedney	11	1873
24.	Dave Eggler	10	1871
	Joe Gerhardt	10	1875
	Nat Hicks	10	1875
27.	Dick Higham	9	1873
28.	Bill Boyd	8	1872
	Bobby Mathews	8	1875
	Candy Nelson	8	1875
31.	Eddie Booth	7	1875
	Bob Ferguson	7	1871
	Bobby Mathews	7	1874
	John McMullin	7	1872
	Charlie Mills	7	1871
	Joe Start	7	1871
37.	Bobby Mathews	6	1873
38.	John Hatfield	5	1871
	Dick Higham	5	1875
	Candy Nelson	5	1873
	Dickey Pearce	5	1871
	Joe Start	5	1872
43.	Nat Hicks	4	1873
	Dick Higham	4	1871
	Dickey Pearce	4	1872
46.	Chick Fulmer	3	1872
	Charlie Smith	3	1871
48.	Steve Bellan	2	1873
	Pat McGee	2	1875
	Tom Patterson	2	1871

Extra Base Hits

Rank	Player	Extra Base Hits	PA
1.	Joe Start	61	1324
2.	John Hatfield	50	1030
3.	Dave Eggler	47	721
4.	Dick Higham	36	743
5.	Nat Hicks	28	672
6.	Count Gedney	25	498
	Jim Holdsworth	25	557
	Candy Nelson	25	760
9.	Bobby Mathews	21	800
10.	Jack Burdock	16	274
11.	Rynie Wolters	15	148
12.	George Bechtel	14	254
	Tom Carey	14	289
	Jack Remsen	14	284
15.	Doug Allison	12	373
	Candy Cummings	12	253
	Jimmy Hallinan	12	204
18.	Joe Gerhardt	10	252
19.	Dickey Pearce	9	377
20.	Bill Boyd	8	176
21.	Eddie Booth	7	281
	Bob Ferguson	7	161
	John McMullin	7	247
	Charlie Mills	7	178
25.	Chick Fulmer	3	168
	Charlie Smith	3	73
27.	Steve Bellan	2	34
	Pat McGee	2	95
	Tom Patterson	2	157
30.	Phonney Martin	1	140
	Nealy Phelps	1	36

Times On Base

Rank	Player	Times On Base	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	105	1872
2.	John Hatfield	102	1872
3.	Joe Start	100	1874
4.	Doug Allison	96	1874
	Dave Eggler	96	1873
6.	Jim Holdsworth	93	1875
	Joe Start	93	1875
8.	Dick Higham	91	1874
9.	Nat Hicks	88	1872
10.	Tom Carey	84	1874
11.	Candy Nelson	82	1874
12.	George Bechtel	81	1872
	John Hatfield	81	1873
14.	Dick Higham	79	1873
15.	Jack Burdock	76	1874
16.	Jim Holdsworth	75	1873
	Bobby Mathews	75	1874
	Joe Start	75	1872
19.	John Hatfield	73	1874
20.	John McMullin	71	1872
	Joe Start	71	1873
22.	Nat Hicks	69	1875
23.	Count Gedney	66	1873
24.	Jack Remsen	65	1874
25.	Candy Nelson	64	1875
26.	Joe Start	61	1871
	Rynie Wolters	61	1871
28.	Jimmy Hallinan	59	1875
29.	Eddie Booth	56	1875
	Candy Cummings	56	1872
	Candy Nelson	56	1873
32.	Count Gedney	55	1875
33.	Joe Gerhardt	54	1875
34.	Chick Fulmer	53	1872
	Bobby Mathews	53	1873
36.	Dave Eggler	51	1871
37.	Bill Boyd	50	1872
	Bobby Mathews	50	1875
39.	Dickey Pearce	48	1871
40.	John Hatfield	47	1871
41.	Dickey Pearce	43	1872
42.	Bob Ferguson	41	1871
43.	Nat Hicks	37	1873
	Charlie Mills	37	1871
45.	Dick Higham	36	1871
46.	Tom Patterson	32	1871
47.	Phonney Martin	31	1873
48.	Dick Higham	25	1875
49.	Charlie Smith	20	1871
50.	Pat McGee	17	1875

Times On Base

Rank	Player	Times On Base	PA
1.	Joe Start	400	1324
2.	John Hatfield	305	1030
3.	Dave Eggler	252	721
4.	Dick Higham	231	743
5.	Candy Nelson	202	760
6.	Nat Hicks	194	672
7.	Bobby Mathews	178	800
8.	Jim Holdsworth	168	557
9.	Count Gedney	121	498
10.	Doug Allison	107	373
11.	Dickey Pearce	91	377
12.	Tom Carey	84	289
13.	George Bechtel	81	254
14.	Jack Burdock	76	274
15.	John McMullin	71	247
16.	Jack Remsen	65	284
17.	Rynie Wolters	61	148
18.	Jimmy Hallinan	59	204
19.	Eddie Booth	56	281
	Candy Cummings	56	253
21.	Joe Gerhardt	54	252
22.	Chick Fulmer	53	168
23.	Bill Boyd	50	176
24.	Bob Ferguson	41	161
	Charlie Mills	41	178
26.	Tom Patterson	34	157
27.	Phonney Martin	31	140
28.	Charlie Smith	20	73
29.	Pat McGee	17	95
30.	Steve Bellan	9	34
31.	Alfred Metcalfe	7	32
32.	Billy Barnie	6	35
33.	Nealy Phelps	5	36
34.	Frank Fleet	2	6
	Billy Geer	2	8
36.	Orator Shafer	1	5

Offensive Win %

Rank	Player	Offensive Win %	Year
1.	Joe Start	.605	1874
2.	Joe Start	.587	1875
3.	Jim Holdsworth	.515	1875
4.	Doug Allison	.467	1874
5.	Dick Higham	.386	1874

Offensive Win %

Rank	Player	Offensive Win %	PA

Hit By Pitch

Rank	Player	Hit By Pitch	Year

Hit By Pitch

Rank	Player	Hit By Pitch	PA

Sacrifice Hits

Rank	Player	Sacrifice Hits	Year

Sacrifice Hits

Rank	Player	Sacrifice Hits	PA

Sacrifice Flies

Rank	Player	Sacrifice Flies	Year

Sacrifice Flies

Rank	Player	Sacrifice Flies	PA

Intentional Bases on Balls

Rank	Player	Intentional Bases on Balls	Year

Intentional Bases on Balls

Rank	Player	Intentional Bases on Balls	PA

Double Plays Grounded Into

Rank	Player	Double Plays Grounded Into	Year
1.	Nat Hicks	7	1872
2.	Bobby Mathews	4	1875
	John McMullin	4	1872
4.	Eddie Booth	3	1875
	Count Gedney	3	1873
	John Hatfield	3	1872
	Jim Holdsworth	3	1873
	Phonney Martin	3	1873
	Charlie Mills	3	1871
	Tom Patterson	3	1871
11.	George Bechtel	2	1872
	Candy Cummings	2	1872
	John Hatfield	2	1873
	Nat Hicks	2	1875
	Bobby Mathews	2	1873
	Candy Nelson	2	1875
	Dickey Pearce	2	1872
18.	Doug Allison	1	1873
	Doug Allison	1	1874
	Bill Boyd	1	1872
	Tom Carey	1	1874
	Dave Eggler	1	1873
	Chick Fulmer	1	1872
	Joe Gerhardt	1	1875
	Jimmy Hallinan	1	1875
	Dick Higham	1	1873
	Jim Holdsworth	1	1875
	Pat McGee	1	1875
	Candy Nelson	1	1873
	Dickey Pearce	1	1871
	Joe Start	1	1873
	Joe Start	1	1874

Double Plays Grounded Into

Rank	Player	Double Plays Grounded Into	PA
1.	Nat Hicks	9	672
2.	Bobby Mathews	6	800
3.	John Hatfield	5	1030
4.	Jim Holdsworth	4	557
	John McMullin	4	247
6.	Eddie Booth	3	281
	Count Gedney	3	498
	Phonney Martin	3	140
	Charlie Mills	3	178
	Candy Nelson	3	760
	Tom Patterson	3	157
	Dickey Pearce	3	377
13.	Doug Allison	2	373
	George Bechtel	2	254
	Candy Cummings	2	253
	Joe Start	2	1324
17.	Bill Boyd	1	176
	Tom Carey	1	289
	Dave Eggler	1	721
	Chick Fulmer	1	168
	Joe Gerhardt	1	252
	Jimmy Hallinan	1	204
	Dick Higham	1	743
	Pat McGee	1	95

Caught Stealing

Rank	Player	Caught Stealing	Year
1.	Dave Eggler	6	1872
2.	Joe Gerhardt	5	1875
	John Hatfield	5	1872
4.	Bob Ferguson	4	1871
	Joe Start	4	1875
6.	Eddie Booth	3	1875
	Dave Eggler	3	1871
	Count Gedney	3	1875
	John Hatfield	3	1871
	Dick Higham	3	1874
	Jim Holdsworth	3	1875
	Joe Start	3	1872
13.	Bill Boyd	2	1872
	Dave Eggler	2	1873
	Jimmy Hallinan	2	1875
	Dick Higham	2	1871
	Dick Higham	2	1873
	Bobby Mathews	2	1875
	John McMullin	2	1872
	Candy Nelson	2	1875
	Joe Start	2	1871
22.	George Bechtel	1	1872
	Jack Burdock	1	1874
	Candy Cummings	1	1872
	Chick Fulmer	1	1872
	Nat Hicks	1	1873
	Phonney Martin	1	1873
	Bobby Mathews	1	1873
	Tom Patterson	1	1871
	Dickey Pearce	1	1872

Caught Stealing

Rank	Player	Caught Stealing	PA
1.	Dave Eggler	11	721
2.	Joe Start	9	1324
3.	John Hatfield	8	1030
4.	Dick Higham	7	743
5.	Joe Gerhardt	5	252
6.	Bob Ferguson	4	161
7.	Eddie Booth	3	281
	Count Gedney	3	498
	Jim Holdsworth	3	557
	Bobby Mathews	3	800
11.	Bill Boyd	2	176
	Jimmy Hallinan	2	204
	John McMullin	2	247
	Candy Nelson	2	760
15.	George Bechtel	1	254
	Jack Burdock	1	274
	Candy Cummings	1	253
	Chick Fulmer	1	168
	Nat Hicks	1	672
	Phonney Martin	1	140
	Tom Patterson	1	157
	Dickey Pearce	1	377

SB %

Rank	Player	SB %	Year
1.	George Bechtel	90.00	1872
2.	Dave Eggler	82.35	1871
3.	John McMullin	80.00	1872
4.	John Hatfield	76.92	1871
5.	Dave Eggler	75.00	1872
6.	John Hatfield	70.59	1872

SB %

Rank	Player	SB %	PA

Power-Speed #

Rank	Player	Power-Speed #	Year
1.	Jack Remsen	3.0	1874
2.	Joe Start	2.9	1874
3.	Jimmy Hallinan	2.4	1875
4.	John Hatfield	2.0	1873
5.	John Hatfield	1.8	1872
6.	Dick Higham	1.7	1874
7.	Bill Boyd	1.6	1872
	Jack Burdock	1.6	1874
	Joe Start	1.6	1871
	Joe Start	1.6	1875
11.	Tom Carey	1.5	1874
12.	Nat Hicks	1.3	1873
13.	Chick Fulmer	1.0	1872
	Count Gedney	1.0	1873
	Dickey Pearce	1.0	1872
	Joe Start	1.0	1873

Power-Speed #

Rank	Player	Power-Speed #	PA
1.	Joe Start	10.2	1324
2.	John Hatfield	5.4	1030
3.	Jack Remsen	3.0	284
4.	Jimmy Hallinan	2.4	204
5.	Dick Higham	1.8	743
6.	Nat Hicks	1.7	672
7.	Bill Boyd	1.6	176
	Jack Burdock	1.6	274
9.	Tom Carey	1.5	289
	Count Gedney	1.5	498
11.	Chick Fulmer	1.0	168
	Dickey Pearce	1.0	377

AB per SO

Rank	Player	AB per SO	Year
1.	Jim Holdsworth	108.0	1875
2.	Doug Allison	63.6	1874

AB per SO

Rank	Player	AB per SO	PA

AB per HR

Rank	Player	AB per HR	Year
1.	Joe Start	78.5	1875
2.	Joe Start	153.0	1874
3.	Dick Higham	333.0	1874

AB per HR

Rank	Player	AB per HR	PA

Outs Made

Rank	Player	Outs Made	Year
1.	Dick Higham	249	1874
2.	Jim Holdsworth	236	1875
3.	Eddie Booth	231	1875
4.	Doug Allison	229	1874
5.	Joe Start	228	1875
6.	John Hatfield	226	1874
	Bobby Mathews	226	1874
8.	Candy Nelson	225	1875
9.	Candy Nelson	224	1874
10.	Bobby Mathews	222	1875
11.	Jack Remsen	219	1874
12.	Count Gedney	215	1875
13.	Joe Start	211	1874
14.	Tom Carey	206	1874
15.	Joe Start	205	1872
16.	Joe Gerhardt	204	1875
	Nat Hicks	204	1875
18.	John Hatfield	203	1872
19.	Candy Cummings	200	1872
20.	Jack Burdock	199	1874
	Dave Eggler	199	1872
22.	Nat Hicks	192	1872
23.	Joe Start	186	1873
24.	Bobby Mathews	183	1873
25.	John McMullin	182	1872
26.	Dave Eggler	179	1873
	John Hatfield	179	1873
28.	George Bechtel	176	1872
29.	Dick Higham	170	1873
	Dickey Pearce	170	1872
31.	Count Gedney	168	1873
32.	Jim Holdsworth	160	1873
33.	Jimmy Hallinan	148	1875
34.	Bill Boyd	129	1872
35.	John Hatfield	128	1871
36.	Bob Ferguson	124	1871
	Tom Patterson	124	1871
38.	Dickey Pearce	120	1871
39.	Chick Fulmer	117	1872
40.	Candy Nelson	114	1873
41.	Phonney Martin	113	1873
	Charlie Mills	113	1871
43.	Joe Start	105	1871
44.	Dave Eggler	103	1871
45.	Nat Hicks	92	1873
46.	Rynie Wolters	87	1871
47.	Pat McGee	79	1875
48.	Dick Higham	62	1871
49.	Charlie Smith	53	1871
50.	Doug Allison	39	1873
	Dick Higham	39	1875

Outs Made

Rank	Player	Outs Made	PA
1.	Joe Start	935	1324
2.	John Hatfield	738	1030
3.	Bobby Mathews	631	800
4.	Candy Nelson	563	760
5.	Dick Higham	520	743
6.	Nat Hicks	488	672
7.	Dave Eggler	481	721
8.	Jim Holdsworth	396	557
9.	Count Gedney	383	498
10.	Dickey Pearce	290	377
11.	Doug Allison	268	373
12.	Eddie Booth	231	281
13.	Jack Remsen	219	284
14.	Tom Carey	206	289
15.	Joe Gerhardt	204	252
16.	Candy Cummings	200	253
17.	Jack Burdock	199	274
18.	John McMullin	182	247
19.	George Bechtel	176	254
20.	Jimmy Hallinan	148	204
21.	Charlie Mills	140	178
22.	Bill Boyd	129	176
23.	Tom Patterson	127	157
24.	Bob Ferguson	124	161
25.	Chick Fulmer	117	168
26.	Phonney Martin	113	140
27.	Rynie Wolters	87	148
28.	Pat McGee	79	95
29.	Charlie Smith	53	73
30.	Nealy Phelps	31	36
31.	Billy Barnie	29	35
32.	Steve Bellan	25	34
	Alfred Metcalfe	25	32
34.	Billy Geer	6	8
35.	Frank Fleet	4	6
	Orator Shafer	4	5

Base-Out Runs Added (RE24)†

Rank	Player	Base-Out Runs Added (RE24)	Year

Base-Out Runs Added (RE24)

Rank	Player	Base-Out Runs Added (RE24)	IP

Win Probability Added (WPA)†

Rank	Player	Win Probability Added (WPA)	Year

Win Probability Added (WPA)

Rank	Player	Win Probability Added (WPA)	IP

Situ. Wins Added (WPA/LI)†

Rank	Player	Situ. Wins Added (WPA/LI)	Year

Situ. Wins Added (WPA/LI)

Rank	Player	Situ. Wins Added (WPA/LI)	IP

Base-Out Wins Added (REW)†

Rank	Player	Base-Out Wins Added (REW)	Year

Base-Out Wins Added (REW)

Rank	Player	Base-Out Wins Added (REW)	IP

† Statistics like WPA, REW and RE24 are computed from play-by-play data which is only complete from 1974 to the present. From 1948-1973, the data is incomplete, though for most seasons only less than 20 games per season total are missing. Please see our page on data coverage for a full view of the data used to create these leaderboards.

Automatic Player Linking / Statistical Sharing Tool / Basic Player Linking / Data Coverage

See Front Page for time of last update

Much of the play-by-play, game results, and transaction information both shown and used to create certain data sets was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by RetroSheet.

Win Expectancy, Run Expectancy, and Leverage Index calculations provided by Tom Tango of InsideTheBook.com, and co-author of The Book: Playing the Percentages in Baseball.

Total Zone Rating and Wins above Replacement calculations provided by Sean Smith of BaseballProjection.com.

Full-year historical Major League statistics provided by Pete Palmer and Gary Gillette of 24-7 Baseball.

Player head shots courtesy of David Davis. Many thanks to him. We have only selected seasons (players who debuted before 1960) for which we believe the image has reverted into the public domain. We will quickly remove any images for which that can be shown to not be the case.Please let us know if you are aware of any such images on this site.

Play Index Loading Photos from the George Grantham Bain Collection at the Library of Congress.

A Sports Reference Site: About Baseball Reference | Found a bug or have a suggestion?
Privacy Statement | Conditions & Terms of Service | Use of Data

Part of the USA TODAY Sports Media Group.

New York Mutuals Top 50 Batting Leaders

Create Custom Leaderboards

New York Mutuals Top 50 Batting Leaders