New York Mutuals Top 10 Career Pitching Leaders

Team Name: New York Mutuals

Also played as a Major League Franchise

Seasons: 5 (1871 to 1875)

Record: 151-122, .553 W-L%

Playoff Appearances: 0

Pennants: 0

World Championships: 0

Winningest Manager: John Hatfield, 35-31, .530 W-L%

Become a Stathead & surf this site ad-free.

New York Mutuals Menu

Career Top 10 Leaders

WAR for Pitchers †

1. Bobby Mathews 31.9

2. Candy Cummings 8.8

3. Rynie Wolters 3.1

4. Count Gedney 0.5

5. John Hatfield 0.1

Phonney Martin 0.1

Earned Run Average

1. Bobby Mathews 2.31

Wins

1. Bobby Mathews 100

2. Candy Cummings 33

3. Rynie Wolters 16

4. Count Gedney 1

John McMullin 1

Win-Loss %

1. Candy Cummings .623

2. Bobby Mathews .546

Walks & Hits per IP

1. Bobby Mathews 1.199

Hits per 9 IP

1. Bobby Mathews 10.122

Bases On Balls per 9 IP

1. Bobby Mathews 0.672

Strikeouts per 9 IP

1. Bobby Mathews 1.394

Games Played

1. Bobby Mathews 187

2. Candy Cummings 55

3. Rynie Wolters 32

4. Phonney Martin 6

5. John Hatfield 3

John McMullin 3

7. Count Gedney 2

8. Bob Ferguson 1

Frank Fleet 1

Saves

1. John McMullin 1

Innings Pitched

1. Bobby Mathews 1646.2

2. Candy Cummings 497.0

3. Rynie Wolters 283.0

4. Phonney Martin 34.0

5. John McMullin 15.0

6. Count Gedney 11.0

7. Frank Fleet 9.0

8. John Hatfield 8.0

9. Bob Ferguson 1.0

Strikeouts

1. Bobby Mathews 255

2. Candy Cummings 45

3. Rynie Wolters 22

4. Count Gedney 2

5. Phonney Martin 1

John McMullin 1

Games Started

1. Bobby Mathews 187

2. Candy Cummings 55

3. Rynie Wolters 32

4. Frank Fleet 1

Count Gedney 1

Phonney Martin 1

John McMullin 1

Complete Games

1. Bobby Mathews 178

2. Candy Cummings 53

3. Rynie Wolters 31

4. Frank Fleet 1

Count Gedney 1

Phonney Martin 1

John McMullin 1

Shutouts

1. Bobby Mathews 9

2. Candy Cummings 3

3. Rynie Wolters 1

Home Runs

1. Bobby Mathews 12

2. Rynie Wolters 7

3. Candy Cummings 2

Bases on Balls

1. Bobby Mathews 123

2. Rynie Wolters 39

3. Candy Cummings 31

4. Phonney Martin 6

5. Frank Fleet 3

6. John McMullin 2

7. Count Gedney 1

Hits

1. Bobby Mathews 1852

2. Candy Cummings 604

3. Rynie Wolters 345

4. Phonney Martin 50

5. Frank Fleet 20

6. John McMullin 18

7. John Hatfield 11

8. Bob Ferguson 8

9. Count Gedney 7

Strikeouts / Base On Balls

1. Bobby Mathews 2.073

Home Runs per 9 IP

1. Bobby Mathews 0.066

Losses

1. Bobby Mathews 83

2. Candy Cummings 20

3. Rynie Wolters 16

4. Frank Fleet 1

John Hatfield 1

Phonney Martin 1

Earned Runs

1. Bobby Mathews 422

2. Candy Cummings 166

3. Rynie Wolters 108

4. Phonney Martin 13

5. Frank Fleet 10

6. John McMullin 6

7. Bob Ferguson 3

8. John Hatfield 2

9. Count Gedney 1

Wild Pitches

1. Bobby Mathews 83

2. Candy Cummings 15

Rynie Wolters 15

4. John McMullin 3

5. Bob Ferguson 2

Count Gedney 2

7. Phonney Martin 1

Batters Faced

1. Bobby Mathews 7310

2. Candy Cummings 2251

3. Rynie Wolters 1349

4. Phonney Martin 177

5. John McMullin 75

6. Frank Fleet 57

7. Count Gedney 43

8. John Hatfield 35

9. Bob Ferguson 14

Games Finished

1. Phonney Martin 5

2. John Hatfield 3

3. John McMullin 2

4. Count Gedney 1

Rynie Wolters 1

Adjusted ERA+

1. Bobby Mathews 109

Fielding Independent Pitching

1. Bobby Mathews 2.42

Adj. Pitching Runs

1. Bobby Mathews 53

2. Candy Cummings 34

3. Rynie Wolters 11

4. Count Gedney 2

Adj. Pitching Wins

1. Bobby Mathews 3.9

2. Candy Cummings 2.4

3. Rynie Wolters 0.7

4. Count Gedney 0.2

Data Notes

More Mutuals Pages

Mutuals History

Year-by-Year Stats

Leaders

People

Starters

Players

Honors

Hall of Fame

All-Stars

Other

New York Mutuals Top 10 Career Pitching Leaders

Career Top 10 Leaders

WAR for Pitchers †

Earned Run Average

Wins

Win-Loss %

Walks & Hits per IP

Hits per 9 IP

Bases On Balls per 9 IP

Strikeouts per 9 IP

Games Played

Saves

Innings Pitched

Strikeouts

Games Started

Complete Games

Shutouts

Home Runs

Bases on Balls

Hits

Strikeouts / Base On Balls

Home Runs per 9 IP

Losses

Earned Runs

Wild Pitches

Batters Faced

Games Finished

Adjusted ERA+

Fielding Independent Pitching

Adj. Pitching Runs

Adj. Pitching Wins

Data Notes

More Mutuals Pages

Full Site Menu

FAQs, Tip & Tricks