Single-Season Top 50 Leaders

WAR for Pitchers †
1. Bobby Mathews1874 13.6
2. Bobby Mathews1873 10.0
3. Candy Cummings1872 8.8
4. Bobby Mathews1875 8.3
5. Rynie Wolters1871 3.1
6. Count Gedney1875 0.5
7. John Hatfield1874 0.1
Phonney Martin1873 0.1
Earned Run Average
1. Bobby Mathews1874 1.9
2. Bobby Mathews1875 2.49
3. Bobby Mathews1873 2.58
4. Candy Cummings1872 3.01
5. Rynie Wolters1871 3.43
Wins
1. Bobby Mathews1874 42
2. Candy Cummings1872 33
3. Bobby Mathews1873 29
Bobby Mathews1875 29
5. Rynie Wolters1871 16
6. Count Gedney1875 1
John McMullin1872 1
Win-Loss %
1. Bobby Mathews1874 .656
2. Candy Cummings1872 .623
3. Bobby Mathews1873 .558
4. Rynie Wolters1871 .500
5. Bobby Mathews1875 .433
Walks & Hits per IP
1. Bobby Mathews1875 1.168
2. Bobby Mathews1874 1.199
3. Bobby Mathews1873 1.244
4. Candy Cummings1872 1.278
5. Rynie Wolters1871 1.357
Hits per 9 IP
1. Bobby Mathews1873 9.935
2. Bobby Mathews1874 10.152
3. Bobby Mathews1875 10.227
4. Candy Cummings1872 10.938
5. Rynie Wolters1871 10.972
Bases On Balls per 9 IP
1. Bobby Mathews1875 0.288
2. Candy Cummings1872 0.561
3. Bobby Mathews1874 0.638
4. Rynie Wolters1871 1.240
5. Bobby Mathews1873 1.260
Strikeouts per 9 IP
1. Bobby Mathews1873 1.605
2. Bobby Mathews1874 1.573
3. Bobby Mathews1875 1.079
4. Candy Cummings1872 0.815
5. Rynie Wolters1871 0.700
Games Played
1. Bobby Mathews1875 70
2. Bobby Mathews1874 65
3. Candy Cummings1872 55
4. Bobby Mathews1873 52
5. Rynie Wolters1871 32
6. Phonney Martin1873 6
7. John Hatfield1874 3
John McMullin1872 3
9. Count Gedney1875 2
10. Bob Ferguson1871 1
Frank Fleet1871 1
Saves
1. John McMullin1872 1
Innings Pitched
1. Bobby Mathews1875 625.2
2. Bobby Mathews1874 578.0
3. Candy Cummings1872 497.0
4. Bobby Mathews1873 443.0
5. Rynie Wolters1871 283.0
6. Phonney Martin1873 34.0
7. John McMullin1872 15.0
8. Count Gedney1875 11.0
9. Frank Fleet1871 9.0
10. John Hatfield1874 8.0
11. Bob Ferguson1871 1.0
Strikeouts
1. Bobby Mathews1874 101
2. Bobby Mathews1873 79
3. Bobby Mathews1875 75
4. Candy Cummings1872 45
5. Rynie Wolters1871 22
6. Count Gedney1875 2
7. Phonney Martin1873 1
John McMullin1872 1
Games Started
1. Bobby Mathews1875 70
2. Bobby Mathews1874 65
3. Candy Cummings1872 55
4. Bobby Mathews1873 52
5. Rynie Wolters1871 32
6. Frank Fleet1871 1
Count Gedney1875 1
Phonney Martin1873 1
John McMullin1872 1
Complete Games
1. Bobby Mathews1875 69
2. Bobby Mathews1874 62
3. Candy Cummings1872 53
4. Bobby Mathews1873 47
5. Rynie Wolters1871 31
6. Frank Fleet1871 1
Count Gedney1875 1
Phonney Martin1873 1
John McMullin1872 1
Shutouts
1. Bobby Mathews1874 4
2. Candy Cummings1872 3
Bobby Mathews1875 3
4. Bobby Mathews1873 2
5. Rynie Wolters1871 1
Home Runs
1. Rynie Wolters1871 7
2. Bobby Mathews1873 5
3. Bobby Mathews1875 4
4. Bobby Mathews1874 3
5. Candy Cummings1872 2
Bases on Balls
1. Bobby Mathews1873 62
2. Bobby Mathews1874 41
3. Rynie Wolters1871 39
4. Candy Cummings1872 31
5. Bobby Mathews1875 20
6. Phonney Martin1873 6
7. Frank Fleet1871 3
8. John McMullin1872 2
9. Count Gedney1875 1
Hits
1. Bobby Mathews1875 711
2. Bobby Mathews1874 652
3. Candy Cummings1872 604
4. Bobby Mathews1873 489
5. Rynie Wolters1871 345
6. Phonney Martin1873 50
7. Frank Fleet1871 20
8. John McMullin1872 18
9. John Hatfield1874 11
10. Bob Ferguson1871 8
11. Count Gedney1875 7
Strikeouts / Base On Balls
1. Bobby Mathews1875 3.75
2. Bobby Mathews1874 2.463
3. Candy Cummings1872 1.452
4. Bobby Mathews1873 1.274
5. Rynie Wolters1871 0.564
Home Runs per 9 IP
1. Candy Cummings1872 0.036
2. Bobby Mathews1874 0.047
3. Bobby Mathews1875 0.058
4. Bobby Mathews1873 0.102
5. Rynie Wolters1871 0.223
Losses
1. Bobby Mathews1875 38
2. Bobby Mathews1873 23
3. Bobby Mathews1874 22
4. Candy Cummings1872 20
5. Rynie Wolters1871 16
6. Frank Fleet1871 1
John Hatfield1874 1
Phonney Martin1873 1
Earned Runs
1. Bobby Mathews1875 173
2. Candy Cummings1872 166
3. Bobby Mathews1873 127
4. Bobby Mathews1874 122
5. Rynie Wolters1871 108
6. Phonney Martin1873 13
7. Frank Fleet1871 10
8. John McMullin1872 6
9. Bob Ferguson1871 3
10. John Hatfield1874 2
11. Count Gedney1875 1
Wild Pitches
1. Bobby Mathews1874 32
2. Bobby Mathews1875 28
3. Bobby Mathews1873 23
4. Candy Cummings1872 15
Rynie Wolters1871 15
6. John McMullin1872 3
7. Bob Ferguson1871 2
Count Gedney1875 2
9. Phonney Martin1873 1
Batters Faced
1. Bobby Mathews1875 2759
2. Bobby Mathews1874 2543
3. Candy Cummings1872 2251
4. Bobby Mathews1873 2008
5. Rynie Wolters1871 1349
6. Phonney Martin1873 177
7. John McMullin1872 75
8. Frank Fleet1871 57
9. Count Gedney1875 43
10. John Hatfield1874 35
11. Bob Ferguson1871 14
Games Finished
1. Phonney Martin1873 5
2. John Hatfield1874 3
3. John McMullin1872 2
4. Count Gedney1875 1
Rynie Wolters1871 1
Adjusted ERA+
1. Bobby Mathews1873 127
2. Bobby Mathews1874 117
3. Rynie Wolters1871 111
4. Candy Cummings1872 110
5. Bobby Mathews1875 90
Fielding Independent Pitching
1. Bobby Mathews1874 2.00
2. Bobby Mathews1875 2.18
3. Bobby Mathews1873 3.31
4. Candy Cummings1872 3.49
5. Rynie Wolters1871 4.16
Adj. Pitching Runs
1. Candy Cummings1872 34
2. Bobby Mathews1873 33
3. Bobby Mathews1874 27
4. Rynie Wolters1871 11
5. Count Gedney1875 2
Adj. Pitching Wins
1. Candy Cummings1872 2.4
Bobby Mathews1873 2.4
3. Bobby Mathews1874 2.1
4. Rynie Wolters1871 0.7
5. Count Gedney1875 0.2

Data Notes