Year-by-Year Top-Tens Leaders & Records for Replay Challenges

Create your own custom leaderboards

Become a Stathead today and run queries with our Season and Career Finders to see the best seasons in MLB history.

Become a Stathead

Top 10 Yearly Leaders

2026

1. Kurt Suzuki 41

2. Craig Albernaz 37

3. Dan Wilson 31

4. Stephen Vogt 28

5. Will Venable 27

Joe Espada 27

7. Blake Butera 26

8. John Schneider 25

Tony Vitello 25

Pat Murphy 25

2025

1. Mark Kotsay 55

2. Bruce Bochy 48

3. Craig Counsell 45

4. Bob Melvin 42

5. John Schneider 41

6. Oliver Marmol 40

7. Dave Roberts 39

8. Rocco Baldelli 38

Clayton McCullough 38

10. Torey Lovullo 37

2024

1. Rob Thomson 47

2. Stephen Vogt 46

3. Bob Melvin 45

4. Mark Kotsay 44

5. Brandon Hyde 42

Carlos Mendoza 42

7. David Bell 40

8. Craig Counsell 38

Skip Schumaker 38

10. John Schneider 36

Derek Shelton 36

Pat Murphy 36

Dave Roberts 36

2023

1. Kevin Cash 55

2. David Bell 53

3. John Schneider 52

4. Gabe Kapler 46

David Ross 46

Oliver Marmol 46

7. Brandon Hyde 41

Terry Francona 41

Derek Shelton 41

10. Pedro Grifol 40

2022

1. Rocco Baldelli 51

2. David Ross 47

3. Brandon Hyde 45

4. A.J. Hinch 43

5. Kevin Cash 42

Mike Matheny 42

7. Torey Lovullo 40

8. Terry Francona 39

9. Brian Snitker 37

David Bell 37

2021

1. Charlie Montoyo 25

2. Dave Roberts 22

3. Rocco Baldelli 21

4. Chris Woodward 20

Joe Maddon 20

6. Gabe Kapler 19

Jayce Tingler 19

8. David Ross 18

9. Kevin Cash 17

Mike Matheny 17

2020

1. Gabe Kapler 35

2. Rocco Baldelli 30

3. Charlie Montoyo 29

Joe Girardi 29

5. Terry Francona 26

Don Mattingly 26

7. Torey Lovullo 24

Brandon Hyde 24

Kevin Cash 24

10. David Bell 23

Bob Melvin 23

Joe Maddon 23

2019

1. Andy Green 50

2. Kevin Cash 48

3. Chris Woodward 46

4. Gabe Kapler 43

Don Mattingly 43

6. Charlie Montoyo 39

Rocco Baldelli 39

Mike Shildt 39

A.J. Hinch 39

10. Scott Servais 38

Bud Black 38

2018

1. Kevin Cash 54

2. Clint Hurdle 48

3. Bud Black 46

4. Brian Snitker 45

Torey Lovullo 45

Paul Molitor 45

7. Andy Green 44

Gabe Kapler 44

9. Alex Cora 43

Joe Maddon 43

2017

1. Jeff Banister 62

2. Kevin Cash 59

3. Joe Maddon 53

4. Mike Matheny 50

5. Clint Hurdle 49

6. Brian Snitker 47

7. John Gibbons 45

8. Craig Counsell 43

John Farrell 43

10. Andy Green 42

2016

1. Andy Green 57

2. Clint Hurdle 55

3. Mike Matheny 54

Walt Weiss 54

5. Don Mattingly 53

6. Jeff Banister 51

Bryan Price 51

8. John Gibbons 49

Kevin Cash 49

Bruce Bochy 49

Terry Francona 49

2015

1. Kevin Cash 54

2. John Farrell 52

3. Jeff Banister 50

4. Joe Maddon 48

A.J. Hinch 48

6. Walt Weiss 47

7. Fredi González 46

8. John Gibbons 45

9. Clint Hurdle 44

10. Paul Molitor 42

2014

1. Rick Renteria 57

2. Joe Maddon 49

3. John Gibbons 47

4. Ron Gardenhire 40

5. Brad Ausmus 39

6. Don Mattingly 38

7. Walt Weiss 37

8. Robin Ventura 36

Kirk Gibson 36

Mike Scioscia 36

More Leaders Pages

Leaders Index

More Leaders Pages

Other Challenges Leaders

Hall of Fame

JAWS

Times Leading League

Times In League Top 10

Award Shares

Other

Year-by-Year Top-Tens Leaders & Records for Replay Challenges

Top 10 Yearly Leaders

2026

2025

2024

2023

2022

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

More Leaders Pages

Full Site Menu

FAQs, Tip & Tricks