Single-Season Leaders & Records for Replay Challenges
POWERED BY
Create your own custom leaderboards
Become a Stathead today and run queries with our Season and Career Finders to see the best seasons in MLB history.
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Jeff Banister (53) | 62 | 2017 | 162 |
| 2. | Kevin Cash (39) | 59 | 2017 | 162 |
| 3. | Andy Green (38) | 57 | 2016 | 162 |
| Rick Renteria (52) | 57 | 2014 | 162 | |
| 5. | Kevin Cash (45) | 55 | 2023 | 162 |
| Clint Hurdle (58) | 55 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Mark Kotsay (49) | 55 | 2025 | 162 | |
| 8. | Kevin Cash (37) | 54 | 2015 | 162 |
| Kevin Cash (40) | 54 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Mike Matheny (45) | 54 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Walt Weiss (52) | 54 | 2016 | 162 | |
| 12. | David Bell (50) | 53 | 2023 | 162 |
| Joe Maddon (63) | 53 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Don Mattingly (55) | 53 | 2016 | 161 | |
| 15. | John Farrell (52) | 52 | 2015 | 162 |
| John Schneider (43) | 52 | 2023 | 162 | |
| 17. | Rocco Baldelli (40) | 51 | 2022 | 162 |
| Jeff Banister (52) | 51 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Bryan Price (54) | 51 | 2016 | 162 | |
| 20. | Jeff Banister (51) | 50 | 2015 | 162 |
| Andy Green (41) | 50 | 2019 | 154 | |
| Mike Matheny (46) | 50 | 2017 | 162 | |
| 23. | Bruce Bochy (61) | 49 | 2016 | 162 |
| Kevin Cash (38) | 49 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (57) | 49 | 2016 | 161 | |
| John Gibbons (54) | 49 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Clint Hurdle (59) | 49 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Joe Maddon (60) | 49 | 2014 | 162 | |
| 29. | Bruce Bochy (70) | 48 | 2025 | 162 |
| Kevin Cash (41) | 48 | 2019 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (41) | 48 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Clint Hurdle (60) | 48 | 2018 | 161 | |
| Joe Maddon (61) | 48 | 2015 | 162 | |
| 34. | Dusty Baker (67) | 47 | 2016 | 162 |
| Craig Counsell (45) | 47 | 2016 | 162 | |
| John Gibbons (52) | 47 | 2014 | 162 | |
| David Ross (45) | 47 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Brian Snitker (61) | 47 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Rob Thomson (60) | 47 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Walt Weiss (51) | 47 | 2015 | 162 | |
| 41. | Bud Black (61) | 46 | 2018 | 163 |
| John Farrell (53) | 46 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Fredi González (51) | 46 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Gabe Kapler (47) | 46 | 2023 | 159 | |
| Pete Mackanin (64) | 46 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Oliver Marmol (36) | 46 | 2023 | 162 | |
| David Ross (46) | 46 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Stephen Vogt (39) | 46 | 2024 | 161 | |
| Chris Woodward (43) | 46 | 2019 | 162 | |
| 50. | Craig Counsell (54) | 45 | 2025 | 162 |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| John Gibbons (53) | 45 | 2015 | 162 | |
| John Gibbons (55) | 45 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Brandon Hyde (48) | 45 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (52) | 45 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (62) | 45 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Paul Molitor+ (61) | 45 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Brian Snitker (62) | 45 | 2018 | 162 | |
| 58. | Andy Green (40) | 44 | 2018 | 162 |
| Clint Hurdle (57) | 44 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Gabe Kapler (42) | 44 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Mark Kotsay (48) | 44 | 2024 | 162 | |
| 62. | Alex Cora (42) | 43 | 2018 | 162 |
| Craig Counsell (46) | 43 | 2017 | 162 | |
| John Farrell (54) | 43 | 2017 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (48) | 43 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Gabe Kapler (43) | 43 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Joe Maddon (64) | 43 | 2018 | 163 | |
| Don Mattingly (58) | 43 | 2019 | 162 | |
| 69. | Kevin Cash (44) | 42 | 2022 | 162 |
| Andy Green (39) | 42 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Brandon Hyde (50) | 42 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Joe Maddon (62) | 42 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Mike Matheny (51) | 42 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (56) | 42 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (63) | 42 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Carlos Mendoza (44) | 42 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Paul Molitor+ (58) | 42 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Mike Scioscia (59) | 42 | 2018 | 162 | |
| 79. | Terry Francona (64) | 41 | 2023 | 162 |
| Brandon Hyde (49) | 41 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Don Mattingly (54) | 41 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Don Mattingly (57) | 41 | 2018 | 161 | |
| John Schneider (45) | 41 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Derek Shelton (52) | 41 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Robin Ventura (47) | 41 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Ned Yost (63) | 41 | 2018 | 162 | |
| 87. | Jeff Banister (54) | 40 | 2018 | 152 |
| David Bell (51) | 40 | 2024 | 157 | |
| Ron Gardenhire (56) | 40 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Joe Girardi (52) | 40 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Pedro Grifol (53) | 40 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (56) | 40 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Oliver Marmol (38) | 40 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Dave Martinez (53) | 40 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Rick Renteria (56) | 40 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Mike Scioscia (56) | 40 | 2015 | 162 | |
| 97. | Brad Ausmus (45) | 39 | 2014 | 162 |
| Rocco Baldelli (37) | 39 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Terry Collins (68) | 39 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (63) | 39 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| John Gibbons (56) | 39 | 2018 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (43) | 39 | 2017 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (45) | 39 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Mark Kotsay (47) | 39 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (57) | 39 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (61) | 39 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Charlie Montoyo (53) | 39 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Dave Roberts (46) | 39 | 2018 | 163 | |
| Dave Roberts (51) | 39 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Dave Roberts (53) | 39 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Mike Scioscia (58) | 39 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Mike Shildt (50) | 39 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Buck Showalter (60) | 39 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Kurt Suzuki (42) | 39 | 2026 | 90 | |
| Robin Ventura (48) | 39 | 2016 | 162 | |
| 116. | Rocco Baldelli (43) | 38 | 2025 | 162 |
| Bud Black (60) | 38 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Bud Black (62) | 38 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Bud Black (66) | 38 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Bruce Bochy (60) | 38 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Craig Counsell (53) | 38 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Don Mattingly (53) | 38 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Lloyd McClendon (56) | 38 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Clayton McCullough (45) | 38 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Bryan Price (55) | 38 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Skip Schumaker (44) | 38 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Mike Scioscia (57) | 38 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Scott Servais (52) | 38 | 2019 | 162 | |
| 129. | Craig Albernaz (43) | 37 | 2026 | 90 |
| Brad Ausmus (48) | 37 | 2017 | 162 | |
| David Bell (49) | 37 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (59) | 37 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Chip Hale (51) | 37 | 2016 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (42) | 37 | 2016 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (49) | 37 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (59) | 37 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Scott Servais (49) | 37 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Scott Servais (51) | 37 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Brian Snitker (66) | 37 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Walt Weiss (50) | 37 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Ned Yost (61) | 37 | 2016 | 162 | |
| 142. | Mickey Callaway (44) | 36 | 2019 | 162 |
| Kevin Cash (47) | 36 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Kirk Gibson (57) | 36 | 2014 | 159 | |
| Clint Hurdle (61) | 36 | 2019 | 161 | |
| Torey Lovullo (53) | 36 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Don Mattingly (61) | 36 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (60) | 36 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Carlos Mendoza (45) | 36 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Pat Murphy (65) | 36 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| Dave Roberts (45) | 36 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Dave Roberts (52) | 36 | 2024 | 162 | |
| John Schneider (44) | 36 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Mike Scioscia (55) | 36 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Derek Shelton (53) | 36 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Rob Thomson (59) | 36 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Robin Ventura (46) | 36 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Chris Woodward (46) | 36 | 2022 | 114 | |
| 159. | Bruce Bochy (59) | 35 | 2014 | 162 |
| Bruce Bochy (69) | 35 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Aaron Boone (45) | 35 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Kevin Cash (46) | 35 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Terry Collins (66) | 35 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Clint Hurdle (56) | 35 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Gabe Kapler (44) | 35 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Oliver Marmol (35) | 35 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Don Mattingly (56) | 35 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Lloyd McClendon (55) | 35 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Matt Quatraro (50) | 35 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Rick Renteria (55) | 35 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Dave Roberts (44) | 35 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Scott Servais (56) | 35 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Stephen Vogt (40) | 35 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Ned Yost (59) | 35 | 2014 | 162 | |
| 175. | Brad Ausmus (47) | 34 | 2016 | 161 |
| Rocco Baldelli (41) | 34 | 2023 | 162 | |
| David Bell (46) | 34 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Craig Counsell (47) | 34 | 2018 | 163 | |
| Joe Espada (48) | 34 | 2024 | 161 | |
| John Farrell (51) | 34 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (66) | 34 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Ron Gardenhire (61) | 34 | 2019 | 161 | |
| Fredi González (50) | 34 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Chip Hale (50) | 34 | 2015 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (44) | 34 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Mark Kotsay (46) | 34 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (54) | 34 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Jim Riggleman (65) | 34 | 2018 | 144 | |
| Dave Roberts (47) | 34 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Scott Servais (50) | 34 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Ron Washington (62) | 34 | 2014 | 140 | |
| Ned Yost (62) | 34 | 2017 | 162 | |
| 193. | Bud Black (57) | 33 | 2014 | 162 |
| Aaron Boone (49) | 33 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Aaron Boone (52) | 33 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Alex Cora (43) | 33 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Craig Counsell (51) | 33 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (55) | 33 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Oliver Marmol (37) | 33 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Mike Matheny (47) | 33 | 2018 | 93 | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| Bryan Price (53) | 33 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Matt Quatraro (49) | 33 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Dave Roberts (50) | 33 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Buck Showalter (66) | 33 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Brian Snitker (60) | 33 | 2016 | 124 | |
| Ned Yost (60) | 33 | 2015 | 162 | |
| 207. | Dusty Baker (68) | 32 | 2017 | 162 |
| Rocco Baldelli (42) | 32 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Bud Black (67) | 32 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (58) | 32 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Ron Gardenhire (60) | 32 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (51) | 32 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Joe Maddon (65) | 32 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Mike Matheny (43) | 32 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (55) | 32 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Ryne Sandberg+ (54) | 32 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Ron Washington (72) | 32 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Matt Williams (48) | 32 | 2014 | 162 | |
| 219. | Brad Ausmus (50) | 31 | 2019 | 162 |
| Bruce Bochy (62) | 31 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Bruce Bochy (63) | 31 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Aaron Boone (51) | 31 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Terry Collins (65) | 31 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Gabe Kapler (46) | 31 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Dave Martinez (54) | 31 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Mike Matheny (44) | 31 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Derek Shelton (51) | 31 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Rob Thomson (58) | 31 | 2022 | 111 | |
| Dan Wilson (57) | 31 | 2026 | 90 | |
| 230. | Rocco Baldelli (38) | 30 | 2020 | 60 |
| Aaron Boone (50) | 30 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Joe Girardi (49) | 30 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Joe Girardi (50) | 30 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Brandon Hyde (45) | 30 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Don Kelly (45) | 30 | 2025 | 124 | |
| Dave Martinez (57) | 30 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Buck Showalter (59) | 30 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Brian Snitker (63) | 30 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Rob Thomson (61) | 30 | 2025 | 162 | |
| 240. | Dusty Baker (73) | 29 | 2022 | 162 |
| Bruce Bochy (68) | 29 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Mickey Callaway (43) | 29 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Craig Counsell (52) | 29 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Joe Girardi (55) | 29 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Pete Mackanin (65) | 29 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Dave Martinez (58) | 29 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (53) | 29 | 2015 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (57) | 29 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Charlie Montoyo (54) | 29 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Skip Schumaker (43) | 29 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| Matt Williams (49) | 29 | 2015 | 162 | |
| 252. | Dusty Baker (74) | 28 | 2023 | 162 |
| Bud Black (65) | 28 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Bruce Bochy (64) | 28 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Terry Collins (67) | 28 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Craig Counsell (48) | 28 | 2019 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (56) | 28 | 2015 | 161 | |
| Joe Girardi (51) | 28 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Dave Martinez (59) | 28 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Paul Molitor+ (59) | 28 | 2016 | 162 | |
| Paul Molitor+ (60) | 28 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Phil Nevin (52) | 28 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Rick Renteria (57) | 28 | 2019 | 161 | |
| Mike Shildt (55) | 28 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Mike Shildt (56) | 28 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Buck Showalter (58) | 28 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Brian Snitker (69) | 28 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Stephen Vogt (41) | 28 | 2026 | 90 | |
| Ned Yost (64) | 28 | 2019 | 162 | |
| 270. | Brad Ausmus (46) | 27 | 2015 | 161 |
| Joe Espada (49) | 27 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Terry Francona (60) | 27 | 2019 | 162 | |
| A.J. Hinch (51) | 27 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (58) | 27 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Pat Murphy (56) | 27 | 2015 | 96 | |
| Bo Porter (41) | 27 | 2014 | 138 | |
| Bryan Price (52) | 27 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Mike Redmond (43) | 27 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Ron Roenicke (57) | 27 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Buck Showalter (62) | 27 | 2018 | 162 | |
| Buck Showalter (67) | 27 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Ron Washington (73) | 27 | 2025 | 74 | |
| 283. | Blake Butera (33) | 26 | 2026 | 90 |
| Joe Espada (50) | 26 | 2026 | 91 | |
| Terry Francona (61) | 26 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Don Mattingly (59) | 26 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Bob Melvin (52) | 26 | 2014 | 162 | |
| Scott Servais (57) | 26 | 2024 | 128 | |
| Buck Showalter (61) | 26 | 2017 | 162 | |
| Will Venable (42) | 26 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Will Venable (43) | 26 | 2026 | 88 | |
| Dan Wilson (56) | 26 | 2025 | 162 | |
| 293. | Craig Counsell (44) | 25 | 2015 | 137 |
| Charlie Montoyo (55) | 25 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Pat Murphy (67) | 25 | 2026 | 87 | |
| Phil Nevin (51) | 25 | 2022 | 106 | |
| John Schneider (46) | 25 | 2026 | 89 | |
| Brian Snitker (67) | 25 | 2023 | 162 | |
| Brian Snitker (68) | 25 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Tony Vitello (47) | 25 | 2026 | 88 | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| 301. | Kevin Cash (42) | 24 | 2020 | 60 |
| Alex Cora (48) | 24 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Brandon Hyde (46) | 24 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Torey Lovullo (54) | 24 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Charlie Montoyo (56) | 24 | 2022 | 88 | |
| Pat Murphy (66) | 24 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Matt Quatraro (51) | 24 | 2025 | 162 | |
| John Schneider (42) | 24 | 2022 | 74 | |
| 309. | David Bell (47) | 23 | 2020 | 60 |
| Craig Counsell (55) | 23 | 2026 | 89 | |
| A.J. Hinch (50) | 23 | 2024 | 162 | |
| Joe Maddon (66) | 23 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Clayton McCullough (46) | 23 | 2026 | 90 | |
| Bob Melvin (58) | 23 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Warren Schaeffer (41) | 23 | 2026 | 90 | |
| Craig Stammen (42) | 23 | 2026 | 88 | |
| 317. | Aaron Boone (46) | 22 | 2019 | 162 |
| Alex Cora (49) | 22 | 2025 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (60) | 22 | 2026 | 88 | |
| Matt Quatraro (52) | 22 | 2026 | 89 | |
| Dave Roberts (49) | 22 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Skip Schumaker (46) | 22 | 2026 | 89 | |
| 323. | Rocco Baldelli (39) | 21 | 2021 | 162 |
| Dan Jennings (54) | 21 | 2015 | 124 | |
| Pete Mackanin (63) | 21 | 2015 | 88 | |
| Tony Mansolino (42) | 21 | 2025 | 119 | |
| Oliver Marmol (39) | 21 | 2026 | 86 | |
| Dave Martinez (60) | 21 | 2025 | 90 | |
| Ron Roenicke (63) | 21 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Chris Woodward (44) | 21 | 2020 | 60 | |
| 331. | Aaron Boone (53) | 20 | 2026 | 88 |
| Terry Francona (67) | 20 | 2026 | 88 | |
| Tony La Russa+ (77) | 20 | 2022 | 128 | |
| Joe Maddon (67) | 20 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Derek Shelton (55) | 20 | 2026 | 90 | |
| Jayce Tingler (39) | 20 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Chris Woodward (45) | 20 | 2021 | 162 | |
| 338. | Alex Cora (47) | 19 | 2023 | 162 |
| Gabe Kapler (45) | 19 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Don Kelly (46) | 19 | 2026 | 90 | |
| Dave Martinez (55) | 19 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Dave Roberts (48) | 19 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Warren Schaeffer (40) | 19 | 2025 | 122 | |
| Scott Servais (55) | 19 | 2022 | 162 | |
| Jayce Tingler (40) | 19 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Walt Weiss (62) | 19 | 2026 | 87 | |
| 347. | Alex Cora (46) | 18 | 2022 | 162 |
| Mark Kotsay (50) | 18 | 2026 | 89 | |
| Don Mattingly (65) | 18 | 2026 | 61 | |
| Carlos Mendoza (46) | 18 | 2026 | 81 | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| Luis Rojas (38) | 18 | 2020 | 60 | |
| David Ross (44) | 18 | 2021 | 162 | |
| 353. | Bud Black (63) | 17 | 2020 | 60 |
| Kevin Cash (43) | 17 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Kevin Cash (48) | 17 | 2026 | 86 | |
| Ron Gardenhire (62) | 17 | 2020 | 50 | |
| A.J. Hinch (52) | 17 | 2026 | 89 | |
| Joe Maddon (68) | 17 | 2022 | 56 | |
| Mike Matheny (50) | 17 | 2021 | 162 | |
| David Ross (43) | 17 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Ryne Sandberg+ (55) | 17 | 2015 | 74 | |
| 362. | Bud Black (64) | 16 | 2021 | 161 |
| Don Mattingly (60) | 16 | 2021 | 162 | |
| 364. | Bud Black (58) | 15 | 2015 | 65 |
| Joe Girardi (56) | 15 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Brandon Hyde (51) | 15 | 2025 | 43 | |
| Rick Renteria (58) | 15 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Derek Shelton (50) | 15 | 2021 | 162 | |
| 369. | Miguel Cairo (51) | 14 | 2025 | 72 |
| Dave Martinez (56) | 14 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Luis Rojas (39) | 14 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Mike Shildt (49) | 14 | 2018 | 69 | |
| Brian Snitker (64) | 14 | 2020 | 60 | |
| 374. | Dusty Baker (71) | 13 | 2020 | 60 |
| Tony Beasley (55) | 13 | 2022 | 48 | |
| David Bell (48) | 13 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Pedro Grifol (54) | 13 | 2024 | 117 | |
| Dave Roberts (54) | 13 | 2026 | 90 | |
| 379. | Dusty Baker (72) | 12 | 2021 | 162 |
| Aaron Boone (47) | 12 | 2020 | 60 | |
| A.J. Hinch (47) | 12 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Scott Servais (53) | 12 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Mike Shildt (51) | 12 | 2020 | 58 | |
| Brian Snitker (65) | 12 | 2021 | 161 | |
| Chad Tracy (40) | 12 | 2026 | 60 | |
| 386. | Terry Francona (62) | 11 | 2021 | 162 |
| Joe Girardi (57) | 11 | 2022 | 51 | |
| Mike Shildt (52) | 11 | 2021 | 162 | |
| 389. | Bud Black (68) | 10 | 2025 | 40 |
| Aaron Boone (48) | 10 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Alex Cora (45) | 10 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Craig Counsell (49) | 10 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Brandon Hyde (47) | 10 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Torey Lovullo (55) | 10 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Bob Melvin (59) | 10 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Mike Redmond (44) | 10 | 2015 | 38 | |
| Scott Servais (54) | 10 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Derek Shelton (49) | 10 | 2020 | 60 | |
| Derek Shelton (54) | 10 | 2025 | 38 | |
| 400. | Tim Bogar (47) | 9 | 2014 | 22 |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Replay Challenges | Year | Games |
| Fredi González (52) | 9 | 2016 | 37 | |
| Tony La Russa+ (76) | 9 | 2021 | 162 | |
| 403. | Grady Sizemore (41) | 8 | 2024 | 45 |
| 404. | Alex Cora (50) | 7 | 2026 | 27 |
| Craig Counsell (50) | 7 | 2021 | 162 | |
| Mike Matheny (49) | 7 | 2020 | 60 | |
| 407. | Miguel Cairo (48) | 6 | 2022 | 34 |
| 408. | Ron Roenicke (58) | 5 | 2015 | 25 |
| Dan Wilson (55) | 5 | 2024 | 34 | |
| 410. | Rod Barajas (43) | 4 | 2019 | 8 |
| Tom Lawless (57) | 4 | 2014 | 24 | |
| Bryan Price (56) | 4 | 2018 | 18 | |
| 413. | Don Wakamatsu (55) | 2 | 2018 | 10 |
| 414. | Freddie Benavides (58) | 1 | 2024 | 5 |
| Andy Green (48) | 1 | 2026 | 8 | |
| Lloyd McClendon (61) | 1 | 2020 | 8 | |
| Ray Montgomery (55) | 1 | 2025 | 88 | |
| Dave Roberts (43) | 1 | 2015 | 1 | |
| Rob Thomson (62) | 1 | 2026 | 28 | |
| Alan Trammell+ (56) | 1 | 2014 | 3 |
