Year-by-Year Top-Tens Leaders & Records for Wins Above Replacement

Top 10 Yearly Leaders

2019
1. Cody Bellinger 9.1
2. Alex Bregman 9.1
3. Marcus Semien 8.9
4. Matt Chapman 8.3
5. Mike Trout 8.2
6. Jacob deGrom 8.2
7. Mike Minor 7.7
8. Lance Lynn 7.5
9. Justin Verlander 7.3
10. Ketel Marte 7.2
2018
1. Mookie Betts 10.6
2. Jacob deGrom 10.3
3. Mike Trout 10.2
4. Aaron Nola 9.7
5. Max Scherzer 9.2
6. Matt Chapman 8.3
7. Kyle Freeland 8.0
8. Francisco Lindor 7.8
9. Jose Ramirez 7.6
10. Alex Bregman 7.3
2017
1. Joey Votto 8.1
2. Giancarlo Stanton 8.0
3. Aaron Judge 7.9
Corey Kluber 7.9
5. Andrelton Simmons 7.8
6. Jose Altuve 7.6
7. Max Scherzer 7.5
8. Jose Ramirez 7.0
9. Mike Trout 6.7
10. Nolan Arenado 6.6
2016
1. Mike Trout 10.5
2. Mookie Betts 9.5
3. Jose Altuve 7.9
4. Justin Verlander 7.4
5. Manny Machado 7.3
Robinson Cano 7.3
7. Kris Bryant 7.3
8. Josh Donaldson 7.2
9. Carlos Correa 7.0
10. Adrian Beltre 6.7
2015
1. Bryce Harper 9.7
2. Mike Trout 9.6
3. Zack Greinke 9.5
4. Jake Arrieta 8.6
5. Paul Goldschmidt 8.3
6. Joey Votto 7.8
7. Manny Machado 7.5
8. Max Scherzer 7.4
9. Clayton Kershaw 7.3
10. Josh Donaldson 7.1
2014
1. Clayton Kershaw 8.2
2. Corey Kluber 8.1
3. Mike Trout 7.7
4. Michael Brantley 7.0
5. Josh Donaldson 6.9
6. Jose Bautista 6.9
7. Cole Hamels 6.6
8. Johnny Cueto 6.6
9. Giancarlo Stanton 6.5
10. Anthony Rendon 6.5
2013
1. Mike Trout 8.9
2. Clayton Kershaw 8.6
3. Andrew McCutchen 7.8
4. Carlos Gomez 7.6
5. Miguel Cabrera 7.5
6. Josh Donaldson 7.2
7. Chris Davis 7.1
8. Hisashi Iwakuma 7.0
9. Cliff Lee 6.8
10. Joey Votto 6.6
2012
1. Mike Trout 10.5
2. Robinson Cano 8.4
3. Justin Verlander 8.0
4. Buster Posey 7.6
5. Adrian Beltre 7.2
6. Yadier Molina 7.2
7. Miguel Cabrera 7.1
8. David Wright 7.1
9. Andrew McCutchen 6.9
10. Ryan Braun 6.9
2011
1. Cliff Lee 9.0
2. Justin Verlander 8.6
Roy Halladay 8.6
4. Jacoby Ellsbury 8.3
5. Jose Bautista 8.3
6. Matt Kemp 8.0
7. Dustin Pedroia 8.0
8. Ryan Braun 7.7
9. Miguel Cabrera 7.6
10. Ben Zobrist 7.6
2010
1. Josh Hamilton 8.7
2. Roy Halladay 8.3
3. Evan Longoria 8.2
4. Robinson Cano 8.1
5. Adrian Beltre 7.8
6. Albert Pujols 7.5
7. Brett Gardner 7.4
8. Ubaldo Jimenez 7.3
9. Felix Hernandez 7.1
10. Carl Crawford 7.0
Joey Votto 7.0
2009
1. Zack Greinke 10.4
2. Albert Pujols 9.7
3. Ben Zobrist 8.6
4. Chase Utley 8.2
5. Joe Mauer 7.8
6. Chone Figgins 7.7
7. Tim Lincecum 7.4
8. Hanley Ramirez 7.4
9. Josh Johnson 7.4
10. Ryan Zimmerman 7.3
2008
1. Albert Pujols 9.2
2. Chase Utley 9.0
3. Tim Lincecum 8.0
4. Mark Teixeira 7.8
5. Nick Markakis 7.4
6. Chipper Jones 7.3
7. CC Sabathia 7.2
8. Johan Santana 7.2
9. Carlos Beltran 7.0
10. Dustin Pedroia 6.9
2007
1. Alex Rodriguez 9.4
2. Albert Pujols 8.7
3. David Wright 8.3
4. Chase Utley 7.8
5. Chipper Jones 7.6
6. Curtis Granderson 7.6
7. Magglio Ordonez 7.3
8. Carlos Pena 7.2
9. Jake Peavy 6.8
10. Troy Tulowitzki 6.8
2006
1. Albert Pujols 8.5
2. Carlos Beltran 8.2
3. Johan Santana 7.6
4. Chase Utley 7.3
5. Bronson Arroyo 7.0
6. Brandon Webb 6.9
7. Grady Sizemore 6.6
8. Vernon Wells 6.2
9. Alfonso Soriano 6.1
10. Roy Oswalt 6.0
2005
1. Alex Rodriguez 9.4
2. Albert Pujols 8.4
3. Dontrelle Willis 8.3
4. Roger Clemens 8.2
5. Derrek Lee 7.7
6. Brian Roberts 7.3
Chase Utley 7.3
8. Mark Teixeira 7.2
9. Johan Santana 7.2
10. Andruw Jones 6.7
2004
1. Barry Bonds 10.6
2. Adrian Beltre 9.6
3. Ichiro Suzuki 9.2
Scott Rolen 9.2
5. Johan Santana 8.8
6. Albert Pujols 8.5
7. Todd Helton 8.3
J.D. Drew 8.3
9. Randy Johnson 8.2
10. Curt Schilling 7.7
2003
1. Barry Bonds 9.2
2. Albert Pujols 8.7
3. Alex Rodriguez 8.4
4. Roy Halladay 8.0
5. Pedro Martinez 8.0
6. Mark Prior 7.9
7. Marcus Giles 7.9
8. Tim Hudson 7.5
9. Esteban Loaiza 7.2
10. Gary Sheffield 6.8
2002
1. Barry Bonds 11.8
2. Randy Johnson 10.5
3. Alex Rodriguez 8.8
4. Curt Schilling 8.5
5. Jim Thome 7.4
6. Derek Lowe 7.3
7. Roy Halladay 7.1
8. Barry Zito 7.1
Jeff Kent 7.1
10. Vladimir Guerrero 7.1
Jason Giambi 7.1
2001
1. Barry Bonds 11.9
2. Sammy Sosa 10.3
3. Randy Johnson 9.5
4. Jason Giambi 9.2
5. Bret Boone 8.8
6. Curt Schilling 8.5
7. Alex Rodriguez 8.3
8. Luis Gonzalez 7.9
9. Larry Walker 7.8
10. Todd Helton 7.8
2000
1. Pedro Martinez 11.7
2. Alex Rodriguez 10.4
3. Todd Helton 8.9
4. Darin Erstad 8.4
5. Andruw Jones 8.2
6. Randy Johnson 8.1
7. Troy Glaus 7.8
8. Jason Giambi 7.8
9. Barry Bonds 7.7
10. Nomar Garciaparra 7.4
1999
1. Pedro Martinez 9.8
2. Randy Johnson 8.6
3. Derek Jeter 8.0
4. Mike Hampton 7.9
5. Jeff Bagwell 7.4
6. Roberto Alomar 7.4
7. Manny Ramirez 7.3
8. Andruw Jones 7.1
9. Randy Velarde 7.0
10. Chipper Jones 6.9
1998
1. Kevin Brown 9.1
2. Alex Rodriguez 8.5
3. Roger Clemens 8.1
4. Barry Bonds 8.1
5. John Olerud 7.6
6. Derek Jeter 7.5
7. Mark McGwire 7.5
8. Kenny Rogers 7.5
9. Andruw Jones 7.4
Vladimir Guerrero 7.4
1997
1. Roger Clemens 12.1
2. Larry Walker 9.8
3. Craig Biggio 9.4
4. Ken Griffey Jr. 9.1
5. Pedro Martinez 8.8
6. Mike Piazza 8.7
7. Andy Pettitte 8.4
8. Barry Bonds 8.2
9. Randy Johnson 8.0
10. Justin Thompson 7.7
1996
1. Ken Griffey Jr. 9.7
2. Barry Bonds 9.7
3. Alex Rodriguez 9.4
4. Chuck Knoblauch 8.7
5. Pat Hentgen 8.6
6. Bernard Gilkey 8.1
7. Ellis Burks 7.9
8. Kevin Brown 7.8
9. Roger Clemens 7.8
10. John Smoltz 7.7
1995
1. Greg Maddux 9.6
2. Randy Johnson 8.6
3. John Valentin 8.3
4. Barry Bonds 7.5
5. Edgar Martinez 7.0
6. David Cone 7.0
7. Albert Belle 7.0
8. Chuck Knoblauch 6.7
9. Reggie Sanders 6.6
10. Tim Salmon 6.6
1994
1. Greg Maddux 8.7
2. Jeff Bagwell 8.2
3. Kenny Lofton 7.2
4. Ken Griffey Jr. 6.9
5. David Cone 6.9
6. Frank Thomas 6.4
7. Barry Bonds 6.2
8. Roger Clemens 6.0
9. Bret Saberhagen 5.7
10. Albert Belle 5.7
1993
1. Jose Rijo 10.1
2. Barry Bonds 9.9
3. Kevin Appier 9.3
4. Ken Griffey Jr. 8.8
5. Mark Langston 8.5
6. John Olerud 7.8
7. Kenny Lofton 7.6
8. David Cone 7.2
9. Chuck Finley 7.1
10. Mike Piazza 7.0
1992
1. Greg Maddux 9.4
2. Barry Bonds 9.0
3. Roger Clemens 8.7
4. Mike Mussina 8.2
5. Kevin Appier 8.0
6. Ryne Sandberg 7.8
7. Kirby Puckett 7.1
8. Frank Thomas 7.0
9. Darren Daulton 6.9
10. Roberto Alomar 6.6
1991
1. Cal Ripken Jr. 11.5
2. Tom Glavine 9.2
3. Barry Bonds 8.0
4. Roger Clemens 7.9
5. Jim Abbott 7.6
6. Mark Langston 7.3
7. Ken Griffey Jr. 7.1
8. Tom Candiotti 7.1
9. Ryne Sandberg 7.0
10. Frank Thomas 7.0
1990
1. Roger Clemens 10.4
2. Rickey Henderson 9.9
3. Barry Bonds 9.7
4. Lenny Dykstra 8.9
5. Chuck Finley 7.7
6. Cal Ripken Jr. 7.5
7. Ryne Sandberg 7.1
8. Ed Whitson 7.0
9. Julio Franco 6.8
10. Alan Trammell 6.7
1989
1. Bret Saberhagen 9.7
2. Lonnie Smith 8.8
3. Rickey Henderson 8.7
4. Will Clark 8.6
5. Wade Boggs 8.4
6. Barry Bonds 8.0
7. Orel Hershiser 7.3
8. Ozzie Smith 7.3
9. Kevin Mitchell 6.9
10. Howard Johnson 6.9
1988
1. Wade Boggs 8.3
2. Kirby Puckett 7.8
3. Mark Gubicza 7.7
4. Frank Viola 7.7
5. Mike Greenwell 7.5
6. Teddy Higuera 7.4
7. Jose Canseco 7.3
8. Orel Hershiser 7.1
Roger Clemens 7.1
10. Barry Larkin 7.0
1987
1. Roger Clemens 9.4
2. Tony Gwynn 8.5
3. Wade Boggs 8.3
4. Alan Trammell 8.2
5. Frank Viola 8.1
6. Bret Saberhagen 8.0
7. Eric Davis 7.9
8. Dale Murphy 7.7
9. Jimmy Key 7.4
Bob Welch 7.4
1986
1. Teddy Higuera 9.4
2. Roger Clemens 8.8
3. Mike Scott 8.2
4. Wade Boggs 8.0
5. Jesse Barfield 7.6
6. Rick Rhoden 7.6
7. Mark Eichhorn 7.3
8. Don Mattingly 7.2
9. Tony Gwynn 6.7
10. Cal Ripken Jr. 6.6
1985
1. Dwight Gooden 13.3
2. Rickey Henderson 9.9
3. Wade Boggs 9.1
4. George Brett 8.3
5. John Tudor 8.2
6. Willie McGee 8.2
7. Pedro Guerrero 8.0
8. Tim Raines 7.6
9. Bret Saberhagen 7.1
10. Gary Carter 6.9
1984
1. Cal Ripken Jr. 10.0
2. Ryne Sandberg 8.6
3. Dave Stieb 7.9
4. Gary Carter 7.5
5. Lloyd Moseby 7.3
6. Bert Blyleven 7.2
7. Eddie Murray 7.1
8. Mike Schmidt 7.0
9. Alan Trammell 6.8
10. Tim Raines 6.5
1983
1. Cal Ripken Jr. 8.2
2. Wade Boggs 7.8
3. John Denny 7.5
4. Dickie Thon 7.4
5. Robin Yount 7.3
6. Dale Murphy 7.1
7. Gary Carter 7.1
8. Dave Stieb 7.0
9. Rickey Henderson 6.9
10. Mike Schmidt 6.9
1982
1. Robin Yount 10.6
2. Gary Carter 8.6
3. Andre Dawson 7.9
4. Steve Rogers 7.7
5. Dave Stieb 7.6
6. Mario Soto 7.6
7. Doug DeCinces 7.6
8. Mike Schmidt 7.4
9. Pedro Guerrero 6.8
10. Rickey Henderson 6.7
1981
1. Mike Schmidt 7.7
2. Andre Dawson 7.5
3. Dwight Evans 6.7
4. Rickey Henderson 6.7
5. Buddy Bell 6.2
6. Bert Blyleven 5.6
7. Steve Carlton 5.5
8. Bobby Grich 5.5
9. Fernando Valenzuela 5.3
10. Nolan Ryan 5.1
1980
1. Steve Carlton 10.1
2. George Brett 9.4
3. Mike Schmidt 8.9
4. Rickey Henderson 8.8
5. Willie Wilson 8.6
6. Robin Yount 7.1
7. Britt Burns 7.0
8. Dwayne Murphy 6.9
9. Andre Dawson 6.8
10. Cecil Cooper 6.8
1979
1. Fred Lynn 8.9
2. George Brett 8.6
3. Dave Winfield 8.3
4. Mike Schmidt 7.9
5. Phil Niekro 7.7
6. Darrell Porter 7.6
7. Keith Hernandez 7.6
8. Jerry Koosman 7.2
9. Dennis Eckersley 7.2
10. Buddy Bell 6.9
1978
1. Phil Niekro 10.4
2. Ron Guidry 9.6
3. Mike Caldwell 8.2
4. Jim Rice 7.6
5. Amos Otis 7.4
6. Dennis Eckersley 7.3
7. Dave Parker 7.0
8. Doug DeCinces 6.8
9. Dave Goltz 6.6
10. Jim Palmer 6.4
1977
1. Rod Carew 9.7
2. Rick Reuschel 9.6
3. Mike Schmidt 8.9
4. Phil Niekro 8.5
5. George Foster 8.4
6. Tom Seaver 8.4
7. Frank Tanana 8.3
8. John Candelaria 7.9
9. Nolan Ryan 7.8
10. George Brett 7.6
1976
1. Joe Morgan 9.6
2. Mark Fidrych 9.6
3. Mike Schmidt 8.0
4. Graig Nettles 8.0
5. Vida Blue 7.6
6. George Brett 7.5
7. Frank Tanana 7.5
8. Pete Rose 7.0
9. Phil Niekro 6.9
10. Rod Carew 6.8
1975
1. Joe Morgan 11.0
2. Jim Palmer 8.4
3. Rich Gossage 8.2
4. Tom Seaver 8.2
5. Catfish Hunter 8.1
6. Rod Carew 7.8
7. Jim Kaat 7.7
8. Mike Schmidt 7.7
9. Randy Jones 7.6
10. Fred Lynn 7.4
1974
1. Mike Schmidt 9.7
2. Jon Matlack 8.7
3. Joe Morgan 8.6
4. Gaylord Perry 8.5
5. Phil Niekro 8.0
6. Johnny Bench 7.9
7. Bert Blyleven 7.8
8. Fergie Jenkins 7.8
9. Jim Wynn 7.7
Luis Tiant 7.7
1973
1. Tom Seaver 11.0
2. Bert Blyleven 9.7
3. Joe Morgan 9.3
4. Darrell Evans 9.0
5. Bobby Grich 8.3
6. Pete Rose 8.3
7. John Hiller 7.9
8. Bobby Bonds 7.8
9. Reggie Jackson 7.8
Gaylord Perry 7.8
1972
1. Steve Carlton 12.5
2. Gaylord Perry 11.0
3. Wilbur Wood 10.3
4. Joe Morgan 9.3
5. Dick Allen 8.6
6. Johnny Bench 8.6
7. Bobby Murcer 8.2
8. Cesar Cedeno 8.0
9. Bob Gibson 7.8
10. Carlton Fisk 7.3
1971
1. Fergie Jenkins 11.8
2. Wilbur Wood 11.0
3. Tom Seaver 10.9
4. Mickey Lolich 8.6
5. Vida Blue 8.5
6. Willie Stargell 7.9
7. Dave Roberts 7.8
8. Graig Nettles 7.5
9. Roberto Clemente 7.3
10. Hank Aaron 7.2
1970
1. Bob Gibson 10.1
2. Carl Yastrzemski 9.5
3. Sam McDowell 7.9
4. Jim Fregosi 7.7
5. Johnny Bench 7.4
6. Tommy Harper 7.4
7. Tony Perez 7.2
8. Gaylord Perry 7.2
9. Tony Oliva 7.0
10. Fergie Jenkins 6.9
1969
1. Bob Gibson 11.3
2. Rico Petrocelli 10.0
3. Reggie Jackson 9.2
4. Larry Dierker 8.4
5. Sal Bando 8.3
6. Hank Aaron 8.1
Willie McCovey 8.1
8. Bill Hands 7.9
9. Denny McLain 7.8
10. Juan Marichal 7.6
1968
1. Bob Gibson 11.9
2. Carl Yastrzemski 10.5
3. Brooks Robinson 8.4
4. Roberto Clemente 8.2
5. Luis Tiant 7.9
6. Denny McLain 7.4
7. Tom Seaver 7.0
8. Willie McCovey 7.0
9. Bill Freehan 6.9
10. Hank Aaron 6.8
1967
1. Carl Yastrzemski 12.5
2. Ron Santo 9.8
3. Roberto Clemente 8.9
4. Hank Aaron 8.5
5. Jim Bunning 8.0
6. Brooks Robinson 7.7
7. Al Kaline 7.5
8. Orlando Cepeda 6.8
9. Paul Blair 6.8
10. Tom Seaver 6.7
1966
1. Juan Marichal 9.8
2. Sandy Koufax 9.7
3. Willie Mays 9.0
4. Jim Bunning 9.0
5. Ron Santo 8.9
6. Roberto Clemente 8.2
7. Hank Aaron 7.9
8. Earl Wilson 7.7
9. Frank Robinson 7.7
10. Dick Allen 7.5
1965
1. Willie Mays 11.2
2. Juan Marichal 10.5
3. Jim Maloney 9.0
4. Sandy Koufax 8.6
5. Jim Bunning 8.3
6. Sam McDowell 7.9
7. Hank Aaron 7.9
8. Billy Williams 7.7
9. Ron Santo 7.7
10. Bob Gibson 7.6
1964
1. Willie Mays 11.0
2. Ron Santo 8.9
3. Dick Allen 8.8
4. Dean Chance 8.7
5. Willie Davis 8.3
6. Don Drysdale 8.3
7. Brooks Robinson 8.1
8. Jim Fregosi 7.9
9. Frank Robinson 7.9
10. Ron Hansen 7.7
1963
1. Willie Mays 10.6
2. Dick Ellsworth 9.9
3. Sandy Koufax 9.9
4. Hank Aaron 9.1
5. Juan Marichal 8.1
6. Johnny Callison 8.0
7. Eddie Mathews 8.0
8. Bob Allison 7.4
9. Dick Groat 7.1
10. Gary Peters 7.0
1962
1. Willie Mays 10.5
2. Frank Robinson 8.7
3. Hank Aaron 8.5
4. Turk Farrell 7.3
5. Bob Purkey 7.0
6. Bob Gibson 6.3
7. Hank Aguirre 6.2
8. Camilo Pascual 6.1
9. Brooks Robinson 6.1
10. Maury Wills 6.0
1961
1. Mickey Mantle 10.4
2. Hank Aaron 9.5
3. Norm Cash 9.2
4. Willie Mays 8.7
5. Al Kaline 8.4
6. Ken Boyer 8.0
7. Frank Robinson 7.7
8. Rocky Colavito 7.6
9. Vada Pinson 7.5
10. Eddie Mathews 7.3
1960
1. Willie Mays 9.5
2. Hank Aaron 8.0
3. Ernie Banks 7.9
4. Ernie Broglio 7.6
5. Roger Maris 7.5
6. Eddie Mathews 7.3
7. Don Drysdale 7.2
8. Ken Boyer 6.9
9. Jim Bunning 6.4
10. Mickey Mantle 6.4
1959
1. Ernie Banks 10.2
2. Hank Aaron 8.6
3. Camilo Pascual 8.6
4. Eddie Mathews 8.2
5. Willie Mays 7.8
6. Ken Boyer 7.4
7. Larry Jackson 6.9
8. Hoyt Wilhelm 6.8
9. Vern Law 6.6
10. Mickey Mantle 6.6
1958
1. Willie Mays 10.3
2. Ernie Banks 9.3
3. Mickey Mantle 8.7
4. Hank Aaron 7.3
5. Richie Ashburn 7.0
6. Frank Lary 6.7
7. Robin Roberts 6.6
8. Al Kaline 6.5
9. Eddie Mathews 6.5
10. Bob Cerv 6.4
1957
1. Mickey Mantle 11.3
2. Ted Williams 9.7
3. Willie Mays 8.3
4. Hank Aaron 8.0
5. Nellie Fox 7.9
6. Eddie Mathews 7.4
7. Jim Bunning 7.0
8. Frank Robinson 6.8
9. Ernie Banks 6.7
10. Stan Musial 6.1
1956
1. Mickey Mantle 11.2
2. Early Wynn 8.4
3. Duke Snider 7.6
4. Willie Mays 7.6
5. Herb Score 7.5
6. Hank Aaron 7.2
7. Frank Lary 6.7
8. Frank Robinson 6.6
9. Al Kaline 6.5
10. Ken Boyer 6.4
1955
1. Mickey Mantle 9.5
2. Willie Mays 9.2
3. Duke Snider 8.6
4. Al Kaline 8.3
5. Ernie Banks 8.2
6. Eddie Mathews 7.3
7. Ted Williams 6.9
8. Billy Pierce 6.9
9. Richie Ashburn 6.3
10. Hank Aaron 6.2
1954
1. Willie Mays 10.5
2. Robin Roberts 8.7
3. Minnie Minoso 8.2
4. Duke Snider 8.2
5. Ted Kluszewski 7.8
6. Eddie Mathews 7.7
7. Johnny Antonelli 7.6
8. Ted Williams 7.5
9. Bobby Avila 7.1
10. Richie Ashburn 7.1
1953
1. Al Rosen 10.2
2. Robin Roberts 9.9
3. Duke Snider 9.2
4. Warren Spahn 9.1
5. Eddie Mathews 8.1
6. Stan Musial 7.6
7. Harvey Haddix 7.3
8. Jackie Robinson 6.9
9. Roy Campanella 6.8
10. Red Schoendienst 6.5
1952
1. Bobby Shantz 9.4
2. Robin Roberts 8.6
3. Jackie Robinson 8.4
4. Stan Musial 7.5
5. Billy Pierce 7.4
6. Larry Doby 7.0
7. Warren Spahn 6.9
8. Solly Hemus 6.8
9. Mickey Mantle 6.4
10. Bob Rush 6.1
1951
1. Jackie Robinson 9.7
2. Stan Musial 8.8
3. Robin Roberts 8.7
4. Ralph Kiner 8.0
5. Warren Spahn 7.9
6. Ted Williams 7.1
7. Monte Irvin 6.9
8. Roy Campanella 6.9
9. Richie Ashburn 6.7
10. Ned Garver 6.6
1950
1. Eddie Stanky 8.2
2. Ned Garver 8.1
3. Jackie Robinson 7.4
4. Stan Musial 7.3
5. Ewell Blackwell 7.2
6. Robin Roberts 6.9
7. Phil Rizzuto 6.8
8. Larry Doby 6.7
9. Andy Pafko 6.4
10. Sid Gordon 6.4
1949
1. Jackie Robinson 9.3
2. Stan Musial 9.1
3. Ted Williams 9.1
4. Mel Parnell 8.4
5. Ralph Kiner 8.1
6. Pee Wee Reese 7.4
7. Bob Lemon 7.0
8. Eddie Joost 7.0
9. Vern Stephens 6.9
10. Howie Pollet 6.6
1948
1. Stan Musial 11.3
2. Lou Boudreau 10.3
3. Johnny Sain 8.6
4. Harry Brecheen 8.5
5. Ted Williams 8.3
6. Joe DiMaggio 6.9
7. Hal Newhouser 6.7
8. Johnny Mize 6.6
9. Joe Gordon 6.5
10. Bob Lemon 6.4
1947
1. Ted Williams 9.5
2. Warren Spahn 9.4
3. Ewell Blackwell 8.7
4. Ralph Kiner 8.1
5. Johnny Mize 7.5
6. Lou Boudreau 7.2
7. Dutch Leonard 6.6
8. Joe Gordon 6.6
9. Harry Walker 6.4
10. Bob Elliott 6.4
1946
1. Ted Williams 10.6
2. Bob Feller 9.7
3. Hal Newhouser 9.5
4. Stan Musial 9.2
5. Johnny Sain 8.0
6. Dizzy Trout 7.9
7. Johnny Pesky 7.1
8. Howie Pollet 6.8
9. Eddie Stanky 6.6
10. Hank Greenberg 6.4
1945
1. Hal Newhouser 12.1
2. Snuffy Stirnweiss 8.8
3. Tommy Holmes 8.3
4. Nels Potter 7.8
5. Eddie Lake 7.1
6. Preacher Roe 6.6
7. Stan Hack 6.5
8. Steve Gromek 6.3
9. Phil Cavarretta 5.9
10. Augie Galan 5.9
1944
1. Dizzy Trout 10.9
2. Stan Musial 8.9
3. Snuffy Stirnweiss 8.6
4. Hal Newhouser 8.4
5. Lou Boudreau 8.1
6. Bobby Doerr 6.3
7. Bob Johnson 6.3
8. Augie Galan 6.3
9. Rip Sewell 6.3
10. Jim Tobin 6.2
1943
1. Stan Musial 9.5
2. Lou Boudreau 8.1
3. Luke Appling 7.3
4. Spud Chandler 7.3
5. Charlie Keller 6.6
6. Bill Nicholson 6.5
7. Lou Klein 6.4
8. Joe Gordon 6.4
9. Rudy York 6.0
10. Augie Galan 5.9
1942
1. Ted Williams 10.4
2. Mort Cooper 8.3
3. Joe Gordon 7.7
4. Mel Ott 7.1
5. Enos Slaughter 6.8
6. Charlie Keller 6.7
7. Joe DiMaggio 6.4
8. Johnny Mize 6.3
9. Tex Hughson 6.3
10. Johnny Pesky 6.1
1941
1. Ted Williams 10.4
2. Joe DiMaggio 9.4
3. Thornton Lee 9.0
4. Bob Feller 8.2
5. Pete Reiser 8.0
6. Whit Wyatt 7.6
7. Bucky Walters 7.0
8. Dolph Camilli 6.8
9. Cecil Travis 6.7
10. Charlie Keller 6.7
1940
1. Bob Feller 9.8
2. Johnny Mize 7.7
3. Claude Passeau 7.6
4. Joe DiMaggio 7.3
5. Bobo Newsom 7.3
6. Bucky Walters 6.9
7. Arky Vaughan 6.9
8. Hank Greenberg 6.8
9. Lonny Frey 6.8
10. Johnny Rigney 6.7
1939
1. Bucky Walters 9.7
2. Bob Feller 9.7
3. Joe DiMaggio 8.4
4. Bobo Newsom 7.7
5. Johnny Mize 7.7
6. Jimmie Foxx 6.9
7. Lefty Grove 6.8
8. Ted Williams 6.8
9. Red Rolfe 6.6
10. Bob Johnson 6.6
1938
1. Arky Vaughan 9.0
2. Mel Ott 8.9
3. Bill Lee 8.2
4. Jimmie Foxx 7.6
5. Hank Greenberg 6.7
6. Johnny Mize 6.5
7. Harlond Clift 6.3
8. Ival Goodman 6.2
9. Joe Cronin 6.1
10. Red Ruffing 6.0
1937
1. Lefty Grove 9.2
2. Lefty Gomez 9.0
3. Joe Medwick 8.5
4. Lou Gehrig 8.3
5. Joe DiMaggio 8.3
6. Charlie Gehringer 7.7
7. Hank Greenberg 7.5
8. Harlond Clift 6.9
9. Mel Ott 6.8
10. Bill Dickey 6.7
1936
1. Lefty Grove 10.6
2. Carl Hubbell 10.0
3. Lou Gehrig 9.7
4. Arky Vaughan 8.1
5. Mel Ott 8.0
6. Charlie Gehringer 7.9
7. Wes Ferrell 7.7
8. Dizzy Dean 7.6
9. Luke Appling 7.2
10. Joe Medwick 7.1
1935
1. Wes Ferrell 10.6
2. Arky Vaughan 9.7
3. Lefty Grove 8.7
4. Lou Gehrig 8.7
5. Charlie Gehringer 8.5
6. Jimmie Foxx 8.1
7. Hank Greenberg 7.7
8. Dizzy Dean 7.5
9. Mel Ott 7.3
10. Mel Harder 7.1
1934
1. Lou Gehrig 10.2
2. Dizzy Dean 9.5
3. Charlie Gehringer 8.9
4. Jimmie Foxx 8.6
5. Curt Davis 8.6
6. Lefty Gomez 7.9
7. Mel Harder 7.7
8. Mel Ott 7.4
9. Carl Hubbell 7.2
10. Arky Vaughan 7.2
1933
1. Carl Hubbell 9.0
2. Jimmie Foxx 9.0
3. Chuck Klein 7.9
4. Lon Warneke 7.8
5. Lefty Grove 7.3
6. Charlie Gehringer 7.2
7. Lou Gehrig 7.1
8. Joe Cronin 7.1
9. Wally Berger 7.0
10. Bump Hadley 6.9
1932
1. Jimmie Foxx 10.4
2. Lefty Grove 9.2
3. Babe Ruth 8.5
4. Mel Ott 8.3
5. Lou Gehrig 8.2
6. Red Ruffing 7.8
7. Bill Terry 7.6
8. Chuck Klein 7.4
9. Carl Hubbell 7.4
10. Wes Ferrell 7.2
1931
1. Babe Ruth 10.5
2. Lefty Grove 10.0
3. Lou Gehrig 8.8
4. Wes Ferrell 8.0
5. Al Simmons 7.5
6. Joe Cronin 6.9
7. Bill Terry 6.5
8. Earl Averill 6.4
9. Watty Clark 6.3
10. Ed Brandt 6.2
1930
1. Babe Ruth 10.5
2. Lefty Grove 10.4
3. Lou Gehrig 9.6
4. Wes Ferrell 9.4
5. Joe Cronin 8.5
6. Bill Terry 7.8
7. Al Simmons 7.8
8. Lefty Stewart 7.7
9. Hack Wilson 7.4
10. George Uhle 7.3
1929
1. Rogers Hornsby 10.4
2. Babe Ruth 8.0
3. Al Simmons 7.9
4. Jimmie Foxx 7.9
5. Tony Lazzeri 7.7
6. Lou Gehrig 7.6
7. Lefty Grove 7.4
8. Willis Hudlin 7.3
9. Lefty O'Doul 7.2
10. Mel Ott 7.2
1928
1. Dazzy Vance 10.3
2. Babe Ruth 10.2
3. Lou Gehrig 9.4
4. Rogers Hornsby 9.0
5. Goose Goslin 7.5
6. Heinie Manush 7.3
7. Lefty Grove 7.2
8. Burleigh Grimes 7.0
9. Tommy Thomas 7.0
10. Paul Waner 6.7
1927
1. Babe Ruth 12.5
2. Lou Gehrig 11.8
3. Rogers Hornsby 10.2
4. Frankie Frisch 9.3
5. Ted Lyons 7.9
6. Tommy Thomas 7.9
7. Dazzy Vance 7.5
8. Harry Heilmann 7.1
9. Earle Combs 7.0
10. Paul Waner 6.9
1926
1. Babe Ruth 11.4
2. George Uhle 9.2
3. Hal Carlson 8.7
4. Goose Goslin 6.8
5. Lou Gehrig 6.7
6. Lefty Grove 6.6
7. Ray Kremer 6.5
8. Johnny Mostil 6.2
9. Joe Sewell 5.9
10. Ted Lyons 5.8
1925
1. Rogers Hornsby 10.2
2. Pete Donohue 7.0
3. Harry Heilmann 6.9
4. Dolf Luque 6.8
5. Kiki Cuyler 6.8
6. Walter Johnson 6.7
7. Al Simmons 6.6
8. Tris Speaker 6.5
9. Goose Goslin 6.4
10. Herb Pennock 6.3
1924
1. Rogers Hornsby 12.2
2. Babe Ruth 11.7
3. Dazzy Vance 10.3
4. Howard Ehmke 8.2
5. Herb Pennock 7.9
6. Walter Johnson 7.5
7. Frankie Frisch 7.4
8. Joe Shaute 6.7
Zack Wheat 6.7
10. Goose Goslin 6.5
1923
1. Babe Ruth 14.1
2. Dolf Luque 10.9
3. Harry Heilmann 9.3
4. Tris Speaker 9.0
5. George Uhle 7.8
6. Ken Williams 7.6
7. Joe Sewell 7.5
8. Frankie Frisch 7.0
9. Jimmy Ring 6.8
10. Rogers Hornsby 6.7
1922
1. Rogers Hornsby 10.0
2. Red Faber 9.5
3. George Sisler 8.7
4. Ken Williams 7.9
5. Wilbur Cooper 7.5
6. Urban Shocker 7.4
7. Eddie Rommel 7.2
8. Bob Shawkey 6.9
9. Tris Speaker 6.9
10. Ty Cobb 6.7
1921
1. Babe Ruth 12.6
2. Red Faber 11.1
3. Rogers Hornsby 10.8
4. Urban Shocker 8.5
5. Burleigh Grimes 8.0
6. Dave Bancroft 7.4
7. Carl Mays 7.4
8. Sad Sam Jones 7.2
9. Frankie Frisch 6.9
10. Harry Heilmann 6.8
1920
1. Pete Alexander 12.6
2. Babe Ruth 11.7
3. George Sisler 9.8
4. Rogers Hornsby 9.6
5. Jim Bagby 9.5
6. Stan Coveleski 8.9
7. Tris Speaker 8.6
8. Burleigh Grimes 8.4
9. Bob Shawkey 8.0
10. Eddie Collins 7.9
1919
1. Walter Johnson 10.8
2. Babe Ruth 9.9
3. Eddie Cicotte 9.7
4. Pete Alexander 7.5
5. Babe Adams 7.5
6. Hippo Vaughn 7.3
7. Stan Coveleski 7.1
8. Rogers Hornsby 6.7
9. Bobby Veach 6.7
10. Roger Peckinpaugh 6.3
1918
1. Walter Johnson 11.7
2. Stan Coveleski 9.5
3. Hippo Vaughn 8.1
4. Scott Perry 7.5
5. Lefty Tyler 7.0
6. Babe Ruth 7.0
7. George Sisler 6.6
8. Ty Cobb 6.5
9. George Burns 5.9
10. Tris Speaker 5.5
1917
1. Eddie Cicotte 11.5
2. Ty Cobb 11.3
3. Rogers Hornsby 9.9
4. Pete Alexander 9.7
5. Babe Ruth 8.6
6. Jim Bagby 8.6
7. Walter Johnson 8.0
8. Ray Chapman 7.8
9. Tris Speaker 7.7
10. Stan Coveleski 7.6
1916
1. Pete Alexander 12.0
2. Walter Johnson 10.9
3. Babe Ruth 10.4
4. Tris Speaker 8.7
5. Ty Cobb 8.0
6. Jeff Pfeffer 7.3
7. Harry Coveleski 7.0
8. Eddie Collins 6.9
9. Shoeless Joe Jackson 6.8
10. Bob Shawkey 6.3
1915
1. Walter Johnson 12.5
2. Pete Alexander 10.9
3. Ty Cobb 10.0
4. Eddie Collins 9.4
5. Dave Davenport 7.3
6. Fred Toney 7.3
7. Tris Speaker 7.2
8. Eddie Plank 7.1
9. Gavvy Cravath 6.9
10. Benny Kauff 6.8
1914
1. Walter Johnson 12.6
2. Tris Speaker 10.0
3. Dutch Leonard 9.3
4. Pete Alexander 9.1
5. Eddie Collins 9.0
6. Bill James 8.3
7. Cy Falkenberg 8.0
8. Benny Kauff 7.8
9. Claude Hendrix 7.6
10. Jeff Pfeffer 7.5
1913
1. Walter Johnson 16.5
2. Babe Adams 9.3
3. Reb Russell 9.2
4. Eddie Collins 9.0
5. Tris Speaker 8.5
6. Home Run Baker 7.9
7. Shoeless Joe Jackson 7.6
8. Ty Cobb 7.4
9. Eddie Cicotte 7.2
10. Christy Mathewson 7.1
1912
1. Walter Johnson 14.2
2. Ed Walsh 12.1
3. Smoky Joe Wood 11.5
4. Tris Speaker 10.1
5. Ty Cobb 9.5
6. Home Run Baker 9.4
7. Shoeless Joe Jackson 9.3
8. Eddie Collins 8.5
9. Nap Rucker 8.3
10. Christy Mathewson 8.2
1911
1. Ty Cobb 10.7
2. Shoeless Joe Jackson 9.2
3. Ed Walsh 9.1
4. Walter Johnson 8.8
5. Nap Rucker 8.7
6. Vean Gregg 8.5
7. Christy Mathewson 7.8
8. Pete Alexander 7.7
9. Russ Ford 7.3
10. Babe Adams 6.7
1910
1. Russ Ford 11.9
2. Ed Walsh 11.7
3. Walter Johnson 10.7
4. Ty Cobb 10.5
5. Eddie Collins 10.5
6. Jack Coombs 9.9
7. Nap Lajoie 9.8
8. Christy Mathewson 8.9
9. Tris Speaker 7.7
10. Sherry Magee 6.8
1909
1. Christy Mathewson 10.6
2. Ty Cobb 9.9
3. Eddie Collins 9.7
4. Mordecai Brown 9.6
5. Honus Wagner 9.2
6. Orval Overall 8.3
7. Frank Smith 7.8
8. Nap Rucker 7.1
9. Ed Walsh 6.8
10. Donie Bush 6.5
1908
1. Christy Mathewson 11.9
2. Honus Wagner 11.5
3. Ed Walsh 10.7
4. Cy Young 9.7
5. Mordecai Brown 9.1
6. George McQuillan 8.9
7. Addie Joss 8.8
8. Nap Lajoie 7.9
9. Joe Tinker 7.9
10. Hooks Wiltse 7.6
1907
1. Honus Wagner 9.0
2. Christy Mathewson 8.9
3. Ed Killian 7.9
4. Cy Young 7.9
5. Nap Lajoie 7.6
Ed Walsh 7.6
7. Sherry Magee 6.9
8. Ty Cobb 6.8
9. Eddie Plank 6.7
10. Ed Karger 6.6
1906
1. Nap Lajoie 10.0
2. Terry Turner 9.3
3. Honus Wagner 9.3
4. Al Orth 9.1
5. George Stone 8.7
6. Vic Willis 8.1
7. Art Devlin 7.9
8. Mordecai Brown 7.5
9. Frank Chance 7.3
10. Tully Sparks 7.3
1905
1. Christy Mathewson 10.5
2. Honus Wagner 10.2
3. Rube Waddell 9.3
4. Irv Young 8.7
5. Ed Reulbach 8.2
6. Ed Killian 8.0
7. Cy Seymour 8.0
8. Eddie Plank 7.4
9. George Davis 7.2
10. Cy Young 7.1
1904
1. Jack Chesbro 11.4
2. Rube Waddell 10.4
3. Cy Young 9.6
4. Joe McGinnity 9.3
5. Eddie Plank 9.3
6. Nap Lajoie 8.6
7. Kid Nichols 8.4
8. Honus Wagner 8.2
9. George Davis 7.2
10. Jack Taylor 6.8
1903
1. Joe McGinnity 11.4
2. Christy Mathewson 10.3
3. Cy Young 8.3
4. Nap Lajoie 8.0
5. Rube Waddell 7.6
6. Bill Donovan 7.5
Honus Wagner 7.5
8. Noodles Hahn 7.3
9. Bill Bradley 7.2
10. Eddie Plank 6.8
1902
1. Rube Waddell 10.0
2. Jack Taylor 9.8
3. Cy Young 9.7
4. Noodles Hahn 8.7
5. Joe McGinnity 8.7
6. Vic Willis 8.0
7. Honus Wagner 7.1
8. Doc White 6.9
Ed Delahanty 6.9
10. Bill Bradley 6.7
1901
1. Cy Young 12.5
2. Christy Mathewson 8.8
3. Vic Willis 8.6
4. Nap Lajoie 8.6
5. Bobby Wallace 7.8
6. Joe McGinnity 7.6
7. Noodles Hahn 7.5
8. Al Orth 7.4
9. Jesse Burkett 7.4
10. Clark Griffith 7.1
1900
1. Cy Young 7.4
2. Bill Dinneen 6.9
3. Honus Wagner 6.4
4. Noodles Hahn 6.1
5. Elmer Flick 6.1
6. John McGraw 5.5
7. Jesse Burkett 5.5
8. Kip Selbach 5.2
9. Joe McGinnity 5.1
10. Clark Griffith 5.0
1899
1. Vic Willis 10.0
2. Joe McGinnity 8.4
3. Ed Delahanty 8.2
4. Cy Young 8.2
5. Jesse Tannehill 8.1
6. Frank Kitson 8.1
7. Jay Hughes 7.9
8. John McGraw 7.8
9. Noodles Hahn 7.7
10. Jimmy Williams 7.1
1898
1. Kid Nichols 11.1
2. Clark Griffith 10.5
3. Al Maul 7.7
4. Hughie Jennings 7.7
5. Doc McJames 7.5
6. Jesse Tannehill 7.4
7. John McGraw 7.4
8. Cy Young 7.3
9. Bert Cunningham 7.1
10. Jimmy Collins 7.0
1897
1. Kid Nichols 11.1
2. Amos Rusie 8.3
3. Theodore Breitenstein 7.9
4. Hughie Jennings 6.9
5. Willie Keeler 6.8
6. Cy Young 6.8
7. George Davis 6.5
8. Fred Clarke 6.3
9. Ed Delahanty 5.8
10. Jimmy Collins 5.4
1896
1. Cy Young 10.5
2. Nig Cuppy 10.3
3. Frank Killen 8.4
4. Bill Hoffer 8.3
5. Pink Hawley 8.3
6. Hughie Jennings 7.9
7. Frank Dwyer 7.6
8. Ed Delahanty 7.4
9. Bill Dahlen 6.8
10. Joe Kelley 6.5
1895
1. Cy Young 11.6
2. Pink Hawley 11.0
3. Kid Nichols 9.4
4. Clark Griffith 9.3
5. Nig Cuppy 8.5
6. Bill Hoffer 7.9
7. Theodore Breitenstein 7.5
8. Hughie Jennings 7.3
9. Ed Delahanty 6.8
10. Sam Thompson 6.0
1894
1. Amos Rusie 13.7
2. Jouett Meekin 11.1
3. Theodore Breitenstein 9.1
4. Cy Young 8.5
5. Kid Nichols 8.2
6. Billy Hamilton 7.8
7. Hugh Duffy 6.8
8. Joe Kelley 6.6
9. George Hemming 6.5
10. Pink Hawley 6.3
1893
1. Kid Nichols 11.7
2. Amos Rusie 11.1
3. Theodore Breitenstein 11.0
4. Cy Young 10.6
5. Frank Killen 8.5
6. Ed Delahanty 7.0
7. Sadie McMahon 6.0
8. Brickyard Kennedy 6.0
9. George Davis 5.7
10. Willie McGill 5.6
1892
1. Cy Young 13.0
2. Bill Hutchison 9.1
3. Dan Brouthers 9.1
4. Kid Nichols 8.8
5. Gus Weyhing 7.5
6. Cupid Childs 7.4
7. Amos Rusie 7.3
8. Ed Stein 7.2
9. Jack Stivetts 7.2
10. Nig Cuppy 6.6
1891
1. John Clarkson 9.9
2. Bill Hutchison 9.5
3. Sadie McMahon 9.4
4. Kid Nichols 9.3
5. Jack Stivetts 9.2
6. Amos Rusie 8.8
7. Gus Weyhing 7.9
8. Harry Staley 7.8
9. Charlie Buffinton 7.2
10. George Haddock 7.2
1890
1. Kid Nichols 13.1
2. Silver King 12.4
3. Kid Gleason 12.0
4. Scott Stratton 11.0
5. Sadie McMahon 10.7
6. Billy Rhines 10.6
7. John Clarkson 8.9
8. Bill Hutchison 8.3
9. Amos Rusie 8.3
10. Old Hoss Radbourn 7.8
1889
1. John Clarkson 16.2
2. Charlie Buffinton 11.1
3. Ice Box Chamberlain 9.2
4. Jesse Duryea 9.2
5. Matt Kilroy 8.7
6. Silver King 8.6
7. Bob Caruthers 8.6
8. Ben Sanders 7.5
9. Cap Anson 6.7
10. Dan Brouthers 6.5
1888
1. Silver King 16.2
2. Charlie Buffinton 12.1
3. Ed Seward 10.0
4. Tim Keefe 9.2
5. Ben Sanders 8.5
6. Mickey Welch 7.9
7. Roger Connor 7.8
8. Cap Anson 7.1
9. Pete Conway 7.0
10. Dan Brouthers 6.7
1887
1. John Clarkson 15.1
2. Matt Kilroy 12.2
3. Mike Smith 10.9
4. Bob Caruthers 10.6
5. Charlie Ferguson 10.1
6. Dan Casey 9.3
7. Jim Whitney 8.5
8. Toad Ramsey 8.0
9. Tony Mullane 7.6
10. Tim Keefe 7.6
1886
1. Toad Ramsey 12.5
2. Charlie Ferguson 11.8
3. Bob Caruthers 11.6
4. Dave Foutz 11.1
5. Lady Baldwin 10.5
6. Ed Morris 10.4
7. Tim Keefe 9.4
8. Dan Brouthers 8.4
9. Roger Connor 7.2
10. Jim McCormick 7.2
1885
1. John Clarkson 12.8
2. Ed Morris 12.7
3. Mickey Welch 10.6
4. Bob Caruthers 10.0
5. Old Hoss Radbourn 8.5
6. Guy Hecker 8.2
7. Roger Connor 8.2
8. Charlie Ferguson 8.1
9. Hardie Henderson 7.8
10. Tim Keefe 6.6
1884
1. Old Hoss Radbourn 19.4
2. Pud Galvin 18.4
3. Guy Hecker 17.8
4. Charlie Buffinton 16.3
5. Jim McCormick 14.7
6. Tony Mullane 13.3
7. Mickey Welch 12.3
8. Billy Taylor 11.5
9. Charlie Sweeney 11.2
10. Ed Morris 8.5
1883
1. Tim Keefe 20.2
2. Old Hoss Radbourn 14.3
3. Jim Whitney 13.5
4. Pud Galvin 9.8
5. Will White 9.3
6. Jim McCormick 8.3
7. Tony Mullane 6.4
8. Jumbo McGinnis 5.7
9. Hugh Daily 5.7
10. Dan Brouthers 5.5
1882
1. Will White 11.3
2. Jim McCormick 10.9
3. Stump Weidman 9.8
4. Jim Whitney 8.4
5. Old Hoss Radbourn 7.9
6. Sam Weaver 6.6
7. Tony Mullane 6.3
8. Dan Brouthers 5.9
9. Larry Corcoran 5.8
10. Tim Keefe 5.2
1881
1. Jim Whitney 8.7
2. George Derby 7.5
3. Pud Galvin 7.5
4. Jim McCormick 7.0
5. Cap Anson 5.9
6. Mickey Welch 5.6
7. Lee Richmond 4.4
8. Charlie Bennett 4.3
9. Fred Dunlap 3.9
10. Old Hoss Radbourn 3.9
1880
1. Jim McCormick 10.8
2. John Ward 7.6
3. Lee Richmond 7.3
4. Larry Corcoran 7.0
5. Mickey Welch 6.5
6. Cap Anson 5.1
7. Tim Keefe 4.6
George Bradley 4.6
9. George Gore 4.6
10. Will White 4.3
1879
1. Tommy Bond 14.3
2. Jim McCormick 9.8
3. John Ward 9.2
4. Pud Galvin 9.0
5. Terry Larkin 4.9
6. Harry McCormick 4.7
7. Charley Jones 4.5
8. Paul Hines 4.4
9. George Wright 4.3
10. Ned Williamson 4.2
1878
1. Tommy Bond 13.4
2. Sam Weaver 10.2
3. Terry Larkin 5.6
4. John Ward 4.7
5. Orator Shafer 3.5
6. Bob Ferguson 3.1
7. Paul Hines 2.8
8. Charley Jones 2.8
9. Joe Gerhardt 2.5
10. Deacon White 2.4
1877
1. Jim Devlin 13.4
2. Tommy Bond 11.5
3. Deacon White 3.4
4. Tricky Nichols 3.0
5. George Bradley 2.8
6. Jim O'Rourke 2.6
7. Joe Start 2.6
8. Charley Jones 2.3
9. John Clapp 2.3
10. Cap Anson 2.2
1876
1. Jim Devlin 18.3
2. Tommy Bond 10.4
3. Al Spalding 10.2
4. George Bradley 9.1
5. Ross Barnes 5.7
6. Cap Anson 3.7
7. Deacon White 3.7
8. Candy Cummings 3.5
9. Cal McVey 3.5
10. Joe Battin 3.5
1875
1. Al Spalding 14.2
2. Candy Cummings 11.7
3. Tommy Bond 11.4
4. Dick McBride 9.8
5. Cherokee Fisher 8.0
6. Bobby Mathews 7.5
7. George Zettlein 7.5
8. Ross Barnes 4.9
9. Deacon White 4.4
10. Cal McVey 4.3
1874
1. Bobby Mathews 13.7
2. Al Spalding 10.6
3. Candy Cummings 6.3
4. Dick McBride 6.3
5. Cherokee Fisher 4.3
6. George Zettlein 3.0
7. Cal McVey 3.0
8. George Wright 2.7
9. Ross Barnes 2.6
10. Dickey Pearce 2.5
1873
1. Bobby Mathews 9.6
2. Al Spalding 9.0
3. Candy Cummings 7.9
4. George Zettlein 7.6
5. Dick McBride 6.2
6. Ross Barnes 4.6
7. George Wright 3.6
8. Deacon White 2.6
9. Davy Force 2.1
10. Cap Anson 2.0
1872
1. Al Spalding 12.4
2. Candy Cummings 8.0
3. George Zettlein 6.1
4. Bobby Mathews 5.4
5. Dick McBride 4.7
6. Ross Barnes 4.2
7. George Wright 2.9
8. Davy Force 2.8
9. Dave Eggler 2.8
10. Cap Anson 2.6
1871
1. George Zettlein 4.5
2. Rynie Wolters 4.3
3. Al Spalding 3.5
4. Dick McBride 3.3
5. Ross Barnes 2.3
6. Asa Brainard 1.9
7. Al Pratt 1.8
8. Cherokee Fisher 1.8
9. Levi Meyerle 1.7
10. Jimmy Wood 1.7