Year-by-Year Top-Tens Leaders & Records for WAR for Pitchers

Create your own custom leaderboards

Become a Stathead today and run queries with our Season and Career Finders to see the best seasons in MLB history.

Become a Stathead

Top 10 Yearly Leaders

2020
1. Shane Bieber 3.3
2. Hyun Jin Ryu 3.0
3. Max Fried 2.9
4. Zack Wheeler 2.9
5. Antonio Senzatela 2.8
6. Trevor Bauer 2.7
7. Zac Gallen 2.7
8. Yu Darvish 2.7
9. Jacob deGrom 2.6
10. Dinelson Lamet 2.4
2019
1. Mike Minor 7.8
2. Jacob deGrom 7.6
3. Lance Lynn 7.5
4. Justin Verlander 7.4
5. Gerrit Cole 6.6
6. Stephen Strasburg 6.2
7. Eduardo Rodriguez 5.9
8. Jack Flaherty 5.7
Max Scherzer 5.7
10. Lucas Giolito 5.7
2018
1. Aaron Nola 10.2
2. Jacob deGrom 9.9
3. Max Scherzer 8.4
4. Kyle Freeland 8.2
5. Blake Snell 7.1
6. Chris Sale 6.9
7. Justin Verlander 6.8
8. Trevor Bauer 5.8
9. Corey Kluber 5.7
10. Gerrit Cole 5.7
2017
1. Corey Kluber 7.9
2. Max Scherzer 7.2
3. Gio Gonzalez 6.5
4. Justin Verlander 6.5
5. Stephen Strasburg 6.4
6. Chris Sale 6.0
7. Zack Greinke 5.7
8. Luis Severino 5.4
9. Marcus Stroman 5.2
10. Carlos Carrasco 5.2
2015
1. Zack Greinke 8.9
2. Jake Arrieta 8.3
3. Clayton Kershaw 7.3
4. Max Scherzer 6.9
5. Dallas Keuchel 6.5
6. David Price 6.3
7. John Lackey 5.8
8. Sonny Gray 5.4
9. Jacob deGrom 5.2
10. Madison Bumgarner 5.0
2014
1. Corey Kluber 8.1
2. Clayton Kershaw 7.7
3. Johnny Cueto 6.6
4. Felix Hernandez 6.4
Cole Hamels 6.4
6. Chris Sale 6.1
7. Adam Wainwright 6.1
8. Max Scherzer 5.8
9. Jake Arrieta 5.3
10. Tanner Roark 4.7
2013
1. Clayton Kershaw 8.1
2. Hisashi Iwakuma 7.0
3. Cliff Lee 6.6
4. Chris Sale 6.5
5. Max Scherzer 6.5
6. Adam Wainwright 6.3
7. Jose Fernandez 6.2
8. Anibal Sanchez 6.1
9. Jhoulys Chacin 5.8
10. Bartolo Colon 5.6
2012
1. Justin Verlander 8.1
2. David Price 6.6
3. Clayton Kershaw 6.4
4. Matt Harrison 5.8
5. R.A. Dickey 5.7
6. Chris Sale 5.7
7. Hiroki Kuroda 5.3
8. Felix Hernandez 5.3
9. Johnny Cueto 5.2
10. Jake Peavy 5.0
2011
1. Roy Halladay 8.8
2. Justin Verlander 8.6
3. Cliff Lee 8.5
4. Jered Weaver 6.9
5. Clayton Kershaw 6.8
6. CC Sabathia 6.4
Cole Hamels 6.4
8. Ricky Romero 6.4
9. Josh Beckett 5.8
10. James Shields 5.8
2010
1. Roy Halladay 8.5
2. Ubaldo Jimenez 7.5
3. Felix Hernandez 7.2
4. Josh Johnson 7.0
5. Adam Wainwright 6.2
6. Roy Oswalt 6.0
7. Tim Hudson 5.8
8. Clayton Kershaw 5.6
9. Clay Buchholz 5.6
10. Cole Hamels 5.5
2009
1. Zack Greinke 10.4
2. Tim Lincecum 7.4
3. Roy Halladay 6.9
4. Josh Johnson 6.7
5. Jair Jurrjens 6.5
6. Dan Haren 6.5
7. Chris Carpenter 6.5
8. Adam Wainwright 6.3
9. CC Sabathia 6.2
10. Jon Lester 6.2
Javier Vazquez 6.2
2008
1. Tim Lincecum 7.8
2. Johan Santana 7.1
3. Ryan Dempster 6.9
4. Cliff Lee 6.8
5. CC Sabathia 6.7
6. John Danks 6.4
7. Roy Halladay 6.2
8. Jon Lester 6.1
9. Dan Haren 6.1
10. Rich Harden 5.9
2007
1. Roy Oswalt 6.6
2. Josh Beckett 6.5
3. Brandon Webb 6.4
4. CC Sabathia 6.3
5. John Lackey 6.3
6. Javier Vazquez 6.2
7. Roberto Hernandez 6.2
8. Jake Peavy 6.2
9. Mark Buehrle 6.1
10. Aaron Harang 6.0
2006
1. Johan Santana 7.6
2. Brandon Webb 7.0
3. Bronson Arroyo 6.8
4. Chien-Ming Wang 6.0
5. John Smoltz 5.9
6. Roy Oswalt 5.9
7. Curt Schilling 5.5
8. Roy Halladay 5.3
9. Carlos Zambrano 5.3
Aaron Harang 5.3
2005
1. Roger Clemens 7.8
2. Dontrelle Willis 7.3
3. Johan Santana 7.2
4. Pedro Martinez 7.0
5. Andy Pettitte 6.8
6. Roy Oswalt 5.9
7. Chris Carpenter 5.8
8. Randy Johnson 5.8
9. Carlos Zambrano 5.6
10. Roy Halladay 5.5
2004
1. Johan Santana 8.7
2. Randy Johnson 8.4
3. Curt Schilling 7.8
4. Ben Sheets 7.2
5. Jason Schmidt 6.8
6. Carlos Zambrano 6.6
7. Brad Radke 5.9
8. Oliver Perez 5.7
9. Joe Kennedy 5.6
10. Pedro Martinez 5.5
2003
1. Roy Halladay 8.1
2. Pedro Martinez 8.0
3. Tim Hudson 7.4
4. Mark Prior 7.4
5. Esteban Loaiza 7.2
6. Jason Schmidt 6.7
7. Mike Mussina 6.6
8. Liván Hernández 6.3
9. Kerry Wood 6.1
Brandon Webb 6.1
2002
1. Randy Johnson 10.7
2. Curt Schilling 8.6
3. Roy Halladay 7.3
4. Derek Lowe 7.2
5. Barry Zito 7.2
6. Bartolo Colon 7.1
7. Roy Oswalt 7.0
8. Tim Hudson 6.9
9. Pedro Martinez 6.5
10. Jamie Moyer 5.6
2001
1. Randy Johnson 10.1
2. Curt Schilling 8.8
3. Mike Mussina 7.1
4. Joe Mays 6.6
5. Mark Buehrle 6.0
6. Javier Vazquez 5.8
7. Roger Clemens 5.7
8. Mark Mulder 5.6
9. Wade Miller 5.3
10. Greg Maddux 5.2
2000
1. Pedro Martinez 11.7
2. Randy Johnson 8.1
3. Kevin Brown 7.0
4. Greg Maddux 6.5
5. Brad Radke 6.2
6. Mike Mussina 5.7
7. Curt Schilling 5.2
8. Kris Benson 5.1
9. Kenny Rogers 5.0
10. Jeff D'Amico 5.0
1999
1. Pedro Martinez 9.8
2. Randy Johnson 9.1
3. Mike Hampton 6.7
4. Brad Radke 6.6
5. Jamie Moyer 6.5
6. Kevin Brown 6.2
7. Kevin Millwood 6.2
8. Pedro Astacio 5.9
9. Freddy Garcia 5.4
10. David Cone 5.1
1998
1. Kevin Brown 8.6
2. Roger Clemens 8.1
3. Kenny Rogers 7.5
4. Pedro Martinez 7.3
5. Chuck Finley 7.2
6. Al Leiter 6.7
7. Greg Maddux 6.6
8. Curt Schilling 6.2
9. Tom Glavine 6.1
10. Randy Johnson 5.7
1997
1. Roger Clemens 11.9
2. Pedro Martinez 9.0
3. Andy Pettitte 8.4
4. Randy Johnson 8.0
5. Greg Maddux 7.8
6. Justin Thompson 7.7
7. Kevin Brown 7.0
8. David Cone 6.7
9. Curt Schilling 6.3
10. Pat Hentgen 5.8
1996
1. Pat Hentgen 8.6
2. Kevin Brown 7.9
3. Roger Clemens 7.7
4. John Smoltz 7.4
5. Greg Maddux 7.2
6. Juan Guzman 6.7
7. Ken Hill 6.6
8. Charles Nagy 6.6
9. Alex Fernandez 6.4
10. Denny Neagle 6.0
1995
1. Greg Maddux 9.7
2. Randy Johnson 8.6
3. David Cone 7.0
4. Mike Mussina 6.1
5. Kenny Rogers 5.8
6. Al Leiter 5.7
Dennis Martinez 5.7
8. David Wells 5.4
9. Tim Wakefield 5.0
10. Andy Ashby 4.9
1994
1. Greg Maddux 8.5
2. David Cone 6.9
3. Roger Clemens 6.0
4. Randy Johnson 5.5
Bret Saberhagen 5.5
6. Mike Mussina 5.4
7. Pat Hentgen 5.4
8. Danny Jackson 4.7
9. Dennis Martinez 4.6
10. Marvin Freeman 4.5
1993
1. Kevin Appier 9.3
2. Jose Rijo 9.2
3. Mark Langston 8.5
4. David Cone 7.2
5. Chuck Finley 7.1
6. Randy Johnson 6.6
7. Jimmy Key 6.3
8. Greg Maddux 5.8
9. Danny Darwin 5.7
10. Alex Fernandez 5.4
1992
1. Greg Maddux 9.1
2. Roger Clemens 8.7
3. Mike Mussina 8.2
4. Kevin Appier 8.0
5. Bob Tewksbury 6.4
6. Frank Viola 6.2
7. Sid Fernandez 6.1
8. Charles Nagy 6.0
9. Melido Perez 5.9
10. Curt Schilling 5.9
1991
1. Tom Glavine 8.5
2. Roger Clemens 7.9
3. Jim Abbott 7.6
4. Mark Langston 7.3
5. Tom Candiotti 7.1
6. Kevin Tapani 6.8
7. Dennis Martinez 5.8
8. Jose Rijo 5.5
9. John Smoltz 5.4
10. Steve Avery 5.2
1990
1. Roger Clemens 10.4
2. Chuck Finley 7.7
3. Ed Whitson 7.0
4. Frank Viola 6.4
5. Mike Boddicker 5.9
6. Dave Stieb 5.9
7. Jose Rijo 5.7
8. Kevin Appier 5.3
9. Danny Darwin 5.3
10. Dave Stewart 5.2
1989
1. Bret Saberhagen 9.7
2. Orel Hershiser 7.0
3. Bruce Hurst 6.5
4. Ed Whitson 6.5
5. Mark Langston 6.4
6. Mark Gubicza 6.3
7. Bert Blyleven 6.0
8. Roger Clemens 5.7
9. Mike Moore 5.4
10. Chris Bosio 5.4
1988
1. Mark Gubicza 7.7
2. Frank Viola 7.7
3. Teddy Higuera 7.4
4. Orel Hershiser 7.2
5. Roger Clemens 7.1
6. Greg Swindell 5.9
7. Tom Candiotti 5.7
8. Mark Langston 5.6
9. David Cone 5.5
10. John Tudor 5.2
Allan Anderson 5.2
1987
1. Roger Clemens 9.4
2. Frank Viola 8.1
3. Bret Saberhagen 8.0
4. Jimmy Key 7.4
5. Bob Welch 7.1
6. Doyle Alexander 6.5
7. Orel Hershiser 6.4
8. Teddy Higuera 6.3
9. Rick Sutcliffe 6.0
10. Charlie Leibrandt 6.0
1986
1. Teddy Higuera 9.4
2. Roger Clemens 8.8
3. Mike Scott 8.4
4. Mark Eichhorn 7.3
5. Rick Rhoden 6.6
6. Mike Witt 6.1
7. Fernando Valenzuela 5.5
8. Jack Morris 5.1
9. Tom Candiotti 4.9
10. Jimmy Key 4.8
1985
1. Dwight Gooden 12.2
2. John Tudor 8.1
3. Bret Saberhagen 7.1
4. Bert Blyleven 6.8
5. Dave Stieb 6.8
6. Charlie Leibrandt 6.6
7. Charlie Hough 6.3
8. Mike Moore 6.3
9. Rick Reuschel 6.2
10. Oil Can Boyd 6.1
1984
1. Dave Stieb 7.9
2. Bert Blyleven 7.2
3. Doyle Alexander 6.1
4. Dwight Gooden 5.5
5. Rick Rhoden 5.2
6. Mike Boddicker 5.2
7. Jim Beattie 5.1
8. Alejandro Pena 5.0
9. Willie Hernandez 4.8
10. Phil Niekro 4.6
Mike Witt 4.6
1983
1. John Denny 7.4
2. Dave Stieb 7.0
3. Mario Soto 6.8
4. Dan Quisenberry 5.5
5. Steve Carlton 5.5
6. Scott McGregor 5.3
7. Ron Guidry 5.3
8. Craig McMurtry 5.2
9. Matt Young 5.1
10. Richard Dotson 5.1
1982
1. Steve Rogers 7.7
2. Dave Stieb 7.6
3. Mario Soto 7.5
4. Joe Niekro 6.8
5. Joaquin Andujar 5.8
6. Rick Sutcliffe 5.7
7. Steve Carlton 5.5
8. Greg Minton 5.4
9. Luis Leal 5.1
10. Fernando Valenzuela 5.0
1981
1. Bert Blyleven 5.6
2. Steve Carlton 5.5
3. Fernando Valenzuela 4.8
4. Nolan Ryan 4.7
5. Steve McCatty 4.5
6. Dave Stieb 4.4
7. Rollie Fingers 4.2
8. Jerry Reuss 4.1
9. Tom Seaver 4.0
10. Britt Burns 3.9
1980
1. Steve Carlton 10.2
2. Britt Burns 7.0
3. Don Sutton 6.3
4. Larry Gura 6.0
5. Steve Rogers 5.9
6. Mike Norris 5.9
7. Doug Corbett 5.7
8. Rick Reuschel 5.7
9. Jim Clancy 5.5
10. Jerry Reuss 5.2
1979
1. Phil Niekro 7.4
2. Jerry Koosman 7.2
3. Dennis Eckersley 7.2
4. Ron Guidry 6.5
5. Jim Kern 6.1
6. Jack Morris 5.8
7. Rick Reuschel 5.7
8. J.R. Richard 5.6
9. Sid Monge 5.6
10. Tommy John 5.5
1978
1. Phil Niekro 10.0
2. Ron Guidry 9.6
3. Mike Caldwell 8.2
4. Dennis Eckersley 7.3
5. Dave Goltz 6.6
6. Jim Palmer 6.4
7. Bob Knepper 6.3
8. Jon Matlack 6.2
9. Vida Blue 5.8
10. Craig Swan 5.6
1977
1. Rick Reuschel 9.5
2. Phil Niekro 8.9
3. Frank Tanana 8.3
4. Tom Seaver 7.9
5. Nolan Ryan 7.8
6. John Candelaria 7.4
7. Jim Palmer 7.3
8. Bruce Sutter 6.5
9. Rich Gossage 6.0
10. Steve Carlton 5.9
1976
1. Mark Fidrych 9.6
2. Vida Blue 7.6
3. Frank Tanana 7.5
4. John Montefusco 6.9
5. Phil Niekro 6.7
6. Bert Blyleven 6.5
7. Jim Palmer 6.5
8. Luis Tiant 6.3
9. Gaylord Perry 5.8
10. Jim Barr 5.6
1975
1. Jim Palmer 8.4
2. Rich Gossage 8.2
3. Catfish Hunter 8.1
4. Tom Seaver 7.8
5. Jim Kaat 7.7
6. Randy Jones 7.5
7. Frank Tanana 7.4
8. John Montefusco 6.8
9. Phil Niekro 6.7
10. Andy Messersmith 6.5
1974
1. Jon Matlack 9.1
2. Gaylord Perry 8.5
3. Phil Niekro 7.9
4. Bert Blyleven 7.8
5. Luis Tiant 7.7
6. Fergie Jenkins 7.7
7. Jim Kaat 7.1
8. Catfish Hunter 6.9
9. Steve Busby 6.5
10. Jim Barr 6.3
1973
1. Tom Seaver 10.6
2. Bert Blyleven 9.7
3. John Hiller 7.9
4. Gaylord Perry 7.8
5. Nolan Ryan 7.7
6. Wilbur Wood 7.5
7. Wayne Twitchell 6.7
8. Jim Palmer 6.3
9. Stan Bahnsen 6.2
10. Bill Lee 6.1
1972
1. Steve Carlton 12.1
2. Gaylord Perry 10.8
3. Wilbur Wood 10.7
4. Mickey Lolich 7.4
5. Bob Gibson 7.1
6. Don Sutton 6.6
7. Luis Tiant 6.5
8. Nolan Ryan 6.2
9. Jon Matlack 6.1
10. Fergie Jenkins 5.8
1971
1. Wilbur Wood 11.8
2. Tom Seaver 10.2
3. Fergie Jenkins 10.1
4. Vida Blue 9.0
5. Mickey Lolich 8.5
6. Dave Roberts 7.5
7. Bert Blyleven 6.5
8. Tom Bradley 6.2
9. Don Wilson 6.1
10. Milt Pappas 5.8
1970
1. Bob Gibson 8.9
2. Sam McDowell 8.3
3. Gaylord Perry 7.6
4. Fergie Jenkins 7.3
5. Jim Palmer 6.4
Ken Holtzman 6.4
7. Tom Seaver 5.8
8. Tommy John 5.5
9. Bill Hands 5.2
10. Dick Selma 5.2
1969
1. Bob Gibson 10.4
2. Larry Dierker 8.7
3. Bill Hands 8.4
4. Denny McLain 8.1
5. Juan Marichal 7.8
6. Tom Seaver 7.2
7. Fergie Jenkins 7.2
8. Steve Carlton 6.9
9. Sam McDowell 6.6
10. Gaylord Perry 6.5
1968
1. Bob Gibson 11.2
2. Luis Tiant 8.5
3. Denny McLain 7.4
4. Tom Seaver 6.8
5. Stan Bahnsen 6.4
6. Jerry Koosman 6.3
7. Fergie Jenkins 6.2
Dean Chance 6.2
9. Dave McNally 5.9
10. Tommy John 5.6
1967
1. Jim Bunning 7.8
2. Jim Merritt 6.5
3. Gary Nolan 6.3
4. Chris Short 6.2
5. Ted Abernathy 6.2
6. Tom Seaver 6.0
7. Dean Chance 5.9
8. Gaylord Perry 5.6
9. Joe Horlen 5.5
10. Mel Queen 5.0
1966
1. Sandy Koufax 10.3
2. Juan Marichal 9.1
3. Jim Bunning 9.0
4. Jim Maloney 7.1
5. Bob Gibson 6.1
6. Earl Wilson 5.9
7. Mike Cuellar 5.7
8. Gary Peters 5.3
9. Gaylord Perry 5.2
10. Phil Regan 4.9
1965
1. Juan Marichal 10.3
2. Sam McDowell 8.2
3. Jim Maloney 8.2
4. Sandy Koufax 8.1
5. Jim Bunning 8.0
6. Mel Stottlemyre 6.9
7. Chris Short 6.8
8. Bob Gibson 6.3
9. Bob Shaw 5.3
10. Sonny Siebert 5.1
1964
1. Dean Chance 9.4
2. Don Drysdale 7.8
3. Sandy Koufax 7.3
4. Whitey Ford 6.7
5. Juan Marichal 6.3
6. Chris Short 6.2
7. Dick Radatz 6.1
8. Bob Gibson 6.0
9. Larry Jackson 6.0
10. Bob Veale 5.8
1963
1. Sandy Koufax 10.7
2. Dick Ellsworth 10.2
3. Juan Marichal 7.8
4. Camilo Pascual 6.1
5. Gary Peters 6.0
6. Bob Friend 5.8
7. Dick Radatz 5.7
8. Larry Jackson 5.1
9. Jim Maloney 5.0
10. Joe Nuxhall 4.9
1962
1. Hank Aguirre 7.4
2. Bob Purkey 7.3
3. Turk Farrell 7.0
4. Ernie Broglio 6.1
5. Bob Friend 5.8
6. Bob Gibson 5.6
7. Warren Spahn 5.6
8. Dick Radatz 5.5
9. Don Drysdale 5.4
10. Jim Kaat 5.4
1961
1. Don Cardwell 6.1
2. Jack Kralick 6.0
3. Sandy Koufax 5.7
4. Don Drysdale 5.4
5. Camilo Pascual 5.3
6. Ken McBride 5.1
Jim O'Toole 5.1
8. Stan Williams 4.7
9. Joey Jay 4.5
10. Bob Gibson 4.4
1960
1. Ernie Broglio 7.1
2. Don Drysdale 7.0
3. Jim Bunning 6.6
4. Lindy McDaniel 5.9
5. Ray Herbert 5.8
6. Bob Friend 5.6
7. Larry Jackson 5.3
8. Mike McCormick 5.1
9. Bill Monbouquette 4.9
10. Johnny Podres 4.8
1959
1. Camilo Pascual 7.8
2. Hoyt Wilhelm 7.6
3. Larry Jackson 7.3
4. Vern Law 6.5
5. Don Drysdale 5.9
6. Sam Jones 5.7
7. Warren Spahn 5.5
8. Roger Craig 5.0
9. Johnny Antonelli 4.9
10. Don Newcombe 4.9
1958
1. Frank Lary 6.7
2. Robin Roberts 6.3
3. Sam Jones 6.3
4. Stu Miller 4.9
5. Bob Purkey 4.9
6. Dick Hyde 4.8
7. Billy Pierce 4.8
8. Camilo Pascual 4.5
9. Whitey Ford 4.3
10. Billy O'Dell 4.1
1957
1. Frank Sullivan 6.4
2. Jim Bunning 6.3
3. Don Drysdale 6.0
4. Johnny Podres 5.8
5. Warren Spahn 4.8
6. Jack Sanford 4.6
7. Moe Drabowsky 4.6
8. Brooks Lawrence 4.0
9. Dick Donovan 3.9
10. Larry Jackson 3.8
1956
1. Early Wynn 7.8
2. Herb Score 7.3
3. Johnny Antonelli 6.4
4. Frank Lary 6.3
5. Bob Friend 5.6
6. Warren Spahn 5.5
7. Billy Pierce 5.2
8. Whitey Ford 5.2
9. Bob Lemon 5.2
10. Sal Maglie 5.0
1955
1. Billy Pierce 7.0
2. Early Wynn 6.1
3. Bob Friend 6.0
4. Herb Score 5.6
5. Bob Rush 5.5
6. Billy Hoeft 5.0
7. Frank Sullivan 4.6
8. Joe Nuxhall 4.3
9. Robin Roberts 4.3
10. Johnny Antonelli 4.1
1954
1. Robin Roberts 9.0
2. Johnny Antonelli 7.5
3. Steve Gromek 5.6
4. Early Wynn 5.3
5. Bob Rush 5.2
6. Warren Spahn 5.1
7. Mike Garcia 4.9
8. Frank Sullivan 4.8
Virgil Trucks 4.8
10. Lew Burdette 4.8
1953
1. Robin Roberts 9.8
2. Warren Spahn 8.8
3. Harvey Haddix 6.4
4. Billy Pierce 6.2
5. Virgil Trucks 6.0
6. Curt Simmons 4.4
7. Vinegar Bend Mizell 4.4
8. Ruben Gomez 4.4
9. Ellis Kinder 4.4
10. Mel Parnell 4.2
Carl Erskine 4.2
1952
1. Bobby Shantz 8.8
2. Robin Roberts 8.4
3. Billy Pierce 7.3
4. Warren Spahn 6.6
5. Ken Raffensberger 6.2
6. Warren Hacker 6.2
7. Mike Garcia 5.4
8. Bob Porterfield 5.3
9. Bob Rush 5.2
10. Murry Dickson 4.9
1951
1. Robin Roberts 8.0
2. Warren Spahn 7.7
3. Sal Maglie 6.6
4. Larry Jansen 5.5
5. Early Wynn 5.5
6. Ned Garver 5.4
7. Ken Raffensberger 5.2
8. Preacher Roe 5.1
9. Ellis Kinder 5.1
10. Saul Rogovin 5.0
1950
1. Ewell Blackwell 7.5
2. Robin Roberts 7.4
3. Ned Garver 7.3
4. Art Houtteman 6.0
5. Mel Parnell 5.7
6. Larry Jansen 5.5
7. Warren Spahn 5.3
8. Preacher Roe 5.2
9. Vern Bickford 5.0
10. Murry Dickson 4.9
1949
1. Mel Parnell 8.0
2. Virgil Trucks 6.9
3. Howie Pollet 6.5
4. Ken Heintzelman 6.3
5. Dave Koslo 6.1
6. Preacher Roe 5.8
7. Warren Spahn 5.6
8. Don Newcombe 5.5
9. Bob Lemon 5.4
10. Hal Newhouser 5.4
1948
1. Harry Brecheen 8.7
2. Johnny Sain 8.5
3. Hal Newhouser 6.5
4. Dutch Leonard 6.3
5. Johnny Vander Meer 5.5
6. Johnny Schmitz 5.4
7. Ray Scarborough 5.2
8. Ned Garver 4.9
9. Preacher Roe 4.9
10. Bob Lemon 4.7
1947
1. Warren Spahn 9.4
2. Ewell Blackwell 9.4
3. Ralph Branca 6.9
4. Dutch Leonard 6.7
5. Hal Newhouser 5.8
6. Eddie Lopat 5.5
7. Walt Masterson 5.3
8. Larry Jansen 5.1
9. Bob Feller 4.9
10. Joe Dobson 4.6
1946
1. Bob Feller 10.0
2. Hal Newhouser 9.6
3. Dizzy Trout 7.6
4. Johnny Sain 7.2
5. Howie Pollet 6.8
6. Tex Hughson 6.0
7. Fritz Ostermueller 5.5
8. Harry Brecheen 5.5
9. Johnny Schmitz 5.4
10. Spud Chandler 5.4
1945
1. Hal Newhouser 11.3
2. Preacher Roe 7.3
3. Nels Potter 7.2
4. Roger Wolff 6.0
5. Steve Gromek 5.7
6. Red Barrett 5.3
7. Claude Passeau 5.0
8. Hank Wyse 4.9
9. Ken Burkhart 4.6
10. Harry Brecheen 4.6
1944
1. Dizzy Trout 9.3
2. Hal Newhouser 7.8
3. Rip Sewell 6.0
4. Tex Hughson 5.7
5. Nels Potter 5.7
6. Jim Tobin 5.6
7. Fritz Ostermueller 5.5
8. Mort Cooper 5.3
9. Jack Kramer 5.2
10. Bucky Walters 5.2
1943
1. Spud Chandler 6.4
2. Tex Hughson 5.7
Mort Cooper 5.7
4. Hi Bithorn 5.5
5. Nate Andrews 5.1
6. Dizzy Trout 5.0
7. Rip Sewell 5.0
8. Tiny Bonham 4.9
9. Tommy Bridges 4.9
10. Max Lanier 4.8
1942
1. Mort Cooper 8.2
2. Tex Hughson 6.2
3. Al Benton 5.6
4. Hal White 5.5
5. Ray Starr 5.4
6. Ted Lyons 4.8
7. Johnny Niggeling 4.7
8. Johnny Vander Meer 4.6
9. Johnny Beazley 4.3
10. Hal Newhouser 4.1
1941
1. Thornton Lee 8.6
2. Bob Feller 8.2
3. Whit Wyatt 6.7
4. Bucky Walters 6.6
5. Elmer Riddle 5.9
6. Al Benton 5.6
7. Ernie White 5.4
8. Eddie Smith 5.3
9. Bob Muncrief 4.6
10. Johnny Vander Meer 4.2
1940
1. Bob Feller 9.9
2. Bobo Newsom 7.4
3. Claude Passeau 6.9
4. Johnny Rigney 6.7
5. Bucky Walters 6.5
6. Dutch Leonard 5.1
7. Tommy Bridges 5.0
8. Schoolboy Rowe 5.0
9. Larry French 4.9
10. Johnny Babich 4.8
1939
1. Bob Feller 9.2
2. Bucky Walters 8.2
3. Bobo Newsom 8.2
4. Lefty Grove 7.1
5. Claude Passeau 6.0
6. Hugh Casey 5.2
7. Bob Bowman 5.2
8. Bill Lee 5.1
9. Luke Hamlin 4.8
10. Dutch Leonard 4.8
1938
1. Bill Lee 8.0
2. Thornton Lee 5.5
3. Paul Derringer 5.5
4. Red Ruffing 5.3
5. Mel Harder 5.2
6. Bob Feller 5.1
Lefty Grove 5.1
8. Clay Bryant 5.1
9. George Caster 5.0
10. Bobo Newsom 4.8
1937
1. Lefty Grove 9.8
2. Lefty Gomez 9.2
3. Red Ruffing 6.2
Johnny Allen 6.2
5. Jack Wilson 5.7
6. Jim Turner 5.5
7. Cliff Melton 4.9
8. Monty Stratton 4.9
9. Lee Grissom 4.5
10. Dizzy Dean 4.5
1936
1. Lefty Grove 11.2
2. Carl Hubbell 9.7
3. Dizzy Dean 7.3
4. Johnny Allen 7.3
5. Wes Ferrell 6.8
6. Van Mungo 6.6
7. Tommy Bridges 6.4
8. Harry Kelley 6.2
9. Danny MacFayden 5.7
10. Ed Brandt 5.2
1935
1. Lefty Grove 9.4
2. Wes Ferrell 8.2
3. Mel Harder 7.3
4. Cy Blanton 7.2
5. Dizzy Dean 7.1
6. Curt Davis 7.1
7. Ivy Andrews 6.4
8. Paul Dean 5.7
9. Syl Johnson 5.2
10. Willis Hudlin 5.1
1934
1. Dizzy Dean 8.9
2. Curt Davis 8.6
3. Lefty Gomez 8.4
4. Mel Harder 8.0
5. Carl Hubbell 7.3
6. Bobo Newsom 6.1
7. Schoolboy Rowe 5.7
8. Fritz Ostermueller 5.5
9. Tommy Bridges 5.4
10. Paul Dean 5.1
1933
1. Carl Hubbell 9.0
2. Lefty Grove 8.4
3. Bump Hadley 7.4
4. Lon Warneke 6.6
5. Mel Harder 5.6
6. Dizzy Dean 5.5
7. Firpo Marberry 5.4
8. Hal Schumacher 5.3
9. Van Mungo 5.2
10. Ed Brandt 5.1
1932
1. Lefty Grove 9.5
2. Lon Warneke 6.9
3. Wes Ferrell 6.9
4. Carl Hubbell 6.8
5. General Crowder 6.6
6. Red Ruffing 6.6
7. Dizzy Dean 5.9
8. Mel Harder 5.8
9. Ted Lyons 5.2
10. Flint Rhem 4.9
1931
1. Lefty Grove 10.4
2. Ray Benge 6.2
3. Wes Ferrell 6.2
4. Lefty Gomez 5.8
5. Watty Clark 5.8
6. Rube Walberg 5.7
7. George Uhle 5.6
8. Ed Brandt 5.5
9. Bill Walker 5.4
10. George Earnshaw 4.9
1930
1. Lefty Grove 10.4
2. Wes Ferrell 8.3
3. Dazzy Vance 7.3
4. Lefty Stewart 7.2
5. George Uhle 6.2
6. Vic Sorrell 5.8
7. Ted Lyons 5.3
8. Milt Gaston 5.3
9. Phil Collins 5.2
10. Bob Smith 4.9
1929
1. Willis Hudlin 7.5
2. Lefty Grove 7.3
3. Firpo Marberry 6.7
4. Rube Walberg 6.3
5. Sam Gray 6.2
6. Watty Clark 6.1
7. Wes Ferrell 6.0
8. George Earnshaw 5.7
9. Burleigh Grimes 5.3
10. Dazzy Vance 5.2
1928
1. Dazzy Vance 10.1
2. Lefty Grove 7.1
3. Larry Benton 7.0
4. Tommy Thomas 6.6
5. Herb Pennock 5.9
6. Garland Braxton 5.9
7. Burleigh Grimes 5.8
8. Bill Sherdel 5.6
9. Sheriff Blake 5.5
10. Sad Sam Jones 5.4
1927
1. Tommy Thomas 8.3
2. Dazzy Vance 7.7
3. Ted Lyons 7.3
4. Ray Kremer 7.0
5. Wilcy Moore 6.6
6. Jesse Petty 6.5
7. Pete Alexander 6.2
8. Waite Hoyt 6.0
9. Lefty Grove 5.7
10. Jesse Haines 5.4
1926
1. George Uhle 8.9
2. Hal Carlson 8.3
3. Lefty Grove 7.5
4. Ray Kremer 6.2
5. Ted Lyons 5.9
6. Jesse Petty 5.4
7. Charlie Root 5.2
8. Eddie Rommel 4.9
9. Urban Shocker 4.9
10. Doug McWeeny 4.1
1925
1. Herb Pennock 6.6
2. Eppa Rixey 6.5
3. Dolf Luque 6.3
Stan Coveleski 6.3
5. Pete Donohue 6.1
6. Slim Harriss 6.0
7. Dazzy Vance 6.0
8. Urban Shocker 5.7
9. Eddie Rommel 5.5
10. Howard Ehmke 5.5
1924
1. Dazzy Vance 10.5
2. Howard Ehmke 8.3
3. Herb Pennock 8.1
4. Walter Johnson 6.8
5. Sherry Smith 5.9
6. Joe Shaute 5.8
7. Alex Ferguson 5.5
8. Jesse Barnes 5.4
9. Jack Quinn 5.3
10. Stan Baumgartner 5.2
1923
1. Dolf Luque 10.7
2. Jimmy Ring 8.1
3. Urban Shocker 6.2
4. Herb Pennock 6.1
5. Howard Ehmke 6.1
6. George Uhle 6.0
7. Elam Vangilder 5.9
8. Eppa Rixey 5.9
9. Eddie Rommel 5.4
10. Pete Alexander 5.2
1922
1. Red Faber 9.6
2. Eddie Rommel 7.4
3. Bob Shawkey 7.2
4. Urban Shocker 7.1
5. Stan Coveleski 6.6
6. Wilbur Cooper 6.5
7. Johnny Morrison 6.3
8. Herman Pillette 5.8
9. Walter Johnson 5.4
10. Jack Quinn 5.2
1921
1. Red Faber 11.4
2. Urban Shocker 7.8
3. Burleigh Grimes 7.8
4. Stan Coveleski 7.3
5. George Mogridge 6.9
6. Sad Sam Jones 6.7
7. Carl Mays 6.0
8. Waite Hoyt 5.7
9. Eddie Rommel 5.4
10. Eppa Rixey 5.1
Whitey Glazner 5.1
1920
1. Pete Alexander 11.9
2. Jim Bagby 9.0
3. Stan Coveleski 8.7
4. Bob Shawkey 8.1
5. Burleigh Grimes 7.1
6. Urban Shocker 6.5
7. Wilbur Cooper 6.1
8. Carl Mays 6.1
9. Babe Adams 5.9
10. Red Faber 5.7
1919
1. Walter Johnson 10.6
2. Eddie Cicotte 9.6
3. Pete Alexander 7.4
4. Babe Adams 7.4
5. Hippo Vaughn 7.3
6. Stan Coveleski 6.7
7. Jim Shaw 6.4
8. Allan Sothoron 6.1
9. Leon Cadore 5.8
10. Lefty Williams 5.4
1918
1. Walter Johnson 10.4
2. Stan Coveleski 9.9
3. Scott Perry 8.2
4. Hippo Vaughn 7.7
5. Lefty Tyler 6.9
6. Burleigh Grimes 4.4
7. Jim Bagby 4.3
8. Harry Harper 4.3
9. Wilbur Cooper 4.3
10. Brad Hogg 4.3
1917
1. Eddie Cicotte 11.4
2. Pete Alexander 9.2
3. Jim Bagby 8.3
Stan Coveleski 8.3
5. Wilbur Cooper 7.1
6. Walter Johnson 6.8
7. Babe Ruth 6.5
8. Hippo Vaughn 6.5
9. Carl Mays 5.8
10. Jeff Pfeffer 5.3
1916
1. Pete Alexander 11.0
2. Walter Johnson 9.9
3. Babe Ruth 8.8
4. Harry Coveleski 6.9
5. Jeff Pfeffer 6.5
6. Bob Shawkey 6.5
7. Hippo Vaughn 6.4
8. Wilbur Cooper 5.8
9. Bullet Joe Bush 5.4
10. Dutch Leonard 5.1
1915
1. Walter Johnson 11.5
2. Pete Alexander 10.9
3. Dave Davenport 8.5
4. Fred Toney 8.0
5. Guy Morton 7.0
6. Eddie Plank 6.4
7. Al Mamaux 6.1
8. Jim Scott 6.1
9. Jeff Pfeffer 5.8
10. Carl Weilman 5.5
1914
1. Walter Johnson 11.7
2. Dutch Leonard 9.4
3. Pete Alexander 8.7
4. Cy Falkenberg 8.3
5. Bill James 7.8
6. Jeff Pfeffer 7.6
7. Carl Weilman 7.0
8. Claude Hendrix 6.9
9. Russ Ford 6.6
10. Ray Caldwell 6.5
1913
1. Walter Johnson 15.1
2. Reb Russell 8.9
3. Babe Adams 8.3
4. Jim Scott 7.6
5. Eddie Cicotte 7.5
6. Cy Falkenberg 7.2
7. Christy Mathewson 7.1
8. Pete Alexander 6.5
9. Willie Mitchell 6.0
10. Tom Seaton 6.0
1912
1. Walter Johnson 13.2
2. Ed Walsh 11.4
3. Smoky Joe Wood 10.1
4. Nap Rucker 8.1
5. Christy Mathewson 7.7
6. Vean Gregg 7.5
7. Jack Warhop 7.0
8. Pete Alexander 6.3
9. Rube Marquard 6.0
10. Slim Sallee 6.0
1911
1. Ed Walsh 9.2
2. Vean Gregg 8.8
3. Walter Johnson 8.5
4. Nap Rucker 8.5
5. Pete Alexander 8.1
6. Christy Mathewson 7.9
7. Russ Ford 7.5
8. Rube Marquard 6.4
9. Babe Adams 6.3
10. Eddie Plank 6.3
1910
1. Russ Ford 11.4
2. Ed Walsh 11.1
3. Walter Johnson 10.4
4. Jack Coombs 9.5
5. Christy Mathewson 8.1
6. Nap Rucker 6.8
7. Ray Collins 6.1
8. Earl Moore 5.7
9. Hippo Vaughn 5.3
10. Chief Bender 5.1
1909
1. Christy Mathewson 9.7
2. Mordecai Brown 9.5
3. Nap Rucker 7.6
4. Orval Overall 7.3
5. Frank Smith 7.1
6. Cy Morgan 6.6
7. Ed Walsh 6.3
8. Earl Moore 5.9
9. Harry Krause 5.7
10. Ed Reulbach 5.6
1908
1. Christy Mathewson 11.8
2. Ed Walsh 10.3
3. Cy Young 9.4
4. Mordecai Brown 9.2
5. George McQuillan 9.1
6. Addie Joss 8.5
7. Eddie Plank 7.6
8. Hooks Wiltse 6.9
9. Rube Vickers 6.2
10. Kaiser Wilhelm 5.9
1907
1. Christy Mathewson 8.6
2. Ed Walsh 7.7
3. Cy Young 7.6
4. Addie Joss 6.9
5. Ed Karger 6.4
6. Ed Killian 6.3
Bob Ewing 6.3
8. Eddie Plank 6.3
9. Mordecai Brown 5.8
10. Carl Lundgren 5.7
1906
1. Vic Willis 8.3
2. Al Orth 8.1
3. Mordecai Brown 7.4
4. Tully Sparks 7.3
5. Doc White 5.8
6. Jake Weimer 5.7
7. Rube Waddell 5.6
8. Bill Duggleby 5.5
9. Jack Taylor 5.4
10. Bob Ewing 5.1
1905
1. Irv Young 9.9
2. Christy Mathewson 9.6
3. Rube Waddell 9.4
4. Ed Reulbach 9.1
5. Cy Young 7.1
6. Ed Killian 6.9
7. Eddie Plank 6.7
8. Bob Ewing 6.6
9. Addie Joss 6.2
10. Harry Howell 5.9
1904
1. Rube Waddell 11.3
2. Jack Chesbro 10.6
3. Joe McGinnity 9.6
4. Cy Young 9.2
5. Eddie Plank 8.8
6. Kid Nichols 8.5
7. Noodles Hahn 6.6
8. Jack Taylor 6.4
9. Jake Weimer 6.1
10. Harry Howell 6.0
1903
1. Joe McGinnity 11.7
2. Christy Mathewson 9.9
3. Rube Waddell 8.5
4. Noodles Hahn 7.7
5. Bill Donovan 7.0
6. Eddie Plank 6.9
7. Cy Young 6.8
8. Willie Sudhoff 6.6
9. Sam Leever 6.5
10. Bill Dinneen 6.3
1902
1. Cy Young 9.7
2. Rube Waddell 9.4
3. Jack Taylor 9.2
4. Joe McGinnity 8.8
5. Noodles Hahn 8.6
6. Vic Willis 8.4
7. Togie Pittinger 7.5
8. Bill Dinneen 6.7
9. Doc White 6.4
10. Win Mercer 6.1
1901
1. Cy Young 12.6
2. Christy Mathewson 9.0
3. Vic Willis 8.7
4. Joe McGinnity 8.0
5. Noodles Hahn 7.9
6. Roscoe Miller 6.9
7. Al Orth 6.9
8. Red Donahue 6.6
9. Bill Dinneen 6.1
10. Bill Donovan 5.9
1900
1. Cy Young 7.7
2. Bill Dinneen 6.7
3. Noodles Hahn 6.4
4. Joe McGinnity 5.8
5. Deacon Phillippe 5.1
6. Kid Nichols 4.8
7. Sam Leever 4.8
8. Clark Griffith 4.5
9. Ned Garvin 4.3
10. Brickyard Kennedy 4.2
1899
1. Vic Willis 10.3
2. Joe McGinnity 9.1
3. Frank Kitson 8.4
4. Cy Young 8.4
5. Noodles Hahn 8.4
6. Jesse Tannehill 7.7
7. Jay Hughes 7.4
8. Kid Nichols 7.3
9. Sam Leever 6.4
10. Jack Powell 6.2
1898
1. Kid Nichols 10.8
2. Clark Griffith 10.7
3. Doc McJames 8.1
4. Al Maul 7.4
5. Bert Cunningham 7.0
6. Cy Young 6.7
7. Jesse Tannehill 6.6
8. Ted Lewis 6.4
9. Pink Hawley 5.9
10. Jack Powell 5.8
1897
1. Kid Nichols 10.7
2. Amos Rusie 8.0
3. Theodore Breitenstein 7.5
4. Cy Young 7.4
5. Jack Powell 5.9
6. Frank Dwyer 4.9
Billy Rhines 4.9
8. Joe Corbett 4.8
9. Jerry Nops 4.7
10. Clark Griffith 4.5
1896
1. Cy Young 9.9
2. Nig Cuppy 9.7
3. Pink Hawley 8.2
4. Frank Killen 7.6
5. Bill Hoffer 7.3
6. Frank Dwyer 7.2
7. Kid Nichols 6.7
8. Clark Griffith 6.1
9. Red Ehret 6.1
10. Billy Rhines 5.5
1895
1. Cy Young 12.0
2. Pink Hawley 10.0
3. Kid Nichols 9.9
4. Theodore Breitenstein 8.8
5. Clark Griffith 8.6
6. Bill Hoffer 8.2
7. Nig Cuppy 7.8
8. Amos Rusie 6.7
9. Adonis Terry 5.3
10. Dad Clarke 5.1
1894
1. Amos Rusie 13.7
2. Jouett Meekin 10.8
3. Cy Young 9.5
4. Theodore Breitenstein 9.3
5. Kid Nichols 8.0
6. George Hemming 6.5
7. Pink Hawley 6.2
8. Clark Griffith 6.2
9. Sadie McMahon 6.1
10. Jack Taylor 5.6
1893
1. Kid Nichols 12.0
2. Theodore Breitenstein 11.5
3. Cy Young 11.2
4. Amos Rusie 11.0
5. Frank Killen 7.3
6. Sadie McMahon 6.3
7. Brickyard Kennedy 5.8
8. Willie McGill 5.4
9. Tony Mullane 4.9
10. Ice Box Chamberlain 4.5
1892
1. Cy Young 13.9
2. Gus Weyhing 9.0
3. Kid Nichols 9.0
4. Bill Hutchison 8.8
5. Amos Rusie 7.3
6. Ed Stein 6.9
7. Nig Cuppy 6.8
8. Frank Dwyer 6.6
9. Tim Keefe 6.0
10. Tony Mullane 6.0
1891
1. Bill Hutchison 10.1
2. Gus Weyhing 9.9
3. John Clarkson 9.7
4. Sadie McMahon 9.7
5. Kid Nichols 9.6
6. Amos Rusie 8.4
7. Harry Staley 7.9
8. Jack Stivetts 7.7
9. Charlie Buffinton 7.5
10. Phil Knell 7.2
1890
1. Silver King 13.2
2. Kid Nichols 12.9
3. Kid Gleason 12.3
4. Billy Rhines 11.0
5. Sadie McMahon 10.7
6. Scott Stratton 9.2
7. Bill Hutchison 8.8
8. John Clarkson 8.6
9. Old Hoss Radbourn 8.0
10. Mark Baldwin 7.9
1889
1. John Clarkson 16.7
2. Charlie Buffinton 11.3
3. Ice Box Chamberlain 9.2
4. Jesse Duryea 8.4
5. Silver King 8.3
6. Matt Kilroy 7.2
7. Ben Sanders 6.9
8. Mickey Welch 6.7
9. Bob Caruthers 6.4
10. Henry Boyle 5.9
1888
1. Silver King 14.7
2. Charlie Buffinton 12.1
3. Tim Keefe 10.3
4. Ed Seward 10.1
5. Mickey Welch 8.0
6. Ben Sanders 7.8
7. Gus Krock 6.8
8. Pud Galvin 6.6
9. Ed Morris 6.4
10. Bob Caruthers 5.7
1887
1. John Clarkson 14.9
2. Matt Kilroy 11.0
3. Dan Casey 10.4
4. Mike Smith 10.3
5. Toad Ramsey 8.4
6. Charlie Ferguson 7.7
7. Jim Whitney 7.5
8. Tony Mullane 7.3
9. Tim Keefe 7.1
10. Ed Seward 7.0
1886
1. Toad Ramsey 12.6
2. Ed Morris 10.9
3. Lady Baldwin 10.8
4. Charlie Ferguson 10.5
5. Tim Keefe 10.0
6. Dave Foutz 9.7
7. Bob Caruthers 7.6
8. Jim McCormick 7.4
9. John Clarkson 7.3
10. Matt Kilroy 6.3
1885
1. Ed Morris 13.3
2. John Clarkson 12.9
3. Mickey Welch 10.4
4. Bob Caruthers 9.5
5. Hardie Henderson 7.4
6. Old Hoss Radbourn 7.4
7. Guy Hecker 7.4
8. Tim Keefe 6.9
9. Ed Daily 6.6
10. Henry Porter 6.5
1884
1. Pud Galvin 20.5
2. Old Hoss Radbourn 19.1
3. Guy Hecker 15.5
4. Charlie Buffinton 14.9
5. Jim McCormick 14.5
6. Mickey Welch 12.1
7. Tony Mullane 11.6
8. Charlie Sweeney 8.8
9. Billy Taylor 8.7
10. Ed Morris 8.6
1883
1. Tim Keefe 19.9
2. Old Hoss Radbourn 13.1
3. Jim Whitney 11.4
4. Pud Galvin 11.0
5. Will White 9.0
6. Jim McCormick 8.5
7. Hugh Daily 6.9
8. Larry Corcoran 6.5
9. Tony Mullane 6.5
10. Jumbo McGinnis 6.3
1882
1. Jim McCormick 11.2
2. Will White 11.0
3. Stump Weidman 10.2
4. Old Hoss Radbourn 7.5
5. Sam Weaver 6.5
6. Larry Corcoran 6.0
7. Jim Whitney 5.7
8. Tony Mullane 5.3
9. Denny Driscoll 5.2
10. Fred Goldsmith 4.9
1881
1. George Derby 8.7
2. Pud Galvin 8.4
3. Jim Whitney 7.8
4. Jim McCormick 6.4
5. Mickey Welch 6.0
6. Old Hoss Radbourn 4.5
7. Lee Richmond 4.4
8. Stump Weidman 3.2
9. Tim Keefe 2.9
10. John Ward 2.7
1880
1. Jim McCormick 10.5
2. Lee Richmond 8.2
3. Larry Corcoran 7.2
4. John Ward 6.7
5. Mickey Welch 5.4
6. Will White 5.2
7. Tim Keefe 4.7
8. Pud Galvin 3.7
9. Fred Goldsmith 3.4
10. George Bradley 3.2
1879
1. Tommy Bond 14.3
2. Jim McCormick 10.0
3. Pud Galvin 8.9
4. John Ward 7.3
5. Terry Larkin 5.0
6. Harry McCormick 4.9
7. Will White 3.8
8. Bobby Mathews 2.6
9. Bill McGunnigle 1.3
Frank Hankinson 1.3
1878
1. Tommy Bond 13.9
2. Sam Weaver 10.4
3. John Ward 4.6
4. Terry Larkin 4.1
5. Jim McCormick 2.3
6. Will White 2.1
7. Bobby Mitchell 1.5
8. Fred Corey .4
9. Joe Ellick .2
10. Tom Healey .0
1877
1. Jim Devlin 13.2
2. Tommy Bond 11.7
3. Tricky Nichols 4.0
4. George Bradley 2.9
5. Laurie Reis 1.9
6. Terry Larkin 1.7
7. Bobby Mitchell 1.0
8. Joe Blong .6
9. Will White .4
10. Joe Battin .1
1876
1. Jim Devlin 17.7
2. Tommy Bond 10.4
3. Al Spalding 9.4
4. George Bradley 8.8
5. Candy Cummings 4.3
6. Bobby Mathews 3.3
7. Cal McVey 1.4
8. Flip Lafferty .4
9. Foghorn Bradley .4
10. Joe Blong .2
1875
1. Al Spalding 12.8
2. Candy Cummings 12.3
3. Tommy Bond 10.9
4. Dick McBride 9.2
5. George Zettlein 8.4
6. Bobby Mathews 8.3
7. Cherokee Fisher 8.2
8. George Bradley 3.1
9. Joe Borden 2.0
10. Jack Manning .9
1874
1. Bobby Mathews 13.6
2. Al Spalding 8.9
3. Dick McBride 6.8
4. Candy Cummings 6.7
5. Cherokee Fisher 5.0
6. George Zettlein 3.7
7. Jack Manning 1.1
8. Tommy Bond .4
9. John Hatfield .1
10. Harry Wright .1
1873
1. Bobby Mathews 10.0
2. George Zettlein 8.5
3. Al Spalding 7.9
4. Candy Cummings 7.8
5. Dick McBride 6.1
6. Cherokee Fisher 1.3
7. John McMullin .3
8. Hugh Campbell .2
9. Chick Fulmer .1
Phonney Martin .1
1872
1. Al Spalding 11.3
2. Candy Cummings 8.5
3. George Zettlein 6.5
4. Bobby Mathews 6.4
5. Dick McBride 4.4
6. Cherokee Fisher 3.0
7. Harry Wright .9
8. Charlie Pabor .4
9. Jim Britt .3
1871
1. George Zettlein 5.0
2. Dick McBride 3.7
3. Al Spalding 3.6
4. Rynie Wolters 3.1
5. Asa Brainard 2.2
6. Cherokee Fisher 2.1
7. Al Pratt 1.9
8. Bobby Mathews 1.7
9. Bill Stearns .7
10. Ed Pinkham .3