New York Mutuals Top 50 Career Batting Leaders

Team Name: New York Mutuals

Seasons: 1 (1876 to 1876)

Record: 21-35, .375 W-L%

Playoff Appearances: 0

Pennants: 0

World Championships: 0

Winningest Manager: Bill Craver, 21-35, .375 W-L%

Career Top 50 Leaders

WAR Position Players †

1. Joe Start 0.7

2. Jimmy Hallinan 0.4

3. Nat Hicks 0.2

4. Jim Holdsworth 0.1

Robert Maloney 0.1

Fred Treacy 0.1

Offensive WAR †

1. Jimmy Hallinan 1.8

2. Joe Start 1.0

3. Nat Hicks 0.6

Jim Holdsworth 0.6

5. Bill Craver 0.2

6. Robert Maloney 0.1

Defensive WAR †

1. Fred Treacy 0.2

Games Played

1. Eddie Booth 57

Al Nichols 57

Fred Treacy 57

4. Bill Craver 56

Bobby Mathews 56

Joe Start 56

7. Jimmy Hallinan 54

8. Jim Holdsworth 52

9. Nat Hicks 45

10. John Hayes 5

11. George Bechtel 2

Robert Maloney 2

Jim Shanley 2

Pete Treacey 2

15. George Fair 1

Davy Force 1

John Hatfield 1

George Heubel 1

Terry Larkin 1

John McGuinness 1

Nealy Phelps 1

George Seward 1

Bob Valentine 1

Billy West 1

At Bats

1. Joe Start 264

2. Fred Treacy 256

3. Bill Craver 246

4. Jim Holdsworth 241

5. Jimmy Hallinan 240

6. Eddie Booth 228

7. Bobby Mathews 218

8. Al Nichols 212

9. Nat Hicks 188

10. John Hayes 21

11. George Bechtel 10

12. Jim Shanley 8

13. Robert Maloney 7

14. Pete Treacey 5

15. George Fair 4

John Hatfield 4

George Heubel 4

Terry Larkin 4

John McGuinness 4

Billy West 4

21. Davy Force 3

Nealy Phelps 3

George Seward 3

Bob Valentine 3

Plate Appearances

1. Joe Start 265

2. Fred Treacy 257

3. Bill Craver 248

4. Jimmy Hallinan 242

Jim Holdsworth 242

6. Eddie Booth 230

7. Bobby Mathews 221

8. Al Nichols 214

9. Nat Hicks 191

10. John Hayes 21

11. George Bechtel 10

12. Jim Shanley 8

13. Robert Maloney 7

14. Pete Treacey 6

15. George Fair 4

John Hatfield 4

George Heubel 4

Terry Larkin 4

John McGuinness 4

Billy West 4

21. Davy Force 3

Nealy Phelps 3

George Seward 3

Bob Valentine 3

Runs Scored

1. Fred Treacy 47

2. Jimmy Hallinan 45

3. Joe Start 40

4. Bill Craver 24

5. Jim Holdsworth 23

6. Nat Hicks 20

Al Nichols 20

8. Bobby Mathews 19

9. Eddie Booth 17

10. George Bechtel 2

11. John Hayes 1

Robert Maloney 1

Pete Treacey 1

Hits

1. Joe Start 73

2. Jimmy Hallinan 67

3. Jim Holdsworth 64

4. Bill Craver 55

5. Fred Treacy 54

6. Eddie Booth 49

7. Nat Hicks 44

8. Bobby Mathews 40

9. Al Nichols 38

10. George Bechtel 3

John Hayes 3

12. Robert Maloney 2

13. John Hatfield 1

Jim Shanley 1

Total Bases

1. Jimmy Hallinan 92

2. Joe Start 79

3. Jim Holdsworth 71

4. Fred Treacy 61

5. Bill Craver 59

6. Eddie Booth 53

7. Nat Hicks 50

8. Bobby Mathews 46

9. Al Nichols 42

10. John Hayes 7

11. Robert Maloney 4

12. George Bechtel 3

13. John Hatfield 1

Jim Shanley 1

Doubles

1. Jimmy Hallinan 7

2. Joe Start 6

3. Fred Treacy 5

4. Bill Craver 4

Nat Hicks 4

Bobby Mathews 4

Al Nichols 4

8. Jim Holdsworth 3

9. Eddie Booth 2

Triples

1. Jimmy Hallinan 6

2. John Hayes 2

Jim Holdsworth 2

4. Eddie Booth 1

Nat Hicks 1

Robert Maloney 1

Bobby Mathews 1

Fred Treacy 1

Home Runs

1. Jimmy Hallinan 2

Runs Batted In

1. Jimmy Hallinan 36

2. Bill Craver 22

3. Joe Start 21

4. Jim Holdsworth 19

5. Fred Treacy 18

6. Nat Hicks 15

7. Bobby Mathews 9

Al Nichols 9

9. Eddie Booth 7

10. John Hayes 2

Robert Maloney 2

12. John Hatfield 1

Bases on Balls

1. Nat Hicks 3

Bobby Mathews 3

3. Eddie Booth 2

Bill Craver 2

Jimmy Hallinan 2

Al Nichols 2

7. Jim Holdsworth 1

Joe Start 1

Fred Treacy 1

Pete Treacey 1

Strikeouts

1. Bill Craver 7

2. Fred Treacy 5

3. Eddie Booth 4

Jimmy Hallinan 4

Nat Hicks 4

6. Al Nichols 3

7. Jim Holdsworth 2

Bobby Mathews 2

Joe Start 2

10. Robert Maloney 1

Nealy Phelps 1

Singles

1. Joe Start 67

2. Jim Holdsworth 59

3. Jimmy Hallinan 52

4. Bill Craver 51

5. Fred Treacy 48

6. Eddie Booth 46

7. Nat Hicks 39

8. Bobby Mathews 35

9. Al Nichols 34

10. George Bechtel 3

11. John Hatfield 1

John Hayes 1

Robert Maloney 1

Jim Shanley 1

Runs Created

1. Jimmy Hallinan 26

2. Joe Start 22

3. Jim Holdsworth 19

4. Bill Craver 14

5. Fred Treacy 13

6. Eddie Booth 12

Nat Hicks 12

8. Bobby Mathews 9

9. Al Nichols 8

10. George Bechtel 1

John Hayes 1

Robert Maloney 1

Adj. Batting Runs

1. Jimmy Hallinan 6

2. Robert Maloney 1

Adj. Batting Wins

1. Jimmy Hallinan 0.7

2. Robert Maloney 0.1

Extra Base Hits

1. Jimmy Hallinan 15

2. Joe Start 6

Fred Treacy 6

4. Nat Hicks 5

Jim Holdsworth 5

Bobby Mathews 5

7. Bill Craver 4

Al Nichols 4

9. Eddie Booth 3

10. John Hayes 2

11. Robert Maloney 1

Times On Base

1. Joe Start 74

2. Jimmy Hallinan 69

3. Jim Holdsworth 65

4. Bill Craver 57

5. Fred Treacy 55

6. Eddie Booth 51

7. Nat Hicks 47

8. Bobby Mathews 43

9. Al Nichols 40

10. George Bechtel 3

John Hayes 3

12. Robert Maloney 2

13. John Hatfield 1

Jim Shanley 1

Pete Treacey 1

Outs Made

1. Fred Treacy 202

2. Bill Craver 191

Joe Start 191

4. Eddie Booth 179

5. Bobby Mathews 178

6. Jim Holdsworth 177

7. Al Nichols 174

8. Jimmy Hallinan 173

9. Nat Hicks 144

10. John Hayes 18

11. George Bechtel 7

Jim Shanley 7

13. Robert Maloney 5

Pete Treacey 5

15. George Fair 4

George Heubel 4

Terry Larkin 4

John McGuinness 4

Billy West 4

20. Davy Force 3

John Hatfield 3

Nealy Phelps 3

George Seward 3

Bob Valentine 3

Data Notes

More Mutuals Pages

Mutuals History

Year-by-Year Stats

Leaders

People

Starters

Players

Honors

Hall of Fame

All-Stars

Other

New York Mutuals Top 50 Career Batting Leaders

Career Top 50 Leaders

WAR Position Players †

Offensive WAR †

Defensive WAR †

Games Played

At Bats

Plate Appearances

Runs Scored

Hits

Total Bases

Doubles

Triples

Home Runs

Runs Batted In

Bases on Balls

Strikeouts

Singles

Runs Created

Adj. Batting Runs

Adj. Batting Wins

Extra Base Hits

Times On Base

Outs Made

Data Notes

More Mutuals Pages

Full Site Menu

FAQs, Tip & Tricks