| 1 | Charlie Atherton | 25.192 | May 30 | Aug 22, 1899 | 5/ | WHS | -0.7 | 5-10 | 160 | R | R | Nov 19, 1873 | New Brunswick, NJ, US | | Pennsylvania State University (State College, PA) | | Charles Morgan Herbert |
| 2 | Harvey Bailey | 22.218 | Jun 30 | May 21, 1900 | 1 | BSN | 1.5 | 6-0 | 160 | | L | Nov 24, 1876 | Palmyra, MI, US | | | | Harvey Francis |
| 3 | Jimmy Barrett | 24.169 | Sep 13 | May 13, 1908 | | CIN | 19.9 | 5-7 | 170 | L | R | Mar 28, 1875 | Athol, MA, US | | | | James Erigena |
| 4 | John Barry | 20.215 | May 30 | Oct 7, 1908 | 356/4 | WHS | 3.7 | | | R | R | Oct 27, 1878 | Newburgh, NY, US | | Niagara University (Lewiston, NY) | | John C. |
| 5 | Burley Bayer | 23.180 | Jun 17 | Jun 17, 1899 | /6 | LOU | -0.2 | | 175 | | | Dec 19, 1875 | Louisville, KY, US | | | | Christopher Andy |
| 6 | Ginger Beaumont | 22.272 | Apr 21 | Oct 15, 1910 | /3 | PIT | 31.0 | 5-8 | 190 | L | R | Jul 23, 1876 | Rochester, WI, US | | Beloit College (Beloit, WI) | | Clarence Howeth |
| 7 | Erve Beck | 21.062 | Sep 19 | Sep 27, 1902 | /46 | BRO | 2.5 | 5-10 | 168 | R | R | Jul 19, 1878 | Toledo, OH, US | | | | Ervin F. |
| 8 | Bill Bernhard | 28.039 | Apr 24 | Sep 27, 1907 | 1 | PHI | 15.9 | 6-1 | 205 | B | R | Mar 16, 1871 | Clarence, NY, US | | | | William Henry |
| 9 | Bill Bradley | 21.194 | Aug 26 | Sep 28, 1915 | 5/6 | CHC | 36.6 | 6-0 | 185 | R | R | Feb 13, 1878 | Cleveland, OH, US | | | | William Joseph |
| 10 | Kitty Brashear | 21.302 | Jun 25 | Jul 30, 1899 | /1 | LOU | -0.1 | 5-11 | 205 | R | R | Aug 27, 1877 | Mansfield, OH, US | | | | Norman Cobb |
| 11 | George Bristow | 28.337 | Apr 15 | May 8, 1899 | / | CLV | -0.1 | 5-10 | 170 | R | R | May 13, 1870 | Paw Paw, IL, US | | | | George Gates |
| 12 | Fritz Buelow | 23.227 | Sep 28 | Jul 13, 1907 | /2 | STL | -1.2 | 5-10 | 170 | R | R | Feb 13, 1876 | Berlin, Berlin, DE | | | | Frederick William Alexander |
| 13 | Jack Chesbro | 25.037 | Jul 12 | Oct 2, 1909 | 1 | PIT | 42.9 | 5-9 | 180 | R | R | Jun 5, 1874 | North Adams, MA, US | | | | John Dwight |
| 14 | Pearce Chiles | 31.325 | Apr 18 | Oct 13, 1900 | 34 | PHI | 1.1 | 5-11 | 185 | R | R | May 28, 1867 | Deepwater, MO, US | | | | Pearce Nuget |
| 15 | Harry Colliflower | 30.132 | Jul 21 | Oct 12, 1899 | 1/3 | CLV | -2.6 | 5-11 | 175 | L | L | Mar 11, 1869 | Petersville, MD, US | | | | James Harry |
| 16 | Bill Coughlin | 21.028 | Aug 9 | Sep 23, 1908 | /5 | WHS | 8.5 | 5-9 | 140 | R | R | Jul 12, 1878 | Scranton, PA, US | | | | William Paul |
| 17 | Sam Crawford | 19.145 | Sep 10 | Sep 16, 1917 | | CIN | 75.9 | 6-0 | 190 | L | L | Apr 18, 1880 | Wahoo, NE, US | | | | Samuel Earl |
| 18 | Pete Cregan | 24.148 | Sep 8 | Jun 11, 1903 | / | NYG | -0.3 | 5-7 | 150 | R | R | Apr 13, 1875 | Kingston, NY, US | | | | Peter James |
| 19 | Pat Crisham | 21.335 | May 5 | Oct 9, 1899 | 32 | BLN | 0.0 | 6-0 | 168 | | | Jun 4, 1877 | Amesbury, MA, US | | | | Patrick J. |
| 20 | Harry Croft | 23.291 | May 19 | Sep 24, 1901 | | LOU | 0.0 | | | | | Aug 1, 1875 | Chicago, IL, US | | Niagara University (Lewiston, NY) | | Henry T. |
| 21 | Walter Curley | 25.184 | Sep 12 | Sep 22, 1899 | 4 | CHC | -0.2 | | | R | R | Mar 12, 1874 | Upton, MA, US | | University of Massachusetts Amherst (Amherst, MA), College of the Holy Cross (Worcester, MA), University of Virginia (Charlottesville, VA) | | Walter James |
| 22 | Ira Davis | 28.288 | Apr 22 | May 3, 1899 | /63 | NYG | 0.0 | | 162 | | R | Jul 8, 1870 | Philadelphia, PA, US | | University of Pennsylvania (Philadelphia, PA) | | James Ira |
| 23 | Frank Dillon | 25.326 | Sep 8 | Oct 8, 1904 | 3 | PIT | 1.0 | 6-1 | 185 | L | R | Oct 17, 1873 | Normal, IL, US | | University of Wisconsin at Madison (Madison, WI) | | Frank Edward |
| 24 | Mike Donlin | 21.050 | Jul 19 | Oct 1, 1914 | 3/16 | STL | 29.1 | 5-9 | 170 | L | L | May 30, 1878 | Peoria, IL, US | | | | Michael Joseph |
| 25 | Jim Duncan | 28.017 | Jul 18 | Oct 15, 1899 | 2 | WHS | -0.5 | 5-8 | 140 | R | R | Jul 1, 1871 | Saltsburg, PA, US | | | | James William |
| 26 | Clay Fauver | 27.037 | Sep 7 | Sep 7, 1899 | /1 | LOU | 0.1 | 5-10 | | B | R | Aug 1, 1872 | North Eaton, OH, US | | Oberlin College (Oberlin, OH) | | Clayton King |
| 27 | Leo Fishel | 21.141 | May 3 | May 3, 1899 | /1 | NYG | 0.0 | 6-0 | 175 | R | R | Dec 13, 1877 | Babylon, NY, US | | Columbia University (New York, NY) | | Leo |
| 28 | Patsy Flaherty | 23.071 | Sep 8 | Sep 14, 1911 | /1 | LOU | 5.6 | 5-8 | 165 | L | L | Jun 29, 1876 | Mansfield, PA, US | | | | Patrick Joseph |
| 29 | Tom Fleming | 25.303 | Sep 19 | May 4, 1904 | | NYG | -0.8 | 5-11 | 155 | L | L | Nov 20, 1873 | Philadelphia, PA, US | | | | Thomas Vincent |
| 30 | Tim Flood | 22.195 | Sep 24 | Sep 24, 1903 | 4 | STL | -0.7 | 5-9 | 160 | B | R | Mar 13, 1877 | Montgomery City, MO, US | | | | Timothy Andrew |
| 31 | Charlie Frisbee | 25.140 | Jun 22 | May 13, 1900 | | BSN | 0.0 | 5-9 | 175 | B | R | Feb 2, 1874 | Dows, IA, US | | Grinnell College (Grinnell, IA) | | Charles Augustus |
| 32 | Emil Frisk | 24.322 | Sep 2 | Apr 23, 1907 | /1 | CIN | 1.4 | 6-1 | 190 | L | R | Oct 15, 1874 | Kalkaska, MI, US | | | | John Emil |
| 33 | Willie Garoni | 22.041 | Sep 7 | Sep 22, 1899 | /1 | NYG | -0.1 | 6-1 | 165 | R | R | Jul 28, 1877 | Fort Lee, NJ, US | | | | William |
| 34 | Billy Ging | 26.322 | Sep 25 | Sep 25, 1899 | /1 | BSN | 0.3 | 5-10 | 170 | R | R | Nov 7, 1872 | Elmira, NY, US | | | | William Joseph |
| 35 | Billy Goeckel | 27.341 | Aug 10 | Sep 21, 1899 | 3 | PHI | -0.3 | 5-11 | 162 | R | L | Sep 3, 1871 | Wilkes-Barre, PA, US | | Canisius College (Buffalo, NY), University of Pennsylvania (Philadelphia, PA) | | William John |
| 36 | Chummy Gray | 26.059 | Sep 14 | Oct 14, 1899 | /1 | PIT | 0.9 | 5-11 | 163 | R | R | Jul 17, 1873 | Rockland, ME, US | | | | George Edward |
| 37 | Noodles Hahn | 19.354 | Apr 18 | Jul 7, 1906 | 1 | CIN | 43.9 | 5-9 | 160 | L | L | Apr 29, 1879 | Nashville, TN, US | | | | Frank George |
| 38 | Scott Hardesty | 29.203 | Aug 17 | Sep 8, 1899 | 6/3 | NYG | -0.1 | | | | L | Jan 26, 1870 | Bellville, OH, US | | | | Scott Durbin |
| 39 | Jack Harper | 21.169 | Sep 18 | Jun 6, 1906 | /1 | CLV | 4.8 | 6-0 | 178 | R | R | Apr 2, 1878 | Galloway, PA, US | | | | Charles William |
| 40 | Charlie Harris | 21.217 | May 26 | Oct 14, 1899 | 5/46 | BLN | 0.1 | 5-8 | 200 | R | R | Oct 21, 1877 | Macon, GA, US | Signed by the Baltimore Orioles as an amateur free agent in 1899. | Mercer University (Macon, GA) | | Charles Jenkins |
| 41 | Charlie Hemphill | 23.068 | Jun 27 | Oct 3, 1911 | | STL | 15.9 | 5-9 | 160 | L | L | Apr 20, 1876 | Greenville, MI, US | | | | Charles Judson |
| 42 | Lefty Herring | 19.073 | May 16 | Sep 3, 1904 | /1 | WHS | 0.1 | 5-11 | 160 | L | L | Mar 4, 1880 | Philadelphia, PA, US | | | | Silas Clarke |
| 43 | Mike Hickey | 27.263 | Sep 14 | Sep 14, 1899 | /4 | BSN | 0.0 | 5-10 | 150 | R | R | Dec 25, 1871 | Chicopee, MA, US | | College of the Holy Cross (Worcester, MA) | | Michael Francis |
| 44 | Lefty Houtz | 23.322 | Jul 23 | Jul 26, 1899 | / | CIN | 0.2 | 5-10 | 170 | L | L | Sep 4, 1875 | Connersville, IN, US | | | | Fred Fritz |
| 45 | Rudy Hulswitt | 22.113 | Jun 16 | Aug 25, 1910 | /6 | LOU | 1.6 | 5-8 | 165 | R | R | Feb 23, 1877 | Newport, KY, US | | | | Rudolph Edward |
| 46 | Mike Kelley | 23.225 | Jul 15 | Oct 14, 1899 | 3 | LOU | 0.1 | 6-0 | 210 | R | R | Dec 2, 1875 | Templeton, MA, US | | | | Michael Joseph |
| 47 | Fred Ketchum | 24.047 | Sep 12 | May 4, 1901 | | LOU | -0.3 | 5-8 | 157 | L | R | Jul 27, 1875 | Elmira, NY, US | | State University of New York at Cortland (Cortland, NY) | | Frederick L. |
| 48 | Charlie Knepper | 28.097 | May 26 | Sep 26, 1899 | 1 | CLV | -1.8 | 6-2 | 202 | R | R | Feb 18, 1871 | Pickaway County, OH, US | | | | Charles |
| 49 | Eddie Kolb | 19.087 | Oct 15 | Oct 15, 1899 | /1 | CLV | -0.4 | 5-11 | | R | R | Jul 20, 1880 | Cincinnati, OH, US | | | | Edward William |
| 50 | Otto Krueger | 22.364 | Sep 16 | Sep 22, 1905 | /546 | CLV | 5.7 | 5-7 | 165 | R | R | Sep 17, 1876 | Chicago, IL, US | | | | Arthur William |
| 51 | Bob Langsford | 33.317 | Jun 18 | Jun 18, 1899 | /6 | LOU | -0.1 | 5-7 | 168 | L | L | Aug 5, 1865 | Louisville, KY, US | | | | Robert William |
| 52 | Bill Leith | 26.117 | Sep 25 | Sep 25, 1899 | /1 | WHS | -0.2 | 6-1 | 208 | | R | May 31, 1873 | Matteawan, NY, US | | | | William |
| 53 | Harry Lochhead | 23.018 | Apr 16 | May 15, 1901 | *6/41 | CLV | -1.8 | 5-11 | 172 | R | R | Mar 29, 1876 | Stockton, CA, US | | | | Robert Henry |
| 54 | Joe McGinnity | 28.029 | Apr 18 | Oct 5, 1908 | 1/ | BLN | 59.3 | 5-11 | 206 | R | R | Mar 20, 1871 | Cornwall, IL, US | | | | Joseph Jerome |
| 55 | Frank McManus | 24.356 | Sep 14 | Oct 8, 1904 | /2 | WHS | 0.0 | 5-10 | 180 | R | R | Sep 23, 1874 | Lawrence, MA, US | | | | Francis Edward |
| 56 | Frank McPartlin | 27.187 | Aug 22 | Aug 22, 1899 | /1 | NYG | -0.1 | 6-0 | 180 | | L | Feb 16, 1872 | Hoosick Falls, NY, US | | | | Frank |
| 57 | Tom Messitt | 25.049 | Sep 14 | Sep 20, 1899 | /2 | LOU | 0.0 | 5-9 | 177 | | R | Jul 27, 1874 | Philadelphia, PA, US | | | | Thomas John |
| 58 | Jack O'Brien | 26.068 | Apr 14 | Sep 28, 1903 | */5 | WHS | -0.6 | 6-1 | 165 | L | R | Feb 5, 1873 | Watervliet, NY, US | | | | John Joseph |
| 59 | John O'Neil | 25.254 | Sep 6 | Sep 5, 1902 | /2 | NYG | -0.3 | | | | R | Dec 26, 1873 | New York, NY, US | | | | John W. |
| 60 | Red Owens | 24.269 | Jul 28 | May 31, 1905 | /4 | PHI | -1.2 | 5-10 | 175 | R | R | Nov 1, 1874 | Pottsville, PA, US | | | | Thomas Llewellyn |
| 61 | Freddy Parent | 23.245 | Jul 14 | Apr 30, 1911 | /4 | STL | 35.8 | 5-7 | 154 | R | R | Nov 11, 1875 | Biddeford, ME, US | | | | Alfred Joseph |
| 62 | Jay Parker | 25.081 | Sep 27 | Sep 27, 1899 | /1 | PIT | 0.0 | 5-11 | 185 | L | R | Jul 8, 1874 | Theresa, NY, US | Signed as a Free Agent with the New York Giants in 1899. | | | Jay |
| 63 | Deacon Phillippe | 26.333 | Apr 21 | Aug 13, 1911 | 1/ | LOU | 35.4 | 6-0 | 180 | R | R | May 23, 1872 | Rural Retreat, VA, US | | | Rural Retreat HS (Rural Retreat, VA) | Charles Louis |
| 64 | Frank Quinn | 22.350 | Aug 9 | Oct 2, 1899 | /4 | CHC | -0.4 | 5-8 | 157 | | | Aug 24, 1876 | Sheffield, PA, US | | | | Franklin Cady |
| 65 | Dorsey Riddlemoser | 24.150 | Aug 22 | Aug 22, 1899 | /1 | WHS | -0.2 | | | R | R | Mar 25, 1875 | Frederick, MD, US | | | | Dorsey Lee |
| 66 | Mike Roach | 29.230 | Aug 10 | Oct 12, 1899 | 2/3 | WHS | -0.6 | 5-7 | 145 | | | Dec 23, 1869 | Driftwood, PA, US | | | | Michael Stephen |
| 67 | Skel Roach | 27.293 | Aug 9 | Aug 9, 1899 | /1 | CHC | 0.2 | 6-2 | | R | R | Oct 20, 1871 | Gdansk, Pomerania, PL | | Northwestern University (Evanston, IL) | | Rudolph Charles |
| 68 | Bobby Rothermel | 28.182 | Jun 18 | Jul 15, 1899 | /456 | BLN | -0.3 | 5-6 | 148 | | R | Dec 18, 1870 | Fleetwood, PA, US | | | | Edward Hill |
| 69 | Doc Sechrist | 23.077 | Apr 28 | Apr 28, 1899 | /1 | NYG | 0.0 | 5-9 | 160 | R | R | Feb 10, 1876 | Williamstown, KY, US | | | | Theodore O'Hara |
| 70 | Socks Seybold | 28.270 | Aug 20 | Oct 7, 1908 | | CIN | 24.1 | 5-11 | 175 | R | R | Nov 23, 1870 | Washingtonville, OH, US | | | | Ralph Orlando |
| 71 | Jimmy Slagle | 25.280 | Apr 17 | Oct 3, 1908 | * | WHS | 15.8 | 5-7 | 144 | L | R | Jul 11, 1873 | Worthville, PA, US | | | | James Franklin |
| 72 | Farmer Steelman | 24.078 | Sep 15 | May 22, 1902 | /2 | LOU | -0.5 | 5-11 | | | R | Jun 29, 1875 | Millville, NJ, US | | | | Morris James |
| 73 | Oscar Streit | 25.288 | Apr 21 | Jun 18, 1902 | /1 | BSN | -2.1 | 6-5 | 190 | L | L | Jul 7, 1873 | Florence, AL, US | | | | Oscar William |
| 74 | Billy Sullivan | 24.224 | Sep 13 | Apr 15, 1916 | 2 | BSN | 8.7 | 5-9 | 155 | R | R | Feb 1, 1875 | Oakland, WI, US | | | Fort Atkinson HS (Fort Atkinson, WI) | William Joseph |
| 75 | Roy Thomas | 25.021 | Apr 14 | Sep 4, 1911 | *3 | PHI | 41.8 | 5-11 | 150 | L | L | Mar 24, 1874 | Norristown, PA, US | | University of Pennsylvania (Philadelphia, PA) | Norristown Area HS (Norristown, PA) | Roy Allen |
| 76 | Harry Wilhelm | 25.127 | Aug 12 | Aug 23, 1899 | /1 | LOU | -0.2 | 5-7 | 155 | R | R | Apr 7, 1874 | Uniontown, PA, US | | Bethany College (Bethany, WV), Westminster College (New Wilmington, PA) | | Harry Lester |
| 77 | Jimmy Williams | 22.116 | Apr 15 | Oct 3, 1909 | *5 | PIT | 33.1 | 5-9 | 175 | R | R | Dec 20, 1876 | St. Louis, MO, US | | | | James Thomas |
| 78 | Dave Wills | 22.133 | Jun 8 | Aug 31, 1899 | 3 | LOU | -0.7 | | | L | L | Jan 26, 1877 | Charlottesville, VA, US | | University of Virginia (Charlottesville, VA) | | Davis Bowles |
| 79 | Howard Wilson | 21.035 | Sep 13 | May 17, 1904 | /1 | CLV | 4.9 | 5-9 | 164 | | R | Aug 9, 1878 | Philadelphia, PA, US | | | | Howard Paul |
| 80 | Pete Woodruff | 25.170 | Sep 19 | Oct 14, 1899 | /3 | NYG | 0.0 | 5-10 | | R | R | Apr 2, 1874 | Baltimore, MD, US | | | | Peter Francis |
| 81 | Charlie Ziegler | 24.253 | Sep 23 | Jun 6, 1900 | /46 | CLV | -0.1 | | | | R | Jan 13, 1875 | Canton, OH, US | | | | Charles Wallace |
Batting