Single-Season Leaders & Records for Errors Committed
POWERED BY
Create your own custom leaderboards
Become a Stathead today and run queries with our Season and Career Finders to see the best seasons in MLB history.
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Herman Long (23) | 122 | 1889 | 1189.0 | R |
| Billy Shindle (29) | 122 | 1890 | 1151.0 | R | |
| 3. | Frank Fennelly (26) | 117 | 1886 | 1165.0 | R |
| 4. | Phil Tomney (26) | 114 | 1889 | 993.0 | R |
| 5. | Jim Canavan (24) | 113 | 1891 | 1189.0 | R |
| 6. | Bill Joyce (22) | 107 | 1890 | 1181.0 | R |
| 7. | Frank Fennelly (28) | 106 | 1888 | 1219.0 | R |
| 8. | Bill McClellan (31) | 105 | 1887 | 1169.0 | L |
| Ed McKean (23) | 105 | 1887 | 1109.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (30) | 105 | 1890 | 1142.0 | R | |
| 11. | William Robinson (26) | 103 | 1886 | 1184.0 | R |
| 12. | Herman Long (26) | 102 | 1892 | 1338.0 | R |
| Lou Say (30) | 102 | 1884 | 860.0 | R | |
| Joe Sullivan (23) | 102 | 1893 | 1114.0 | ||
| 15. | Thomas Burns (22) | 101 | 1887 | 1200.0 | R |
| 16. | Jim Davis (26) | 100 | 1888 | 1075.0 | R |
| Herman Long (27) | 100 | 1893 | 1138.0 | R | |
| Frank Shugart (25) | 100 | 1892 | 1200.0 | R | |
| 19. | Frank Fennelly (27) | 99 | 1887 | 1172.0 | R |
| 20. | Jim Davis (25) | 98 | 1887 | 1122.0 | R |
| John Gochnaur (27) | 98 | 1903 | 1182.0 | R | |
| Gil Hatfield (36) | 98 | 1891 | 1160.0 | R | |
| 23. | Gene DeMontreville (23) | 97 | 1896 | 1124.0 | R |
| Bill Keister (29) | 97 | 1901 | 951.0 | R | |
| 25. | Tom Burns (28) | 96 | 1885 | 989.0 | R |
| Roger Connor+ (26) | 96 | 1884 | 1041.0 | L | |
| Al Myers (25) | 96 | 1889 | 1104.0 | R | |
| Bill White (26) | 96 | 1886 | 1178.0 | R | |
| Bill White (27) | 96 | 1887 | 1170.0 | R | |
| 30. | Shorty Fuller (23) | 95 | 1891 | 1203.0 | R |
| Cub Stricker (24) | 95 | 1883 | 783.0 | R | |
| 32. | Ed Delahanty+ (22) | 94 | 1890 | 998.0 | R |
| Tom Evers (32) | 94 | 1884 | 931.0 | L | |
| Billy Geer | 94 | 1884 | 1022.0 | R | |
| Nat Hicks (31) | 94 | 1876 | 411.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (29) | 94 | 1888 | 943.0 | R | |
| 37. | Monte Cross (28) | 93 | 1898 | 1275.0 | R |
| Frank Fennelly (29) | 93 | 1889 | 1199.0 | R | |
| Milt Whitehead (22) | 93 | 1884 | 919.0 | R | |
| 40. | Shorty Fuller (24) | 92 | 1892 | 1199.0 | R |
| Ed McKean (28) | 92 | 1892 | 1137.0 | R | |
| Frank Scheibeck (25) | 92 | 1890 | 1159.0 | R | |
| Cub Stricker (28) | 92 | 1887 | 1131.0 | R | |
| 44. | Gene DeMontreville (24) | 91 | 1897 | 1146.0 | R |
| Shorty Fuller (22) | 91 | 1890 | 1130.0 | R | |
| Charlie Irwin (25) | 91 | 1894 | 1070.0 | R | |
| Ed McKean (27) | 91 | 1891 | 1242.0 | R | |
| Tom O'Brien (24) | 91 | 1884 | 935.0 | R | |
| 49. | Monte Cross (29) | 90 | 1899 | 1326.0 | R |
| Hughie Jennings+ (23) | 90 | 1892 | 1333.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| Lefty Marr (26) | 90 | 1889 | 1287.0 | L | |
| William Robinson (24) | 90 | 1884 | 995.0 | R | |
| Billy Shindle (31) | 90 | 1892 | 1230.0 | R | |
| Cub Stricker (31) | 90 | 1890 | 1137.0 | R | |
| 55. | Lou Bierbauer (20) | 89 | 1886 | 1203.0 | R |
| Paul Radford (25) | 89 | 1887 | 1121.0 | R | |
| Pop Smith (23) | 89 | 1880 | 718.0 | R | |
| Joe Werrick (25) | 89 | 1887 | 1195.0 | R | |
| 59. | Tommy Corcoran (21) | 88 | 1890 | 1098.0 | R |
| Ed Crane (22) | 88 | 1884 | 962.0 | R | |
| Bob Ferguson (38) | 88 | 1883 | 773.0 | R | |
| Arlie Latham (26) | 88 | 1886 | 1183.0 | R | |
| Reddy Mack (20) | 88 | 1886 | 1194.0 | ||
| Bill McClellan (30) | 88 | 1886 | 1234.0 | L | |
| Tom McLaughlin (25) | 88 | 1885 | 1001.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (24) | 88 | 1884 | 997.0 | R | |
| Billy Shindle (28) | 88 | 1889 | 1183.0 | R | |
| Ed Williamson (25) | 88 | 1883 | 854.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (25) | 88 | 1883 | 828.0 | R | |
| 70. | Ollie Beard (27) | 87 | 1889 | 1241.0 | R |
| Sam Crane (29) | 87 | 1883 | 861.0 | R | |
| Charlie Hickman (24) | 87 | 1900 | 1078.0 | R | |
| John Irwin (22) | 87 | 1884 | 912.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Peoples (22) | 87 | 1886 | 822.0 | R | |
| 75. | Bill Dahlen (25) | 86 | 1895 | 1119.0 | R |
| Emil Gross (22) | 86 | 1880 | 795.0 | R | |
| King Kelly+ (26) | 86 | 1884 | 1011.0 | R | |
| Chippy McGarr (24) | 86 | 1887 | 1185.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (23) | 86 | 1883 | 815.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (25) | 86 | 1885 | 1020.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (28) | 86 | 1888 | 1078.0 | R | |
| Bill White (28) | 86 | 1888 | 1107.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (27) | 86 | 1885 | 953.0 | R | |
| 84. | Bill Gleason (23) | 85 | 1882 | 688.0 | R |
| Sadie Houck (27) | 85 | 1883 | 891.0 | R | |
| Herman Long (25) | 85 | 1891 | 1228.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (27) | 85 | 1886 | 923.0 | R | |
| 88. | Tom Burns (26) | 84 | 1883 | 854.0 | R |
| Monte Cross (26) | 84 | 1896 | 1082.0 | R | |
| Tommy Dowd (23) | 84 | 1892 | 1201.0 | R | |
| Pete Gilbert (23) | 84 | 1891 | 1215.0 | R | |
| Jack Gleason (27) | 84 | 1882 | 682.0 | R | |
| Herman Long (29) | 84 | 1895 | 1116.0 | R | |
| Bill McClellan (28) | 84 | 1884 | 962.0 | L | |
| Jerry McCormick (21) | 84 | 1883 | 821.0 | ||
| Ed Whiting (22) | 84 | 1882 | 639.0 | L | |
| 97. | Bill Gleason (27) | 83 | 1886 | 1106.0 | R |
| Bill Gleason (28) | 83 | 1887 | 1179.0 | R | |
| Herman Long (30) | 83 | 1896 | 1039.0 | R | |
| Reddy Mack (23) | 83 | 1889 | 1171.0 | ||
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| William Robinson (27) | 83 | 1887 | 1082.0 | R | |
| 102. | Cupid Childs (23) | 82 | 1891 | 1243.0 | R |
| Bill Gleason (29) | 82 | 1888 | 1084.0 | R | |
| Bill Kuehne (31) | 82 | 1890 | 1117.0 | R | |
| Jerry McCormick (22) | 82 | 1884 | 926.0 | ||
| George Miller (25) | 82 | 1890 | 1164.0 | R | |
| Lou Say (29) | 82 | 1883 | 679.0 | R | |
| George Van Haltren (25) | 82 | 1891 | 1281.0 | L | |
| 109. | Neal Ball (27) | 81 | 1908 | 1129.0 | R |
| Bones Ely (31) | 81 | 1894 | 1102.0 | R | |
| Rudy Hulswitt (26) | 81 | 1903 | 1191.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Knowles (29) | 81 | 1886 | 1024.0 | ||
| Harry Lochhead (23) | 81 | 1899 | 1199.0 | R | |
| Denny Lyons (23) | 81 | 1889 | 1134.0 | R | |
| William Robinson (29) | 81 | 1889 | 1170.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (26) | 81 | 1885 | 947.0 | R | |
| Cub Stricker (25) | 81 | 1884 | 937.0 | R | |
| Cub Stricker (26) | 81 | 1885 | 942.0 | R | |
| Bobby Wheelock (26) | 81 | 1891 | 1198.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (29) | 81 | 1887 | 972.0 | R | |
| 121. | Ed Caskin (31) | 80 | 1883 | 837.0 | R |
| Jack Gleason (29) | 80 | 1884 | 799.0 | R | |
| Sadie Houck (30) | 80 | 1886 | 969.0 | R | |
| George Miller (26) | 80 | 1891 | 1183.0 | R | |
| Dick Phelan (29) | 80 | 1884 | 899.0 | ||
| 126. | Bob Allen (23) | 79 | 1891 | 1065.0 | R |
| Kid Baldwin (22) | 79 | 1887 | 829.0 | R | |
| Bill Hallman (22) | 79 | 1889 | 1071.0 | R | |
| William Robinson (31) | 79 | 1891 | 843.0 | R | |
| Joe Werrick (26) | 79 | 1888 | 956.0 | R | |
| Ed Williamson (28) | 79 | 1886 | 1058.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (35) | 79 | 1893 | 1062.0 | R | |
| 133. | Ed Abbaticchio (27) | 78 | 1904 | 1333.0 | R |
| Billy Gilbert (26) | 78 | 1902 | 1107.0 | R | |
| Arthur Irwin (24) | 78 | 1882 | 770.0 | R | |
| Herman Long (28) | 78 | 1894 | 906.0 | R | |
| John Morrill (21) | 78 | 1876 | 616.0 | R | |
| George Myers (23) | 78 | 1884 | 708.0 | R | |
| Billy Nash (25) | 78 | 1890 | 1145.0 | R | |
| Ollie O'Mara (24) | 78 | 1915 | 1319.0 | R | |
| Whitey Witt (20) | 78 | 1916 | 1229.0 | R | |
| 142. | Bob Allen (24) | 77 | 1892 | 1345.0 | R |
| Monte Cross (25) | 77 | 1895 | 949.0 | R | |
| Tom Daly (27) | 77 | 1893 | 1172.0 | R | |
| Emil Gross (25) | 77 | 1883 | 484.0 | R | |
| Sadie Houck (29) | 77 | 1885 | 843.0 | R | |
| Bill Joyce (27) | 77 | 1895 | 1048.0 | R | |
| Al Myers (23) | 77 | 1887 | 932.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (31) | 77 | 1891 | 1218.0 | R | |
| James Stafford (29) | 77 | 1897 | 1002.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| 151. | Amos Booth (27) | 76 | 1876 | 570.0 | R |
| Tommy Corcoran (25) | 76 | 1894 | 1106.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (28) | 76 | 1898 | 1226.0 | R | |
| Kid Elberfeld (26) | 76 | 1901 | 1064.0 | R | |
| Bill Everitt (26) | 76 | 1895 | 1142.0 | R | |
| Sam LaRocque (27) | 76 | 1890 | 960.0 | R | |
| Jack O'Brien (23) | 76 | 1883 | 823.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (22) | 76 | 1882 | 755.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (30) | 76 | 1890 | 1111.0 | R | |
| Lee Tannehill (22) | 76 | 1903 | 1227.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (29) | 76 | 1889 | 991.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (31) | 76 | 1889 | 1004.0 | R | |
| 163. | Ed Abbaticchio (28) | 75 | 1905 | 1346.0 | R |
| Donie Bush (23) | 75 | 1911 | 1351.0 | R | |
| Monte Cross (27) | 75 | 1897 | 1112.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (24) | 75 | 1894 | 1097.0 | R | |
| Frank Fennelly (24) | 75 | 1884 | 787.0 | R | |
| Otto Krueger (25) | 75 | 1902 | 1079.0 | R | |
| Arlie Latham (31) | 75 | 1891 | 1178.0 | R | |
| Doc Lavan (24) | 75 | 1915 | 1338.0 | R | |
| Bill McClellan (27) | 75 | 1883 | 701.0 | L | |
| Ed McKean (26) | 75 | 1890 | 1167.0 | R | |
| Mike Moynahan (27) | 75 | 1883 | 848.0 | R | |
| John Shetzline (30) | 75 | 1882 | 636.0 | ||
| Germany Smith (32) | 75 | 1891 | 1218.0 | R | |
| Pop Smith (27) | 75 | 1884 | 946.0 | R | |
| Pop Smith (29) | 75 | 1886 | 1117.0 | R | |
| 178. | Harry Aubrey (21) | 74 | 1903 | 822.0 | R |
| Frank Fennelly (25) | 74 | 1885 | 999.0 | R | |
| Ed McKean (29) | 74 | 1893 | 1102.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (31) | 74 | 1890 | 1144.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (35) | 74 | 1894 | 1100.0 | R | |
| Pop Smith (26) | 74 | 1883 | 856.0 | R | |
| Joe Tinker+ (21) | 74 | 1902 | 1190.0 | R | |
| Dasher Troy (28) | 74 | 1884 | 938.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (32) | 74 | 1892 | 1324.0 | R | |
| Art Whitney (32) | 74 | 1890 | 1033.0 | R | |
| 188. | George Baker (26) | 73 | 1884 | 695.0 | |
| Sam Crane (30) | 73 | 1884 | 723.0 | R | |
| Jim Donnelly (20) | 73 | 1886 | 979.0 | R | |
| Henry Easterday (23) | 73 | 1888 | 1004.0 | R | |
| Shorty Fuller (26) | 73 | 1894 | 863.0 | R | |
| Shorty Fuller (27) | 73 | 1895 | 1095.0 | R | |
| Jack Glasscock (29) | 73 | 1887 | 1041.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Hallinan (27) | 73 | 1876 | 501.0 | L | |
| Rudy Kemmler (23) | 73 | 1883 | 736.0 | R | |
| Denny Lyons (21) | 73 | 1887 | 1185.0 | R | |
| Reddy Mack (21) | 73 | 1887 | 1134.0 | ||
| Joe Mulvey (25) | 73 | 1884 | 863.0 | R | |
| Al Nichols (24) | 73 | 1876 | 531.0 | ||
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| Ivy Olson (25) | 73 | 1911 | 1229.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (26) | 73 | 1886 | 1032.0 | R | |
| Paul Radford (32) | 73 | 1894 | 774.0 | R | |
| Frank Shugart (34) | 73 | 1901 | 942.0 | R | |
| Bobby Wallace+ (25) | 73 | 1899 | 1357.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (33) | 73 | 1893 | 1199.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (32) | 73 | 1890 | 1018.0 | R | |
| 208. | Lew Brown (26) | 72 | 1884 | 759.0 | R |
| Tom Burns (32) | 72 | 1889 | 1244.0 | R | |
| Tommy Corcoran (22) | 72 | 1891 | 1159.0 | R | |
| Bill Craver (32) | 72 | 1876 | 539.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (23) | 72 | 1893 | 996.0 | R | |
| Jack Doyle (22) | 72 | 1892 | 949.0 | R | |
| Duke Farrell (25) | 72 | 1892 | 1390.0 | R | |
| Frank Hankinson (30) | 72 | 1886 | 1175.0 | R | |
| King Kelly+ (29) | 72 | 1887 | 1031.0 | R | |
| Bill Kuehne (24) | 72 | 1883 | 807.0 | R | |
| Bid McPhee+ (27) | 72 | 1887 | 1134.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (27) | 72 | 1887 | 1081.0 | R | |
| Danny Richardson (27) | 72 | 1890 | 1129.0 | R | |
| William Robinson (28) | 72 | 1888 | 1179.0 | R | |
| Jack Rowe (31) | 72 | 1888 | 919.0 | R | |
| Frank Shugart (26) | 72 | 1893 | 985.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (28) | 72 | 1887 | 899.0 | R | |
| Pop Smith (32) | 72 | 1889 | 1179.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (31) | 72 | 1891 | 924.0 | R | |
| Joe Werrick (24) | 72 | 1886 | 1197.0 | R | |
| Zeke Wrigley (24) | 72 | 1898 | 928.0 | R | |
| 229. | Ollie Beard (28) | 71 | 1890 | 1087.0 | R |
| Donie Bush (21) | 71 | 1909 | 1390.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (26) | 71 | 1896 | 1099.0 | R | |
| Jack Farrell (24) | 71 | 1882 | 760.0 | R | |
| Shorty Fuller (25) | 71 | 1893 | 1151.0 | R | |
| Arlie Latham (32) | 71 | 1892 | 1330.0 | R | |
| George Magoon (24) | 71 | 1899 | 1054.0 | R | |
| Ed McKean (30) | 71 | 1894 | 1122.0 | R | |
| John Peters (29) | 71 | 1879 | 744.0 | R | |
| Marr Phillips (27) | 71 | 1884 | 831.0 | ||
| Paul Radford (29) | 71 | 1891 | 1179.0 | R | |
| Frank Shugart (28) | 71 | 1895 | 998.0 | R | |
| Buck Weaver (21) | 71 | 1912 | 1292.0 | R | |
| 242. | Lou Bierbauer (22) | 70 | 1888 | 1193.0 | R |
| Hick Carpenter (31) | 70 | 1887 | 1100.0 | L | |
| Billy Clingman (28) | 70 | 1898 | 1376.0 | R | |
| Jack O'Brien (26) | 70 | 1886 | 895.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (33) | 70 | 1892 | 1228.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Smith (20) | 70 | 1915 | 1064.0 | R | |
| Pop Smith (31) | 70 | 1888 | 1136.0 | R | |
| Dasher Troy (27) | 70 | 1883 | 738.0 | R | |
| Buck Weaver (22) | 70 | 1913 | 1327.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| Deacon White+ (33) | 70 | 1881 | 693.0 | R | |
| 252. | Bob Allen (22) | 69 | 1890 | 1195.0 | R |
| Thomas Burns (23) | 69 | 1888 | 1237.0 | R | |
| Tommy Cahill (22) | 69 | 1891 | 1019.0 | ||
| Hick Carpenter (33) | 69 | 1889 | 1059.0 | L | |
| Gene DeMontreville (26) | 69 | 1899 | 1258.0 | R | |
| Jack Glasscock (32) | 69 | 1890 | 1077.0 | R | |
| Jack Glasscock (34) | 69 | 1892 | 1212.0 | R | |
| Frank Hankinson (31) | 69 | 1887 | 1087.0 | R | |
| Ed McKean (31) | 69 | 1895 | 1150.0 | R | |
| Henry Myers (24) | 69 | 1882 | 618.0 | R | |
| George Pinkney (27) | 69 | 1886 | 1227.0 | R | |
| William Robinson (30) | 69 | 1890 | 880.0 | R | |
| Dan Shannon (24) | 69 | 1889 | 1036.0 | ||
| Ed Somerville (23) | 69 | 1876 | 603.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (26) | 69 | 1886 | 1044.0 | R | |
| Deacon White+ (28) | 69 | 1876 | 604.0 | R | |
| 268. | Billy Alvord (27) | 68 | 1891 | 821.0 | R |
| Lew Brown (21) | 68 | 1879 | 542.0 | R | |
| Fred Carroll (21) | 68 | 1886 | 1171.0 | R | |
| Tommy Corcoran (24) | 68 | 1893 | 1022.0 | R | |
| George Creamer (25) | 68 | 1880 | 763.0 | R | |
| Tom Daly (28) | 68 | 1894 | 1082.0 | R | |
| Tommy Dowd (22) | 68 | 1891 | 946.0 | R | |
| Jack Farrell (23) | 68 | 1881 | 749.0 | R | |
| Jack Glasscock (31) | 68 | 1889 | 1148.0 | R | |
| John Knight (25) | 68 | 1911 | 1148.0 | R | |
| Larry Kopf (26) | 68 | 1917 | 1284.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Macullar (30) | 68 | 1885 | 885.0 | L | |
| John McGraw+ (20) | 68 | 1893 | 1063.0 | R | |
| Joe Miller (24) | 68 | 1885 | 883.0 | ||
| Hardy Richardson (28) | 68 | 1883 | 824.0 | R | |
| Pop Snyder (21) | 68 | 1876 | 508.0 | R | |
| Deacon White+ (38) | 68 | 1886 | 1086.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (33) | 68 | 1891 | 875.0 | R | |
| 286. | Billy Alvord (26) | 67 | 1890 | 1007.0 | R |
| Ross Barnes (29) | 67 | 1879 | 688.0 | R | |
| Tommy Corcoran (29) | 67 | 1898 | 1348.0 | R | |
| George Creamer (28) | 67 | 1883 | 802.0 | R | |
| Kid Elberfeld (27) | 67 | 1902 | 1115.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Esmond (24) | 67 | 1914 | 1328.0 | R | |
| Shorty Fuller (21) | 67 | 1889 | 1235.0 | R | |
| Rudy Hulswitt (25) | 67 | 1902 | 1119.0 | R | |
| Bill Joyce (29) | 67 | 1897 | 989.0 | R | |
| Jack Kerins (27) | 67 | 1886 | 1115.0 | R | |
| Arlie Latham (34) | 67 | 1894 | 1114.0 | R | |
| Herman Long (32) | 67 | 1898 | 1275.0 | R | |
| Reddy Mack (22) | 67 | 1888 | 995.0 | ||
| Bill McClellan (29) | 67 | 1885 | 1003.0 | L | |
| Mike McGeary (28) | 67 | 1879 | 778.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| Charlie Reilly (23) | 67 | 1890 | 1187.0 | R | |
| Charlie Reilly (24) | 67 | 1891 | 986.0 | R | |
| Jack Rowe (28) | 67 | 1885 | 855.0 | R | |
| Jack Rowe (33) | 67 | 1890 | 1055.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (30) | 67 | 1889 | 1055.0 | R | |
| Joe Tinker+ (22) | 67 | 1903 | 1084.0 | R | |
| Deacon White+ (35) | 67 | 1883 | 855.0 | R | |
| Jimmy Williams (22) | 67 | 1899 | 1353.0 | R | |
| 309. | Bob Allen (25) | 66 | 1893 | 1111.0 | R |
| Donie Bush (24) | 66 | 1912 | 1255.0 | R | |
| Hick Carpenter (30) | 66 | 1886 | 984.0 | L | |
| Hick Carpenter (32) | 66 | 1888 | 1224.0 | L | |
| Joe Cassidy (22) | 66 | 1905 | 1320.0 | R | |
| Monte Cross (32) | 66 | 1902 | 1214.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (32) | 66 | 1902 | 1218.0 | R | |
| Mickey Doolin (26) | 66 | 1906 | 1334.0 | R | |
| Joe Farrell (26) | 66 | 1883 | 891.0 | ||
| Arthur Irwin (25) | 66 | 1883 | 859.0 | R | |
| Hughie Jennings+ (27) | 66 | 1896 | 1148.0 | R | |
| Bill Keister (27) | 66 | 1899 | 1115.0 | R | |
| King Kelly+ (30) | 66 | 1888 | 903.0 | R | |
| Arlie Latham (27) | 66 | 1887 | 1213.0 | R | |
| Phil Lewis (21) | 66 | 1905 | 1022.0 | R | |
| Herman Long (31) | 66 | 1897 | 922.0 | R | |
| Freddy Parent (29) | 66 | 1905 | 1358.0 | R | |
| Blondie Purcell (29) | 66 | 1883 | 866.0 | R | |
| Paul Radford (30) | 66 | 1892 | 1132.0 | R | |
| Bill Sweeney (24) | 66 | 1910 | 1277.0 | R | |
| Bobby Wallace+ (27) | 66 | 1901 | 1195.0 | R | |
| John Ward+ (34) | 66 | 1894 | 1201.0 | R | |
| 331. | Charlie Babb (31) | 65 | 1904 | 1309.0 | R |
| Tom Burns (25) | 65 | 1882 | 745.0 | R | |
| Monte Cross (31) | 65 | 1901 | 1232.0 | R | |
| Joe Gerhardt (30) | 65 | 1885 | 1000.0 | R | |
| Arthur Irwin (31) | 65 | 1889 | 876.0 | R | |
| Jack Kerins (26) | 65 | 1885 | 1038.0 | R | |
| Tommy Leach (25) | 65 | 1903 | 1127.0 | R | |
| Rabbit Maranville+ (22) | 65 | 1914 | 1397.0 | R | |
| Deacon McGuire (27) | 65 | 1891 | 906.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (28) | 65 | 1888 | 1184.0 | R | |
| Deacon White+ (40) | 65 | 1888 | 1102.0 | R | |
| Ed Williamson (30) | 65 | 1888 | 1157.0 | R | |
| 343. | Dave Bancroft+ (24) | 64 | 1915 | 1350.0 | R |
| Dave Bancroft+ (27) | 64 | 1918 | 1127.0 | R | |
| Wid Conroy (24) | 64 | 1901 | 1131.0 | R | |
| Tommy Corcoran (23) | 64 | 1892 | 1347.0 | R | |
| Tommy Corcoran (26) | 64 | 1895 | 1113.0 | R | |
| Tommy Corcoran (27) | 64 | 1896 | 1138.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (21) | 64 | 1891 | 1264.0 | R | |
| George Davis+ (22) | 64 | 1893 | 1178.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| Jerry Denny (29) | 64 | 1888 | 1171.0 | R | |
| Kid Gleason (35) | 64 | 1901 | 1183.0 | R | |
| Fred Hartman (32) | 64 | 1897 | 1051.0 | R | |
| Ed Holly (27) | 64 | 1907 | 1322.0 | R | |
| Arthur Irwin (30) | 64 | 1888 | 1100.0 | R | |
| Barry McCormick (25) | 64 | 1900 | 976.0 | R | |
| Al Myers (21) | 64 | 1885 | 821.0 | R | |
| Dick Padden (28) | 64 | 1899 | 1108.0 | R | |
| Pop Smith (28) | 64 | 1885 | 967.0 | R | |
| Cub Stricker (30) | 64 | 1889 | 1192.0 | R | |
| Dan Sullivan (25) | 64 | 1882 | 604.0 | R | |
| Joe Tinker+ (23) | 64 | 1904 | 1235.0 | R | |
| 363. | Jack Barry (23) | 63 | 1910 | 1308.0 | R |
| Bill Bradley (22) | 63 | 1900 | 1053.0 | R | |
| Dave Brain (24) | 63 | 1903 | 1022.0 | R | |
| Pete Browning (21) | 63 | 1882 | 667.0 | R | |
| Cupid Childs (26) | 63 | 1894 | 1017.0 | R | |
| Cupid Childs (27) | 63 | 1895 | 1043.0 | R | |
| John Clapp (28) | 63 | 1880 | 702.0 | R | |
| Tom Daly (33) | 63 | 1899 | 1214.0 | R | |
| Fred Dunlap (23) | 63 | 1882 | 747.0 | R | |
| Art Fletcher (29) | 63 | 1914 | 1198.0 | R | |
| Will Foley (20) | 63 | 1876 | 525.0 | R | |
| Barney Gilligan (29) | 63 | 1885 | 601.0 | R | |
| Bill Gleason (26) | 63 | 1885 | 1001.0 | R | |
| Hughie Jennings+ (25) | 63 | 1894 | 1110.0 | R | |
| Barry McCormick (23) | 63 | 1898 | 1180.0 | R | |
| Jack Nelson (36) | 63 | 1885 | 925.0 | R | |
| Simon Nicholls (25) | 63 | 1908 | 1329.0 | R | |
| Freddy Parent (25) | 63 | 1901 | 1213.0 | R | |
| Freddy Parent (28) | 63 | 1904 | 1382.0 | R | |
| Gracie Pierce (22) | 63 | 1882 | 423.0 | R | |
| Hardy Richardson (27) | 63 | 1882 | 721.0 | R | |
| Harry Schafer (29) | 63 | 1876 | 632.0 | R | |
| Billy Shindle (32) | 63 | 1893 | 1087.0 | R | |
| Sammy Strang (25) | 63 | 1902 | 1233.0 | R | |
| Joe Sullivan (25) | 63 | 1895 | 808.0 | ||
| Chicken Wolf (26) | 63 | 1888 | 1174.0 | R | |
| 389. | Dave Bancroft+ (31) | 62 | 1922 | 1377.0 | R |
| Charlie Bastian (27) | 62 | 1885 | 894.0 | R | |
| Cupid Childs (25) | 62 | 1893 | 1082.0 | R | |
| Joe Cronin+ (22) | 62 | 1929 | 1258.0 | R | |
| Monte Cross (30) | 62 | 1900 | 1159.0 | R | |
| George Davis+ (26) | 62 | 1897 | 1121.0 | R | |
| Jerry Denny (22) | 62 | 1881 | 758.0 | R | |
| Tom Downey (25) | 62 | 1909 | 1064.0 | R | |
| Kid Elberfeld (28) | 62 | 1903 | 1101.0 | R | |
| Bones Ely (33) | 62 | 1896 | 1132.0 | R | |
| Lonny Frey (25) | 62 | 1936 | 1284.0 | R | |
| Hughie Jennings+ (29) | 62 | 1898 | 1229.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| Bill Joyce (28) | 62 | 1896 | 1108.0 | R | |
| Arlie Latham (28) | 62 | 1888 | 1184.0 | R | |
| Billy Lauder (25) | 62 | 1899 | 1297.0 | R | |
| Ed McKean (25) | 62 | 1889 | 1068.0 | R | |
| Joe Mulvey (26) | 62 | 1885 | 927.0 | R | |
| Bert Myers (22) | 62 | 1896 | 1038.0 | R | |
| Billy Nash (27) | 62 | 1892 | 1182.0 | R | |
| Fred Smith (23) | 62 | 1915 | 1236.0 | R | |
| Joe Sullivan (24) | 62 | 1894 | 795.0 | ||
| Bobby Wallace+ (29) | 62 | 1903 | 1186.0 | R | |
| Bobby Wallace+ (31) | 62 | 1905 | 1377.0 | R | |
| Sam Wise (30) | 62 | 1888 | 939.0 | R | |
| 413. | Al Brancato (22) | 61 | 1941 | 1219.0 | R |
| Eddie Burke (25) | 61 | 1892 | 884.0 | R | |
| Hub Collins (25) | 61 | 1889 | 1212.0 | R | |
| Tommy Corcoran (31) | 61 | 1900 | 1115.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (22) | 61 | 1892 | 1315.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (34) | 61 | 1904 | 1266.0 | R | |
| Jack Farrell (21) | 61 | 1879 | 623.0 | R | |
| Jack Farrell (22) | 61 | 1880 | 735.0 | R | |
| Hobe Ferris (26) | 61 | 1901 | 1210.0 | R | |
| Jack Glasscock (30) | 61 | 1888 | 959.0 | R | |
| Kid Gleason (29) | 61 | 1895 | 893.0 | R | |
| Tommy Leach (21) | 61 | 1899 | 966.0 | R | |
| Swede Risberg (22) | 61 | 1917 | 1300.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (38) | 61 | 1897 | 956.0 | R | |
| James Stafford (27) | 61 | 1895 | 1053.0 | R | |
| Heinie Wagner (27) | 61 | 1908 | 1342.0 | R | |
| Heinie Wagner (31) | 61 | 1912 | 1277.0 | R | |
| 430. | Charlie Babb (30) | 60 | 1903 | 1066.0 | R |
| Dave Bancroft+ (25) | 60 | 1916 | 1258.0 | R | |
| Jack Boyle (25) | 60 | 1892 | 1005.0 | R | |
| Hick Carpenter (26) | 60 | 1882 | 720.0 | L | |
| Roger Connor+ (22) | 60 | 1880 | 739.0 | L | |
| William Coon (21) | 60 | 1876 | 473.0 | ||
| Gene DeMontreville (25) | 60 | 1898 | 1326.0 | R | |
| Mickey Doolin (27) | 60 | 1907 | 1265.0 | R | |
| Tom Downey (26) | 60 | 1910 | 951.0 | R | |
| Henry Easterday (24) | 60 | 1889 | 789.0 | R | |
| Bones Ely (34) | 60 | 1897 | 1145.0 | R | |
| Charles Fulmer (28) | 60 | 1879 | 687.0 | R | |
| Kid Gleason (32) | 60 | 1898 | 1316.0 | R | |
| Otto Krueger (24) | 60 | 1901 | 1269.0 | R | |
| Bill Lange (22) | 60 | 1893 | 1078.0 | R | |
| Tommy Leach (26) | 60 | 1904 | 1257.0 | R | |
| Herman Long (33) | 60 | 1899 | 1280.0 | R | |
| Barry McCormick (26) | 60 | 1901 | 1021.0 | R | |
| George Miller (29) | 60 | 1894 | 1047.0 | R | |
| Billy Nash (30) | 60 | 1895 | 1184.0 | R | |
| Joe Quest (25) | 60 | 1878 | 563.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Errors Committed | Year | Innings Played | Throws |
| Joe Quest (27) | 60 | 1880 | 749.0 | R | |
| Danny Richardson (29) | 60 | 1892 | 1308.0 | R | |
| Heinie Sand (27) | 60 | 1925 | 1146.0 | R | |
| Bill Smiley (26) | 60 | 1882 | 676.0 | ||
| Sammy Strang (24) | 60 | 1901 | 1177.0 | R | |
| Billy Taylor (27) | 60 | 1882 | 604.0 | R | |
| Honus Wagner+ (31) | 60 | 1905 | 1281.0 | R | |
| Rollie Zeider (26) | 60 | 1910 | 1223.0 | R | |
| 459. | Ross Barnes (31) | 59 | 1881 | 637.0 | R |
| Charley Bassett (29) | 59 | 1892 | 984.0 | R | |
| Jack Burdock (27) | 59 | 1879 | 752.0 | R | |
| Ray Chapman (26) | 59 | 1917 | 1412.0 | R | |
| Bones Ely (36) | 59 | 1899 | 1240.0 | R | |
| Bill Gray (27) | 59 | 1898 | 1196.0 | ||
| Hunter Hill (25) | 59 | 1904 | 1161.0 | R | |
| Bill Holbert (27) | 59 | 1882 | 621.0 | R | |
| King Kelly+ (24) | 59 | 1882 | 750.0 | R | |
| Bobby Lowe (28) | 59 | 1894 | 1146.0 | R | |
| Barry McCormick (22) | 59 | 1897 | 856.0 | R | |
| Freddy Parent (30) | 59 | 1906 | 1315.0 | R | |
| Dave Pierson (20) | 59 | 1876 | 524.0 | R | |
| Phil Reccius (23) | 59 | 1885 | 892.0 | ||
| Joe Sewell+ (24) | 59 | 1923 | 1351.0 | R | |
| Germany Smith (36) | 59 | 1895 | 1107.0 | R | |
| Charlie Sweasy (30) | 59 | 1878 | 496.0 | R | |
| Buck Weaver (23) | 59 | 1914 | 1165.0 | R | |
| 477. | Ed Abbaticchio (26) | 58 | 1903 | 1157.0 | R |
| Donie Bush (26) | 58 | 1914 | 1403.0 | R | |
| James Casey (31) | 58 | 1901 | 1109.0 | R | |
| John Clapp (24) | 58 | 1876 | 576.0 | R | |
| George Davis+ (33) | 58 | 1904 | 1334.0 | R | |
| Doc Farrell (25) | 58 | 1927 | 1296.0 | R | |
| Bob Ferguson (35) | 58 | 1880 | 734.0 | R | |
| Art Fletcher (30) | 58 | 1915 | 1305.0 | R | |
| Travis Jackson+ (20) | 58 | 1924 | 1334.0 | R | |
| King Kelly+ (21) | 58 | 1879 | 733.0 | R | |
| King Kelly+ (27) | 58 | 1885 | 1012.0 | R | |
| Jim Levey (24) | 58 | 1931 | 1146.0 | R | |
| George McBride (28) | 58 | 1909 | 1360.0 | R | |
| George McBride (29) | 58 | 1910 | 1356.0 | R | |
| Charley O'Leary (30) | 58 | 1906 | 1098.0 | R | |
| Ivy Olson (32) | 58 | 1918 | 1128.0 | R | |
| Fred Pfeffer (32) | 58 | 1892 | 1120.0 | R | |
| Claude Ritchey (24) | 58 | 1898 | 1304.0 | R | |
| Ezra Sutton (26) | 58 | 1876 | 506.0 | R | |
| Harry Wolverton (25) | 58 | 1899 | 861.0 | R | |
| 497. | Cap Anson+ (33) | 57 | 1885 | 1003.0 | R |
| Emil Batch (25) | 57 | 1905 | 1253.0 | R | |
| Donie Bush (27) | 57 | 1915 | 1395.0 | R | |
| Bill Dahlen (31) | 57 | 1901 | 1152.0 | R |
