2004 Hall of Fame Voting

Baseball Writers

  • 506 total ballots (380 votes needed for election)
Baseball Writers Table
Batting Stats Pitching Stats
Rk Name YoB Votes %vote HOFm HOFs Yrs WAR WAR7 JAWS Jpos G AB R H HR RBI SB BB BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ W L ERA ERA+ WHIP G GS SV IP H HR BB SO Pos Summary
1y Paul Molitor1st43185.2%166592175.739.757.755.72683108351782331923413075041094.306.369.448.817122 *D*5*4368/79
2y Dennis Eckersley1st42183.2%158342462.437.950.232.321818192431209.133.173.199.37201971713.501161.16110713613903285.230763477382401*1/D
3y Ryne Sandberg HOF2nd30961.1%158431668.047.157.557.021648385131823862821061344761.285.344.452.795114 *45/6D
4y Bruce Sutter HOF11th30159.5%79171224.224.424.332.3661102690617.088.153.088.241-3368712.831361.14066103001042.087977309861*1
5y Jim Rice HOF10th27654.5%147431647.736.442.153.52089822512492452382145158670.298.352.502.854128 *7*D9/8
6y Andre Dawson HOF3rd25350.0%118442164.842.753.757.926279927137327744381591314589.279.323.482.806119 *9*8D7
7y Rich Gossage HOF5th20640.7%109192241.431.936.732.338885190204.106.146.118.264-251241073.011261.2321002373101809.114971197321502*1/D
8y Lee Smith2nd18536.6%127131829.020.924.932.377064231203.047.090.094.183-5071923.031321.256102264781289.11133894861251*1
9y Bert Blyleven HOF7th17935.4%121502295.050.672.861.8218451195902505.131.144.146.290-192872503.311181.19869268504970.0463243013223701*1
10y Jack Morris HOF5th13326.3%123391843.932.738.361.8231400000.000.000.000.000-1002541863.901051.29654952703824.0356738913902478*1/D
11y Steve Garvey12th12324.3%131321938.128.833.454.72332883511432599272130883479.294.329.446.775117 *35/749
12y Tommy John10th11121.9%112442662.034.748.461.845290043141554033.157.187.188.37572882313.341111.28376070034710.1478330212592245*1
13y Alan Trammell HOF3rd7013.8%119402070.744.857.855.022938288123123651851003236850.285.352.415.767110 *6D5/478
14y Don Mattingly4th6512.8%134341442.435.739.154.71785700310072153222109914588.307.358.471.830127 *3D97/548
15y Dave Concepcion11th5711.3%107291940.129.935.055.0248887239932326101950321736.267.322.357.67988000.001.5001001.12001*6453/81
16y Dave Parker8th5310.5%125421940.137.438.757.824669358127227123391493154683.290.339.471.810121 *9*D78/34
17y Dale Murphy6th438.5%116341846.541.243.957.921807960119721113981266161986.265.346.469.815121 *8*9372
18y X-Keith Hernandez9th224.3%86321760.441.350.854.720887370112421821621071981070.296.384.436.821128 *3/79
19y X-Fernando Valenzuela2nd193.8%67251741.633.637.661.843993656187108408.200.205.262.467301731533.541041.32045342422930.0271822611512074*1/379
20y X-Joe Carter1st193.8%87321619.621.520.557.821898422117021843961445231527.259.306.464.771105 *7*9*8*3D/45
21y X-Dennis Martinez1st163.2%67372349.033.441.261.82935202574033115.142.169.165.334-72451933.701061.26669256283999.2389737211652149*1/D
22y X-Dave Stieb1st71.4%56271656.744.650.761.8132200000.000.000.000.000-1001761373.441221.24544341232895.1257222510341669*1/D7
23y X-Jim Eisenreich1st30.6%16161513.214.513.957.814223995492116052477105324.290.341.404.746103 *9*78D3
24y X-Jimmy Key1st30.6%69331549.136.642.961.822000000.000.000.000.000-1001861173.511221.229470389102591.225182546681538*1/D
25y X-Doug Drabek1st20.4%35211329.326.728.061.833371642119246017.166.193.207.399121551343.731011.24339838702535.024482467041594*1
26y X-Juan Samuel1st20.4%26181617.017.717.357.0172060818731578161703396440.259.315.420.735101 *48D397/5
27y X-Kevin Mitchell1st20.4%38231329.126.527.853.512234134630117323476030491.284.360.520.880142 *75D9/638
28y X-Cecil Fielder1st10.2%75221317.217.417.354.714705157744131331910082693.255.345.482.827119 *3*D/547
29y X-Randy Myers1st10.2%87111415.315.015.232.3574605110703.183.222.233.4562744633.191231.30472812347884.275869396884*1
30y X-Terry Pendleton1st10.2%38161528.525.426.955.7189370328511897140946127486.270.316.391.70792 *5D/9
31y X-Bob Tewksbury1st00.0%11101320.920.920.961.82053802050019021.132.177.150.327-91101023.921041.29230227711807.02043142292812*1
32y X-Danny Darwin1st00.0%26202139.827.333.661.8288305153922226.128.146.197.343-61711823.841061.268716371323016.229513218741942*1
Notes: Each voting cycle, qualified members of the BBWAA name no more than 10 eligible players whom they consider worthy of Hall of Fame honors. To be enshrined, a player must be named on at least 75% of the voters' ballots. Currently, players are removed from the ballot if they are named on fewer than 5% of ballots or have been on the ballot 15 times without election. Changed to 10 times prior to the 2015 election.

"X" means off ballot for future elections. "HOF" means they were selected to the Hall of Fame in a future election.
Support us without the ads? Go Ad-Free.