1958 Hall of Fame Voting

Baseball Writers

  • 266 total ballots (200 votes needed for election)
Baseball Writers Table
Batting Stats Pitching Stats
Rk Name YoB Votes %vote HOFm HOFs Yrs WAR WAR7 JAWS Jpos G AB R H HR RBI SB BB BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ W L ERA ERA+ WHIP G GS SV IP H HR BB SO Pos Summary
1X-Max Carey HOF14th13651.1%77362054.232.943.657.92476936315452665708027381040.285.361.386.747108 *O*8*79
2Edd Roush HOF18th11242.1%72361845.231.538.357.9196773631099237668981268484.323.369.446.815126 *87/394
3Red Ruffing HOF10th9937.2%130382270.441.355.862.1882193720752136273197.269.306.389.695812732253.801091.341624538184344.0428425415411987*1/79
4Hack Wilson HOF13th9435.3%100391238.835.837.357.9134847608841461244106352674.307.395.545.940144 *879/4
5Sam Rice HOF11th9033.8%128512052.830.841.858.12404926915142987341077351708.322.374.427.801112112.521171.27193039.13101912*9*87/1
6Kiki Cuyler HOF10th9033.8%117461846.734.940.858.118797161130522991281065328676.321.386.474.860125 *9*8*7
7Tony Lazzeri HOF12th8030.1%89391449.935.142.556.91740629798618401781194148869.292.380.467.846121 *456/73
8Luke Appling HOF4th7728.9%149572074.543.859.154.824228856131927494511161791302.310.399.398.798113 *654/3
9Lefty Gomez HOF13th7628.6%128341438.435.637.062.136890459133058150.147.194.159.353-71891023.341251.352368320102503.0229013810951468*1
10Burleigh Grimes HOF12th7126.7%115381953.040.947.062.1632153515738021681569.248.282.306.588582702123.531081.365616497184180.0441214812951512*1
11Red Faber HOF14th6825.6%89372064.840.652.762.16701269981703717169.134.240.161.401102542133.151191.302669483274086.2410611112131471*1
12Lou Boudreau HOF2nd6424.1%89341563.048.755.854.81646602986117796878951796.295.380.415.795120 *65/342
13Jim Bottomley HOF10th5721.4%99421635.328.832.054.61991747111772313219142258664.310.369.500.869125 *3/4
14Joe Medwick HOF3rd5018.8%200471755.639.747.653.31984763511982471205138342437.324.362.505.867134 *79/38
15Pepper Martin11th4617.3%49211317.516.717.157.911894117756122759501146369.298.358.443.801113002.252151.0002004.02020*5*897/1
16Hank Gowdy16th4516.9%6251718.213.716.043.9105027352707382132159311.270.351.358.709104 *23
17Bucky Harris HOF9th4516.9%12181215.115.315.256.91263473672212979508167472.274.352.354.70686 *4/659
18Dave Bancroft HOF14th4316.2%85291648.537.242.954.8191371821048200432591145827.279.355.358.71498 *6/457
19Lloyd Waner HOF6th3914.7%87311824.120.322.257.919937772120124592759867420.316.353.393.74799 *879/45
20Waite Hoyt HOF13th3713.9%94322151.834.042.962.16741287962550100040.198.223.235.458202371823.591121.340674425533762.1403715410031206*1
21Chuck Klein HOF9th3613.5%194481743.636.740.258.11753648611682076300120179601.320.379.543.922137 *978/3
22Johnny Vander Meer3rd3513.2%33121325.624.925.262.138268558104126141.152.200.180.37961191213.441071.39334628622104.2179910011321294*1
23Al Lopez HOF5th3412.8%71241916.611.714.243.91950591661315475165246556.261.326.337.66383 *2/453
24X-Stan Coveleski HOF5th3412.8%109381460.249.955.062.1451105870168181053.159.202.205.40792151422.891271.251450385213082.0305566802981*1/9
25Earle Combs HOF12th3412.8%97371242.534.338.457.914555746118618665863398670.325.397.462.859125 *879
26Bucky Walters5th3312.4%105271954.243.048.662.171519662274772323412114.243.286.344.630691981603.301161.32442839843104.2299015511211107*15/478
27Eppa Rixey HOF14th3212.0%75352155.433.444.462.16941522952913111249.191.221.224.445222662513.151151.272692554144494.246339310821350*1
28Leo Durocher HOF5th2810.5%1514175.17.36.254.81637535057513202456731377.247.299.320.61966 *64/5
29Lefty O'Doul8th2710.2%92311127.127.227.253.39703264624114011354236333.349.413.532.945143114.87831.970341077.210414919*791/8
30Goose Goslin HOF7th269.8%159611866.143.354.753.322878656148227352481612176949.316.387.500.887128 *798/35
31Charlie Grimm10th269.8%18192013.413.213.354.621667917908229979107757578.290.341.397.73894 *3/9758
32Jimmy Dykes9th269.8%27302235.421.428.455.22282804611082256108106970958.280.365.399.76496004.501111.5002012.02010*5*436/8719
33Bobby Doerr HOF3rd259.4%96411451.236.443.856.91865709310942042223124754809.288.362.461.823115 *4
34Jesse Haines HOF10th228.3%64271932.721.927.362.1560112476209379230.186.208.218.426122101583.641091.350555387113208.23460165871981*1/3
35Heinie Manush HOF4th228.3%137461745.834.740.253.320087654128825241101183113506.330.377.479.856121 *7*89/3
36Nick Altrock7th207.5%31181910.212.211.262.12305505297227529.176.232.207.4394083752.67961.14121816171514.01455162724251/3O9
37Billy Southworth HOF8th186.8%12191321.019.820.458.111924359661129652561138402.297.359.415.773111 *987/4
38Freddie Fitzsimmons5th166.0%56331935.723.229.562.1513115511223114103036.200.233.279.511362171463.511121.297513424133223.23335187846870*1
39Paul Derringer6th155.6%99281537.026.932.062.15791260702202102016.175.186.208.39492232123.461081.282579445293645.039121587611507*1
40Dolf Luque8th155.6%44232047.635.841.762.1559104396237590770.227.283.291.573531941793.241181.288550367293220.132311139181130*1/57
41Earl Averill HOF5th145.3%129501348.037.342.757.91669635312242019238116470774.318.395.534.928133 *879
42Babe Herman11th134.9%74391340.331.836.058.115525603882181818199794520.324.383.532.915141 *937
43Red Rolfe6th134.9%74211023.522.222.855.21175482794213946949744526.289.360.413.77399 *56
44X-Art Nehf11th134.9%71321529.524.927.262.146491590192876786.210.281.279.560571841203.201051.239451320142707.22715107640844*1/987
45Terry Moore3rd124.5%21131118.917.418.257.91298470071913188051382406.280.340.399.73999000.000.0001001.00001*8/5791
46Schoolboy Rowe1st124.5%64221543.536.439.962.149190911423918153386.263.328.382.710881581013.871101.302382278122219.12332131558913*1
47Chick Hafey HOF10th124.5%68331330.127.128.653.312834625777146616483370372.317.372.526.898133 *789
48Tommy Henrich4th114.1%49271135.728.031.958.112844603901129718379537712.282.382.491.873132 *9387
49Tommy Bridges2nd114.1%81291651.135.043.062.1424100384181074074.180.237.223.460191941383.571261.368424362102826.1267518111921674*1
50Travis Jackson HOF10th114.1%28291544.035.139.554.816566086833176813592971412.291.337.433.770102 *6*5/49
51Joe Gordon HOF4th114.1%88311157.145.851.556.915665707914153025397589759.268.357.466.822120 *43/6
52Steve O'Neill7th103.8%46261724.220.422.343.91590479544812591353430592.263.349.337.68588 *2/3
53Muddy Ruel9th103.8%49281918.516.517.543.9146845144941242453661606.275.365.332.69783 *2/3
54Wes Ferrell4th93.4%75221561.655.058.362.15481176175329382082129.280.351.446.7971001931284.041161.481374323132623.028451321040985*1/7
55Charlie Keller3rd93.4%47301343.038.640.853.311703790725108518976045784.286.410.518.928152 *79
56Joe Judge6th93.4%33322046.926.436.754.62171789811842352711034213965.298.378.420.798114 *3/9
57Jack Quinn3rd93.4%63302358.133.245.662.17711349902488115589.184.236.240.476292472183.291141.300756443563920.142381038601329*1/97
58Wally Schang4th83.0%58331945.025.235.143.918425307769150659705121849.284.393.401.794117 *2785/96
59Birdie Tebbetts1st83.0%1725144.46.05.243.91162370435710003846929389.270.341.358.70081 *2
60Glenn Wright10th83.0%33271125.324.424.854.81119415358412199472338209.294.328.447.77599 *6/3459
61Billy Herman HOF3rd72.6%147381554.735.545.156.919227707116323454783967737.304.367.407.774112 *45/3
62Howard Ehmke8th72.6%32121538.332.235.262.1429100971210073526.208.228.258.486291661663.751041.388427338152820.2287310310421030*1
63Eddie Rommel7th72.6%49231350.137.743.962.150882680164159162.199.255.245.499281711193.541211.350501249302557.02729138724599*1/749
64Mel Harder6th62.3%51212043.837.540.662.1584120389199493239.165.194.215.40972231863.801131.408582433243426.1370616111181161*1
65Stan Hack6th62.3%76381652.535.243.955.21938727812392193576421651092.301.394.397.791119 *53
66Arky Vaughan HOF5th62.3%116531472.950.661.854.8181766221173210396926118937.318.406.453.859136 *657/4
67Carl Mays1st62.3%114411550.238.344.362.150210851132915111166.268.313.350.663822071262.921191.207490325313021.1291273734862*1
68Cy Williams12th62.3%44311937.125.631.357.920026780102419812511005115690.292.365.470.835125 *O*8*97
69Pete Reiser1st62.3%39171021.821.521.657.986126624737865836887343.295.380.450.829128 *875/96
70Pinky Higgins3rd62.3%27301427.521.024.355.2180266369311941140107561800.292.370.428.798107 *5/46
71Charlie Root5th62.3%61281737.926.132.062.16321086861961193144.180.217.266.483272011603.591111.295632341423197.132521898891459*1
72Fielder Jones4th51.9%33231543.128.735.957.9178867471180192021631359817.285.368.347.715112 *O/968
73Joe Dugan6th51.9%2213149.410.59.955.21447541066515164256737250.280.317.372.68982 *564/7
74Bullet Joe Bush1st51.9%63221737.734.235.962.158012391283137140453.253.283.345.628721961843.511001.378488370203085.129909612631318*1/798
75Bob Meusel10th51.9%76311127.623.625.658.11407547582616931561071143375.309.356.497.852118 *7*958/3
76Frankie Crosetti4th51.9%58231723.919.121.554.8168362771006154198649113792.245.341.354.69583 *65/4
77Firpo Marberry3rd51.9%48241430.826.028.434.455166860128165222.192.224.237.46120148883.631161.323551186992067.1204996686822*1
78Freddie Lindstrom HOF3rd51.9%56261328.326.327.355.214385611895174710377984334.311.351.449.800110 *5879/46
79Orval Grove1st51.9%64101.54.02.862.12073732348119031.129.201.158.360463733.78921.42920715241176.21237624443741
80George Uhle2nd41.5%52211756.043.549.762.172213601723939190698.289.339.384.722862001663.991061.405513368273119.234171199661135*1
81Dolph Camilli3rd41.5%56261242.839.541.254.614905353936148223995060947.277.388.492.880135 *3
82Ernie Lombardi HOF4th41.5%133421745.927.836.843.91853585560117921909908430.306.358.460.818126 *2
83Moe Berg1st41.5%0015-4.40.4-2.043.9663181315044162061278.243.278.299.57749 *26/453
84X-Urban Shocker5th41.5%65331358.745.051.962.1412798891671701139.209.334.249.584551871173.171241.255412317252681.22709130657983*1
85Max Bishop3rd41.5%28291237.429.233.356.913384494966121641379401156.271.423.366.789103 *4/36
86Cookie Lavagetto1st41.5%16161011.212.111.755.2104335094879454048663485.269.360.377.73799 *54/36
87Mort Cooper2nd31.1%90301132.931.832.362.129765450127668023.194.223.246.46929128752.971241.215295239151840.21666845719131
88Jimmie Wilson10th31.1%4526189.28.79.043.91525477858013583262186356.284.336.370.70782 *2/34879
89Billy Werber4th31.1%33221125.122.623.855.212955024875136378539215701.271.364.392.75698 *567/948
90Lew Fonseca4th31.1%45211214.014.414.254.6937340451810753148564186.316.355.432.788103000.000.0001001.00000*3*47/5961
91Charlie Berry2nd31.1%04115.45.85.643.970920181965392325613160.267.322.374.69684 *2
92Mike Gonzalez4th31.1%019177.28.37.843.9104228292837171326352231.253.314.324.63880 *23/97
93Bill Doak1st31.1%48221623.422.923.262.145390540115130030.127.157.158.315-91691572.981071.267453369162782.22676718511014*1
94Bob O'Farrell2nd31.1%34292119.917.018.443.91492410151711205154935547.273.360.388.74898 *2
95Frankie Gustine1st31.1%1214127.810.89.355.21261458255312143848060369.265.322.359.68187 *4*5*6/23
96Tony Cuccinello2nd31.1%21201535.328.031.656.91704618473017299488442579.280.343.394.737104 *4*5/6
97Willie Kamm1st31.1%5201335.226.030.655.216935851802164329827126824.281.372.384.75697 *5
98Luke Sewell2nd31.1%3823203.86.65.243.91630538365313932069866486.259.323.341.66570 *2/39745
99Freddy Leach1st20.8%2217108.09.98.953.3991373354311477250932163.307.341.446.787101 *7*89/3
100Bill Sherdel8th20.8%37161531.424.127.762.154996096214986263.223.271.298.569521651463.721041.358514273262709.13018150661839*1/93
101High Pockets Kelly HOF5th20.8%48221625.223.924.654.6162259938191778148102065386.297.342.452.794109100.001.0001005.04012*34/7985
102Lee Meadows1st20.8%39201528.625.226.962.1498111780201575034.180.208.230.438201881803.371061.34049040673160.23280859561063*1
103Ray Kremer2nd20.8%63211023.925.424.762.130968757122569037.178.220.249.46920143853.761131.32630824791954.22108123483516*1
104Marty McManus1st20.8%26301533.523.728.656.91831666010081926120992126675.289.357.430.787102 *4*536/9
105Ossie Bluege5th20.8%8181828.319.724.055.218676440883175143848140723.272.352.356.70785 *564/37
106Earl Whitehill2nd20.8%32201737.527.132.362.15481291107264498397.204.261.242.503312181854.361001.500541473113564.2391719214311350*1/9
107Doc Cramer2nd20.8%8130208.411.19.757.922399140135727053784262572.296.340.375.71587004.501181.5001004.03031*897/16
108X-Joe McCarthy HOF5th20.8%
109Van Mungo3rd20.8%34121432.428.930.762.141078756174074129.221.250.262.511401201153.471101.337364259162113.01957898681242*1/79
110Cy Perkins1st20.8%023176.88.57.743.9117136043299333040918301.259.319.352.67076 *2/6345
111Wally Berger2nd20.8%60291142.135.838.957.913505163809155024289836435.300.359.522.881138 *8*7/39
112Lon Warneke2nd20.8%87341546.235.140.762.145996287215497152.223.266.267.533461921213.181191.245445343142782.127261757391140*1
113Tommy Holmes1st20.8%55221134.331.032.758.11320499269815078858140480.302.366.432.798122 *9*87
114Hal Schumacher4th10.4%44211329.927.928.962.145089610018115102032.202.233.287.520421581213.361111.34039132972482.12424140902906*1/8
115Bing Miller1st10.4%39301628.820.724.858.1182062129461934116993127383.311.359.461.820108 *9*78/3
116Harry Danning1st10.4%2581015.515.815.643.989029713638475739713187.285.330.415.745104 *2/3
117Curt Davis1st10.4%33201338.631.935.362.1449813701651181128.203.229.264.494331581313.421161.264429280332325.02459142479684*1
118Red Lucas3rd10.4%21191646.133.539.862.1907143915540431902124.281.340.347.687851571353.721071.25539630272542.02736136455602*1/4657
119Johnny Mostil2nd10.4%34201024.224.524.357.99723507618105423375176415.301.386.427.812113 *89/7456
120Pep Young1st10.4%13106.07.06.556.973024662746453234718152.262.308.380.68885 *465/97
121Dick Bartell3rd10.4%67321840.229.735.054.8201676291130216579710109748.284.355.391.74796 *654
122Harry Walker1st10.4%24121110.911.811.457.980726513857861021442245.296.358.383.741103 *879/345
123Red Kress1st10.4%24211416.717.116.954.81391508769114548979946474.286.347.420.767970012.54342.0364009.113166*65394/71
124Sparky Adams1st10.4%17191315.914.715.356.91424555784415889394154453.286.343.353.69582 *4*56/79
125Monte Pearson1st10.4%36141020.721.020.962.122551358117262239.228.283.290.57346100614.001121.49122419141429.21392827407031
126Sam Chapman1st10.4%12171117.417.017.257.913684988754132918077341562.266.342.438.780107 *87/39
127Ken Keltner1st10.4%37191333.828.731.355.215265683737157016385239514.276.338.441.778112 *5/3
128Whit Wyatt1st10.4%4191624.826.825.862.136660753133769026.219.254.303.55750106953.791061.321360210131761.0168498642872*1
129George Case1st10.4%48141115.316.315.853.312265016785141521377349426.282.341.358.69995 *7*98
130Bill Hallahan3rd10.4%3421214.314.514.462.13285574390232136.162.214.201.4159102944.031021.50432422471740.1183871779856*1
131Mule Haas3rd10.4%23171212.413.112.857.91168430370612574349612433.292.359.402.76194 *893/7
132General Crowder1st10.4%66201128.728.928.862.140384766164060037.194.227.227.454181671154.121051.388402292222344.12453137800799*1
133Rip Sewell1st10.4%42211327.123.925.562.1423750811526591237.203.241.264.50540143973.481081.344390243152119.12101116748636*1
134Warren Spahn HOF1st10.4%2606621100.251.775.962.1783187214136335189494.194.234.287.520433632453.091191.195750665285243.2483043414342583*1
135Ken Williams2nd10.4%68391442.636.539.553.3139748628601552196916154566.319.393.530.924138 *78/349
136Gus Suhr2nd10.4%22151123.021.122.154.61435517671414468481853718.279.368.428.796113 *3/9
137Rube Walberg1st10.4%3191536.326.931.662.154790578162484248.179.220.232.452151551414.161071.447544306342644.0279516310311085*1
138Billy Jurges2nd10.4%24161730.722.826.854.81816625372116134365636568.258.325.335.66082 *654
139Joe Sewell HOF6th10.4%68451453.737.345.554.8190371321141222649105474842.312.391.413.804108 *6*5/4
140Ray Blades1st10.4%23211015.115.215.153.376724154677265034033331.301.395.460.855123 *79/5468
141Clyde Sukeforth1st10.4%02100.52.21.443.948612371223262961295.264.319.331.65072 *2
142George Grantham1st10.4%36311332.424.628.556.9144449899121508105712132717.302.392.461.854122 *4*3/75
143Jack Scott1st10.4%1451218.016.717.462.140868067187573139.275.319.354.673841031093.85951.357356195191814.2196995493657*1/9
144Wally Moses1st10.4%45281733.024.228.658.1201273561124213889679174821.291.364.416.779109 *98/7
145Rick Ferrell HOF2nd10.4%109341829.819.924.943.91884602868716922873429931.281.378.363.74195 *2
146Bubbles Hargrave2nd10.4%24201218.617.818.243.985225333147862937629217.310.372.452.824118 *2
147Jimmy Austin1st10.4%0131822.617.920.355.215805388661132813390244592.246.326.314.64090 *56/4
148Gus Mancuso1st10.4%35241711.612.011.843.9146045053861194535438418.265.328.351.67984 *2
149Jumbo Elliott1st10.4%63108.610.49.562.12534162668437021.163.205.219.4241063744.241001.452252144121206.21338694144531
150Riggs Stephenson2nd10.4%57321432.124.228.253.31310450871415156377353494.336.407.473.880129 *745/9
151Wally Pipp1st10.4%28181531.423.527.554.6187269149741941901004125596.281.341.408.749104 *3
152Charley O'Leary2nd10.4%50110.23.41.854.89553232317731322074164.226.270.272.54367 *645/O
153Larry Benton1st10.4%2171317.117.717.462.146273854122242130.165.202.195.39761281284.03981.415455261202297.02559108691670*1
154Tom Zachary1st10.4%32151941.230.135.762.15461122792546112062.226.268.289.557481861913.731071.437533408233126.13580118914720*1
Notes: Each voting cycle, qualified members of the BBWAA name no more than 10 eligible players whom they consider worthy of Hall of Fame honors. To be enshrined, a player must be named on at least 75% of the voters' ballots. Currently, players are removed from the ballot if they are named on fewer than 5% of ballots or have been on the ballot 15 times without election. Changed to 10 times prior to the 2015 election.

"X" means off ballot for future elections. "HOF" means they were selected to the Hall of Fame in a future election.
Support us without the ads? Go Ad-Free.