Single-Season Top 50 Leaders

WAR for Pitchers †
1. Candy Cummings • 1873 7.8
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 6.7
3. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 3.1
4. Jack Manning • 1874 1.1
Earned Run Average
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 1.8
2. Jack Manning • 1874 2.09
3. Candy Cummings • 1873 2.8
4. Bobby Mathews • 1872 3.19
5. Asa Brainard • 1874 3.71
6. Asa Brainard • 1873 4.14
Wins
1. Candy Cummings • 1873 28
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 25
3. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 10
4. Asa Brainard • 1873 5
Asa Brainard • 1874 5
6. Jack Manning • 1874 4
7. Davy Force • 1873 1
Win-Loss %
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 .909
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 .667
3. Bobby Mathews • 1872 .581
4. Asa Brainard • 1873 .417
5. Jack Manning • 1874 .200
6. Asa Brainard • 1874 .185
Walks & Hits per IP
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 0.945
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 1.310
3. Jack Manning • 1874 1.325
4. Candy Cummings • 1873 1.330
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 1.758
6. Asa Brainard • 1874 1.800
Hits per 9 IP
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 7.609
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 10.640
3. Candy Cummings • 1873 11.191
4. Jack Manning • 1874 11.309
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 15.074
6. Asa Brainard • 1874 15.188
Bases On Balls per 9 IP
1. Jack Manning • 1874 0.611
2. Asa Brainard • 1873 0.745
3. Candy Cummings • 1873 0.777
4. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 0.900
5. Asa Brainard • 1874 1.013
6. Bobby Mathews • 1872 1.153
Strikeouts per 9 IP
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 1.636
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 1.264
3. Candy Cummings • 1873 0.801
4. Jack Manning • 1874 0.611
5. Asa Brainard • 1874 0.300
6. Asa Brainard • 1873 0.248
Games Played
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 49
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 42
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 30
4. Jack Manning • 1874 22
5. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 19
6. Asa Brainard • 1873 14
7. Davy Force • 1873 3
8. Johnny Ryan • 1874 1
Saves
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 1
Innings Pitched
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 406.0
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 382.0
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 240.0
4. Jack Manning • 1874 176.2
5. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 110.0
6. Asa Brainard • 1873 108.2
7. Davy Force • 1873 18.0
8. Johnny Ryan • 1874 3.1
Strikeouts
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 57
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 34
3. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 20
4. Jack Manning • 1874 12
5. Asa Brainard • 1874 8
6. Asa Brainard • 1873 3
Games Started
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 47
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 42
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 27
4. Jack Manning • 1874 20
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 14
6. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 11
7. Davy Force • 1873 1
Complete Games
1. Candy Cummings • 1873 42
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 39
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 25
4. Jack Manning • 1874 17
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 12
6. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 9
7. Davy Force • 1873 1
Shutouts
1. Candy Cummings • 1873 1
Cherokee Fisher • 1872 1
Home Runs
1. Candy Cummings • 1873 4
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 3
3. Jack Manning • 1874 2
4. Asa Brainard • 1874 1
Bases on Balls
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 52
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 33
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 27
4. Jack Manning • 1874 12
5. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 11
6. Asa Brainard • 1873 9
7. Davy Force • 1873 1
Hits
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 480
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 475
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 405
4. Jack Manning • 1874 222
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 182
6. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 93
7. Davy Force • 1873 23
8. Johnny Ryan • 1874 13
Strikeouts / Base On Balls
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 1.818
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 1.096
3. Candy Cummings • 1873 1.03
4. Jack Manning • 1874 1
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 0.333
6. Asa Brainard • 1874 0.296
Home Runs per 9 IP
1. Asa Brainard • 1874 0.038
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 0.067
3. Candy Cummings • 1873 0.094
4. Jack Manning • 1874 0.102
Losses
1. Asa Brainard • 1874 22
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 18
3. Jack Manning • 1874 16
4. Candy Cummings • 1873 14
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 7
6. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 1
Davy Force • 1873 1
Earned Runs
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 144
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 119
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 99
4. Asa Brainard • 1873 50
5. Jack Manning • 1874 41
6. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 22
7. Johnny Ryan • 1874 6
8. Davy Force • 1873 5
Wild Pitches
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 25
2. Asa Brainard • 1874 19
3. Candy Cummings • 1873 10
4. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 5
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 3
6. Jack Manning • 1874 2
7. Davy Force • 1873 1
Johnny Ryan • 1874 1
Batters Faced
1. Bobby Mathews • 1872 1922
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 1768
3. Asa Brainard • 1874 1267
4. Jack Manning • 1874 846
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 568
6. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 482
7. Davy Force • 1873 90
8. Johnny Ryan • 1874 23
Games Finished
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 6
2. Asa Brainard • 1874 4
Bobby Mathews • 1872 4
4. Davy Force • 1873 2
5. Jack Manning • 1874 1
Adjusted ERA+
1. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 206
2. Candy Cummings • 1873 124
3. Bobby Mathews • 1872 116
4. Jack Manning • 1874 108
5. Asa Brainard • 1873 84
6. Asa Brainard • 1874 61
Fielding Independent Pitching
1. Jack Manning • 1874 2.28
2. Asa Brainard • 1874 2.39
3. Asa Brainard • 1873 3.29
4. Candy Cummings • 1873 3.32
5. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 3.37
6. Bobby Mathews • 1872 3.63
Adj. Pitching Runs
1. Candy Cummings • 1873 32
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 24
3. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 19
4. Davy Force • 1873 1
Adj. Pitching Wins
1. Candy Cummings • 1873 2.3
2. Bobby Mathews • 1872 1.7
3. Cherokee Fisher • 1872 1.3
4. Davy Force • 1873 0.1

Data Notes