Want All the News in One Spot?

Every day, we'll send you an email to your inbox with scores, today's schedule, top performers, new debuts and interesting tidbits. View a sample email. It's also available for football, basketball and hockey.

Subscribe to our Stathead Newsletter

1885 Most Common Starters

  • Players listed have the most games at that position
  • (WAR)
1885 Most Common Starters
Rk Tm C 1B 2B 3B SS LF CF RF
1BAL (41-68, 0.33 oWAR)B.Traffley (-1.27)D.Stearns (0.13)T.Manning (-0.06)M.Muldoon (0.96)J.Macullar (0.30)J.Sommer (1.16)D.Casey (0.67)O.Burns (0.27)
2BRO (53-59, 7.51 oWAR)J.Hayes (-0.71)B.Phillips (2.90)G.Pinkney (1.93)B.McClellan (1.24)G.Smith (3.43)E.Swartwood (0.78)P.Hotaling (1.21)J.Cassidy (-0.97)
3BSN (46-66, 5.14 oWAR)T.Gunning (-0.69)J.Morrill (2.03)J.Burdock (-0.80)E.Sutton (4.05)S.Wise (2.62)T.McCarthy (-0.78)J.Manning (0.39)T.Poorman (0.03)
4BUF (38-74, 5.26 oWAR)G.Myers (-0.23)D.Brouthers (5.24)H.Richardson (3.34)D.White (2.10)J.Rowe (2.20)B.Crowley (-0.29)S.Carroll (-0.55)J.Lillie (-0.73)
5CHC (87-25, 23.94 oWAR)S.Flint (0.32)C.Anson (3.86)F.Pfeffer (2.48)N.Williamson (4.51)T.Burns (2.92)A.Dalrymple (3.17)G.Gore (4.90)K.Kelly (3.50)
6CIN (63-49, 9.66 oWAR)P.Snyder (0.50)J.Reilly (1.77)B.McPhee (1.65)H.Carpenter (0.71)F.Fennelly (3.29)C.Jones (3.95)J.Clinton (-0.77)P.Corkhill (0.48)
7DTN (41-67, 12.18 oWAR)C.Bennett (4.54)M.McQuery (1.88)S.Crane (-0.31)J.Donnelly (0.29)M.Phillips (-0.16)G.Wood (2.51)N.Hanlon (3.32)S.Thompson (2.39)
8LOU (53-59, 6.21 oWAR)J.Crotty (-0.87)J.Kerins (0.49)T.McLaughlin (-0.61)P.Reccius (-0.47)J.Miller (0.32)L.Maskrey (-0.21)P.Browning (5.25)C.Wolf (1.97)
9NYG (85-27, 28.11 oWAR)B.Ewing (3.86)R.Connor (8.16)J.Gerhardt (-0.04)D.Esterbrook (1.88)J.Ward (2.42)P.Gillespie (2.03)J.O'Rourke (4.04)M.Dorgan (3.10)
10NYP (44-64, 15.81 oWAR)C.Reipschlager (0.93)D.Orr (4.48)T.Forster (0.30)F.Hankinson (1.59)C.Nelson (3.88)E.Kennedy (-0.50)C.Roseman (2.35)S.Brady (2.55)
11PHA (55-57, 10.99 oWAR)J.Milligan (2.20)H.Stovey (3.75)C.Stricker (-1.09)F.Corey (0.45)S.Houck (1.02)B.Purcell (0.26)H.Larkin (4.25)J.Coleman (1.07)
12PHI (56-54, 12.39 oWAR)J.Clements (-0.30)S.Farrar (2.47)A.Myers (0.16)J.Mulvey (2.77)C.Bastian (0.92)E.Andrews (2.09)J.Fogarty (2.29)J.Manning (1.94)
13PIT (56-55, 7.07 oWAR)F.Carroll (1.35)J.Field (0.86)P.Smith (2.42)B.Kuehne (0.69)A.Whitney (0.35)C.Eden (-0.51)F.Mann (0.66)T.Brown (2.85)
14PRO (53-57, 8.70 oWAR)B.Gilligan (1.25)J.Start (2.88)J.Farrell (0.00)J.Denny (0.73)A.Irwin (0.18)C.Carroll (1.16)P.Hines (1.99)P.Radford (0.45)
15SLM (36-72, 6.74 oWAR)F.Briody (0.51)A.McKinnon (2.73)F.Dunlap (4.33)E.Caskin (-0.37)J.Glasscock (5.14)E.Seery (-0.86)F.Lewis (1.06)O.Shafer (0.16)
16STL (79-33, 11.27 oWAR)D.Bushong (2.24)C.Comiskey (1.28)S.Barkley (2.87)A.Latham (-0.71)B.Gleason (1.05)T.O'Neill (1.85)C.Welch (2.22)H.Nicol (-0.42)

More 1885 MLB Pages

1885 MLB Season

Minor Leagues

Standings

Schedule

Fielding

Batting

Pitching

Managers

Fielding

Batting

Pitching

Leaders & Awards

Other

Support us without the ads? Go Ad-Free.