Yearly League Leaders & Records for Replay Challenge Success %

Stathead Logo
.com Logo
Create your own custom leaderboards
Become a Stathead today and run queries with our Season and Career Finders to see the best seasons in MLB history.
Become a Stathead

Year National League Overturn%   American League Overturn%      
2024 (NL AL)Brian Snitker (ATL)100.00 Aaron Boone (NYY)100.00   
2023 (NL AL)Dave Martinez (WSN)75.86 Dusty Baker (HOU)64.29   
2022 (NL AL)Buck Showalter (NYM)78.79 Miguel Cairo (CHW)66.67   
2021 (NL AL)David Bell (CIN)76.92 Tony La Russa+ (CHW)77.78   
2020 (NL AL)Dave Martinez (WSN)73.68 Lloyd McClendon (DET)100.00   
2019 (NL AL)Rod Barajas (SDP)75.00 Ned Yost (KCR)82.14   
2018 (NL AL)Bruce Bochy (SFG)74.19 Ned Yost (KCR)75.61   
2017 (NL AL)Dave Roberts (LAD)63.89 Joe Girardi (NYY)75.00   
2016 (NL AL)Terry Collins (NYM)64.29 Ned Yost (KCR)67.57   
2015 (NL AL)Ron Roenicke (MIL)80.00 Joe Girardi (NYY)73.33   
2014 (NL AL)Mike Redmond (MIA)70.37 Joe Girardi (NYY)80.00