Players who played for New York Mets and New York Yankees

Return to the form to edit this search or create a new search.

Are you hooked on Immaculate Grid, the daily trivia game from Baseball Reference? Whether you're looking for a little help on your grid or you already filled it out and want to know who else qualified, we have you covered. There were 163 players who played for both the New York Mets and New York Yankees.

Top Players who Played for the New York Mets and New York Yankees.

(Ranked by WAR)

Rickey Henderson

Hall of Famer Rickey Henderson played 2 seasons for the New York Mets (1.3 WAR) and 5 seasons for the New York Yankees (30.8 WAR).

Willie Randolph

Willie Randolph played 1 season for the New York Mets (0.9 WAR) and 13 seasons for the New York Yankees (54.1 WAR).

Yogi Berra

Hall of Famer Yogi Berra played 1 season for the New York Mets (-0.1 WAR) and 18 seasons for the New York Yankees (59.6 WAR).

Robinson Canó

Robinson Canó played 3 seasons for the New York Mets (1.1 WAR) and 9 seasons for the New York Yankees (44.4 WAR).

Dwight Gooden

Dwight Gooden played 11 seasons for the New York Mets (46.4 WAR) and 3 seasons for the New York Yankees (5.1 WAR).

Batting

  • 124 players batted for each of these franchises.
Batting Table
New York Mets New York Yankees
Name Yrs G AB BA HR SB WAR Yrs G AB BA HR SB WAR
Bobby Abreu201478133.24811-0.52006-20083721423.29543577.0
Juan Acevedo1997226.00000-0.1200320000.0
Jack Aker1974242.500000.11969-197212428.07100-0.4
Sandy Alomar19671522.00000-0.51974-1976294931.2484462.0
Jason Anderson200360000.02003-200530000.0
Tucker Ashford19833556.17900-0.4198130000.0
Luis Ayala2008190000.0201170000.0
Harrison Bader202481255.2756131.32022-202398334.2377190.8
Carlos Beltrán2005-20118393133.28014910031.12014-20163411240.2705632.8
Yogi Berra196549.22200-0.11946-196321167546.2853583059.6
Ángel Berroa20091427.14800-0.320092122.13600-0.7
Dellin Betances2020-202110000.02011-2019281.000000.0
Daryl Boston1990-1992382910.26627452.819945277.18240-0.6
Darren Bragg20011857.263030.0200154.250000.0
Jay Bruce2016-2018247894.2374621.820211034.11810-0.3
Miguel Cairo2005100327.251213-0.52004-2007257689.2696322.0
Robinson Canó2019-2022168602.2692401.12005-201313745336.3092043844.4
Chris Capuano20113456.07100-0.52014-201521.000000.0
Duke Carmel196347149.235320.8196568.00000-0.2
Alberto Castillo1995-199892182.198210.620021537.13500-0.4
Miguel Castro2020-2021650000.02022
Rick Cerone199190227.273211.71980-19905871842.2493123.9
Tony Clark2003125254.232160-0.82004106253.2211600.2
Tyler Clippard2015291.000000.02007-201772.500000.1
Bartolo Colon2014-201690180.08310-0.9201111.000000.0
David Cone1987-2003188399.155000.81995-2000412.16700-0.1
Billy Cowan196582156.17933-0.719693248.16710-0.5
Ike Davis2010-20144541512.2416875.72016814.214000.0
J.D. Davis2019-2022335960.2783751.82024513.07700-0.2
Wilson Delgado200442130.292210.720003145.244110.0
Brandon Drury20215184.274400.220181851.17610-0.3
Dock Ellis19791726.07700-0.21976-1977
Kevin Elster1986-19925371584.22434104.61994-19951737.05400-0.8
Scott Erickson200423.000000.0200610000.0
Álvaro Espinoza199648134.306400.81988-19914471424.255783.4
Kyle Farnsworth2014170000.02006-2008160000.0
Tony Fernández199348173.225160.21995108384.245560.9
Tim Foli1970-1979218719.243171.1198461163.25200-0.4
Todd Frazier2018-2020262904.23241104.7201766194.2221101.1
Bob Friend19662229.03400-0.419661211.00000-0.3
Ben Gamel202487.143010.0201668.125000.0
Karim García200462192.23473-0.82002-200354156.301600.3
Rob Gardner1965-19664848.14600-0.11970-19722331.12900-0.2
Jesse Gonder1963-1965226572.2711411.91960-19612219.316100.2
Dwight Gooden1984-1994309730.197714.81996-200046.00000-0.1
Curtis Granderson2014-20175732026.239952710.92010-20135131859.2451155514.9
Lee Guetterman1992432.000000.01988-199230000.0
LaTroy Hawkins2013690000.0200820000.0
Adeiny Hechavarría201960142.20453-0.320181836.194210.0
Rickey Henderson1999-2000152534.29812421.31985-19895962302.2887832630.8
Sean Henn201340000.02005-200711.000000.0
Félix Heredia200530000.02003-200450000.0
Orlando Hernández2006-20074583.157030.11998-2004619.05300-0.2
Keith Hughes199089.00000-0.2198744.00000
Stan Jefferson19861424.208100.119891012.08301-0.5
Kelly Johnson2015-2016131311.2601441.1201477201.219620.3
Lance Johnson1996-1997232947.32610658.620001830.300020.0
Dave Kingman1975-19836642323.219154293.01977824.250400.4
Brandon Knight200843.00000-0.12001-200210000.0
Matt Lawton200148183.2463100.320052148.12521-0.4
Tim Leary1981-19842314.286110.31990-199210000.0
Ricky Ledée2006-20074468.16221-0.31998-2000192520.25817141.3
Al Leiter1998-2004198394.08400-1.61987-2005
Cory Lidle1997515.000000.02006
Phil Linz1967-1968102316.20901-1.41962-1965354968.24610124.1
Graeme Lloyd2003350000.01996-199840000.0
Tim Locastro20234356.232260.42021-20224764.18838-0.3
Phil Lombardi19891848.22910-0.21986-19872544.250200.2
Terrence Long199933.0000020061236.16700-0.4
Elliott Maddox1978-19803351024.255762.61974-1976210730.2994157.5
Cameron Maybin2021928.03601-0.3201982239.2851191.6
Lee Mazzilli1976-19899793013.2646815212.5198237128.266620.3
Billy McKinney20213991.220510.32018-202350132.227610.1
Doc Medich197712.000000.01972-197520000.0
Doug Mientkiewicz200587275.2401101.1200772166.277501.4
Gustavo Molina200827.14300-0.1201136.167000.0
Xavier Nady200675265.2641420.62008-200966256.2701211.0
Eduardo Núñez202022.500010.02010-2013270752.2671048-1.4
John Olerud1997-19994761662.31563517.3200449164.280400.6
Adam Ottavino2022-20242019-202050000.0
Chan Ho Park200711.000000.0201050000.0
Andy Phillips200845.20000-0.12004-2007203479.2531130.4
Lenny Randle1977-1978268950.2727475.019792039.17900-0.5
Willie Randolph199290286.252210.91976-198816946303.2754825154.1
Hal Reniff1967294.00000-0.11961-196725048.10400-0.3
Joely Rodríguez202220000.0202130000.0
Kenny Rogers19991225.12000-0.11996-199723.000000.0
Rafael Santana1984-19874831514.248821.51988148480.24041-0.6
Gary Sheffield2009100268.2761020.32004-20063471308.29176208.7
Bill Short1968342.000000.019601015.200000.1
Chasen Shreve2020-202210000.02015-2018102.000000.0
Charley Smith1964-1965262942.2423642.81967-1968181495.2241001.2
Shane Spencer200474185.281460.41998-20023451091.2634354.0
Roy Staiger1975-1977148446.226442.21979411.273000.0
Mike Stanton2003-20041283.333000.01997-2005305.200000.1
Kelly Stinnett1994-2006131358.229640.120063479.22810-0.2
Darryl Strawberry1983-199011093903.26325219136.61995-1999231662.25541162.9
Tom Sturdivant1964161.000000.01955-1959115174.218000.6
Bill Sudakis19721849.14310-0.2197489259.23270-0.4
Anthony Swarzak2018270000.0201640000.0
Ron Swoboda1965-19707372212.24269207.01971-1973152294.235400.3
Gary Sánchez202336.16700-0.12015-20215381932.230138411.7
Rey Sánchez200356174.20701-1.01997-200561181.304100.3
Tony Tarasco20026096.250620.719991431.16101-0.5
Stephen Tarpley202110000.02018-2019
Ralph Terry1966-1967136.167000.01956-1964210394.15500-1.2
Ryan Thompson1992-1995283997.2393983.420003350.260300.2
Marv Throneberry1962-1963130371.2401610.11955-1959141344.2381520.2
Dick Tidrow1984110000.01974-197910000.0
Mike Torrez1983-19844875.08000-0.61977
Bubba Trammell20003656.232310.020032255.20000-0.1
Robin Ventura1999-20014441513.26077611.02002-2003230748.2493635.5
José Vizcaíno1994-19963341282.2827182.3200073174.276050.2
Neil Walker2016-2017186677.2753333.52018113347.219110-0.1
Claudell Washington198079284.27510170.11986-1990315982.27726343.8
Allen Watson19991310.300000.01999-200010000.0
David Weathers2002-20041694.00000-0.11996-1997
Gerald Williams2004-200596159.23354-0.31992-2002384659.24118211.0
Mason Williams20211733.212100.02015-20172564.28112-0.2
Justin Wilson2019-2020400000.02015-202160000.0
Gene Woodling196281190.274500.41949-19546982272.285511316.2
Chris Young201488254.205870.12014-2015163389.2571742.0
Eric Young Jr.2013-2015209662.2392712.1201661.00001-0.1
Todd Zeile2000-20044411423.2594142.7200366186.21060-0.4

Pitching

  • 83 players pitched for each of these franchises.
Pitching Table
New York Mets New York Yankees
Name Yrs G IP W L SV ERA WAR Yrs G IP W L SV ERA WAR
David Aardsma20134339.22204.31-0.1201211.00009.000.0
Juan Acevedo19972547.23103.590.120032525.20367.71-1.0
Jack Aker19742441.12123.480.51969-1972124197.11610312.235.6
Neil Allen1979-1983223381.22540693.543.71985-198866171.16413.622.7
Jason Anderson2003610.20005.060.02003-20052526.12005.470.0
Luis Avilán20194532.04005.060.12020108.10004.320.1
Luis Ayala20081918.01295.50-0.320115256.02202.091.3
Anthony Banda202157.11007.36-0.3202220.200040.50-0.1
Jacob Barnes20211918.21126.27-0.4202211.20000.000.1
Armando Benítez1999-2003333347.018141602.709.8200399.11101.930.2
Dellin Betances2020-20211612.20107.82-0.32011-2019358381.22122362.3611.4
Phil Bickford20232525.13214.620.0202455.000014.40-0.3
Tim Burke1991-19925071.14513.410.319922327.22203.250.1
Ray Burris1979-198033192.071503.941.319791527.21306.18-0.9
John Candelaria1987312.12005.84-0.11988-198935206.0161013.802.5
Chris Capuano201133186.0111204.550.82014-201534106.12705.67-0.9
Buddy Carlyle2014-20153839.02112.310.6201187.20104.700.0
Miguel Castro2020-20217979.14603.520.720223429.05004.03-0.3
Tyler Clippard20153232.14123.060.32007-20177588.26934.670.3
Bartolo Colon2014-201698588.2443403.904.7201129164.181004.001.5
David Cone1987-20031871209.1815113.1319.41995-2000145922.0644003.9120.3
Octavio Dotel19991985.18305.380.220061410.000010.80-0.5
Dock Ellis19791785.03706.04-1.11976-197735231.118903.071.4
Scott Erickson200428.00107.88-0.32006911.10007.94-0.4
Kyle Farnsworth20141917.00333.180.22006-2008181170.16974.331.6
Bob Friend19662286.05814.40-0.519661244.21404.84-0.3
Rob Gardner1965-196646161.241014.79-0.41970-197223107.19503.190.0
Paul Gibson1992-19935170.21205.22-0.71993-19965468.23104.060.5
Dwight Gooden1984-19943052169.21578513.1041.61996-200067341.1241424.675.2
Lee Guetterman19924343.13425.82-0.91988-1992233347.12119213.734.0
Greg Harris19811668.23514.460.2199435.00105.40-0.2
LaTroy Hawkins20137270.232132.930.620083341.01105.710.0
Sean Henn201342.20103.380.12005-20073657.12607.53-1.2
Félix Heredia200532.20000.000.12003-20045953.21204.860.2
Orlando Hernández2006-200747264.1181203.883.91998-2004139876.1614013.9619.0
Rich Hill20211363.11403.840.72014145.10001.690.2
Ryota Igarashi2010-20117969.05205.74-1.0201223.000012.00-0.1
Brandon Knight2008412.01005.250.02001-20021119.100010.71-0.7
Aaron Laffey2013410.00007.20-0.320111110.22103.380.2
Tim Leary1981-19842366.14403.80-0.11990-199277425.2183505.120.5
Al Leiter1998-20042131360.0956703.4228.01987-200538169.0111305.170.4
Cory Lidle19975481.27223.530.420061045.14305.160.5
Graeme Lloyd20033635.11203.310.51996-199810992.14313.511.1
Bob MacDonald19962019.00204.26-0.119953346.11104.860.3
Josías Manzanillo1993-19996794.04424.210.719951117.10002.080.4
Doc Medich197717.00103.860.11972-1975111787.0494003.4011.2
Dale Murray1978-1979111183.1121394.27-0.81983-198562120.03614.73-0.7
C.J. Nitkowski200155.21000.000.220041913.01107.62-0.2
Darren O'Day200943.00000.000.020211210.20003.380.3
Bob Ojeda1986-1990140764.0514003.129.6199423.000024.00-0.4
Jesse Orosco1979-1987372595.247471072.7312.32003154.100010.38-0.4
Adam Ottavino2022-2024168162.1812163.103.22019-20209784.28822.762.1
John Pacella1977-198039104.13604.83-0.41982310.00107.20-0.2
Juan Padilla20052436.13111.491.42004611.10003.970.2
Chan Ho Park200714.001015.75-0.320102735.12105.60-0.5
Jeff Reardon1979-198197159.2109102.652.91994119.21028.38-0.3
Tim Redding200930120.03605.100.1200511.001054.00-0.3
Hal Reniff19672943.03343.350.21961-1967247428.11820413.263.8
Royce Ring2005-20062623.10203.470.4201052.100015.43-0.2
David Robertson20234044.042142.051.92008-2018501498.03822532.7512.9
Joely Rodríguez20225550.12404.47-0.220212119.01002.840.3
Kenny Rogers19991276.05104.031.21996-199761324.0181505.113.5
Dennis Santana2023910.21005.91-0.120242327.12026.26-0.5
Don Schulze1987521.21206.23-0.31989211.01104.090.1
Luis Severino202418109.26303.781.32015-2023141727.1543703.7911.9
Bill Short19683429.20314.85-0.819601047.03504.79-0.3
Chasen Shreve2020-20224251.12105.26-0.12015-2018180174.214623.921.6
Mike Stanton2003-2004133122.141353.681.41997-2005456448.13114153.778.8
Marcus Stroman2019-202144238.2141503.214.7202419105.07403.511.6
Tom Sturdivant19641628.20015.97-0.51955-1959115524.1362553.196.1
Anthony Swarzak20182926.10246.15-0.520162631.01205.52-0.1
Frank Tanana199329183.071504.480.71993319.20203.200.2
Stephen Tarpley202110.00000.02018-20193133.21025.88-0.3
Walt Terrell1982-198457369.2192303.534.019891383.06505.20-0.4
Ralph Terry1966-19671328.00114.180.21956-19642101198.0785993.449.6
Dick Tidrow19841115.20009.19-0.81974-1979211711.14133233.614.6
Michael Tonkin202457.01205.14-0.820242635.12111.530.9
Mike Torrez1983-198448260.0112204.47-0.2197731217.0141203.822.4
Raúl Valdés20103858.23314.91-0.3201166.20002.700.2
Allen Watson19991439.22214.080.51999-20003856.14005.270.8
David Weathers2002-2004180198.2121273.223.31996-19972126.10309.57-1.0
Wally Whitehurst1989-1992127310.0112233.832.3199628.01106.750.0
Justin Wilson2019-20206858.26342.911.42015-20219579.06104.101.0

What is Immaculate Grid?

Immaculate Grid is a daily trivia game powered by Sports Reference.

Is there an Immaculate Grid game for basketball, football, hockey and soccer?

Yes, Sports Reference has Immaculate Grid games for Men's Basketball, Women's Basketball, Football, Hockey and Soccer as well as Baseball.

How do you play Immaculate Grid?

To play Immaculate Grid, you choose nine players to fill a grid. The grid is laid out as three rows and three columns. You select a player for each cell that matches the criteria for that cell's row and column. You have nine guesses to fill out the grid. Each guess, whether correct or incorrect, counts as a guess.

There is a new grid every day at 6:00 am ET.

See the full rules for more.