Year and record in Bold indicates they won pennant.
Shading is not used to differentiate the players' performances. It is merely used to quickly illustrate long strings of games/years played by a single player. When a player in the column changes, so does the color of the shading.
| Year | C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | LF | CF | RF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Most Years | Bushong | Stovey | Creamer | Carpenter | Irwin | Wood | Hayes | Corey |
| Most Games | Bushong 185 gms Bennett 46 gms Hayes 15 gms Hotaling 3 gms Reilley 2 gms | Stovey 137 gms Sullivan 43 gms Dorgan 26 gms Smith 19 gms Cogswell 13 gms | Creamer 246 gms Smith 3 gms O'Brien 2 gms Evans 1 gms Nichols 0 gms | Carpenter 83 gms Whitney 76 gms Irwin 54 gms Mann 18 gms Corey 7 gms | Irwin 165 gms Corey 36 gms Nelson 24 gms McLaughlin 14 gms Evans 11 gms | Wood 80 gms Dickerson 79 gms Stovey 47 gms Clinton 21 gms O'Brien 16 gms | Hotaling 72 gms Hayes 55 gms Stovey 42 gms Dickerson 31 gms Corey 16 gms | Evans 64 gms Knight 49 gms Corey 45 gms Richmond 36 gms Dorgan 23 gms |
| 1882 (18-66) | Bushong | Stovey | Creamer | Irwin | Corey | Clinton | Hayes | Evans |
| 1881 (32-50) | Bushong | Stovey | Creamer | Carpenter | Irwin | Dickerson | Hotaling | Corey |
| 1880 (40-43) | Bennett | Sullivan | Creamer | Whitney | Irwin | Wood | Stovey | Knight |
| 3 years | 2 players | 2 players | 1 players | 3 players | 2 players | 3 players | 3 players | 3 players |