Play Index Relaunched--Free Trial / Blog Post
B-R on Twitter / Facebook
S-R.com: Baseball | Basketball | Football | Hockey | Olympics

You Are Here > Baseball-Reference.com > Teams > Franchise Encyclopedia > Batting Leaders

New York Mutuals Top 10 Batting Leaders

Team Encyclopedia
  Starters: Positional / Pitching - Players: Batting / Pitching - Teams: Batting / Pitching
  Leaders: Batting / Pitching - Managers - Attendance/Parks
  Hall of Fame Register - Opening Day Starters
  Logos from SportsLogos.net. Page: none available.

Create Custom Leaderboards

The Baseball-Reference.com Play Index's Batting Season Finder lets you create your own custom leaderboards by team, age, position, years, or any other common criteria. View Sample Leaderboards created with the batting season finder.

New York Mutuals Top 10 Batting Leaders

See Also: Top 10 / Top 50
Click on the Player for player statistics, biography, and information.
Click on the Year for team roster, statistics, and leaders.
1500 PA required for career rate statistics.

Single-Season Leaders

Career Leaders

Batting Average
Rank Player BA Year

Batting Average
Rank Player BA PA

On-Base%
Rank Player OBP Year

On-Base%
Rank Player OBP PA

Slugging %
Rank Player SLG Year

Slugging %
Rank Player SLG PA

On-Base Plus Slugging
Rank Player OPS Year

On-Base Plus Slugging
Rank Player OPS PA

Games Played
Rank Player Games Year

1. Eddie Booth 57 1876

Al Nichols 57 1876

Fred Treacey 57 1876

4. Bill Craver 56 1876

Bobby Mathews 56 1876

Joe Start 56 1876

7. Jimmy Hallinan 54 1876

8. Jim Holdsworth 52 1876

9. Nat Hicks 45 1876

10. John Hayes 5 1876

Games Played
Rank Player Games PA

1. Eddie Booth 57 230

Al Nichols 57 214

Fred Treacey 57 257

4. Bill Craver 56 248

Bobby Mathews 56 221

Joe Start 56 265

7. Jimmy Hallinan 54 242

8. Jim Holdsworth 52 242

9. Nat Hicks 45 191

10. John Hayes 5 21

At Bats
Rank Player AB Year

1. Joe Start 264 1876

2. Fred Treacey 256 1876

3. Bill Craver 246 1876

4. Jim Holdsworth 241 1876

5. Jimmy Hallinan 240 1876

6. Eddie Booth 228 1876

7. Bobby Mathews 218 1876

8. Al Nichols 212 1876

9. Nat Hicks 188 1876

10. John Hayes 21 1876

At Bats
Rank Player AB PA

1. Joe Start 264 265

2. Fred Treacey 256 257

3. Bill Craver 246 248

4. Jim Holdsworth 241 242

5. Jimmy Hallinan 240 242

6. Eddie Booth 228 230

7. Bobby Mathews 218 221

8. Al Nichols 212 214

9. Nat Hicks 188 191

10. John Hayes 21 21

Plate Appearances
Rank Player PA Year

1. Joe Start 265 1876

2. Fred Treacey 257 1876

3. Bill Craver 248 1876

4. Jimmy Hallinan 242 1876

Jim Holdsworth 242 1876

6. Eddie Booth 230 1876

7. Bobby Mathews 221 1876

8. Al Nichols 214 1876

9. Nat Hicks 191 1876

10. John Hayes 21 1876

Plate Appearances
Rank Player PA PA

1. Joe Start 265 265

2. Fred Treacey 257 257

3. Bill Craver 248 248

4. Jimmy Hallinan 242 242

Jim Holdsworth 242 242

6. Eddie Booth 230 230

7. Bobby Mathews 221 221

8. Al Nichols 214 214

9. Nat Hicks 191 191

10. John Hayes 21 21

Runs Scored
Rank Player Runs Year

1. Fred Treacey 47 1876

2. Jimmy Hallinan 45 1876

3. Joe Start 40 1876

4. Bill Craver 24 1876

5. Jim Holdsworth 23 1876

6. Nat Hicks 20 1876

Al Nichols 20 1876

8. Bobby Mathews 19 1876

9. Eddie Booth 17 1876

10. George Bechtel 2 1876

Runs Scored
Rank Player Runs PA

1. Fred Treacey 47 257

2. Jimmy Hallinan 45 242

3. Joe Start 40 265

4. Bill Craver 24 248

5. Jim Holdsworth 23 242

6. Nat Hicks 20 191

Al Nichols 20 214

8. Bobby Mathews 19 221

9. Eddie Booth 17 230

10. George Bechtel 2 10

Hits
Rank Player Hits Year

1. Joe Start 73 1876

2. Jimmy Hallinan 67 1876

3. Jim Holdsworth 64 1876

4. Bill Craver 55 1876

5. Fred Treacey 54 1876

6. Eddie Booth 49 1876

7. Nat Hicks 44 1876

8. Bobby Mathews 40 1876

9. Al Nichols 38 1876

10. George Bechtel 3 1876

John Hayes 3 1876

Hits
Rank Player Hits PA

1. Joe Start 73 265

2. Jimmy Hallinan 67 242

3. Jim Holdsworth 64 242

4. Bill Craver 55 248

5. Fred Treacey 54 257

6. Eddie Booth 49 230

7. Nat Hicks 44 191

8. Bobby Mathews 40 221

9. Al Nichols 38 214

10. George Bechtel 3 10

John Hayes 3 21

Total Bases
Rank Player TB Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 92 1876

2. Joe Start 79 1876

3. Jim Holdsworth 71 1876

4. Fred Treacey 61 1876

5. Bill Craver 59 1876

6. Eddie Booth 53 1876

7. Nat Hicks 50 1876

8. Bobby Mathews 46 1876

9. Al Nichols 42 1876

10. John Hayes 7 1876

Total Bases
Rank Player TB PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 92 242

2. Joe Start 79 265

3. Jim Holdsworth 71 242

4. Fred Treacey 61 257

5. Bill Craver 59 248

6. Eddie Booth 53 230

7. Nat Hicks 50 191

8. Bobby Mathews 46 221

9. Al Nichols 42 214

10. John Hayes 7 21

Doubles
Rank Player Doubles Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 7 1876

2. Joe Start 6 1876

3. Fred Treacey 5 1876

4. Bill Craver 4 1876

Nat Hicks 4 1876

Bobby Mathews 4 1876

Al Nichols 4 1876

8. Jim Holdsworth 3 1876

9. Eddie Booth 2 1876

Doubles
Rank Player Doubles PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 7 242

2. Joe Start 6 265

3. Fred Treacey 5 257

4. Bill Craver 4 248

Nat Hicks 4 191

Bobby Mathews 4 221

Al Nichols 4 214

8. Jim Holdsworth 3 242

9. Eddie Booth 2 230

Triples
Rank Player Triples Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 6 1876

2. John Hayes 2 1876

Jim Holdsworth 2 1876

4. Eddie Booth 1 1876

Nat Hicks 1 1876

John Maloney 1 1876

Bobby Mathews 1 1876

Fred Treacey 1 1876

Triples
Rank Player Triples PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 6 242

2. John Hayes 2 21

Jim Holdsworth 2 242

4. Eddie Booth 1 230

Nat Hicks 1 191

John Maloney 1 7

Bobby Mathews 1 221

Fred Treacey 1 257

Home Runs
Rank Player HR Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 2 1876

Home Runs
Rank Player HR PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 2 242

Runs Batted In
Rank Player RBI Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 36 1876

2. Bill Craver 22 1876

3. Joe Start 21 1876

4. Jim Holdsworth 19 1876

5. Fred Treacey 18 1876

6. Nat Hicks 15 1876

7. Bobby Mathews 9 1876

Al Nichols 9 1876

9. Eddie Booth 7 1876

10. John Hayes 2 1876

John Maloney 2 1876

Runs Batted In
Rank Player RBI PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 36 242

2. Bill Craver 22 248

3. Joe Start 21 265

4. Jim Holdsworth 19 242

5. Fred Treacey 18 257

6. Nat Hicks 15 191

7. Bobby Mathews 9 221

Al Nichols 9 214

9. Eddie Booth 7 230

10. John Hayes 2 21

John Maloney 2 7

Bases on Balls
Rank Player BB Year

1. Nat Hicks 3 1876

Bobby Mathews 3 1876

3. Eddie Booth 2 1876

Bill Craver 2 1876

Jimmy Hallinan 2 1876

Al Nichols 2 1876

7. Jim Holdsworth 1 1876

Joe Start 1 1876

Fred Treacey 1 1876

Pete Treacey 1 1876

Bases on Balls
Rank Player BB PA

1. Nat Hicks 3 191

Bobby Mathews 3 221

3. Eddie Booth 2 230

Bill Craver 2 248

Jimmy Hallinan 2 242

Al Nichols 2 214

7. Jim Holdsworth 1 242

Joe Start 1 265

Fred Treacey 1 257

Pete Treacey 1 6

Strikeouts
Rank Player SO Year

1. Bill Craver 7 1876

2. Fred Treacey 5 1876

3. Eddie Booth 4 1876

Jimmy Hallinan 4 1876

Nat Hicks 4 1876

6. Al Nichols 3 1876

7. Jim Holdsworth 2 1876

Bobby Mathews 2 1876

Joe Start 2 1876

10. John Maloney 1 1876

Nealy Phelps 1 1876

Strikeouts
Rank Player SO PA

1. Bill Craver 7 248

2. Fred Treacey 5 257

3. Eddie Booth 4 230

Jimmy Hallinan 4 242

Nat Hicks 4 191

6. Al Nichols 3 214

7. Jim Holdsworth 2 242

Bobby Mathews 2 221

Joe Start 2 265

10. John Maloney 1 7

Nealy Phelps 1 3

Stolen Bases
Rank Player SB Year

Stolen Bases
Rank Player SB PA

Singles
Rank Player Singles Year

1. Joe Start 67 1876

2. Jim Holdsworth 59 1876

3. Jimmy Hallinan 52 1876

4. Bill Craver 51 1876

5. Fred Treacey 48 1876

6. Eddie Booth 46 1876

7. Nat Hicks 39 1876

8. Bobby Mathews 35 1876

9. Al Nichols 34 1876

10. George Bechtel 3 1876

Singles
Rank Player Singles PA

1. Joe Start 67 265

2. Jim Holdsworth 59 242

3. Jimmy Hallinan 52 242

4. Bill Craver 51 248

5. Fred Treacey 48 257

6. Eddie Booth 46 230

7. Nat Hicks 39 191

8. Bobby Mathews 35 221

9. Al Nichols 34 214

10. George Bechtel 3 10

Adjusted OPS+
Rank Player OPS+ Year

Adjusted OPS+
Rank Player OPS+ PA

Runs Created
Rank Player RC Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 26 1876

2. Joe Start 22 1876

3. Jim Holdsworth 19 1876

4. Bill Craver 14 1876

5. Fred Treacey 13 1876

6. Eddie Booth 12 1876

Nat Hicks 12 1876

8. Bobby Mathews 9 1876

9. Al Nichols 8 1876

10. George Bechtel 1 1876

John Hayes 1 1876

John Maloney 1 1876

Runs Created
Rank Player RC PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 26 242

2. Joe Start 22 265

3. Jim Holdsworth 19 242

4. Bill Craver 14 248

5. Fred Treacey 13 257

6. Eddie Booth 12 230

Nat Hicks 12 191

8. Bobby Mathews 9 221

9. Al Nichols 8 214

10. George Bechtel 1 10

John Hayes 1 21

John Maloney 1 7

Adj. Batting Runs
Rank Player BtRuns Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 5 1876

2. John Maloney 0 1876

3. George Bechtel 0 1876

Adj. Batting Runs
Rank Player BtRuns PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 5 242

2. John Maloney 0 7

3. George Bechtel 0 10

Adj. Batting Wins
Rank Player BtWins Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 0.6 1876

2. John Maloney 0.1 1876

Adj. Batting Wins
Rank Player BtWins PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 0.6 242

2. John Maloney 0.1 7

Extra Base Hits
Rank Player XBH Year

1. Jimmy Hallinan 15 1876

2. Joe Start 6 1876

Fred Treacey 6 1876

4. Nat Hicks 5 1876

Jim Holdsworth 5 1876

Bobby Mathews 5 1876

7. Bill Craver 4 1876

Al Nichols 4 1876

9. Eddie Booth 3 1876

10. John Hayes 2 1876

Extra Base Hits
Rank Player XBH PA

1. Jimmy Hallinan 15 242

2. Joe Start 6 265

Fred Treacey 6 257

4. Nat Hicks 5 191

Jim Holdsworth 5 242

Bobby Mathews 5 221

7. Bill Craver 4 248

Al Nichols 4 214

9. Eddie Booth 3 230

10. John Hayes 2 21

Times On Base
Rank Player TOB Year

1. Joe Start 74 1876

2. Jimmy Hallinan 69 1876

3. Jim Holdsworth 65 1876

4. Bill Craver 57 1876

5. Fred Treacey 55 1876

6. Eddie Booth 51 1876

7. Nat Hicks 47 1876

8. Bobby Mathews 43 1876

9. Al Nichols 40 1876

10. George Bechtel 3 1876

John Hayes 3 1876

Times On Base
Rank Player TOB PA

1. Joe Start 74 265

2. Jimmy Hallinan 69 242

3. Jim Holdsworth 65 242

4. Bill Craver 57 248

5. Fred Treacey 55 257

6. Eddie Booth 51 230

7. Nat Hicks 47 191

8. Bobby Mathews 43 221

9. Al Nichols 40 214

10. George Bechtel 3 10

John Hayes 3 21

Offensive Win %
Rank Player OWn% Year

Offensive Win %
Rank Player OWn% PA

Hit By Pitch
Rank Player Hit By Pitch Year

Hit By Pitch
Rank Player Hit By Pitch PA

Sacrifice Hits
Rank Player Sacrifice Hits Year

Sacrifice Hits
Rank Player Sacrifice Hits PA

Sacrifice Flies
Rank Player Sacrifice Flies Year

Sacrifice Flies
Rank Player Sacrifice Flies PA

Intentional Bases on Balls
Rank Player Int. Bases on Balls Year

Intentional Bases on Balls
Rank Player Int. Bases on Balls PA

Double Plays Grounded Into
Rank Player GDP Year

Double Plays Grounded Into
Rank Player GDP PA

Caught Stealing
Rank Player CS Year

Caught Stealing
Rank Player CS PA

Power-Speed #
Rank Player PwrSpd Year

Power-Speed #
Rank Player PwrSpd PA

AB per SO
Rank Player AB/SO Year

AB per SO
Rank Player AB/SO PA

AB per HR
Rank Player AB/HR Year

AB per HR
Rank Player AB/HR PA

Outs Made
Rank Player Outs Year

1. Fred Treacey 202 1876

2. Bill Craver 191 1876

Joe Start 191 1876

4. Eddie Booth 179 1876

5. Bobby Mathews 178 1876

6. Jim Holdsworth 177 1876

7. Al Nichols 174 1876

8. Jimmy Hallinan 173 1876

9. Nat Hicks 144 1876

10. John Hayes 18 1876

Outs Made
Rank Player Outs PA

1. Fred Treacey 202 257

2. Bill Craver 191 248

Joe Start 191 265

4. Eddie Booth 179 230

5. Bobby Mathews 178 221

6. Jim Holdsworth 177 242

7. Al Nichols 174 214

8. Jimmy Hallinan 173 242

9. Nat Hicks 144 191

10. John Hayes 18 21

Site last updated Thursday, November 5, 2009 at 07:09:43 AM

Much of the play-by-play, game results, and transaction information both shown and used to create certain data sets was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by RetroSheet.

Win Probability and Leverage Index calculations provided by Tom Tango of InsideTheBook.com, and co-author of The Book: Playing the Percentages in Baseball.

Total Zone Rating calculations provided by Sean Smith of BaseballProjection.com.

A Sports Reference Site: About Baseball Reference | Found a bug or have a suggestion?
Privacy Statement | Conditions & Terms of Service | Use of Data

Partner With: FantasyPlayers.com. Contact Fantasy Sports Ventures for advertising information.