Promote your website or business by sponsoring this page for $5 on Baseball-Reference.com. Your message will replace this ad.
Year and record in Bold indicates they won pennant.
| Year | C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | LF | CF | RF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Most Years | Buckley | Esterbrook | Bassett | Denny | Glasscock | Seery | Sullivan | McGeachey |
| Most Games | Myers 115 gms Buckley 106 gms Daily 93 gms Arundel 42 gms Hackett 40 gms | Schomberg 127 gms Hines 115 gms Schoeneck 64 gms Esterbrook 61 gms Daily 11 gms | Bassett 374 gms Denny 13 gms Gardner 7 gms Glasscock 5 gms Andrews 1 gms | Denny 335 gms Buckley 34 gms Myers 15 gms Cahill 9 gms Daily 6 gms | Glasscock 364 gms Denny 34 gms Hines 2 gms Seery 2 gms McGeachey 1 gms | Seery 382 gms Myers 11 gms McGeachey 2 gms Boyle 2 gms Buckley 1 gms | Hines 137 gms McGeachey 103 gms Sullivan 63 gms Andrews 40 gms Myers 25 gms | McGeachey 242 gms Cahill 53 gms Polhemus 20 gms Brown 19 gms Schomberg 16 gms |
| 1889 (59-75) | Buckley | Hines | Bassett | Denny | Glasscock | Seery | Sullivan | McGeachey |
| 1888 (50-85) | Buckley | Esterbrook | Bassett | Denny | Glasscock | Seery | Hines | McGeachey |
| 1887 (37-89) | Myers | Schomberg | Bassett | Denny | Glasscock | Seery | McGeachey | Cahill |
| 3 years | 2 players | 3 players | 1 players | 1 players | 1 players | 1 players | 3 players | 2 players |