Year and record in Bold indicates they won pennant.
Shading is not used to differentiate the players' performances. It is merely used to quickly illustrate long strings of games/years played by a single player. When a player in the column changes, so does the color of the shading.
| Year | C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | LF | CF | RF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Most Years | Allison | Mills | Addy | Boyd | Barlow | Tipper | Pike | Allison |
| Most Games | Allison 59 gms Hastings 39 gms Harbridge 31 gms Barnie 30 gms Quinn 3 gms | Mills 133 gms Bond 4 gms Harbridge 3 gms Allison 2 gms Allison 1 gms | Burdock 73 gms Addy 45 gms Harbridge 11 gms Pike 7 gms Bond 3 gms | Ferguson 85 gms Boyd 25 gms Brady 16 gms Fisher 7 gms Addy 5 gms | Carey 86 gms Barlow 32 gms Pike 20 gms Fisher 2 gms Barnie 1 gms | York 86 gms Tipper 45 gms Shafer 8 gms Cummings 2 gms Manning 0 gms | Remsen 81 gms Pike 27 gms Hastings 12 gms Fisher 8 gms Brady 6 gms | Allison 37 gms Bond 29 gms Barnie 25 gms Stearns 15 gms Hastings 14 gms |
| 1875 (54-28) | Allison | Mills | Burdock | Ferguson | Carey | York | Remsen | Allison |
| 1874 (16-37) | Hastings | Mills | Addy | Boyd | Barlow | Tipper | Pike | Barnie |
| 2 years | 2 players | 1 players | 2 players | 2 players | 2 players | 2 players | 2 players | 2 players |