Year and record in Bold indicates they won pennant.
Shading is not used to differentiate the players' performances. It is merely used to quickly illustrate long strings of games/years played by a single player. When a player in the column changes, so does the color of the shading.
| Year | C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | LF | CF | RF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Most Years | Murphy | Brouthers | Stricker | Nash | Irwin | Richardson | Brown | Duffy |
| Most Games | Murphy 171 gms Kelly 60 gms Farrell 37 gms Swett 34 gms Cotter 5 gms | Brouthers 253 gms Farrell 4 gms Richardson 4 gms Buffinton 4 gms Kelly 4 gms | Stricker 139 gms Quinn 130 gms Murphy 0 gms Joyce 0 gms Kilroy 0 gms | Nash 129 gms Farrell 66 gms Joyce 64 gms Richardson 9 gms Duffy 3 gms | Radford 131 gms Irwin 102 gms Kelly 27 gms Richardson 10 gms Murphy 2 gms | Richardson 181 gms McGeachey 38 gms Farrell 20 gms Irwin 9 gms Duffy 7 gms | Brown 265 gms Murphy 3 gms Johnston 2 gms Kelly 2 gms Duffy 2 gms | Duffy 118 gms Stovey 116 gms Irwin 9 gms Buffinton 6 gms Gumbert 5 gms |
| 1891 (93-42) | Murphy | Brouthers | Stricker | Farrell | Radford | Richardson | Brown | Duffy |
| 1890 (81-48) | Murphy | Brouthers | Quinn | Nash | Irwin | Richardson | Brown | Stovey |
| 2 years | 1 players | 1 players | 2 players | 2 players | 2 players | 1 players | 1 players | 2 players |