| 1916 | | | |
Max Flack | .991 | |
| | |
Max Flack | .991 |
| 1917 | | | |
Max Flack | .991 | |
| | |
Harry Hooper+ | .971 |
| 1918 | | | |
Max Flack | .991 | |
| | |
Max Flack | .978 |
| 1919 | Harry Hooper+ | .971 | |
Max Flack | .991 | |
Harry Hooper+ | .971 | |
Max Flack | .986 |
| 1920 | Max Flack | .974 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Max Flack | .974 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .991 |
| 1921 | Max Flack | .977 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Max Flack | .977 | |
Max Flack | .989 |
| 1922 | Max Flack | .975 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Max Flack | .975 | |
Frank Brower | .982 |
| 1923 | Max Flack | .971 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Max Flack | .971 | |
Cliff Heathcote | .980 |
| 1924 | Max Flack | .972 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Max Flack | .972 | |
George Harper | .991 |
| 1925 | Max Flack | .973 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Max Flack | .973 | |
Curt Walker | .979 |
| 1926 | Cliff Heathcote | .976 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Cliff Heathcote | .976 | |
Cliff Heathcote | .984 |
| 1927 | Cliff Heathcote | .978 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Cliff Heathcote | .978 | |
Paul Waner+ | .980 |
| 1928 | Cliff Heathcote | .977 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Cliff Heathcote | .977 | |
Earl McNeely | .984 |
| 1929 | Paul Waner+ | .979 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Paul Waner+ | .979 | |
Paul Waner+ | .986 |
| 1930 | Cliff Heathcote | .978 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Cliff Heathcote | .978 | |
Kiki Cuyler+ | .982 |
| 1931 | Cliff Heathcote | .979 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Cliff Heathcote | .979 | |
Bing Miller | .987 |
| 1932 | Cliff Heathcote | .979 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .992 | |
Mel Ott+ | .976 | |
Mel Ott+ | .984 |
| 1933 | Cliff Heathcote | .979 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mel Ott+ | .977 | |
Dick Porter | .996 |
| 1934 | Cliff Heathcote | .979 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Paul Waner+ | .977 | |
Paul Waner+ | .985 |
| 1935 | Cliff Heathcote | .979 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mel Ott+ | .978 | |
Pete Fox | .991 |
| 1936 | Cliff Heathcote | .979 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mel Ott+ | .979 | |
Mel Ott+ | .985 |
| 1937 | Mel Ott+ | .980 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mel Ott+ | .980 | |
Beau Bell | .984 |
| 1938 | Pete Fox | .983 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Pete Fox | .983 | |
Pete Fox | .994 |
| 1939 | Mel Ott+ | .980 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mel Ott+ | .980 | |
Ival Goodman | .981 |
| 1940 | Mel Ott+ | .980 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mel Ott+ | .980 | |
Enos Slaughter+ | .989 |
| 1941 | Frank Demaree | .980 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Frank Demaree | .980 | |
Bruce Campbell | .976 |
| 1942 | Frank Demaree | .981 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Frank Demaree | .981 | |
Mel Ott+ | .990 |
| 1943 | Frank Demaree | .981 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Frank Demaree | .981 | |
Stan Musial+ | .990 |
| 1944 | Frank Demaree | .981 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Frank Demaree | .981 | |
Pete Fox | .987 |
| 1945 | Frank Demaree | .981 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mel Ott+ | .980 | |
Dixie Walker | .992 |
| 1946 | Tommy Henrich | .982 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Tommy Henrich | .982 | |
Tommy Henrich | .991 |
| 1947 | Tommy Henrich | .982 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Tommy Henrich | .982 | |
Bill Nicholson | .989 |
| 1948 | Tommy Holmes | .984 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Tommy Holmes | .984 | |
Taffy Wright | .987 |
| 1949 | Tommy Holmes | .985 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Tommy Holmes | .985 | |
Stan Musial+ | .994 |
| 1950 | Tommy Holmes | .986 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Tommy Holmes | .986 | |
Bob Kennedy | .986 |
| 1951 | Tommy Holmes | .986 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Tommy Holmes | .986 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 |
| 1952 | Tommy Holmes | .986 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Tommy Holmes | .986 | |
Sam Mele | .994 |
| 1953 | Sam Mele | .991 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Sam Mele | .991 | |
Enos Slaughter+ | .996 |
| 1954 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Sam Mele | .990 | |
Stan Musial+ | .989 |
| 1955 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Sam Mele | .990 | |
Carl Furillo | .981 |
| 1956 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Sam Mele | .990 | |
Don Mueller | .989 |
| 1957 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Dave Philley | .985 | |
Al Kaline+ | .993 |
| 1958 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Willard Marshall | .996 | |
Dave Philley | .985 | |
Al Kaline+ | .994 |
| 1959 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Gus Bell | .996 | |
Dave Philley | .986 | |
Gus Bell | .996 |
| 1960 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Gus Bell | .996 | |
Stan Musial+ | .987 | |
Bob Will | .991 |
| 1961 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Gus Bell | .996 | |
Gus Bell | .987 | |
Floyd Robinson | .991 |
| 1962 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Gus Bell | .996 | |
Gus Bell | .986 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .993 |
| 1963 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Gus Bell | .996 | |
Al Kaline+ | .986 | |
Johnny Callison | .994 |
| 1964 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Gus Bell | .996 | |
Johnny Callison | .986 | |
Roger Maris | .995 |
| 1965 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .989 | |
Rocky Colavito | 1.000 |
| 1966 | Frank Robinson+ | .990 | |
Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .990 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .992 |
| 1967 | Frank Robinson+ | .990 | |
Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .990 | |
Roger Maris | .991 |
| 1968 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .988 | |
Ken Harrelson | 1.000 |
| 1969 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson | 1.000 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .988 | |
Vada Pinson | .995 |
| 1970 | Sam Mele | .990 | |
Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .988 | |
Pete Rose | .997 |
| 1971 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Rose | .992 | |
Al Kaline+ | 1.000 |
| 1972 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Frank Robinson+ | .986 | |
Jim Wynn | .985 |
| 1973 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Al Kaline+ | .985 | |
Jim Wynn | .985 |
| 1974 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Ron Fairly | .984 | |
Greg Gross | .993 |
| 1975 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Vada Pinson | .986 | |
Pat Kelly | .991 |
| 1976 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Rose | .992 | |
Dwight Evans | .994 |
| 1977 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Dwight Evans | .991 | |
Ken Griffey | .990 |
| 1978 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Dwight Evans | .989 | |
Bake McBride | .996 |
| 1979 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Dwight Evans | .988 | |
George Hendrick | .992 |
| 1980 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Al Kaline+ Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson | 1.000 | |
Dwight Evans | .988 | |
George Hendrick | .991 |
| 1981 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Ken Harrelson Terry Puhl Rocky Colavito Ken Singleton Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Bake McBride | .990 | |
Ken Singleton Terry Puhl | 1.000 |
| 1982 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Ken Singleton Terry Puhl Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Bake McBride | .990 | |
Terry Puhl | .995 |
| 1983 | Pete Rose | .991 | |
Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito Ken Singleton Terry Puhl | 1.000 | |
Pete Rose | .991 | |
Terry Puhl | .990 |
| 1984 | Terry Puhl | .992 | |
Ken Harrelson Ken Singleton Terry Puhl Al Kaline+ Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .992 | |
Dave Winfield+ | .996 |
| 1985 | Terry Puhl | .992 | |
Ken Singleton Rocky Colavito Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Terry Puhl | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .992 | |
Andy Van Slyke | .995 |
| 1986 | Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Terry Puhl Al Kaline+ Ken Singleton | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Lee Lacy | .992 |
| 1987 | Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Ken Singleton Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Terry Puhl Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Mike Kingery | .992 |
| 1988 | Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Terry Puhl Ken Singleton Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Dale Murphy | .992 |
| 1989 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito Ken Singleton | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Cory Snyder | .997 |
| 1990 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Terry Puhl Ken Singleton Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Tony Gwynn+ | .986 | |
Paul O'Neill | .993 |
| 1991 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Ken Singleton Al Kaline+ Terry Puhl Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Paul O'Neill | .987 | |
Paul O'Neill | .994 |
| 1992 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Rocky Colavito Terry Puhl Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Ken Singleton | 1.000 | |
Paul O'Neill | .989 | |
Paul O'Neill | .997 |
| 1993 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Ken Singleton Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Paul O'Neill | .989 | |
Jim Eisenreich | .996 |
| 1994 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson James Mouton Ken Singleton Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Paul O'Neill | .990 | |
James Mouton | 1.000 |
| 1995 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito Al Kaline+ Ken Singleton James Mouton Terry Puhl | 1.000 | |
Jim Eisenreich | .990 | |
Brian Jordan | .996 |
| 1996 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Singleton Terry Puhl Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Paul O'Neill James Mouton | 1.000 | |
Paul O'Neill | .991 | |
Paul O'Neill | 1.000 |
| 1997 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Ken Singleton Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Paul O'Neill Rocky Colavito James Mouton | 1.000 | |
Paul O'Neill | .990 | |
Jay Buhner | .997 |
| 1998 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Paul O'Neill Terry Puhl Rocky Colavito Ken Singleton Ken Harrelson James Mouton Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Dave Martinez | .993 | |
Michael Tucker | .995 |
| 1999 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Singleton Paul O'Neill Al Kaline+ Terry Puhl James Mouton Ken Harrelson | 1.000 | |
Dave Martinez | .991 | |
Shawn Green | .997 |
| 2000 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Ken Singleton James Mouton Al Kaline+ Terry Puhl Paul O'Neill | 1.000 | |
Dave Martinez | .991 | |
Paul O'Neill | .993 |
| 2001 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Paul O'Neill Ken Harrelson Ken Singleton James Mouton Rocky Colavito Terry Puhl Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Dave Martinez | .992 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .997 |
| 2002 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Paul O'Neill James Mouton Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Al Kaline+ Ken Singleton | 1.000 | |
Brian Jordan | .989 | |
Richard Hidalgo | .995 |
| 2003 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Terry Puhl James Mouton Al Kaline+ Ken Singleton Paul O'Neill Juan Encarnacion Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Brian Jordan | .989 | |
Juan Encarnacion | 1.000 |
| 2004 | Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Juan Encarnacion Paul O'Neill Ken Singleton James Mouton Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Jacque Jones | .994 |
| 2005 | Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Ken Singleton Juan Encarnacion Paul O'Neill Ken Harrelson Shawn Green Rocky Colavito James Mouton Al Kaline+ | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Shawn Green | 1.000 |
| 2006 | Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Shawn Green Ken Harrelson Terry Puhl Al Kaline+ Juan Encarnacion Rocky Colavito Ken Singleton James Mouton Paul O'Neill | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Nick Markakis | .996 |
| 2007 | Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Terry Puhl Juan Encarnacion Rocky Colavito Ken Harrelson Paul O'Neill Al Kaline+ Ken Singleton Shawn Green James Mouton | 1.000 | |
Alex Rios | .990 | |
Magglio Ordonez | .996 |
| 2008 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Andre Ethier Rocky Colavito Shawn Green Ken Singleton Terry Puhl Paul O'Neill James Mouton Al Kaline+ Juan Encarnacion Ken Harrelson | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .992 | |
Andre Ethier | 1.000 |
| 2009 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Rocky Colavito James Mouton Al Kaline+ Ken Singleton Paul O'Neill Andre Ethier Terry Puhl Ken Harrelson Juan Encarnacion Shawn Green | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .992 | |
Jeff Francoeur | .997 |
| 2010 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Al Kaline+ Paul O'Neill Rocky Colavito James Mouton Andre Ethier Juan Encarnacion Ken Singleton Terry Puhl Ken Harrelson Shawn Green | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .992 | |
J.D. Drew | .996 |
| 2011 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Paul O'Neill Rocky Colavito Juan Encarnacion Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Nick Markakis James Mouton Andre Ethier Shawn Green | 1.000 | |
Nick Markakis | .992 | |
Nick Markakis Andre Ethier | 1.000 |
| 2012 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Shawn Green Rocky Colavito Nick Markakis Juan Encarnacion Andre Ethier Al Kaline+ Ken Harrelson Paul O'Neill James Mouton | 1.000 | |
Nick Markakis | .992 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .996 |
| 2013 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Al Kaline+ Andre Ethier Ken Harrelson Juan Encarnacion Shawn Green Jay Bruce Rocky Colavito Nick Markakis | 1.000 | |
Nick Markakis | .992 | |
Andre Ethier Travis Snider Shane Victorino Chris Parmelee Nick Markakis Jay Bruce | 1.000 |