+ - Indicates Hall of Famer. Bold indicates active player.
Minimum of 1000 IP, 3000 PA, 500 games (fielding), 200 stolen base attempts (catchers) or 100 decisions for career and active leaderboards for rate statistics.
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Fielding % as RF (s.1954) | Throws |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Terry Puhl (15) | .9936 | R |
| 2. | Nick Markakis (6, 27) | .9921 | L |
| 3. | Dave Martinez (16) | .9915 | L |
| 4. | Pete Rose (24) | .9914 | R |
| 5. | Ichiro Suzuki (11, 37) | .9910 | R |
| 6. | Sam Mele (10) | .9898 | R |
| Alex Rios (8, 30) | .9898 | R | |
| 8. | Brian Jordan (15) | .9897 | R |
| 9. | Andre Ethier (6, 29) | .9895 | L |
| 10. | Bake McBride (11) | .9892 | R |
| 11. | Jay Buhner (15) | .9884 | R |
| Corey Hart (8, 29) | .9884 | R | |
| 13. | Jim Eisenreich (15) | .9883 | L |
| 14. | Paul O'Neill (17) | .9881 | L |
| 15. | Randy Winn (13) | .9875 | R |
| 16. | Jacque Jones (10) | .9872 | L |
| 17. | Nick Swisher (8, 30) | .9870 | L |
| 18. | Richard Hidalgo (9) | .9869 | R |
| 19. | Tony Gwynn+ (20) | .9868 | L |
| 20. | Magglio Ordonez (15, 37) | .9867 | R |
| 21. | Dwight Evans (20) | .9866 | R |
| Matt Stairs (19, 43) | .9866 | R | |
| 23. | Tommy Holmes (11) | .9865 | L |
| 24. | Gus Bell (15) | .9864 | R |
| 25. | Jayson Werth (9, 32) | .9863 | R |
| 26. | Austin Kearns (10, 31) | .9860 | R |
| Dave Philley (18) | .9860 | R | |
| Frank Robinson+ (21) | .9860 | R | |
| 29. | Larry Walker (17) | .9859 | R |
| 30. | Vada Pinson (18) | .9857 | L |
| Michael Tucker (12) | .9857 | R | |
| 32. | Shawn Green (15) | .9856 | L |
| Hunter Pence (5, 28) | .9856 | R | |
| 34. | J.D. Drew (14, 35) | .9853 | R |
| 35. | Michael Cuddyer (11, 32) | .9851 | R |
| 36. | Al Kaline+ (22) | .9850 | R |
| Lee Lacy (16) | .9850 | R | |
| 38. | Johnny Callison (16) | .9848 | R |
| Stan Musial+ (22) | .9848 | L | |
| 40. | Danny Bautista (12) | .9847 | R |
| 41. | Tom Brunansky (14) | .9845 | R |
| 42. | Jeff Francoeur (7, 27) | .9844 | R |
| Richie Zisk (13) | .9844 | R | |
| 44. | Dale Murphy (18) | .9841 | R |
| Joe Orsulak (14) | .9841 | L | |
| 46. | Dave Winfield+ (22) | .9839 | R |
| 47. | Tony Armas (14) | .9837 | R |
| Juan Gonzalez (17) | .9837 | R | |
| Matt Lawton (12) | .9837 | R | |
| Don Mueller (12) | .9837 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Fielding % as RF (s.1954) | Throws |
| 51. | Reggie Sanders (17) | .9835 | R |
| 52. | Roger Maris (12) | .9834 | R |
| 53. | Mike Hershberger (11) | .9833 | R |
| Trot Nixon (12) | .9833 | L | |
| 55. | Von Hayes (12) | .9832 | R |
| Sixto Lezcano (12) | .9832 | R | |
| 57. | Ron Fairly (21) | .9829 | L |
| Floyd Robinson (9) | .9829 | R | |
| 59. | George Hendrick (18) | .9824 | R |
| 60. | Bobby Abreu (16, 37) | .9823 | R |
| 61. | Moises Alou (17) | .9822 | R |
| Al Cowens (13) | .9822 | R | |
| Greg Gross (17) | .9822 | L | |
| Bob Kennedy (16) | .9822 | R | |
| 65. | Andre Dawson+ (21) | .9821 | R |
| 66. | Kevin Bass (14) | .9820 | R |
| Jermaine Dye (14) | .9820 | R | |
| 68. | Felipe Alou (17) | .9819 | R |
| Frank Baumholtz (10) | .9819 | L | |
| 70. | Cory Snyder (9) | .9817 | R |
| 71. | Jim King (11) | .9815 | R |
| 72. | Gary Sheffield (22) | .9814 | R |
| 73. | Frank Demaree (12) | .9813 | R |
| Willard Marshall (11) | .9813 | R | |
| 75. | Brian Giles (15) | .9812 | L |
| 76. | Juan Encarnacion (11) | .9811 | R |
| 77. | Felix Jose (11) | .9810 | R |
| 78. | Jesse Barfield (12) | .9809 | R |
| Tony Conigliaro (8) | .9809 | R | |
| 80. | Enos Slaughter+ (19) | .9808 | R |
| 81. | Lou Clinton (8) | .9805 | R |
| 82. | Mel Ott+ (22) | .9804 | R |
| 83. | Hank Bauer (14) | .9803 | R |
| 84. | Hank Aaron+ (23) | .9802 | R |
| 85. | Joe Carter (16) | .9799 | R |
| Tommy Henrich (11) | .9799 | L | |
| 87. | Ken Griffey (19) | .9797 | L |
| Jerry Morales (15) | .9797 | R | |
| 89. | Bill Nicholson (16) | .9795 | R |
| 90. | Willie Crawford (14) | .9791 | L |
| Cliff Heathcote (15) | .9791 | L | |
| 92. | Orlando Merced (13) | .9790 | R |
| 93. | Leon Roberts (11) | .9789 | R |
| 94. | Ken Singleton (15) | .9788 | R |
| 95. | Jeff Burroughs (16) | .9784 | R |
| 96. | Harold Baines (22) | .9781 | L |
| 97. | Brad Hawpe (8, 32) | .9779 | L |
| Manny Ramirez (19, 39) | .9779 | R | |
| 99. | Jack Clark (18) | .9778 | R |
| 100. | Jay Johnstone (20) | .9777 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Fielding % as RF (s.1954) | Throws |
| 101. | Carl Furillo (15) | .9776 | R |
| Mike Marshall (11) | .9776 | R | |
| 103. | Keith Moreland (12) | .9775 | R |
| 104. | Rocky Colavito (14) | .9774 | R |
| Pete Fox (13) | .9774 | R | |
| 106. | Ollie Brown (13) | .9773 | R |
| Tim Salmon (14) | .9773 | R | |
| Glenn Wilson (10) | .9773 | R | |
| 109. | Jim Northrup (12) | .9772 | R |
| 110. | Bobby Bonds (14) | .9771 | R |
| 111. | Bobby Higginson (11) | .9769 | R |
| 112. | Jeromy Burnitz (14) | .9767 | R |
| 113. | David Justice (14) | .9765 | L |
| Darryl Strawberry (17) | .9765 | L | |
| 115. | Bobby Bonilla (16) | .9764 | R |
| Kiki Cuyler+ (18) | .9764 | R | |
| 117. | Raul Mondesi (13) | .9763 | R |
| 118. | Jackie Jensen (11) | .9761 | R |
| 119. | Bobby Murcer (17) | .9760 | R |
| 120. | Dante Bichette (14) | .9759 | R |
| 121. | Pat Kelly (15) | .9758 | L |
| 122. | Derek Bell (11) | .9755 | R |
| 123. | Willie Kirkland (9) | .9754 | R |
| Vic Wertz (17) | .9754 | R | |
| Taffy Wright (9) | .9754 | R | |
| 126. | Tony Oliva (15) | .9753 | R |
| 127. | Rob Deer (11) | .9749 | R |
| George Harper (11) | .9749 | R | |
| 129. | Paul Waner+ (20) | .9747 | L |
| 130. | Ival Goodman (10) | .9746 | R |
| Gene Moore (14) | .9746 | L | |
| 132. | Al Zarilla (10) | .9743 | R |
| 133. | Ron Swoboda (9) | .9740 | R |
| 134. | Sammy Sosa (18) | .9739 | R |
| 135. | Reggie Smith (17) | .9736 | R |
| 136. | Wally Moses (17) | .9734 | L |
| 137. | Max Flack (12) | .9731 | L |
| 138. | Danny Tartabull (14) | .9729 | R |
| 139. | Beau Bell (7) | .9728 | R |
| Candy Maldonado (15) | .9728 | R | |
| Ellis Valentine (10) | .9728 | R | |
| 142. | Roberto Clemente+ (18) | .9727 | R |
| 143. | Willie McGee (18) | .9726 | R |
| 144. | Dick Porter (6) | .9725 | R |
| Elmer Valo (20) | .9725 | R | |
| 146. | Jim Rivera (10) | .9724 | L |
| 147. | Ben Chapman (15) | .9720 | R |
| 148. | Al Smith (12) | .9719 | R |
| 149. | Jose Guillen (14) | .9718 | R |
| 150. | Jose Canseco (17) | .9717 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | Fielding % as RF (s.1954) | Throws |
| 151. | Bing Miller (16) | .9716 | R |
| 152. | Dan Ford (11) | .9713 | R |
| Sam Rice+ (20) | .9713 | R | |
| 154. | Harry Hooper+ (17) | .9712 | R |
| 155. | Buddy Lewis (11) | .9709 | R |
| Wally Post (15) | .9709 | R | |
| 157. | Roy Cullenbine (10) | .9707 | R |
| 158. | Rusty Staub (23) | .9706 | R |
| 159. | Frank Howard (16) | .9705 | R |
| Ron Northey (12) | .9705 | R | |
| 161. | Bob Allison (13) | .9702 | R |
| 162. | Carl Reynolds (13) | .9698 | R |
| 163. | Lance Richbourg (8) | .9697 | R |
| 164. | Dixie Walker (18) | .9696 | R |
| Johnny Wyrostek (11) | .9696 | R | |
| 166. | Ruben Sierra (20) | .9694 | R |
| 167. | Leroy Stanton (9) | .9689 | R |
| 168. | Claudell Washington (17) | .9686 | L |
| Mark Whiten (11) | .9686 | R | |
| 170. | Billy Southworth+ (13) | .9685 | R |
| 171. | Reggie Jackson+ (21) | .9675 | L |
| 172. | Hubie Brooks (15) | .9671 | R |
| 173. | Jose Cardenal (18) | .9663 | R |
| 174. | Jesus Alou (15) | .9659 | R |
| 175. | Dave Parker (19) | .9657 | R |
| 176. | Babe Ruth+ (22) | .9655 | L |
| 177. | Harry Heilmann+ (17) | .9647 | R |
| 178. | Mike Davis (10) | .9646 | L |
| 179. | Del Ennis (14) | .9640 | R |
| 180. | Vladimir Guerrero (16, 36) | .9634 | R |
| 181. | Chuck Klein+ (17) | .9633 | R |
| 182. | Elmer Smith (10) | .9626 | R |
| 183. | Justin Upton (5, 23) | .9625 | R |
| 184. | Homer Summa (10) | .9615 | R |
| 185. | Curt Walker (12) | .9612 | R |
| 186. | Babe Herman (13) | .9593 | L |
| 187. | Earl Webb (7) | .9581 | R |
| 188. | Jack Tobin (13) | .9572 | L |
| 189. | Bruce Campbell (13) | .9563 | R |
| 190. | Tommy Griffith (13) | .9559 | R |
| 191. | Ross Youngs+ (10) | .9529 | R |
| 192. | Bob Meusel (11) | .9490 | R |
Note that seasons prior to 1876 are not included in single-season marks, but are included in career marks.