| 1871 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 |
| 1872 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Candy Cummings+ | .911 |
| 1873 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Harry Wright+ | .909 |
| 1874 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Al Spalding+ | .854 |
| 1875 | | | |
Dick McBride | .954 | |
| | |
Dick McBride | .955 |
|
| 1876 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 |
| 1877 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
George Bradley | .950 |
| 1878 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Tricky Nichols | .971 |
| 1879 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Tommy Bond | .957 |
| 1880 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Monte Ward+ | .983 |
| 1881 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Fred Corey | .957 |
| 1882 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Tony Mullane | .959 |
| 1883 | | | |
Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Dupee Shaw | .962 |
| 1884 | | | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
| | |
Jim Whitney Frank Meinke | 1.000 |
| 1885 | Bobby Mathews | .822 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Bobby Mathews | .822 | |
Larry McKeon | .983 |
| 1886 | Bobby Mathews | .823 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Bobby Mathews | .823 | |
Pretzels Getzien | .988 |
| 1887 | Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Bob Caruthers | .971 |
| 1888 | Pud Galvin+ | .917 | |
Jim Whitney Jack Manning Frank Meinke | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .917 | |
Ice Box Chamberlain | .963 |
| 1889 | Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Old Hoss Radbourn+ | .975 |
| 1890 | Pud Galvin+ | .916 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .916 | |
Scott Stratton | .977 |
| 1891 | Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Pat Luby | .962 |
| 1892 | Pud Galvin+ | .914 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .914 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .966 |
| 1893 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert | 1.000 |
| 1894 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Duke Esper | .982 |
| 1895 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
| | |
Bill Kissinger | .976 |
| 1896 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
| | |
Kid Nichols+ | 1.000 |
| 1897 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
| | |
Red Donahue | .976 |
| 1898 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
| | |
Bill Hill | .986 |
| 1899 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Gus Weyhing | .880 | |
Frank Kitson | .976 |
| 1900 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .985 |
| 1901 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .992 |
| 1902 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .938 | |
Clark Griffith+ | 1.000 |
| 1903 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .939 | |
Harry Howell | 1.000 |
| 1904 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Buttons Briggs Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Frank Owen Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Buttons Briggs Frank Owen | 1.000 |
| 1905 | Kid Nichols+ | .952 | |
Buttons Briggs Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Frank Owen Tully Sparks Jim Whitney | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .952 | |
Tully Sparks | 1.000 |
| 1906 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Buttons Briggs Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Frank Owen Lew Richie Tully Sparks | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Lew Richie | 1.000 |
| 1907 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Buttons Briggs Gus Dorner Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Frank Owen Lew Richie | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .940 | |
Gus Dorner | 1.000 |
| 1908 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Buttons Briggs Mordecai Brown+ Gus Dorner Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Jack Manning Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ Frank Owen | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .941 | |
Mordecai Brown+ | 1.000 |
| 1909 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Buttons Briggs Mordecai Brown+ Gus Dorner Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Jack Manning George McQuillan Frank Meinke Kid Nichols+ | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .939 | |
George McQuillan | 1.000 |
| 1910 | Vic Willis+ | .954 | |
Buttons Briggs Mordecai Brown+ Gus Dorner Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Sam Leever Jack Manning George McQuillan Frank Meinke | 1.000 | |
Vic Willis+ | .954 | |
Sam Leever Doc Scanlan Irv Young | 1.000 |
| 1911 | Vic Willis+ | .954 | |
Chief Bender+ Buttons Briggs Mordecai Brown+ Gus Dorner Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell Sam Leever Jack Manning George McQuillan | 1.000 | |
Jack Powell | .939 | |
Chief Bender+ Big Jeff Pfeffer | 1.000 |
| 1912 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Chief Bender+ Buttons Briggs Buster Brown Mordecai Brown+ Jack Coombs Gus Dorner Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Harry Howell | 1.000 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Hank Robinson Doc White Joe Willis Buster Brown Jack Coombs Eddie Plank+ Babe Adams Hooks Wiltse | 1.000 |
| 1913 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Chief Bender+ Buttons Briggs Buster Brown Mordecai Brown+ Ray Caldwell Jack Coombs Doc Crandall Gus Dorner | 1.000 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Pete Alexander+ Ray Caldwell Doc Crandall Art Fromme Walter Johnson+ Eppa Rixey+ | 1.000 |
| 1914 | Eddie Plank+ | .970 | |
Pete Alexander+ Chief Bender+ Buttons Briggs Buster Brown Mordecai Brown+ Ray Caldwell Joe Conzelman Jack Coombs Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Eddie Plank+ | .970 | |
Marty O'Toole Babe Adams Joe Conzelman | 1.000 |
| 1915 | Eddie Plank+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Cy Barger Chief Bender+ Dave Black Buttons Briggs Buster Brown Mordecai Brown+ | 1.000 | |
Eddie Plank+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Cy Barger Dave Black Al Demaree Bunny Hearn Rankin Johnson Ernie Koob George LeClair Hank Robinson | 1.000 |
| 1916 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Cy Barger Chief Bender+ Rube Benton Dave Black Buttons Briggs | 1.000 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Fred Anderson Rube Benton Tom Hughes Ernie Koob Slim Sallee Lefty Williams | 1.000 |
| 1917 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Cy Barger Chief Bender+ Rube Benton Dave Black Buttons Briggs Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Eddie Plank+ | .971 | |
Rube Schauer Al Demaree Hod Eller Earl Hamilton Walter Johnson+ George Mogridge Gene Packard Eppa Rixey+ Slim Sallee | 1.000 |
| 1918 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Cy Barger Chief Bender+ Rube Benton Dave Black Buttons Briggs | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .961 | |
Wilbur Cooper Hod Eller Happy Finneran Elmer Jacobs Erskine Mayer Bill Sherdel | 1.000 |
| 1919 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Cy Barger Chief Bender+ Rube Benton | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .963 | |
Pete Alexander+ Rube Benton Al Demaree Dolf Luque Jimmy Ring Babe Adams | 1.000 |
| 1920 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Cy Barger Chief Bender+ Rube Benton | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .963 | |
George Uhle | 1.000 |
| 1921 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Jesse Barnes Jose Acosta Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Cy Barger | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .964 | |
Jose Acosta Elam Vangilder Jesse Barnes Leon Cadore Ray Kolp Rosy Ryan | 1.000 |
| 1922 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Cy Barger | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .966 | |
Pete Alexander+ Bullet Joe Bush Virgil Cheeves Wilbur Cooper Johnny Couch Earl Hamilton Walter Johnson+ Tiny Osborne Duster Mails Rollie Naylor | 1.000 |
| 1923 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Sherry Smith Tom Zachary Vic Aldridge Dan Boone Dave Danforth Nick Dumovich Ralph Head Joe Oeschger Charlie Robertson | 1.000 |
| 1924 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Sheriff Blake Hal Carlson Joe Genewich Walter Johnson+ Red Lucas George Lyons Tim McNamara Hooks Dauss Pete Donohue Jesse Barnes | 1.000 |
| 1925 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Jakie May Bullet Joe Bush Leo Dickerman Pete Alexander+ Garland Buckeye Jess Doyle Milt Gaston Walter Johnson+ Ray Kremer Firpo Marberry | 1.000 |
| 1926 | Pete Alexander+ | .983 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .983 | |
Joe Pate Red Lucas Vic Keen Bunny Hearn Ken Holloway Tony Kaufmann Larry Benton Ted Blankenship James Edwards Freddie Fitzsimmons | 1.000 |
| 1927 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Jose Acosta | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Jim Brillheart Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Burleigh Grimes+ Dutch Henry Del Lundgren General Crowder Joe Genewich Hal Carlson Bobby Burke | 1.000 |
| 1928 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Appleton Pete Alexander+ Ed Brandt Lloyd Brown George Cox Alex Ferguson Freddie Fitzsimmons George Grant Jesse Haines+ Slim Harriss | 1.000 |
| 1929 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ray Kremer Hal Elliott Bill Bayne Lloyd Brown Hal Carlson Rip Collins Dolf Luque Firpo Marberry Art Nehf Fred Heimach | 1.000 |
| 1930 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ed Brandt Dick Coffman Rip Collins Bruce Cunningham Jumbo Elliott Ad Liska Red Lucas Ray Phelps Jack Quinn Eppa Rixey+ | 1.000 |
| 1931 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Jose Acosta | 1.000 | |
Eppa Rixey+ | .978 | |
Lefty Grove+ Clint Brown Watty Clark Clise Dudley Si Johnson Red Ruffing+ Fred Heimach Hank Johnson Jack Berly Sheriff Blake | 1.000 |
| 1932 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Eppa Rixey+ | .978 | |
Huck Betts Bob Brown Dick Coffman Benny Frey Socks Seibold Fred Heimach Waite Hoyt+ Charlie Root Syl Johnson Ray Kolp | 1.000 |
| 1933 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Eppa Rixey+ | .978 | |
Vic Frazier Ed Holley Chad Kimsey Red Lucas Jim Peterson Ray Benge Clint Brown Watty Clark General Crowder Wes Ferrell | 1.000 |
| 1934 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Herb Pennock+ | .973 | |
Oral Hildebrand Si Johnson Dutch Leonard Pat Malone Gordon Rhodes Schoolboy Rowe Joe Bowman General Crowder Jesse Haines+ Snipe Hansen | 1.000 |
| 1935 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Firpo Marberry | .968 | |
Elden Auker Guy Bush General Crowder Red Ruffing+ Hal Schumacher Bill Swift Whitey Wilshere Si Johnson | 1.000 |
| 1936 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Guy Bush | .972 | |
Oral Hildebrand Orville Jorgens Ted Lyons+ Bobby Reis Bob Smith Johnny Broaca Mace Brown Guy Bush Bump Hadley Tex Carleton | 1.000 |
| 1937 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Guy Bush | .974 | |
Joe Bowman Guy Bush Harry Kelley Johnny Lanning Eddie Smith Jake Wade | 1.000 |
| 1938 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Charlie Root | .976 | |
Curt Davis Lou Fette Bump Hadley Al Hollingsworth Bob Klinger Hugh Mulcahy Red Ruffing+ Gene Schott Jim Tobin Jim Turner | 1.000 |
| 1939 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Charlie Root | .974 | |
Bill Beckmann Joe Bowman Max Butcher Hugh Casey Harry Eisenstat Freddie Fitzsimmons Kirby Higbe Ira Hutchinson Bob Joyce Carl Hubbell+ | 1.000 |
| 1940 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Charlie Root | .975 | |
Joe Beggs Nels Potter Johnny Rigney Schoolboy Rowe Johnny Allen Harry Gumbert Vern Kennedy Bob Klinger Cliff Melton Vern Olsen | 1.000 |
| 1941 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Freddie Fitzsimmons | .977 | |
Elden Auker Clint Brown Max Butcher Alex Carrasquel Chubby Dean Denny Galehouse Luke Hamlin Joe Heving Si Johnson Max Lanier | 1.000 |
| 1942 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Jose Acosta | 1.000 | |
Freddie Fitzsimmons | .977 | |
Joe Haynes Johnny Allen Joe Beggs Tiny Bonham Bob Carpenter Curt Davis Murry Dickson Bill Dietrich Joe Dobson Harry Gumbert | 1.000 |
| 1943 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Freddie Fitzsimmons | .977 | |
Joe Beggs Don Black Tiny Bonham Harry Brecheen Milo Candini Johnny Gorsica Mickey Haefner Joe Heving Kirby Higbe Bob Klinger | 1.000 |
| 1944 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Paul Derringer | .968 | |
Dick Barrett Harry Brecheen Mort Cooper Atley Donald Clem Hausmann Ira Hutchinson Sig Jakucki Andy Karl Eddie Lopat Bobo Newsom | 1.000 |
| 1945 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Guy Bush | .974 | |
Hank Borowy Bud Byerly Al Hollingsworth Hal Newhouser+ Claude Passeau Preacher Roe Mike Ryba Sandy Ullrich | 1.000 |
| 1946 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Red Ruffing+ | .968 | |
Paul Erickson Harry Gumbert Jack Hallett Joe Haynes Ken Heintzelman Sid Hudson Oscar Judd Lou Knerr Johnny Lanning Eddie Lopat | 1.000 |
| 1947 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Red Ruffing+ | .968 | |
Mickey Haefner Joe Hatten Tommy Hughes Si Johnson Joe Dobson Al Gettel Joe Beggs Bill Bevens Ken Burkhart Bob Chipman | 1.000 |
| 1948 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Bobo Newsom | .957 | |
Earl Johnson Dave Koslo Al Gettel Clint Hartung Lou Brissie Murry Dickson Dave Ferriss Harry Brecheen Fred Hutchinson Al Brazle | 1.000 |
| 1949 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Harry Gumbert | .979 | |
Ted Gray Harry Gumbert Bubba Harris Dave Koslo Cliff Chambers Joe Dobson Karl Drews Hank Borowy Lou Brissie Paul Calvert | 1.000 |
| 1950 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Harry Gumbert | .979 | |
Ralph Branca Harry Brecheen Tommy Byrne Bob Feller+ Sheldon Jones Doyle Lade Russ Meyer Bob Miller Red Munger Fred Sanford | 1.000 |
| 1951 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Dutch Leonard | .965 | |
Ralph Branca Sandy Consuegra Turk Lown Sal Maglie Johnny Klippstein Dave Koslo Dutch Leonard Steve Gromek Don Johnson Clyde King | 1.000 |
| 1952 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Dutch Leonard | .965 | |
Johnny Klippstein Jim McDonald Satchel Paige+ Mel Parnell Duane Pillette Fritz Dorish Warren Hacker Jim Hearn Alex Kellner Bob Porterfield | 1.000 |
| 1953 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Bob Feller+ | .967 | |
Sonny Dixon Fritz Dorish Marion Fricano Mike Garcia Johnny Hetki Larry Jansen Al Brazle Harry Brecheen Jackie Collum Charlie Bishop | 1.000 |
| 1954 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Bob Feller+ | .968 | |
Alex Kellner Johnny Klippstein Lou Kretlow Bob Purkey Paul LaPalme Tom Morgan Chet Nichols Camilo Pascual Warren Hacker Ernie Johnson | 1.000 |
| 1955 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .965 | |
Ray Crone Dick Donovan Art Fowler Billy Hoeft Don Mossi Billy Pierce Tom Poholsky Johnny Schmitz Chuck Stobbs Dean Stone | 1.000 |
| 1956 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .967 | |
Tom Poholsky Pedro Ramos Willard Schmidt Mike Garcia Vern Law Sal Maglie Bob Miller Stu Miller Roger Craig Mike Fornieles | 1.000 |
| 1957 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .967 | |
Jim Bunning+ Dick Hyde Larry Jackson Bob Keegan Wally Burnette Roger Craig Ray Crone Dick Donovan Moe Drabowsky Don Gross | 1.000 |
| 1958 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .968 | |
Murry Dickson Don Elston Bill Fischer Paul Foytack Paul Giel Vern Law Ray Moore Don Newcombe Billy O'Dell Arnie Portocarrero | 1.000 |
| 1959 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Gerry Staley | .971 | |
Ernie Broglio Harvey Haddix Jack Harshman Clem Labine Bill Monbouquette Jim O'Toole Camilo Pascual Jim Perry Pedro Ramos Jerry Walker | 1.000 |
| 1960 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Robin Roberts+ | .974 | |
Jim Bunning+ Dick Ellsworth Chuck Estrada Roy Face Bill Fischer Ken Johnson Ron Kline Jack Kralick Don Lee Lindy McDaniel | 1.000 |
| 1961 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Bob Anderson Jack Baldschun Hal Brown Joe Gibbon Billy Hoeft Bobby Locke Mike McCormick Lindy McDaniel Cal McLish Stu Miller | 1.000 |
| 1962 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .979 | |
Joe Bonikowski Jim Bouton Jim Bunning+ John Buzhardt Bill Fischer Jack Fisher Paul Foytack Dallas Green Ray Herbert Glen Hobbie | 1.000 |
| 1963 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Bob Buhl Ray Culp Turk Farrell Jack Fisher Dick Hall Bob Hendley Joe Horlen Bill Monbouquette Orlando Pena Juan Pizarro | 1.000 |
| 1964 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .979 | |
Bob Buhl Joe Horlen Larry Jackson Denny Lemaster Larry Bearnarth Wade Blasingame Lew Burdette Al Downing Turk Farrell Mudcat Grant | 1.000 |
| 1965 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .981 | |
Howie Koplitz Sandy Koufax+ Frank Linzy Whitey Ford+ Larry Jackson Cal Koonce Ted Abernathy Wade Blasingame Jim Bouton Ray Culp | 1.000 |
| 1966 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .981 | |
Vern Law Billy McCool Lindy McDaniel Denny McLain Dave McNally Don Nottebart Jack Lamabe Jack Aker Clay Carroll Mike McCormick | 1.000 |
| 1967 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .979 | |
Denny Lemaster Frank Linzy Bruce Howard Cal Koonce Dave Boswell Chuck Dobson Woodie Fryman Joe Gibbon Ron Herbel Joe Horlen | 1.000 |
| 1968 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .980 | |
Steve Blass Ray Culp Larry Jackson Fergie Jenkins+ Jerry Koosman Lew Krausse Frank Linzy Jim Merritt Joe Niekro Camilo Pascual | 1.000 |
| 1969 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Denny Lemaster Casey Cox Woodie Fryman Gary Gentry Jim Hannan Chuck Hartenstein Catfish Hunter+ Pat Jarvis Tommy John Jack Aker | 1.000 |
| 1970 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .977 | |
Bob Miller Bill Stoneman Chuck Taylor Dick Bosman Joe Coleman Pat Dobson Mudcat Grant Bob Johnson Jim McAndrew Jim McGlothlin | 1.000 |
| 1971 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Mike Kekich Tom Kelley Denny McLain Vida Blue Steve Carlton+ Chuck Dobson Rollie Fingers+ Gary Gentry Wayne Granger Catfish Hunter+ | 1.000 |
| 1972 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge Ted Abernathy | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Al Fitzmorris Gary Gentry Bill Gogolewski Ross Grimsley Mike Hedlund Tommy John Mike Kekich Bill Lee Milt Pappas Larry Dierker | 1.000 |
| 1973 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Wilbur Wood | .974 | |
Ken Forsch Ross Grimsley Don Gullett Vida Blue Ken Brett Jim Colborn Steve Arlin Jim Barr Gaylord Perry+ Horacio Pina | 1.000 |
| 1974 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Wilbur Wood | .972 | |
Rollie Fingers+ Al Fitzmorris Dave Giusti Kevin Kobel Jon Matlack Randy Moffitt Tom Murphy Phil Niekro+ Mike Caldwell John Curtis | 1.000 |
| 1975 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .975 | |
Jack Billingham Woodie Fryman Ross Grimsley Darold Knowles Mickey Lolich Joe McIntosh Phil Niekro+ Gary Nolan Rick Reuschel Jerry Reuss | 1.000 |
| 1976 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .974 | |
Doyle Alexander Ray Bare Bert Blyleven+ Nelson Briles Tom Burgmeier John Candelaria John Curtis Mark Fidrych Woodie Fryman Burt Hooton | 1.000 |
| 1977 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .977 | |
Phil Niekro+ Rick Langford John Montague Joe Niekro Burt Hooton Mike Caldwell Adrian Devine Nino Espinosa Mike Flanagan Willie Hernandez | 1.000 |
| 1978 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .978 | |
Jerry Augustine Francisco Barrios Vida Blue Mike Caldwell John Candelaria Woodie Fryman Gene Garber Preston Hanna Dave Heaverlo Bob Knepper | 1.000 |
| 1979 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Don Sutton+ | .974 | |
Jim Barr Joe Niekro Mike Parrott Bert Blyleven+ John Candelaria Burt Hooton Phil Huffman Rick Langford Rick Matula Lynn McGlothen | 1.000 |
| 1980 | Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Tom Hume Gary Lucas Reggie Cleveland Larry Gura Willie Hernandez Len Barker Jim Beattie Tommy Boggs Tom Burgmeier Steve Carlton+ | 1.000 |
| 1981 | Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Doug Bird Tom Burgmeier Ross Baumgarten Bruce Berenyi Floyd Bannister Rick Camp Larry Gura Tommy John Dennis Leonard Gary Lucas | 1.000 |
| 1982 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Mike Flanagan Moose Haas LaMarr Hoyt Bill Campbell Dave Dravecky Salome Barojas Doug Bird Luis Leal Tim Lollar Jon Matlack | 1.000 |
| 1983 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Jack Aker Vic Aldridge Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Dave LaPoint Ed Lynch Mike LaCoss Larry Gura Ron Guidry Fergie Jenkins+ Tommy John Neil Allen Ray Burris John Butcher | 1.000 |
| 1984 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Ron Reed | .975 | |
Bruce Hurst Bill Laskey Luis Leal Salome Barojas Jim Beattie Bruce Berenyi Steve Carlton+ Mike Flanagan Larry Gura Moose Haas | 1.000 |
| 1985 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jack Aker Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Willie Hernandez | .983 | |
Bert Blyleven+ Storm Davis John Denny Gene Garber Mark Gubicza Charles Hudson Dennis Lamp Phil Niekro+ Dan Petry Rick Reuschel | 1.000 |
| 1986 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Rick Aguilera Jack Aker | 1.000 | |
Willie Hernandez | .985 | |
Jim Acker Rick Aguilera Bert Blyleven+ Don Carman John Cerutti Mark Eichhorn Bob Forsch Mark Gubicza Jose Guzman Andy Hawkins | 1.000 |
| 1987 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Rick Aguilera Jack Aker | 1.000 | |
Willie Hernandez | .981 | |
Bill Gullickson Atlee Hammaker Jimmy Jones Greg Minton Jim Acker Jack Morris Jeff Robinson Don Carman Roger Clemens Bob Forsch | 1.000 |
| 1988 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Rick Aguilera Jack Aker | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .983 | |
Jose DeLeon Richard Dotson John Farrell Mike Flanagan Wes Gardner Atlee Hammaker Tim Belcher Don Carman John Cerutti Teddy Higuera | 1.000 |
| 1989 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Rick Aguilera Jack Aker | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .983 | |
Luis Aquino Scott Bankhead Bert Blyleven+ Tom Browning Roger Clemens Mike Flanagan Tom Gordon Greg Harris Ken Howell Bruce Hurst | 1.000 |
| 1990 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Juan Agosto Rick Aguilera | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .984 | |
Dan Petry Allan Anderson Jack Armstrong John Cerutti Pat Combs Dennis Cook Greg Hibbard Les Lancaster Greg Maddux Juan Agosto | 1.000 |
| 1991 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Juan Agosto Rick Aguilera | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .985 | |
Don August Andy Benes Mike Bielecki Buddy Black Oil Can Boyd Mike Flanagan Tom Glavine Bill Gullickson Bill Krueger Jack McDowell | 1.000 |
| 1992 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Juan Agosto | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .982 | |
Tom Glavine Jeff Innis Scott Kamieniecki Mike Magnante Ben McDonald Rheal Cormier Jim Abbott Buddy Black Chris Bosio Jim Bullinger | 1.000 |
| 1993 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Juan Agosto | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .984 | |
Andy Ashby Steve Avery John Burkett Jim Deshaies John Dopson Doug Drabek Alex Fernandez Kevin Gross Bill Gullickson Greg Hibbard | 1.000 |
| 1994 | Mark Eichhorn | .991 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Juan Agosto | 1.000 | |
Mark Eichhorn | .991 | |
Andy Ashby Chris Bosio John Burkett Kevin Appier Mark Clark Tom Edens Mark Eichhorn Cal Eldred Marvin Freeman Erik Hanson | 1.000 |
| 1995 | Mark Eichhorn | .991 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .985 | |
Kevin Appier Jason Bere Ricky Bones John Burkett John Doherty Jim Abbott Wilson Alvarez Mark Gubicza Curt Leskanic Felipe Lira | 1.000 |
| 1996 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy | 1.000 | |
Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Wilson Alvarez Kevin Appier Sean Bergman Jim Bullinger Mark Clark Chris Haney Jon Lieber Jose Lima Felipe Lira Mike Mussina | 1.000 |
| 1997 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Bob Patterson | .990 | |
Roger Bailey Tim Belcher Jim Bullinger Danny Darwin Mark Gardner Ken Hill Kent Mercker Mike Morgan Jamie Moyer Mike Mussina | 1.000 |
| 1998 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Bob Patterson | .990 | |
LaTroy Hawkins Livan Hernandez Scott Karl Jon Lieber Pedro Astacio Andy Benes Kent Bottenfield Mark Clark Mark Gardner Pete Harnisch | 1.000 |
| 1999 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Paul Assenmacher | .986 | |
Kent Bottenfield Jeff Fassero Danny Graves Dustin Hermanson Brian Moehler Russ Ortiz Chan Ho Park Mark Portugal Brad Radke Shane Reynolds | 1.000 |
| 2000 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Trevor Hoffman | .987 | |
Jason Bere Dave Burba Elmer Dessens Scott Elarton Tom Glavine Pedro Astacio Orlando Hernandez Al Leiter Pedro Martinez Livan Hernandez | 1.000 |
| 2001 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Trevor Hoffman | .989 | |
Rolando Arrojo Dave Burba John Burkett Paul Abbott Elmer Dessens Tom Glavine Mike Hampton Jimmy Haynes Livan Hernandez Chris Carpenter | 1.000 |
| 2002 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Mike Trombley | .986 | |
Gary Glover Tony Armas James Baldwin Frank Castillo Roger Clemens Ryan Dempster Jon Garland Tom Glavine Danny Graves Tim Hudson | 1.000 |
| 2003 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jose Acosta Babe Adams Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .984 | |
Cory Lidle Derek Lowe Al Leiter Ryan Franklin Wayne Franklin Jon Garland Danny Graves Adam Bernero Mark Buehrle Rheal Cormier | 1.000 |
| 2004 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Trevor Hoffman | .981 | |
Mark Hendrickson John Lackey Brian Lawrence Al Leiter Jose Lima Esteban Loaiza Aaron Harang Luis Ayala Jeff Fassero Freddy Garcia | 1.000 |
| 2005 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Shigetoshi Hasegawa | .982 | |
Aaron Harang Jose Lima Kyle Lohse Noah Lowry Mike Maroth Jamie Moyer Tom Glavine Kris Benson Jeff Fassero Freddy Garcia | 1.000 |
| 2006 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Braden Looper | .982 | |
Bronson Arroyo Josh Beckett Jeff Francis Felix Hernandez Orlando Hernandez Tim Hudson Josh Johnson John Lackey Kyle Lohse Greg Maddux | 1.000 |
| 2007 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Braden Looper | .986 | |
Shaun Marcum Matt Belisle Paul Byrd Matt Cain Josh Fogg Aaron Harang Tim Hudson Braden Looper Derek Lowe Daisuke Matsuzaka | 1.000 |
| 2008 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
R.A. Dickey Dan Haren Kyle Lohse Braden Looper Brett Myers Bronson Arroyo Brian Bass Mark Buehrle Matt Cain John Danks | 1.000 |
| 2009 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Jim Abbott Jim Acker Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Livan Hernandez Josh Johnson John Lannan Joe Blanton Matt Cain Brett Anderson Chris Carpenter Cole Hamels Jason Hammel Dan Haren | 1.000 |
| 2010 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Mariano Rivera | .982 | |
Mark Buehrle John Danks Brian Duensing Zach Duke Bronson Arroyo Brad Bergesen Derek Lowe Scott Feldman Jaime Garcia Livan Hernandez | 1.000 |
| 2011 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Mariano Rivera | .983 | |
Jeff Francis Zack Greinke Dan Haren Jeremy Hellickson Ian Kennedy Clayton Kershaw Hiroki Kuroda Chris Capuano Roberto Hernandez Wade Davis | 1.000 |
| 2012 | Luis Vizcaino Heath Bell | 1.000 | |
Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Ted Abernathy Jim Acker Jose Acosta Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Heath Bell | 1.000 | |
Bronson Arroyo Mark Buehrle Yu Darvish Zack Greinke J.A. Happ Lucas Harrell Luke Hochevar Tommy Hunter Clayton Kershaw Hiroki Kuroda | 1.000 |