| 1871 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 |
| 1872 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Candy Cummings+ | .911 |
| 1873 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Al Spalding+ | .885 |
| 1874 | | | |
Cherokee Fisher | .927 | |
| | |
Al Spalding+ | .854 |
| 1875 | | | |
Dick McBride | .954 | |
| | |
Dick McBride | .955 |
|
| 1876 | | | |
Jack Manning Dale Williams | 1.000 | |
| | |
Jack Manning Dale Williams | 1.000 |
| 1877 | | | |
Jack Manning Dale Williams | 1.000 | |
| | |
George Bradley | .950 |
| 1878 | | | |
Jack Manning Dale Williams | 1.000 | |
| | |
Tricky Nichols | .971 |
| 1879 | | | |
Dale Williams Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Tommy Bond | .957 |
| 1880 | | | |
Tim Keefe+ Dale Williams Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Tim Keefe+ | 1.000 |
| 1881 | | | |
Tim Keefe+ Stump Wiedman Dale Williams Jack Manning | 1.000 | |
| | |
Stump Wiedman | 1.000 |
| 1882 | | | |
Jack Manning Guy Hecker Stump Wiedman Tim Keefe+ Dale Williams | 1.000 | |
| | |
Guy Hecker | 1.000 |
| 1883 | | | |
Jack Manning Dale Williams Tim Keefe+ Guy Hecker Stump Wiedman | 1.000 | |
| | |
Dupee Shaw | .962 |
| 1884 | | | |
Tim Keefe+ Ed Dundon Frank Meinke Jack Manning Guy Hecker Dale Williams Jim Whitney Stump Wiedman | 1.000 | |
| | |
Ed Dundon Frank Meinke Jim Whitney | 1.000 |
| 1885 | Bobby Mathews | .822 | |
Frank Meinke Dale Williams Stump Wiedman Jim Whitney Al Mays Ed Dundon Guy Hecker Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ | 1.000 | |
Bobby Mathews | .822 | |
Al Mays | 1.000 |
| 1886 | Bobby Mathews | .823 | |
Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ Guy Hecker Al Mays Dale Williams Jim Whitney Ed Dundon Cyclone Miller Stump Wiedman Frank Meinke | 1.000 | |
Bobby Mathews | .823 | |
Cyclone Miller | 1.000 |
| 1887 | Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Dale Williams Stump Wiedman Tim Keefe+ Frank Meinke Jim Whitney Ed Dundon Cyclone Miller Al Mays Jack Manning Guy Hecker | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Pete Conway | .979 |
| 1888 | Pud Galvin+ | .917 | |
Jim Whitney Ed Dundon Guy Hecker Tim Keefe+ Frank Meinke Cyclone Miller Jack Manning Al Mays Dale Williams Stump Wiedman | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .917 | |
Ice Box Chamberlain | .963 |
| 1889 | Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Jim Whitney Jack Manning Frank Meinke Al Mays Tim Keefe+ Cyclone Miller Ed Morris Mickey Hughes Guy Hecker Ed Dundon | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Ed Morris Mickey Hughes | 1.000 |
| 1890 | Pud Galvin+ | .916 | |
Jack Manning Ed Morris Cyclone Miller Jim Whitney Tim Keefe+ Mickey Hughes Guy Hecker Ed Dundon Frank Meinke Al Mays | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .916 | |
Dave Anderson | .980 |
| 1891 | Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Al Mays Tim Keefe+ Mickey Hughes Guy Hecker Frank Meinke Ed Dundon Ed Morris Jim Whitney Jack Manning Cyclone Miller | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .915 | |
Pat Luby | .962 |
| 1892 | Pud Galvin+ | .914 | |
Jim Whitney Tim Keefe+ Guy Hecker Ed Morris Cyclone Miller Frank Meinke Jack Manning Al Mays Mickey Hughes Ed Dundon | 1.000 | |
Pud Galvin+ | .914 | |
Duke Esper | .978 |
| 1893 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ed Dundon Frank Meinke Jack Manning Al Mays Guy Hecker Ad Gumbert Tim Keefe+ Ed Morris Cyclone Miller Mickey Hughes | 1.000 | |
Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert | 1.000 |
| 1894 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Al Mays Frank Meinke Cyclone Miller Ed Morris Tim Keefe+ Mickey Hughes Jack Manning Ad Gumbert Ed Dundon Guy Hecker | 1.000 | |
Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Duke Esper | .982 |
| 1895 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Cyclone Miller Al Mays Ed Morris Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ Mickey Hughes Guy Hecker Frank Meinke Ad Gumbert Ed Dundon | 1.000 | |
| | |
Bill Kissinger | .976 |
| 1896 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Jack Manning Al Mays Guy Hecker Tim Keefe+ Cyclone Miller Mickey Hughes Ad Gumbert Ed Dundon Frank Meinke Ed Morris | 1.000 | |
| | |
Kid Nichols+ | 1.000 |
| 1897 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Guy Hecker Ed Dundon Cyclone Miller Al Mays Ad Gumbert Frank Meinke Mickey Hughes Chauncey Fisher Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ | 1.000 | |
| | |
Chauncey Fisher | 1.000 |
| 1898 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Tim Keefe+ Guy Hecker Chauncey Fisher Ed Dundon Cyclone Miller Jack Manning Al Mays Ad Gumbert Frank Meinke Mickey Hughes | 1.000 | |
| | |
Bill Hill | .986 |
| 1899 | Tony Mullane | .918 | |
Ad Gumbert Mickey Hughes Ed Dundon Frank Meinke Cyclone Miller Al Mays Jack Manning Chauncey Fisher Tim Keefe+ Guy Hecker | 1.000 | |
Gus Weyhing | .880 | |
Frank Kitson | .976 |
| 1900 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ Chauncey Fisher Frank Meinke Ad Gumbert Cyclone Miller Ed Dundon Guy Hecker Mickey Hughes Al Mays | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .985 |
| 1901 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Ad Gumbert Chauncey Fisher Frank Meinke Al Mays Cyclone Miller Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ Guy Hecker Mickey Hughes Ed Dundon | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .992 |
| 1902 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Jack Manning Frank Meinke Clark Griffith+ Al Mays Chauncey Fisher Ed Dundon Guy Hecker Tim Keefe+ Ad Gumbert Mickey Hughes | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .938 | |
Clark Griffith+ | 1.000 |
| 1903 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ Mickey Hughes Chauncey Fisher Ad Gumbert Al Mays Guy Hecker Clark Griffith+ Harry Howell Ed Dundon | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .939 | |
Harry Howell | 1.000 |
| 1904 | Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Harry Howell Clark Griffith+ Ad Gumbert Chauncey Fisher Buttons Briggs Tim Keefe+ Jack Manning Mickey Hughes Ed Dundon Guy Hecker | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .955 | |
Buttons Briggs Frank Owen | 1.000 |
| 1905 | Kid Nichols+ | .952 | |
Harry Howell Ad Gumbert Clark Griffith+ Chauncey Fisher Buttons Briggs Mickey Hughes Ed Dundon Tim Keefe+ Jack Manning Guy Hecker | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .952 | |
Tully Sparks | 1.000 |
| 1906 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Ed Dundon Jack Manning Tim Keefe+ Mickey Hughes Buttons Briggs Harry Howell Ad Gumbert Guy Hecker Clark Griffith+ Chauncey Fisher | 1.000 | |
Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Lew Richie | 1.000 |
| 1907 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Chauncey Fisher Ed Dundon Mickey Hughes Gus Dorner Buttons Briggs Harry Howell Clark Griffith+ Guy Hecker Ad Gumbert Tim Keefe+ | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .940 | |
Gus Dorner | 1.000 |
| 1908 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Harry Howell Mickey Hughes Ad Gumbert Guy Hecker Clark Griffith+ Chauncey Fisher Ed Dundon Mordecai Brown+ Buttons Briggs Gus Dorner | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .941 | |
Mordecai Brown+ | 1.000 |
| 1909 | Kid Nichols+ | .953 | |
Buttons Briggs Ad Gumbert Mickey Hughes Chauncey Fisher Harry Howell Gus Dorner Ed Dundon Guy Hecker Clark Griffith+ Mordecai Brown+ | 1.000 | |
Cy Young+ | .939 | |
George McQuillan | 1.000 |
| 1910 | Vic Willis+ | .954 | |
Gus Dorner Chauncey Fisher Ed Dundon Mordecai Brown+ Buttons Briggs Mickey Hughes Guy Hecker Harry Howell Ad Gumbert Clark Griffith+ | 1.000 | |
Vic Willis+ | .954 | |
Doc Scanlan | 1.000 |
| 1911 | Vic Willis+ | .954 | |
Ed Dundon Clark Griffith+ Guy Hecker Ad Gumbert Chief Bender+ Harry Howell Chauncey Fisher Gus Dorner Mordecai Brown+ Buttons Briggs | 1.000 | |
Jack Powell | .939 | |
Chief Bender+ | 1.000 |
| 1912 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Buttons Briggs Buster Brown Clark Griffith+ Gus Dorner Chief Bender+ Babe Adams Chauncey Fisher Jack Coombs Ed Dundon Mordecai Brown+ | 1.000 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Eppa Rixey+ Doc White Hank Robinson Babe Adams Eddie Plank+ Buster Brown Jack Coombs | 1.000 |
| 1913 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Jack Coombs Ray Caldwell Mordecai Brown+ Ed Dundon Buttons Briggs Buster Brown Gus Dorner Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Chief Bender+ | 1.000 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Ray Caldwell Walter Johnson+ Pete Alexander+ Art Fromme Eppa Rixey+ | 1.000 |
| 1914 | Eddie Plank+ | .970 | |
Buster Brown Buttons Briggs Chief Bender+ Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Mordecai Brown+ Gus Dorner Jack Coombs Ray Caldwell | 1.000 | |
Eddie Plank+ | .970 | |
Babe Adams | 1.000 |
| 1915 | Eddie Plank+ | .971 | |
Dave Black Mordecai Brown+ Buster Brown Buttons Briggs Ray Caldwell Chief Bender+ Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Eddie Plank+ | .971 | |
Dave Black Al Demaree Babe Adams Bunny Hearn Rankin Johnson | 1.000 |
| 1916 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Chief Bender+ Fred Anderson Rube Benton Buster Brown Buttons Briggs Dave Black | 1.000 | |
Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Tom Hughes Rube Benton Slim Sallee Ernie Koob Jack Coombs Fred Anderson Lefty Williams | 1.000 |
| 1917 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Babe Adams Buttons Briggs Buster Brown Dave Black Rube Benton Chief Bender+ Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson | 1.000 | |
Eddie Plank+ | .971 | |
Gene Packard Walter Johnson+ Slim Sallee George Mogridge Al Demaree Eppa Rixey+ Rube Schauer | 1.000 |
| 1918 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Fred Anderson Dave Black Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Chief Bender+ Buster Brown Rube Benton Buttons Briggs | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .961 | |
Happy Finneran Wilbur Cooper Hod Eller Erskine Mayer Slim Sallee Bill Sherdel Elmer Jacobs | 1.000 |
| 1919 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Rube Benton Chief Bender+ Fred Anderson | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .963 | |
Carl Weilman Babe Adams Rube Benton Jimmy Ring Pete Alexander+ Brad Hogg | 1.000 |
| 1920 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Chief Bender+ Rube Benton Fred Anderson Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .963 | |
Carl Mays | .992 |
| 1921 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Jesse Barnes Chief Bender+ Fred Anderson Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .964 | |
Babe Adams Jesse Barnes Elam Vangilder Leon Cadore Ray Kolp | 1.000 |
| 1922 | Christy Mathewson+ | .971 | |
Jesse Barnes Pete Alexander+ Fred Anderson Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Walter Johnson+ | .966 | |
Bullet Joe Bush Virgil Cheeves Walter Johnson+ Dutch Ruether Tiny Osborne Pete Alexander+ Johnny Couch Rollie Naylor Wilbur Cooper Earl Hamilton | 1.000 |
| 1923 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Fred Anderson Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Joe Oeschger Tom Zachary Charlie Robertson Vic Aldridge Dave Danforth | 1.000 |
| 1924 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Fred Anderson Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Herb Pennock+ Bill Sherdel Urban Shocker Jesse Barnes Joe Genewich Clarence Mitchell Pete Donohue Hal Carlson Walter Johnson+ Tim McNamara | 1.000 |
| 1925 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Pete Alexander+ Bullet Joe Bush Ray Kremer Bob Shawkey Lee Meadows Clarence Mitchell Bill Sherdel Art Nehf Walter Johnson+ Milt Gaston | 1.000 |
| 1926 | Pete Alexander+ | .983 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .983 | |
Joe Shaute Red Lucas Lil Stoner Larry Benton Sherry Smith Ted Blankenship Tommy Thomas Freddie Fitzsimmons Tony Kaufmann | 1.000 |
| 1927 | Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .984 | |
Dutch Henry Hal Carlson Pete Alexander+ Firpo Marberry Jack Quinn Dutch Ruether Burleigh Grimes+ Joe Genewich Jakie May Vic Aldridge | 1.000 |
| 1928 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Freddie Fitzsimmons Sad Sam Jones Jesse Haines+ Ed Morris Pete Alexander+ George Grant Red Lucas Ed Brandt Flint Rhem Jimmy Ring | 1.000 |
| 1929 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Lloyd Brown Dolf Luque Firpo Marberry Rip Collins Herb Pennock+ Socks Seibold Jack Russell Ray Kremer Jesse Haines+ Eppa Rixey+ | 1.000 |
| 1930 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Jumbo Elliott Eppa Rixey+ Rip Collins Ray Phelps Charlie Root Red Lucas Dick Coffman | 1.000 |
| 1931 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Eppa Rixey+ | .978 | |
Si Johnson Clint Brown Lefty Grove+ Red Ruffing+ Clise Dudley Watty Clark Socks Seibold Hank Johnson Bob Smith George Uhle | 1.000 |
| 1932 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Eppa Rixey+ | .978 | |
Lefty Stewart Bob Brown Syl Johnson Charlie Root Fred Heimach Huck Betts Ray Kolp Steve Swetonic | 1.000 |
| 1933 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Eppa Rixey+ | .978 | |
Red Lucas Hank Johnson Clint Brown General Crowder Ed Holley Lon Warneke Ray Benge Wes Ferrell | 1.000 |
| 1934 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Herb Pennock+ | .973 | |
Les Tietje Johnny Welch Dutch Leonard Gordon Rhodes Pat Malone Schoolboy Rowe Si Johnson General Crowder Oral Hildebrand Lon Warneke | 1.000 |
| 1935 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Firpo Marberry | .968 | |
General Crowder Elden Auker Ted Lyons+ Red Ruffing+ Guy Bush Hal Schumacher Bill Swift | 1.000 |
| 1936 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Guy Bush | .972 | |
Ted Lyons+ Tommy Thomas Tex Carleton Orville Jorgens Mace Brown Johnny Broaca Bump Hadley Oral Hildebrand Joe Cascarella | 1.000 |
| 1937 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Guy Bush | .974 | |
Monty Stratton Bill Swift Bud Thomas Harry Kelley Guy Bush Ted Lyons+ Van Mungo Jake Wade Eddie Smith | 1.000 |
| 1938 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Charlie Root | .976 | |
Bump Hadley Lou Fette Curt Davis Red Ruffing+ Bob Klinger Hugh Mulcahy Lefty Grove+ Spud Chandler Carl Hubbell+ Al Hollingsworth | 1.000 |
| 1939 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Charlie Root | .974 | |
Al Milnar Bill McGee Vito Tamulis Max Butcher Carl Hubbell+ Joe Bowman Bill Beckmann Hugh Casey Kirby Higbe Claude Passeau | 1.000 |
| 1940 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Charlie Root | .975 | |
Marius Russo Nels Potter Al Smith Johnny Rigney Harry Gumbert Vern Kennedy Vern Olsen Schoolboy Rowe Lon Warneke Cliff Melton | 1.000 |
| 1941 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Freddie Fitzsimmons | .977 | |
Denny Galehouse Si Johnson Elden Auker Red Ruffing+ Johnny Lanning Elmer Riddle Hal Newhouser+ Lon Warneke Max Butcher Johnny Niggeling | 1.000 |
| 1942 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Freddie Fitzsimmons | .977 | |
Bill Dietrich Elmer Riddle Tiny Bonham Harry Gumbert Bob Carpenter Joe Dobson Claude Passeau Curt Davis Si Johnson Johnny Niggeling | 1.000 |
| 1943 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Freddie Fitzsimmons | .977 | |
Bobo Newsom Tommy Bridges Milo Candini Mickey Haefner Johnny Niggeling Van Mungo Don Black Tiny Bonham Kirby Higbe Bob Klinger | 1.000 |
| 1944 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Paul Derringer | .968 | |
Harry Brecheen Mort Cooper Dick Barrett Bucky Walters Eddie Lopat Johnny Niggeling Claude Passeau Sig Jakucki Bobo Newsom Atley Donald | 1.000 |
| 1945 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Guy Bush | .974 | |
Hal Newhouser+ Preacher Roe Hank Borowy Al Hollingsworth Tiny Bonham Claude Passeau | 1.000 |
| 1946 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Red Ruffing+ | .968 | |
Oscar Judd Joe Haynes Ken Heintzelman Johnny Schmitz Ken Raffensberger Eddie Lopat Bobo Newsom | 1.000 |
| 1947 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Red Ruffing+ | .968 | |
Mickey Haefner Joe Dobson Fritz Ostermueller Bill Bevens Dutch Leonard Vic Lombardi Bob Muncrief Howie Pollet Spec Shea Joe Hatten | 1.000 |
| 1948 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Bobo Newsom | .957 | |
Vic Lombardi Lou Brissie Murry Dickson Fred Hutchinson Preacher Roe Vic Raschi Harry Brecheen Red Munger Al Gettel Al Brazle | 1.000 |
| 1949 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Harry Gumbert | .979 | |
Ted Gray Dave Koslo Lou Brissie Joe Dobson Don Newcombe Paul Calvert Hank Borowy Mel Parnell Cliff Chambers Early Wynn+ | 1.000 |
| 1950 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Harry Gumbert | .979 | |
Harry Brecheen Gerry Staley Chuck Stobbs Curt Simmons Sheldon Jones Red Munger Tommy Byrne Russ Meyer Bob Feller+ Bob Miller | 1.000 |
| 1951 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Dutch Leonard | .965 | |
Don Johnson Ralph Branca Chet Nichols Sal Maglie | 1.000 |
| 1952 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Dutch Leonard | .965 | |
Bobby Shantz Bob Porterfield Mel Parnell Johnny Klippstein Spec Shea Warren Hacker Jim Hearn Duane Pillette Preacher Roe Alex Kellner | 1.000 |
| 1953 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Bob Feller+ | .967 | |
Bob Porterfield Bob Feller+ Larry Jansen Jim Konstanty Mike Garcia Harry Perkowski Charlie Bishop Morrie Martin Bob Miller Marion Fricano | 1.000 |
| 1954 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Bob Feller+ | .968 | |
Lou Kretlow Dean Stone Virgil Trucks Allie Reynolds Alex Kellner Warren Hacker | 1.000 |
| 1955 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .965 | |
Gene Conley Dick Donovan Dean Stone Johnny Schmitz Billy Pierce Art Fowler Billy Hoeft Virgil Trucks | 1.000 |
| 1956 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .967 | |
Jim Wilson Mike Garcia Sal Maglie Warren Hacker Vern Law Tom Poholsky Roger Craig | 1.000 |
| 1957 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .967 | |
Ray Crone Moe Drabowsky Don Mossi Willard Nixon Pedro Ramos Larry Jackson Ray Moore Robin Roberts+ Dick Donovan Jim Bunning+ | 1.000 |
| 1958 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Murry Dickson | .968 | |
Billy O'Dell Paul Foytack Frank Sullivan Don Newcombe Ray Semproch Jim Bunning+ Gary Bell Vern Law Arnie Portocarrero Robin Roberts+ | 1.000 |
| 1959 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Gerry Staley | .971 | |
Camilo Pascual Pedro Ramos Jerry Walker Ernie Broglio Harvey Haddix Hoyt Wilhelm+ | 1.000 |
| 1960 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Robin Roberts+ | .974 | |
Sandy Koufax+ Dick Ellsworth Don Lee Bill Monbouquette Pedro Ramos Vinegar Bend Mizell Ralph Terry Don Mossi Jim Bunning+ Chuck Estrada | 1.000 |
| 1961 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Cal McLish Tom Sturdivant Hal Brown Jerry Walker Carl Willey Rollie Sheldon Mike McCormick Ralph Terry Joe Gibbon Paul Foytack | 1.000 |
| 1962 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .979 | |
Jim Bunning+ Glen Hobbie Art Mahaffey Don Mossi Phil Regan Ray Herbert Bill Stafford Dave Stenhouse Early Wynn+ | 1.000 |
| 1963 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Bob Hendley Orlando Pena Turk Farrell Chris Short Ray Culp Bill Monbouquette Juan Pizarro Johnny Podres Bob Buhl Don Rudolph | 1.000 |
| 1964 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .979 | |
Bob Buhl Milt Pappas Bill Monbouquette Denny Lemaster Claude Osteen Turk Farrell Larry Jackson Mudcat Grant Al Downing Joe Horlen | 1.000 |
| 1965 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .981 | |
Cal Koonce Sandy Koufax+ Wade Blasingame Ray Culp Bobby Bolin Whitey Ford+ Larry Jackson | 1.000 |
| 1966 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .981 | |
Jose Santiago Dave McNally Bob Shaw Denny McLain Lee Stange Denny Lemaster Mike McCormick Vern Law Woodie Fryman | 1.000 |
| 1967 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .979 | |
Joe Niekro Dave Boswell Mike McCormick Chuck Dobson Denny Lemaster Joe Horlen Bob Gibson+ Earl Wilson Milt Pappas Chris Short | 1.000 |
| 1968 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .980 | |
Camilo Pascual Larry Jackson Jerry Koosman Gary Peters Steve Blass Joe Niekro Lew Krausse Ray Culp Fergie Jenkins+ Jim Merritt | 1.000 |
| 1969 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Woodie Fryman Mike McCormick Tom Phoebus Tommy John Pat Jarvis Casey Cox Gary Gentry Gaylord Perry+ Denny Lemaster Catfish Hunter+ | 1.000 |
| 1970 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .977 | |
Dick Bosman Jerry Koosman Joe Coleman Pat Dobson Bob Johnson Bill Stoneman Jim McGlothlin Jim McAndrew Danny Coombs | 1.000 |
| 1971 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Gary Nolan Steve Carlton+ Catfish Hunter+ Denny McLain Vida Blue Milt Pappas Mike Kekich Gary Gentry Chuck Dobson Skip Lockwood | 1.000 |
| 1972 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Hoyt Wilhelm+ | .978 | |
Bill Parsons Larry Dierker Milt Pappas Gary Nolan Andy Messersmith Mike Kekich Tommy John Ross Grimsley Gary Gentry Dock Ellis | 1.000 |
| 1973 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Wilbur Wood | .974 | |
Jim Barr Don Gullett Ross Grimsley Gaylord Perry+ Ken Forsch Jim Colborn Ken Brett Vida Blue Steve Arlin | 1.000 |
| 1974 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Vic Albury Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Wilbur Wood | .972 | |
Al Fitzmorris Doug Rau Phil Niekro+ Jon Matlack Kevin Kobel Vic Albury Dick Drago Ken Brett Mike Caldwell John Curtis | 1.000 |
| 1975 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .975 | |
Ross Grimsley Dave Roberts Jerry Reuss Rick Reuschel Phil Niekro+ Gary Nolan Joe McIntosh Jack Billingham Mickey Lolich | 1.000 |
| 1976 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Pete Alexander+ Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .974 | |
Doyle Alexander John Candelaria Fergie Jenkins+ Steve Carlton+ Mark Fidrych Pete Falcone Woodie Fryman Bert Blyleven+ Nelson Briles Burt Hooton | 1.000 |
| 1977 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge Pete Alexander+ Babe Adams Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .977 | |
Phil Niekro+ Joe Niekro Rick Rhoden John Montague Rick Langford Burt Hooton Mike Flanagan Bob Owchinko Doug Rau Nino Espinosa | 1.000 |
| 1978 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ | 1.000 | |
Paul Lindblad | .978 | |
Mike Caldwell Joe Niekro Bob Forsch Francisco Barrios Rick Langford Dennis Eckersley+ John Candelaria Bob Knepper Vida Blue Jerry Augustine | 1.000 |
| 1979 | Pete Alexander+ | .985 | |
Babe Adams Pete Alexander+ Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Don Sutton+ | .974 | |
Bert Blyleven+ Mike Krukow Rick Langford Rick Matula Phil Huffman Jim Barr John Henry Johnson Burt Hooton John Candelaria Floyd Bannister | 1.000 |
| 1980 | Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Pete Alexander+ Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Doyle Alexander Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Steve Renko Tom Seaver+ Lary Sorensen Dan Spillner Larry Gura Scott McGregor Len Barker Steve Carlton+ Tommy Boggs Jim Beattie | 1.000 |
| 1981 | Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Vic Aldridge Doyle Alexander Babe Adams Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .989 | |
Doyle Alexander Fernando Arroyo Ron Guidry Bob Forsch Larry Gura Burt Hooton Jim Clancy Steve Carlton+ Bruce Berenyi Mike Caldwell | 1.000 |
| 1982 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Vic Albury Babe Adams Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Doug Bird Scott McGregor LaMarr Hoyt Luis Leal Moose Haas Brad Havens Ron Guidry Mike Flanagan Tim Lollar Pete Falcone | 1.000 |
| 1983 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Vic Aldridge Doyle Alexander Babe Adams Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Neil Allen Dave LaPoint Tommy John Tim Lollar Fergie Jenkins+ Ed Lynch Larry Gura Moose Haas Ron Guidry John Candelaria | 1.000 |
| 1984 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Doyle Alexander Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Ron Reed | .975 | |
Tommy John Larry Gura Ron Guidry Moose Haas Mike Flanagan John Candelaria Jim Beattie Ray Burris Bruce Berenyi Bruce Hurst | 1.000 |
| 1985 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Babe Adams Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Willie Hernandez | .983 | |
Rick Reuschel Dan Petry Phil Niekro+ Charles Hudson Bert Blyleven+ Rick Rhoden Mark Gubicza Sid Fernandez Storm Davis John Denny | 1.000 |
| 1986 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Vic Albury Doyle Alexander | 1.000 | |
Willie Hernandez | .985 | |
Teddy Higuera Andy Hawkins Jose Guzman Mark Gubicza Mike Flanagan David Palmer Steve Carlton+ Bert Blyleven+ Bob Forsch Jimmy Key | 1.000 |
| 1987 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Vic Aldridge Doyle Alexander Vic Albury Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Willie Hernandez | .981 | |
Zane Smith Jack Morris Atlee Hammaker Roger Clemens Don Sutton+ Bill Gullickson Bob Forsch Doyle Alexander Don Carman Eric Bell | 1.000 |
| 1988 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .983 | |
Jimmy Jones Sid Fernandez Tim Belcher Don Carman John Farrell Teddy Higuera Mike Flanagan Richard Dotson Jose DeLeon Bruce Hurst | 1.000 |
| 1989 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Babe Adams Doyle Alexander Vic Albury Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .983 | |
Roger Clemens Bert Blyleven+ Scott Bankhead Bruce Hurst Tom Browning Dennis Rasmussen Ken Howell Tom Gordon Mike Flanagan Sid Fernandez | 1.000 |
| 1990 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Doyle Alexander Babe Adams Vic Albury Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .984 | |
Jack Armstrong Allan Anderson Greg Maddux Charlie Leibrandt Bill Gullickson Greg Hibbard Dave Stewart Ron Robinson Pat Combs Nolan Ryan+ | 1.000 |
| 1991 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Doyle Alexander Babe Adams Vic Albury Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Lee Smith | .985 | |
Rich DeLucia Oil Can Boyd Jose DeLeon Bill Krueger Tom Glavine Bill Gullickson Buddy Black Andy Benes Mike Bielecki Jack McDowell | 1.000 |
| 1992 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Jim Abbott Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .982 | |
Juan Guzman Charlie Hough Rheal Cormier Scott Kamieniecki Bill Krueger Tom Glavine Chris Bosio Jim Abbott Buddy Black Ben McDonald | 1.000 |
| 1993 | Woodie Fryman | .988 | |
Jim Abbott Babe Adams Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Doyle Alexander | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .984 | |
Dave Fleming Tim Leary Randy Johnson Alex Fernandez Greg Hibbard Kevin Gross John Burkett Jim Deshaies Doug Drabek Steve Avery | 1.000 |
| 1994 | Mark Eichhorn | .991 | |
Jim Abbott Babe Adams Vic Albury Doyle Alexander Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Mark Eichhorn | .991 | |
Charlie Hough Marvin Freeman Wilson Alvarez Mark Clark Sid Fernandez Chris Bosio Tom Candiotti Jeff Fassero Pedro Astacio Andy Benes | 1.000 |
| 1995 | Mark Eichhorn | .991 | |
Vic Albury Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Jim Abbott | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .985 | |
Kevin Appier Kevin Foster Al Leiter Sterling Hitchcock John Burkett Jim Bullinger Mark Gubicza Jim Abbott Ricky Bones Wilson Alvarez | 1.000 |
| 1996 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Babe Adams Jim Abbott | 1.000 | |
Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Shane Reynolds Mark Clark Wilson Alvarez Charles Nagy Mike Mussina Kevin Appier Brad Radke Felipe Lira Mark Gardner Chris Haney | 1.000 |
| 1997 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Bob Patterson | .990 | |
Mike Morgan Jamie Moyer Chuck Finley Roger Bailey Mark Gardner Cal Eldred Ken Hill Tim Belcher Charles Nagy Mike Mussina | 1.000 |
| 1998 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Jim Abbott Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Bob Patterson | .990 | |
Livan Hernandez Al Leiter Sterling Hitchcock Pedro Astacio Pete Harnisch Jon Lieber Mark Clark Mark Gardner Andy Benes LaTroy Hawkins | 1.000 |
| 1999 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Albury Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Jim Abbott | 1.000 | |
Paul Assenmacher | .986 | |
Todd Ritchie Hideki Irabu Dustin Hermanson Chan Ho Park Shane Reynolds Brian Moehler Hideo Nomo Brad Radke Kent Bottenfield Russ Ortiz | 1.000 |
| 2000 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Jim Abbott Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Trevor Hoffman | .987 | |
Tom Glavine Livan Hernandez Jason Bere Jeff D'Amico Pedro Astacio Orlando Hernandez Pedro Martinez Andy Benes Al Leiter Scott Elarton | 1.000 |
| 2001 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Albury Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Jim Abbott Paul Abbott | 1.000 | |
Trevor Hoffman | .989 | |
Chris Carpenter Bobby Jones Paul Abbott John Burkett Tom Glavine Livan Hernandez Jon Lieber Mike Hampton Elmer Dessens Jimmy Haynes | 1.000 |
| 2002 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Babe Adams Jim Abbott Paul Abbott Vic Albury Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Mike Trombley | .986 | |
Brandon Duckworth Ryan Dempster Jon Garland Roger Clemens Frank Castillo Tim Hudson Brian Lawrence Tom Glavine Tony Armas Kevin Appier | 1.000 |
| 2003 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Jim Abbott Babe Adams Vic Albury Vic Aldridge Paul Abbott | 1.000 | |
Jesse Orosco | .984 | |
Ryan Franklin Mark Buehrle Wayne Franklin Jon Garland Danny Graves Elmer Dessens Derek Lowe Cory Lidle Al Leiter Ted Lilly | 1.000 |
| 2004 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Aldridge Paul Abbott Jim Abbott Babe Adams Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Trevor Hoffman | .981 | |
Rodrigo Lopez Esteban Loaiza John Lackey Mark Hendrickson Cliff Lee Freddy Garcia Brian Lawrence Randy Johnson Jose Lima Kelvim Escobar | 1.000 |
| 2005 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Vic Albury Jim Abbott Paul Abbott | 1.000 | |
Shigetoshi Hasegawa | .982 | |
Tom Glavine Freddy Garcia Mike Maroth Noah Lowry Bartolo Colon Jose Lima Ryan Franklin Pedro Martinez Kyle Lohse Aaron Harang | 1.000 |
| 2006 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Vic Albury Paul Abbott Jim Abbott | 1.000 | |
Braden Looper | .982 | |
Kelvim Escobar Jeff Francis Josh Beckett Orlando Hernandez Felix Hernandez Kevin Millwood Bronson Arroyo Chris Carpenter John Lackey Greg Maddux | 1.000 |
| 2007 | Mark Eichhorn | .992 | |
Paul Abbott Jim Abbott Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Braden Looper | .986 | |
Tim Hudson Paul Byrd Matt Belisle Erik Bedard Aaron Harang Josh Fogg Matt Cain Matt Chico Joe Blanton Brian Bannister | 1.000 |
| 2008 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Babe Adams Paul Abbott Jim Abbott | 1.000 | |
Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Bronson Arroyo Kyle Lohse John Danks Braden Looper Ted Lilly Dan Haren Matt Cain Tim Lincecum Nick Blackburn Dana Eveland | 1.000 |
| 2009 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Jim Abbott Vic Aldridge Babe Adams Paul Abbott Vic Albury | 1.000 | |
Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Dan Haren Clayton Kershaw Chris Carpenter Brett Anderson Joe Blanton Matt Cain Livan Hernandez Cole Hamels Josh Johnson Jason Hammel | 1.000 |
| 2010 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Paul Abbott Jim Abbott Babe Adams Vic Albury Vic Aldridge | 1.000 | |
Mariano Rivera | .982 | |
Bronson Arroyo R.A. Dickey Jaime Garcia Shaun Marcum Mark Buehrle Brad Bergesen John Danks Phil Hughes Derek Lowe Livan Hernandez | 1.000 |
| 2011 | Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Paul Abbott Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Babe Adams Jim Abbott | 1.000 | |
Mariano Rivera | .983 | |
John Danks Chris Capuano Jeff Francis Roberto Hernandez Dan Haren Wade Davis Jeremy Hellickson Clayton Kershaw Ian Kennedy Zack Greinke | 1.000 |
| 2012 | Heath Bell Luis Vizcaino | 1.000 | |
Paul Abbott Vic Albury Jim Abbott Vic Aldridge Babe Adams | 1.000 | |
Heath Bell | 1.000 | |
Scott Diamond Hiroki Kuroda Clayton Kershaw Yu Darvish Bronson Arroyo Lucas Harrell Mark Buehrle Luke Hochevar Mat Latos Zack Greinke | 1.000 |
| 2013 | Luis Vizcaino Heath Bell | 1.000 | |
Vic Aldridge Vic Albury Babe Adams Jim Abbott Paul Abbott | 1.000 | |
Heath Bell | 1.000 | |
Homer Bailey Patrick Corbin Mat Latos Jaime Garcia Dan Haren Derek Holland Kevin Correia R.A. Dickey Marco Estrada Lucas Harrell | 1.000 |