| 1871 | | | |
Fred Treacey | .918 | |
| | |
Fred Treacey | .918 |
| 1872 | | | |
Al Reach | .943 | |
| | |
Al Reach | .943 |
| 1873 | | | |
Al Reach | .943 | |
| | |
Tom York | .872 |
| 1874 | | | |
Al Reach | .943 | |
| | |
Dave Eggler | .906 |
| 1875 | | | |
Al Reach | .943 | |
| | |
Dave Eggler | .921 |
|
| 1876 | | | |
Andy Leonard | .925 | |
| | |
Andy Leonard | .925 |
| 1877 | | | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
| | |
John Glenn | .948 |
| 1878 | | | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
| | |
Jack Remsen | .944 |
| 1879 | Tom York | .879 | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
Tom York | .879 | |
Charley Jones | .933 |
| 1880 | Tom York | .883 | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
Tom York | .883 | |
Tom York | .934 |
| 1881 | Tom York | .880 | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
Tom York | .880 | |
Joe Hornung | .948 |
| 1882 | Tom York | .880 | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
Tom York | .880 | |
Joe Hornung | .932 |
| 1883 | Dave Eggler | .899 | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
Dave Eggler | .899 | |
Joe Hornung | .936 |
| 1884 | Joe Hornung | .913 | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
Joe Hornung | .913 | |
Dave Rowe | .947 |
| 1885 | Joe Hornung | .913 | |
John Glenn | .948 | |
Joe Hornung | .913 | |
Curt Welch | .946 |
| 1886 | Joe Hornung | .918 | |
Abner Dalrymple | .953 | |
Joe Hornung | .918 | |
Abner Dalrymple | .953 |
| 1887 | Pop Corkhill | .937 | |
Abner Dalrymple | .953 | |
Pop Corkhill | .937 | |
Pop Corkhill | .952 |
| 1888 | Pop Corkhill | .942 | |
Pop Corkhill | .961 | |
Pop Corkhill | .942 | |
Pop Corkhill | .961 |
| 1889 | Pop Corkhill | .943 | |
Pop Corkhill | .961 | |
Pop Corkhill | .943 | |
Jim Fogarty | .961 |
| 1890 | Pop Corkhill | .946 | |
Jim Fogarty | .963 | |
Pop Corkhill | .946 | |
Jim Fogarty | .963 |
| 1891 | Pop Corkhill | .946 | |
Jim Fogarty | .963 | |
Pop Corkhill | .946 | |
Ed Andrews | .961 |
| 1892 | Pop Corkhill | .947 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Pop Corkhill | .947 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 |
| 1893 | Steve Brodie | .950 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Steve Brodie | .950 | |
Mike Griffin | .965 |
| 1894 | Mike Griffin | .951 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Mike Griffin | .951 | |
Sam Thompson+ | .972 |
| 1895 | Mike Griffin | .953 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Mike Griffin | .953 | |
Mike Griffin | .969 |
| 1896 | Steve Brodie | .956 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Steve Brodie | .956 | |
Sam Thompson+ | .974 |
| 1897 | Steve Brodie | .958 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Steve Brodie | .958 | |
Steve Brodie | .983 |
| 1898 | Willie Keeler+ | .958 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Willie Keeler+ | .958 | |
Mike Griffin | .974 |
| 1899 | Willie Keeler+ | .961 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Willie Keeler+ | .961 | |
Harry Blake | .979 |
| 1900 | Chick Stahl | .960 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Chick Stahl | .960 | |
Chick Stahl | .968 |
| 1901 | Willie Keeler+ | .960 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Willie Keeler+ | .960 | |
Willie Keeler+ | .985 |
| 1902 | Willie Keeler+ | .962 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Willie Keeler+ | .962 | |
Willie Keeler+ | .978 |
| 1903 | Roy Thomas | .962 | |
Mike Griffin | .986 | |
Roy Thomas | .962 | |
Fielder Jones | .985 |
| 1904 | Roy Thomas | .964 | |
Harry Bay | .987 | |
Roy Thomas | .964 | |
Harry Bay | .987 |
| 1905 | Roy Thomas | .968 | |
Sam Crawford+ | .988 | |
Roy Thomas | .968 | |
Sam Crawford+ | .988 |
| 1906 | Roy Thomas | .970 | |
Sam Crawford+ | .988 | |
Roy Thomas | .970 | |
Fielder Jones | .988 |
| 1907 | Spike Shannon | .976 | |
Ed Hahn | .990 | |
Spike Shannon | .976 | |
Ed Hahn | .990 |
| 1908 | Spike Shannon | .974 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Spike Shannon | .974 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 |
| 1909 | Frank Schulte | .976 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Frank Schulte | .976 | |
Fred Clarke+ | .987 |
| 1910 | Frank Schulte | .975 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Frank Schulte | .975 | |
Rube Oldring | .978 |
| 1911 | Tommy Leach | .975 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Tommy Leach | .975 | |
Tommy Leach | .987 |
| 1912 | Tommy Leach | .976 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Tommy Leach | .976 | |
Amos Strunk | .990 |
| 1913 | Tommy Leach | .978 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Tommy Leach | .978 | |
Tommy Leach | .990 |
| 1914 | Tommy Leach | .976 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Tommy Leach | .976 | |
Amos Strunk | .987 |
| 1915 | Amos Strunk | .978 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Amos Strunk | .978 | |
Chief Wilson | .984 |
| 1916 | Amos Strunk | .978 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Amos Strunk | .978 | |
Max Flack | .991 |
| 1917 | Amos Strunk | .979 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Amos Strunk | .979 | |
Amos Strunk | .986 |
| 1918 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Frank Schulte | .994 | |
Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Amos Strunk | .988 |
| 1919 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 |
| 1920 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Billy Southworth+ | .991 |
| 1921 | Amos Strunk | .979 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Amos Strunk | .979 | |
Max Flack | .989 |
| 1922 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Zack Wheat+ | .991 |
| 1923 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Pat Duncan | .993 |
| 1924 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Ty Cobb+ George Harper | .986 |
| 1925 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Baby Doll Jacobson | .974 | |
George Burns | .990 |
| 1926 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Baby Doll Jacobson | .974 | |
Bibb Falk | .992 |
| 1927 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Ira Flagstead | .974 | |
Dick Spalding | .992 |
| 1928 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Al Simmons+ | .976 | |
Sam West | .996 |
| 1929 | Amos Strunk | .980 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Paul Waner+ | .979 | |
Fred Schulte | .989 |
| 1930 | Lloyd Waner+ | .981 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Lloyd Waner+ | .981 | |
Rube Bressler | .995 |
| 1931 | Ethan Allen | .984 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Ethan Allen | .984 | |
Tom Oliver | .993 |
| 1932 | Ethan Allen | .983 | |
Babe Ruth+ | .996 | |
Ethan Allen | .983 | |
Wally Berger | .993 |
| 1933 | Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Dick Porter | .996 |
| 1934 | Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Wally Roettger | .986 | |
Len Koenecke | .994 |
| 1935 | Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mule Haas | .984 | |
Mel Ott+ | .990 |
| 1936 | Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Dick Porter | .996 | |
Mule Haas | .984 | |
Johnny Cooney | .994 |
| 1937 | Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Mule Haas | .984 | |
Mel Ott+ | 1.000 |
| 1938 | Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Mule Haas | .984 | |
Pete Fox | .994 |
| 1939 | Tom Oliver | .986 | |
Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Johnny Cooney | .986 | |
Terry Moore | .994 |
| 1940 | Johnny Cooney | .987 | |
Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Johnny Cooney | .987 | |
Harry Craft | .997 |
| 1941 | Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Johnny Cooney | .996 |
| 1942 | Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Danny Litwhiler Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Danny Litwhiler | 1.000 |
| 1943 | Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Danny Litwhiler Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Milt Byrnes | .997 |
| 1944 | Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Danny Litwhiler Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Johnny Cooney | .988 | |
Johnny Hopp | .997 |
| 1945 | Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Danny Litwhiler Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Andy Pafko | .995 |
| 1946 | Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Danny Litwhiler Mel Ott+ Dick Whitman | 1.000 | |
Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Dick Whitman | 1.000 |
| 1947 | Wally Judnich | .989 | |
Dick Whitman Danny Litwhiler Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Wally Judnich | .989 | |
Joe DiMaggio+ | .997 |
| 1948 | Tommy Holmes | .988 | |
Mel Ott+ Danny Litwhiler Johnny Hopp Dick Whitman | 1.000 | |
Tommy Holmes | .988 | |
Johnny Hopp | 1.000 |
| 1949 | Thurman Tucker | .988 | |
Johnny Hopp Dick Whitman Mel Ott+ Danny Litwhiler | 1.000 | |
Thurman Tucker | .988 | |
Stan Spence | .996 |
| 1950 | Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Johnny Hopp Dick Whitman Mel Ott+ Danny Litwhiler Tommy Holmes | 1.000 | |
Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Tommy Holmes | 1.000 |
| 1951 | Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Danny Litwhiler Dick Whitman Johnny Hopp Willard Marshall Mel Ott+ Tommy Holmes | 1.000 | |
Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Willard Marshall | 1.000 |
| 1952 | Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Dick Whitman Willard Marshall Tommy Holmes Mel Ott+ Danny Litwhiler Johnny Hopp | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Sid Gordon | .996 |
| 1953 | Gene Woodling | .992 | |
Willard Marshall Danny Litwhiler Bob Kennedy Johnny Hopp Dick Whitman Tommy Holmes Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .992 | |
Bob Kennedy | 1.000 |
| 1954 | Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Tommy Holmes Johnny Hopp Mel Ott+ Bob Kennedy Danny Litwhiler Willard Marshall Dick Whitman | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Jim Delsing | .996 |
| 1955 | Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Danny Litwhiler Tommy Holmes Johnny Hopp Bob Kennedy Dick Whitman Willard Marshall Mel Ott+ | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Gene Woodling | .995 |
| 1956 | Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Johnny Hopp Mel Ott+ Dick Whitman Danny Litwhiler Willard Marshall Bob Kennedy Tommy Holmes Johnny Groth | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Johnny Groth | 1.000 |
| 1957 | Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Johnny Groth Mel Ott+ Willard Marshall Dick Whitman Tommy Holmes Bob Kennedy Danny Litwhiler Johnny Hopp | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .991 | |
Charlie Maxwell | .997 |
| 1958 | Gene Woodling | .989 | |
Johnny Groth Mel Ott+ Danny Litwhiler Andy Pafko Johnny Hopp Tommy Holmes Willard Marshall Bob Kennedy Dick Whitman | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .989 | |
Andy Pafko | 1.000 |
| 1959 | Tommy Holmes | .989 | |
Tommy Holmes Dick Whitman Andy Pafko Willard Marshall Mel Ott+ Johnny Groth Johnny Hopp Bob Kennedy Danny Litwhiler | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .989 | |
Gus Bell | .996 |
| 1960 | Gene Woodling | .989 | |
Danny Litwhiler Bob Kennedy Johnny Hopp Tommy Holmes Johnny Groth Mel Ott+ Andy Pafko Dick Whitman Willard Marshall | 1.000 | |
Gene Woodling | .989 | |
Charlie Maxwell | .996 |
| 1961 | Jim Piersall | .989 | |
Mel Ott+ Bob Kennedy Tommy Holmes Johnny Groth Andy Pafko Johnny Hopp Willard Marshall Dick Whitman Danny Litwhiler Whitey Herzog+ | 1.000 | |
Jim Piersall | .989 | |
Whitey Herzog+ | 1.000 |
| 1962 | Jim Piersall | .990 | |
Mel Ott+ Johnny Hopp Tony Gonzalez Johnny Groth Whitey Herzog+ Danny Litwhiler Tommy Holmes Willard Marshall Andy Pafko Bob Kennedy | 1.000 | |
Jim Piersall | .990 | |
Tony Gonzalez Bobby Smith | 1.000 |
| 1963 | Don Demeter | .991 | |
Mel Ott+ Don Demeter Johnny Groth Willard Marshall Tony Gonzalez Johnny Hopp Bob Kennedy Tommy Holmes Danny Litwhiler Whitey Herzog+ | 1.000 | |
Don Demeter | .991 | |
Don Demeter Jim Piersall | 1.000 |
| 1964 | Don Demeter | .992 | |
Willard Marshall Bob Kennedy Don Demeter Tony Gonzalez Tommy Holmes Whitey Herzog+ Danny Litwhiler Johnny Groth Johnny Hopp | 1.000 | |
Don Demeter | .992 | |
Don Demeter | 1.000 |
| 1965 | Don Demeter | .992 | |
Rocky Colavito Tony Gonzalez Johnny Groth Danny Litwhiler Whitey Herzog+ Don Demeter Johnny Hopp Bob Kennedy Tommy Holmes | 1.000 | |
Don Demeter | .992 | |
Rocky Colavito Russ Snyder | 1.000 |
| 1966 | Don Demeter | .991 | |
Bob Kennedy Tommy Holmes Johnny Hopp Tony Gonzalez Don Demeter Johnny Groth Rocky Colavito Curt Flood Whitey Herzog+ | 1.000 | |
Don Demeter | .991 | |
Curt Flood Mickey Stanley Mickey Mantle+ | 1.000 |
| 1967 | Don Demeter | .990 | |
Don Demeter Johnny Groth Whitey Herzog+ Curt Flood Tommy Holmes Johnny Hopp Rocky Colavito Bob Kennedy Tony Gonzalez | 1.000 | |
Don Demeter | .990 | |
Ted Uhlaender | .996 |
| 1968 | Don Demeter | .990 | |
Johnny Callison Johnny Groth Don Demeter Whitey Herzog+ Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito Tony Gonzalez Curt Flood Tommy Holmes | 1.000 | |
Paul Blair | .989 | |
Ken Harrelson Mickey Stanley Johnny Callison | 1.000 |
| 1969 | Ted Uhlaender | .991 | |
Ken Berry Don Demeter Whitey Herzog+ Johnny Groth Curt Flood Ken Harrelson Rocky Colavito Johnny Callison Tony Gonzalez | 1.000 | |
Ted Uhlaender | .991 | |
Ken Berry | 1.000 |
| 1970 | Mickey Stanley | .994 | |
Whitey Herzog+ Ken Berry Ken Harrelson Johnny Groth Johnny Callison Rocky Colavito Curt Flood Tony Gonzalez Don Demeter | 1.000 | |
Mickey Stanley | .994 | |
Cleo James Mickey Stanley | 1.000 |
| 1971 | Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Rocky Colavito Don Demeter Tony Gonzalez Ken Berry Curt Flood Johnny Groth Johnny Callison Whitey Herzog+ Ken Harrelson | 1.000 | |
Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Al Kaline+ Roger Repoz Roy White Walt Williams | 1.000 |
| 1972 | Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Johnny Groth Don Demeter Curt Flood Tony Gonzalez Johnny Callison Roberto Clemente+ Rocky Colavito Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Roberto Clemente+ Willie Horton Tommy McCraw Ken Berry | 1.000 |
| 1973 | Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Johnny Groth Tony Gonzalez Curt Flood Don Demeter Roberto Clemente+ Johnny Callison Rocky Colavito Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Ken Berry | .997 |
| 1974 | Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Curt Flood Rocky Colavito Don Demeter Roberto Clemente+ Tony Gonzalez Johnny Groth Johnny Callison Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Pete Rose | .997 |
| 1975 | Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Roberto Clemente+ Curt Flood Rocky Colavito Ken Berry Johnny Callison Don Demeter Tony Gonzalez Johnny Groth | 1.000 | |
Mickey Stanley | .993 | |
Jim Rice+ | 1.000 |
| 1976 | Mickey Stanley | .992 | |
Curt Flood Don Demeter Rocky Colavito Johnny Callison Roberto Clemente+ Ken Berry Tony Gonzalez Johnny Groth | 1.000 | |
Mickey Stanley | .992 | |
Dusty Baker | .996 |
| 1977 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Tony Gonzalez Steve Brye Rocky Colavito Ken Berry Roberto Clemente+ Don Demeter Curt Flood Johnny Callison | 1.000 | |
Dwight Evans | .991 | |
Steve Brye Jay Johnstone Tom Poquette Carl Yastrzemski+ | 1.000 |
| 1978 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Ken Berry Johnny Callison Roberto Clemente+ Don Demeter Curt Flood Tony Gonzalez Steve Brye Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Pete Rose | .992 | |
Bake McBride | .996 |
| 1979 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Rocky Colavito Don Demeter Steve Brye Johnny Callison Ken Berry Roberto Clemente+ Tony Gonzalez Curt Flood | 1.000 | |
Joe Rudi | .991 | |
Terry Puhl Billy Sample | 1.000 |
| 1980 | Pete Rose | .992 | |
Ken Berry Steve Brye Johnny Callison Roberto Clemente+ Rocky Colavito Don Demeter Curt Flood Cesar Geronimo | 1.000 | |
Joe Rudi | .991 | |
Cesar Geronimo Gary Roenicke | 1.000 |
| 1981 | Terry Puhl | .995 | |
Ken Berry Johnny Callison Curt Flood Don Demeter Cesar Geronimo Steve Brye Roberto Clemente+ Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .995 | |
Dave Henderson Ken Landreaux Tito Landrum Terry Puhl Ken Singleton | 1.000 |
| 1982 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Johnny Callison Steve Brye Rocky Colavito Ken Berry Brian Downing Bobby Clark Don Demeter Roberto Clemente+ | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .994 | |
John Lowenstein Gary Woods Bobby Clark Brian Downing | 1.000 |
| 1983 | Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Don Demeter Rocky Colavito Brian Downing Johnny Callison Steve Brye Roberto Clemente+ Bobby Clark Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .994 | |
Lee Lacy | 1.000 |
| 1984 | Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Ken Berry Roberto Clemente+ Bobby Clark Johnny Callison Brian Downing Steve Brye Rocky Colavito Don Demeter | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Andy Van Slyke Brian Downing | 1.000 |
| 1985 | Brian Downing | .997 | |
Steve Brye Roberto Clemente+ Don Demeter Rocky Colavito Ken Berry Brian Downing Bobby Clark Johnny Callison | 1.000 | |
Brian Downing | .997 | |
Brett Butler | .998 |
| 1986 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Don Demeter Johnny Callison Bobby Clark Ken Berry Steve Brye Rocky Colavito Brian Downing Roberto Clemente+ | 1.000 | |
Brian Downing | .995 | |
Robin Yount+ | .997 |
| 1987 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Mark Davidson Steve Brye Roberto Clemente+ Rocky Colavito Johnny Callison Bobby Clark Don Demeter Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Brian Downing | .995 | |
Mark Davidson | 1.000 |
| 1988 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Steve Brye Don Demeter Ken Berry Bobby Clark Rocky Colavito Roberto Clemente+ Johnny Callison Mark Davidson | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Dave Gallagher John Moses | 1.000 |
| 1989 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Don Demeter Mark Davidson Ken Berry Bobby Clark Roberto Clemente+ Rocky Colavito Johnny Callison Steve Brye | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Terry Puhl | 1.000 |
| 1990 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Ken Berry Roberto Clemente+ Rocky Colavito Doug Dascenzo Don Demeter Bobby Clark Johnny Callison Mark Davidson Steve Brye | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Doug Dascenzo Stan Javier John Moses Willie Wilson | 1.000 |
| 1991 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Brett Butler Doug Dascenzo Ken Berry Roberto Clemente+ Steve Brye Bobby Clark Johnny Callison Jesse Barfield Rocky Colavito | 1.000 | |
Terry Puhl | .993 | |
Jesse Barfield Brett Butler Dave Gallagher Gerald Young | 1.000 |
| 1992 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Brett Butler Johnny Callison Roberto Clemente+ Rocky Colavito Bobby Clark Jesse Barfield Shawn Abner Ken Berry Steve Brye | 1.000 | |
Gerald Young | .992 | |
Shawn Abner Henry Cotto Darryl Hamilton Darren Lewis | 1.000 |
| 1993 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Shawn Abner Ken Berry Johnny Callison Brett Butler Roberto Clemente+ Steve Brye Jesse Barfield Bobby Clark | 1.000 | |
Dave Gallagher | .993 | |
Tim Raines Brett Butler Darren Lewis | 1.000 |
| 1994 | Darryl Hamilton | .996 | |
Brett Butler Ken Berry Steve Brye Bobby Clark Roberto Clemente+ Jesse Barfield Johnny Callison Shawn Abner | 1.000 | |
Darryl Hamilton | .996 | |
Lance Johnson Dave Martinez Milt Thompson | 1.000 |
| 1995 | Darren Lewis | .997 | |
Brett Butler Ken Berry Steve Brye Shawn Abner Jesse Barfield Johnny Callison Bobby Clark Roberto Clemente+ | 1.000 | |
Darren Lewis | .997 | |
Jim Eisenreich Stan Javier James Mouton Luis Polonia | 1.000 |
| 1996 | Darren Lewis | .996 | |
Shawn Abner Johnny Callison Rich Amaral Bobby Clark Brett Butler Steve Brye Jesse Barfield Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Darren Lewis | .996 | |
Darryl Hamilton Paul O'Neill Rich Amaral | 1.000 |
| 1997 | Darren Lewis | .996 | |
Rich Amaral Shawn Abner Brett Butler Johnny Callison Steve Brye Jesse Barfield Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Darren Lewis | .996 | |
Brett Butler Roberto Kelly F.P. Santangelo | 1.000 |
| 1998 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Rich Amaral Jesse Barfield Shawn Abner Johnny Callison Ken Berry Steve Brye Brett Butler | 1.000 | |
Darren Lewis | .995 | |
Mike Kelly | 1.000 |
| 1999 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Ken Berry Steve Brye Brett Butler Jesse Barfield Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Johnny Callison | 1.000 | |
Darren Lewis | .995 | |
Darryl Hamilton Jeffrey Hammonds B.J. Surhoff | 1.000 |
| 2000 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Jay Buhner Brett Butler Ken Berry Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Jesse Barfield Steve Brye | 1.000 | |
Darryl Hamilton | .995 | |
Bernie Williams Jay Buhner Eric Owens | 1.000 |
| 2001 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Steve Brye Jay Buhner Jesse Barfield Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Brett Butler Ken Berry | 1.000 | |
Darryl Hamilton | .995 | |
Luis Gonzalez Marquis Grissom Chris Richard Devon White | 1.000 |
| 2002 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Brett Butler Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Jesse Barfield Ken Berry Steve Brye Jay Buhner | 1.000 | |
Darin Erstad | .995 | |
Dave Roberts Rondell White Doug Glanville Brian Hunter Bobby Kielty Kenny Lofton | 1.000 |
| 2003 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Steve Brye Rich Amaral Brett Butler Ken Berry Jesse Barfield Jay Buhner Shawn Abner | 1.000 | |
Darin Erstad | .995 | |
Juan Encarnacion Geoff Jenkins Orlando Palmeiro Kerry Robinson Aaron Rowand | 1.000 |
| 2004 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Brett Butler Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Jesse Barfield Ken Berry Steve Brye Jay Buhner | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Carlos Lee | 1.000 |
| 2005 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Jay Buhner Rich Amaral Jesse Barfield Ken Berry Steve Brye Brett Butler Shawn Abner | 1.000 | |
Ichiro Suzuki | .994 | |
Frank Catalanotto Ryan Church Shawn Green Jay Payton Vernon Wells | 1.000 |
| 2006 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Jesse Barfield Ken Berry Steve Brye Jay Buhner Brett Butler Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Garret Anderson | 1.000 | |
Darin Erstad | .995 | |
Garret Anderson Endy Chavez Jason Lane Juan Pierre Dave Roberts Shane Victorino | 1.000 |
| 2007 | Brian Downing | .995 | |
Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Garret Anderson Jesse Barfield Ken Berry Steve Brye Jay Buhner Brett Butler | 1.000 | |
Darin Erstad | .995 | |
Felix Pie | 1.000 |
| 2008 | Darin Erstad | .996 | |
Jesse Barfield Ken Berry Ryan Braun Steve Brye Brian Anderson Garret Anderson Rich Amaral Shawn Abner | 1.000 | |
Darin Erstad | .996 | |
Brian Anderson Garret Anderson Ryan Braun Jacoby Ellsbury Darin Erstad Torii Hunter Mark Kotsay Jay Payton Josh Willingham | 1.000 |
| 2009 | Darin Erstad | .996 | |
Ken Berry Garret Anderson Jesse Barfield Rich Amaral Brian Anderson Jason Bay Shawn Abner Ryan Braun | 1.000 | |
Darin Erstad | .996 | |
Randy Winn Jason Bay David DeJesus Mitch Maier Grady Sizemore | 1.000 |
| 2010 | Darin Erstad | .996 | |
Garret Anderson Jesse Barfield Jason Bay Ken Berry Ryan Braun Brian Anderson Shawn Abner Rich Amaral | 1.000 | |
Shane Victorino | .995 | |
Franklin Gutierrez Tony Gwynn Reed Johnson Aaron Rowand Ryan Sweeney David DeJesus Vernon Wells Ben Zobrist | 1.000 |
| 2011 | Shane Victorino | .996 | |
Rich Amaral Brian Anderson Garret Anderson Jesse Barfield Jason Bay Ken Berry Ryan Braun Shawn Abner | 1.000 | |
Shane Victorino | .996 | |
Ryan Sweeney Shane Victorino Andre Ethier Carlos Gomez Franklin Gutierrez Nick Markakis Jacoby Ellsbury | 1.000 |
| 2012 | Jacoby Ellsbury | .996 | |
Jason Bay Ken Berry Ryan Braun Shawn Abner Rich Amaral Jesse Barfield Brian Anderson Garret Anderson | 1.000 | |
Jacoby Ellsbury | .996 | |
Craig Gentry Curtis Granderson Jon Jay Desmond Jennings Ben Revere | 1.000 |