+ - Indicates Hall of Famer. Bold indicates active player.
Statistic Description: 9 * ER / IP For recent years, leaders need 1 IP per team game played
Only players who finished in the top 40 for the majors in a season will appear on this list.
Leaders from the current season are only included for rate stats after July 1st.
For batting rate stats, generally a minimum of 3.1 Plate Appearances/G, 1.0 IP/G, 0.5 Gm and Chances/Team Game (fielding), 0.2 SB att/Team Game (catchers), and 0.1 SB att/Team Game (baserunners only since 1951), and 0.1 decision/G for single-season leaderboards generally needed for rate statistics. For pitcher fielding the minimums are reduced by a third. For LF, CF, RF fielding stats, we only have reliable data since 1954, so all leaders are since 1954. Explanation of min. requirements
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Tim Keefe+ (23) | 0.857 | 1880 | R |
| 2. | Dutch Leonard (22) | 0.961 | 1914 | L |
| 3. | Mordecai Brown+ (29) | 1.038 | 1906 | R |
| 4. | Bob Gibson+ (32) | 1.123 | 1968 | R |
| 5. | Christy Mathewson+ (28) | 1.144 | 1909 | R |
| 6. | Walter Johnson+ (25) | 1.145 | 1913 | R |
| 7. | Jack Pfiester (29) | 1.154 | 1907 | L |
| 8. | Addie Joss+ (28) | 1.163 | 1908 | R |
| 9. | Carl Lundgren (27) | 1.174 | 1907 | R |
| 10. | Denny Driscoll (26) | 1.209 | 1882 | L |
| 11. | Pete Alexander+ (28) | 1.220 | 1915 | R |
| 12. | George Bradley (23) | 1.225 | 1876 | R |
| 13. | Cy Young+ (41) | 1.264 | 1908 | R |
| 14. | Ed Walsh+ (29) | 1.266 | 1910 | R |
| 15. | Walter Johnson+ (30) | 1.270 | 1918 | R |
| 16. | Christy Mathewson+ (24) | 1.276 | 1905 | R |
| 17. | Jack Taylor (28) | 1.295 | 1902 | R |
| 18. | Guy Hecker (26) | 1.298 | 1882 | R |
| 19. | Jack Coombs (27) | 1.300 | 1910 | R |
| 20. | Mordecai Brown+ (32) | 1.313 | 1909 | R |
| 21. | Walter Johnson+ (22) | 1.362 | 1910 | R |
| 22. | George Bradley (27) | 1.378 | 1880 | R |
| 23. | Old Hoss Radbourn+ (29) | 1.379 | 1884 | R |
| 24. | Walter Johnson+ (24) | 1.390 | 1912 | R |
| 25. | Mordecai Brown+ (30) | 1.391 | 1907 | R |
| 26. | Harry Krause (20) | 1.394 | 1909 | L |
| 27. | Ed Walsh+ (28) | 1.407 | 1909 | R |
| 28. | Ed Walsh+ (27) | 1.416 | 1908 | R |
| 29. | Ed Reulbach (22) | 1.419 | 1905 | R |
| 30. | Orval Overall (28) | 1.421 | 1909 | R |
| 31. | Christy Mathewson+ (27) | 1.428 | 1908 | R |
| 32. | Fred Anderson (31) | 1.444 | 1917 | R |
| 33. | Mordecai Brown+ (31) | 1.470 | 1908 | R |
| 34. | Rube Waddell+ (28) | 1.479 | 1905 | L |
| 35. | Smoky Joe Wood (25) | 1.487 | 1915 | R |
| 36. | Walter Johnson+ (31) | 1.488 | 1919 | R |
| 37. | Jack Pfiester (28) | 1.508 | 1906 | L |
| 38. | Monte Ward+ (18) | 1.509 | 1878 | R |
| 39. | Harry McCormick (26) | 1.516 | 1882 | R |
| 40. | Doc White (27) | 1.518 | 1906 | L |
| 41. | George McQuillan (23) | 1.526 | 1908 | R |
| 42. | Dwight Gooden (20) | 1.529 | 1985 | R |
| 43. | Eddie Cicotte (33) | 1.532 | 1917 | R |
| 44. | Will White (27) | 1.538 | 1882 | R |
| 45. | Cy Morgan (31) | 1.548 | 1910 | R |
| 46. | Pete Alexander+ (29) | 1.550 | 1916 | R |
| Walter Johnson+ (27) | 1.550 | 1915 | R | |
| 48. | Howie Camnitz (26) | 1.559 | 1908 | R |
| Greg Maddux (28) | 1.559 | 1994 | R | |
| 50. | Jim Devlin (27) | 1.563 | 1876 | R |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 51. | Tim Keefe+ (28) | 1.575 | 1885 | R |
| 52. | Fred Toney (26) | 1.576 | 1915 | R |
| 53. | Eddie Cicotte (29) | 1.578 | 1913 | R |
| 54. | Rube Marquard+ (29) | 1.580 | 1916 | L |
| 55. | Chief Bender+ (26) | 1.584 | 1910 | R |
| 56. | Barney Pelty (25) | 1.588 | 1906 | R |
| 57. | Addie Joss+ (24) | 1.591 | 1904 | R |
| 58. | Ed Walsh+ (26) | 1.598 | 1907 | R |
| 59. | Luis Tiant (27) | 1.603 | 1968 | R |
| 60. | Joe McGinnity+ (33) | 1.610 | 1904 | R |
| 61. | Ray Collins (23) | 1.619 | 1910 | L |
| 62. | Rube Waddell+ (27) | 1.621 | 1904 | L |
| 63. | Howie Camnitz (27) | 1.622 | 1909 | R |
| 64. | Cy Young+ (34) | 1.624 | 1901 | R |
| 65. | Greg Maddux (29) | 1.631 | 1995 | R |
| 66. | Silver King (20) | 1.632 | 1888 | R |
| 67. | Spud Chandler (35) | 1.636 | 1943 | R |
| 68. | Ernie Shore (24) | 1.640 | 1915 | R |
| 69. | Ed Summers (23) | 1.645 | 1908 | R |
| 70. | Dean Chance (23) | 1.649 | 1964 | R |
| 71. | Walter Johnson+ (20) | 1.650 | 1908 | R |
| 72. | Ed Reulbach (23) | 1.651 | 1906 | R |
| 73. | Russ Ford (27) | 1.652 | 1910 | R |
| 74. | Chief Bender+ (25) | 1.656 | 1909 | R |
| 75. | Carl Hubbell+ (30) | 1.662 | 1933 | L |
| Sam Leever (35) | 1.662 | 1907 | R | |
| 77. | Mickey Welch+ (25) | 1.665 | 1885 | R |
| 78. | Candy Cummings+ (27) | 1.667 | 1876 | R |
| 79. | Tommy Bond (20) | 1.676 | 1876 | R |
| 80. | Orval Overall (26) | 1.677 | 1907 | R |
| 81. | Ed Reulbach (24) | 1.688 | 1907 | R |
| 82. | Claude Hendrix (25) | 1.691 | 1914 | R |
| Nolan Ryan+ (34) | 1.691 | 1981 | R | |
| 84. | Jim McCormick (21) | 1.692 | 1878 | R |
| 85. | Smoky Joe Wood (20) | 1.693 | 1910 | R |
| 86. | Bill Burns (28) | 1.701 | 1908 | L |
| Rube Foster (26) | 1.701 | 1914 | R | |
| Charlie Sweeney (21) | 1.701 | 1884 | R | |
| 89. | Addie Joss+ (29) | 1.706 | 1909 | R |
| 90. | Ed Killian (32) | 1.713 | 1909 | L |
| 91. | Ned Garvin (30) | 1.719 | 1904 | R |
| Walter Johnson+ (26) | 1.719 | 1914 | R | |
| 93. | Doc White (30) | 1.722 | 1909 | L |
| 94. | Pete Alexander+ (32) | 1.723 | 1919 | R |
| Bill Doak (23) | 1.723 | 1914 | R | |
| Addie Joss+ (26) | 1.723 | 1906 | R | |
| 97. | Sandy Koufax+ (30) | 1.728 | 1966 | L |
| 98. | Bob Ewing (34) | 1.731 | 1907 | R |
| 99. | Vic Willis+ (30) | 1.733 | 1906 | R |
| 100. | Sandy Koufax+ (28) | 1.735 | 1964 | L |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 101. | Hippo Vaughn (30) | 1.736 | 1918 | L |
| 102. | Charlie Chech (30) | 1.738 | 1908 | R |
| 103. | Monte Ward+ (20) | 1.739 | 1880 | R |
| 104. | Henry Boyle (23) | 1.740 | 1884 | R |
| 105. | Tim Keefe+ (31) | 1.741 | 1888 | R |
| 106. | Pedro Martinez (28) | 1.742 | 2000 | R |
| 107. | Ron Guidry (27) | 1.743 | 1978 | L |
| 108. | Carl Mays (25) | 1.744 | 1917 | R |
| Earl Moore (25) | 1.744 | 1903 | R | |
| 110. | Babe Ruth+ (21) | 1.752 | 1916 | L |
| 111. | Al Spalding+ (25) | 1.753 | 1876 | R |
| 112. | Fred Goldsmith (24) | 1.754 | 1880 | R |
| 113. | Henry Boyle (25) | 1.757 | 1886 | R |
| 114. | Tom Seaver+ (26) | 1.760 | 1971 | R |
| 115. | Doc White (26) | 1.763 | 1905 | L |
| 116. | Eddie Plank+ (33) | 1.764 | 1909 | L |
| 117. | Noodles Hahn (23) | 1.766 | 1902 | L |
| 118. | Bob Rhoads (28) | 1.767 | 1908 | R |
| 119. | Jack Powell (31) | 1.770 | 1906 | R |
| 120. | Mort Cooper (29) | 1.776 | 1942 | R |
| Doc White (25) | 1.776 | 1904 | L | |
| 122. | Ed Killian (30) | 1.777 | 1907 | L |
| 123. | Eddie Cicotte (32) | 1.781 | 1916 | R |
| 124. | Andy Coakley (25) | 1.782 | 1908 | R |
| Ed Reulbach (26) | 1.782 | 1909 | R | |
| 126. | Will White (23) | 1.788 | 1878 | R |
| 127. | Hippo Vaughn (31) | 1.790 | 1919 | L |
| 128. | Guy Hecker (28) | 1.798 | 1884 | R |
| 129. | Bob Rhoads (26) | 1.800 | 1906 | R |
| Frank Smith (29) | 1.800 | 1909 | R | |
| Stump Wiedman (20) | 1.800 | 1881 | R | |
| 132. | Vean Gregg (26) | 1.802 | 1911 | L |
| 133. | King Cole (24) | 1.803 | 1910 | R |
| 134. | Sam McDowell (25) | 1.807 | 1968 | L |
| 135. | Stan Coveleski+ (27) | 1.810 | 1917 | R |
| Cy Morgan (30) | 1.810 | 1909 | R | |
| Hal Newhouser+ (24) | 1.810 | 1945 | L | |
| 138. | Vida Blue (21) | 1.817 | 1971 | L |
| Dutch Ruether (25) | 1.817 | 1919 | L | |
| 140. | Russ Ford (31) | 1.819 | 1914 | R |
| 141. | Eddie Cicotte (35) | 1.820 | 1919 | R |
| 142. | Jack Chesbro+ (30) | 1.821 | 1904 | R |
| 143. | Stan Coveleski+ (28) | 1.823 | 1918 | R |
| 144. | Cy Young+ (38) | 1.824 | 1905 | R |
| 145. | Lew Richie (24) | 1.827 | 1908 | R |
| Hippo Vaughn (22) | 1.827 | 1910 | L | |
| 147. | Pete Alexander+ (30) | 1.832 | 1917 | R |
| 148. | Otto Hess (27) | 1.834 | 1906 | L |
| Addie Joss+ (27) | 1.834 | 1907 | R | |
| 150. | Andy Coakley (22) | 1.835 | 1905 | R |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 151. | Fred Toney (30) | 1.840 | 1919 | R |
| 152. | Jim McCormick (26) | 1.842 | 1883 | R |
| 153. | Jim McCormick (23) | 1.847 | 1880 | R |
| 154. | John Clarkson+ (23) | 1.849 | 1885 | R |
| 155. | Eppa Rixey+ (25) | 1.850 | 1916 | L |
| 156. | Lady Baldwin (26) | 1.857 | 1885 | L |
| 157. | Mordecai Brown+ (33) | 1.859 | 1910 | R |
| 158. | Mordecai Brown+ (27) | 1.865 | 1904 | R |
| 159. | Wilbur Cooper (24) | 1.866 | 1916 | L |
| Lefty Leifield (22) | 1.866 | 1906 | L | |
| 161. | Phil Niekro+ (28) | 1.870 | 1967 | R |
| Kaiser Wilhelm (34) | 1.870 | 1908 | R | |
| 163. | Roger Clemens (42) | 1.874 | 2005 | R |
| 164. | Ed Walsh+ (25) | 1.875 | 1906 | R |
| 165. | Tony Mullane (23) | 1.877 | 1882 | |
| 166. | Clark Griffith+ (28) | 1.879 | 1898 | R |
| 167. | Joe Horlen (26) | 1.880 | 1964 | R |
| 168. | Sandy Koufax+ (27) | 1.881 | 1963 | L |
| Joe Lake (28) | 1.881 | 1909 | R | |
| 170. | Nick Altrock (28) | 1.882 | 1905 | L |
| 171. | Pol Perritt (25) | 1.884 | 1917 | R |
| 172. | Harry Howell (31) | 1.887 | 1908 | R |
| 173. | Rube Waddell+ (31) | 1.890 | 1908 | L |
| 174. | Kevin Brown (31) | 1.893 | 1996 | R |
| 175. | Christy Mathewson+ (29) | 1.894 | 1910 | R |
| 176. | Bill James (22) | 1.896 | 1914 | R |
| Ben Sanders (23) | 1.896 | 1888 | R | |
| 178. | Max Lanier (27) | 1.898 | 1943 | L |
| 179. | Walter Johnson+ (23) | 1.899 | 1911 | R |
| Walter Johnson+ (28) | 1.899 | 1916 | R | |
| 181. | Art Fromme (25) | 1.901 | 1909 | R |
| 182. | Pedro Martinez (25) | 1.902 | 1997 | R |
| Jim Scott (25) | 1.902 | 1913 | R | |
| 184. | Reb Russell (24) | 1.904 | 1913 | L |
| 185. | Jake Weimer (30) | 1.906 | 1904 | L |
| 186. | Pete Alexander+ (33) | 1.907 | 1920 | R |
| 187. | Charley Hall (25) | 1.908 | 1910 | R |
| Willie Mitchell (23) | 1.908 | 1913 | L | |
| 189. | Smoky Joe Wood (22) | 1.910 | 1912 | R |
| 190. | Charlie Buffinton (27) | 1.911 | 1888 | R |
| Luis Tiant (31) | 1.911 | 1972 | R | |
| 192. | Ed Siever (27) | 1.912 | 1902 | L |
| 193. | Wilbur Wood (29) | 1.913 | 1971 | L |
| 194. | Earl Moseley (27) | 1.914 | 1915 | R |
| 195. | Bill Burns (29) | 1.916 | 1909 | L |
| 196. | Gaylord Perry+ (33) | 1.917 | 1972 | R |
| Jeff Pfeffer (28) | 1.917 | 1916 | R | |
| 198. | Orval Overall (27) | 1.920 | 1908 | R |
| 199. | Larry Cheney (30) | 1.921 | 1916 | R |
| 200. | Red Faber+ (28) | 1.923 | 1917 | R |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 201. | Mickey Welch+ (28) | 1.926 | 1888 | R |
| 202. | Cy Young+ (25) | 1.927 | 1892 | R |
| 203. | Dolf Luque (32) | 1.929 | 1923 | R |
| 204. | Roger Clemens (27) | 1.931 | 1990 | R |
| John Tudor (31) | 1.931 | 1985 | L | |
| 206. | Harry Howell (30) | 1.935 | 1907 | R |
| 207. | Hal Newhouser+ (25) | 1.937 | 1946 | L |
| 208. | Allan Sothoron (25) | 1.938 | 1918 | R |
| 209. | Eddie Cicotte (25) | 1.940 | 1909 | R |
| 210. | Frank Owen (24) | 1.943 | 1904 | R |
| 211. | Ray Caldwell (26) | 1.944 | 1914 | R |
| 212. | Dave McNally (25) | 1.945 | 1968 | L |
| 213. | Larry Corcoran (20) | 1.947 | 1880 | R |
| 214. | Larry Corcoran (22) | 1.948 | 1882 | R |
| Jesse Tannehill (27) | 1.948 | 1902 | L | |
| 216. | Reb Russell (28) | 1.949 | 1917 | L |
| 217. | Sam Weaver (22) | 1.950 | 1878 | R |
| 218. | Billy Rhines (21) | 1.951 | 1890 | R |
| 219. | Ferdie Schupp (26) | 1.952 | 1917 | L |
| 220. | Fred Olmstead (28) | 1.953 | 1910 | R |
| 221. | Pretzels Getzien (20) | 1.955 | 1884 | R |
| Denny McLain (24) | 1.955 | 1968 | R | |
| 223. | Tommy Bond (23) | 1.961 | 1879 | R |
| 224. | Jeff Tesreau (24) | 1.963 | 1912 | R |
| 225. | Cy Young+ (37) | 1.966 | 1904 | R |
| 226. | Carl Lundgren (22) | 1.969 | 1902 | R |
| Billy Pierce (28) | 1.969 | 1955 | L | |
| 228. | Harry Coveleski (30) | 1.970 | 1916 | L |
| 229. | Jeff Pfeffer (26) | 1.971 | 1914 | R |
| 230. | Perry Werden (22) | 1.974 | 1884 | R |
| 231. | Steve Carlton+ (27) | 1.975 | 1972 | L |
| 232. | Scott Perry (27) | 1.977 | 1918 | R |
| 233. | Harry Howell (28) | 1.978 | 1905 | R |
| 234. | Charlie Ferguson (23) | 1.979 | 1886 | R |
| Tommy John (25) | 1.979 | 1968 | L | |
| Gary Peters (29) | 1.979 | 1966 | L | |
| 237. | Babe Adams (37) | 1.982 | 1919 | R |
| 238. | Will White (24) | 1.985 | 1879 | R |
| 239. | Bobby Bolin (29) | 1.987 | 1968 | R |
| 240. | Cy Young+ (40) | 1.992 | 1907 | R |
| 241. | Jim Bagby (27) | 1.993 | 1917 | R |
| Christy Mathewson+ (30) | 1.993 | 1911 | R | |
| 243. | Pud Galvin+ (27) | 1.994 | 1884 | R |
| Gary Nolan (24) | 1.994 | 1972 | R | |
| Jack Taylor (32) | 1.994 | 1906 | R | |
| 246. | Christy Mathewson+ (26) | 2.000 | 1907 | R |
| Jack Pfiester (30) | 2.000 | 1908 | L | |
| 248. | Tully Sparks (32) | 2.004 | 1907 | R |
| 249. | Lefty Tyler (28) | 2.005 | 1918 | L |
| Lon Warneke (24) | 2.005 | 1933 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| Hooks Wiltse (29) | 2.005 | 1909 | L | |
| 252. | Harry Gaspar (26) | 2.008 | 1909 | R |
| Charlie Hodnett (23) | 2.008 | 1884 | ||
| 254. | Hippo Vaughn (29) | 2.009 | 1917 | L |
| 255. | Whitey Ford+ (29) | 2.011 | 1958 | L |
| 256. | Eddie Plank+ (34) | 2.013 | 1910 | L |
| Babe Ruth+ (22) | 2.013 | 1917 | L | |
| Ed Seward (21) | 2.013 | 1888 | R | |
| Doc Watson (29) | 2.013 | 1914 | L | |
| 260. | Addie Joss+ (25) | 2.014 | 1905 | R |
| 261. | Red Faber+ (27) | 2.016 | 1916 | R |
| Kid Nichols+ (34) | 2.016 | 1904 | R | |
| 263. | Al Benton (34) | 2.019 | 1945 | R |
| 264. | Lefty Tyler (26) | 2.021 | 1916 | L |
| 265. | Bob Wicker (27) | 2.022 | 1905 | R |
| 266. | Smoky Joe Wood (21) | 2.024 | 1911 | R |
| 267. | Bugs Raymond (26) | 2.026 | 1908 | R |
| Ed Reulbach (25) | 2.026 | 1908 | R | |
| Frank Smith (28) | 2.026 | 1908 | R | |
| 270. | Phil Douglas (29) | 2.028 | 1919 | R |
| Orel Hershiser (26) | 2.028 | 1985 | R | |
| 272. | Adonis Terry (23) | 2.031 | 1888 | R |
| 273. | Christy Mathewson+ (23) | 2.032 | 1904 | R |
| 274. | Ed Karger (24) | 2.035 | 1907 | L |
| Jim Scott (27) | 2.035 | 1915 | R | |
| 276. | Eddie Cicotte (30) | 2.038 | 1914 | R |
| Sandy Koufax+ (29) | 2.038 | 1965 | L | |
| Al Mamaux (21) | 2.038 | 1915 | R | |
| 279. | Catfish Hunter+ (26) | 2.042 | 1972 | R |
| 280. | Roger Clemens (34) | 2.045 | 1997 | R |
| Jesse Tannehill (29) | 2.045 | 1904 | L | |
| 282. | Buttons Briggs (28) | 2.047 | 1904 | R |
| 283. | Nick Cullop (28) | 2.048 | 1916 | L |
| 284. | Old Hoss Radbourn+ (28) | 2.050 | 1883 | R |
| 285. | Deacon Phillippe (30) | 2.051 | 1902 | R |
| Dave Righetti (22) | 2.051 | 1981 | L | |
| 287. | Chief Bender+ (23) | 2.052 | 1907 | R |
| Rube Waddell+ (25) | 2.052 | 1902 | L | |
| 289. | Patsy Flaherty (28) | 2.053 | 1904 | L |
| Hippo Vaughn (26) | 2.053 | 1914 | L | |
| 291. | Stan Bahnsen (23) | 2.054 | 1968 | R |
| Bob Veale (32) | 2.054 | 1968 | L | |
| 293. | Glenn Liebhardt (24) | 2.055 | 1907 | R |
| 294. | Noodles Hahn (25) | 2.056 | 1904 | L |
| Slim Sallee (34) | 2.056 | 1919 | L | |
| 296. | Sam Leever (31) | 2.057 | 1903 | R |
| 297. | Lefty Grove+ (31) | 2.058 | 1931 | L |
| Joe Horlen (29) | 2.058 | 1967 | R | |
| 299. | Christy Mathewson+ (32) | 2.059 | 1913 | R |
| Nap Rucker (22) | 2.059 | 1907 | L | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 301. | Tommy Bond (22) | 2.061 | 1878 | R |
| 302. | Allie Reynolds (35) | 2.063 | 1952 | R |
| 303. | Nick Altrock (29) | 2.065 | 1906 | L |
| 304. | Pedro Martinez (27) | 2.067 | 1999 | R |
| Jim Palmer+ (26) | 2.067 | 1972 | R | |
| 306. | Carl Weilman (29) | 2.068 | 1919 | L |
| Vic Willis+ (32) | 2.068 | 1908 | R | |
| 308. | George Winter (29) | 2.069 | 1907 | R |
| 309. | Bob Caruthers (21) | 2.071 | 1885 | R |
| 310. | Bill Sowders (23) | 2.073 | 1888 | R |
| 311. | Bill Donovan (31) | 2.077 | 1908 | R |
| Roger Nelson (28) | 2.077 | 1972 | R | |
| Pat Ragan (30) | 2.077 | 1916 | R | |
| Bill Swift (30) | 2.077 | 1992 | R | |
| Carl Weilman (24) | 2.077 | 1914 | L | |
| 316. | Nap Rucker (23) | 2.079 | 1908 | L |
| Tom Seaver+ (28) | 2.079 | 1973 | R | |
| Don Sutton+ (27) | 2.079 | 1972 | R | |
| 319. | Eddie Plank+ (39) | 2.080 | 1915 | L |
| 320. | Cy Young+ (36) | 2.081 | 1903 | R |
| 321. | Jerry Koosman (25) | 2.082 | 1968 | L |
| 322. | Mike O'Neill (26) | 2.086 | 1904 | L |
| 323. | Dazzy Vance+ (37) | 2.087 | 1928 | R |
| 324. | Jim Whitney (26) | 2.089 | 1884 | R |
| 325. | Jim Palmer+ (29) | 2.090 | 1975 | R |
| Will White (28) | 2.090 | 1883 | R | |
| 327. | Bill James (30) | 2.091 | 1917 | R |
| Frank Smith (24) | 2.091 | 1904 | R | |
| 329. | Mordecai Brown+ (38) | 2.094 | 1915 | R |
| 330. | Ned Garvin (28) | 2.095 | 1902 | R |
| 331. | Ted Lyons+ (41) | 2.096 | 1942 | R |
| Ed Poole (27) | 2.096 | 1902 | R | |
| 333. | Spud Chandler (38) | 2.098 | 1946 | R |
| Carl Mays (27) | 2.098 | 1919 | R | |
| Jeff Pfeffer (27) | 2.098 | 1915 | R | |
| Howie Pollet (25) | 2.098 | 1946 | L | |
| 337. | Lefty Leifield (24) | 2.099 | 1908 | L |
| Billy Taylor (29) | 2.099 | 1884 | R | |
| 339. | Warren Spahn+ (32) | 2.100 | 1953 | L |
| 340. | Bill Dinneen (32) | 2.102 | 1908 | R |
| Sam Leever (36) | 2.102 | 1908 | R | |
| Juan Marichal+ (31) | 2.102 | 1969 | R | |
| Earl Moore (31) | 2.102 | 1909 | R | |
| Frank Owen (25) | 2.102 | 1905 | R | |
| 345. | Al Maul (32) | 2.103 | 1898 | R |
| Dave Roberts (26) | 2.103 | 1971 | L | |
| 347. | Eddie Plank+ (35) | 2.104 | 1911 | L |
| Slim Sallee (29) | 2.104 | 1914 | L | |
| Pete Schneider (21) | 2.104 | 1917 | R | |
| 350. | Frank Corridon (28) | 2.105 | 1909 | R |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| Old Hoss Radbourn+ (27) | 2.105 | 1882 | R | |
| 352. | Dick Ellsworth (23) | 2.106 | 1963 | L |
| 353. | Tommy Bond (21) | 2.107 | 1877 | R |
| Wilbur Cooper (26) | 2.107 | 1918 | L | |
| Dave Foutz (29) | 2.107 | 1886 | R | |
| 356. | Ray Fisher (27) | 2.108 | 1915 | R |
| 357. | Jack Powell (33) | 2.109 | 1908 | R |
| Jack Powell (34) | 2.109 | 1909 | R | |
| 359. | Bullet Joe Bush (25) | 2.112 | 1918 | R |
| 360. | Harry Howell (29) | 2.114 | 1906 | R |
| 361. | Joe Benz (29) | 2.115 | 1915 | R |
| Rube Foster (27) | 2.115 | 1915 | R | |
| 363. | Lew Brockett (28) | 2.118 | 1909 | R |
| Johnny Lush (22) | 2.118 | 1908 | L | |
| Christy Mathewson+ (21) | 2.118 | 1902 | R | |
| 366. | Bill Bernhard (32) | 2.119 | 1903 | R |
| Tom Hughes (31) | 2.119 | 1915 | R | |
| Christy Mathewson+ (31) | 2.119 | 1912 | R | |
| 369. | Dizzy Trout (29) | 2.120 | 1944 | R |
| 370. | Heinie Berger (26) | 2.122 | 1908 | R |
| 371. | Steve Blass (26) | 2.124 | 1968 | R |
| Roger Wolff (34) | 2.124 | 1945 | R | |
| 373. | Dutch Leonard (36) | 2.125 | 1945 | R |
| 374. | Wilbur Cooper (22) | 2.126 | 1914 | L |
| Phil Douglas (28) | 2.126 | 1918 | R | |
| 376. | Monte Ward+ (21) | 2.127 | 1881 | R |
| 377. | Frank Smith (25) | 2.129 | 1905 | R |
| 378. | Doc White (24) | 2.130 | 1903 | L |
| 379. | Johnny Beazley (24) | 2.132 | 1942 | R |
| Mickey Hughes (21) | 2.132 | 1888 | R | |
| 381. | Bill Bernhard (33) | 2.133 | 1904 | R |
| Burleigh Grimes+ (24) | 2.133 | 1918 | R | |
| Juan Marichal+ (27) | 2.133 | 1965 | R | |
| 384. | Whitey Ford+ (35) | 2.134 | 1964 | L |
| Kid Nichols+ (28) | 2.134 | 1898 | R | |
| 386. | John Clarkson+ (22) | 2.136 | 1884 | R |
| 387. | Terry Larkin (21) | 2.138 | 1877 | R |
| Bobby Mitchell (22) | 2.138 | 1878 | L | |
| Guy Morton (22) | 2.138 | 1915 | R | |
| 390. | Will White (25) | 2.140 | 1880 | R |
| 391. | Joe Boehling (22) | 2.142 | 1913 | L |
| 392. | Buttons Briggs (29) | 2.143 | 1905 | R |
| 393. | Jack Manning (22) | 2.144 | 1876 | R |
| George McQuillan (24) | 2.144 | 1909 | R | |
| 395. | Don Drysdale+ (31) | 2.146 | 1968 | R |
| 396. | Charlie Buffinton (23) | 2.147 | 1884 | R |
| Monte Ward+ (19) | 2.147 | 1879 | R | |
| 398. | Lee Richmond (23) | 2.148 | 1880 | L |
| 399. | Bill Bernhard (31) | 2.150 | 1902 | R |
| Howie Camnitz (25) | 2.150 | 1907 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| Rube Waddell+ (30) | 2.150 | 1907 | L | |
| 402. | Babe Adams (31) | 2.152 | 1913 | R |
| Carl Weilman (26) | 2.152 | 1916 | L | |
| 404. | Vern Law (35) | 2.153 | 1965 | R |
| Ed Walsh+ (31) | 2.153 | 1912 | R | |
| Cy Young+ (35) | 2.153 | 1902 | R | |
| 407. | Babe Adams (38) | 2.156 | 1920 | R |
| 408. | Hal Schumacher (22) | 2.157 | 1933 | R |
| 409. | Zack Greinke (25) | 2.158 | 2009 | R |
| 410. | Red Ames (24) | 2.160 | 1907 | R |
| Art Nehf (24) | 2.160 | 1917 | L | |
| Tully Sparks (31) | 2.160 | 1906 | R | |
| Dazzy Vance+ (33) | 2.160 | 1924 | R | |
| 414. | Bret Saberhagen (25) | 2.161 | 1989 | R |
| 415. | Chief Bender+ (27) | 2.163 | 1911 | R |
| Dick Rudolph (28) | 2.163 | 1916 | R | |
| Ed Siever (32) | 2.163 | 1907 | L | |
| Bob Tewksbury (31) | 2.163 | 1992 | R | |
| 419. | Casey Patten (32) | 2.165 | 1906 | L |
| 420. | Eddie Plank+ (28) | 2.166 | 1904 | L |
| 421. | Doc Ayers (26) | 2.167 | 1917 | R |
| Sam Leever (32) | 2.167 | 1904 | R | |
| 423. | Ray Fisher (31) | 2.168 | 1919 | R |
| 424. | Mordecai Brown+ (28) | 2.169 | 1905 | R |
| Jack Chesbro+ (28) | 2.169 | 1902 | R | |
| 426. | Eddie Plank+ (32) | 2.170 | 1908 | L |
| Slim Sallee (32) | 2.170 | 1917 | L | |
| Jeff Tesreau (25) | 2.170 | 1913 | R | |
| 429. | Steve Carlton+ (24) | 2.171 | 1969 | L |
| Dutch Leonard (25) | 2.171 | 1917 | L | |
| Mike Paul (27) | 2.171 | 1972 | L | |
| Dick Rudolph (31) | 2.171 | 1919 | R | |
| 433. | Guy Hecker (29) | 2.175 | 1885 | R |
| Hooks Wiltse (27) | 2.175 | 1907 | L | |
| 435. | Harry Harper (23) | 2.176 | 1918 | L |
| Sam McDowell (22) | 2.176 | 1965 | L | |
| Jesse Tannehill (26) | 2.176 | 1901 | L | |
| 438. | Dave Foutz (27) | 2.177 | 1884 | R |
| Joe Magrane (23) | 2.177 | 1988 | L | |
| 440. | Bob Gibson+ (33) | 2.178 | 1969 | R |
| Ed Morris (21) | 2.178 | 1884 | L | |
| 442. | Slim Sallee (31) | 2.180 | 1916 | L |
| 443. | Bob Feller+ (27) | 2.181 | 1946 | R |
| George Mogridge (29) | 2.181 | 1918 | L | |
| 445. | Bob Knepper (27) | 2.183 | 1981 | L |
| Greg Maddux (26) | 2.183 | 1992 | R | |
| 447. | Tully Sparks (30) | 2.184 | 1905 | R |
| 448. | Frank Arellanes (27) | 2.185 | 1909 | R |
| Don Drysdale+ (27) | 2.185 | 1964 | R | |
| Willie Mitchell (27) | 2.185 | 1917 | L | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| Smoky Joe Wood (19) | 2.185 | 1909 | R | |
| 452. | Dummy Taylor (27) | 2.186 | 1902 | R |
| 453. | Tony Mullane (24) | 2.188 | 1883 | |
| 454. | Addie Joss+ (23) | 2.189 | 1903 | R |
| 455. | Hoyt Wilhelm+ (36) | 2.190 | 1959 | R |
| 456. | Dick Bosman (25) | 2.192 | 1969 | R |
| Ice Box Chamberlain (20) | 2.192 | 1888 | R | |
| Bill Donovan (30) | 2.192 | 1907 | R | |
| Harry Howell (27) | 2.192 | 1904 | R | |
| 460. | Deacon Phillippe (33) | 2.194 | 1905 | R |
| 461. | Vic Willis+ (26) | 2.195 | 1902 | R |
| 462. | Jack Chesbro+ (31) | 2.196 | 1905 | R |
| 463. | Dummy Taylor (31) | 2.197 | 1906 | R |
| 464. | Glenn Liebhardt (25) | 2.198 | 1908 | R |
| George McConnell (37) | 2.198 | 1915 | R | |
| 466. | Bill Dinneen (28) | 2.199 | 1904 | R |
| Fred Toney (28) | 2.199 | 1917 | R | |
| 468. | Dave Davenport (25) | 2.200 | 1915 | R |
| Eddie Plank+ (31) | 2.200 | 1907 | L | |
| Allan Sothoron (26) | 2.200 | 1919 | R | |
| 471. | George Derby (23) | 2.201 | 1881 | R |
| Old Hoss Radbourn+ (30) | 2.201 | 1885 | R | |
| Tom Seaver+ (23) | 2.201 | 1968 | R | |
| 474. | Chris Short (26) | 2.202 | 1964 | L |
| 475. | Joe Lake (29) | 2.204 | 1910 | R |
| Don Sutton+ (35) | 2.204 | 1980 | R | |
| Hippo Vaughn (28) | 2.204 | 1916 | L | |
| 478. | Greg Maddux (31) | 2.205 | 1997 | R |
| 479. | Chief Bender+ (29) | 2.206 | 1913 | R |
| Tom Seaver+ (24) | 2.206 | 1969 | R | |
| 481. | Bob Ewing (35) | 2.207 | 1908 | R |
| Nap Rucker (27) | 2.207 | 1912 | L | |
| 483. | Hank Aguirre (31) | 2.208 | 1962 | L |
| Johnny Sain (28) | 2.208 | 1946 | R | |
| 485. | Ed Daily (22) | 2.209 | 1885 | R |
| Al Demaree (28) | 2.209 | 1913 | R | |
| Norwood Gibson (27) | 2.209 | 1904 | R | |
| Walter Johnson+ (29) | 2.209 | 1917 | R | |
| Carl Mays (26) | 2.209 | 1918 | R | |
| 490. | Carl Lundgren (26) | 2.210 | 1906 | R |
| 491. | Rube Waddell+ (29) | 2.211 | 1906 | L |
| 492. | Bob Shawkey (25) | 2.212 | 1916 | R |
| 493. | Danny Darwin (34) | 2.213 | 1990 | R |
| Nick Maddox (22) | 2.213 | 1909 | R | |
| 495. | Doc Ayers (24) | 2.215 | 1915 | R |
| Tom Hughes (29) | 2.215 | 1908 | R | |
| Rube Vickers (30) | 2.215 | 1908 | R | |
| 498. | Jake Weimer (32) | 2.216 | 1906 | L |
| 499. | Mike Cuellar (29) | 2.217 | 1966 | L |
| Cy Falkenberg (33) | 2.217 | 1913 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| Walter Johnson+ (21) | 2.217 | 1909 | R |
Note that seasons prior to 1876 are not included in single-season marks, but are included in career marks.