The Baseball-Reference.com Play Index's Batting Season Finder lets you create your own custom leaderboards by team, age, position, years, or any other common criteria. View Sample Leaderboards created with the batting season finder.
+ - Indicates Hall of Famer. Bold indicates active player.
Only players who finished in the top 40 for the majors in a season will appear on this list. Leaders from the current season are only included for rate stats after July 1st.
Minimum of 3.1 PA/G, 1.0 IP/G, and 0.1 decision/G for single-season leaderboards generally needed for rate statistics. Explanation of min. requirements
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Tim Keefe+ (23) | 0.8571 | 1880 | R |
| 2. | Dutch Leonard (22) | 0.9614 | 1914 | L |
| 3. | Mordecai Brown+ (29) | 1.0385 | 1906 | R |
| 4. | Bob Gibson+ (32) | 1.1225 | 1968 | R |
| 5. | Christy Mathewson+ (28) | 1.1441 | 1909 | R |
| 6. | Walter Johnson+ (25) | 1.1445 | 1913 | R |
| 7. | Jack Pfiester (29) | 1.1538 | 1907 | L |
| 8. | Addie Joss+ (28) | 1.1631 | 1908 | R |
| 9. | Carl Lundgren (27) | 1.1739 | 1907 | R |
| 10. | Denny Driscoll (26) | 1.2090 | 1882 | L |
| 11. | Pete Alexander+ (28) | 1.2197 | 1915 | R |
| 12. | George Bradley (23) | 1.2251 | 1876 | R |
| 13. | Cy Young+ (41) | 1.2642 | 1908 | R |
| 14. | Ed Walsh+ (29) | 1.2660 | 1910 | R |
| 15. | Walter Johnson+ (30) | 1.2699 | 1918 | R |
| 16. | Christy Mathewson+ (24) | 1.2756 | 1905 | R |
| 17. | Guy Hecker (26) | 1.2981 | 1882 | R |
| 18. | Jack Coombs (27) | 1.3003 | 1910 | R |
| 19. | Mordecai Brown+ (32) | 1.3132 | 1909 | R |
| 20. | Jack Taylor (28) | 1.3306 | 1902 | R |
| 21. | Walter Johnson+ (22) | 1.3622 | 1910 | R |
| 22. | George Bradley (27) | 1.3776 | 1880 | R |
| 23. | Charley Radbourn+ (29) | 1.3792 | 1884 | R |
| 24. | Walter Johnson+ (24) | 1.3902 | 1912 | R |
| 25. | Mordecai Brown+ (30) | 1.3906 | 1907 | R |
| 26. | Harry Krause (20) | 1.3944 | 1909 | L |
| 27. | Ed Walsh+ (28) | 1.4067 | 1909 | R |
| 28. | Ed Walsh+ (27) | 1.4160 | 1908 | R |
| 29. | Ed Reulbach (22) | 1.4194 | 1905 | R |
| 30. | Orval Overall (28) | 1.4210 | 1909 | R |
| 31. | Christy Mathewson+ (27) | 1.4283 | 1908 | R |
| 32. | Fred Anderson (31) | 1.4444 | 1917 | R |
| 33. | Mordecai Brown+ (31) | 1.4696 | 1908 | R |
| 34. | Rube Waddell+ (28) | 1.4787 | 1905 | L |
| 35. | Joe Wood (25) | 1.4873 | 1915 | R |
| 36. | Walter Johnson+ (31) | 1.4879 | 1919 | R |
| 37. | Jack Pfiester (28) | 1.5080 | 1906 | L |
| 38. | John Ward+ (18) | 1.5090 | 1878 | R |
| 39. | Harry McCormick (26) | 1.5159 | 1882 | R |
| 40. | Doc White (27) | 1.5182 | 1906 | L |
| 41. | George McQuillan (23) | 1.5264 | 1908 | R |
| 42. | Dwight Gooden (20) | 1.5289 | 1985 | R |
| 43. | Eddie Cicotte (33) | 1.5317 | 1917 | R |
| 44. | Will White (27) | 1.5375 | 1882 | R |
| 45. | Cy Morgan (31) | 1.5482 | 1910 | R |
| 46. | Pete Alexander+ (29) | 1.5501 | 1916 | R |
| 47. | Walter Johnson+ (27) | 1.5505 | 1915 | R |
| 48. | Howie Camnitz (26) | 1.5592 | 1908 | R |
| 49. | Greg Maddux (28) | 1.5594 | 1994 | R |
| 50. | Jim Devlin (27) | 1.5627 | 1876 | R |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 51. | Tim Keefe+ (28) | 1.5750 | 1885 | R |
| 52. | Fred Toney (26) | 1.5764 | 1915 | R |
| 53. | Eddie Cicotte (29) | 1.5784 | 1913 | R |
| 54. | Rube Marquard+ (29) | 1.5805 | 1916 | L |
| 55. | Chief Bender+ (26) | 1.5840 | 1910 | R |
| 56. | Barney Pelty (25) | 1.5882 | 1906 | R |
| 57. | Addie Joss+ (24) | 1.5910 | 1904 | R |
| 58. | Ed Walsh+ (26) | 1.5983 | 1907 | R |
| 59. | Luis Tiant (27) | 1.6026 | 1968 | R |
| 60. | Joe McGinnity+ (33) | 1.6103 | 1904 | R |
| 61. | Ray Collins (23) | 1.6185 | 1910 | L |
| 62. | Rube Waddell+ (27) | 1.6214 | 1904 | L |
| 63. | Howie Camnitz (27) | 1.6219 | 1909 | R |
| 64. | Cy Young+ (34) | 1.6239 | 1901 | R |
| 65. | Greg Maddux (29) | 1.6312 | 1995 | R |
| 66. | Spud Chandler (35) | 1.6364 | 1943 | R |
| 67. | Ernie Shore (24) | 1.6397 | 1915 | R |
| 68. | Silver King (20) | 1.6443 | 1888 | R |
| 69. | Ed Summers (23) | 1.6445 | 1908 | R |
| 70. | Dean Chance (23) | 1.6491 | 1964 | R |
| 71. | Walter Johnson+ (20) | 1.6502 | 1908 | R |
| 72. | Ed Reulbach (23) | 1.6514 | 1906 | R |
| 73. | Russ Ford (27) | 1.6518 | 1910 | R |
| 74. | Chief Bender+ (25) | 1.6560 | 1909 | R |
| 75. | Sam Leever (35) | 1.6615 | 1907 | R |
| 76. | Carl Hubbell+ (30) | 1.6620 | 1933 | L |
| 77. | Mickey Welch+ (25) | 1.6646 | 1885 | R |
| 78. | Candy Cummings+ (27) | 1.6667 | 1876 | R |
| 79. | Joe Wood (20) | 1.6762 | 1910 | R |
| 80. | Tommy Bond (20) | 1.6765 | 1876 | R |
| 81. | Orval Overall (26) | 1.6770 | 1907 | R |
| 82. | Ed Reulbach (24) | 1.6875 | 1907 | R |
| 83. | Claude Hendrix (25) | 1.6906 | 1914 | R |
| 84. | Bill Burns (28) | 1.6909 | 1908 | L |
| 85. | Nolan Ryan+ (34) | 1.6913 | 1981 | R |
| 86. | Jim McCormick (21) | 1.6923 | 1878 | R |
| 87. | Rube Foster (26) | 1.7008 | 1914 | R |
| 88. | Charlie Sweeney (21) | 1.7012 | 1884 | R |
| 89. | Addie Joss+ (29) | 1.7060 | 1909 | R |
| 90. | Ed Killian (32) | 1.7135 | 1909 | L |
| 91. | Walter Johnson+ (26) | 1.7193 | 1914 | R |
| 92. | Ned Garvin (30) | 1.7194 | 1904 | R |
| 93. | Doc White (30) | 1.7223 | 1909 | L |
| 94. | Bill Doak (23) | 1.7227 | 1914 | R |
| 95. | Pete Alexander+ (32) | 1.7234 | 1919 | R |
| Addie Joss+ (26) | 1.7234 | 1906 | R | |
| 97. | Sandy Koufax+ (30) | 1.7276 | 1966 | L |
| 98. | Bob Ewing (34) | 1.7315 | 1907 | R |
| 99. | Vic Willis+ (30) | 1.7329 | 1906 | R |
| 100. | Sandy Koufax+ (28) | 1.7354 | 1964 | L |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 101. | Hippo Vaughn (30) | 1.7359 | 1918 | L |
| 102. | Charlie Chech (30) | 1.7384 | 1908 | R |
| 103. | John Ward+ (20) | 1.7395 | 1880 | R |
| 104. | Henry Boyle (23) | 1.7400 | 1884 | R |
| 105. | Tim Keefe+ (31) | 1.7406 | 1888 | R |
| 106. | Pedro Martinez (28) | 1.7419 | 2000 | R |
| 107. | Ron Guidry (27) | 1.7430 | 1978 | L |
| 108. | Carl Mays (25) | 1.7439 | 1917 | R |
| 109. | Earl Moore (23) | 1.7443 | 1903 | R |
| 110. | Babe Ruth+ (21) | 1.7518 | 1916 | L |
| 111. | Al Spalding+ (25) | 1.7535 | 1876 | R |
| 112. | Fred Goldsmith (24) | 1.7544 | 1880 | R |
| 113. | Henry Boyle (25) | 1.7571 | 1886 | R |
| 114. | Tom Seaver+ (26) | 1.7602 | 1971 | R |
| 115. | Doc White (26) | 1.7631 | 1905 | L |
| 116. | Eddie Plank+ (33) | 1.7638 | 1909 | L |
| 117. | Noodles Hahn (23) | 1.7664 | 1902 | L |
| 118. | Bob Rhoads (28) | 1.7667 | 1908 | R |
| 119. | Jack Powell (31) | 1.7705 | 1906 | R |
| 120. | Mort Cooper (29) | 1.7763 | 1942 | R |
| Doc White (25) | 1.7763 | 1904 | L | |
| 122. | Ed Killian (30) | 1.7771 | 1907 | L |
| 123. | Eddie Cicotte (32) | 1.7808 | 1916 | R |
| 124. | Andy Coakley (25) | 1.7817 | 1908 | R |
| Ed Reulbach (26) | 1.7817 | 1909 | R | |
| 126. | Will White (23) | 1.7885 | 1878 | R |
| 127. | Hippo Vaughn (31) | 1.7902 | 1919 | L |
| 128. | Guy Hecker (28) | 1.7982 | 1884 | R |
| 129. | Bob Rhoads (26) | 1.8000 | 1906 | R |
| Frank Smith (29) | 1.8000 | 1909 | R | |
| Stump Wiedman (20) | 1.8000 | 1881 | R | |
| 132. | Vean Gregg (26) | 1.8024 | 1911 | L |
| 133. | King Cole (24) | 1.8025 | 1910 | R |
| 134. | Sam McDowell (25) | 1.8067 | 1968 | L |
| 135. | Hal Newhouser+ (24) | 1.8096 | 1945 | L |
| 136. | Stan Coveleski+ (27) | 1.8101 | 1917 | R |
| 137. | Cy Morgan (30) | 1.8102 | 1909 | R |
| 138. | Vida Blue (21) | 1.8173 | 1971 | L |
| Dutch Ruether (25) | 1.8173 | 1919 | L | |
| 140. | Russ Ford (31) | 1.8194 | 1914 | R |
| 141. | Eddie Cicotte (35) | 1.8196 | 1919 | R |
| 142. | Jack Chesbro+ (30) | 1.8211 | 1904 | R |
| 143. | Stan Coveleski+ (28) | 1.8232 | 1918 | R |
| 144. | Cy Young+ (38) | 1.8243 | 1905 | R |
| 145. | Lew Richie (24) | 1.8266 | 1908 | R |
| 146. | Hippo Vaughn (22) | 1.8271 | 1910 | L |
| 147. | Pete Alexander+ (30) | 1.8325 | 1917 | R |
| 148. | Addie Joss+ (27) | 1.8337 | 1907 | R |
| 149. | Otto Hess (27) | 1.8342 | 1906 | L |
| 150. | Andy Coakley (22) | 1.8353 | 1905 | R |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 151. | Fred Toney (30) | 1.8398 | 1919 | R |
| 152. | Jim McCormick (26) | 1.8421 | 1883 | R |
| 153. | Jim McCormick (23) | 1.8474 | 1880 | R |
| 154. | John Clarkson+ (23) | 1.8491 | 1885 | R |
| 155. | Eppa Rixey+ (25) | 1.8502 | 1916 | L |
| 156. | Lady Baldwin (26) | 1.8569 | 1885 | L |
| 157. | Mordecai Brown+ (33) | 1.8589 | 1910 | R |
| 158. | Mordecai Brown+ (27) | 1.8650 | 1904 | R |
| 159. | Lefty Leifield (22) | 1.8657 | 1906 | L |
| 160. | Wilbur Cooper (24) | 1.8658 | 1916 | L |
| 161. | Phil Niekro+ (28) | 1.8696 | 1967 | R |
| 162. | Kaiser Wilhelm (34) | 1.8705 | 1908 | R |
| 163. | Roger Clemens (42) | 1.8738 | 2005 | R |
| 164. | Ed Walsh+ (25) | 1.8754 | 1906 | R |
| 165. | Tony Mullane (23) | 1.8769 | 1882 | R |
| 166. | Clark Griffith+ (28) | 1.8792 | 1898 | R |
| 167. | Joe Horlen (26) | 1.8798 | 1964 | R |
| 168. | Joe Lake (28) | 1.8808 | 1909 | R |
| 169. | Sandy Koufax+ (27) | 1.8810 | 1963 | L |
| 170. | Nick Altrock (28) | 1.8817 | 1905 | L |
| 171. | Pol Perritt (25) | 1.8837 | 1917 | R |
| 172. | Harry Howell (31) | 1.8870 | 1908 | R |
| 173. | Rube Waddell+ (31) | 1.8903 | 1908 | L |
| 174. | Kevin Brown (31) | 1.8927 | 1996 | R |
| 175. | Christy Mathewson+ (29) | 1.8942 | 1910 | R |
| 176. | Bill James (22) | 1.8957 | 1914 | R |
| 177. | Ben Sanders (23) | 1.8959 | 1888 | R |
| 178. | Max Lanier (27) | 1.8984 | 1943 | L |
| 179. | Walter Johnson+ (23) | 1.8987 | 1911 | R |
| 180. | Walter Johnson+ (28) | 1.8990 | 1916 | R |
| 181. | Art Fromme (25) | 1.9010 | 1909 | R |
| 182. | Jim Scott (25) | 1.9018 | 1913 | R |
| 183. | Pedro Martinez (25) | 1.9019 | 1997 | R |
| 184. | Reb Russell (24) | 1.9042 | 1913 | L |
| 185. | Jake Weimer (30) | 1.9055 | 1904 | L |
| 186. | Pete Alexander+ (33) | 1.9073 | 1920 | R |
| 187. | Willie Mitchell (23) | 1.9078 | 1913 | L |
| 188. | Charley Hall (25) | 1.9081 | 1910 | R |
| 189. | Joe Wood (22) | 1.9099 | 1912 | R |
| 190. | Luis Tiant (31) | 1.9106 | 1972 | R |
| 191. | Charlie Buffinton (27) | 1.9109 | 1888 | R |
| 192. | Ed Siever (27) | 1.9115 | 1902 | L |
| 193. | Wilbur Wood (29) | 1.9132 | 1971 | L |
| 194. | Earl Moseley (27) | 1.9142 | 1915 | R |
| 195. | Bill Burns (29) | 1.9155 | 1909 | L |
| 196. | Jeff Pfeffer (28) | 1.9168 | 1916 | R |
| 197. | Gaylord Perry+ (33) | 1.9173 | 1972 | R |
| 198. | Orval Overall (27) | 1.9200 | 1908 | R |
| 199. | Larry Cheney (30) | 1.9210 | 1916 | R |
| 200. | Red Faber+ (28) | 1.9234 | 1917 | R |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 201. | Mickey Welch+ (28) | 1.9256 | 1888 | R |
| 202. | Cy Young+ (25) | 1.9272 | 1892 | R |
| 203. | Dolf Luque (32) | 1.9286 | 1923 | R |
| 204. | John Tudor (31) | 1.9309 | 1985 | L |
| 205. | Roger Clemens (27) | 1.9314 | 1990 | R |
| 206. | Harry Howell (30) | 1.9347 | 1907 | R |
| 207. | Hal Newhouser+ (25) | 1.9374 | 1946 | L |
| 208. | Allen Sothoron (25) | 1.9378 | 1918 | R |
| 209. | Frank Owen (24) | 1.9429 | 1904 | R |
| 210. | Ray Caldwell (26) | 1.9437 | 1914 | R |
| 211. | Dave McNally (25) | 1.9450 | 1968 | L |
| 212. | Larry Corcoran (20) | 1.9466 | 1880 | R |
| 213. | Jesse Tannehill (27) | 1.9480 | 1902 | L |
| 214. | Larry Corcoran (22) | 1.9484 | 1882 | R |
| 215. | Reb Russell (28) | 1.9489 | 1917 | L |
| 216. | Sam Weaver (22) | 1.9504 | 1878 | R |
| 217. | Billy Rhines (21) | 1.9510 | 1890 | R |
| 218. | Ferdie Schupp (26) | 1.9522 | 1917 | L |
| 219. | Fred Olmstead (28) | 1.9530 | 1910 | R |
| 220. | Charlie Getzien (20) | 1.9548 | 1884 | R |
| 221. | Denny McLain (24) | 1.9554 | 1968 | R |
| 222. | Tommy Bond (23) | 1.9610 | 1879 | R |
| 223. | Jeff Tesreau (24) | 1.9630 | 1912 | R |
| 224. | Jim Bagby (27) | 1.9647 | 1917 | R |
| 225. | Cy Young+ (37) | 1.9658 | 1904 | R |
| 226. | Carl Lundgren (22) | 1.9688 | 1902 | R |
| 227. | Billy Pierce (28) | 1.9692 | 1955 | L |
| 228. | Harry Coveleski (30) | 1.9702 | 1916 | L |
| 229. | Jeff Pfeffer (26) | 1.9714 | 1914 | R |
| 230. | Eddie Cicotte (25) | 1.9729 | 1909 | R |
| 231. | Perry Werden (18) | 1.9741 | 1884 | R |
| 232. | Steve Carlton+ (27) | 1.9750 | 1972 | L |
| 233. | Scott Perry (27) | 1.9769 | 1918 | R |
| 234. | Harry Howell (28) | 1.9783 | 1905 | R |
| 235. | Gary Peters (29) | 1.9788 | 1966 | L |
| 236. | Charlie Ferguson (23) | 1.9789 | 1886 | R |
| 237. | Tommy John (25) | 1.9793 | 1968 | L |
| 238. | Babe Adams (37) | 1.9823 | 1919 | R |
| 239. | Will White (24) | 1.9853 | 1879 | R |
| 240. | Bobby Bolin (29) | 1.9868 | 1968 | R |
| 241. | Cy Young+ (40) | 1.9922 | 1907 | R |
| 242. | Christy Mathewson+ (30) | 1.9935 | 1911 | R |
| 243. | Pud Galvin+ (27) | 1.9942 | 1884 | R |
| 244. | Gary Nolan (24) | 1.9943 | 1972 | R |
| 245. | Jack Taylor (32) | 1.9945 | 1906 | R |
| 246. | Christy Mathewson+ (26) | 2.0000 | 1907 | R |
| Jack Pfiester (30) | 2.0000 | 1908 | L | |
| 248. | Tully Sparks (32) | 2.0038 | 1907 | R |
| 249. | Lon Warneke (24) | 2.0046 | 1933 | R |
| 250. | Lefty Tyler (28) | 2.0050 | 1918 | L |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| Hooks Wiltse (29) | 2.0050 | 1909 | L | |
| 252. | Harry Gaspar (26) | 2.0077 | 1909 | R |
| 253. | Charlie Hodnett (23) | 2.0083 | 1884 | |
| 254. | Hippo Vaughn (29) | 2.0090 | 1917 | L |
| 255. | Whitey Ford+ (29) | 2.0106 | 1958 | L |
| 256. | Ed Seward (21) | 2.0128 | 1888 | R |
| 257. | Doc Watson (28) | 2.0132 | 1914 | L |
| 258. | Eddie Plank+ (34) | 2.0133 | 1910 | L |
| Babe Ruth+ (22) | 2.0133 | 1917 | L | |
| 260. | Addie Joss+ (25) | 2.0140 | 1905 | R |
| 261. | Kid Nichols+ (34) | 2.0158 | 1904 | R |
| 262. | Red Faber+ (27) | 2.0162 | 1916 | R |
| 263. | Al Benton (34) | 2.0191 | 1945 | R |
| 264. | Lefty Tyler (26) | 2.0214 | 1916 | L |
| 265. | Bob Wicker (27) | 2.0225 | 1905 | R |
| 266. | Joe Wood (21) | 2.0242 | 1911 | R |
| 267. | Bugs Raymond (26) | 2.0257 | 1908 | R |
| 268. | Ed Reulbach (25) | 2.0258 | 1908 | R |
| Frank Smith (28) | 2.0258 | 1908 | R | |
| 270. | Orel Hershiser (26) | 2.0278 | 1985 | R |
| 271. | Phil Douglas (29) | 2.0282 | 1919 | R |
| 272. | Adonis Terry (23) | 2.0308 | 1888 | R |
| 273. | Christy Mathewson+ (23) | 2.0317 | 1904 | R |
| 274. | Jim Scott (27) | 2.0349 | 1915 | R |
| 275. | Ed Karger (24) | 2.0350 | 1907 | L |
| 276. | Sandy Koufax+ (29) | 2.0377 | 1965 | L |
| 277. | Eddie Cicotte (30) | 2.0384 | 1914 | R |
| Al Mamaux (21) | 2.0384 | 1915 | R | |
| 279. | Catfish Hunter+ (26) | 2.0418 | 1972 | R |
| 280. | Jesse Tannehill (29) | 2.0450 | 1904 | L |
| 281. | Roger Clemens (34) | 2.0455 | 1997 | R |
| 282. | Buttons Briggs (28) | 2.0469 | 1904 | R |
| 283. | Nick Cullop (28) | 2.0479 | 1916 | L |
| 284. | Charley Radbourn+ (28) | 2.0496 | 1883 | R |
| 285. | Dave Righetti (22) | 2.0506 | 1981 | L |
| 286. | Deacon Phillippe (30) | 2.0515 | 1902 | R |
| 287. | Chief Bender+ (23) | 2.0517 | 1907 | R |
| 288. | Rube Waddell+ (25) | 2.0519 | 1902 | L |
| 289. | Patsy Flaherty (28) | 2.0526 | 1904 | L |
| 290. | Hippo Vaughn (26) | 2.0534 | 1914 | L |
| 291. | Stan Bahnsen (23) | 2.0536 | 1968 | R |
| 292. | Bob Veale (32) | 2.0544 | 1968 | L |
| 293. | Glenn Liebhardt (24) | 2.0547 | 1907 | R |
| 294. | Slim Sallee (34) | 2.0556 | 1919 | L |
| 295. | Noodles Hahn (25) | 2.0560 | 1904 | L |
| 296. | Sam Leever (31) | 2.0574 | 1903 | R |
| 297. | Lefty Grove+ (31) | 2.0577 | 1931 | L |
| 298. | Joe Horlen (29) | 2.0581 | 1967 | R |
| 299. | Christy Mathewson+ (32) | 2.0588 | 1913 | R |
| 300. | Nap Rucker (22) | 2.0593 | 1907 | L |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 301. | Tommy Bond (22) | 2.0613 | 1878 | R |
| 302. | Allie Reynolds (35) | 2.0628 | 1952 | R |
| 303. | Nick Altrock (29) | 2.0649 | 1906 | L |
| 304. | Jim Palmer+ (26) | 2.0668 | 1972 | R |
| 305. | Pedro Martinez (27) | 2.0672 | 1999 | R |
| 306. | Carl Weilman (29) | 2.0676 | 1919 | L |
| 307. | Vic Willis+ (32) | 2.0678 | 1908 | R |
| 308. | George Winter (29) | 2.0688 | 1907 | R |
| 309. | Bob Caruthers (21) | 2.0712 | 1885 | R |
| 310. | Bill Sowders (23) | 2.0726 | 1888 | R |
| 311. | Bill Donovan (31) | 2.0769 | 1908 | R |
| Roger Nelson (28) | 2.0769 | 1972 | R | |
| Pat Ragan (30) | 2.0769 | 1916 | R | |
| Bill Swift (30) | 2.0769 | 1992 | R | |
| Carl Weilman (24) | 2.0769 | 1914 | L | |
| 316. | Nap Rucker (23) | 2.0790 | 1908 | L |
| 317. | Tom Seaver+ (28) | 2.0793 | 1973 | R |
| 318. | Eddie Plank+ (39) | 2.0795 | 1915 | L |
| Don Sutton+ (27) | 2.0795 | 1972 | R | |
| 320. | Cy Young+ (36) | 2.0810 | 1903 | R |
| 321. | Jerry Koosman (25) | 2.0822 | 1968 | L |
| 322. | Mike O'Neill (26) | 2.0864 | 1904 | R |
| 323. | Dazzy Vance+ (37) | 2.0868 | 1928 | R |
| 324. | Charley Radbourn+ (27) | 2.0886 | 1882 | R |
| 325. | Jim Whitney (26) | 2.0893 | 1884 | R |
| 326. | Jim Palmer+ (29) | 2.0898 | 1975 | R |
| 327. | Will White (28) | 2.0901 | 1883 | R |
| 328. | Frank Smith (24) | 2.0906 | 1904 | R |
| 329. | Bill James (30) | 2.0909 | 1917 | R |
| 330. | Mordecai Brown+ (38) | 2.0945 | 1915 | R |
| 331. | Ned Garvin (28) | 2.0948 | 1902 | R |
| 332. | Ed Poole (27) | 2.0959 | 1902 | R |
| 333. | Ted Lyons+ (41) | 2.0961 | 1942 | R |
| 334. | Carl Mays (27) | 2.0977 | 1919 | R |
| Howie Pollet (25) | 2.0977 | 1946 | L | |
| 336. | Jeff Pfeffer (27) | 2.0983 | 1915 | R |
| 337. | Spud Chandler (38) | 2.0984 | 1946 | R |
| 338. | Lefty Leifield (24) | 2.0991 | 1908 | L |
| 339. | Billy Taylor (29) | 2.0994 | 1884 | R |
| 340. | Warren Spahn+ (32) | 2.1004 | 1953 | L |
| 341. | Bill Dinneen (32) | 2.1018 | 1908 | R |
| Frank Owen (25) | 2.1018 | 1905 | R | |
| 343. | Sam Leever (36) | 2.1021 | 1908 | R |
| 344. | Juan Marichal+ (31) | 2.1023 | 1969 | R |
| Earl Moore (29) | 2.1023 | 1909 | R | |
| 346. | Dave Roberts (26) | 2.1026 | 1971 | L |
| 347. | Al Maul (32) | 2.1029 | 1898 | R |
| 348. | Eddie Plank+ (35) | 2.1039 | 1911 | L |
| Slim Sallee (29) | 2.1039 | 1914 | L | |
| Pete Schneider (21) | 2.1039 | 1917 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 351. | Frank Corridon (28) | 2.1053 | 1909 | R |
| 352. | Dick Ellsworth (23) | 2.1055 | 1963 | L |
| 353. | Dave Foutz (29) | 2.1071 | 1886 | R |
| 354. | Wilbur Cooper (26) | 2.1073 | 1918 | L |
| 355. | Tommy Bond (21) | 2.1075 | 1877 | R |
| 356. | Ray Fisher (27) | 2.1077 | 1915 | R |
| 357. | Jack Powell (34) | 2.1088 | 1909 | R |
| 358. | Jack Powell (33) | 2.1094 | 1908 | R |
| 359. | Joe Bush (25) | 2.1125 | 1918 | R |
| 360. | Harry Howell (29) | 2.1145 | 1906 | R |
| Christy Mathewson+ (21) | 2.1145 | 1902 | R | |
| 362. | Joe Benz (29) | 2.1147 | 1915 | R |
| 363. | Rube Foster (27) | 2.1149 | 1915 | R |
| 364. | Lew Brockett (28) | 2.1176 | 1909 | R |
| 365. | Johnny Lush (22) | 2.1184 | 1908 | L |
| 366. | Bill Bernhard (32) | 2.1187 | 1903 | R |
| 367. | Tom Hughes (31) | 2.1189 | 1915 | R |
| 368. | Christy Mathewson+ (31) | 2.1194 | 1912 | R |
| 369. | Dizzy Trout (29) | 2.1202 | 1944 | R |
| 370. | Zack Greinke (25) | 2.1204 | 2009 | R |
| 371. | Heinie Berger (26) | 2.1221 | 1908 | R |
| 372. | Steve Blass (26) | 2.1240 | 1968 | R |
| Roger Wolff (34) | 2.1240 | 1945 | R | |
| 374. | Dutch Leonard (36) | 2.1250 | 1945 | R |
| 375. | Phil Douglas (28) | 2.1255 | 1918 | R |
| 376. | Wilbur Cooper (22) | 2.1263 | 1914 | L |
| 377. | John Ward+ (21) | 2.1273 | 1881 | R |
| 378. | Frank Smith (25) | 2.1291 | 1905 | R |
| 379. | Doc White (24) | 2.1300 | 1903 | L |
| 380. | Johnny Beazley (24) | 2.1316 | 1942 | R |
| 381. | Mickey Hughes (21) | 2.1322 | 1888 | R |
| 382. | Bill Bernhard (33) | 2.1331 | 1904 | R |
| 383. | Juan Marichal+ (27) | 2.1332 | 1965 | R |
| 384. | Burleigh Grimes+ (24) | 2.1333 | 1918 | R |
| 385. | Whitey Ford+ (35) | 2.1335 | 1964 | L |
| 386. | Kid Nichols+ (28) | 2.1340 | 1898 | R |
| 387. | John Clarkson+ (22) | 2.1356 | 1884 | R |
| 388. | Bobby Mitchell (22) | 2.1375 | 1878 | L |
| Guy Morton (22) | 2.1375 | 1915 | R | |
| 390. | Terry Larkin () | 2.1377 | 1877 | R |
| 391. | Will White (25) | 2.1398 | 1880 | R |
| 392. | Joe Boehling (22) | 2.1416 | 1913 | L |
| 393. | Buttons Briggs (29) | 2.1429 | 1905 | R |
| 394. | Jack Manning (22) | 2.1436 | 1876 | R |
| 395. | George McQuillan (24) | 2.1440 | 1909 | R |
| 396. | Don Drysdale+ (31) | 2.1464 | 1968 | R |
| 397. | Charlie Buffinton (23) | 2.1465 | 1884 | R |
| John Ward+ (19) | 2.1465 | 1879 | R | |
| 399. | Lee Richmond (23) | 2.1484 | 1880 | L |
| 400. | Rube Waddell+ (30) | 2.1499 | 1907 | L |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 401. | Howie Camnitz (25) | 2.1500 | 1907 | R |
| 402. | Bill Bernhard (31) | 2.1504 | 1902 | R |
| 403. | Babe Adams (31) | 2.1520 | 1913 | R |
| 404. | Carl Weilman (26) | 2.1522 | 1916 | L |
| 405. | Cy Young+ (35) | 2.1525 | 1902 | R |
| 406. | Ed Walsh+ (31) | 2.1527 | 1912 | R |
| 407. | Vern Law (35) | 2.1534 | 1965 | R |
| 408. | Babe Adams (38) | 2.1559 | 1920 | R |
| 409. | Danny Haren (28) | 2.1570 | 2009 | R |
| 410. | Hal Schumacher (22) | 2.1572 | 1933 | R |
| 411. | Red Ames (24) | 2.1600 | 1907 | R |
| Art Nehf (24) | 2.1600 | 1917 | L | |
| Tully Sparks (31) | 2.1600 | 1906 | R | |
| Dazzy Vance+ (33) | 2.1600 | 1924 | R | |
| 415. | Bret Saberhagen (25) | 2.1614 | 1989 | R |
| 416. | Ed Siever (32) | 2.1626 | 1907 | L |
| 417. | Bob Tewksbury (31) | 2.1631 | 1992 | R |
| 418. | Chief Bender+ (27) | 2.1633 | 1911 | R |
| 419. | Dick Rudolph (28) | 2.1635 | 1916 | R |
| 420. | Case Patten (32) | 2.1651 | 1906 | L |
| 421. | Eddie Plank+ (28) | 2.1660 | 1904 | L |
| 422. | Doc Ayers (26) | 2.1669 | 1917 | R |
| 423. | Sam Leever (32) | 2.1671 | 1904 | R |
| 424. | Ray Fisher (31) | 2.1683 | 1919 | R |
| 425. | Mordecai Brown+ (28) | 2.1687 | 1905 | R |
| 426. | Jack Chesbro+ (28) | 2.1688 | 1902 | R |
| 427. | Slim Sallee (32) | 2.1700 | 1917 | L |
| 428. | Jeff Tesreau (25) | 2.1702 | 1913 | R |
| 429. | Eddie Plank+ (32) | 2.1703 | 1908 | L |
| 430. | Dick Rudolph (31) | 2.1705 | 1919 | R |
| 431. | Steve Carlton+ (24) | 2.1707 | 1969 | L |
| 432. | Dutch Leonard (25) | 2.1710 | 1917 | L |
| 433. | Mike Paul (27) | 2.1711 | 1972 | L |
| 434. | Guy Hecker (29) | 2.1750 | 1885 | R |
| 435. | Hooks Wiltse (27) | 2.1751 | 1907 | L |
| 436. | Jesse Tannehill (26) | 2.1757 | 1901 | L |
| 437. | Sam McDowell (22) | 2.1758 | 1965 | L |
| 438. | Harry Harper (23) | 2.1762 | 1918 | L |
| 439. | Dave Foutz (27) | 2.1774 | 1884 | R |
| Joe Magrane (23) | 2.1774 | 1988 | L | |
| 441. | Bob Gibson+ (33) | 2.1783 | 1969 | R |
| 442. | Ed Morris (21) | 2.1784 | 1884 | L |
| 443. | Slim Sallee (31) | 2.1798 | 1916 | L |
| 444. | George Mogridge (29) | 2.1811 | 1918 | L |
| 445. | Bob Feller+ (27) | 2.1813 | 1946 | R |
| 446. | Greg Maddux (26) | 2.1828 | 1992 | R |
| 447. | Bob Knepper (27) | 2.1830 | 1981 | L |
| 448. | Tully Sparks (30) | 2.1836 | 1905 | R |
| 449. | Don Drysdale+ (27) | 2.1846 | 1964 | R |
| Joe Wood (19) | 2.1846 | 1909 | R | |
| Rank | Player (age that year) | Earned Run Average | Year | Throws |
| 451. | Frank Arellanes (27) | 2.1850 | 1909 | R |
| 452. | Willie Mitchell (27) | 2.1852 | 1917 | L |
| 453. | Dummy Taylor (27) | 2.1861 | 1902 | R |
| 454. | Tony Mullane (24) | 2.1881 | 1883 | R |
| 455. | Addie Joss+ (23) | 2.1892 | 1903 | R |
| 456. | Hoyt Wilhelm+ (36) | 2.1903 | 1959 | R |
| 457. | Elton Chamberlain (20) | 2.1916 | 1888 | R |
| 458. | Dick Bosman (25) | 2.1917 | 1969 | R |
| 459. | Bill Donovan (30) | 2.1919 | 1907 | R |
| 460. | Harry Howell (27) | 2.1924 | 1904 | R |
| 461. | Deacon Phillippe (33) | 2.1936 | 1905 | R |
| 462. | Vic Willis+ (26) | 2.1951 | 1902 | R |
| 463. | Jack Chesbro+ (31) | 2.1956 | 1905 | R |
| 464. | Dummy Taylor (31) | 2.1972 | 1906 | R |
| 465. | George McConnell (37) | 2.1980 | 1915 | R |
| 466. | Glenn Liebhardt (25) | 2.1985 | 1908 | R |
| 467. | Bill Dinneen (28) | 2.1986 | 1904 | R |
| 468. | Fred Toney (28) | 2.1992 | 1917 | R |
| 469. | Eddie Plank+ (31) | 2.1998 | 1907 | L |
| 470. | Allen Sothoron (26) | 2.2000 | 1919 | R |
| 471. | Dave Davenport (25) | 2.2003 | 1915 | R |
| 472. | Charley Radbourn+ (30) | 2.2012 | 1885 | R |
| 473. | George Derby (23) | 2.2015 | 1881 | R |
| 474. | Chris Short (26) | 2.2024 | 1964 | L |
| 475. | Joe Lake (29) | 2.2041 | 1910 | R |
| Tom Seaver+ (23) | 2.2041 | 1968 | R | |
| Don Sutton+ (35) | 2.2041 | 1980 | R | |
| Hippo Vaughn (28) | 2.2041 | 1916 | L | |
| 479. | Greg Maddux (31) | 2.2049 | 1997 | R |
| 480. | Chief Bender+ (29) | 2.2056 | 1913 | R |
| 481. | Tom Seaver+ (24) | 2.2061 | 1969 | R |
| 482. | Bob Ewing (35) | 2.2066 | 1908 | R |
| 483. | Nap Rucker (27) | 2.2072 | 1912 | L |
| 484. | Johnny Sain (28) | 2.2076 | 1946 | R |
| 485. | Hank Aguirre (31) | 2.2083 | 1962 | L |
| 486. | Walter Johnson+ (29) | 2.2086 | 1917 | R |
| 487. | Al Demaree (28) | 2.2087 | 1913 | R |
| 488. | Norwood Gibson (27) | 2.2088 | 1904 | R |
| 489. | Ed Daily (22) | 2.2091 | 1885 | R |
| Carl Mays (26) | 2.2091 | 1918 | R | |
| 491. | Carl Lundgren (26) | 2.2103 | 1906 | R |
| 492. | Rube Waddell+ (29) | 2.2115 | 1906 | L |
| 493. | Bob Shawkey (25) | 2.2120 | 1916 | R |
| 494. | Danny Darwin (34) | 2.2131 | 1990 | R |
| Nick Maddox (22) | 2.2131 | 1909 | R | |
| 496. | Doc Ayers (24) | 2.2145 | 1915 | R |
| Rube Vickers (30) | 2.2145 | 1908 | R | |
| 498. | Tom Hughes (29) | 2.2147 | 1908 | R |
| 499. | Jake Weimer (32) | 2.2155 | 1906 | L |
| 500. | Mike Cuellar (29) | 2.2170 | 1966 | L |
Note that seasons prior to 1876 are not included in single-season marks, but are included in career marks.