+ - Indicates Hall of Famer. Bold indicates active player.
Statistic Description: Wins Above Replacement for Pitchers A single number that presents the number of wins the player added to the team above what a replacement player (think AAA or AAAA) would add. This value includes defensive support and includes additional value for high leverage situations. Scale: 8+ MVP Quality, 5+ All-Star Quality, 2+ Starter, 0-2 Reserve, < 0 Replacement Level Developed by Sean Smith of BaseballProjection.com
This statistic is computed from play-by-play data which is only complete from 1974 to the present. From 1945-1973, the data is incomplete, though for most seasons only less than 20 games per season total are missing. Please see our page on data coverage for a full view of the data used to create these lists.
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Cy Young+ (22) | 170.3 | R |
| 2. | Walter Johnson+ (21) | 152.3 | R |
| 3. | Roger Clemens (24) | 139.4 | R |
| 4. | Pete Alexander+ (20) | 117.0 | R |
| 5. | Kid Nichols+ (15) | 116.6 | R |
| 6. | Lefty Grove+ (17) | 109.9 | L |
| 7. | Tom Seaver+ (20) | 106.3 | R |
| 8. | Greg Maddux (23) | 104.6 | R |
| 9. | Randy Johnson (22) | 104.3 | L |
| 10. | Phil Niekro+ (24) | 97.4 | R |
| 11. | Bert Blyleven+ (22) | 96.5 | R |
| 12. | Christy Mathewson+ (17) | 95.3 | R |
| 13. | Gaylord Perry+ (22) | 93.7 | R |
| 14. | Warren Spahn+ (21) | 92.6 | L |
| 15. | Tim Keefe+ (14) | 88.9 | R |
| 16. | Eddie Plank+ (17) | 86.5 | L |
| 17. | Pedro Martinez (18) | 86.0 | R |
| 18. | John Clarkson+ (12) | 85.7 | R |
| 19. | Steve Carlton+ (24) | 84.1 | L |
| 20. | Nolan Ryan+ (27) | 83.8 | R |
| 21. | Pud Galvin+ (15) | 83.6 | R |
| 22. | Robin Roberts+ (19) | 83.1 | R |
| 23. | Fergie Jenkins+ (19) | 82.8 | R |
| 24. | Mike Mussina (18) | 82.7 | R |
| 25. | Bob Gibson+ (17) | 81.9 | R |
| 26. | Curt Schilling (20) | 80.7 | R |
| 27. | Jim McCormick (10) | 75.5 | R |
| 28. | Tom Glavine (22) | 74.0 | L |
| 29. | Old Hoss Radbourn+ (12) | 73.5 | R |
| 30. | Don Sutton+ (23) | 68.7 | R |
| 31. | Kevin Brown (19) | 68.5 | R |
| 32. | Red Faber+ (20) | 68.4 | R |
| Amos Rusie+ (10) | 68.4 | R | |
| 34. | Rick Reuschel (19) | 68.2 | R |
| 35. | Jim Palmer+ (19) | 68.1 | R |
| 36. | Carl Hubbell+ (16) | 67.8 | L |
| 37. | Ted Lyons+ (21) | 67.2 | R |
| 38. | Vic Willis+ (13) | 67.1 | R |
| 39. | John Smoltz (21) | 66.5 | R |
| 40. | Luis Tiant (19) | 66.1 | R |
| 41. | Roy Halladay (16, 36) | 65.4 | R |
| 42. | Stan Coveleski+ (14) | 65.2 | R |
| Bob Feller+ (18) | 65.2 | R | |
| 44. | Mickey Welch+ (13) | 63.8 | R |
| 45. | Ed Walsh+ (14) | 63.2 | R |
| 46. | Dennis Eckersley+ (24) | 62.5 | R |
| Dazzy Vance+ (16) | 62.5 | R | |
| 48. | Tommy John (26) | 62.3 | L |
| 49. | Bobby Mathews (15) | 62.2 | R |
| 50. | Juan Marichal+ (16) | 61.9 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 51. | David Cone (17) | 61.7 | R |
| 52. | Don Drysdale+ (14) | 61.2 | R |
| 53. | Tommy Bond (10) | 61.0 | R |
| Rube Waddell+ (13) | 61.0 | L | |
| 55. | Charlie Buffinton (11) | 60.6 | R |
| 56. | Joe McGinnity+ (10) | 60.4 | R |
| Hal Newhouser+ (17) | 60.4 | L | |
| 58. | Jim Bunning+ (17) | 60.3 | R |
| 59. | Tony Mullane (13) | 60.2 | |
| 60. | Bret Saberhagen (16) | 59.1 | R |
| 61. | Jack Quinn (23) | 59.0 | R |
| 62. | Andy Pettitte (18, 41) | 58.8 | L |
| 63. | Chuck Finley (17) | 58.5 | L |
| 64. | Clark Griffith+ (21) | 57.7 | R |
| 65. | Frank Tanana (21) | 57.5 | L |
| 66. | Jerry Koosman (19) | 57.1 | L |
| 67. | Dave Stieb (16) | 57.0 | R |
| 68. | Eddie Cicotte (14) | 56.9 | R |
| 69. | Eppa Rixey+ (21) | 56.8 | L |
| 70. | Jack Powell (16) | 56.0 | R |
| 71. | Red Ruffing+ (22) | 55.4 | R |
| 72. | CC Sabathia (13, 32) | 55.2 | L |
| 73. | Kevin Appier (16) | 55.1 | R |
| Mordecai Brown+ (14) | 55.1 | R | |
| 75. | Mariano Rivera (19, 43) | 54.9 | R |
| 76. | Urban Shocker (13) | 54.8 | R |
| 77. | Tim Hudson (15, 37) | 54.3 | R |
| 78. | Whitey Ford+ (16) | 53.9 | L |
| 79. | David Wells (21) | 53.5 | L |
| 80. | Waite Hoyt+ (21) | 53.3 | R |
| 81. | Sandy Koufax+ (12) | 53.2 | L |
| 82. | Billy Pierce (18) | 53.0 | L |
| 83. | Tommy Bridges (16) | 52.5 | R |
| Larry Jackson (14) | 52.5 | R | |
| 85. | Al Spalding+ (8) | 52.2 | R |
| Wilbur Wood (17) | 52.2 | L | |
| 87. | Ted Breitenstein (11) | 52.1 | L |
| 88. | Mark Buehrle (14, 34) | 52.0 | L |
| 89. | Orel Hershiser (18) | 51.7 | R |
| Bobo Newsom (20) | 51.7 | R | |
| 91. | Early Wynn+ (23) | 51.6 | R |
| 92. | Dutch Leonard (20) | 51.4 | R |
| 93. | Silver King (10) | 51.3 | R |
| 94. | Kenny Rogers (20) | 51.1 | L |
| 95. | Roy Oswalt (12) | 50.8 | R |
| 96. | Johan Santana (12, 34) | 50.7 | L |
| 97. | Eddie Rommel (13) | 50.4 | R |
| 98. | Mark Langston (16) | 50.3 | L |
| 99. | Jamie Moyer (25) | 50.2 | L |
| 100. | Hoyt Wilhelm+ (21) | 50.1 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 101. | Babe Adams (19) | 49.5 | R |
| Dennis Martinez (23) | 49.5 | R | |
| 103. | Jimmy Key (15) | 49.4 | L |
| 104. | Wilbur Cooper (15) | 49.0 | L |
| 105. | Wes Ferrell (15) | 48.8 | R |
| Mickey Lolich (16) | 48.8 | L | |
| 107. | Dwight Gooden (16) | 48.2 | R |
| 108. | Mel Harder (20) | 47.9 | R |
| Nap Rucker (10) | 47.9 | L | |
| 110. | Ron Guidry (14) | 47.8 | L |
| 111. | Frank Viola (15) | 47.4 | L |
| 112. | Bob Friend (16) | 47.0 | R |
| 113. | Burleigh Grimes+ (19) | 46.9 | R |
| 114. | Milt Pappas (17) | 46.8 | R |
| 115. | Hippo Vaughn (13) | 46.6 | L |
| Jim Whitney (10) | 46.6 | R | |
| 117. | Bucky Walters (19) | 46.4 | R |
| Gus Weyhing (14) | 46.4 | R | |
| 119. | Bob Shawkey (15) | 46.2 | R |
| 120. | Dizzy Trout (15) | 46.1 | R |
| 121. | Noodles Hahn (8) | 45.9 | L |
| Addie Joss+ (9) | 45.9 | R | |
| 123. | Brad Radke (12) | 45.6 | R |
| 124. | Steve Rogers (13) | 45.3 | R |
| 125. | Jim Kaat (25) | 45.2 | L |
| 126. | Vida Blue (17) | 45.0 | L |
| 127. | George Uhle (17) | 44.4 | R |
| 128. | Al Orth (15) | 44.1 | R |
| Herb Pennock+ (22) | 44.1 | L | |
| 130. | Chief Bender+ (16) | 44.0 | R |
| 131. | Larry French (14) | 43.9 | L |
| 132. | Bob Caruthers (10) | 43.8 | R |
| Jack Morris (18) | 43.8 | R | |
| 134. | Murry Dickson (18) | 43.5 | R |
| Bob Welch (17) | 43.5 | R | |
| 136. | Javier Vazquez (14) | 43.3 | R |
| 137. | Dolf Luque (20) | 43.2 | R |
| 138. | Lefty Gomez+ (14) | 43.1 | L |
| 139. | Sam McDowell (15) | 42.9 | L |
| 140. | Claude Passeau (13) | 42.8 | R |
| 141. | Dizzy Dean+ (12) | 42.7 | R |
| Curt Simmons (20) | 42.7 | L | |
| 143. | Al Leiter (19) | 42.6 | L |
| Doc White (13) | 42.6 | L | |
| 145. | Tom Candiotti (16) | 42.5 | R |
| Carl Mays (15) | 42.5 | R | |
| Ed Morris (7) | 42.5 | L | |
| 148. | Frank Dwyer (12) | 42.3 | R |
| 149. | Virgil Trucks (17) | 42.2 | R |
| 150. | Sadie McMahon (9) | 41.9 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Lon Warneke (15) | 41.9 | R | |
| 152. | Bill Donovan (18) | 41.8 | R |
| Rich Gossage+ (22) | 41.8 | R | |
| Sam Leever (13) | 41.8 | R | |
| 155. | Harry Brecheen (12) | 41.4 | L |
| 156. | Jack Chesbro+ (11) | 41.2 | R |
| 157. | Bill Dinneen (12) | 41.1 | R |
| Jesse Tannehill (15) | 41.1 | L | |
| 159. | Jack Stivetts (11) | 41.0 | R |
| 160. | Mel Stottlemyre (11) | 40.6 | R |
| 161. | Danny Darwin (21) | 40.5 | R |
| 162. | Nig Cuppy (10) | 40.4 | R |
| Sad Sam Jones (22) | 40.4 | R | |
| 164. | Bill Hutchinson (9) | 40.3 | R |
| 165. | John Candelaria (19) | 40.1 | L |
| 166. | Bartolo Colon (16, 40) | 40.0 | R |
| 167. | Charlie Hough (25) | 39.6 | R |
| 168. | Jon Matlack (13) | 39.1 | L |
| Ed Reulbach (13) | 39.1 | R | |
| 170. | Paul Derringer (15) | 39.0 | R |
| 171. | Howard Ehmke (15) | 38.9 | R |
| Will White (10) | 38.9 | R | |
| 173. | Pink Hawley (10) | 38.8 | R |
| 174. | Ned Garver (14) | 38.7 | R |
| Jim Perry (17) | 38.7 | R | |
| 176. | Tom Zachary (19) | 38.6 | L |
| 177. | Candy Cummings+ (6) | 38.5 | R |
| 178. | Rube Walberg (15) | 38.3 | L |
| 179. | Justin Verlander (9, 30) | 38.2 | R |
| Carlos Zambrano (12) | 38.2 | R | |
| 181. | Jeff Pfeffer (13) | 38.1 | R |
| 182. | Charlie Root (17) | 38.0 | R |
| 183. | Camilo Pascual (18) | 37.8 | R |
| 184. | Mark Gubicza (14) | 37.7 | R |
| 185. | Bob Lemon+ (15) | 37.5 | R |
| 186. | Andy Messersmith (12) | 37.4 | R |
| Fernando Valenzuela (17) | 37.4 | L | |
| 188. | Curt Davis (13) | 37.3 | R |
| 189. | Claude Osteen (18) | 37.0 | L |
| 190. | Cliff Lee (12, 34) | 36.9 | L |
| 191. | Burt Hooton (15) | 36.6 | R |
| Catfish Hunter+ (15) | 36.6 | R | |
| 193. | Felix Hernandez (9, 27) | 36.4 | R |
| Dutch Leonard (11) | 36.4 | L | |
| 195. | Earl Whitehill (17) | 36.3 | L |
| 196. | Barry Zito (14, 35) | 36.2 | L |
| 197. | Bob Rush (13) | 35.8 | R |
| 198. | Jesse Haines+ (19) | 35.7 | R |
| 199. | Bump Hadley (16) | 35.6 | R |
| 200. | Chris Carpenter (15, 38) | 35.5 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 201. | Jake Peavy (12, 32) | 35.4 | R |
| 202. | Hooks Dauss (15) | 35.2 | R |
| Freddy Garcia (15, 36) | 35.2 | R | |
| 204. | Preacher Roe (12) | 35.1 | L |
| 205. | Bruce Hurst (15) | 35.0 | L |
| Thornton Lee (16) | 35.0 | L | |
| Jose Rijo (14) | 35.0 | R | |
| 208. | Doyle Alexander (19) | 34.9 | R |
| Dean Chance (11) | 34.9 | R | |
| Tom Gordon (21) | 34.9 | R | |
| Schoolboy Rowe (15) | 34.9 | R | |
| 212. | Sal Maglie (10) | 34.5 | R |
| Tim Wakefield (19) | 34.5 | R | |
| 214. | Charlie Leibrandt (14) | 34.4 | L |
| Fritz Ostermueller (15) | 34.4 | L | |
| Deacon Phillippe (13) | 34.4 | R | |
| 217. | Jim Maloney (12) | 34.3 | R |
| George Mullin (14) | 34.3 | R | |
| John Tudor (12) | 34.3 | L | |
| 220. | Larry Dierker (14) | 34.2 | R |
| Rube Marquard+ (18) | 34.2 | L | |
| 222. | Howie Pollet (14) | 34.0 | L |
| 223. | Josh Beckett (13, 33) | 33.6 | R |
| Slim Sallee (14) | 33.6 | L | |
| 225. | Freddie Fitzsimmons (19) | 33.5 | R |
| Ken Raffensberger (15) | 33.5 | L | |
| 227. | Brandon Webb (7) | 33.3 | R |
| 228. | Derek Lowe (17, 40) | 33.1 | R |
| Jerry Reuss (22) | 33.1 | L | |
| 230. | Pat Hentgen (14) | 32.9 | R |
| 231. | Bill Lee (14) | 32.5 | R |
| 232. | Mort Cooper (11) | 32.2 | R |
| Brickyard Kennedy (12) | 32.2 | R | |
| 234. | Bobby Shantz (16) | 32.1 | L |
| Rick Wise (18) | 32.1 | R | |
| 236. | Red Lucas (16) | 32.0 | R |
| 237. | Harry Howell (13) | 31.8 | R |
| 238. | Zack Greinke (10, 29) | 31.7 | R |
| Firpo Marberry (14) | 31.7 | R | |
| Jason Schmidt (14) | 31.7 | R | |
| 241. | Mike Boddicker (14) | 31.6 | R |
| 242. | Bullet Joe Bush (17) | 31.5 | R |
| Ray Caldwell (12) | 31.5 | R | |
| Kid Gleason (22) | 31.5 | R | |
| 245. | Andy Benes (14) | 31.4 | R |
| Matt Cain (9, 28) | 31.4 | R | |
| Sid Fernandez (15) | 31.4 | L | |
| Chris Short (15) | 31.4 | L | |
| 249. | Russ Ford (7) | 31.3 | R |
| George Zettlein (6) | 31.3 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 251. | John Denny (13) | 31.2 | R |
| John Hiller (15) | 31.2 | L | |
| Willis Hudlin (16) | 31.2 | R | |
| Rick Sutcliffe (18) | 31.2 | R | |
| 255. | Johnny Antonelli (12) | 31.1 | L |
| 256. | Ellis Kinder (12) | 31.0 | R |
| Lee Meadows (15) | 31.0 | R | |
| 258. | Jim Devlin (5) | 30.8 | R |
| Dan Haren (11, 32) | 30.8 | R | |
| 260. | Jim Barr (12) | 30.6 | R |
| Bob Ewing (11) | 30.6 | R | |
| Teddy Higuera (9) | 30.6 | L | |
| Earl Moore (14) | 30.6 | R | |
| 264. | Mike Garcia (14) | 30.4 | R |
| 265. | Greg Swindell (17) | 30.3 | L |
| 266. | Bill Hands (11) | 30.2 | R |
| Dick McBride (6) | 30.2 | R | |
| Kevin Millwood (16) | 30.2 | R | |
| Van Mungo (14) | 30.2 | R | |
| Rick Rhoden (16) | 30.2 | R | |
| Jack Taylor (10) | 30.2 | R | |
| 272. | Max Lanier (14) | 30.1 | L |
| 273. | Red Donahue (13) | 30.0 | R |
| Harvey Haddix (14) | 30.0 | L | |
| 275. | George Mogridge (15) | 29.9 | L |
| Jered Weaver (8, 30) | 29.9 | R | |
| 277. | Cole Hamels (8, 29) | 29.7 | L |
| Smoky Joe Wood (14) | 29.7 | R | |
| 279. | Ice Box Chamberlain (10) | 29.6 | R |
| General Crowder (11) | 29.6 | R | |
| Scott Sanderson (19) | 29.6 | R | |
| 282. | Frank Killen (10) | 29.5 | L |
| Don Newcombe (10) | 29.5 | R | |
| 284. | Syl Johnson (19) | 29.4 | R |
| Sonny Siebert (12) | 29.4 | R | |
| Lee Smith (18) | 29.4 | R | |
| 287. | Mike Cuellar (15) | 29.3 | L |
| 288. | Bill Doak (16) | 29.2 | R |
| Frank Lary (12) | 29.2 | R | |
| Ted Lilly (15, 37) | 29.2 | L | |
| Billy Rhines (9) | 29.2 | R | |
| Kevin Tapani (13) | 29.2 | R | |
| 293. | Mike Morgan (22) | 28.9 | R |
| 294. | Jim Bagby (9) | 28.8 | R |
| 295. | Eddie Lopat (12) | 28.7 | L |
| Lindy McDaniel (21) | 28.7 | R | |
| Joe Niekro (22) | 28.7 | R | |
| Jim Scott (9) | 28.7 | R | |
| 299. | Pedro Astacio (15) | 28.4 | R |
| Monte Ward+ (17) | 28.4 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 301. | Mike Moore (14) | 28.2 | R |
| Johnny Podres (15) | 28.2 | L | |
| Adonis Terry (14) | 28.2 | R | |
| 304. | Johnny Allen (13) | 28.1 | R |
| Red Ames (17) | 28.1 | R | |
| Jack McDowell (12) | 28.1 | R | |
| 307. | Trevor Hoffman (18) | 28.0 | R |
| 308. | Bob Buhl (15) | 27.9 | R |
| Alex Fernandez (10) | 27.9 | R | |
| Guy Hecker (9) | 27.9 | R | |
| Bill Sherdel (15) | 27.9 | L | |
| Jarrod Washburn (12) | 27.9 | L | |
| 313. | Ed Brandt (11) | 27.8 | L |
| Doug Drabek (13) | 27.8 | R | |
| 315. | Turk Farrell (14) | 27.7 | R |
| Fred Toney (12) | 27.7 | R | |
| Billy Wagner (16) | 27.7 | L | |
| Woody Williams (15) | 27.7 | R | |
| Don Wilson (9) | 27.7 | R | |
| 320. | Joe Dobson (14) | 27.5 | R |
| 321. | Larry Corcoran (8) | 27.4 | R |
| Mel Parnell (10) | 27.4 | L | |
| 323. | Stu Miller (16) | 27.3 | R |
| 324. | Clayton Kershaw (6, 25) | 27.2 | L |
| 325. | Ken Forsch (16) | 27.1 | R |
| Ken Holtzman (15) | 27.1 | L | |
| 327. | Hal Schumacher (13) | 27.0 | R |
| Johnny Vander Meer (13) | 27.0 | L | |
| 329. | Mario Soto (12) | 26.9 | R |
| 330. | Tim Belcher (14) | 26.8 | R |
| Ewell Blackwell (10) | 26.8 | R | |
| 332. | Floyd Bannister (15) | 26.7 | L |
| Jouett Meekin (10) | 26.7 | R | |
| Kerry Wood (14) | 26.7 | R | |
| 335. | Mark Baldwin (7) | 26.6 | R |
| Jon Lester (8, 29) | 26.6 | L | |
| Joe Nuxhall (16) | 26.6 | L | |
| 338. | A.J. Burnett (15, 36) | 26.3 | R |
| Tommy Thomas (12) | 26.3 | R | |
| Hooks Wiltse (12) | 26.3 | L | |
| 341. | Watty Clark (12) | 26.2 | L |
| Vern Law (16) | 26.2 | R | |
| Kent Tekulve (16) | 26.2 | R | |
| 344. | Dennis Leonard (12) | 26.1 | R |
| Danny MacFayden (17) | 26.1 | R | |
| Ramon Martinez (14) | 26.1 | R | |
| Ben Sheets (10) | 26.1 | R | |
| Dave Stewart (16) | 26.1 | R | |
| 349. | Mike Flanagan (18) | 26.0 | L |
| Kevin Gross (15) | 26.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Allie Reynolds (13) | 26.0 | R | |
| Jake Weimer (7) | 26.0 | L | |
| 353. | Lew Burdette (18) | 25.8 | R |
| Harry Staley (8) | 25.8 | R | |
| 355. | Denny Galehouse (15) | 25.7 | R |
| Tex Hughson (8) | 25.7 | R | |
| Gary Nolan (10) | 25.7 | R | |
| 358. | Charlie Ferguson (4) | 25.5 | R |
| Joe Horlen (12) | 25.5 | R | |
| Ray Kremer (10) | 25.5 | R | |
| 361. | George Blaeholder (11) | 25.4 | R |
| Jon Lieber (14) | 25.4 | R | |
| Art Nehf (15) | 25.4 | L | |
| Johnny Sain (11) | 25.4 | R | |
| Tully Sparks (12) | 25.4 | R | |
| 366. | Jeff Fassero (16) | 25.2 | L |
| Livan Hernandez (17) | 25.2 | R | |
| Ed Killian (8) | 25.2 | L | |
| Dave McNally (14) | 25.2 | L | |
| 370. | Red Ehret (11) | 25.1 | R |
| Charles Nagy (14) | 25.1 | R | |
| 372. | Wilson Alvarez (14) | 25.0 | L |
| Hal Carlson (14) | 25.0 | R | |
| Joe Coleman (15) | 25.0 | R | |
| Kelvim Escobar (12, 37) | 25.0 | R | |
| Rollie Fingers+ (17) | 25.0 | R | |
| Claude Hendrix (10) | 25.0 | R | |
| Josh Johnson (9, 29) | 25.0 | R | |
| Ron Reed (19) | 25.0 | R | |
| Rip Sewell (13) | 25.0 | R | |
| 381. | Scott Erickson (15) | 24.9 | R |
| Bob Purkey (13) | 24.9 | R | |
| Dan Quisenberry (12) | 24.9 | R | |
| 384. | Bronson Arroyo (14, 36) | 24.8 | R |
| Vean Gregg (8) | 24.8 | L | |
| John Lackey (11, 34) | 24.8 | R | |
| Lefty Stewart (10) | 24.8 | L | |
| Steve Trachsel (16) | 24.8 | R | |
| Bob Veale (13) | 24.8 | L | |
| 390. | Bob Ojeda (15) | 24.7 | L |
| 391. | Chris Bosio (11) | 24.6 | R |
| Juan Guzman (10) | 24.6 | R | |
| Bob Smith (15) | 24.6 | R | |
| Ismael Valdez (12) | 24.6 | R | |
| 395. | Al Benton (14) | 24.5 | R |
| Tiny Bonham (10) | 24.5 | R | |
| Jack Coombs (14) | 24.5 | R | |
| Bruce Sutter+ (12) | 24.5 | R | |
| 399. | Johnny Schmitz (13) | 24.4 | L |
| Carl Weilman (8) | 24.4 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 401. | Sam Gray (10) | 24.3 | R |
| 402. | Barney Pelty (10) | 24.0 | R |
| Mike Scott (13) | 24.0 | R | |
| Mike Torrez (18) | 24.0 | R | |
| 405. | Bill Gullickson (14) | 23.9 | R |
| Win Mercer (9) | 23.9 | R | |
| 407. | Stan Bahnsen (16) | 23.8 | R |
| Earl Hamilton (14) | 23.8 | L | |
| Tim Lincecum (7, 29) | 23.8 | R | |
| Bob Stanley (13) | 23.8 | R | |
| 411. | John Franco (21) | 23.7 | L |
| Ben Sanders (5) | 23.7 | R | |
| Sherry Smith (14) | 23.7 | L | |
| 414. | Joe Nathan (13, 38) | 23.5 | R |
| Stan Williams (14) | 23.5 | R | |
| 416. | Guy Bush (17) | 23.3 | R |
| Dick Ellsworth (13) | 23.3 | L | |
| Dave Goltz (12) | 23.3 | R | |
| Dutch Ruether (11) | 23.3 | L | |
| Lefty Tyler (12) | 23.3 | L | |
| 421. | Spud Chandler (11) | 23.2 | R |
| Ryan Dempster (16, 36) | 23.2 | R | |
| Orlando Hernandez (9) | 23.2 | R | |
| 424. | Ray Collins (7) | 23.1 | L |
| Cy Falkenberg (12) | 23.1 | R | |
| Tom Henke (14) | 23.1 | R | |
| Esteban Loaiza (14, 41) | 23.1 | R | |
| 428. | Larry Jansen (9) | 23.0 | R |
| 429. | Ken Hill (14) | 22.9 | R |
| Sparky Lyle (16) | 22.9 | L | |
| Jesse Orosco (24) | 22.9 | L | |
| Frank Sullivan (11) | 22.9 | R | |
| Ed Whitson (15) | 22.9 | R | |
| 434. | Matt Kilroy (10) | 22.8 | L |
| Nels Potter (12) | 22.8 | R | |
| Dick Rudolph (13) | 22.8 | R | |
| Paul Splittorff (15) | 22.8 | L | |
| Stump Wiedman (9) | 22.8 | R | |
| 439. | Dave Foutz (13) | 22.7 | R |
| Jon Garland (13, 33) | 22.7 | R | |
| Don McMahon (18) | 22.7 | R | |
| 442. | Orval Overall (7) | 22.6 | R |
| 443. | Al Downing (17) | 22.5 | L |
| Steve Gromek (17) | 22.5 | R | |
| Bill Monbouquette (11) | 22.5 | R | |
| Don Mossi (12) | 22.5 | L | |
| Denny Neagle (13) | 22.5 | L | |
| Gary Peters (14) | 22.5 | L | |
| 449. | Erik Hanson (11) | 22.4 | R |
| Billy O'Dell (13) | 22.4 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Pedro Ramos (15) | 22.4 | R | |
| Whit Wyatt (16) | 22.4 | R | |
| 453. | Dan Casey (7) | 22.3 | L |
| Adam Wainwright (8, 31) | 22.3 | R | |
| 455. | Henry Boyle (6) | 22.2 | R |
| Dave Roberts (13) | 22.2 | L | |
| 457. | Ray Fisher (10) | 21.9 | R |
| Gerry Staley (15) | 21.9 | R | |
| 459. | Al Brazle (10) | 21.8 | L |
| Hideo Nomo (12) | 21.8 | R | |
| Mike Witt (12) | 21.8 | R | |
| 462. | Larry Gura (16) | 21.7 | L |
| 463. | John Burkett (15) | 21.6 | R |
| Reb Russell (9) | 21.6 | L | |
| 465. | Andy Ashby (14) | 21.5 | R |
| Doug Davis (13) | 21.5 | L | |
| George McQuillan (10) | 21.5 | R | |
| J.R. Richard (10) | 21.5 | R | |
| Bob Tewksbury (13) | 21.5 | R | |
| 470. | George Bradley (11) | 21.4 | R |
| Oral Hildebrand (10) | 21.4 | R | |
| Rick Honeycutt (21) | 21.4 | L | |
| Mike Krukow (14) | 21.4 | R | |
| Bill Lee (14) | 21.4 | L | |
| Lefty Leifield (12) | 21.4 | L | |
| John Montefusco (13) | 21.4 | R | |
| Johnny Morrison (10) | 21.4 | R | |
| Jim O'Toole (10) | 21.4 | L | |
| Dave Righetti (16) | 21.4 | L | |
| 480. | Roy Face (16) | 21.3 | R |
| Doug Jones (16) | 21.3 | R | |
| 482. | Jim Clancy (15) | 21.2 | R |
| Rick Helling (12) | 21.2 | R | |
| Marty Pattin (13) | 21.2 | R | |
| Ed Siever (7) | 21.2 | L | |
| 486. | Buddy Black (15) | 21.1 | L |
| James Shields (8, 31) | 21.1 | R | |
| Todd Stottlemyre (14) | 21.1 | R | |
| 489. | Hank Aguirre (16) | 21.0 | L |
| Bob Knepper (15) | 21.0 | L | |
| Tug McGraw (19) | 21.0 | L | |
| Darren Oliver (20, 42) | 21.0 | L | |
| Toad Ramsey (6) | 21.0 | L | |
| Steve Renko (15) | 21.0 | R | |
| Jeff Tesreau (7) | 21.0 | R | |
| 496. | Jesse Barnes (13) | 20.9 | R |
| Aaron Harang (12, 35) | 20.9 | R | |
| Pat Malone (10) | 20.9 | R | |
| Shane Rawley (12) | 20.9 | L | |
| Johnny Rigney (8) | 20.9 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Zane Smith (13) | 20.9 | L | |
| Jack Taylor (9) | 20.9 | R | |
| 503. | Dick Donovan (15) | 20.8 | R |
| Mike Hampton (16) | 20.8 | L | |
| Rudy May (16) | 20.8 | L | |
| Ben McDonald (9) | 20.8 | R | |
| Denny McLain (10) | 20.8 | R | |
| Ed Seward (6) | 20.8 | R | |
| 509. | Rick Aguilera (16) | 20.7 | R |
| Joe Benz (9) | 20.7 | R | |
| Keith Foulke (11) | 20.7 | R | |
| Fred Hutchinson (11) | 20.7 | R | |
| Geoff Zahn (13) | 20.7 | L | |
| 514. | Nelson Briles (14) | 20.6 | R |
| Jeff Montgomery (13) | 20.6 | R | |
| Babe Ruth+ (22) | 20.6 | L | |
| Earl Wilson (11) | 20.6 | R | |
| 518. | Dick Drago (13) | 20.5 | R |
| Darryl Kile (12) | 20.5 | R | |
| Vic Sorrell (10) | 20.5 | R | |
| Randy Wolf (14) | 20.5 | L | |
| 522. | Ken Johnson (13) | 20.4 | R |
| Ron Kline (17) | 20.4 | R | |
| George Suggs (8) | 20.4 | R | |
| 525. | Clarence Mitchell (18) | 20.3 | L |
| 526. | Scott McGregor (13) | 20.2 | L |
| Rick Reed (15) | 20.2 | R | |
| Aaron Sele (15) | 20.2 | R | |
| 529. | George Earnshaw (9) | 20.0 | R |
| Sam Jones (12) | 20.0 | R | |
| Doc Medich (11) | 20.0 | R | |
| Togie Pittinger (8) | 20.0 | R | |
| John Smiley (12) | 20.0 | L | |
| 534. | Moe Drabowsky (17) | 19.9 | R |
| 535. | Jim Abbott (10) | 19.8 | L |
| Lloyd Brown (12) | 19.8 | L | |
| Frank Kitson (10) | 19.8 | R | |
| 538. | Tom Browning (12) | 19.7 | L |
| Gary Lavelle (13) | 19.7 | L | |
| 540. | Clint Brown (15) | 19.6 | R |
| John Danks (6, 28) | 19.6 | L | |
| Kirby Higbe (12) | 19.6 | R | |
| Mark Mulder (9) | 19.6 | L | |
| 544. | Johnny Niggeling (9) | 19.5 | R |
| Fritz Peterson (11) | 19.5 | L | |
| Francisco Rodriguez (11, 31) | 19.5 | R | |
| Jim Tobin (9) | 19.5 | R | |
| 548. | Ivy Andrews (8) | 19.4 | R |
| Mudcat Grant (14) | 19.4 | R | |
| Jeremy Guthrie (10, 34) | 19.4 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Rick Mahler (13) | 19.4 | R | |
| Guy Morton (11) | 19.4 | R | |
| Brad Penny (13) | 19.4 | R | |
| Jim Shaw (9) | 19.4 | R | |
| Bill Singer (14) | 19.4 | R | |
| 556. | Larry Benton (13) | 19.3 | R |
| Mark Eichhorn (11) | 19.3 | R | |
| Greg Harris (15) | 19.3 | R | |
| Bill Hoffer (6) | 19.3 | R | |
| 560. | Mike Timlin (18) | 19.2 | R |
| John Wetteland (12) | 19.2 | R | |
| 562. | Bob Forsch (16) | 19.1 | R |
| Pascual Perez (11) | 19.1 | R | |
| Jeff Reardon (16) | 19.1 | R | |
| Bob Shaw (11) | 19.1 | R | |
| Bill Swift (11) | 19.1 | R | |
| 567. | Leon Cadore (10) | 19.0 | R |
| Mike Caldwell (14) | 19.0 | L | |
| Ron Darling (13) | 19.0 | R | |
| Pretzels Getzien (9) | 19.0 | R | |
| Pete Harnisch (14) | 19.0 | R | |
| Denny Lemaster (11) | 19.0 | L | |
| Ron Perranoski (13) | 19.0 | L | |
| 574. | Monte Pearson (10) | 18.9 | R |
| Steve Stone (11) | 18.9 | R | |
| 576. | Michael Jackson (17) | 18.8 | R |
| Randy Jones (10) | 18.8 | L | |
| Ted Lewis (6) | 18.8 | R | |
| Dupee Shaw (6) | 18.8 | L | |
| 580. | Howie Camnitz (11) | 18.7 | R |
| Rip Collins (11) | 18.7 | R | |
| Slim Harriss (9) | 18.7 | R | |
| Jonathan Papelbon (9, 32) | 18.7 | R | |
| Jack Russell (15) | 18.7 | R | |
| Bill Swift (13) | 18.7 | R | |
| 586. | Jim Bibby (12) | 18.5 | R |
| Terry Forster (16) | 18.5 | L | |
| Roberto Hernandez (17) | 18.5 | R | |
| 589. | Clay Carroll (15) | 18.4 | R |
| Cherokee Fisher (8) | 18.4 | R | |
| Woodie Fryman (18) | 18.4 | L | |
| 592. | Jack Kralick (9) | 18.3 | L |
| Matt Morris (11) | 18.3 | R | |
| Ed Stein (8) | 18.3 | R | |
| 595. | Steve Barber (15) | 18.2 | L |
| Bill Bonham (10) | 18.2 | R | |
| Ernie Broglio (8) | 18.2 | R | |
| Max Butcher (10) | 18.2 | R | |
| Pat Dobson (11) | 18.2 | R | |
| Ned Garvin (7) | 18.2 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Harry Gumbert (15) | 18.2 | R | |
| Chan Ho Park (17) | 18.2 | R | |
| 603. | Oil Can Boyd (10) | 18.1 | R |
| Shane Reynolds (13) | 18.1 | R | |
| 605. | Britt Burns (8) | 18.0 | L |
| Steve Farr (11) | 18.0 | R | |
| Danny Jackson (15) | 18.0 | L | |
| Paul Quantrill (14) | 18.0 | R | |
| Jack Warhop (8) | 18.0 | R | |
| 610. | Bob Miller (17) | 17.9 | R |
| Bill Wegman (11) | 17.9 | R | |
| 612. | Larry Cheney (9) | 17.7 | R |
| Rich Harden (9) | 17.7 | R | |
| Vinegar Bend Mizell (9) | 17.7 | L | |
| Steve Reed (14) | 17.7 | R | |
| Frank Smith (11) | 17.7 | R | |
| Bill Walker (10) | 17.7 | L | |
| 618. | Dave Koslo (12) | 17.6 | L |
| Carl Morton (8) | 17.6 | R | |
| Jesse Petty (7) | 17.6 | L | |
| Jack Sanford (12) | 17.6 | R | |
| 622. | Jose DeLeon (13) | 17.5 | R |
| Duke Esper (9) | 17.5 | L | |
| Moose Haas (12) | 17.5 | R | |
| Ubaldo Jimenez (8, 29) | 17.5 | R | |
| Willie Mitchell (11) | 17.5 | L | |
| Jim Slaton (16) | 17.5 | R | |
| Ted Wilks (10) | 17.5 | R | |
| 629. | Armando Benitez (15) | 17.4 | R |
| Ray Culp (11) | 17.4 | R | |
| Jim Hearn (13) | 17.4 | R | |
| Mike Marshall (14) | 17.4 | R | |
| Fred Norman (16) | 17.4 | L | |
| 634. | Storm Davis (13) | 17.3 | R |
| Dick Ruthven (14) | 17.3 | R | |
| 636. | Fred Frankhouse (13) | 17.2 | R |
| Milt Gaston (11) | 17.2 | R | |
| Troy Percival (14) | 17.2 | R | |
| Dan Plesac (18) | 17.2 | L | |
| 640. | Rube Benton (15) | 17.1 | L |
| Kyle Lohse (13, 34) | 17.1 | R | |
| Mike McCormick (16) | 17.1 | L | |
| Gil Meche (10) | 17.1 | R | |
| Dan Petry (13) | 17.1 | R | |
| Jimmy Ring (12) | 17.1 | R | |
| Al Worthington (14) | 17.1 | R | |
| 647. | Hal Brown (14) | 17.0 | R |
| Don Cardwell (14) | 17.0 | R | |
| Chick Fraser (14) | 17.0 | R | |
| Greg Minton (16) | 17.0 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Carl Pavano (14) | 17.0 | R | |
| Bob Porterfield (12) | 17.0 | R | |
| Jim Rooker (13) | 17.0 | L | |
| Anibal Sanchez (8, 29) | 17.0 | R | |
| 655. | Vic Aldridge (9) | 16.9 | R |
| Chad Billingsley (8, 28) | 16.9 | R | |
| Tom Burgmeier (17) | 16.9 | L | |
| Francisco Cordero (14) | 16.9 | R | |
| Dick Hall (19) | 16.9 | R | |
| Billy Hoeft (15) | 16.9 | L | |
| Hiroki Kuroda (6, 38) | 16.9 | R | |
| 662. | Joaquin Andujar (13) | 16.8 | R |
| Bob Wickman (15) | 16.8 | R | |
| 664. | Ted Abernathy (14) | 16.7 | R |
| Don Gullett (9) | 16.7 | L | |
| Ken Heintzelman (13) | 16.7 | L | |
| Scott Kazmir (9, 29) | 16.7 | L | |
| 668. | Bobby Bolin (13) | 16.6 | R |
| Roger Craig (12) | 16.6 | R | |
| Carl Erskine (12) | 16.6 | R | |
| Gene Garber (19) | 16.6 | R | |
| Willie Hernandez (13) | 16.6 | L | |
| Vic Raschi (10) | 16.6 | R | |
| Pete Vuckovich (11) | 16.6 | R | |
| 675. | Roy Patterson (7) | 16.5 | R |
| Bryn Smith (13) | 16.5 | R | |
| 677. | Erik Bedard (10, 34) | 16.4 | L |
| Cal Eldred (14) | 16.4 | R | |
| Dummy Taylor (9) | 16.4 | R | |
| 680. | Ralph Branca (12) | 16.3 | R |
| Jim Colborn (10) | 16.3 | R | |
| Harry Coveleski (9) | 16.3 | L | |
| Ray Herbert (14) | 16.3 | R | |
| 684. | Dave Burba (15) | 16.2 | R |
| Steve Busby (8) | 16.2 | R | |
| Richard Dotson (12) | 16.2 | R | |
| Paul Minner (10) | 16.2 | L | |
| Juan Pizarro (18) | 16.2 | L | |
| Ray Sadecki (18) | 16.2 | L | |
| Eddie Smith (10) | 16.2 | L | |
| 691. | Bill Bernhard (9) | 16.1 | R |
| Dave Giusti (15) | 16.1 | R | |
| Cliff Melton (8) | 16.1 | L | |
| Jim Merritt (11) | 16.1 | L | |
| Dick Radatz (7) | 16.1 | R | |
| 696. | Scott Baker (7, 31) | 16.0 | R |
| Tex Carleton (8) | 16.0 | R | |
| Pete Donohue (12) | 16.0 | R | |
| Bob Groom (10) | 16.0 | R | |
| Jake Miller (9) | 16.0 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Mark Portugal (15) | 16.0 | R | |
| Kirk Rueter (13) | 16.0 | L | |
| 703. | Paul Byrd (14) | 15.9 | R |
| Jimmy Callahan (13) | 15.9 | R | |
| Ed Figueroa (8) | 15.9 | R | |
| Bill Hallahan (12) | 15.9 | L | |
| 707. | Elden Auker (10) | 15.8 | R |
| George Hemming (8) | 15.8 | R | |
| Eric Milton (11) | 15.8 | L | |
| Alejandro Pena (15) | 15.8 | R | |
| Dave Rozema (10) | 15.8 | R | |
| Jeff Suppan (17) | 15.8 | R | |
| 713. | Hank Borowy (10) | 15.7 | R |
| Jim Brewer (17) | 15.7 | L | |
| Phil Collins (8) | 15.7 | R | |
| Gene Conley (11) | 15.7 | R | |
| Octavio Dotel (15, 39) | 15.7 | R | |
| Al Fitzmorris (10) | 15.7 | R | |
| Mickey Haefner (8) | 15.7 | L | |
| LaTroy Hawkins (19, 40) | 15.7 | R | |
| Red Munger (10) | 15.7 | R | |
| Mark Prior (5, 32) | 15.7 | R | |
| 723. | Aaron Cook (11, 34) | 15.6 | R |
| Ad Gumbert (9) | 15.6 | R | |
| Joey Jay (13) | 15.6 | R | |
| Scott Perry (7) | 15.6 | R | |
| 727. | Gavin Floyd (10, 30) | 15.5 | R |
| Joey Hamilton (10) | 15.5 | R | |
| Ray Kolp (12) | 15.5 | R | |
| Lew Richie (8) | 15.5 | R | |
| 731. | Steve Bedrosian (14) | 15.4 | R |
| Frank Foreman (11) | 15.4 | R | |
| Dennis Lamp (16) | 15.4 | R | |
| Dontrelle Willis (9) | 15.4 | L | |
| 735. | Ray Burris (15) | 15.3 | R |
| Luke Hamlin (9) | 15.3 | R | |
| David Price (6, 27) | 15.3 | L | |
| Eric Show (11) | 15.3 | R | |
| 739. | Jim Beattie (9) | 15.2 | R |
| Ray Benge (12) | 15.2 | R | |
| Dixie Davis (10) | 15.2 | R | |
| Bob Muncrief (12) | 15.2 | R | |
| Randy Myers (14) | 15.2 | L | |
| Robb Nen (10) | 15.2 | R | |
| 745. | Dock Ellis (12) | 15.1 | R |
| Bill Henry (16) | 15.1 | L | |
| Jay Howell (15) | 15.1 | R | |
| Doc McJames (6) | 15.1 | R | |
| Wade Miller (9) | 15.1 | R | |
| Johnny Murphy (13) | 15.1 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 751. | Don Aase (13) | 15.0 | R |
| Tom Hughes (13) | 15.0 | R | |
| Arthur Rhodes (20) | 15.0 | L | |
| Jake Westbrook (13, 35) | 15.0 | R | |
| 755. | Johnny Cueto (6, 27) | 14.9 | R |
| Jim Lonborg (15) | 14.9 | R | |
| Al Mamaux (12) | 14.9 | R | |
| Brett Myers (12, 32) | 14.9 | R | |
| Bobby Witt (16) | 14.9 | R | |
| 760. | Rafael Betancourt (11, 38) | 14.8 | R |
| Cy Blanton (9) | 14.8 | R | |
| Phil Douglas (9) | 14.8 | R | |
| Jeff Nelson (15) | 14.8 | R | |
| Jeff Russell (14) | 14.8 | R | |
| 765. | Doc Ayers (9) | 14.7 | R |
| Bill Duggleby (8) | 14.7 | R | |
| Paul Maholm (9, 31) | 14.7 | L | |
| 768. | Rick Waits (12) | 14.6 | L |
| 769. | Joe Shaute (13) | 14.5 | L |
| 770. | Gary Bell (12) | 14.4 | R |
| Dave Dravecky (8) | 14.4 | L | |
| Casey Patten (8) | 14.4 | L | |
| Willie Sudhoff (10) | 14.4 | R | |
| 774. | Miguel Batista (18, 42) | 14.3 | R |
| Jim Brosnan (9) | 14.3 | R | |
| Clem Labine (13) | 14.3 | R | |
| Dave LaRoche (14) | 14.3 | L | |
| Kirk McCaskill (12) | 14.3 | R | |
| Lynn McGlothen (11) | 14.3 | R | |
| 780. | Dave Davenport (6) | 14.2 | R |
| Grant Jackson (18) | 14.2 | L | |
| Bruce Kison (15) | 14.2 | R | |
| Ervin Santana (9, 30) | 14.2 | R | |
| Elam Vangilder (11) | 14.2 | R | |
| 785. | Lady Baldwin (6) | 14.1 | L |
| Francisco Cordova (5) | 14.1 | R | |
| Dick Tidrow (13) | 14.1 | R | |
| Bob Turley (12) | 14.1 | R | |
| Jeff Weaver (11) | 14.1 | R | |
| 790. | R.A. Dickey (11, 38) | 14.0 | R |
| Harry Harper (10) | 14.0 | L | |
| Jim Kern (13) | 14.0 | R | |
| Herb Score (8) | 14.0 | L | |
| Allan Sothoron (11) | 14.0 | R | |
| Chris Young (9, 34) | 14.0 | R | |
| 796. | Jesse Flores (7) | 13.9 | R |
| Chuck Stobbs (15) | 13.9 | L | |
| 798. | Ben Cantwell (11) | 13.8 | R |
| Ruben Gomez (10) | 13.8 | R | |
| Carl Lundgren (8) | 13.8 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Johnny Marcum (7) | 13.8 | R | |
| Mickey McDermott (12) | 13.8 | L | |
| Cy Morgan (10) | 13.8 | R | |
| Jeff Shaw (12) | 13.8 | R | |
| Mike Stanton (19) | 13.8 | L | |
| 806. | Larry Andersen (17) | 13.7 | R |
| Jim Deshaies (12) | 13.7 | L | |
| Jim Hughes (4) | 13.7 | R | |
| Joel Pineiro (12) | 13.7 | R | |
| Wandy Rodriguez (9, 34) | 13.7 | L | |
| 811. | Matt Clement (9) | 13.6 | R |
| Jose Contreras (11, 41) | 13.6 | R | |
| Fred Goldsmith (7) | 13.6 | R | |
| Jose Guzman (8) | 13.6 | R | |
| Warren Hacker (12) | 13.6 | R | |
| Pat Jarvis (8) | 13.6 | R | |
| Al McBean (10) | 13.6 | R | |
| Lary Sorensen (11) | 13.6 | R | |
| Bill Wight (12) | 13.6 | L | |
| 820. | Huck Betts (10) | 13.5 | R |
| Jesse Duryea (5) | 13.5 | R | |
| Marv Grissom (10) | 13.5 | R | |
| 823. | Rick Camp (9) | 13.4 | R |
| Greg Harris (8) | 13.4 | R | |
| Shaun Marcum (8, 31) | 13.4 | R | |
| Eric Plunk (14) | 13.4 | R | |
| 827. | Matt Garza (7, 29) | 13.3 | R |
| Eddie Guardado (17) | 13.3 | L | |
| Johnny Klippstein (18) | 13.3 | R | |
| Pete Richert (13) | 13.3 | L | |
| Scott Stratton (8) | 13.3 | R | |
| Ralph Terry (12) | 13.3 | R | |
| Steve Trout (12) | 13.3 | L | |
| Chien-Ming Wang (7, 33) | 13.3 | R | |
| Lefty Williams (7) | 13.3 | L | |
| 836. | Paul Assenmacher (14) | 13.2 | L |
| Len Barker (11) | 13.2 | R | |
| Kris Benson (9) | 13.2 | R | |
| Sid Hudson (12) | 13.2 | R | |
| Erskine Mayer (8) | 13.2 | R | |
| Omar Olivares (12) | 13.2 | R | |
| Ugueth Urbina (11) | 13.2 | R | |
| Sam Weaver (6) | 13.2 | R | |
| 844. | Orlando Pena (14) | 13.1 | R |
| Milt Wilcox (16) | 13.1 | R | |
| 846. | Vern Bickford (7) | 13.0 | R |
| Clay Buchholz (7, 28) | 13.0 | R | |
| Yovani Gallardo (7, 27) | 13.0 | R | |
| Rafael Soriano (12, 33) | 13.0 | R | |
| Justin Thompson (5) | 13.0 | L | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| 851. | Red Barrett (11) | 12.9 | R |
| Mike Henneman (10) | 12.9 | R | |
| Don Robinson (15) | 12.9 | R | |
| 854. | LaMarr Hoyt (8) | 12.8 | R |
| Kent Mercker (18) | 12.8 | L | |
| Terry Mulholland (20) | 12.8 | L | |
| Gregg Olson (14) | 12.8 | R | |
| Sloppy Thurston (9) | 12.8 | R | |
| 859. | Hugh Casey (9) | 12.7 | R |
| Dustin Hermanson (12) | 12.7 | R | |
| 861. | Tom Brewer (8) | 12.6 | R |
| Bill Campbell (15) | 12.6 | R | |
| Fred Glade (6) | 12.6 | R | |
| Russ Meyer (13) | 12.6 | R | |
| Jack Scott (12) | 12.6 | R | |
| Mike Smith (14) | 12.6 | L | |
| Craig Swan (12) | 12.6 | R | |
| Dave Veres (10) | 12.6 | R | |
| George Winter (8) | 12.6 | R | |
| 870. | Steve Avery (11) | 12.5 | L |
| Doc Crandall (10) | 12.5 | R | |
| Art Fromme (10) | 12.5 | R | |
| Alex Kellner (12) | 12.5 | L | |
| Frank Linzy (11) | 12.5 | R | |
| J.J. Putz (11, 36) | 12.5 | R | |
| Doug Rau (9) | 12.5 | L | |
| Joakim Soria (5, 29) | 12.5 | R | |
| Jose Valverde (11, 35) | 12.5 | R | |
| Bob Weiland (12) | 12.5 | L | |
| 880. | Tim Burke (8) | 12.4 | R |
| Bryan Harvey (9) | 12.4 | R | |
| 882. | Ken Brett (14) | 12.3 | L |
| Sandy Consuegra (8) | 12.3 | R | |
| Edwin Jackson (11, 29) | 12.3 | R | |
| Brian Moehler (14) | 12.3 | R | |
| Pat Ragan (11) | 12.3 | R | |
| Armando Reynoso (12) | 12.3 | R | |
| Max Scherzer (6, 28) | 12.3 | R | |
| Bill Voiselle (9) | 12.3 | R | |
| Hank Wyse (8) | 12.3 | R | |
| 891. | Sheriff Blake (10) | 12.2 | R |
| Bob Harmon (9) | 12.2 | R | |
| Jason Isringhausen (16) | 12.2 | R | |
| Darold Knowles (16) | 12.2 | L | |
| Don Larsen (14) | 12.2 | R | |
| Doc Scanlan (8) | 12.2 | R | |
| Scot Shields (10) | 12.2 | R | |
| Lee Viau (5) | 12.2 | R | |
| John Whitehead (7) | 12.2 | R | |
| 900. | Ted Blankenship (9) | 12.1 | R |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Buster Brown (9) | 12.1 | R | |
| Trevor Cahill (5, 25) | 12.1 | R | |
| Diego Segui (15) | 12.1 | R | |
| Chuck Taylor (8) | 12.1 | R | |
| 905. | Mace Brown (10) | 12.0 | R |
| Al Holland (10) | 12.0 | L | |
| Si Johnson (17) | 12.0 | R | |
| George Pipgras (11) | 12.0 | R | |
| Elmer Riddle (10) | 12.0 | R | |
| Vern Ruhle (13) | 12.0 | R | |
| Dave Smith (13) | 12.0 | R | |
| C.J. Wilson (9, 32) | 12.0 | L | |
| 913. | John Buzhardt (11) | 11.9 | R |
| Curt Leskanic (11) | 11.9 | R | |
| Frank Miller (7) | 11.9 | R | |
| Tomo Ohka (10) | 11.9 | R | |
| Vicente Padilla (14) | 11.9 | R | |
| 918. | Gio Gonzalez (6, 27) | 11.8 | L |
| Jim Konstanty (11) | 11.8 | R | |
| Phil Regan (13) | 11.8 | R | |
| Pat Zachry (10) | 11.8 | R | |
| 922. | Hugh Daily (6) | 11.7 | R |
| Tom Ferrick (9) | 11.7 | R | |
| Eric Gagne (10) | 11.7 | R | |
| Jack Knott (11) | 11.7 | R | |
| Larry McWilliams (13) | 11.7 | L | |
| Jose Mesa (19) | 11.7 | R | |
| 928. | Ryan Franklin (12) | 11.6 | R |
| Ed Halicki (7) | 11.6 | R | |
| Steve Hargan (12) | 11.6 | R | |
| Shigetoshi Hasegawa (9) | 11.6 | R | |
| Tom Hughes (9) | 11.6 | R | |
| Walt Masterson (14) | 11.6 | R | |
| Al Maul (15) | 11.6 | R | |
| Ramiro Mendoza (10) | 11.6 | R | |
| Chris Sale (4, 24) | 11.6 | L | |
| John Thomson (10) | 11.6 | R | |
| 938. | Jeff Brantley (14) | 11.5 | R |
| Bob Rhoads (8) | 11.5 | R | |
| B.J. Ryan (11) | 11.5 | L | |
| Jim Wilson (12) | 11.5 | R | |
| 942. | Bill Caudill (9) | 11.4 | R |
| Russ Christopher (7) | 11.4 | R | |
| Al Demaree (8) | 11.4 | R | |
| Mark Fidrych (5) | 11.4 | R | |
| Jack Harshman (10) | 11.4 | L | |
| Joe Magrane (8) | 11.4 | L | |
| Andy McGaffigan (11) | 11.4 | R | |
| Mike Remlinger (14) | 11.4 | L | |
| Ken Sanders (10) | 11.4 | R | |
| Rank | Player (yrs, age) | WAR for Pitchers | Throws |
| Tom Seaton (6) | 11.4 | R | |
| Jack Wilson (9) | 11.4 | R | |
| 953. | Bernie Boland (7) | 11.3 | R |
| Dick Bosman (11) | 11.3 | R | |
| Paul Dean (9) | 11.3 | R | |
| Elmer Dessens (14) | 11.3 | R | |
| Carmen Hill (10) | 11.3 | R | |
| Melido Perez (9) | 11.3 | R | |
| Sidney Ponson (12) | 11.3 | R | |
| Ed Summers (5) | 11.3 | R | |
| Matt Thornton (10, 36) | 11.3 | L | |
| Roger Wolff (7) | 11.3 | R | |
| Clyde Wright (10) | 11.3 | L | |
| 964. | Scott Bankhead (10) | 11.2 | R |
| Rod Beck (13) | 11.2 | R | |
| Steve Hamilton (12) | 11.2 | L | |
| Byung-Hyun Kim (9) | 11.2 | R | |
| Ernie Shore (7) | 11.2 | R | |
| Todd Worrell (11) | 11.2 | R | |
| Irv Young (6) | 11.2 | L | |
| 971. | Doug Fister (5, 29) | 11.1 | R |
| Art Fowler (9) | 11.1 | R | |
| Jair Jurrjens (6, 27) | 11.1 | R | |
| Jack Pfiester (8) | 11.1 | L | |
| Mark Redman (10) | 11.1 | L | |
| Lee Richmond (6) | 11.1 | L | |
| Tom Underwood (11) | 11.1 | L | |
| Hal White (12) | 11.1 | R | |
| 979. | Joaquin Benoit (12, 35) | 11.0 | R |
| Rube Foster (5) | 11.0 | R | |
| Art Houtteman (12) | 11.0 | R | |
| Steve Karsay (11) | 11.0 | R | |
| Lee Stange (10) | 11.0 | R | |
| John Wyatt (9) | 11.0 | R | |
| 985. | Brian Anderson (13) | 10.9 | L |
| Joe Blanton (10, 32) | 10.9 | R | |
| Tom Bradley (7) | 10.9 | R | |
| Andy Coakley (9) | 10.9 | R | |
| David Palmer (10) | 10.9 | R | |
| Walt Terrell (11) | 10.9 | R | |
| Brett Tomko (14) | 10.9 | R | |
| David Weathers (19) | 10.9 | R | |
| 993. | Jeff Francis (9, 32) | 10.8 | L |
| Rick Langford (11) | 10.8 | R | |
| Phil Marchildon (9) | 10.8 | R | |
| Charlie Smith (10) | 10.8 | R | |
| Ed Willett (10) | 10.8 | R | |
| Sam Zoldak (9) | 10.8 | L | |
| 999. | Harry Gaspar (4) | 10.7 | R |
Note that seasons prior to 1876 are not included in single-season marks, but are included in career marks.