Mobile Site You Are Here > > > MLB EloRater

Elliott, Kalb, MLB Network:From MLB Network’s launch on January 1, 2009—when I used baseballreference.com’s play...

The Elo Rater will be shutting down, please see this blog post for details.

MLB EloRater

This is a community-based project with the goal of rating the best players in MLB history. Please read the fine details or view the complete ratings below.


All-Time Batters Top 10:
1. Babe Ruth+ (2557)
2. Lou Gehrig+ (2469)
3. Honus Wagner+ (2467)
4. Ty Cobb+ (2465)
5. Ted Williams+ (2461)
6. Willie Mays+ (2455)
7. Stan Musial+ (2438)
8. Hank Aaron+ (2438)
9. Frank Robinson+ (2431)
10. Eddie Collins+ (2429)


Active Batters Top 10:
1. Alex Rodriguez (2368)
2. Ichiro Suzuki (2365)
3. Albert Pujols (2322)
4. Carlos Beltran (2205)
5. Adrian Beltre (2183)
6. Miguel Cabrera (2158)
7. Robinson Cano (2111)
8. Torii Hunter (2056)
9. David Ortiz (2055)
10. Chase Utley (2053)


All-Time Pitchers Top 10:
1. Walter Johnson+ (2350)
2. Cy Young+ (2302)
3. Lefty Grove+ (2295)
4. Pete Alexander+ (2292)
5. Kid Nichols+ (2247)
6. Christy Mathewson+ (2233)
7. Randy Johnson+ (2208)
8. Greg Maddux+ (2206)
9. Tom Seaver+ (2203)
10. Warren Spahn+ (2202)


Active Pitchers Top 10:
1. Tim Hudson (2079)
2. Mark Buehrle (2037)
3. Felix Hernandez (2035)
4. CC Sabathia (2027)
5. Bartolo Colon (1954)
6. Clayton Kershaw (1901)
7. Cole Hamels (1871)
8. John Lackey (1859)
9. Zack Greinke (1859)
10. Justin Verlander (1858)

» Would You Like To Participate?

1930 Batters

1235 Pitchers