| Player | Yrs | WAR | Team (click to sort by first year) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Don Baylor | 1 | 28.32 | Oakland Athletics (88) |
| Bobby Bonds | 1 | 57.61 | St. Louis Cardinals (80) |
| Jose Canseco | 1 | 42.20 | Toronto Blue Jays (98) |
| Jack Clark | 1 | 52.91 | San Diego Padres (90) |
| Tony Clark | 1 | 12.52 | New York Mets (03) |
| Paul Dade | 3 | 1.18 | Cleveland Indians (77, 78, 79) |
| Curtis Goodwin | 2 | -1.04 | Cincinnati Reds (96, 97) |
| Cliff Johnson | 2 | 16.19 | Toronto Blue Jays (85, 86) |
| Jeffrey Leonard | 4 | 9.69 | San Francisco Giants (87, 88) Milwaukee Brewers (88) Seattle Mariners (89, 90) |
| Curt Leskanic | 2 | 12.37 | Milwaukee Brewers (00, 01) |
| John Mayberry | 1 | 24.85 | Houston Astros (68) |
| Eddie Milner | 1 | 12.80 | Cincinnati Reds (88) |
| Bobo Newsom | 3 | 48.18 | Washington Senators (43, 46, 47) |
| Omar Olivares | 2 | 15.71 | St. Louis Cardinals (93) Philadelphia Phillies (95) |
| Joe Page | 1 | 6.99 | Pittsburgh Pirates (54) |
| Kerry Robinson | 1 | -0.37 | Cincinnati Reds (99) |
| Brandon Watson | 3 | -0.37 | Washington Nationals (05, 06, 07) Cincinnati Reds (06) |
| Rick White | 3 | 2.53 | Cleveland Indians (04) Pittsburgh Pirates (05) Cincinnati Reds (06) Philadelphia Phillies (06) |