Max George Carey
- Bats Both, Throws Right
- Height 5' 11½", Weight 170 lb.
- School St. Louis Theological Seminary
- High School Concordia College (IN)
- Debut October 3, 1910
- Final Game September 29, 1929
- Born January 11, 1890 in Terre Haute, IN USA
- Died May 30, 1976 in Miami, FL USA
Born "Maximilian George Carnarius", Carey was born and raised in Indiana. He studied to become a minister before embarking on a baseball career instead. He began his pro career with the South Bend Greens of the Central League in 1909. He hit just .158 in 48 games in his first season but improved to .294 for South Bend in 1910 before being sold to the Pittsburgh Pirates late that year. He went 3-for-6 in his first taste of big league ball with the Pirates and never returned to the minors.
Carey became the Pittsburgh's regular centerfielder in 1911, hitting .258 while stealing 27 bases that summer. Two years later, he stole 61 bases, to lead the National League for the first of ten times in his career, while also pacing the circuit with 99 runs scored. In 1914, he led the NL with 17 triples, and he recorded a career-best 63 steals in 1916.
As the Deadball Era came to a close, Carey hit over .300 several times in the early 1920s. He put together his finest year in 1925, hitting .343 as a 35 year-old while leading the NL in steals for the final time with 46. The Pirates won the pennant that season, and he hit .458 in the World Series against the Washington Senators. Facing Walter Johnson in Game Seven, he had three doubles, a single, and a stolen base, while scoring three times, and Pittsburgh won the crown.
Carey struggled at the plate in 1926, hitting just .222 in 86 games for the Pirates before being sold to the Brooklyn Robins. He bounced back in 1927, hitting .266 while stealing 32 bases, but he retired in 1929 after playing in just 19 games.
After his playing days, Carey went on the be a Pirates coach in 1930 and skipper of the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1932 and 1933. He later was a manager in the AAGPBL, guiding the Milwaukee Chicks to the 1944 title, and then served as president of that league. He managed the Fort Wayne Daisies in 1950.
Carey's line of .285/.361/.386 isn't too impressive for a Hall of Famer, but three other things need to be considered:
1) Carey won a National League-record 10 stolen base titles (only Rickey Henderson led his league in stolen bases more often). He once scored 5 runs in a game without picking up a hit. He is the all-time NL leader in steals of home with 33 (only Ty Cobb had more in a career). We lack caught stealing data for much of Carey's career, but he still made the Guinness Book of World Records for his 1922 season - 51 steals in 53 tries, a record still unmatched despite much higher steal success rates in later decades. He also once reached base 9 times in a game.
2) Carey was a great defensive center fielder. He ranks among the top 10 all-time in chances per game in the outfield, 7th in outfield assists and 3rd in double plays by an OF (behind only Tris Speaker and Cobb). In 2000, Total Baseball ranked him 16th all-time in fielding wins, regardless of position; among outfielders only Speaker and Richie Ashburn were higher.
3) He spent the bulk of his career in the deadball era, making his stats appear worse in relation to players from higher-offense eras.
- 2-time NL At Bats Leader (1913 & 1914)
- NL Runs Scored Leader (1913)
- 2-time NL Triples Leader (1914 & 1923)
- 2-time NL Bases on Balls Leader (1918 & 1922)
- 10-time NL Stolen Bases Leader (1913, 1915-1920 & 1922-1925)
- 100 Runs Scored Seasons: 5 (1912 & 1922-1925)
- 200 Hits Seasons: 1 (1922)
- 50 Stolen Bases Seasons: 6 (1913, 1916, 1918, 1920, 1922 & 1923)
- Won a World Series with the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1925
- Baseball Hall of Fame: Class of 1961
|Brooklyn Dodgers Manager
- Runs, switch hitter, season, 140, 1922
- Times reached base, extra inning game, 9, July 7, 1922
- Most times two hits in an inning in a game, twice, June 22, 1925 (tied)
Year-by-Year Managerial Record
|1940||Miami Wahoos||Florida East Coast League||42-71||6th|
|1955||Cordele Orioles||Georgia-Florida League||6th||replaced Lloyd Brown|
|1956||Louisville Colonels||American Association||15-27||8th||replaced Red Marion|