From BR Bullpen
Carlos Luis Carrasco
- Bats Right, Throws Right
- Height 6' 3", Weight 215 lb.
- High School Liceo Federico Carmona
- Debut September 1, 2009
 Biographical Information
Carlos Carrasco was twice named the top prospect in the Philadelphia Phillies organization, in 2006 and 2007, and made his debut with the Cleveland Indians in 2009 after being involved in a deal at the trading deadline.
Carrasco was signed by scout Sal Agostinelli for the Phillies in November of 2003, at age 16. He debuted professionally in 2004, going 5-4 with a 3.56 ERA for the GCL Phillies. Baseball America rated the youngster as the #14 prospect in the Gulf Coast League.
Carrasco had a miserable 2005, with a 1-10 record at three stops: 1-7, 7.04 for the Lakewood Blue Claws (allowing a .302 average), 0-3, 13.50 for the Batavia Muckdogs (.392 opponent average, 8 HR in 15 1/3 IP) and 0-0, 1.80 for the GCL Phillies.
The Venezuelan right-hander had a breakout year in 2006. He won the Paul Owens Award as the top pitcher in the Phillies chain and Baseball America named him the Phillies Minor League Player of the Year. He allowed a .182 average, lowest in the Phils system, and a vast improvement over 2005. He went 12-6 with a 2.26 ERA for Lakewood and allowed 103 hits in 159 1/3 innings and just 6 home runs after giving up 8 in his brief action with Batavia in 2005. Carrasco allowed a .178 average to lefties and .186 to righties. He was 4th in the affiliated minor leagues in lowest average allowed following only Donald Veal, Philip Hughes and Matt Garza. Carlos was second in the South Atlantic League in ERA behind Matt Maloney and was third in strikeouts behind teammates Maloney and Josh Outman as the BlueClaws had the league's top staff and went on to win the title for the first time in franchise history. Carrasco also tied four others hurlers for the league lead with two complete games. Carrasco took a perfect game into the 8th inning against the Asheville Tourists and threw a combined no-hitter in another outing. He threw a third of an inning in the 2006 Futures Game, allowing two hits in a shaky appearance as the World team lost 8-4. Carrasco was left off the SAL post-season All-Star team in favor of Will Inman. Baseball America rated Carrasco as the SAL's #5 prospect, behind Andrew McCutchen, Jose Tabata, Fernando Martinez and Elvis Andrus and ahead of all the other pitchers in the league, including Inman, Outman, Maloney and Clay Buchholz. The publication also rated him as the top Philadelphia prospect.
Carrasco had another fine year in 2007. The 20-year-old went 6-2 with a 2.84 ERA and .199 opponent average for the Clearwater Threshers and made the Florida State League Mid-Season All-Star team. He was picked for the 2007 Futures Game and pitched the second inning, relieving Rick Vanden Hurk. Carrasco retired Steve Pearce on a pop-up and fanned Brent Lillibridge. Jay Bruce tripled and Chris Coghlan drew a four-pitch walk but Carrasco recovered to fan Bryan Anderson. Fautino De Los Santos replaced Carrasco on the mound for the World Team in the third inning. Carrasco was promoted to the Reading Phillies and had a 6-4, 4.86 record, with 46 walks in 70 1/3 innings including a no-hitter against the Altoona Curve. Baseball America rated him as the #6 prospect in the FSL, between Johnny Cueto and Ian Kennedy and again ranked him as the #1 Phillies prospect.
Carrasco split 2008 between Class AA Reading, where he was 7-7, and the AAA Lehigh Valley IronPigs, for which he was 2-2 with a sparkling 1.72 ERA. His overall record was 9-9, 3.69 with 155 strikeouts in 151 innings. Baseball America ranked him as the #6 prospect in the Eastern League, between Jordan Zimmermann and Fernando Martinez.
He returned to Lehigh Valley in 2009, going 6-9, 5.18 in 20 starts. In spite of this disappointing performance, he was probably the top prize in the package of four players put together by the Phillies to acquire 2008 American League Cy Young Award winner Cliff Lee from the Cleveland Indians at the trading deadline. He started 6 games for the Columbus Clippers and pitched lights out, with a 5-1 record, a 3.19 ERA and 36 strikeouts in 42 innings. He finished the 2009 International League season first with 148 strikeouts (8 ahead of Wade Davis) and tied for fourth in wins (with Drew Carpenter and Andy Mitchell). That earned him a call to the big leagues as soon as the rosters expanded on September 1st and he made his debut that very day, starting for the Indians against the Detroit Tigers. It was a rough welcome to the Show, however, as he was rocked for 9 hits, 3 walks and 6 runs in 3 innings and was charged with the loss. He went 0-4, 8.87 in 5 starts for the Indians that first season.
In 2010, Carrasco again began the season in the minors before earning a September call-up to Cleveland. In the minors, he went 10-6, 3.65 in 25 starts for Columbus, pitching 150 1/3 innings and striking out 133 batters. He tied for 9th in the 2010 IL in wins, 9th in ERA (between Richard De Los Santos and Matt Chico) and was fourth in whiffs (behind Dillon Gee, Todd Redmond and Carlos Torres). In the big leagues, he was 2-2, 3.83 in 7 starts, improving markedly over his first taste of the Show the previous year. He earned his first big league win on September 17th, when he pitched 6 innings and gave up 3 runs in an 11-4 win over the Kansas City Royals. Carrasco made the Indians' staff out of spring training in 2011 and made 21 starts before his season as cut short by injuries which required a sting on the disabled list and a rehabilitation start in Akron in June, and then ended his season in early August when an elbow problem forced him to undergo Tommy John surgery. He went 8-9, 4.62 during his stint in the majors, pitching 124 2/3 innings. In his penultimate game on July 29th, he threw a pitch at the head of Kansas City's Billy Butler, earning him a six-game suspension. However, the surgery prevented him from serving the suspension, and he then missed the entire 2012 season while recovering.
In spring training in 2013, he showed that he was on his way to returning to the majors, and the Indians decided to put him on the roster for the season's first six days, in order for him to serve his suspension before going down to AAA Columbus where he could pitch his way back into major league shape. That decision meant that once he was ready, he would be able to play immediately for Cleveland, without having first to serve the five days (the length of the suspension had been reduced in the meantime). The Indians changed their mind, however, and kept Carrasco with the club once his suspension was served. After his return to the majors on April 9th, they may have regretted their decision, as not only was he roughed up by the New York Yankees for 7 runs in 3 2/3 innings, but he was again ejected from a game, this time for throwing at Kevin Youkilis following a home run by Robinson Cano. Carlos claimed after the game that he had slipped on the mound, but umpire Jordan Baker did not even feel the need to issue a warning before tossing Carrasco. On April 12th, he was handed a suspension of 8 games, which he would not serve immediately as he had been sent to the minor leagues after his poor performance.