| Pick
| Team
| Player
| Position
| School (Type)
| Hometown
| Notes
|
| 1 | Seattle Mariners | Ken Griffey, Jr. | OF | Moeller High School (HS) | Cincinnati, OH |
|
| 2 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Mark Merchant | OF | Oviedo High School (HS) | Oviedo, FL |
|
| 3 | Minnesota Twins | Willie Banks | RHP | St. Anthony High School (HS) | Jersey City, NJ |
|
| 4 | Chicago Cubs | Mike Harkey | RHP | California State-Fullerton (Col.) | San Diego, CA |
|
| 5 | Chicago White Sox | Jack McDowell | RHP | Stanford University (Col.) | Van Nuys, CA |
|
| 6 | Atlanta Braves | Derek Lilliquist | LHP | University of Georgia (Col.) | Winter Park, FL |
|
| 7 | Baltimore Orioles | Chris Myers | LHP | Plant High School (HS) | Tampa, FL |
|
| 8 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Dan Opperman | RHP | Valley High School (HS) | Las Vegas, NV |
|
| 9 | Kansas City Royals | Kevin Appier | RHP | Antelope Valley Junior College (Col.) | Lancaster, CA |
|
| 10 | San Diego Padres | Kevin Garner | RHP-OF | University of Texas (Col.) | [[]] |
|
| 11 | Oakland Athletics | Lee Tinsley | OF | Shelby County High School (HS) | Shelbyville, KY |
|
| 12 | Montreal Expos | Delino DeShields | SS-2B | Seaford High School (HS) | Seaford, DE |
|
| 13 | Milwaukee Brewers | Bill Spiers | SS | Clemson University (Col.) | Orangeburg, SC |
|
| 14 | St. Louis Cardinals | Cris Carpenter | RHP | University of Georgia (Col.) | St. Augustine, FL |
|
| 15 | Baltimore Orioles | Brad DuVall | RHP | Virginia Tech (Col.) | [[]] | Did not sign/Compensation from Cleveland Indians for Rick Dempsey
|
| 16 | San Francisco Giants | Mike Remlinger | LHP | Dartmouth College (Col.) | Middletown, NY |
|
| 17 | Toronto Blue Jays | Alex Sanchez | RHP | UCLA (Col.) | Concord, CA |
|
| 18 | Cincinnati Reds | Jack Armstrong | RHP | University of Oklahoma (Col.) | Englewood, NJ |
|
| 19 | Texas Rangers | Brian Bohanon | LHP | North Shore High School (HS) | Houston, TX |
|
| 20 | Detroit Tigers | Bill Henderson | C | Westminster High School (HS) | Miami, FL | Compensation from Philadelphia Phillies for Lance Parrish
|
| 21 | Detroit Tigers | Steve Pegues | OF | Pontotoc High School (HS) | Pontotoc, MS |
|
| 22 | Houston Astros | Craig Biggio | C | Seton Hall University (Col.) | Smithtown, NY |
|
| 23 | Texas Rangers | Bill Haselman | C | UCLA (Col.) | Long Branch, NJ | Compensation from New York Yankees for Gary Ward
|
| 24 | New York Mets | Chris Donnels | 3B | Loyola Marymount University (Col.) | Los Angeles, CA |
|
| 25 | California Angels | John Orton | C | Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo (Col.) | Santa Cruz, CA |
|
| 26 | Boston Red Sox | Reggie Harris | RHP | Waynesboro High School (HS) | Waynesboro, VA |
|
