| Pick
| Team
| Player
| Position
| School (Type)
| Hometown
| Notes
|
| 1 | New York Mets | Shawn Abner | OF | Mechanicsburg Area Senior High School (HS) | Mechanicsburg, PA |
|
| 2 | Seattle Mariners | Billy Swift | RHP | University of Maine (Col.) | Portland, ME |
|
| 3 | Chicago Cubs | Drew Hall | LHP | Morehead State University (Col.) | Louisville, KY |
|
| 4 | Cleveland Indians | Cory Snyder | SS | Brigham Young University (Col.) | Inglewood, CA |
|
| 5 | Cincinnati Reds | Pat Pacillo | RHP | Seton Hall University (Col.) | Jersey City, NJ |
|
| 6 | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | Erik Pappas | C | Mount Carmel High School (HS) | Chicago, IL |
|
| 7 | St. Louis Cardinals | Mike Dunne | RHP | Bradley University (Col.) | South Bend, IN |
|
| 8 | Minnesota Twins | Jay Bell | SS | Tate High School (HS) | Pensacola, FL |
|
| 9 | San Francisco Giants | Alan Cockrell | OF | University of Tennessee (Col.) | Kansas City, KS |
|
| 10 | Oakland Athletics | Mark McGwire | 1B | University of Southern California (Col.) | Pomona, CA |
|
| 11 | San Diego Padres | Shane Mack | OF | UCLA (Col.) | Los Angeles, CA |
|
| 12 | Texas Rangers | Oddibe McDowell | OF | Arizona State University (Col.) | Hollywood, FL |
|
| 13 | Montreal Expos | Bob Caffrey | C | California State-Fullerton (Col.) | [[]] |
|
| 14 | Boston Red Sox | John Marzano | C | Temple University (Col.) | Philadelphia, PA |
|
| 15 | Pittsburgh Pirates | Kevin Andersh | LHP | University of New Mexico (Col.) | [[]] |
|
| 16 | Kansas City Royals | Scott Bankhead | RHP | University of North Carolina (Col.) | Raleigh, NC |
|
| 17 | Houston Astros | Don August | RHP | Chapman University (Col.) | Inglewood, CA |
|
| 18 | Milwaukee Brewers | Isaiah Clark | SS | Crockett High School (HS) | Crockett, TX |
|
| 19 | Atlanta Braves | Drew Denson | 1B-OF | Purcell Marion High School (HS) | Cincinnati, OH |
|
| 20 | Chicago White Sox | Tony Menendez | RHP | American High School (HS) | Carol City, FL | Compensation from Toronto Blue Jays for Dennis Lamp
|
| 21 | Philadelphia Phillies | Pete Smith | RHP | Burlington High School (HS) | Burlington, MA |
|
| 22 | New York Yankees | Jeff Pries | RHP | UCLA (Col.) | [[]] |
|
| 23 | Los Angeles Dodgers | Dennis Livingston | LHP | Oklahoma State University (Col.) | [[]] |
|
| 24 | San Francisco Giants | Terry Mulholland | LHP | Marietta College (Col.) | Uniontown, PA | Compensation from Detroit Tigers for Darrell Evans
|
| 25 | Baltimore Orioles | John Hoover | RHP | Fresno State University (Col.) | Fresno, CA |
|
| 26 | Chicago White Sox | Tom Hartley | OF | Hudson's Bay High School (HS) | Vancouver, WA |
|
