I had the pleasure of hearing former Commissioner Fay Vincent speak at Saint Joseph’s yesterday. He was invited to speak in John Lord’s baseball course, but the talk was open to the public. Dr. Lord has done a tremendous job bringing in speakers for this course. In the past few years, he’s had Andrew Zimbalist, Bill Giles (every semester), Gerry Hunsicker, Pat Gillick, several sportswriters and negro league players as well.
Commissioner Vincent gave a few remarks, starting with a Yogi Berra story and then going on to discuss Larry Doby’s place in history and stressing to the students that they couldn’t fathom the difficulty that Negro League players had to overcome just to play ball. He also discussed the oral history project that he and Claire Smith of the Philly Inquirer had put together for the Hall of Fame.
Some other comments.
“Warren Spahn had a unique intelligence and is probably the smartest ballplayer he ever met.”
Greatest accomplishment was putting Negro Leaugers on the veteran’s health plan.
“Reinsdorft is 5x smarter than me and 50x smarter than Steinbrenner.” He had a lot of good Steinbrenner stories.
“Steroids is 50x worse than the Pete Rose incident.” and “It is absurd to say that steroids were not banned.” He also equated amphetamines to a “strong cup of coffee.”
He recommended that Bonds should hold a three hour news conference admitting all and answering all questions and that would then cause the public to lose interest, just as they’ve done with Giambi.
He was surprised that Buck O’Neil was not inducted.
He thought that an owner as commish was bad because you can never be viewed as independent and he thinks the next commish will be independent.
He claimed that if he were still commissioner and had the minority hiring record of the current administration, he would be absolutely killed in the press, but Selig gets off scot free.
He called the Florida-Montreal-Boston ownership machinations very ugly and underhanded.
He said if the senate was really interested in pushing MLB’s buttons, they would threaten to make luxury boxes non-deductible. Of course, the senators wouldn’t get to sit in them then.
He also feels the sport is healthy among young fans as a viewing and entertaining sport. He worries about it in terms of the percentage of kids who play baseball. He also pointed to the decrease in african americans in baseball and doesn’t believe there are any easy answers. He seems to think the lack of division I scholarships in baseball is a primary reason.
Later, he was asked about the next collective bargaining agreement and that since teams were doing much better now if he thought they would get a deal done easily. I was pretty stunned by his answer. He believed that half the teams were losing money and that the Brewers were probably worth only a fifth of what Attanasio paid for them ($225m or so). I pointed out to him that Tampa Bay probably makes $45m from revenue sharing, TV, and internet and they clearly had to be making money. He commented their payroll was $15m, but seemed to imply they were still losing money.
The latest Sports Business Journal states that MLB made $5.1 billion in reveneu last year and will see $300m in internet revenues alone. They also said that 27 teams were profitable. Mr. Vincent may have been combining the profitability and competitive balance issues in saying that 15 teams can’t both compete and be profitable, but his statements seem way out of whack with reality to me. Of course, he hasn’t seen real books for 12 years or more, so that might explain it.