You Are Here > > Blog >

SITE NEWS: We are moving all of our site and company news into a single blog for We'll tag all B-R content, so you can quickly and easily find the content you want.

Also, our existing B-R blog rss feed will be redirected to the new site's feed. ยป Sports Reference

For more from Andy and the gang, check out their new site High Heat Stats.

20 Questions: Which player and year am I?

Posted by Andy on February 25, 2011

Let's start an all-new 20 Questions game. See my last such game for the rules. Remember, I will only answer the first valid question posted in the comments after each previous answer I give, so there is no point in posting question after question.

As an added twist, the subject of this 20 Questions is a particular season by a particular player.

To illustrate, let's use Mark Whiten as an example. If I were thinking of Mark Whiten in 1997 and you asked "did you appear as a pitcher?" I would say no, because he didn't in 1997. If I were thinking of Mark Whiten in 1998 and you asked the same question, then the answer would be yes. The same rules apply to all of his stats, teams he played for, post-season, etc. It's all confined to the one year of which I am thinking. Of course, if you phrase a question such as "did you appear at any time in your career as a pitcher?" then I'd answer yes, but such a question only helps to identify the player and not the year.

So, somebody start us off with our first question.

This entry was posted on Friday, February 25th, 2011 at 8:51 am and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

89 Responses to “20 Questions: Which player and year am I?”

  1. Did you win at least 15 games in this season?

  2. Answer #1: No (I assume you mean was I credited with 15 Wins in my personal least that's what I am answering 'no' to).

  3. Were / are you primarily a National League player?

  4. Answer #2: Yes, I was primarily a National League player (just as a reminder, my answer is restricted to the particular season for the particular player I am thinking of---don't read anything into this comment, I'm not saying I was an AL player the rest of my career...just trying to make it clear.)

  5. Is the mystery player still living?

  6. Who was President of the United States during this playing year?

  7. What year came immediately after this particular playing year?

  8. Answer #3: Yes, I am still living (obviously this question relates to today and not just the specific year in question.)

    #6--not only did you post before I answered the previous question, but that's not even a yes/no question. Why don't you just ask what the player's name is?

  9. OMG #7.

  10. What era did you play in? (Ex: deadball, steriod, etc.)

  11. did you pitch a lot of shutout innings in this particular year?

  12. i should say consecutively my bad so the question is did you pitch a lot of consecutive shutout innings the year in question?

  13. Someone's trolling... A "yes or no" question is one that can be answered by either "yes" or "no." So far, you've posted three questions that don't follow the rules, and called the OP a douche.

    Are you having a bad day? (Ooh -- that's a yes or no question!)

  14. @11 -

    Frankly, that's just rude. Someone trying to do something fun for the rest of us should not be subjected to name-calling. And, had you actually, you know, READ THE RULES at the top of the page, you would know that Andy will only post one answer at a time. So, if Gibby's Limp, or anyone else for that matter, already posted a question, Andy isn't going to answer your question unless you wait for him to answer the first person's question first. I hope that helps. And, in the future, please keep it respectful. There are a lot of us here because this particular community is not as venomous as many other online baseball communities out there. We're just trying to have fun. Please don't spoil it for the rest of us.

  15. Answer #4: No, I did not pitch a lot of shutout innings, consecutively or otherwise, that year. (That's a little extra clue for you...)

    #13: I just spammed the particular offending comment, but thanks for the defense. I spammed a bunch of comments he made under a different name as well.

  16. Again I have spammed certain offending comments, so comments like #16 won't make a lot of sense to people...

  17. were you known for an unusual leg kick or wind up?

  18. Did you hit more than 20 home runs in the year in question?

  19. Ok I am going to give you guys a little help. I WAS NOT A PITCHER.

  20. Answer #5: No, I did not hit more than 20 homers that year.

  21. did our mystery player hit over 50 home runs that year?

  22. Were you primarily an infielder that year?

  23. did this hitter flirt with batting .400?

  24. I'm ignoring #21 since that was answered in #20.


    Answer #6: Yes, I was primarily an infielder that year.

  25. Was this player primarily an infielder in the year in question?

  26. did you drive in 100 runs?

  27. Did your team win more games than they lost?

  28. Is the subject year in the decade of the 1990's?

  29. Answer #7: No I did not drive in 100 runs.

  30. did you win the NLCS with an unusual home run?

  31. Tom, that's a really vague question so I am going to ignore it. Let's give somebody else a chance.

  32. BTW the higher-ups have informed me that the troll's IP address has been blacklisted. It's a shame because he used to make genuine comments on this blog and now he's permanently blocked.

  33. okay but i did have a purpose for that question so i will let others go for a moment

  34. Did your team play in the postseason this year?

  35. Chris Castonguay Says:

    Did the player steal 30+ bases that year?

  36. Answer #8: Yes, my team played in the post-season that year.

  37. Are you left-handed?

  38. lol, what would have been the most obvious first question! (are you a pitcher/ are you a hitter?)

  39. Chris Castonguay Says:

    Are you a middle infielder?

  40. Answer #9: No I am not left-handed. (Meaning that my B-R page says I throw righty.)

  41. Did your team win the World Series that year?

  42. Answer #10: No, my team did not win the World Series that year.

  43. Halfway through the questions, you've got it narrowed it down decently. There was a question posted earlier that I did not answer because it came after other unanswered questions that was a good one...would really help you narrow it down.

  44. WanderingWinder Says:

    Does the year in question fall in the range 1990-2010?

  45. Answer #11: No, not in the range 1990-2010. That only leaves, what, 120 other years?

  46. WanderingWinder Says:

    Well, I can assume it's not going to be too old, since the guy's still alive.

  47. did this player play for the Cardinals?

  48. That's fair, WW! Sorry for the snarkiness ๐Ÿ™‚

  49. Answer #12: No, I did not play for the Cardinals (in the year in question...again I'm not saying anything about other years.)

    Tom your questions might be a bit too specific. For example you could have asked if he played for the NL West, a 50/50 question instead of focusing on just one team.

  50. Tom, shouldn't you just guess Ozzie Smith? ๐Ÿ™‚

  51. I'll repost this one... did I steal over 30 bases this year?

  52. @49,

    So we can assume it is after 1968 (NL West)?

  53. #52 Such an assumption would be foolish.

  54. @52 I meant...Assume after 1968, not that it was the NL west.

  55. #51

    Answer #13: Yes, I did steal over 30 bases this year.

    Those of you with PI subscriptions are cooking with gas now...a player who is still alive, right-handed, infielder, 30+ SB, <20 HR, on a playoff team before 1990. There aren't very many guys who qualify for each year (in fact zero most year.) There are only 40 seasons in the last 10 years that match, and that's before sorting out who was on a playoff team.

  56. okay so subtlety isn't my strong suit lol

  57. did he play in the NL west the year in question?

  58. Andy,

    Here's a yes / no question...could you institute a cover charge to keep out all the riff-raff?

  59. Lets narrow it down. Was the year in question 1968 or more recent?

  60. Answer #14: No I did not play in the NL West that year.

  61. did the mystery season occur for a team based in California?

  62. take back my question

  63. were you part of a "miracle" that year?

  64. I'm going to ignore the last 2 questions....the first one is pretty close to the one I just answered, and Tom's is just too vague.

  65. For the record, my comment at #58 was directed at Gibby's limp (whose comment was subsequently deleted) and not at anyone else

  66. Did you have fewer than 60 strikeouts in your year?

  67. Are you Ryne Sandberg in 1984?

  68. Was he a teammate of Bob McClure?

  69. Answer #15: Yes, I had fewer than 60 strikeouts.

  70. were you in the NL East?

  71. Are you Larry Bowa?

  72. Tom, I'm ignoring your question again. I'm really appreciation your participation but I think you might need a little more practice. See also most post at #60 where I answered that I was not in the NL West.

    As for #71...

    Answer #16: Yes, I am Larry Bowa. Now you just need the year...

  73. Are you Larry Bowa, 1976 edtion?

  74. Larry Bowa 1977

  75. I'll guess bowa in '78 then

  76. oops meant 76

  77. Was it really narrowed down enough to know it was Bowa or was that a shot in the dark? I would have guessed there were dozens of options left to filter through.

  78. I think it was down to four choices and Bowa was the only one with multiple years.

  79. It was a toss-up between Bowa and Rodney Scott, '81. I realize now it could only be LB '77 since Andy said OVER 30 steals. We had a lot of information -- playoff team, but not a WS winner. Before 1990. Living player. Infielder. More than 30 steals/less than 20 HR. National League, but not NL West. That really narrows down the possibilities.

  80. #73

    Answer #17 No, not Larry Bowa in 1976. (Although in a quick check by me, it could have been that year just the same...I think the answers to what's been guessed are all the same)

  81. has to be Bowa 77

  82. Larry Bowa 1977?

  83. Answer #18: Yes, I am Larry Bowa in 1977!

  84. man, that was excruciating to read through because of all the dumb comments.

  85. Michael E Sullivan Says:

    Yeah, no kidding Fordham, and that's even after Andy had filtered the worst of it by the time I got here.

  86. Michael E Sullivan Says:

    You live in Seattle? Do you know Joe?

  87. I like this idea for the blog! Both times (that I've seen it, I assumed it had only happened twice so far) it has been a bit of a nightmare, but I'm confident it can get worked out. Maybe next time you can make a rule that each question has to be from a different person? Or at least consecutive questions can't be from the same person, or the same person can't ask more than 3 of the 20 questions....

  88. dukeofflatbush Says:

    Larry Bowa has the fewest HRs for a player with 2000 hits

  89. DoubleDiamond Says:

    My first visit here since the game was started. I followed it all of the way through, but it had already been guessed.

    Thanks for trying this again.

    Regarding the types of questions - Bringing up pitching statistics before it was even determined whether or not the player was primarily a pitcher that year was somewhat premature.

    The phrase, "a lot of shutout innings" or "a lot of consecutive shutout innings", is open to interpretation. What constitutes "a lot"? A Drysdale or Hershiser record-setting streak? Or something less? So is "unusual home run". Is this a home run hit by someone who doesn't usually homer (such as Ozzie Smith)? Or is it a grand slam inside the park walk-off home run?

    I think we have gotten better in our question selection, and I hope we'll have the chance to participate in more of these, at least until the games that count start up again. Thanks again, Andy, for trying this again, with a twist this time.