The top 8 vote getters are shown for each BBWAA election. Click the year for the full results. Those inducted on that ballot are in italics.
| Year | Ballots | Vts/Blt | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | 573 | 5.10 | Larkin (86.4%) | Morris (66.7%) | Bagwell (56.0%) | Smith (50.6%) | Raines (48.7%) | Trammell (36.8%) | Martinez (36.5%) | McGriff (23.9%) |
| 2011 | 581 | 5.98 | Alomar (90.0%) | Blyleven (79.7%) | Larkin (62.1%) | Morris (53.5%) | Smith (45.3%) | Bagwell (41.7%) | Raines (37.5%) | Martinez (32.9%) |
| 2010 | 539 | 5.67 | Dawson (77.9%) | Blyleven (74.2%) | Alomar (73.7%) | Morris (52.3%) | Larkin (51.6%) | Smith (47.3%) | Martinez (36.2%) | Raines (30.4%) |
| 2009 | 539 | 5.38 | Henderson (94.8%) | Rice (76.4%) | Dawson (67.0%) | Blyleven (62.7%) | Smith (44.5%) | Morris (44.0%) | John (31.7%) | Raines (22.6%) |
| 2008 | 543 | 5.35 | Gossage (85.8%) | Rice (72.2%) | Dawson (65.9%) | Blyleven (61.9%) | Smith (43.3%) | Morris (42.9%) | John (29.1%) | Raines (24.3%) |
| 2007 | 545 | 6.58 | Ripken (98.5%) | Gwynn (97.6%) | Gossage (71.2%) | Rice (63.5%) | Dawson (56.7%) | Blyleven (47.7%) | Smith (39.8%) | Morris (37.1%) |
| 2006 | 520 | 5.64 | Sutter (76.9%) | Rice (64.8%) | Gossage (64.6%) | Dawson (61.0%) | Blyleven (53.3%) | Smith (45.0%) | Morris (41.2%) | John (29.6%) |
| 2005 | 516 | 6.32 | Boggs (91.9%) | Sandberg (76.2%) | Sutter (66.7%) | Rice (59.5%) | Gossage (55.2%) | Dawson (52.3%) | Blyleven (40.9%) | Smith (38.8%) |
| 2004 | 506 | 6.55 | Molitor (85.2%) | Eckersley (83.2%) | Sandberg (61.1%) | Sutter (59.5%) | Rice (54.5%) | Dawson (50.0%) | Gossage (40.7%) | Smith (36.6%) |
| 2003 | 496 | 6.60 | Murray (85.3%) | Carter (78.0%) | Sutter (53.6%) | Rice (52.2%) | Dawson (50.0%) | Sandberg (49.2%) | Smith (42.3%) | Gossage (42.1%) |
| 2002 | 472 | 5.95 | Smith (91.7%) | Carter (72.7%) | Rice (55.1%) | Sutter (50.4%) | Dawson (45.3%) | Gossage (43.0%) | Garvey (28.4%) | John (26.9%) |
| 2001 | 515 | 6.33 | Winfield (84.5%) | Puckett (82.1%) | Carter (64.9%) | Rice (57.9%) | Sutter (47.6%) | Gossage (44.3%) | Garvey (34.2%) | John (28.3%) |
| 2000 | 499 | 5.64 | Fisk (79.6%) | Perez (77.2%) | Rice (51.5%) | Carter (49.7%) | Sutter (38.5%) | Gossage (33.3%) | Garvey (32.1%) | John (27.1%) |
| 1999 | 497 | 6.74 | Ryan (98.8%) | Brett (98.2%) | Yount (77.5%) | Fisk (66.4%) | Perez (60.8%) | Carter (33.8%) | Garvey (30.2%) | Rice (29.4%) |
| 1998 | 473 | 5.41 | Sutton (81.6%) | Perez (67.9%) | Santo (43.1%) | Rice (42.9%) | Carter (42.3%) | Garvey (41.2%) | Sutter (31.1%) | Kaat (27.3%) |
| 1997 | 473 | 5.59 | Niekro (80.3%) | Sutton (73.2%) | Perez (66.0%) | Santo (39.3%) | Rice (37.6%) | Garvey (35.3%) | Sutter (27.5%) | Kaat (22.6%) |
| 1996 | 470 | 5.72 | Niekro (68.3%) | Perez (65.7%) | Sutton (63.8%) | Garvey (37.2%) | Santo (37.0%) | Oliva (36.2%) | Rice (35.3%) | Sutter (29.1%) |
| 1995 | 460 | 6.15 | Schmidt (96.5%) | Niekro (62.2%) | Sutton (57.4%) | Perez (56.3%) | Garvey (42.6%) | Oliva (32.4%) | Santo (30.2%) | Sutter (29.8%) |
| 1994 | 456 | 6.37 | Carlton (95.6%) | Cepeda (73.5%) | Niekro (59.9%) | Perez (57.7%) | Sutton (56.8%) | Garvey (36.4%) | Oliva (34.6%) | Santo (32.9%) |
| 1993 | 423 | 5.79 | Jackson (93.6%) | Niekro (65.7%) | Cepeda (59.6%) | Perez (55.1%) | Garvey (41.6%) | Oliva (37.1%) | Santo (36.6%) | Kaat (29.6%) |
| 1992 | 430 | 6.07 | Seaver (98.8%) | Fingers (81.2%) | Cepeda (57.2%) | Perez (50.0%) | Mazeroski (42.3%) | Oliva (40.7%) | Santo (31.6%) | Kaat (26.5%) |
| 1991 | 443 | 6.65 | Carew (90.5%) | Perry (77.2%) | Jenkins (75.4%) | Fingers (65.7%) | Bunning (63.7%) | Cepeda (43.3%) | Oliva (36.1%) | Mazeroski (32.1%) |
| 1990 | 444 | 6.87 | Palmer (92.6%) | Morgan (81.8%) | Perry (72.1%) | Jenkins (66.7%) | Bunning (57.9%) | Cepeda (47.5%) | Oliva (32.0%) | Mazeroski (29.5%) |
| 1989 | 447 | 6.75 | Bench (96.4%) | Yastrzemski (94.6%) | Perry (68.0%) | Bunning (63.3%) | Jenkins (52.3%) | Cepeda (39.4%) | Oliva (30.2%) | Mazeroski (30.0%) |
| 1988 | 427 | 6.60 | Stargell (82.4%) | Bunning (74.2%) | Oliva (47.3%) | Cepeda (46.6%) | Maris (43.1%) | Kuenn (39.3%) | Mazeroski (33.5%) | Tiant (30.9%) |
| 1987 | 413 | 6.61 | Williams (85.7%) | Hunter (76.3%) | Bunning (70.0%) | Cepeda (43.3%) | Maris (42.6%) | Oliva (38.7%) | Kuenn (34.9%) | Mazeroski (30.3%) |
| 1986 | 425 | 7.04 | McCovey (81.4%) | Williams (74.1%) | Hunter (68.0%) | Bunning (65.6%) | Maris (41.6%) | Oliva (36.2%) | Cepeda (35.8%) | Kuenn (33.9%) |
| 1985 | 395 | 7.39 | Wilhelm (83.8%) | Brock (79.7%) | Fox (74.7%) | Williams (63.8%) | Bunning (54.2%) | Hunter (53.7%) | Maris (32.4%) | Kuenn (31.6%) |
| 1984 | 403 | 7.21 | Aparicio (84.6%) | Killebrew (83.1%) | Drysdale (78.4%) | Wilhelm (72.0%) | Fox (61.0%) | Williams (50.1%) | Bunning (49.9%) | Oliva (30.8%) |
| 1983 | 374 | 8.36 | Robinson (92.0%) | Marichal (83.7%) | Killebrew (71.9%) | Aparicio (67.4%) | Wilhelm (65.0%) | Drysdale (64.7%) | Hodges (63.4%) | Fox (46.3%) |
| 1982 | 415 | 8.06 | Aaron (97.8%) | Robinson (89.2%) | Marichal (73.5%) | Killebrew (59.3%) | Wilhelm (56.9%) | Drysdale (56.1%) | Hodges (49.4%) | Aparicio (41.9%) |
| 1981 | 401 | 7.80 | Gibson (84.0%) | Drysdale (60.6%) | Hodges (60.1%) | Killebrew (59.6%) | Wilhelm (59.4%) | Marichal (58.1%) | Fox (41.9%) | Schoendienst (41.4%) |
| 1980 | 385 | 7.70 | Kaline (88.3%) | Snider (86.5%) | Drysdale (61.8%) | Hodges (59.7%) | Wilhelm (54.3%) | Bunning (46.0%) | Schoendienst (42.6%) | Fox (41.8%) |
| 1979 | 432 | 7.70 | Mays (94.7%) | Snider (71.3%) | Slaughter (68.8%) | Hodges (56.0%) | Drysdale (53.9%) | Fox (40.3%) | Wilhelm (38.9%) | Wills (38.4%) |
| 1978 | 379 | 7.78 | Mathews (79.4%) | Slaughter (68.9%) | Snider (67.0%) | Hodges (59.6%) | Drysdale (57.8%) | Bunning (47.8%) | Reese (44.6%) | Wilhelm (41.7%) |
| 1977 | 383 | 7.67 | Banks (83.8%) | Mathews (62.4%) | Hodges (58.5%) | Slaughter (58.0%) | Snider (55.4%) | Drysdale (51.4%) | Reese (42.6%) | Fox (39.7%) |
| 1976 | 388 | 7.57 | Roberts (86.9%) | Lemon (78.6%) | Hodges (60.1%) | Slaughter (50.8%) | Mathews (48.7%) | Reese (47.9%) | Fox (44.8%) | Snider (41.0%) |
| 1975 | 362 | 7.93 | Kiner (75.4%) | Roberts (72.7%) | Lemon (64.4%) | Hodges (51.9%) | Slaughter (48.9%) | Newhouser (42.8%) | Reese (42.5%) | Mathews (40.9%) |
| 1974 | 365 | 8.25 | Mantle (88.2%) | Ford (77.8%) | Roberts (61.4%) | Kiner (58.9%) | Hodges (54.2%) | Lemon (52.1%) | Slaughter (39.7%) | Reese (38.6%) |
| 1973 | 380 | 8.01 | Spahn (83.2%) | Ford (67.1%) | Kiner (61.8%) | Hodges (57.4%) | Roberts (56.1%) | Lemon (46.6%) | Mize (41.3%) | Slaughter (38.2%) |
| 1972 | 396 | 7.79 | Koufax (86.9%) | Berra (85.6%) | Wynn (76.0%) | Kiner (59.3%) | Hodges (40.7%) | Mize (39.6%) | Slaughter (37.6%) | Reese (32.6%) |
| 1971 | 360 | 7.45 | Berra (67.2%) | Wynn (66.7%) | Kiner (58.9%) | Hodges (50.0%) | Slaughter (45.8%) | Mize (43.6%) | Reese (35.3%) | Schoendienst (34.2%) |
| 1970 | 300 | 7.67 | Boudreau (77.3%) | Kiner (55.7%) | Hodges (48.3%) | Wynn (46.7%) | Slaughter (44.3%) | Mize (42.0%) | Marion (40.0%) | Schoendienst (32.3%) |
| 1969 | 340 | 7.66 | Musial (93.2%) | Campanella (79.4%) | Boudreau (64.1%) | Kiner (40.3%) | Slaughter (37.6%) | Mize (34.1%) | Marion (32.9%) | Reynolds (28.8%) |
| 1968 | 283 | 7.45 | Medwick (84.8%) | Campanella (72.4%) | Boudreau (51.6%) | Slaughter (45.6%) | Kiner (41.7%) | Mize (36.4%) | Reynolds (33.6%) | Marion (31.4%) |
| 1967 | 292 | 7.95 | Ruffing (72.6%) | Medwick (72.6%) | Campanella (69.9%) | Boudreau (49.0%) | Kiner (42.5%) | Slaughter (42.1%) | Lopez (39.0%) | Marion (30.8%) |
| 1966 | 302 | 7.32 | Williams (93.4%) | Ruffing (68.9%) | Campanella (65.2%) | Medwick (61.9%) | Boudreau (38.1%) | Lopez (36.1%) | Slaughter (33.1%) | Reese (31.5%) |
| 1964 | 201 | 8.12 | Appling (70.6%) | Ruffing (70.1%) | Campanella (57.2%) | Medwick (53.7%) | Reese (36.3%) | Boudreau (33.8%) | Lopez (28.4%) | Klein (27.9%) |
| 1962 | 160 | 6.82 | Feller (93.8%) | Robinson (77.5%) | Rice (50.6%) | Ruffing (45.0%) | Rixey (30.6%) | Appling (30.0%) | Rizzuto (27.5%) | Grimes (26.9%) |
| 1960 | 269 | 8.60 | Roush (54.3%) | Rice (53.2%) | Rixey (52.8%) | Grimes (34.2%) | Bottomley (33.1%) | Ruffing (32.0%) | Faber (30.9%) | Wilson (26.8%) |
| 1958 | 266 | 9.02 | Carey (51.1%) | Roush (42.1%) | Ruffing (37.2%) | Wilson (35.3%) | Rice (33.8%) | Cuyler (33.8%) | Lazzeri (30.1%) | Appling (28.9%) |
| 1956 | 193 | 8.28 | Greenberg (85.0%) | Cronin (78.8%) | Ruffing (50.3%) | Roush (47.2%) | Gomez (46.1%) | Wilson (38.3%) | Carey (33.7%) | Lazzeri (33.2%) |
| 1955 | 251 | 9.49 | DiMaggio (88.8%) | Lyons (86.5%) | Vance (81.7%) | Hartnett (77.7%) | Greenberg (62.5%) | Cronin (53.8%) | Carey (47.4%) | Schalk (45.0%) |
| 1954 | 252 | 8.30 | Maranville (82.9%) | Dickey (80.2%) | Terry (77.4%) | DiMaggio (69.4%) | Lyons (67.5%) | Vance (62.7%) | Hartnett (59.9%) | Greenberg (38.5%) |
| 1953 | 264 | 9.56 | Dean (79.2%) | Simmons (75.4%) | Terry (72.3%) | Dickey (67.8%) | Maranville (62.1%) | Vance (56.8%) | Lyons (52.7%) | DiMaggio (44.3%) |
| 1952 | 234 | 9.34 | Heilmann (86.8%) | Waner (83.3%) | Terry (66.2%) | Dean (65.0%) | Simmons (60.3%) | Dickey (59.4%) | Maranville (56.8%) | Vance (44.9%) |
| 1951 | 226 | 9.59 | Ott (87.2%) | Foxx (79.2%) | Waner (71.7%) | Heilmann (67.7%) | Terry (65.5%) | Dean (64.2%) | Dickey (52.2%) | Simmons (51.3%) |
| 1950 | 168 | 8.82 | Ott (68.5%) | Terry (62.5%) | Foxx (61.3%) | Waner (56.5%) | Simmons (53.6%) | Heilmann (51.8%) | Dean (50.6%) | Dickey (46.4%) |
| 1949 | 153 | 9.21 | Gehringer (66.7%) | Ott (61.4%) | Simmons (58.2%) | Dean (57.5%) | Foxx (55.6%) | Terry (52.9%) | Waner (47.7%) | Greenberg (43.8%) |
| 1948 | 121 | 8.56 | Pennock (77.7%) | Traynor (76.9%) | Simmons (49.6%) | Terry (43.0%) | Gehringer (43.0%) | Waner (42.1%) | Foxx (41.3%) | Heilmann (33.1%) |
| 1947 | 161 | 9.68 | Hubbell (87.0%) | Frisch (84.5%) | Cochrane (79.5%) | Grove (76.4%) | Traynor (73.9%) | Gehringer (65.2%) | Maranville (56.5%) | Dean (54.7%) |
| 1945 | 247 | 10.11 | Chance (72.5%) | Waddell (62.3%) | Walsh (55.5%) | Evers (54.3%) | Huggins (53.8%) | Bresnahan (53.8%) | Cochrane (50.6%) | Collins (49.0%) |
| 1942 | 233 | 10.03 | Hornsby (78.1%) | Waddell (58.4%) | Chance (58.4%) | Walsh (48.5%) | Huggins (47.6%) | Delahanty (44.6%) | Evers (39.1%) | Robinson (38.2%) |
| 1939 | 274 | 9.89 | Sisler (85.8%) | Collins (77.7%) | Keeler (75.5%) | Waddell (65.3%) | Hornsby (64.2%) | Chance (57.7%) | Delahanty (52.9%) | Walsh (48.2%) |
| 1938 | 262 | 9.45 | Alexander (80.9%) | Sisler (68.3%) | Keeler (67.6%) | Collins (66.8%) | Waddell (56.5%) | Chance (50.8%) | Delahanty (50.4%) | Walsh (42.0%) |
| 1937 | 201 | 9.55 | Lajoie (83.6%) | Speaker (82.1%) | Young (76.1%) | Alexander (62.2%) | Keeler (57.2%) | Collins (57.2%) | Sisler (52.7%) | Delahanty (34.8%) |
| 1936 | 226 | 9.87 | Cobb (98.2%) | Wagner (95.1%) | Ruth (95.1%) | Mathewson (90.7%) | Johnson (83.6%) | Lajoie (64.6%) | Speaker (58.8%) | Young (49.1%) |